Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Oregon daily emerald. (Eugene, Or.) 1920-2012 | View Entire Issue (Sept. 28, 2005)
Tim Bobosky | Photo editor Tim Smith, left, a small business owner, and Kent Kullby, a city planner, discuss the voiding of their marriage license by the Oregon Supreme Court. University alumni challenge Ballot Measure 36 outcome Basic Rights Oregon claims the measure is illegal, and is taking it to court with the help of volunteer attorneys BY EMILY SMITH NEWS REPORTER Several University alumni are among 22 Oregonians who filed a complaint in Marion County on Monday, challenging the legitimacy of Measure 36, which was passed last November prohibiting gay mar riage in Oregon. Basic Rights Oregon, a gay rights advocacy group, initiated the case with the help of volunteer attor neys, recruiting 10 gay and lesbian couples who were affected by Mea sure 36 and whom BRO officials hoped would strengthen the com plaint, BRO Communications Direc tor Rebekah Kassell said. According to BRO’s Web site, “the measure is illegal and should not have been presented to Oregon voters.” Prosecuting Attorney Mark John son of Portland said Measure 36 is unconstitutional because it makes two amendments to the constitution. If a ballot measure contains more than one amendment, Oregon’s constitution states that each amend ment must be voted on separately. He also said the process used to change Oregon’s constitution was inappropriate because the changes were so sweeping that they should qualify as a revision instead of an amendment. But Charles Fletcher, an assistant attorney general defending the measure, said voters only clarified marriage law in the simple one sen tence proposition and didn’t change it. “There was no right to same-sex marriage before Measure 36, and there is no right to same-sex mar riage after Measure 36,” Fletcher said. Marion County Circuit Court Judge Joseph Guimond is scheduled to rule on the complaint by Nov. 1. If he rules in favor of the plaintiffs, the case will move to the appeals court. If it succeeds there, it will be forwarded to the Oregon Supreme Court, Johnson said. If the plaintiffs win, the amend ment will be stricken. Without the amendment, the court might choose to interpret the words “husband and wife” in the constitution as gen der-neutral, Johnson said. The complaint names Gov. Ted Kulongoski as a defendant because he was responsible for issuing a proclamation declaring the measure approved. When questioned about the case on Thesday afternoon, Ku longoski said he had not read the complaint. To plaintiffs Kent Kully and Tim Smith, a victory would be a small step toward the United States hon oring their marriage. The Eugene couple was selected because of the media coverage they received in 2004 as the first gay couple to be married in Eugene and because of the instrumental role they played in starting the Domestic Partner Reg istry, Smith said. He and Kully at tended the hearing in Salem to lis ten to arguments about the case. “They were splitting split hairs,” said Smith. “But on some level they were talking about my life.” Smith believes that he and Kully will eventually be able to wed legiti mately, although it may be a long process. The couple of 14 years met while they were both attending giaduate school at the University in 1991. Other plaintiffs include Dan O’Neil and Steve Kenison of Bend, who have been a couple for eight years. Kenison has a health insur ance policy that won’t cover O’Neil, who has “serious health issues,” ac cording to the BRO Web site. The site also lists lesbian couple Cristina Caravaca and Sandra Naranjo, a University graduate, who are putting off adopting another baby until “they can be assured that their family is protected.” Becky Hanson and Kathy Flynn a couple for 15 years who married in Multnomah County last year, are also plaintiffs in the case. Flynn is a sergeant for the Eugene Police De partment, and if she were injured or killed in the line of duty, Hanson would not receive survivor benefits under Measure 36. Hanson, also a former University student, worked for the EPD for 27 years before retir ing in 2003. The couple remains op timistic that someday gay couples will enjoy the same rights as straight couples, according to BRO’s Web site. The complaint also names as plaintiffs two Oregon reverends whose churches defend gay mar riage. Canada, most of Europe and New Zealand are more open to the issue of gay marriage than the United States, he said. “The United States is way behind the rest of the world,” Smith said. Oregon was among the first states where marriage licenses were is sued when Multnomah County granted more than 3,000 licenses. The state Supreme Court invalidat ed them, saying the county had no authority to issue the licenses. esmith® daily emerald, com The Associated Press contributed to this report. Student Groups! Advertise in the Emerald call 346-4343 or place your ad online at www.dailyemerald.com You Should Consider a Career in Teaching if... Apply today for January 2006 Fifth Year Master of Arts in Teaching Program! « Earn your Master of Arts in Teaching and Initial Oregon Teaching license tn 12 months. • En)oy small classes and personal attention from our accomplished faculty. * Take advantage of our respected relationships with local school districts. Information Meeting October 4th, 4-5 pm EMU Rogue Room RSVP to teach@paciftcu.edu or 485-6812 Substance Abuse Prevention Program SAPP is a nationally recognized program designed to provide education and to increase awareness and prevention in the areas of: www.sweetlifedesserts.com Voted best of Eugene: Baker) S Sweet Tootb Indulgence I'Weet Life 755 MONROE ST.,EUGENE,OR 97402 • 541.683.5676 A patisserie serving fine desserts, gourmet pastries,
