Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The Oregon daily journal. (Portland, Or.) 1902-1972 | View Entire Issue (Dec. 21, 1911)
PORTLAND, OREGON, THURSDAY EVENING, DECEMBER 21, 1911 TWENTY-TWO PAGES. PRICE TWO CFHTS tsains akd inrwt ni.c iwu i-cnis standi mi cjjitv Nathan Harvey May Be Barbara Holtzman Slayer Lives With Convicts L Mrs. Nelson Partially Identifies Him as the Man REFEUDfl OFF MESSAGE BY TAFT J E VOL. X. NO. 248. IY WINS M ON ETARY REFORM BOB POSTOFFI E N fa T-TT , .....loV ID 0 : SRFCTKPFM EAST PORTLAND OF T 508 AND FSCAP I . M V v. E SAID POSITIVELY This Was Soon After Hill Mur ders When Trap Was Laid for Ardenwald Man and She Picked Him Out. Is Nathan B. Harvey, the Mllwaukle nurseryman who Is accused of the mur- er of the Hill family at Ardenwald Station June 9, the same man who strangled 6-year-old Barbara Iloltzniaii In an Alblna lodging house March 14? Since the partial identification of Har ,vey by Mrs. Bertha Nelson, proprietor Of the lodging house at 107 Russell street where the Holtzman child was killed, as the man who rented from her the room In which the girl's body later was found, the authorities have bet n seeking more positive evidence. Mrs. Nelson wild positively today that Leond Lochard was not Barbara Holt7. mar.'fi slayer. A reporter for The Journal tills morn ing showed Mrs. Nelson a 'photograph of Harvey taken by a Journal stuff pho tographer yi sterday. It Is nn excellent likeness of the accused murderer. It Looks Lite the Man. "I would not ncike a positive state ment that this Is tile man," fa Id Mrs. Nelson, after slie had made a detailed e aminatlim of the photograph, "but the resemblance is remarkable. There are runny th'na-s about this man's face that T remember alout the fare of the man who rented the loom In which I found the little girl's boilv. 1 wouldn't say positively this Is the man because if I did and he wes handed and then found to have hen Innocent, I would be a muroVior mvsclf." She then went on to tell of her first view of Harvey. It was four of five days after the Hill murder. Harvey was not then actually under suspicion, but like all of the Hills' neighbors, was being watched. His close resemblance to the description given by Mrs, Nelson of the Holtzman murderer raused Sheriff Ptevens and his defidty, 'Archie Leonard, to arrange so that Mrs. Nelson could see Mm wlthjpv.t ,.H$r,Yer.,upistinK that he Was untie'r scrutiny. ..,. , The Trapping of Harvey. The officers knew Harvey would re turn to his home from the field at about 6:30 o'clock in the evening, driving in his helperb. Sheriff Stevens. Deputy Ar chie Leonard and Detective L. L. liv ings took Mrs. Nelson to a cross road, which they knew farvey would pass. In an automobile. When Harvey drove lip with his half dozen or so employes, Leonard called to him to stop and asked Mm which was the nearest route to Oregon City. Mrs. Nelson had not been told what part she was to play. She presumed the would be called upon to scan the faces of everyone who might resemble Holtzman murderer. Leonard, (Continued on Page Six.) JONES. DEFAULTER, RETURNS TO FACE. Former Bookkeeper of Oregon Hotel Willing to Make Full Restitution and Suffer Pen alty if Necessary. Aged 10 years In appearance since he fled from Portland following the dis covery of his peculations as book keeper of the Hotel Oregon last August, Charles W. Jones returned voluntarily this morning In company with Attorney George Joseph, representing Wright & Dickinson, proprietors of the hotel, to explain what he can of his shortages and to pay the penalty for those he cannot explain. The shortages amounted to between (4000 and $5000 as far as can be dis covered and Jones declares that he can rot tell what became of tho money that lie took. Part of it went for his church and charitable contributions, part for luxuries, several hundred dollars to pay the expenses of an operation for ap pendicitis on his youngest son, and a ijjfislderable amount to make payments on his home and to keep up taxes and sessiiitmts against it. Wot Put Under Arrest. Jones has not been placed under ar rest yet and will not be for a few days while he is working over the books of the hotel trying to .straighten up the mess he has made of them. While he has -been in the company of Attorney Joseph he has not been under any sur veillance. He is allowed to come and go as he wishes and will be permitted to visit his family. Jones makes no effort to explain his actions except to say that his stealing started through taking out small amounts and putting cosh tags In their place. . As the amount represented by these tags Increased he became alarmed and began to cover the amounts up by listing them on the cash book as cur rency or coin. When they still kept Increasing he covered them by falsify ing bank deposits and by raising the rigures on the deposit slips. He also tooic considerable by charging various i (Continued on Puge Seventeen.) ONCE BEFOG HARVEY WAS MAN BP J?" ? - , Is X .4 V I V-'tM!- :..Vr--':'' t :LlW - , Nathan II. flarvcj', charged with Ardcn Unpopular in Ardenwald Sec tion, Residents Now Recall Unsavory Tales Concerrrtng Murder Suspect. With the breaking of the strain that residents of tho Ardenwald district have been under for the six months follow ing the murder of the William Hill fam ily, many stories regarding Nathan Hur vey, who ia charged with the murcdis, and the strange things that have hap pened about the Harvey homo aro being told by the neighbors who have known the family for a score or mere of years. Harvey himself is unpopular with most of his neighbors, as nearly all who have had business dealings with him claim to have found him oishonfst. Hu is well-to-do, being worth perhaps J7&,- 000, and the methods by which he ac-! quired much of his property is the. sub ject of adverse comment by his neigh bors. The Harvey family has lived in Mll waukle and Ardenwald for 30 years. They camo from a farm IS miles froin St. Paul. Iowa. Acordlng to statements Harvey Is said to have ine.de to detec tives, some years after he had moved to the Pacific slope he received u tele grain from a brother In St. Paul asking him to take the next train for home and not giving any explanation of his reason. From Investigations made by Ij. L. Levings of the Western Detec tive bureau in St. Paul and among for mer neighbors of the Harveya, Nathan Harvey met his brother in St. Paul. He did not go out to the farm that day with his brother when he returned home. He was visited again by his brother and that day the two went to tho farm and talked with their father. Nathan Harvey and this brother wero the only ones of tho Harvey children who had not been provided for by their father. It is said. The following, day the father died suddenly and the two sons pro duced a paper showing that he had willed them his property in Iowa. The detectives claim to have tho statements attributed to Gtorge Holland, now dead, but who was then postmaster of St. Paul and who prepared the body of tho elder Harvey for burial, that it showed every evidence of Harvey having been poisoned. Dan Shot Througk Back of Bead. Following the death of the father, all of the Harvey family moved west. Those living at Ardenwald In the houso now occupied by the Harvey family Included Nathan, Dan and Wlllard Harvey and their mother. On morning the mother and Dan Harvey were found lying In a pool of blood in a corner room in the Harvey home, the mother" head having been crushed by an ax, much as the Hills were killed, while Dan had been (shot to death. Out at Ardenwald Is a family that lived next the Harveys at that time. and that knew them well. The man of (Continued on Page Four.) NEIGHBORS RECALL STRANGE ACTIONS OF NATHAN HARVEY the murder of the Hill family at w uld. ATTORNEYS ADMIT HARVEY EMPLOYED THEM AFTER CRIME Jay Bowerman and W. H. Abel Issue Statements; Authori ties Insist Harvey Was to Pay $20,000 Fee. .dnilsslons that Nathan IJ. Harvey, In Jail In Oregon City on a cliargo of being tho murderer of the Hill family, em ployed them as attorneys to defend him In case he should bo arrested and charged with the murders were mado today by Jay Iiowcrman and W. H. Abel. Uoth attorneys deny that Harvey paid them anything at tho time, that he called on them sooner than several weeks after tho murders, and that they have acted for him since then. The statements wore Issued following a con sultation between Bowerman and Abel and ( M. Idleman, who Is now acting as Harvey's attorney. This morning, before the statements wero Issued, Mr. Idleman was inclined to contradict tho entire statement that any other attorneys had been retained. He denied that Harvey had given any lawyers a mortgage on his property to insure the payment of a $20,000 fee, and insisted that tho entire report be denied. Later, however, Iiowcrman and Abel Is sued the following statements: A.bel's Statement. "I know nothing whatever about Mr. Harvey that would bo detrimental to him. Ho consulted mo last summer sev eral weeks after the 11111 murders, and stated that detectives and deputy sher iffs and other persons were constantly at his place running over his land and following him around and making accu sations against him. He stated that he was entirely innocent of the charge, but that it seemed ns though tho officers were so eager to earn tho largo reward offered that they were going to try to make him trouble. He stated to me that if the officers had him arrested he would liko to have me defend him. "As I had been In the state but a short time, I suggested that we call some other attorney Into the case in tho event an arrest was made and after conferring over this matter we called In Jay Bowerman. The conference last ed perhaps "0 minutes, at the termina tion of which Mr. Harvey left and in the course of a few days retArnod and said that ho was not being botjherej as hn had boon heretofore and that there would be nothing further of It, where upon wo, terminated our relationship of attorney and client "I have not seen Mr. Harvey for several months andam not engaged to represent him. As already stated, Mr. Harvey said or did nothing In my pres ence which indicated that na was any thing but an innocent man. He said that his property laid near the Hill property and that It was being; constant ly over-run by officers and. detectives and others, I do not know how tho In formation got abroad that I was to (Continued on Page Six.) With Harshest Words Judge Rules Petitions' Void and Scores Men Who, Knowing Illegality, Put Them In. FORGING NAMES AS BAD AS COUNTERFEITING COIN Unless Appeal Goes to the Su preme Court, U.-0. Can Now Have $500,000. (Sulrm rurpiin of Tb JmirDul. Eulem, Or.. Dec. 21. Unless Judge Galloway of tho clrcfilt ourt for Marlon county has failed to Interpret the law correctly, after hearing the extended suit involving the validity of the ref erendum petitions circulated under the direction of H. J. I'arkison. against House Hills 210 and 211, appropriating approximately $000,000 for the Uni versity of Oregon, the school will get the money. In an opinion handed down at i o . lo' k this afternoon .ludguf'i fai lo- ; way ruled that the letitioriK were void, 'both because of fraud and because of ' failure on the- part of the circulators to tile them in proper form. The case will doubtless go to the supreme court. Tho appropriation b comes uvallable January 1, unless the supreme court re verses Judgo Galloway. "It is the opinion f this court that Judged by logal consideration alone, the petition Is void and ought not be stand because of the evident lack of a suf- fli'tTlt ritimhpr itf l'i ll 1 1 ill,, i,nm,.u rf measure," said Judge Ualloway this j ill UOUII. And Judged by the conscience of the court of equity, thoso seeking to maintain it are not in court with clean hands, and ought not to he granted their unusual risjuest to purgo the peti tion of fraud for which they are more or less responsible. The injunction will he made permanent, and it Is so or dered. Only 3300 Names Admitted. "Other than some 2300 names to these petitions secured in the counties of Benton, I.unc, Man, Marlon, Polk and Yamhill, all other names to petition.? secured in Portland, Oregon City, The Dalles and Astoria by conspiring circu lators, aU residents of Portland in tlsu empfny arfd Tis agehls of H. J. I'arkison, aro so permeated wi..i fraud, forgery and conspiracy that a court of equity and good conscience will not hesitate to decree all os invalid and of no effect. "Defendants' counsel admits that tho petition filed by -Mr. I'arkison with tho secretary of state contains nearly 40u0 fraudulent names, mid that others may bo tainted, hut that he is con vinced there are morn bnnafldo nanus (viz 6135J on the petit lun than aro necessary to meet the requirements of the law to referend houe hill 21b. I'pon this showing lio asks the court to dis miss the plaintiff's complaint. False S"me and Counterfeiting. "If a party were Indebted to tlio stat In tho sum of ftiUi.l. and should tender to tha secretary of state $13.61 5 with tho admission that $1000 of the sum so tendered were counterfeit, and other money bore cvldenrp of Its suspicious character, the court surmises that tho learned attorney (Attorney General Crawford) would net advise the secre tary of state to accept the tender and liquidate the obligation, but rather that he would have the circulator of counter, felt money arested and prosecuted as tho law directs. Tho court Is of tho (Continued on Page Two.) T REPOBLIC IF HE IS MADE PRESIDENT Revolutionists Not Willing to Promise Premier's Election but Offer Their Help; Dr. Sun Bound for Shanghai. (bulled IreM Leaned Wire.), Shanghai. Dec. 21 Premlor Yuan Shi Kat has offered to concede the estab lishment of the Clilncdo republic If promised the presidency. Dr. Wu Ting Fang, tlia revolutionary minister of foreign affairs, who Is con ducting the pence negotiations here with Tang Shao YI, tho imperial envoy. refused to accept recognition of the re public on these terms. But he' says that If the premier concedes the re public ho will be nominated for the presidency and Wu Ting Fang believes Yuan Shi Kal's election would be cer tain. Dr. Sun Yet Sen, the American Chi nese who is credited with having Insti gated the'rebellion, but whose claim to this distinction lias been denied by Dr. Wu, has loft Hongkong in company with Homer Lc-a, the military expert. They are bound for Shanghai. Dr. Sun had been slated for the presi dency of the Chinese republic, accord ing to reports reaching here and from one source It was declared that he had been elected at Nanking. But these re ports failed of substantiation and tt was even denied by Wu Ting Fang that Sun Yet Sen was connected with the revolution. , Both Dr. Bunkand Homer Lee refused to mako any statement before leaving Hongkong, according to dispatches from there. ; . nh.nrh.l 51 rwinrino- .v., the abdication of the "Infant Chinese I (Continued on Pas; Six.) YUANW AC President Says Central Bank Idea Cannot Be Injected Into Legislation at Present Time; Policy Controls. RESERVE ASSOCIATION FULFILLMENT OF SYSTEM President Urges Legislation for Military Government ion Canal Zone. (United Prcn r.rp( wire ) Washington. Ore. 21.-President Taft today s-nt to congress a special mes sage on the financial condition of the treasury, needed banking and currency reforms and departmental questions. Tho message recited that the finances of the nation at the close of the fiscal year ended June 3'b 1911, stood: l)r Unary receipts, exclusive of postal -revenues, $7n 1 7 1 1 ishursi ineiits.' $i:'i4,1.17,PQ7i The in. ssagc ref( rred particularly to the monetary reforms, declaring that the monetary commission's report would be pitseiited to congress In Iho n...r future, and he urged prompt considera tion ana action upon the commission s report. Referring to the central bank plan, the message says: "It Is unfortunate that the wise and undisputed policy of maintaining un changed the main features of tho bank ing f.vstein rendered It impossible to Introduce the central bank, for the cen tral bank v-ould certainly be resisted, and the plan In which it could have been introduced probably would have been defeated. Hut as the central bank could not be a part of the only pta.ii discussed and considered, that troublesome, ques tion la eliminated. "Ingenuous ami novel ns the proposed national reserve association appears, It simply is tho logical outgrowth of what Is best In tho present system, and is, in fact, the fulfillment of that system." Discussing the management of tho as sociation, President Taft said that he favored a riiisonublo representation of the government in Its management. Referring to tho army reorganization bill, the president says he favors an army service corps, and Is opposed, to "any plan the result of .wlilwrtiid be to break up and lnt rferu In the centra! principles and d tailed system in the staff corps; also, 1 oppose any plan the result of which would givo any officer chosen chief of staff, or any member of the general staff, greater permanency of office than now." President Taft declared the army to be In good condition, and tin recent mobilization along the .Mexican border a success. 'The president urged legislation to fix a method whereby too Panama canal may bo maintained and controlled and tho zone governed. President Taft thinks the canal zone should be gov erned through tho authority of ths president- approximating a military government. The message urges tho enactment of an employer's liability law, extension of tho postal savings bank and a rural parcels posts law. The president de clares his belief that the rural parcels post minus an Increase In business for the ben. fit of all the people. Referring to tho navy, tho president ag.iln urged a national counsel of de fense. In conclusion, the message says that the president favors tho exclusion of tho local general offices of the country from politics, and putting them In tho classified service. BATTLE AT TABRIZ Movement of 4000 Russians on Teheran Delayed An other Day; Shuster Says He Stick Till Put Out. (t'nited Prew beiipril Wire.) Teheran, Dec. 21. Dispatches from Tabriz today stato that serious fighting Is in progress there between Russian and Persian troops. Reports from Kasbln say that 4000 Russian troops are ordered to move on Teheran . tomorrow unless tho Persian parliament agrees to dismiss Shustor. Shuster today Informed parliament of his intention to remain in charge of the Persian treasury until the Russians eject him forcibly, unless parliament asks for his resignation. The Persian deputies notified Shuster that they do not Intend to yield to Russia's demand. 2 OREGON POSTMASTERS C0NFIRMEDJ5Y SENATE (United l"res Leaned Wire.) Washington, Dec. 21. The appoint ment of the following postmasters was confirmed today by the senate: Oregon Oeorge Donnell, Grants Pass; Charles Hazard, Drain. Washington Anna Arnold, Walts burg; John Gruber, Wlnlock. Convicts Form Exclusive Set. (United Prom Leniwd Wirt.) Sydney, N. S. W Dec. 21. Convicts of the Pentbrldge penal settlement who do not care to associate with the "unde- irBBi oimiiHii in me prison navo form n, exclusive union, boycotting transfer to other parts of the building. GOES ON between RUSS AND PERSIAN Governor llenjamin V. Hofper of Tennessee. HIMSELFTHAT HE MAY Tennessee Chief Executive Eats and Sleeps I'ntler the Same Regula tions ns Men I'nder Sentence for Crime. (t'nltd Pr r.ensfrt Wire.) Nashville, Tenn., Dec. 21. Sentencing himself to two days' imprisonment In the penitentiary for the purpose of studying prison conditions at first hand, f'.overnor Henjamln W. Hooper today nrose In a cell In the state prison, performed his ablutions In a tin pail furnished nil prisoners, and accompanied the convicts Into the prison dining room, pnrtnklng of their coarse fare In exactly tho saniu way as tho most hardened felon In tho lot. Following accusations that his prede cessor, former Governor M. R. Patter son, pardoned convicted prisoners too freely. Governor Hooper promised to be more careful In this respect during his administration, und is mingling with the convicts in; order to learn exactly how they live, arjd to be more competent to ci.pc with their problems. Governor Hooper has ordered the war den of the penitentiary to treat him ex actly like tho rest of the prisoners except that he Is to be permitted to min gle, freely with the convicts, hearing complaints and suggestions. Ills idea Is to decide personally what prisoners are entitled to receive Christmas par dons. (Sim-cIhI ti The Journal.) Kllensburg, Wash.. Dec. 21. While playing with a loaded revolver, Fred erick Harnhart, the 3-year-old son of Frederick Rarnhart, a Northern Pacific engineer, shot and killed his 6-months-old sister Louisa. The bullet entered tho child's forehead and passed through the brain, but sho lived two hours after ward. During Mr. Harnhart's absenra on the road. Mrs. Hnrnhnrt niado a practice of keeping the loadrd 32 cnllbre revolver In the house for protection. While she wns at tho telephone the children, see ing tho revolver, started to play with It ami the boy pointed It at his sister. Mrs. Uunihart Is prostrated. The lit tle boy Is too young to realize the seri ousness of his act. (Sprctnl tn The .lonriinl.) Vancouver, Wash, Dec 21. Before Saturday night proceedings are likely to b- under way against State Bank Ex aminer J. L, Mohundro, former Superior Court Judge A. L. Miller nnd A. J. Cook, In connection with the dismal failure of the Commercial bank of Van couver. The unexpected development is a re sult of the rejuvenation of activity among tho depositors, who, thoroughly angered at tho failure to secure a con viction In tho recent trial at Kalama of H. C. Phillips, president of the defunct institution, held a mass meeting last Saturday and named a committee to In sist on thorough prosecution of all per sons dollnquent In connection with the failure. This committee, consisting of Captain Aloe, Dr. J. M. P. Chalmers and City Attorney R. C. Sugg, interviewed Pros ecuting Attorney Tempes yesterday. Plain words wero spoken to this official during the conference. It was insisted by 'the committee that he institute pro ceedings osainst Mr. Cook and Judge Miller before the end of the week, to gether, with Bank Kxaminer Mohundro, against whom the depositors have ex pressed utmost bitterness, i ; , " If the prosecutor did not tak such action, he was told, tha oommlttee Itself would probably begin action .. against them in Justice court the first of next week.. Justice court would ba used, merely for Institution of proceedings. . A. J, .Cook was a director - In tHs broken Commercial bank. He Is son-in. law of Mrs. -Wlntler, a wealthy Van GOVERNOR IMPRISONS STUDY CONVICTS' LIFE BOY AGED 3 WITH GUN KILLSSISTER,5IViONTHS PROSECUTION DEMANDED HOW OF ; IHlDfiO, MILLER fi'ltl COOK Safe Demolished With Chisels and Sledge Hammers and Stamps and Money Re moved; No Explosives Used entrance is gained Through rear window Roomers Nearby Hear Robbers Pounding at 2 A. M.; Safe Not Burglar Proof. t The east side postof f Ice, at the corner of East Alder Btreet and Uniowavenue, was robbed shortly after 2 o'clock this morning and $438.30 In stamps and $1010 in gold and silver was stolen. En trance to the station was gained through a rearw window, and the safe In which the money and stamps were kept was demolished with sledge hammers and chlcels, no explosives having been used to force tha entrance. The robbery was discovered shortly before G:30 o'clock this morning, by Superintendent A. G. Ott, when he start ed to open the safe door. Both the outer and Inner doors were completely demolished. The combination had been knocked off, and the bolts on the in side smashed with a heavy sledge. The Inside door was treated in the same manner. - This safe Is the only one in the city not equipped with a burglar proof inner door. The loot consists of MfO two cent stamps, 800 three cant' stamps and other stamps in numbers ranging from 0 to 300 and valued at from 4 to 12 cents each. The money consisted of $750 in gold, $250 In stiver and $10 in pennies, which the robbers took for gold, as both the peunies and gold were In similar rolls. As soon as the report was made to police headquarters, Detective Smith was sent to investigate. He learned' that F. C. Games, who rooms In room 3it of 108V4 Union avenue, above the postof floe, heard pounding at 2:10 thin morning-, but paid no attention to it he thought it was from a near-by m-. chine shop where they have been work( lng nights. Alphonse Oborgefell, who rooms in the same, place and Mrsj, 33. J'' Turley, -tbtJantUiidy,- Ifear the sara noises, but gave the same explanation of It. Other roomers declare that they heard n man come up one. flight of stairs shortly after 2 o'clock and leavn the place, by another flight, and shortly after the pounding started. ' Postof flee Inspectors and secret ser vice men are working on the case a:s are also local police detectives. I OFFICIALLY FINISHED ffnlted rrens Leaned Wire.) Washington, Dec. 21. President Taft returned to the capital from New York at 7:15 o'clock today and immediately after reaching his office signed the Joint resolution abrogating the Russian! treaty, adopted by both houses of con gress. Secretary of State Knox was' the only official present when the reso-, lutlon was signed. No formality marked the signing by President Taft of the Joint resolution.' Secretary Knox said no word had yet, been received from Russia regarding any new treaty. Pacific Fleet to ISeturn. (frilled I'rean Lemted Wire.) Vallejo, L'al., Dec. 21. As no change has been made In thp schedule, the Pa cific fleet Is expected back from Hono-," lulu January 15. Several of the cruisers, are said to bo In need of repairs, the, Maryland especially. She was rushed, to San Diego last fall with her over hauling only half completed. - , couver woman. Mrs. Wlntler Is grand mother of Gilbert Daniels, cashier of the wrecked bank, who is under indict ment along with President Phillips for accepting deposits in an institution known to be Insolvent. The charge against him would be similar to those against Phillips and Daniels. A. L. Miller Is a prominent Vancou ver attorney and a director In the bank. Ho was Judge of superior court In the Clarke county district several years, ago. The charge against State Bank Exam iner Mohundro would be that Of falling to follow the provisions of the law in ' the case of banks known to be tottering., This is a misdemeanor. Journal Magazine Next Sunday Two Unusual Illustrated Features TIMBER TESTIXQ Unique work performod !n , interest of the general publlo by the United States forest eerrlce. 1 " WIIERK CONVICTS ARK FKEK "Westvllle-IIotior Camp No. i 1"- -An experiment In mait iiJngr roads and men. REATY ABROGATION V