Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The Oregon statesman. (Salem, Or.) 1916-1980 | View Entire Issue (April 21, 1928)
4 THE OREGON STATESMAN. SALEM, OREGON. SATURDAY MORNING, APRIL 21. 1928 fi 1" J: The Oregon lnaii i i nil n ii l ill ii i ii i ii m ii ii i r i ii Iuned Daily Except Uonday by THE STATESMAN PUBLISHING COMPANY 115 Seath t"OJ"rrial Strrat. Salem, Oregon K. J. Hendricks rIrl 8. JlcSherry Balph C. Curtia Kaialla Bunch Managing Kditor - City Editor Society Editor MEMBER O THE ASSOCIATED FKESS Tie Aiocited Pr.ai it eaciuiivrly entitled tetie ne fur publication of all bows dispatebea credited to il or not otherwise credited ia thia paper and ) the local aew published herein business orricxs ataaber Selected Oregon Newapapera Pacific Coaat Repreentati.a -Doty Stypef. In., Portland. Security BIdg.; Ban 'rancico. Sharon Bldf.; Loa Aagelea. Chamber of Commerce BIdg. Thoaaaa '. Clark Co.. -New York. 12S 13 W 31t St.. Chicago Mar-jiette Btdg. Bualaeat Officer..JJ or 583 TELEPHONE! Joy, p.p.rtiuent 5 Society Editor 100 Stmt Ipt 23 or 583 Circulation Office Watered at the Poat O'fit. in hm. April 21, 1928 He trusted in God; let Him deliver Him now. if He will hare Him: for He said. I am the Son of Cod. The thieves also, which were crurified with Him, east the same in his teeth. Matthew -7: 43-44. CAPITAL PUNISHMENT "Official hangings alwavs large percentage of the people, orvri .,n.iviri7nfi 9nri w.n.' in tious ODjectors. ii retaineu, guilty of cold blooded and premeditated murder. So writes a neighboring editor commenting on the Willos and Kelley hanging of yesterday morning at the state peni tentiary. But we now have that very thing A Capital punishment for those found guilty of "cold blood ed and premediated murder." That is, murder in the first degree. And we have a rather strange experience with this idea of capital punishment. There was a movement in the constitutional convention of 1857 for the abolition of capital punishment. It failed. Then there was a movement to not allow the governor of Oregon to pardon or commute the sentences of persons convicted of crime. This! motion was lost by a vote of only 18 to 15. We had capital punishment in Oregon till Nov. 3, 1914, when an iniated amendment carried abolishing it. There fol lowed several horrible murders. And the legislature of 1920 initiated a new law, which was carried at the election of May 21, 1920, providing that conviction for first degree murder should carry the death penalty, "excepting when the trial jury shall recommend life imprisonment." But this provision, plainly written and initiated and in tended to have capital punishment inflicted in Oregon onlyj in extreme cases of "cold blooded and premeditated murder, is of Dracticallv no effect. It than by its observance" by juries in this state. And this is true of juries composed partly of women as of those made up exclusively of men. There has been a string of convictions of first degree mur der in Oregon, right down the line, since 1920, and there have been almost no recommendations by juries of life imprison Oh, yes; there was one notable case. It was the case of (incidents objected to by her took Hugh D'Autremont ! That recommendation led to life impris-j p1"- As she scorned his over 6 - , . - , tures, so the story goes, he choked onment for the twin brothers. nen a second girl attempted to There was another one. in Frank Clark, in Klamath county. Just those two. There may have been another one, but a man in Salem . a mm I who keeps track of such matters, on account of his official position, does not know of could find only the D'Autremont case. The conclusion is that the majority of the people of Ore gon are now evidently in favor of capital punishment, though they voted to abolish it in 1914, by a majority of 157, with 101,552 for and 100,395 against. The majority for the law as it now stands was 17,167. The majority of the people of Oregon do not want capital punishment inflicted excepting upon persons found guilty of "cold blooded and premeditated -. The majority of the people complete abolition of capital punishment, if they could be as sured that life imprisonment for all persons guilty of murder in the first degree ; and per haps a majority of them would so express themselves at a plebiscite as to second degree murder With the pardoning and commuting power resting as at present, to prevent grave .injustices found by the develop ment of new evidence not available at first trials. It might be added as a final word in the case that a great many people in Oregon who are not in favor of capital pun ishment in general at all will of the Willos and Kelley case, commutation might have had discipline at the state penitentiary. That is a thing that every consideration of penology calls else. There can be no measure discipline. And no adequate workings of the laws of ref orma tion, which, according to our Constitution, and of right, is then main spring of prison servitude. THE HEART OF HERBERT HOOVER "There is, to my mind, no economic failure so terrible in its import as that of a country possessing a surplus of every necessity of life, with numbers willing and anxious to work deprived of those necesities. It simply cannot be if our mor al and economic system is to survive." Who said that? Herbert Hoover. The statement shows the heart of Her bert Hoover And it shows the sound economic ideas of the man. The highest duty of statesmanship in the United States is the abolition of involuntary unemployment. Every person in this country who is willing to work for self support ought to have the opportunity to work. There is enough for all, and to spare. How shall it be pro vided? How shall involuntary unemployment and conse quent hunger and distress be abolished in this land of plen ty?, ; There are other considerations of statesmanship in the United States, but none so important, and none so pressing as this. Herbert Hoover as president could perhaps not go the whole way in a term or two terms as president But that great constructive engineer could go as far in pointing the way to the solution of this problem as any man now walking the earth. His record of great accomplishments go to prove this. . - t Statesman, Ralph If. Klatiing. Adartaing Ifanagar l.ioyd K. htiffier - - Superintendent W. H. Haodertan, Cin-nlation sfr K. A. Khot.n - - Lireetoek Miter W. C. Conner Poaltry Editor Oregen. at rond rUa matter. outrage the sensibilities of a who regard it as abhorrent m-ineiDle. hence are conseien-f ...ii. u mkuuu uc ii t.-c ... is "more honored in its breach June of last year, in the case of any other. In fact, he at first murder." of this state would vote for the would mean life imprisonment, rest content with the outcome on account of the fact that a the effect of breaking down of for, almost above everything of safety in prisons without EDITORIALS OF THE PEOPLE AU eorreapoae'eaee (or this SSSart eaeat aaaat ba algaed ky tae writer. ka writ aa eaa aid el tae pa par oalr. anl ol let ka I get Uncle Ham PoUoner? Editor Statesman: It appears our Unci Samuel he with the bell crowned hat Is really a poisoner. Not on of your low down dog poisoners, but of the whole country. He has put a fatal kick in certain brands of alcohol. Honest men and may be women imbibe, then shuffle off aud fall ont of the procession of the living and are seen no more. Now this is awful! For shame, Uncle, why do you do so? He could say. though. "Well. I put a skull and crossbones on the killer. I told them not to use It as a bev erage, as that is not its purpose. It belongs in the laboratory and to the chemists. But notwith standing if any dry throat must have it, go ahead. It is probably as good a way as any to commit suicide." Well. yes. Why blame the law when, a plain warning goes with il? The charge is Just a kick 'against prohibition No matter now si ail(i njust anything will do. "You can't enforce prohlbi- tion." A Rood contemporary newspa per which most of us over here in West Salem take keeps telling us this. Weil, it is doing all it can to not have it enforced, and has been doing it for years, so it ought to be satisfied. There are a dozen or more other prohibition laws on our statute books that are not enforced, yet we hear little against them. Why? N. J. BOWERS. West Salem. April 20. 1928. GIRL RESENTS KILVERTON YOUTH'S ATTENTIONS Because he kissed Myra Thomas, local waitress, and forced other unwelcome attentions upon her, a Silverton youth last night lan guished in the Marion county Jail. Robert Goetz, Jr., son of the Silverton superintendent of schools, was the youth. Miss Thomas yesterday swore out a complaint against him. tery. Arrested and brought Into justice court Goetz Is said to have confessed that he did salute the girl as alleged In the complaint. The whole matter grows out of a trip home from a dance here last Saturday night. It was when Goetz was taking the girl home in com- Irtanv with several others that the .come to the rescue but was struck by Goetz. According to Goetz' story he did not strike the other :girl untll after Bne nad CJLiied him ' ..... . . several objectionable names Justice of the Peace Brazier Small has ordered the case con tinued for trial. COUPLE MAKES ACTOR EFFECTS RECONCILIA TION WITH WIFE SAN FRANCISCO. April 20. (AP) Pat Somerset, actor play ing here, and his wife, Shelby Den ison Worrel Somerset who yes terday filed a separate mainte nance suit in Loa Angeles, tonight announced that they had effected a reconciliation. Mrs. Somerset arrived here from Los Angeles by automobile. Mrs. Somerset said she under stood process servers were en route north to serve her husband with papers In the separate main tenance suit. Then she decided to come north and call on him her self. "I have seen him play in his San Francisco vehicle," said Mrs Somerset. "He does a beautiful piece of acting. We had a good talk and decided to drop all the talk of suits and divorces. "I do hope I can stop my moth er from coming to California," she added. "She wrote me that she was leaving Galveston right away to take charge of my af fairs." The couple were installed again In their apartment here. Somer set agreed that a reconciliation had been arranged. "We're both sorry it happened. but we have made up again and all is rosy once more," he said. A. M. Southwick, Resident In Salem 46 Years. Dies Albert M. Southwick. SO, con tractor and architect of this city, died at his home 1065 Marlon street yesterday noon. He had lived in this city for the past 4 C years. Hs had been 111 for many years. Southwick served in the Spsnish American war with the old second Oregon regiment. He leaves his wife. Mrs. Clara Southwick; his mother. Mrs. Helen M. Southwick; two sisters, Mrs. J. W. Hastings, of Salem and R. A. Cox, Salt Lake city; and two brothers. Rolls snd Ralph, both of this city. Hs was a member of the Woodmen of the World lodge. Funeral arrange ments havs not been completed. GORDON FIGHTS TONIGHT SAN FRANCISCO. April 20.- (AP) "Midget- Mike O'Dowd, of Colnmbos, Ohio, one of the few "knockout-potmen" featherweight fighting today, Ukes on "Sailor Willis Gordon of Portland. Ore.. in & tsn round bout hers Friday night. O'Dowd Is fsvored over the northern boy. KISSES KT DJIRRllw ATTACKS HEWS PRACTICES Famous Criminal Lawyer Addresses Society of Newspaper Editors WASHINGTON, April 20. (AP) After bearing the faults of journalistic practice as recited by representatives of the law, medi cine and ministry, the American Society of Newspaper Editors in convention here amended its con stitution to provide for stringent action against any member found guilty "of violation of the code of professional ethics of the organi zation." The vote was 18 to 15 and fol lowed a protracted debate in which the majority present par ticipated. The amendment was sponsored by Willis Abbott, editor of the Christian Science Monitor, and Tom Wallace of the Louisville Times, as opposed to a less force ful change to the same effect which had been recommended by the constitution committee. The alternative penalties pro vided by the amendment were cen sure, suspension or expulsion. In arguing for it. Abbott said: "This society should not be left without any means of protection against members who may flag rantly and wilfully offend against its code of ethics which it had adopted as part of its fundament al law." The society comprises 217 newspaper editors in cities all over the cuontry of over 50,000 popu lation. Clarence Darrow, criminal law yer, assailed the newspapers on several points around which he wound at the same time a con demnation of the social system in this country. "The money-getting itch has seized the press," he said, "and It Is certain that the newspapers look first of all to the advertisers, saying 'we can't offend them.' "People say they can't believe the newspapers," he went on, "but they do believe them. That the trouble with them." Darrow charged that editors kept a list of "sacred, white ele phants." or persons and Institu tions that must not be disparged. "Of course, I'm not on that list.", he added. The lawyer attacked "sensation alism," saying that Justice is vir tually Impossible in this country because the newspaper accounts of crime determine the guilt of the accused in outstanding cases "in the moronic public mind." "We have the most barbarous criminal code In the world." he declared. "Today It's '100 per cent Amer icanism'." shouted Darrow. "with D. A. R.'s and everythlnr like that. Their ancestors were rebels but they're not." He was included on the recently published so-called "blacklist" of the Massa chusetts chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution, now in convention here. ober.'psq .(A. and adn adn aod Charges Advanced by Re publican State Chairman Yesterday COLUMBUS. Ohio. April 20. (AP) That Willis and Hoover forces are suspecting each other of fraud in next Tuesday's presi dential primary was indicated to day in a statement issued from the camp of the latter. Charges made this week by the republican state chairman. Fred W. Warner, that frauds were be ing contemplated in Cincinnati. Cleveland and Toledo admitted to oe Hoover strongholds, were met oy a counter charge from Thad H thrown, manager of the Hoover campaign that "this la only a smoke screen to afford an excuse and opportunity for juggling the returns in localities where the .ll W m auu-nwier iorces are most actllve. The Hoover campaign managers construes Chairman Warner's warning to imply that the Hoover forces are contemplating retorting to fraud tactics in the three big cities and Mr. Brown's statement was construed as indicating that Hoover managers are suspecting similar tactics in districts where sentiment is strongest for Willis pledged delegates. It Is known that both sides sre most concerned in this respect with the fate of candidates for delegates at large. BROOKS, Apr. 20 (Special) A very interesting meeting- of the Brooks Community club was held at the home of Mrs. Charles CofTindaffer on Thursday after noon. April 1. The usual routine of work was done and a short business session was held with the president. Mrs. Walter Fuller, presiding. at. mis time plans were dis cussed and a vote taken in regard to baying a elab house for the community the vote was yes. The following members were present: Mrs. Geo. Campbell, Mrs. Al Wood, Mrs. Evans. Mrs. Archie Bailey, Mrs. Al Nys. Mrs. Harding. Mrs. Bingham: Mrs. B. IIP FRAUD SUSPECTED IN HO PRIMARY BROOKS COMNUr CLUB S AAEETIUC r. Ramp, Mrs, P. T. Koala. Mra. Raymond Stanton. Jr- Mrs. Mary Martin. Mrs. Emma Stnrgis, Mrs John Leiher, Mrs. George Ramp, Mrs. Walter Fuller, Mrs. Ralph 8turgia. Miss Ellen Hackstt, Mrs. Malcolm Ssmp. Mrs. Sylvester Manning, Mrs. Howard Booster, Mrs. Alios Barnstt, Mrs. John Dunlang, Mrs. Virgil Loomis, Mrs Carl Ashbaugh. Mrs. Charley Stur- gis. Mrs. WiUard Ramp, Mrs Howard Ramp, and Misses Edna Lewler and Hazel Nys. At the tea hour, Mrs. Archie Bailey and Mrs. Al Nys assisted the hostesses in serving light re freshments. The next meeting will be held on Thursday, May 3. at the home of Mrs. Malcolm Ramp, to which every one is Invited. Mr. and Mrs. Ralph Sturgis had as their guests for the week end their son.-Francis E. Sturgis of U. of O. and Jim Fruit of Salem. Orval Shoey is the guest of his aunt, Mrs. Frank Sturgis, and family. Clarita Fuller, the youngest daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Walter Fuller, met with a very painful accident Wednesday evening, the handle of the tea kettle breaking and the hot water scalding her badly below the knee. Irene Sturgis has been absent from school for some time, but is slowly improving. Death List Mounts in Denver Blast as 2 Die DENVER, COLO.. Apr. 2 (AP) With the death of two of the injured In a Denver hospital, the death list In the explosions and fire today in the paint shop of the Alexander Industries com pany at Englewood mounted to eight tonight. Twelve employes of the . com pany were in hospitals here, many of them It was reported, critically injured. Six other em ployes injured in the fire had been returned to their homes. Motorship Beulah Long Overdue; Said Missing HONOLULU. Apr. 20 (AP) The motorship Beulah. 1389 tons, bound from Tonga Island to Fan ning island has been overdue since April 5. Anxiety over the fate of the vessel caused the owners, the Society Islands company, Ltd., to list the vessel as missing in message received today by Brit ish Consul Phlpps here. FIGHT TO DRAW VANCOUVER. B. C, April 20. (AP) Ritchie King of San Diego and Vic Foley. Vancouver, Junior lightweight, fought a fast ten round draw here tonight in the main event of a boxing card. Bits For Breakfast How big is it S W The Marion county community club talent contest? S It is "big enough so that a rep resentative of the American Ma gazine will be in Salem to see the finals on May 11, and to write up the whole big idea for that maga zine of immense circulation. That will give Salem a wonderful amount of free advertising. And it is big enough so that the district manager for Fanchon & Marco will be In Salem, too, for the finals. He will be here to ab sorb the idea, and perhaps to give the whole thing a once over with the notion of capturing some of the talent of this county. S V Ivan Stewart, who first con ceived the bright idea of the con test, and Dr. P. O. Riley of Hub bard, who caught on and helped put it over, each deserve a medal of honor. They builded wiser than they knew. They put Salem on the map. S The Elslnore theater has some thing new for SaTem, the B. & C Players, stock company, of San Francisco. Here today, and every Saturday hereafter. V S Salem had a distinguished visit or yesterday for an hour, between stages, in the person of Mrs., Lois P. Myers, editorial writer of the Portland Telegram, Her husband, since deceased, was postmaster of Portland.' She likes Salem, and the Salem Idea of boosting and de velopment snd growth the Slo gan idea. Mrs. Myers had been at Corvaills, where she wss enter tained by the Chi Omega frater nity, and where she talked to a group of the students in the clsss of the department of industrial journalism, and to an honor fra ternity of the girl students of Journalism. Mrs. Myers has been doing editorial work on the Tele gram for three years, and has had msny kind words to say about Sa lem and the outstanding things concerning this city. H S m If you sre interested in Salem's growth, you will wsnt to besr the Ulustrsted Angora goat Industry lecture, "Flock to Fabric," on Monday evening at the chamber of commerce. PRISON BREAK DEATHS REPAID AT EXECUTION (Coatinnad from jag 1) bang last Friday, April 13. but due to a telegram from Ksllsys attorney to Governor Patterson who at the time was in MarshfJeld, informing him that five of the su nrm eourt Justices were ready as individuals to Tecommend ItJs Imprisonment, they were granted a third reprieve for one week. Up on his return to Salem he wns in formed by the suprems court Jus- ttrat ther had not made any such recommendations and had no intentions of doing so. In spits of the fact that he was swamped with petition for clem ency, the Governor declared that hs would not interfere, letting the law take Us coarse. SECOND COUNTY CLUBS CONTEST HUGE SUCCESS (Oontiaaed from par D a messing Damons: ana iumu place wa accorded to the Turner hitrh school dee club, a mixed chorus which presented two excel lent numbers under the direction of Mrs. piercy. , These entertainers took tne honors and the cash prizes, and nothing can detract rrom tne credit due them: but if the writer were Judging the event, he would have decided it differently. Reading Excellent Frances Fields of Union Hill presented an unpretentious dii, and it was familiar to at least some of those In the audience, be ing James Whitcomb Riley's "The Bear Story;" but she gave to it such vivacity and captivating per sonality, that it was outstanding among the numbers on the pro gram. Judged even from the standards of professional dramatic reading, it was almost flawless and more than that, it was brll liant. Then Mr. Broms would rank second, and third place would be mighty hard to pick. In addition to the Mill City and Turner chor uses, which deserve consideration, there was the Jefferson entry, the Melodian orchestra, which caused Press Watkins, the regular Elsl nore orchestra leader, some un easiness lest he and his musicians might be supplanted; then there was Harry Keizer of Gates, whose yodeling, despite the burlesqued manner in which he chose to pre vent it. was worth the price of ad mission itself. Other numbers included solos with a Spanish trend, sung by Mrs. H. E. Russell, of Marion, whose high notes were especially good; and the Aumsville pair. Irene Nance and Mathilda Hlghberger, who presented some Italian com edy songs; and Mrs. W. O. Royse of West Stayton.-in a remarkably true to life impersonation. Numbers not in the competi tion, but none the less excellent, where the music by the Hubbard community brass band, and im promptu songs by William McGH chrlst, who played his owjn accom paniments on a tiny but tuneful accordion. The program was in charge of Edgar A. Pierce, banker at Turner and Aumsville, and was sponsored by the local Klwanis club, mem bers of which provided the prizes. ,Word which indicates that this county wide contest is attracting national attention because of its uniqueness and values along the line of community building, was received here yesterday when it was learned that a writer for the American Magazine will be here about the time of the final contest, to prepare an article for that pub lication, and that representatives of Fanchon and Marco, Los An geles producers, will also be on hand to look over Marion county's home entertainers. Judges of last night's contest were J. Lyman Steed of the Rotary club, Adolph Nelson of the Kiwan ians and Henry Crawford of the Lions club. The program was opened with brief talks by Iran Stewart and Charles Archerd. local men who are taking particular Interest in promoting these contests. Next week the community clubs south and east of Salem will pre sent the program, which will be sponsored by the local Rotary club. PK0T0GRAPHER BACK WITH BREMEN STORY (Continued from page 1) erwtse the clothes they wore on their transatlantic flight. Although the island had near ly shed Its winter covering of snow and ice, Fernstrom said that a solid sheet of Ice still connected it to the mainland and stretched out of sight in every direction. On this ice field the Germans have marked the flags the limits of the smoothest landing place. Difficulties Noted Fernstrom was not optimistic about getting the Bremen into po sition for a take off. "There is almost a straight drop of 20 feet from the Island to the Ice," he said. "The great difflcul ty in the way of resuming the flight Is to get the plane down that sharp Incline. Dr. Cuiainier has been directing the building of a ramp of boards for which work scores of nstlves have volunteer ed, but I think it will still be a hszardous Job." The filers read with Interest the newspapers brought them by Fern strom, whickv had long accounts of their flight. They took the op portunity to send out msny, mes sages. Pointing helplessly to the BLANKS THAT ARE LEGAL We carry in stock over 115 legal blanks suited to most any business transactions. We may have just the form you are looking for at a big saving as compared to made to order forms. Some of the forms: Contract of Sale. Road Notice, Will Forms, Assign ment of Mortgage, Mortgage forms, Quit Claim Deeds, Abstract forms. Bill of Sale, Building Contract, Promissory Notes, Installment Notes, General Lease, Power of Attorney, Prune Books and Pads, Scale Re ceipts, etc. These forms are carefully prepared for the courts and private use. Price on forms range from 4 cents to 16 cents apiece, and on note books from 25 to 50 cents. PRINTED AND FOR SALE BY The Statesman Publishing Co. LEGAL BLANK HEADQUARTERS At Business Office, Ground Floor THE MORNING ARGUMENT AUNT HET By Robert Qulllea "I didn't aim to have company for supper, but I throwed a flat iruu ai a simy uug m me DacK yard an' hit our speckled rooster." q-opyrifat. fuuliahera Syndicate. I ; pile of telegrams which had been brought from the station at Blanc Sablon on the mainland, the baron Jsaid of the operator who alone has kept them in contact with the out side world until planes were flown in, "poor fellow, he has done nobly but always there are more." Flight Hazardous Fernstrom stayed only an hour and a half on the island for it was necessary to make a start by day light. His own experiences in the successful air dash to be the first photographer to reach the isolated spot, almost matched those of the Bremen in hazards. Romeo Vachon was the pilot. A snow covered field was selected for one forced landing. Just be fore the plane skimmed the ground the passengers Baw with horror a row of fence posts which had been invisible from the air. Vachon shouted "hold on and raise your feet." There was a crash but the plane stood upright with a broken post beneath it. The underf uselage was ripped and dented but no vital spot was touched. The propeller fortunately had been horizontal at the moment of striking and they were able to continue their flight. At other points they met the ex pected hazards of snow storms and dense fog that made flight impos sible. Receptions Informal During these enforced waits they were the guests of whatever little hamlet they found them selves in. Fernstrom told of one such reception. "We were taken to a large house. All of the men of the vil lage sat about the kitchen with its scoured floors. All smoked pipes, even boys of 12, and at regular in tervals spat into the center of the floor. We talked little. "Later, there was a dance, first four men danced a few measures of some square dance. Then four women took their place. At no time did men and women dance together until the parish priest nodded his approval, when I sought a partner." Fernstrom and his precious film changed planes at Murray Bay, Que., early this morning and left at 6:40 a. m. In a little less than six hours the film wss landed at Curtiss Field, New York, an am phibian plane took it to the Hud son river near the Paramount lab oratories and before Fernstrom reached the city by automobile it was being shown on a screen and "still" pictures were being pre pared for Associated Press. STATE WINNER IN FISH WHEEL COURT APPEAL (Contlnaed from page 1) In the fishing laws and regulations of the two states, as applying to the Columbia river, would be made without mutual consent. BEG 189 N. High & POOR PA By Claade Callaa "My brother Joe's wife is his second au' he's beginning to sell on ine property he accumulated while he w as Ifvin with his first " )', Coprrifht. 1928. PufclUhera Syndicate. Washington had not consented, he declared to the Oregon law prohibiting fish wheels and drag seines. Members of the court said they could see no basis upon which any party except Washington could appeal to the courts to enforce tha compact. Van Winkle Presented Victory Justice VandevtMiter termed th law a conservation measure, but the merits of its provisions never reached the court because of t he injection of the jurisdiction ques tion. When McCord took his seat there was a conference on tlis hLnih. and Chief Justice Taft told I. H. Van Winkle, attorney general for Oregon, that it would not be nec essary for him to make a reply. This was taken to mean that the court will, at an early date, announce dismissal of appeal for want of jurisdiction. Justice Vandeventer was par ticularly searching in his ques tions as to the right of the fishing compact to challenge the validity of the law on the ground that it violated the compact, suggesting that it Eeemed to be strictly In the interest of preserving fish in the river. He wanted to know whether Washington was formally a party to the proceedings, and, when in formed that it was not, suggested that the court seemingly had no jurisdiction to consider the lone complaint of the company. Justice McReynolds shared the same view, and within a few min utes after opening of oral argu ment Chief Justice Taft conferred with his associates on the bench, and indicated that the court took the view that there was presented no controversy over which it had jurisdiction. SINCLAIR'S TRIAL NOW DRAWING TOWARD END (Continued from page 1 ) ing a rich man. Hoover ended hU argument with a plea that Sin clair be given,1 fair treatment even if he is a riflh ran. Such treat ment, the counsel said, would ac quit him. Littleton's plea was the most eloquent of the day and at the outset he brought smiles to tha faces of the jurors frequently wlh the witty barbs he shot at Roberts. He insisted the Roberts ynes tion as to why the long deposition of Fall was not introduced was answered by the government's own testimony. Everhart, he said, tes tifying as a government witness, had told the true story of the bond deal and coming from its own witness it could not be de nied by the government. This te- timony, he argued, must be ac cepted by the jury as the corrert story, as It was put in by the gov ernment which knew what Ever hart would say. VltH wtywef BufWfttrttVtR. HENDRICKS Telephone 161