Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Medford mail tribune. (Medford, Or.) 1909-1989 | View Entire Issue (July 8, 1963)
""Everyone in Southern Oregon' Bead' Tim Wall Tribune" published Dally except Saturday by MEDKOBD PRINTING CO. 33 North Jit $ Ph-772-em " ROBERT W BUHL. Editor HERB CREV Advertising Manager GERALD T LATHAM Bui Mar ERIC W ALLEN JR., Mne Editor FAJHL B ADAMS, City Editor HARRY CH1HMAN, Teleg Editor RICHARD JEWETT, Sporu Ed tor OLIVE STARCHER women's Edlloi DALERJCJtNCirculaUonIgr "" An Independent Newapapel Entered aa second clan matter at Medford Oregon under Act of March 3, 1897 SUBSCRIPTION RATES By Mail In Advance ., Dally and Sunday 1 year S18.00 Daily and Sunday 8 moa 10.00 Dallv and Sunday 3 moa. 5.00 " Sunday Only One year Iseo Single Copy (Mailed l iOQ By Camel And Motor Route. Dally and Sunday 1 year S21.00 Pally and Sunday 1 mo. . 1.7a Sunday Only 1 mo. sou Carrier anaVendora JTopy loo Official Paper of City of Medford Of IlcialPaperoJt Jacksun County United Press International Jul! Leaaed Wire U P i Telephoto Newsplcturea MESiBESOF AUDIT BUREAU" Advertising Reprefcentatlve: NELSW ROBERTS 4 ASSOCI ATES Of'lcea In New York, Chi cago Detroit, San Franclaco. Los Angelas. SeatUe, Portland . Denver, NEWSPAMK PUIlUrUM ASSOCIATION NAT! ON At EDITORIAL Memnar California Newspaper Publishers Association Flight o' Time Medford and Jackson Coijnty History from the files of ,n Mall Tribune 10, 20, 30, 40 and' 50 years ago. 10 YEARS AGO . July 8, 1953 (Wednesday) Test holes at the ite for the new First National bank building were sunk during the week end to determine the nature of underlying soil, bank officials said today. A two-place Navy training plane from Seattle crash-landed at the Medford airport at , about 6 p.m. yesterday when the pilot reportedly forgot to lower his landing gear, ac cording to airport sources. 20 YEARS AGO July 8, 1943 (Wednesday) Russell Brothers circus moves to South Riverside ave, site. From Arthur Perry's "Ye Smudge Pot" column: "Now that the. feet of former real' dents of the metropolis and Willamette valley are dry for the first time in years, they have started voicing protests about 'the horrible Medford climate'." 30 YEARS AGO July 8, 1933 (Friday) Oregon drys open drive to keep state dry. Joe F. Fllegel, exalted ruler of Elks, leaves to attend state convention In Portland. 40 YEARS AGO July 8, 1923 (Saturday) Fire In Eagle Point causes $3,000 damage. Apple and pear crops ben efit by recent rains but grain crops damaged. SO YEARS AGO Julyy 8. 1913 (Monday) "In the Claws of the Vul ture," a gripping story In three reels, playing at Star theater. Admission 10 cents Montague ball team, three times victor over Medford de parts for home on Train No 13. What's Your I.Q.? Nina or ten correct it superior; seven or eight It eicellent; five er tlx It good. 1. "Simon Legree" Is a character in which famous book? 2. A fathom comprises how many feet? 3. Is a boa constrictor a Venemous snake? 4. To be eligible for elec tion to the Congress, a can didate must be a native-born citizen; true or false? 8. What governmental or ganization Is charged by the law with responsibility for potecting the person of the President? , 6. In governmental regula tion, anti-trust refers to safe guards against what? 7. On which day of the week does Labor Day always fall? 8. Name the Roman goddess of wisdom. 8. Is the federal tax on Jewelry a property, excise, or sales tax? 10. Does the U.S. Constitu tion reserve the "police pow ers" to the states or the fed eral government? Anawersi 1, Uncle Tom's Cabin. 2. Six feat. 3. No. 4. False. 8. Secret Service.' 8. Monopoly and , limiting of competition. 7. Monday. 8. Minerva, 9. Excite. 10. States. MONDAY, JULY 8. 1963 What Is a Communist? What is a Communist? We ought to ask again, because this label is being pinned on some people in this country more than at any time since the McCarthy era of the 1950s. Controversy over civil rights, economics, poli tics, welfare programs, easily end up with somebody shouting at some body else: "What are you, a Communist or something?" TO ANSWER THE question: What is a Com-miimct? You can begin, of course, by citing avowed members of the Communist party. You may presume number of secret members, not to mention actual professional spies working for the soviet Union By the very nature of their purposes, they are not likely to wear red light You can add identifiable persons who, while avoiding party memberships, nevertheless un mistakably serve the party s goals as dictated by Moscow. , Beyond these levels, identification becomes tricky and presumption dangerous. FOR EXAMPLE, the Reds often try to adopt as their own a flock of foreign and do mestic proposals which may accord roughly with programs advanced by legitimate political parties in the free democracies. As practiced under Moscow's guidance, this device is a conscious fraud. Its aim is to gain for Communism an identity Kremlin believes to be either popular or provoca tive in the free countries. People in free lands away with this nonsense cow s game. It could lead us to such absurdities as having to oppose Highway safety cause the Communists may say they favor them. You don't prove a man is a Communist be cause he says he favors six or eight or ten American-born programs the Communist Party also pre tends it wants for the country. Programs in the Communist world are mere stratagems. IT IS MORE fundamental to remember that a 1 Communst is a person of totalitarian men tality. Whatever his programs of the moment, he is a man who : Brooks no opposition from any quarter, whether school, church, business community, other political party or what not. ' Wants not simply to defeat his rivals but to crush and eliminate them. Rule or ruin is the game. In support of these purposes, seeks to con trol both the thought and the action so that only his ideas, policies and program exist. Would bend every power element in society every agency of the covernment and the economy to this Let this distinctively it will. Coos Bay World. Federal Employment It has become commonplace for the man in the street to speak of Federal agencies and em ployes as though they comprised an ever-spread ing, suffocating blanket. this out. As Congresswoman Edith Green points out in a recent newsletter to her constituents, the number of Federal employers is actually declin ing in relation to the nation's population. Where there were 1.6 Federal civilian employes for each 100 Americans in 1952, there are now 1.3 now or a decline of almost 19 per cent. And they are not widely spread. Of the 2.5 million Federal civilian employes, 1.8 million are in one of three agencies Defense Department, Post Office, and Veterans Administration. The 0.7 million remaining in all other government activities are fewer than the total employment in the telephone industry alone. Capital Press, Salem. Safe Boating Neglect of elementary rules of safe boating contribute to the annual loss of 1,300 lives in boating accidents. This is a heavy toll for the nation s No. 1 family sport, which lures 40 mil lion Americans onto waterways each year. The $2.5 billion recreational craft industry in the United States now services a civilian navy of almost 7.5 million boats of all kinds, including 483,000 sailboats, 795,000 inboard motorboats, and 2,105,000 canoes, rowboats and miscellane ous craft. There are 6,250,000 outboard motors in use, of which 372,000 were sold in 1962. Last year about one out of every five persons in the United States went boating at one time or an other. In their enthusiasm too'many people forget elementary rules of safety Among the vignettes of u. a. Loast uuard is the incredible folly of a one armed man who could not swim and who never wore a lifejacket but went to sea one dav in a very small boat in very rough weather. He never ..,... J t 1L.1 ..!.- i cuii ueu i rum mat win. Most boating fatalities could be prevented simply by wearing 1 i f e i a c k e t s at all times. E. R. R. almost anything, can there are a considerable bulbs over their heads, with certain causes the who let the Reds get are just playing Mos and better libraries be overriding goal. marked shoe fit where The facts do not bear to get out on the water, death compiled by the Grand Alliance Communications Letters to the Editor must bear the name and address of the writer. although under certain circumstances the use of a pen name or Initial for publication Is permissible. Th Mail Tribune reserves the right to edit all letters with a view to clarification and condensation. Letter submitted for publication must not exceed 400 words. The letters printed In this column do not necessarily represent the views of t.t, paper. In fact the contrary Is often Guilt? To the Editor: Are we going to belong all to the colpred race? Are we, in a few gen erations, going to look into old photographic-albums, and then look at one another and remark: "Mahl how we have all changed!" At first the Negro popu- larized his garish art (Gay Ninety's), his noisy music (jazz: -1920's(, and his amor al literature (pornographic realism: 1930's) among us. Now he Is beginning to in- breed with us, demanding full social and political equality. But witness the words of Abraham Lincoln, the Great Emancipator, from a speech delivered at Charleston, 111., in the year 1858: 'I am not now, or ever have been in favor of bring ing about in any way the so cial or political equality of the white and black races . . . There is a physical difference between the white and black races which will forever for bid the two races living to gether In social or political equality. There must be a po sition of superior and Inferior, and I am in favor of assign ing the superior position to the white man. But the difference Is more than physical. For instance, most Negro arts seem degen erate and revolting to the un initiated, sensitive taste of a Caucasian. Next, If we are to sanction full civil and re ligious liberty, we must en tertain voodooism among us, and, when we have succumb ed to barbaric promiscuous ness and lasciviousness engen dered of the above mentioned arts and religion, the uninhib ited, Irresponsible, strongly sexed. Inferior-feeling Negro male will aggressvlely propa gate, and accelerate the proc ess of "de-Caucasianization"- even as our central govern ment is today accelerating "de-Segregation." From the same book as the above quotation, "Meet Gen eral Grant" by W. E. Wood ward, we read: "The experi ence of mankind shows that in all slave civilizations the master eventually succumbs, morally and spiritually, to those held in bondage . . . Slavery . . . did the Negro no permanent harm . . . But it did the Southern White Man a great deal of harm . . . (though) the terrific shock of the Civil War tore the two races apart and created a new and sharp antagonism". Also, "The American NeRroes are the only people in the history ot the world, as far as I know, that ever became free without any effort of their own." Can it be, as one Negro expressed it, that the Negro is a "guilt" of the white man - which he must atone for? Ralph McKlnnis P. O. Box 321 Ashland, Ore. Happy Ending To the Editor: In June all the world seems to be in love. And the newspapers carry many announcements of hap py engagements and weddings . . . And sometimes proud mammas, perhaps recalling their own romances, get their metaphors slightly mixed when they compose the an nouncement of their daugh ter's engagement. This unforgettable classic appeared in the column "A line-o-type or two" in the Chicago Tribune some years ago: "Mr. and Mrs. Roy Gillett take groat pleasure in an nouncing the engagement of their daughter Gloria to Mr. Robert Bottomfeldt. Every young man may have his Gillett - but It is not every young lady who Is so fortun ate as to have her romance end so happily." Bruce Y. KlelnSmid 1719 S.E. Portoli dr. Grants Pass, Ore. MEDFORD MAIL TRIBUNE, MEDFORD, OREGON the case. Hatchet Man And Patriot To the Editor: Yes, Mr. Ed itor, Senator Kuchel did lash out on the Senate floor at his conservative constituents (M. T. Editorial 7-4-83). And too few of our citizens grasped the meaning of this startling, vitriolic outburst. The left wing has become bit frantic because, in spite of our controlled and managed news, two many alarmed Americans are waking up too rapidly. So you might say that the big life and struggle is now on. The traitors, the mind washers, the appeasers, and the vote hungry demagogues have decided to destroy and annihilate the fearless Con servatives who have dared to expose their satanlc machin ations. From all appearances U. S. Senator Thomas Kuchel of California has been chosen as 'hatchet man" for the "left." Intentionally or not, he has certainly laid his hand upon the dagger of smear and drove it straight into the back of the right wing patriot. He has labeled us fright peddlers" who are more dangerous than the Communists (the current, phony, Red "line"). He con fessed his own panic by re vealing that inundation ot mail from his right wing con stituents had overwhelmed him. The blow that brought the most pain to the Kuchel crowd and the entire Kennedy ad ministration was the multi plied thousands of letters to Congress exposing and pro testing the proposed disarm ament ("treason") treaty which would transfer all U.S. Armed Forces to the United, Nations. I ciety senator tvu chel to prove that , this pro posed treaty does not exist. Another dagger pointing at the heart of America which the right wing has exposed, infuriating Mr. Kuchel into trying to brand it as an out right falsehood, is that the fol lowing representatives of the Soviet Union have consecu tively held the position of head of the military affairs committee of the United Na tions: Arkady Sobelov (1946 to 1949), Konstantine Zynchenko (1930 to 1953), lllya Tcherny- shev (1953 to 1957), A. Dobry- nln (1957 to 1960), Georgy Arkadev (1960 to 1962), Eu geny Kiseliv (1962 till now). In other words there has never been anybody but a So viet red at the head of the UN military secretariat. I challenge Senator Kuchel to prove that this is not so. He can't do it. The UN records stand in his way. This explains why even Congress is fright ened by the plan in Publica tion 7277, which is nothing less than the surrender of our military forces to the enemy. Herman Lee Wood, 725 N.W. Second St. Grants Pass, Ore. Wat It Luck? To the Editor: Mr. Wirth's letter of July 4th concerning the evils of profitmaking in Industry was a fine letter, one which an embittered employee might be happy to see in print It drew the usual picture of "them." those well dressed men In their expensive offices, feet propped on mahogony desk while their workers make money for them. These men are the prime targets of both the socialists and com munists, and in Mr. Wirth's case, as in all such cases, the entire group of employers has been gathered Into one vague gold-covered world and called "hoggish." It's true that some men in herit the reins of industry, but the laws of business survival usually make quick work of them If their weaknesses be gin to affect the workings of their Industrial machines. Trying to get "something for nothing," of which Mr. Wirth Foreign News: De Gaulle's New Rad Faction Break-Up; Japanese Kowaies By PHIL NEWSOM UPI Foreign News Analyst De Gaulle Dilemma French President Charles de Gaulle's next big press conference is scheduled for July 30 and is expected to reveal a soft er tone both toward Great Britain and the United States. It was at a news con ference last January that Nswsom De Gaulle an veto of British nounced his Miss Mehilabel And World History By Arthur Hoppe Young ladies of the evening seem much in the news. One s busy overthrowing the British Empire. Others are practicing human brotherhood at the U.N. On a fee basis. And now the California State Capitol is rocked by the scandalous news that nefarious lobbyists are employing young ladies to influence our legislators. Which is certainly scandalous. If not news. But where, I ask you, will it all end? And if you're not worried yet, let me tell you what happened at last night s ses sion of the Greater Southwest Centervllle Sanitary Control District Board, which I was attending as an interested citizen. I was about to enter the august Board Chambers (a sixth grade classroom dur ing daylight), when I was ap proached by a once-young lady in a black velveteen evening gown, false eyelashes and a feather boa. "Honey," she whispered in a husky voice as she stroked my cheek and looked deep in to my eyes, "buy Katzenbach er's Cast Iron Sewer Pipe. I go with it." Thank you, I said, but I didn't happen to need any sewer pipe at the moment. I was just a simple Interested citizen. "Pardon," she said, squint ing at me. "My eyes aren't what they used to be. I thought you were Board Member Alvln Battersbee. He's the swing vote on the new contract." Was she herself, I ask ed delicately, perhaps a young lady of the evening in the pay of nefarious sewer pipe lobbyists? "Young!" she cried happily. "Honey, I will tell you the story of my life for free." And she 'did: "My name," she began, "is Mehltabel Pinkham and I have not always been In the low circumstances you find me now. Once I was the rage of six continents, attending only the largest international conferences representing naught but the finest cartels. Toujours gai, toujours gai. "Ah, how well I remember Versailles. (That Clemenceau was a real tiger, honey.) And complains, is one of these undercutting weaknesses. Let's consider Joe, who owns the new restaurant in town. He hires, or "exploits," 15 workers. Was it luck that put Joe in his position? And what about Mack, who works in Joe's kitchen. Is it luck that keeps him there? Joe is in a profit-making position because of his own ambition and yearning. Mack, on the other hand, works in the kitchen because he has felt no urgent need to preson and on into a position which would satisfy more than just his essential needs. It would be wrong to say Mack has failed-that Is for Mack to de termine. But it must also be wrong to call Joe an exploiter of humanlty-a parasite-simp-ly because he has had a yearn ing to spend his time on earth pursuing more than bread and wine. He has longed for and finally obtained the owner ship of his restaurant. Perhaps his hunger will drive him on to more restaurants-m ore buildings and stools and tables and chairs which he can call his own. Doesn't Joe's spirit, that something that drives him harder than others, merit a profit for it's labor? "Profit does not add one whit to value . . ." Mr. Wirth states. Perhaps the profit Joe makes from each bowl of soup does not add value to the dinner. It does add value to the effort Joe has put forth in building his restaurant. It increases in the eyes of Joe and others the worth of personal ambition and sheer Yankee guts. .And remember, a was this ambition which brought about a place for the 15 employees to make a profit from their own labor. Frank D. Long 1090 S. Ellendale dr. Medford membership in the European Common Market, a move which has irritated his rela tions with his Common Mar ket partners ever since. In last week's visit to Germany, De Gaulle failed either to reach accord with the Ger mans on the British question or on the question of ridding himself of French farm sur Dluses. Furthermore, he is nearing the time when he must get along with Ludwig Erhard, who is scheduled to take over this fair as West German chancellor. There fore, it is expected that his next news conference will deal primarily with a defense the London Naval Confer ence. (Those British sailors!) And when you read of how the League of Nations col lapsed of sheer exhaustion, I can only say modestly that I was there. Toujours gai, tou jours gal. "But now the times have passed me by and I am reduc ed to representing Katzen bacher's Cast Iron Sewer Pipe. And, honey, toujours gal Mr. Katzenbacher ain't." I thanked Miss Mehitabel and said that, in view of the furor caused by the current scandals it was surprising to hear her type had been ac tive In politics for years. "Honey," she said with pride, "lobbying is the oldest pro fession. And I personally have swung more issues than the League of Women Voters combined." No offense, I said, but was it moral? "Moral!" she re plied with an indignant flick of her ivory cigarette holder. "Nobody objects when a lobbyist gives a lawmaker a free lunch, a free theater ticket or a free campaign contribution. Why such a fuss when he's given a free me?" Well, I m sure none of us would agree with Miss Mehit abel's clearly immoral an alogy. And I know you'll be happy to hear the nefarious Mr. Katzenbacher didn't get the sewer pipe contract. It went instead to a Mr. Graf tendorf er, who presented Board . Member Battersbee with a free case of whiskey, which, as you know, is per fectly acceptable these days. And It all goes to prove that under our code of public morality, virtue will triumph in the end. Either that, or it proves Miss Mehitabel is growing old. In the Day's News By FRANK JENKINS As this is written, the Na tional Safety Council is hop ing it can scrap its gloomy prediction of a possible new all-time record for highway deaths in the U. S. A. over the 1963 Independence Day week end. It had estimated that from Wednesday evening until mid night Sunday the total for the five nights and four days might run from a minimum of 550 to a maximum of 650 traf fic deaths. QUESTION; Do you reckon we Amer icans MIGHT be getting a lit tle more sensible in our holi day driving habits? Let's hope so. INCIDENTALLY The all time record for traffic deaths for a summer holiday week end was set on Memorial Day of this year when 525 traffic fatalities were counted. The high mark for an Inde pendence Day long week end was set in 1961, when 509 peo ple died in highway crashes. FROM Moscow: The Soviet Union fired two blasts at Red China on the eve of peace talks between the two feuding communist powers In Moscow. The Rus sian communist party central committee issued a statement accusing the Chinese of slan der, meddling and "aggravat ing relations." The Soviet Foreign Ministry later issued a sharp statement rejecting Red China's "tenden tious lecture" over the expul sion last week of five Chinese from Moscow for distributing an attack on Premier Nikita Khrushchev's leadership of the world communist move ment. 1 The broadcasts said Com munist China would reply to the latest Soviet blasts later when it meets the Russians face to face In the big pow wow. It termed the Russian charges "distortions of -the truth." CME! Fie! Chlllrenl i. Y You ought to be ashamed of yourselves, fighting and of the French position inter nationally, and especially on her relationship with the At lantic alliance. No Hope ' Moscow dispatches now are referring to the "almost hope less" attempt to salvage any thing from the once monolith ic Communist bloc that strech- ed from the Pacific to the Adriatic. In fact they-are say ine that the exchange of in sults between the Soviet Union and Red China make it almost impossible for the two Communist giants to agree even on the simplest matters of normal diplomatic protocol. Moscow observers are predicting a complete Soviet ideological, political and strategic reorientation which may have its effect on the tri-power nuclear test talks to begin, in Moscow July 15. U. S. delegate Averell Har riman is expected to arrive in Moscow at the end of this week for preliminary sound ings on what appears to be a reasonable chance to break the nuclear deadlock and achieve at least a partial test ban agreement. Boisterous Youth For the last two weeks, rowdy tactics of the minority Socialists have kept the Japa nese Diet in an uproar. Op posed to them is a cynical and faction - ridden majority of Conservatives which can ram bills through at any time it wishes. Apologists for this sorry state point out that real parliamentary government in Japan is only 11 years old. Before that, the American oc cupiers and the emperor, re spectively, held the ultimate control. Moreover, the mi nority Socialists have no chance of winning power in the near future, and this makes them irresponsible. The expressed hope is that in Conference About Real Estate Set Seattle Real Estate people and those' in allied businesses from the states of Oregon, Montana, Idaho, Washington, Hawaii and Alaska are invit ed to attend a six-state educa tion and sales conference here Sept. 11-14. The Washington Associa tion of Realtors and the Wash ton State Department of Li censes, Real Estate division, will be hosts, to the sessions to be held at the Seattle Cen ter, site of Seattle's 1962 World's Fair. Those interested are invit ed to write Fraser D. Mac Donell, Chairman, Six-State convention, 531 First ave. West, Seattle 19, for descrip tive brochures and detailed Information. quarreling like that. You should read Isaac Watts' Di vine Songs, in which he says: Let dogs delight to bark and bite, For God hath made them so; Let bears and lions growl and fight, For 'tis their nature to. But, . children, you should never let Such angry passions rise; Your little hands were never made To tear each other's eyes. Birds in their little nests agree; And 'tis a shameful sight When children of one fam ily Fall out and chide and fight. OTILL andaTf If somebody has to chide and fight, let's be duly grate ful that it's the commies who are doing it. There is an ancient prov erb to Uie effect that when thieves fall out, honest men have a chance to come into their own. "Romnty marched . . . Barry demonstration, toe. So they'll SI T 1 I Dilemma; the fullness of time these fac tors will change and Japanese democracy will thus matura and grow stronger. Unrest The Russians are concerned about desertions of East Ger man border guards, according to reports reaching West Ber lin police. The Russians are, said to believe that the deser tions may show unreliability of the entire East German army. Strictly Personal By Sydney J. Harris c Field Enterprises, Inc. MAN IN THE MIDDLE I was talking with a man not long ago, who turned out to be a John Bircher, and his con versation struck a re miniscent nota that I could not recall un u aiterwaros. Suddenly I re. membered-h a 5 ' reminded ma the occa sional Com- Harm munists I used to run into during the 1940s. In fact, he was the Derfect mirror image" of the Com munist zealot. It was not merely that all his arguments were the Com munist line turned inside out; it was also that his attitudes and reactions were the same as theirs, only "right-handed" instead of "left-handed." He had what mother used to call "a plaster for every sore." His conversation was made up of a vast supply of cliches and labels and sero types to cover all situations. There was no doubt, no modifications, no qualifica tions, no admitting that problems are difficult and good men may not agree. Like the Communists, his world was divided into black and white; the "loyal Americans" and the "trai tors," conscious or uncon scious. He would yield not an Inch, for he possessed the absolute gospel truth. Those who could not see it were fools or dupes or rogues. It is an interesting psych' ological fact the sealots on opposite sides of questions are more alike than they aia different; they differ in ab stract principles, but their motivations and attitudes are quite similar. Fascism and Communism are ugly twins, for they share the same deformation of the human spirit, only curved in opposite directions. And it is no accident that the official title of the Nazi party was "National Social-ist"-for Hitler was shrewd enough to appeal to both ex tremes of fanatical thought in Germany; to those who be lieved in "Germany Over All," and to those who wanted a collectivist society on a na tional level. Nor was is any more an accident that the Communists in Germany combined with the Fascists to vote against the Social Democrats and other moderate forces; for both extremes recognize that their true enemy is the hu mane spirit, and they despise the man in the middle mora than they hate each other. The man in the middle is tentative, wary of generaliza tions, suspicious of slogans and rigid systems of thought, unwilling to condemn blocs of people for the faults of some in the group, and trust ing the essential decency of men rather than forces or re pression. In these basic re spects, the zealots on both ex tremes have more in common with each other than they have with the rest of us. VOLUNTEERS of GOLDWATER has to march In civil rights call him 1 liberal! So what?" ox- ; NOMINATE f lie H ' llllll