Newberg graphic., March 22, 1901, Image 2

I
'
I
! ffoeirse” Fruf. Koine? flatly defied »he not justly be charged with plagiarism
president to pr»iaoe ;i single eenteace liecuuse tie used wliut lie so learned fir
copied verbatim, * lieve quotation marks the purposes of hiu oration. I am quite
E. H, W<K»««Kisn#, Ear?«« 4 Fr mah as«. i were not used, with the result that ■ sure that if all the orations upon Wash*
W . C . W o i» v e r o , .1
E » c a c . nothing coul t tie produced by that yen- ingle»« and Lincoln were eouipared they
Has b e co m e a p ro ­
verbial phrase to e x ­
tlcjiisn aside (tout a frequent »how of would iKit only be fouud to resemble
press
th e fu tility o f
u iliy ^ ssa ry warmth. Mr. Kekniun ml- , each other in their ideas imt also in
tK*.'€JT * r t KV FRUJSV U»JBKtJMä.
m ere d esire.
T h ere
milted that he had been Jod into error their forms ol expression, In-cause one
are a great m an y p e o ­
p
le
w
h
o
th
in
k
it
is as
current o l thought is common to ull
I and seemed ready to make amends.
b u n i l w K i - w i t . s : w , o i i « t « atttoe rm tV fco : j
u seless t o h o p e tor health as to cr y for the
win*
writ«
as
to
those
great
men.
\
At
the
clone
of
the
conference
this
m oou .
T h e y have tried m an y m e d ic in e s
ii X«where, Oee?»a.
The charge of literary theft is a serious and m an y d o o to rs, but all iti vain.
|question was put to .Mr. Board mtui,
A great m a n y h op eless m en and w om en
I “ Haa there been or will there be a pro­ one and ought not to be made unless have b e e n cu r e d b v the use o f Dr. P ie r c e ’s
FRI WAY, MARCH 22, ItOl.
test filed by your local assoeiation,” und there are good and substantial grounds G o ld e n M e d ica l d i s c o v e r y ; p e o p le w ith
co u g h s , b le e d in g lungs, night-
It obstinate
! Ids «newer was “ I do not know.” upon which to base the accusation.
sw eats and o th e r s y m p to m s o f disease
FALSELY ACCI S E ».
! When a dispatch from Albany apocared is «e ll to keep iu mind the good words which if neglected or unskillful!? treated
Jin Sunday'* Oregonian H a yin g that a j of (Shakespeare:
i find a fatal term in ation in consumption.
. . . . )>oeJ| filed by McMinnville
...I
,, . . . .
.
,
.
1 , 1
"G o ld e n M e d ica l D is c o v e r y ” h a s a w on -
»frutn-vitt*
I-Iwyw tv* BuXy Art. ! p .,roti.öt
r o t e s t (lU()
lia d I m en file d b y .VlcM ir in v iiie
W h o s te a l* m y p u r s e s te a ls t r a s h ; I <}e rf u i h e a lin g p ow er.
It in cre a se s th e
NEEBERG
G R A P H IC .
U.
“ C F I jia g Í 3 P
ifte M o o » ”
- ! t . « b . r e ' i OraJ.iK-
C h . r j e t u tlh
A W e R f if e u ie
l».y
I ’ l a l lu ri not —An
«£ h < Í | William*.
J. Littlefield.
II. A. Littlefield.
LIT T LE FIE LD BROS.,
PHYSICIANS & SURGEONS.
Offices in Chehalem V alley Bank B uildin g. I
Phone No. 4a.
R esidence north o i P ublic School B uilding, *
P hone No. 44.
N E W
B E 5 .G , O R B .
J ^ T T O K N E Y -AT-LAW.
CLARENCE B U T T .
" ’id p ra ctice in all the court* o f the state
S pecial atteutiou given to probate w ork, the
w riting o f deeds, mortgages, contracts and the
d raftiu g o f all legal papers.
X ew .be rg. O r e g o n . f
O f f ic e - S econ d Floor
Bank o f N ew terg Building.
S p r in g
'T o r n i C o m m e n c e s M a rch 2 7 »
ADVANTAGES—
n u trition o f th e b o d y , and so g iv e s strength
with the executive committee of the ’ tie som ething, nothing,
to th row o f f disea se. It cle a n se s the b lo o d
T he C ollege is located iu a good moral town o f prosperous
'T » « s mine, ’ ti* hi*, and has been from p o is o n o u s im p u rities a n d e n rich e s it
I state association, and that the commit­
w ith th e red co rp u scle s o f health. It is
tee had met on Friday night to oonskl- slave to thousands;
Churches, there being n o saloon.
n ot a stim ulant, but a strength g iv in g m e d i­
Hut he that filches from me my good cin
Tlie last tw o week* have certainly or it, tie-fact was railed to mind that
e . ft co n .u in s no a lco h o l, n e ith e r op iu m ,
co ca in e , n o r a n y oth er n a rcotic.
(seen history oinking epoch* in Oregon the president of McMinnville College had name
S o m e tim e s th e extra p rofit p a id b y j .Special attention also given to diseases o f the
Robs me of that which not enriches
inter-eoHegiste circles, and especially so | Mated in the presence of live men ihnt
in fe rio r m e d ic in e s tem pts th e d e a le r to
A c o m p e t e n t e o r p s o f ih s t r u e t o r s in t h e F a c u lt y .
E very
him.
E Y E , EAR, NOSE AND T H R O A T .
to two educational institutions, both of lie did not know wLellier a protest had
offe r a su b stitu te as "ju 9 t as g o o d " as "D is* ;
S t u d e n t ’ s in t e r e s t s r e c e i v e s p e c ia l a t t e n t io n . A P r e p a r a ­
And makes me poor indeed.”
c o v e r y .” i f y o u are c o n v in c e d that "D is - : I Office over Bank o f Newberg.
which are located in \ i*»ltill county. ! been filed or not. This seemed so singu-
to r y a n d tw o C o lle g ia te C ou rses.
T w o lit e r a r y s o e i e t i m
I make tin* further remark that if the c o v e r y ” w ill cu re yo u a cce p t n o th in g else. |
In whatever light these institutions have lar that a representative of the Graphic
" I was in poor health when I com m enced 1-----
a n d a C o l le g e P a p e r .
L ib r a r y a n d I t e a d i n g I t o o m w e ll
discomfited
parties
or
those
interested
taking
Dr.
Pierce's
medicine,”
writes
Mr,
Elm
er
t,
,,
trrevionsly been held bv the public, the who was in VfcMinrtviHe on last Tties-
Price.
O. I.. Price
I.iiwl.r, o f Volga, Jeffersor. c o ,, Indiana. " I ,
s u p p lie d w it h t h e le a d i n g M a g a z in e s a n d P e r i o d i c a l s .
events of the past two weeks will largely lay called at the college e.nd held a ! for tliem in these inter-collegiate orator­ h id stomach, ktdnr", iieart. and lung trouble.
L a b o r a t o r y f o r I n d iv id u a l w o r k in C h e m is t r y , P h y s ic s a n d
Was not able to d> any work. I had a severe
ical
contests
are
to
make
a
fuss
and
row
determine their present arid future l short interview with the president arid
cough and hem o. rhage o f the lungs, but after '
B i o l o g y . A g o o d M u s e u m w it h a w id e r a n g e o f s p e c im e n s .
standing us viewed by Oregon at large, seen tary of the local association, J. Fujorer defeats and go into the newspapers using your medicine a while I com m enced to i
gain In strength and flesh, and stopped cough-
Only two weeks »go this evening, J’ i- McKlilop and K. A. Smith respectively, i*° *ttaek tlie successful orator or discuss m g right away. “
S P E C IA L IN D U C E M E N T S T O T E A C H E ltS .
Discovery ’ then, and last
elli.: College, with
her
peerless
young
in
tire
presence
of
.1.
8.
Wallace.
The
the
integrity
and
capacity
of
the
judges
ith h e r
t lie p r e s e n e * o f
K W a lla c e . T h e !
•*>vcB I.vy .....
o.
J“ '1* ' " ¡ Golden
ï h ^ Medical
Grippe,« and it settled on my lungs,
Newber^, Oregon.
cough. I had tne
(C. V. Bank Bldg.)
Freshman orator r, m e t a n d d e f e a t e d a t ; \ o u n g m e n s ta t e .! t h a t t h e y m a i l e d ! 8U<:*' c o n t e s t s b e c o m e r i d i c u l o u s a n d n o | leaving rae w ith .» » severe
seem to help me any ; so j
A ll legal work prom ptly and carefu lly attended
te r* in
III t the
h e o open
p e n f field
ie ld o of f |
h e ir |irotest
o t the
h e committee
c o m m it t e e a
b o u t « « I f - r e s p e t i n g g e n t le m a n w ill h a v e a n y - ^
r;n“ “ ¿ ' ySiar med-
m.
Corvallis all comers
I t their
|irotest t to
about,
to. C ollections given our im m ediate at­ F o r I n f o r m a t i o n , A d d r e s s ,
icine again and took
tention.
oratory. In the next few .lays, malign-1 the middle of the week, that the pres!-' ^ in g to
l*ie'n
three or four Ixjttles o f
G k >. II. W i l l i a m s .
tlie ‘ Discovery' and two
d l by ever jealous and insidious ene- dent of the college hail been consulted
vials o f Dr. Pierce’s Pel­
A tto rn e y B p » » an gl».
lets, and that straight­
mies, she lias bravely a ml proudly met. in the matter, and that he knew the
P ortl . vno , Gregou, March II), 190J.
ened me up. I feel like
a l l charges, ami, triumphantly vindi­ protest had been tent. The question Mr. Jesse K d u ards
a different p e r s o n . I
gladly
recommend your
and
was
put
two
or
three
times
and
very
cated in the eye* of the public by the
medicine to all suffer­
ers, for I know it cured
unprejudiced testimony o f such a man positive answers were each time given Prof. It. W. K elsey,
m e."
New berg, Oregon.
Our familiar belongings
as Hon. G oo. H . William«, Attorney- in the alfirmative.
G entlem en: —
Dr. P ie rce ’ s P lea s­
g row old and unsightly to
W . W . H O L L IN G S W O R T H , P rop .
I’res. Board man said on March 17
General under (’ resident Grant, she
In referen ce to o u r conversation o f today I ant r e lic t s cu re c o n ­
.others’ eyes before our ow n
now stands higher than ever before'in t h a t h e M ill n o t k n o w w h e t h e r a pro* I beg to say that f have carefu lly read the ora- stip a tion b y cu rin g its
cause.
accustomed and u ncon­
the estimation of the people. Gn the t e s t Imd been filed o r n o t , while t w o of ,lou hV Mr- Kl w a « l s . M ioch in on "W e n d e ll
scious eyes perceive their
Ills
students
say
lie
did
know
at
least
also
the
srllele
in
the
“
Oregon-
other hand the students of McMinnville
lau o f touuy. sn ow in g extracts from the ora-
ItE TJ-JliILj Z L I U n T E O F
gradual decline.
college, frenzied with childish jealousy, three days before this that it had been tton, and iu parallel colum ns extracts from
have, led by their jtrewide.it, stooped in done. This is not a ease of plagiarism. Martyu s “ W endell P hillips, the A gitator,” and caused by tho failure of the precinct’s
H O U S B F U K X IS H IN G G O O D S ,
t
I must say that, lu uiy op inion, if this is the candiiate to secure the nomination at
the attempt to is'siiiircli the name of our
I 'lil.tlr Hen 11 in ,-lit.
M a ttin g , F lo o r O ilcloth , Floor-
strongest e v id e n c e that can be ad d uced to the previous convention. lie told them j n o w — and sin ce y o u r atten tion is F lo o r
young orator, and bring disgrace on liis
For forty years tile cry lias been
support the ch arge o f plagiarism , brought they Imd a right to kick. “ W hy?” ask ¡ca lled to it y ou see that it is sh ab-
L in o le u m .
family.
In the eyes of a fair public, no “ Yamhill against the world,” but it ap­ against Mr. M iuchlu, the accusation is not sus
j by, u n a ttractive, o u t o f date.
justification exists for such cowardly pears that ti small circle at tho county taiued. I w ould in fe r from reading the par ed the precinct boss, in surprise.
“ Because you were beaten. ’
j Nobody hut a rich man can afford to ;
conduct on tlie juirt of the students, ex- seat liiis made a revision and t h e cry allel passages that Mr. M inchin’s thought upon
“ Yes hut we were beaten by unfair I go shabbily dressed. Trimness is a sort
Sc
ce|»t the somewhat doubtful one of now is McMinnville against New berg. the su b ject has been influenced by carefu l
study o f M artyn’s work or som e w ork o f si mi
Oi/VKU credential;
V ic t i c n u a i , a
il guaranty
f i l il í ¡m i V o
Ul f sol
HOI-
means.”
| o V*. f social
their being aided and encouraged in it A m for the results t h o future will tell. Inr character. But iu this not legitim ate? If
“ Fair or •unfair,” said the wily o!d ven cy; a certificate o f self-rezpei.-t. You
itv a man whose responsible position is However the Graphic made the discov­ not, I con fess I am ut a loss to understand what
. . . . . . .
.
!. .
can’ t afford to challenge the good opln-
“ lt
i__„r ot ___
_ a ____
. .. by continuing
.• ■ . to
politician,
It is riL'ht
right of the minoriti'
minority to I . ,on
g 00(|
people
one supposed to call for a higher quality ery last Tuesday Unit many of the purpose books o f this kind are to serve. If we
A Fu ll L in e of U n d e rt a k in g
o f manhood. As a result McMinnville citizens of McMinnville deplore the ac­ are not to profit by the work o f those w ho have kick.” “ Its all they have left and its wear that shabby chain when a choice
Cootis C o n s ta n tly in Stock,
preserved th eir thoughts for us upon tho print thelroniy comfort, and we don’ t propose i ° f many beautiful new patterns can he j
College has placed upon her a Wasting tion of tlie college. A few of those con­ ed page, then their labor has been vain and we
to deny you that satisfaction.”
New- bought at a moderate price from those
shown by
sligitia infinitely worse than a dozen de­ sulted will I*1 quoted.
are none the rich er for their efforts.
It seems to m e that it com es in bad grace liert- will please accept this explanation.
Rev. Jos. Ilnlierg and w ife; "W e
feats.
W I N S L O W B R O S., T h o Je w e le rs .
Along the latter part o f last week, have noted that very competent judges from M inchin's Into rivals or their frien d s to iSpme things may have been said and
carry
this
m
atter
into
new
spaper
controversy
done
that
were
better
left
unsaid
and
rumors came floating down from the passed on the orations and our home
If the charges ca n n ot be fully sustained a great
county seat that,encouraged and assist­ college should huve submitted grace­ wrong w ill have been done the person thus at undone, but the thinking public know
H . C O O PE R, President.
the characteristics of College students
ed by Pies. Boardnian, the McMinn­ fully.”
racked, and it is a matter o f com m on ob serva­
and
make
due
allowance
for
their
zeal.
Carriage and W a g on Builder.
ville students were |ireparing to protest
J . I*. Irvine:
“ We don’ t want to tion that those w h o rush into print with such
| E. K . S H A W , Vice Pres.
J. M. W R IG H T , Sec. and M anager.
If one of them would
Mr. Minchin's right to the gold medal fight our neighbors. It is a grave mis­ j Controversies are n ev er in grout haste to reme- Wo like It, too.
| dy the evil they have wrought, In the same climb the gable end of hades and bite o ff
' Choice Farm and City Property.
by bringing against lilin the gross take.”
I form. I d eem it a great injustice, too, to the
the very nose of lucifer himself, we Repairing, Painting and Trim m ing
charge of plagiarism. There was not
■Ins. McCain : " I 'll warrant that if all ! judges w ho have passed upon these orations,
Collect Rents and L ook A fter Estates.
•
much credence put in the report how­ Hie otlier orations weie subjected to tlie ■ that their decision 's should bo appealed from might not think it judicious but we
Prom ptly Done.
Investments Made for N on-Residents.
j
to
the
cou
rt
o
f
p
u
b
lic
op
inion
w
h
ich
has
not
would
applaud.
ever as it was commonly believed that public gaze, they would show uji no bet­
I been, and cann ot be, fully inform ed in relation
Insurance W ritten iu Select Com panies.
No serious harm will come of tills
the president of McMinnville College ter and probuhly not so well.”
I to the matter.
If the d ecision o f the jud ges is
It wilt come out all right
was too much of a man to by engaged in
Frank Fenton: "O ur fellows have [ not to be accepted by thosefwho have voluntarily controversy.
H orseshoeing and General B lack -
A victory for
I subm itted them selves to tho ju risd ictio n o f if not carried too far.
auch shady work himself, und was loo done well In the jiast in the way of
smithing.
well aware of tlie dignity of Ids position wards, ami now 0 * 1 ,«dally since the ! s,,cl‘
If you want to buy, either a large or small farm, you. can save both
tlie,‘ M1I'h ' “ ,,tCsts
a (’ireR- McMinnville by the humiliation or at­
\ our* .slueerely,
tempted humiliation of Newberg would
to countenance It, in Ida Pludents.
On in...Li 1 conies to mir comity, they ought
Vime and m oney by calling on us.
I f we haven’t what y ou
K aki , c . IinoNAiaH.
be worse than the sorest defeat. Neith­
Saturday morning however our citizen« to have been satisfied.”
Want we will take pleasure in assisting you in procuring p rop -
J. C. Cn«»|ier>
er college can afford it. The county
read (lie following tin! 1 charge which
eVty to your satisfaction.
I f a non-resident and wish to o b ­
A1 Snyder: " I have read the oration
M c M i n n v i l l e , On.
cannot afford it, nor can the state afford
appeared in tho Yamhill Reporter:
tain information about Real Estate or the country in general,
••
carefully ami for the life of mo I can’ t E n r r o s G r a p h i c : —
“ Elwood Minehin, tho youngoralorof see where they huve any grounds for a
or N ew berg (the town o f schools and churches) in particular,
You ask mo to give you an Impartial to go into an interstate contest with a
Pacific College, though pOMHeHninjf a gold kick.”
write us.
opinion ol the merits of the oration of divided allegiance. Much of this con­
medal, occupies a very linen viable posi­
tf*AV*ueWZ»rnlÄCa>T -VX
BH
« V» i^ -TSJKWaUJB
Col. .1. C. Cooper covers the whole 101 wood iH. Minehin, awarded tho «old troversy is laid at tlie door of Mr. Eck-
tion. It has been ascertained that his
oration, which captured the judges at ground in a well written urflclu which | medal at the late inter-collegiate contest man, associate editor of the Reporter.
Corvallis, is a general paraphrase of Car­ up|>ears elsewhere In this issue.
i und now disputed by McMinnville and We are confident that Mr. Eckman
los .Martin's life ot Phillips, some two
* some of tlie other state colleges, on the wrote what ho did, based on what he
One
newspaper
limn
said,
“
I
see
tho
-I F SO -
MM<n
has for nearly sixty years been
hundred words being taken I I i I y from
published on Monday, Wednes­
believed reliable information. I think
j UK
recognized as the People’ s N a-
that work. This is no idle dream. The injustice of this thing and I only wish I ¡ground that the oration is a plagiarism
day and Friday, is a com plst»
® ■B**
tional Family Newspaper, for
NEW-
comparison has been made. There is a nus in a position to say what I think of j 0,1 C!a|d°s Martyn’s, “ Wendell Phillips, lie is one of the most careful, conscien­
farmers and
villagers.
Its
up to date daily newspaper*
n
C
v
i
"
splondid
Agricultural
Depart-
tious
as
well
as
able
local
editors
in
tlie
natural and unwritten law governing it,”
three
days in the week, with
the Agitator."
“ ■*J w*
nient, its reliable market re-
all
important news of the other
ouch contests which stamps plagiarism
ports,
recognized
authority
At PortlaiiU.
Plagiarism formerly meant kldnnp- state. I state this after years o f inti­
four days.
Profusely illus­
lü lfir k
throughout the country; its
as an unpardonable oH’ense.
There Is
Many prominent men at Portland who ping or man-stealing, later being used mate acquaintance.
fashion notes, its Science and
trated, and filled With interest-
much speculation as to what the result
V
*kIec,ian*cs
Department,
i
t
s
I
sincerely
hope
the
cooler,
better
WEEKLY lng reading for all who wish tw
of this discovery will he. The opinion were approached said, ‘ Oh yes, wo see | for stealing or borrowing tho phruses or
V ? ib 2 í \ L ¡1 fascinating short stories, etc.,
etc., render it indispensable in
keep in close touch with new»
is general that it should bar Mtnchiti it is the fellows who were defeated In | Ideas of another without proper credit. judgment of nil will prevail and the
every family. llP K u l u r J*ul>-
T R 5 R U N C o f the nation and world.
from the interstate contest, if indeed it j the contest w ho ure kicking.”
price,
$ 1 .0 0
One | In tlie parallel published in the Ore- controversy will stop. It must stop. I b y callin g on me before; TRÎ3UÎÎE p Mcrlptic.n
I n iD U n C H e g a l a r » a b s c r ip tlo A
e
r
y
e
a
r
.
does not place Pacific College l>eyond
p r i c e , 9 1 .5 0 p e r y e a r *
i prominent attorney formerly from this ! gotdan of the 19th inst. the Newberg have helped too many students over
*n fonnection with The Tribune we offer to t.iose wh0 desire to secure the heat nukcAzln*«
the pule of future purtieipution in inter-1
clo sin g a trade w ith
illusuated weeklies and agricultural journals, the follow ing splendid inducements*
8
*
collegiate contest*
The amende lion- m i,llt.v
11 ia die same old Me- j committee admits of twelve quotations rough places to sav aught against any
_
_
With
orahlo for that institution would «com ; Minnvillo y o w l."
¡from Martyn but claim the manuscript, one. They till need help, and God bless
Regular
With
Weekly
T
ri-W
eekly
others.
Price
Tribune,
Tribune,
to t.e lliat'thcy gracefully "acknowledge
Mr. M inchin’s friends were advised used by Minehin and submitted to the them, I will do it again and again.
One Year.
On* Year.
K o n ^ A m e rie n n R e v ie w , N e w Y e r U C I t r ......... sr'-O O ^'
*
5
.0
0
They
shall
not.
go
away
from
me
or
my
jlllrper.M »l:!Kn. l u e , \ e w Y o r k C i t y . . . . ........... 4 LOO
i* .
ranv^hc sidd'for Mr.^Mlnehln’ tlEiT' with I ''y ,'r" " 1“ " 'nt
" 1>' ,r|b>'>d
K''‘ , coimmttee on awards gave due credit by
4 .0 0
l l a i - p e r n II u n r . l e w Y o r k C l t v . , . . .....................
1.00
library without the liest I can give in
4 .0 0
4 .5 0
a personal subject Hindi a* ha chose, the written opinion» from Hon. George II. quotation marks.
IlHiiii-r'n W e e k l y , n e w Y o r k C i t y .
4
.0
0
4
.0 0
C c n . iir y •i i jit u .ljie , Jierv ^ o r k C it y
4 .0 0
teinptution is very strong to use Ian- W illiiniis und attorney Karl C. Brouaogh j The McMinnville committee publish work and eneourngernert. Tho New­
4 .0 0
15S
C«. \ j W ioiiiM v „ ; g H / I n r . N on Y o r k C i t y .
3 .0 0
3 .0 0
3 .3 0
His address was
guago other I hun hi* own, but yielding on the oration, which they have done,
entitled, "A
“ An
Interesting I t'ar- berg hoy is all right.
me. a leaflet
leutiet cnimeti,
n interesting
1.00
1 .3 0
1 .0 5
1 .oo
is sin.
\\ rtlcrs and speakers generally
1.2 3
1 .8 5
an able one and showed great work in
Judge
Williams
lias
probably
deliver-
allel,”
in
which
they
claim
sixteen
quo-
l.(K)
1 .3 5
2.00
get their ideas handed down, hilt most
1.00
1.10
Newliorg shows the true
1 .7 »
-I have both-
ol them display the ability to cloth ed more oration* than any other man | tutions were made by Minehin, of preparation.
1.00
1.20
1 .7 3
f u n ' s . .Yo-.v i '..-It C i t y .
5 .0 0
5 .0 0
5 .5 0
them in their own verbiage. The pow on the Pacific Coast and Mr. Urousugh phrases and Ideas from Martyn.
They spiiit and it is the duty o f the county
• I l i c i ' . '-*■ V. l o r o C i '. v ..................................
5 .0 0
5
.0
0
5
.5 0
er to express conies from possession of a ranks as one of the best attorneys in do not sav whether due c e d it is given and state to stand by them.
'* .-
lv .
Y o r k C i t y ...........................
4 .0 0
4.0 0
4 .5 0
AND
2 .5 0
knowledge ol thesut joct matter treated.
2 .5 0
3 .1 5
.
'"
'i
r
"
*
r
.
-
.
n
e
.
N
e
w
Y
o
r
k
C
it
s
-..............
J.
C.
C
ooper
.
3 .0 0
3 .5 0
3 .0 0
The knowledge acquired, the student Portland. Hero are written opinions \ by quotation marks or not. They claim
iltu rl.t,
Y ork u t * . . . .
1 .00
1.2 5
-< ir i 1 , e -■ V : ‘ \ i r, h r vv Y oris C i t y .................
should he able to frame his own from men who arc eminently well quali- however that the stanza used by Min-
1.00
1 .2 5
property in
5.“
'■ •
¡ s i ’ ' . I r v ú n s í o u , N. Y . . .
1.00
1.2 3
i jim
thought» concerning it, and not expect fled to judge in this matter. Read what chin at the clone of his oration was used
C o m i t : ’ t,
: i . ir - n . .Y ï '. n o v .
Y ........................
Tin* leading editorial in Monday's Or­
2.00
2.00
2 .5 0
J o ! - n i, f i
ïa if.-r -itifii. f o r n i ...................
to fly with another’ s w ings. ”
Jto
1 .0 0
1 .5 0
they have to say.
! without credit or quotation marks.
In egonian says:
t,.:
,
, ,
f ! , i i . : . V ' i r, ,,|n . f i n n .
“ Considerable agitation
3 .0 0
3 . AO
3 .5 0
Y
o
l
.
l
,
.
■
■
-
O,
.
ItO
ilO
P
.
M
l'..,;,.....................
The writer ol the above has informed
1.7 3
2 .2 3
All the other orations delivered at the Memorial Addresses on the Life and is reported from Albany over the discov­
2.00
; :! r ‘d. ■ ,
• ; i ri i: •. -, i l . ' ( o . , ......................
.5
0
1.00
1 .5 0
tho Graphic that lie thought he was on Corvallis have gone Into hiding and Mr_ Character of a deceased Senator or Uep-
.' 1 >, ,1 ...
Pprl-ictteld. .11,,»..
1.00
1 .2 3
1^3
ery that Klwood Minehin, who recently j
1 .0 0 * *>-.!i.o-
, .- - r ! i ' 4 n c l e . » i n « . ...........
1.00
1.00
safe ground as lie got his Information Miuchin's is the only one that is lieing rosentative by his living colleagues in
i il ri i. . ÏI'1,1 r, n-|
* ■ f s h I r , ( 'l i j o s f l o , l i t . . .
i.<»o
1.0
0
j won the state oratorical contest oh he- j
O r i n u f Jrn: ! t ' n r m r r . ( li i r n a o , l i t ...................
l.oo
1.2 5
direct from Pro». Hoardmnn. The mis­ dissected. Hut nothing is being Covered Congress, quotations are often made
1 .8 3
p '. s i ,
I»»ci.....................
| half of Pacific College, Newberg, had 1 and prices as low as the lowest. r O . h p i i o t o K
..50
1.00
1 .3 0
ik ' u f - , < L v e L in f l, l'iijr».......................... **
take lie made was in not making a up by the young man or Ins friends. At from tho poets and no thought of credit
.OO
1.00
F t'.-it iir, I* e tr o it . Miela.....................
preiiure.i himself for the oration on Votl will find the property I offer
.oo
1 .0 0
F
*
rm
nu
l
l
i
r
e
-
i
(|y».
*ril<*!<l,
O
h
i
o
..............
further investigation before he publish­ their request the Oregonian on Tuesday is entertained or quotation marks ap-
.5 0
1.00
1 .5 0
r a ran >eiVN. Snrinicflriil. O h i o ........................
Wendell Phillips by reading, and that
for sale as represented.
.50
1.00
1 .5 0
H o m e n iu f i ’ u . i n , l,on ÍK Y Íi| p , K v ...........
***
ed such a charge to the world, hut since puhlished in |uira!lel columns extracts pear on the printed page.
.50
They pie- 1 from at least one book lie had taken J
1.00
1
.5 0
Th** F « rr.»**r, - 1 . P a u l. M l n n . . . . ............. .. * * '
.50
1 . 01 »
he admits that he was deceived and h is from the oration and Phillijis’ hook, sume that their hearers and the reading
1 .5 0
T r i h n n f t l m n n a o . 1!>01........................................ * ‘ *
1 .1 0
1 ideas, and even words.
While plagiar- ;
agreed to set the mutter right in the fids liaa given the public an opportu- public nre sufficiently familiar with enr-
ism, of course,
nine, is a crime of peculiar
pwbHcatt6«s . « comwetiok „ 0 »
N ew berg, Ore.
next Issue of the Reporter no further nitv to read ami compare.
rent literature to know that they are turpitude, the defeated colleges that Opposite P. O.
__________________________________________ AJtlreas T 1 I C T U I P U N E . N e w Y o r k . C i t y .
comment is necessary here on lids point.
In this care there seems to have been not trying to paint ol their literary gems hope now to take from young Minehin
Soon after liavlnc read tlie lfoporter I *ome star chamber work done So far as original. On the life and character tho honor they faded to win from him
article a representative ol tlie Graphic Pacific Collette has not been able to se- of John A. Logan many of the most dis­ m open mutest run great risk of making
In company with 1 rof. R. \\ . Kelsey cure a copy ol the protest. The officers tinguished men o f the time delivered much ado nhout nothing. Tne amount
drove out to tho home o f Mr. Minehin of tho McMinnville, local association Addresses in Congress, such ns Win. M.
of knowledge possessed bv a 19 v.*ar-old
mid made a careful examination of Ids «ere usked (or a cop) hut they saiilthey F.vtrts, of New Y ork, McKinley, of
hov on the subject of Wended Rliillipps,
oration iu comparison with the hook in hud none. On Wednesday Mr. Nowby Ohio, Cullom, of Illinois, and twenty
or any of tlie subjects custom imposes
question. Mr. Minehin turned to every recelved a lettor frutti the prcsident of others, which w ere published in tH)ok o f
for collegiate orations, cannot lie exten­
page in the I«>ok from which passsac* the state associatimi saying tiro execu­ •-"JO pages. At least thirty quotations are
sive or profound, and if he has found
had in any way heen used and pointed tive colli mi ttee would meet in S iletu on I made from tho poets and no quotation
books Dial liel|K-1 him stel used their
them out.
T’ pnn completing tlie inves­ nexl Satunlay tu considsr the contest I marks appear and in very few instances
contents effectively, this fact itself is
tigation and being fully convinced that case, tliis boing the tirsi officiai notici1 is tho author of the fines even men­
not enough to condemn him as un­
a great wrong had hceu done the young recai visi licre of all Ilio row wliich tms | tioned.
worthy to wear tlie coveted honor.
man a meeting ol hi* friends was Im­ leen kicked up. Tliis gives little timo
He who writes of the past must get Surely i: is n- t ex|-cctrd that a youth of
mediately called nod ns n result of the for preparation hut M iuchin’a accuserà his information from books or tradition.
his tender years will bring history and
conference, Jesse Edwards, B. t’ . Miles, will Ite met with a warm reception.
Therefore tho phrase* and ideas built economics any great amoiiut of neb-
l’m f. Kelsey snd AV. IV Woodward
i
^ i -i m
•
I*1*». Re», il William».
i frolli h<K'ks piri.ikc more or 1< of tlie thought or original investigation. There
drove over to McMinnville the next
lli.iv o Invìi requesteil lo give my originai, heneo are inorerei »hie, hat as is very little original thinking in this
morning.
views a* In whether or not Mr. Klwood an instance oi “ borrowed ide.i*,” will
pretentious world. Over and over again
Mr. Ihknii-i of the If.
rter was S. Vinchin was guilty o f plagiarism in some one read T. Bachannn Rea l's,
every bottle— hence you
The formula is pin
we are revolving the speculations o f tlie
found and on giving I’n
Board in an as his oration n j»n Wemlell Iliillips, the Closing Boene, which the Westminster
ancients, tlie douh's they cherished, the
:u take Grove's. Imitators
know just what you arc
hi* nnthority for the statement pub- Agitator.
Review says |* unquestionably tlie hope* they clutched at, tlie dream* they
fished, ho conducted tin e party over h>
I have eoiupared th i oration wit»i Mr. liin-st American poem ever written, and
that you would net buy
d
o
not
advertise
their
to:
Over and over again we tell
tlie college, and called up Mr. ItiMid- Martyn’s tionk “ Wen.l. ll I’ liillips, tlie then read that mwteliles* poem, Grnv'a dreamed.
i f ncd.
Grove’ s contains
the stories o f our tew great men, point
their medicine it you !;r
man, who lo o k all his visitors into lin­ Agitator” and do not lind Ihnt Mr. Min-
Elegy. Either Ideas aro borrowed lien­
college udioo. Tlie obj ci ■.( the visit d im has appropriatisl in its entirety or the ectasy of the muses produces ihe same morals, sound the same alarm.
rr.( is an J is in a Tasteless
Iron
and
Quinine
put
up
There i* little new, and if we have any
was soon state I, and w i:h Ilio oration any paragraph of lliu hinik not properly very similar inspiration in tlie minds ol
.
he Quinine drives the
form.
1 he Iron act» ;
well-defined need among lli-ise who pose
and tlie l.sik at hainl, I'rof. Kelsey and expressed iu quotation marks.
He has tile author*.
ns instruct.res ol opinion todav, it is that
J:
;i.-t will tell you that
malaria
out
ot
the
sytc.v
the presi.lent liegsn investigation in the US"I many of the idea* and some of the
Tlie quotation* ol Minehin are ‘ taken If icy AiMlltl nc»t
hlimi to tlie light that
presence ol Mr. Eckman.
I t » .1A HiMHI word* in tlie l.vik, hut it would l>o didi- from a soqn- ol nearly
.■
_r
so-called
I iile v d
itoilred IS coitic inf«» Un* inarid, ami cease pro-
Grove’s is the
!
discovered ii|Min how sutwlantial grounds cult, if not imjiossihle. lor any one writ­ pages, while hi. ad lr e -s o
>t more nmit'Atlng things new snd strange,
off
: r c • ’ . I ton es shews
Chill T o n v i *”*re imitatio
Mr. Boardnian’s eoniplaints were U s«|, ing upon Wendell 1‘ liillipi to s.iy nny* thsn three pages, hence it
jvtrinKe which the hext geineration will be at
as lie went «o far ns to deny the right of thing in iiis praise that is not found in more ol a synopsis th in
i
. ’■/ tsoect.
You
that Grove’ s is iupt io
ptlilK* tO Ulnravel aml disprove.
Min-
Mr. Minehin to tf ns nf
*•> 1111 * form In Martyn’s Book ol mon A plagiarism oi that length w.vjid
chin, wc tnke it. ih noi tìnti that tli‘ *î»o
are not c v p e r m c n 'i n ; a
properly credit« I. Me
than 500 page*.
low mon* the theme ol a single char t
who 1 1 liti studied \Y m ie li l ’ iiillip s
orator of trying to pain
Mr. Minehin could not po ssihly know
an i excellence
v : u;
Now, in Iella!I of McMinnville'* rn
3ltO|3*ther wroc.f,
ul m a V it b t lon^r
rv whicli was not ene
anything about Wendell I’ ll il'ips eXIY|>' to kick.
An olii politician was sent
h. « kiw n i
until
such
ori
«r
mahl
b.cun»oí
!ho
u
ieis*,
only
Chill
Cure
tuurks as his own. It
■I wtini lie learned from lerdk® •»tul he Can- quell a disaffection in a cvitaig pre.it
lire of Urs-t r r ik i.
j.
DR. WOODS HUTCHINSON,
PHYSICIAN & SURCECIf.
PRICE & PRICE.
A TTO R K EYS -A T-LA W .
P r e s id e n t P a c ific College.
Shabby, isn’t it?
LOOK
Newberg Furniture
Store.
YOUR WATCH CHAIN
Portier Curtains, W indow Shades, Couches
Baby Buggies. W all Paper and Picture
Moulding a Specialty.
N ew berg
Land
C o.
ROY GARDNER
Newberg, Ore.
Do Yoa Contemplate Pnrciiasiiir
REAL ESTATE
POPOLAR PUBLICATIONS— POPULAR PRICES
SAVE MONEY
Y03K
TRI-
•m
CITY
COUNTRY
M
Tracts to suit
purchasor,
IS
m
A. P. OLIYEtf,
&eve.
T*i£ B E S T FiiZSV-FJPTfON SS
Grove: T ricrei
the
i
UniicJ
C m l! T o n ic .