Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Morning Oregonian. (Portland, Or.) 1861-1937 | View Entire Issue (May 29, 1909)
lO CHIEF CAMPBELL BESTS ACCUSERS Fire Department Head Is Con vincing in Denial of Favoritism. SALESMEN UPHOLD HIM Montag and Swett CIswh Over Ap pointment of Master Meetianic. . Mayor Says Man Was Marketl 100 for Lying Well. Fire Chief Campbell, who has been the center of much criticism by Mayor Lu and members ot the Are- committee of the Executive Board during; recent months, appeared before, a special meeting of the committee yesterday afternoon and en tered a complete and exceptionally con vincing denial of the aspersions cast against him. including the charge that he has favored A. G. I.nK. a local fire apparatus dealer, by drawing specifications to fit the latter's engines. Mr. Long also presented a strong case when he was called upon to state his position, and de clared that, even were it possible for him to have his good favored by the Chief, he would not do so. knowing the Mayor anl members of too committee have demanded oit.e.y oen Kpeftc tior.s on all supplies. Prior to taking up the matter In which Chief Campbell la involved, the com mittee, had under consideration the case of Waiter J. Phillips, hydrantman and acting master mechanic of the depart ment, who was mixed up in charges, brought by Hoge and Swift several months ago. This portion of the meeting was heated, and once there was a posi tive clash between John Montag and Isaac Swett, members of the committee. Mr. Montag favored Phillips for the per manent appointment as mechanic, but Mr. Swett objected, saying Phillips" record Is not sufficiently clear to warrant nla pro motion. Mr. Swett then began to set forth the virtues of B. M. 'WV-nlnger, cer tified with Phillips by the Civil Service Commission as eligible for the position of master mechanic. "Why don't you proceed to make your motion and appoint Mr. Wisslnger, then?" demanded Mr. Montag in heated manner, his face flushing. "You know good and well it's all cut and dried to appoint him why don't you go ahead and do It; don't beat around the bush and take up s lot of time, but go ahead and make your appointment, as you Intended to." "You're badly mistaken." retorted Mr. Bwett, as well as P. B. Sullivan, also a member of the committee. Mayor Lane also assured Mr. Montag he was mis taken. "I stand pat on what I said It's cut and dried to appoint Wlssinger," replied Mr. Montag. "I want to tell you. Mr. Montag. you're very much mistaken." said Mr. Swett. "I have never spoken about "Wtsstna-er o the Mayor or to Mr. Sullivan. You are certainly mistaken." "I should say you are mistaken." said Mr. Sullivan. "I don't know whom to name for the place. I cannot accept the certification of the Civil Service Commis sion, as it haa been- demonstrated that the tests given guarantee nothing; ft is not cut and dried at all." CalU Self Stumbling Block. Mr. Swett then moved that Wlssinger be appointed, but there was no second to the motion, and Mayor Lane remarked: "It does not look like it Is very much cut and dried." Mr. Montag then advised the other members of the committee to wait until next week, aaylng he will then be on his way to Europe, where he is going for an extended trip. He sarcas tically remarked "you will then be rid of the stumbling block." Messrs. Swett and Sullivan. In explaining why they would not stand for the ap pointment of Phillips, said that h 3 "Is not the proper man for the place, as his rec ord Is not clear." This angered Mr. Montag. who declared that "Phillips Is the best machinist and mechanic n Ore gon, and you will see the day when you will realize that you have lost the best man In the state for the position." Mayor Lane said, as official head o the .ty government, he would not approve Phil lips as master mechanic, as he regards Phillips as unfit for the responsibility attaching to the position, and alio has suspected Phillips of duplicity In connec tion with hydrant tests. Cnlcf Campbell recommended Phillips very highly, de claring him to be a good man for the place -and well qualified to perform the high-grade labor required of one in that place. It being Impossible for the committee to agree upon a man for the place, noth ing definite was done. Mayor Lane and Messrs. Swett and Sullivan sarcastically scored the tests, so-called, given by the Civil Service .Commission. as "utterly wanting in anything necessary to guide the committee In making an appoint ment." . The "tests" consisted of running, jumping and leaping, it was shown, al though the position now open is a me cnanlcal one of the highest order, the efficiency of the entire fire department service depending very much upon the skill and ability of the master mechanic. One applicant was given 100 and is certi fied as eligible for the position, although it has been proven, it Is said, he fabri cated as to his previous experience. "The Commission certifies us one man. who lied about his experience." said Mayor Lane. "The Commission gave him 100 perfect: I suppose this was given for the lie he told." The meeting was Interrupted at this point, as it was time for the Executive Board to meet, but the committee re sumed its session an hour later, and will meet again at 2 o'clock this afternoon to finish the Inquiry and to make up a re port. Chief Waa Laconic. Chief Campbell did not talk long, mere ly . answering a few questions -put by Mayor I-ane. touching the alleged favor itism. The chief was armed wltn a copy ot the specifications, which, he showed, were open to the whole world. Having been made aware of the fact that there had been some complaint, ha said, he not only made the specifications open to all. but added a paragraph wherehy any bid der could come In with any make or kind of fire engine without any specifications by the city. "1 certainly had no Intention of mak ing any prohibitory specifications de clared Chief Campbell. "And to make certain that they were open to all. I add ed a clause, so that the manufacturers could bid on any kind of an engine, aside from the regular specifications. There was nothing to shut out anyone." A. G. Long, who Li deeply Interested because he is the lowest bidder on the contracts for the two third-sis engines, which the Mayor has so far failed to sign, declared also that the specifica tions are absolutely open. lie said he would not attempt to have the specifica tions otherwise, even If he could, owing to the attitude of the Executive Board. mmriBM he regards himself as too good a WILL LEAD THE CHANTIES AT i: - t. - . . T -- 1 T s Jpl. '. ., .- .,y - v N- -1 -jjt- . : : 4 r i ' . J . ' y ' ' i - - i .--if1 HARRY BINGES OK TDK SHIP J, .tLVIX. The sailors of the port are taking great !- -t In the concert for the benefit ot the Seamen's Friend r-M-l-ty V C e Armory tonight. Harry Bunges. sallmaker of the ship Glenal v(.t, ,,,-Jr I lead the chanties the singing of 'which win be one of the unique :v;vti ot the concert. A business man to do anything like that. He assured the Mayor and members of the committee that his firm l not favored by Chief Campbell, and that th.-re la nothing upon which to base the charsea that have been made by his competitors. In course of his testimony Mr. 1oti( called attention to the fact that In April. blda were Invited to furnish the city with four fire engines. Every fire engine manufacturer In the I nltrd S'.ates offered bids, thus shewing that specifications ad mitted all bfcldcrs. The specifications then were the same precisely as now, except that for this year thero has b.-en added a further specific clause providing that the bids shall be open to all for any type of Ore engine. SHOE MEN WOULD CLOSE Leading Firms Mgn Petition to Ob serve Iecoratlon lay Monday. In an endeavor to make the closing of stores next Monday universal, a petition haa been circulated among the leading firms dealing In shoes, asking that atten tion be paid to the observance of the day. The pledge signed and the names of the signers follow: "We. the following merchants, agree to close all day Monday. May 31. as Monday U a legal holiday, and ail banks, state and county of nee. will be closed on that day. Knight Shoe Company. Ergert Young Company. Crawford tfhoe Com pany, Stalger Shoe Company. Reeves Shoe Company. Goddard & Kelly Company, Phillips Shoe Company. W. J. KMIlara. 1 : ILI. PARTICIPATE IX DF.DI CATIOX OP ( III K II OP THE XAIAREE. i! i i 31 P. Breeee. Oeaeral Snt tea dealt Rev. P. P. Bresee. of Los An geles, general superintendent of the Church of the Naxarene. ar rived in Portland yesterday morning. He will have charge of the services In the First Church. Kast Seventh and East Couch streets, at 11 A. M.. and 7:30 P. M. today. In the morning there will be baptismal service. At 3 o'clock there will be dedication of the new church on East Sev enth and East Couch streets. Rosenthal A Co., Regal Shoe Company. "Korrect Shape" Shoe Store. Leo Selling Goodyear Shoe Company. John Uellar.". CUPID ALLAYS DARK PLOT Man and Woman. to Wed After Hurl ing I'gly Charges. ArKXF- W""Mr !. Special.) After having been sued hy Miss Elis abeth J. Hurn. for SlO.ftno for breach of promts., this after having a--tis-d her of staying In 1-ortUnd and Colfax as the wlf. of Harry Draper. Thomas Jefferson Cofrman has decided tn call bygones bygones and get married, and his bride Is the woman -whom he pub licly accused of scandalous conduct. Miss Bums, whose home Is at Halley Idaho, sued Co-man for breach of promise some months ago. Coffman filed an answer and croas-cnmplalnu accusing Miss Burns and Harry traper of Improper conduct and of pretend ing to he husband and wife. Hoth ve hementlv denied the accusation. The tlOOOe breach of promise suit was settled out of court and the cul mination of the affair la the issuing of the marriage license to Mr. Cofrman and Miss Burns. Coffman. Miss Burns alleged In her suit, waa engaged to be married to another woman. r . J nissswars mi in" in i i " J r-. AT ..... . Rrr. P X X ttit: moicstim. ABAIORT CONCERT TONIGHT. v ! IN MEW HOME SOON Y. M. C. A. Headquarters to Be Moved About August 1. CONTRACTORS PROMISE ITJ CUwt-Ilooma WIH lie Ilrady for Oc cupancy In September Itellgloas Work Iepartment I'rogrec. Many Oailng-a Planned. The board of directors of the T. M C. A. haa decided to move the headquarters to tl.e new buUd-.g at Sixth and Taylor s:ret about August L While the brlrg work at present extends only to the mo ond story, the contractors and archi tect have assured members of the board that the change can be made at that time. The swimming pool, baths, small gymnasium and handball court win also be ready for use. The educational class, rooms will be occupied when the term opns In September. The Spring term of the educational de. partment closes Tuesday. June L No classes will be conducted during the Summer. R. C. French, president of the Weston State Norma School, will be come director of the educational depart ment, and will fake charge about July 1. Several new courses are to be added! Many Inquiries have been received re garding the educational work to be under taken during the coming term. Religious Work Progresses. Progress la also being made In the re ligious work department, under the direc tion of R. R Perkins, who until reo-ntly was In charge of the same work In the ioieao. Ohio. T. M. C. A. Mr. Perkins. " inaunumei a correspondence lilhle study course which promises to he hlchly successful. Mr. Perkins Is armnalng for a special meeting to be held durlnc the sessions of the Northern Raptlst conven tion, when several of the prominent dele gates to that meeting will be Invited to deliver addresses. Among those aha will participate In this service will be Dr. Clarence Barbour, formerly pastor of a Bnptlst church In Rochester. N. V., and late a member of the International com mittee of the Y. M. :. A.: John Sleaman. of the Layman's Mlsslnnsry Movement, and President Hunt, of Denlson Cnlver slty. of Grandvsile. O. These will speak on the general subject. "Keltglous Work for Men in a Large City." Outings Are Arranged. Arrangements have been made by the director of the boys' department for a series of outings during the Summer. On June 2 members of this department will take their annual walking trip. Ta coma. haa ben selected as the objective point for this season. The party mm leave here on the above date for Kelso, Wash.. In the association' launch. From there they mill walk to Tacoma. and dur ing their sojourn will visit the Seattle Fair. The party Is expected ta reach Portland on the return trip July la A second walking trip will he made from Tillamook August 3 to Seattle. The trip to Astoria will he made In the associa tion launch. Weekly outings will be given to Ross Island during the vacation season. J. V. Guthrie. In charge of the em ployment bureau, reports more than ) applications for positions have been re ceived during the month, and permanent places have been found for more than U of them. An equal number of temporary positions hare been filled. Secretary H. w. Stone. TV. C. Moore and C. X. Wonacott are attending the Y. M. C. A. employee- conference now in session In Omaha. Neb. COMPLAIN OF NOISY BOYS Resident Near Tenth and Yamhill Aroused by Depredations. The Dark Deep Mystery Club, cvnpoeed of boys, who smtke clsarettes, dm h4 lana-uax and are devotees of lurid liter ature, is mk:r.g ntrht hideous for peo. pie who resirte tn the vicinity of the old Multnomah Athletic club building. Tenth and Yamhill streets. The hoys meet in the basement of t.ie buil-llng. a here they hold hih carnival, occasionally sending forth expeditions to forage on trie rose gardena and lawns of surrounding homes. Complaint has been made to the p'!'' and unless the youtns desist there wtil probably be trouble for them. . . ' v- : f okkcoma:. .Tnti. GIRL WHO ELOPED DESERTS M'GREERY Her Faith in Accused Bigamist Broken When She Learns He Is Drug Fiend. LEAVES TO MEET FATHER Itedlands Irng Clerk. Who Is Sal to Have Two Wltea. Changes Ills .Mlml and Will right Against K xt rail I Hon. ,h" or1, rllmas of a thrilling ro mance In leaving a luxuriou.iy.aprMlnlM home at Redlands. t el.. to elor- to Port, land with a pennll-aa drug cl-rk Miss Mary Alice White boarded a futh-rn a. clflc train Ut nlsht on her war bark tn the abetter of the paternal rf. And went In a torment of unrertamtly as to whether she Is Ml White or Mrs. Utor A. Mnw,. w.f. of uim man In the case, for while there mas a reremo. ry several w-ek mt r1wfod CT al.. the California aulhortiirs now aay ,hrr.'IT I" ot evidence upptll by tha girls tanner, that the rtomeo of the romance has a ir . n f 111 r,:,,arrn nuur for themmrlvtm -e I T I Vasadena. C. J ) Maintaining Implicit confidence In hef f e urtK-l hutlmntt mt tlt lime nf him ar- I rrt by the Portland po'.ice Thursdav her ar "un woman experienced a radical chaoge of heart early Ul h!M when she was shown cocaine found hy the detectives In lrt'nvrr .ulica-e. it wma la a form eonventenl for use by a slave ot the onil. Couple with the fact of the fellow's sallow complexion sM hta erratic moods there nttw doubt about bka being a devotee of the druac. Yields to lather's Plea. Halt Bn hour after this dseorny Miss While or. m may poasiMy prove to be the case. Mrs. MeCreery. made up her mind to go home. The hv k of such a discovery undermined her confidence la the man and she yielded to the persist ent plead Hiss of her wealthy father t return home. Kfte left planning to meet htm at Oakland. There waa a final Interview between the elopers at Hie man's cell in ll.e City Jail last night. Their meeting found Mc Creery m a hopeful mood and he has tened to the bars to kfcea her. She as sented wtth a considerable lack of warmth and proceeded to rross x amine McOeery in no endearing aay. Her eus pldons were all too plain to him. There was no farewell salute. After she left Mcteery suddenly made up his mind to Slant extradition. The young woman. decidedly attractive, not past y. properly reared and used to luxury, had Intended playing the I. til romance out to the end. . has a mind of her own and believing that someone was trying lo make trouble for McOreery she didn't Intend to turn from him at the first sign of trouble. Hut when she learned that he carried cocaine about with him that waa the turning point. If the man she Idolised ae a cocaine fiend and she had never learned then he might have a neglected lfe and two 111 lie children. "It's all wrong and It m III all come out right." the man In the cap kept telllr.g her. "I hope so." waa her on a response. -Wife Mtowa Her Trouble. The parting Interview occurred In Me Creery's cell on the second floor of the City Jail. Station Officer Oram took her up to the relL She had Just learned about the cocaine. As the bolts were slipped sod MeOeery saw the pretty young woman he vowrs la his only wife, he Jumped up. cast aside a magaame and catching her through the bars, kissed her. "How about the cocaine T' she de manded anxiously. McCreery stepped bsck from the bars as If he'd been struck. Although he Is most fluent and self-assured It waa some moments before he rvgatmd auiythlr.g resembling composure. He began a rambling conversation about being a drug clerk and carrying all sorts of things. When he was through she made no com ment but larr distrust as as unmis takable aa words. I think I'll go back to California," she next announced. "Well, alright." said McCreery con fusedly. Then aa an afterthought he added. "You can wait for me there as I'm going back with the IMierlff." "Father .will meet tne triers." she said rather Icily. Sends Her for Cigar. "I wish you'd bring me up something To smoke," he plead-nl. "The officer says I can smoke, but I have only a dime left. Will you get me something?" She said she would, and returned later with a handful of stogies. Then she left the Jail, saying she must hurry to catch her train. "This whole thing would be a Joke." said McCreery afterwards, "except for the Inconvenience to that dear little glrL I married her In itood faith. I love her. She loves me. She Is the only wife I have, or that I ever have bud. "Of course. he added, with a hlshly expressive Jerk of the head, "there have been other women. I've paid bills for a score of them. It's one of that kind that's making all this trouble. You know that 'hell hath no fury.' and all t.iat sort of thing. So there you hsve It. I was a young man once. My past la 'rUIr up to smite me,' so to spesk. "I'll explain the whole thing away when I go back. I'll not Bxht extradi tion one minute. Know no re I tn u I married thla girl for love and love alone. Her father Is worth somewhere around t-o "O. so they say at li-dlanda. and they have everything in the world. Hut that hadn't' anything to do with the match. It was a love matc?i-the only ray of sunshine I've ever bad in try life. "No. I don't know Just who tins other woman Is that claims to be my first wire. There are several women. Several. In fact, have passed aa mv wile, at vari ous times. But I waa neret married to any of them, so the law can now do nothing. I mill show my c n tempt for the charges by .oing buct t fa .- the charges." In view of eh'rh stat.-m-nt it la some, what remarks lie that M.- reery an nounced half an hour later tiiat he In tended fighting extradition. TWO HUNDRED ELKS TO GO Portland Ixstlge Mill Send Urre terlegalion to lares Angclea. Portland I-!e of Kika mriil make a fine shoeing at the coming meeting of the tarand lywlar at jrm AnXetee. After the resular meeting of the M( Thjre dsy nixM. the grand toV committee and mercbera Interested In having a g-od turnout held an Informal aeseloti and die ruseed the aner.srmer.la. It developed r, may vt, that memSere had ir.l p. Ku t tt as tSa oe'nteaa of a rwnmttlea that at - .ka from IVu-tl.rd ar.4 vtr'nliy weak! go oat the pe. i.l train, a t In 1. f oa-ra. The uniform adopted la a siMte fanr.e suit. tse coat a tars-Kllos douhie-tr-easted se-a. Imaera and a an aah-te telt Kal. n the hattd of ahl-li a r.l N " w.ta Porllaad. 1 1W m til j. teeing; trtmtt-.lrta-s ta purr-. Tl-e Msyor ot I-o. Aaselee haa sent a " te tr-e ally -or--! rroH n f e cuttlrg Xsllonal fne-tirg In the fol ios Irs : Is Keeer ef the laaar iawaa ef iaa. ee Is .f rli t ( t Oe t- - -"" ef tlS . a - I eeat-a tf.. , reeeaa fn4 ir-el '.a heaters, s"4 . .ia ana aoe la r i a i if.a t , . . . Sn4 H'fM ee ffMat J.lr l "at the cittaeea la awoarai aaarta . a4 Set ' - a eresi hoi:aa) At the conference Thursday ti'.tht It waa decided to make another active ran. Vaes 'f the munleianj so sa to trm( up the r presentation te aa htgn a flsure as rea!lie. toe rairtaea beln( not only lo have Portland lwlce make a credits, hie holn. hut to have the State of tirecon advertte-d among l'l!ng breth. ren from all psrta of the nmntrr. committee, eonsisllng of John H. Coffey, rhalnran. Judge K l Morrow, ,,r- A. L. Ilerkley. John 1. Jenn'tiyta and ! 11 ard Krjrll. has In hand araanate. roenta for a prot.r obeervance of Mag Iay. June 14. Flsg lay h an annual oheervanc held by every lodge tn ISe country in commemoration el the "Mrth of the "e." and Ihe oiamanie ass niade otl!(atnry at t.e forty. Ihle.1 annual seeaion of the erand lode. held at phu. ad.lnhu m t - a . i . . . . ... a laaiiv inienos I to hold the exercises In Its lodrercen I In the eVer.lffte keeloelee e S .'.I. -A. ... ahlle Ihe procramme haa not been com. pleted. It u reported that It a HI constat ef patriotic music by an orchestra and vocal selection, an address by a sneaker, not yet selected, and the prase rl bed rit ual adopted by the grand lodge. The rooms of the local loalge. both rlua and hall, are being freshly raJrlmlned and painted, the decorations renewed and a seneral houaacleantr.g doate, ta have the room In good order for the reception ef I hyndrr! of Imftnrm mho are to nut . rw after eorcVwor, of v gtarel lo.le eesalnns In lxs Angelea. c-wre-tmrr Blllm im In relx of copio of It In eratiea from various RVa' exrurstoret la the West, nearly all ol which Induda at least one dae In port land Why Does It Cure Net boCalUM It la tinaunlls. but becsuis it Is m moorclrMa of pescullar marlt, compotetl of moral than twonty cJlffcront ramascllal ganta affaotlrtB prtaeiomanal curaa et troubeaa of trva telood. lomach, Ihear and bowels. Thug Hood'a 8rsparU'i etirea arro. dU, erxema, anemia, catarrh, twrroos. tseaa, that tired (eelinc, dyspepsia, loat) olappecite, aoj bikl op th s Vetera. ee wear aa aae eaaal Keaet faesa a SB Something That Will Interest You ''Coming events cast their shadows before them. The -laska Ex pedition and the" North Bank" Railroad will draw the East nearer to the North Pacific Coast Tha Barliorton, Northern Pa riTic and Orent Kortbera road hara felt tb atimalatiag mo lion of thia advance, and hara arrterurrd, fffeetire May 23, for all kinds of new and elaborat through train service, both via St- Paol aad Billing, Montana, betwtstn Chicajro, St. Loaia, Kansaa City, Omaha, Denver, tha Lakes and tha Mississippi Valley on the east, and Paget . Sound and Portland. When planning- an Eastern trip, look at tha map, and nota tha choice of attractive routes thia new throurh aerrira offer. Doea not continuity of servica to these important Eastern eitiaa moan a great deal to Too T Con sult any agent of the Burling ton, Northern Pacific or Great Northern roads in the North, weat. or the undersigned. - c nnnos Oaaal - j sty, sa Takes aac. HENS 19c LB. Chinook Salmon, lb j , . Halibut. S lba. for ...". 8had. each joj iarfe Crabe 10 and IT.! Kaior Clama dot en 10 8KAMOKAWA BUTTER, roli!!in- sw a-csa, aoten 115 coldmblTfish CO. "V Ire eed aaeey aal HaatlaaM I-aklle Hark.l, " aa Ua.tlann Sareana. Mala a a Ifi-'iir ATHLETES TO KEEP IN GOOD TRIM ITCST LOOK WELL TO T7IS CONDITION OF THE 6KTX. TO THIS END THE BATH BIIOULD BS TAKEN WITH MAINE) SAPOLIO A3 OTwCaara a THXXX"- EASTERN EXCORSION RATES VIA Great Northern Railway JUNE 2-3 JULY CHICAGO inl Return . . . $7-te50 ST. LOUIS and Return . . 567.50 ST. PAUL. MINNEAPOLIS. Projaortionale rsles ,.her points. !xl for return xasce t.niil (Wbrr 3IU Mover a:io-d. C"hica of rxuies pins either xta SEATTLE or ia SPOKANE, PORTLAND xVND SEATTLE RY. "THE NORTH DANK ROAD" Makir- riirect eonneelions xia either route with THE ORIENT Ala LIMITED r THE TAST MAIL. Choice of routes rrturninf. New through service to Kansas Cily. rw ,hr,,ush sen ice. Portland lo Vancouver. H. 10 A. M. to 10 P. M. Kor tickets and aJeepii.g-ear resenations ra:i on or adorer H. DICKSON, Giy raenCcr and Ticket Agent. TtWt EinfcS0-A2rSfi 122 Third St, Portland, Or. mmmm a A f jS If the Box Isn't Green It Isn't a PUCK. X Five cents worth of cigar. A frd smoke a free tmolce a smooth, vvcll-blcndcd, taty cigar made in two imrxrted aha pes witi a long well- blended feUer and a thoroughly seasoned binder wrapped in a genuine Sumatra leaf. iere is very V little profit on each cigar, but m&adrtg; l l . FUCK A-BETTER.TIIAN-S-CENT-CIGAR y-v with, the Havana taste j f ) will bring; us out all right in the end V ' . 2 Sharxs 1 tortar-a r MASON, EH R MAN & CO., DISTRIBUTORS. 1'orttaod, taeattle. bpoksaa. The ideal food for BDSEDDED I I Crisp, delicious shreds of baked wheat Try it for breakfast with milk or cream. 2-3 AUG. 1 1-12 NEW YORK nj Return . JI0S.30 I BOSTON asd Ruarn . . 5110-50 DULUTH nl Return. 560.00 1 I school or workshop is I I I I J