Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Roseburg news-review. (Roseburg, Or.) 1920-1948 | View Entire Issue (March 2, 1925)
i ALLTHEKEWSTC2AY WEATHER mm Y Highest Yesterday Lowest Last Night. ASSOCIATED LEASED WIRE SERVICE Partly cloudy and cooler to night, Tuesday cloudy. DOUGLAS COU NTY Consolidation at The Evening News and Th Roseburg Review. An Independent Newspspsr, Published far tho Beet lirts rests of the People. 'JRQ REVIEW ROSEBURG NEWS-REVIEW MONDAY, MARCH 2, 1925. VOL, XIL NO. 299 OF THE EVENING NEWS 1'-f-iLi'.:- JJ, VOL. XXVII. NO. 88 JUDGE WOLVEr TITLES TO TR BAY WAGON Another Chapter Added to Long Legal Battle to Secure Possession of Land Decision Throws Out Claims of Homestead Entrymen. (Aaorlared Prea Uucd Wb.) I After this other suits began, so PORTLAND, Ore., Mar. 2. An- the old military road company of other chapter In the legal battle fered to compromise with the gov to secure possession of lands I eminent. This negotiation took granted the Coos Bay Wagon Road company transpired today when Judge Wolverton ruled that tax ti tles to tracts In this grant held by A. J. Mays, of Marshtield, are good. This throws out the homestead claims of two entrymen, 8. 1 Leatherman and Otto E. Parry of Coos county. The case Is expect ed to be appealed. The decision comes within a day of the fifty sixth anniversary of giving a tract of more than 200, 000 acres of valuable land In south ern Oregon to the company build ing a military wagon road from Roseburg to Coos bay. The grant was made March 3, 1869. There were three provisions made by the government that the land should be sold only to bona fide settlers, that the lands In this grant should be sold in tracts not larger than 160 acres each, and that the price to these settlers should be $2.50 an acre. Having secured the grant, tho wagon road company is Alleged to have paid no heed to government conditions. Suits and counter suits filed against this company would fill a large library if the pa per were collected In book form. The most famous of these many cases was brought by the federal government In the United States district court here In 1915. when suit filed to forfeit the grant for alleged violations of conditions. Judge Wolverton decided that the company had hold possosslon of the grant but at the Same time Issued an Injunction forblding It to sell any more land until congress could legislate concerning the dis position of the grant. Judge Wolvertons decision was given July 12, 1915. EUGENE TO DEBATED The debate championship of the Southern Willamette District will be decided Tuesday evening when the teams of Eugene and Roseburg high schools meet tomorrow even ing. The Eugene affirmative team will meet the local negative team, composed of Eldress Judd and Paul Geddes, In the high school auditor-' Day today reported that the lum at 7:30. The local affirmative! earth shocks were being felt team, composed of Edith Starrett I In the Saguenay river dis and Norman Hess will debate the 1 trlct, the latest tremor oc- Eugene negative team at Eugene. The question to be discussed Is, Re solved, That the Japanese should be admitted to the U. S. under the quota terms of the general immi gration laws, A lively discussion of this ques tion Is anticipated. Eugene has de feated the representatives of Co berg and the University high school. Roseburg's teams have sue- cessfully mot the teams from Cam-1 shaken down In the Murray as Valley, Riddle an dWalker high' "y district, Harvey said. schools. ' The people of Rosebufg are urged ; to hear this debate tomorrow night as It means much to the success o(:ee44eeeeete the debate. 0 4 CAN SEARCH CARS MRS. SARVER i dies Sunday!; sTl-1 . ! Prohibition law enforcement Sirs. George Sarver passed away, ,gen lawfully ,top ,nd , at her home on Winchester street, . ,arcn ,n ,ufo w,hout wap. Sunday night at about 8 o'clock, at . ram. tno ,upreme court de- the age of 42 years. Mrs. Sarver rdd toda, , . ,, from . was born In London, England, May Michigan ?i;18Siund m,Ved to, cntd " The decision, which upheld 1910. She was Jesse Lee before ,ne of tn low, h-r marriage to George Server at , WM on , apal brought by foP,o w"hington. April lO.'ooeorge Clrro and John 1919. The couple moved to South- Klro. and then came to Roseburg to lo cate. Mrs. Sarver has been a resi dent here for the past number of years, and leaves many friends and neighbors to grieve at her death. She leaves no surviving relatives In the United Slates side her husband. Her father sur-1 vlves In England. Funeral serv-1 I. h.lH T. i " - "'" ' """"!. ;ilvineJorA:i!he sarz dertaklng Chapel. Rev. Caldwell of the Baptist church will officiate and Interment will be held at the Odd Fellows cemetery. TO STUDY MUSCLE SHOALS Anr(tHl rreH lmm4 Wire.) WASHINGTON. Mar. J By an overwhelming vote the house to day adopted a resolution declaring Its "sense" that President Coolldge should sppolnt a commission to study the Muscle Shoals problem. i'ilESTAX 9 AG I j many months, and in the mean time, the land, said to have been subject to local and state taxes was neglected by the company. During this period, A. J. Mays took tax title to a number of tracts In the grant. The compromise effected was that the government would buy back the land from the company for $2.50. Congress then legislat ed to throw the tract open to set tlers, giving preference to ex-sr-vlce men. It was in 1919 that the government paid the company $232,463.07 for what remained of the grant. The new homestead legislation for the settlement of this Oregon district was passed. July 11, 1923, Parry, a world war veteran, and Leatherman. also said to be a veteran took up home steads in the old grant and under provisions of the new law. but Mays at once sent up claims to ownership of the tracts home steided and demanded that he be paid his price for the land. The government brought suit to oust Mays, but some months ago Judge Wolverton decided that Mays tox title were good. Then tho two entrymen brought suit against Mays. demanding that they be permitted to get the patents to their homesteads from the government direct. The set tlers have built dwellings on the land and have cleared part ftf it. The government suit against Maya Is now pending In the feder al court of appeals, and the case decided this morning will like wise be appealed. If the two set tlers lose In the San Franslco trib unal, they expect to carry the fight to the I'nlted States supreme court. QTAKES IX Ql'ERKC. fAOTcUttd Frea Lcsstd Win.) QUEBEC, March 2. Three persons dead, scores of homes damaged by tremor and fire. one church collapsed and 4 general consternation among residents of the St. Lawrence and Saguenay valleys are the known result of the earth- quokes of last Saturday night and Sunday morning. QUEBEC. March 2. Agent Harvey of the Dominion Ex- press company at Murray furring at eight o'clock this morning. Seismic experts considered this a proof that the Saguenay river was the center of the disturbance. Tremors were felt all day Saturday and throughout yes- terday and last night con- tinning today. Harvey re- ported by telephone to Que- bee. Several rhlmnevs were FIVE ARE DROWNED fAMnHatrd Pre Lttlrd Wir BOSTON. Mar. J Tantaln GRANT VALID be-iMosher of Providence. R. I., his 18 vear old daurhter. a crew of 1 men wer. lost when the rnal harm t . - ' . " .. . ..7 ." jsmea m. tiuason. rtonojg, lor - i late last night. The bodies of two of the crew were recovered. Mrs. MeMn Ellison resumed her duties st the offices of Dr. B. R. Shoemaker this morning, after be ing absent for several days last week with tonsllltla. . . " . t. Archie Rruerker. formerly of this rl'v. returned to Dunsmutr. Csllfor- nla, this morning, after spending for the movement of men, animals her." I asked him sow. and he said i former Inmate of the once notnr several days here visiting with bis , and material. Competition among 'I looked It np: I investigated." lous 'Everlelgh Club" and other parents and friends. army shippers will be eliminated." I then he said she was the niece of I resorts of unsavory name. I PHJOHH Jl IN CONGRESS IS STARTED TODAY WifeHINGTON. March I. The pre-adjournment Jam In congress has Bwung to Its crest today aa the session entered Its last 48 hours. As usual, the principal crush e was In the senate, and as 4 soon as that body convened. members were on their feet all over the chamber seek- lng unanimous consent for consideration of pet meas- e tures. Objections were lm- mediate and vociferous. So much disorder resulted that Senator Walsh, demo- crat, Massachusetts, asked that the sergeant-at-arms 'be brought into the chamber and kept here until Wednes- day noon to maintain or- der." President Cummins stopped 1 proceedings until e 4 semblance of decorum had been restored. 11 OFFICIALS LEADERS MEET Will Work Out Plans for National Defense to Co ordinate Endeavors. RAILWAYS NEEDED Secretary Weeks Empha sizes Need of Trans portation Facilities During War. (Aasoclated Pre U-utd Wire.) WASHINGTON. March 2.-"Rail transportation officials and busi ness leaders met with war depart ment officers here today to work out plans for national defense by which war time endeavors of business, transportation and gov ernment may be co-ordinated In a workable unit. The gathering was addressed by Secretary Weeks and Major Oeneral John L. Hines, chief of staff, who outlined the defense plans tentatively mapped otlt by the department and the part as signed to transportation and busi ness agencies. Secretary Weeks emphasised the vital need of transportation to the national defense and ex plained that armed force depend ed for its effectiveness upon I "If mtr armfift fnrrM ahonM h. compelled at some future date to defend the continental territory of the United States, the railways of the United States would assume prime Importance." the secretary said. "You know as well as I, thst It will not be possible for the railroads and army to co-operate effectively immediately upon the occurrence of an unfortunate emergency unless they spend some time together preparing and developing plans for such co-operation. That is why we have ask ed vou to be here. General Hines described more In detail what services to nation al defense and army expected the transportation lines to render In sn emergency and pointed out something of how they would be expected to function. "Our field service regulations." General Hines said, "now defin itely assign the operation and) maintenance of railroads In. the theatre of operations nnder the control of the commander In chief to the rallwav engineer troops. On the other hand it is prnnosed that the actual operation of the railroads In the xone of the In terior shall be In charge' of the railroads themselves under snch a plan for unified control as shall be arreed upon by the railroads ..j ,i. . "" suwrnmrai. How the railroads In the vatia m fh in. .ho,d,hh.,op:r.0,Vh,ona fentlemen will hsvo to determine In study of ynur side of the plsn. "We Intend that In time of emergency all requisitions on the railroads In the zone of the In terior shall emanate from a single nnlt of nnr orranlrstlnn, rsmelv tt frsnnnrtsMnn corns. The of- ''''Is" of thst body will be vested with sole authority to call for ninn.n, a j AND Business BATTLE FLEET 1 MANEUVER FDD 2 MONTHS .Greatest Game of Naval Strategy Ever Staged Is Started by Fleet WILL USE 200 SHIPS "Black Fleet" Wil Attempt an Invasion of Pacific Coast Using Navy's Major Power. (AancUtH Prrej Uicd Wire.) - NAVAL BASE. San Pedro, Cal.. Mar. 2. The United States battle fleet today weighed anchor and slipped out In the Pacific In the role of an enemy invader. Its Identity now Is the "Black Fleet". Decks are cleared for action. baf tie orders are In the hands of all units, radfos are silenced and the ships and crews are ready for one of the the greatest peace time maneuvers In American history. The California, flagship of Ad miral Samuel S. Robinson, was In the van of the nine steel dread naughts that moved majestically out- of the harbor In alignment as perfect as If they were tied togeth er by cables. The West Virginia, Colorado, Maryland, Idaho Mis sissippi. Arizona, Oakland and Ne vada followed. Thirty destroyers under the leadership of their flagship, the cruiser Omaha, were under steam at San Diego to join the battle ships at the mobilization point off coronaao Islands.. The alrrraftil tenders Langley, Aroostook and Gannett, the former housing 14 air planes for use In the maneuvers likewise were 'under steam at the southern point. The marine force of the "Black fleet" included tho flagship Uroc yon, the repair ship Medusa, the oilers Cuayama and Canawaha, the hospital ship Relief and the mine sweepers Brant, Kingfisher, Part ridge and Tern. This force embarks upon a mis sion to attack the Pacific fleet at a point off lower California, which will be defended by the . "Blue fleet." It left the Panama canal several days ago. Its main line force is composed of eight new first line cruisers, the Richmond, Milwaukee, Cincinnati, Trenton. Marblehead, Detroit, Raleigh and Concord, the latter, being flagship of the destroyer squadrons. There are 24 destroyers and a destroyer tender, the Dobbin. Twelve submarines of the 'S" class are Included, with three sub marine tenders the Savannah, Camden andBushnell. And there is a mine squadron, three mine layers and four mine sweepers. (AaurUtrd ITm Lutd Wire.) NAVAI BASE, SAN PEDRO, Cal., March 2. Fifty-two vessels of the battle fleet today moved to a mobilization point off the Coronado Islands from whenre will start one of the greatest games of naval strategy ever stag ed In the Pacific ocean, as the first step In a series of spectacu lar fleet maneuvers extending two months. More than a hundred fighting ships will participate. Under the ten day maneuver problem the great naval force has- ea nere as tne strong srm of the United States In the t'acinc (Continued on page .' Stokes Told Mother-in-Law He Knew AH About Helen Before He Married Her; Made Investigation (Aaneistnt Preaj Lnard Wire.) CHICAGO, Mar. 2 That W. E. D. Stokes, New York millionaire. told his mother-in-law that he "knew all about" Mrs. Helen Ell wood Stokes before marrying her. was testified today by the mothi-r- In Isw, Mrs. Emma Ellwood Miller of Denver. Stokes and three oth- Jond time Identified Meyer has the ers are charged with conspiring to man In a photograph of her daugh detume Mrs. Stokes, his estranged ter, Helen, perched on a man's wife, by procuring scandalous 1 shoulders. The defense said they Statements ahnilt h MrlU. lift. had nn nt-evlnna nnHr-a that tavt-r ueiense nave contenueu tnattwouia oe a witness. 'i nia me r. Btnses merely investigated in state aeniea Dut tne judge ruiea good faith suspicions for which he that Meyer might not testify to had grounds: the stste contend day, though perhaps' be might lat- tnat knowledge of Mrs. Stokes earlier life was In Mr. Stokes' pos- session snd he therefore knew the scsndslous statements were false. "I asked Mr. Htokes Jokingly." said Mrs. Miller, "after his nsr- rlage to my daughter without my knowledge why he married her af- ter such a short acquaintance. He replied 'I knew all about riERCR SIGNS TAX LAW OX TOBACCO. Areorlatnl Pm bud Win.) SALEM, Ore.. March 2 Oregon's tobacco tax law, w passed during the closing hours of the legislative ses- sion and signed by the gov- ernor yesterday, will become operative May 27 or 28, ac- cording to unofficial calcula- Hons made here today. It goes into effect 90 days after adjournment of the !e- glslature. and the Attorney. General will be asked to de- finitely determine the date. Among bills signed by Gov- ernor Pierce are: 8. B. 274. by game com- e mlHafnti nrnvMlnv fn. n,n. A t eel Ion of bear in Crater Lake park. 4 H. 1). 238 by game com- mission relating to protoc- 4 tion of game birds. H. B. 405 by Pierce fir h- lng code. S. II. 245 by Senator Up- ton and Representative Lur- 4 dick Increasing salaries of Klamath county officials. 8. B. 206 by Eddy for the payment of a reward of 11,000 to captors of Dr. R. e) M.. Brumfteld. Governor Pierce and Dr. C. J. Smith, chairman of the democratic state central com- 4 mittee yesterday' considered 4) various appropriation bills yet to be disposed of. lm- 4 portant among these mils Is the one appropriating )17R,- 000 for the re-opening of the 4 state normal school at Ash,- land. 4 It there Is sufficient money In sight to meet the demands of the state, the governor has Intimated that he will sign the normal school bill. BILL TO TVCRF.ASF! WATER MASTER SALARY. (AanoUtrd Prat Uurd Wire.) SALEM, Ore.. March 2 Gov ernor Pierce today signed house bill 428, which authorized the state engineer department to In crease the salaries of water mas ters from $1800 to S270O a vear. The act la for special application to uescnutes county as one dis trict and Jackson and Josephine counties as another, where, it Is claimed, the work of the water maters Is so complicated that It is Impossible to get any one to serve for $1800. .The Governor signed honse bill 407 relating to exemptions under the Inheritance tax law. The Governor vetoed house bills 429 and 430. Both are curative meas ures, the first designed to cure defects In titles to real property and the other to cure defects In deeds and other Instruments. Both were vetoed on advices from the attorney general pointing to an Illegal manner In which they were drawn. CAN USE HIGHWAYS (Aaockttd Prm M Wire.) WASHINGTON, Mar. 2. States cannot refuse to permit motor ve hicles for hire as common carriers In Interstate commerce to use Its highways, It was held today by the supreme court. The decision was a defeat for Maryland, in a rase brought bv George Bush A 8ona. who as com mon carriers had been refused the permit to operate motor vehicles for hire over the state roads in In terstate commerce. CAN USE PARDON POWER fAaoriared Prea Vtt Wire.) WASHINGTON. Mar. 2-The president has authority under the constitution to pardon persons held In contempt of court In crlm- linal rase, the siinremn cnurt hulif today In a decision upholding the pardon granted by President Cool- jidge to Philip Grossman of Chl- cago. Colonel Isaac L. Ellwood. the barb wire man, and In short, told us all about ourselves." The state blocked for the time being the withdrawal of Mrs. Miller snd the substitution ss a state's witness, Wlllism Meyer of ' St Louis, Mo. Mrs. Miller a seo- er, Mrs. Miller Identified Meyer In s number of pictures In Mrs. Stokes album, this sdbum, the state says. Stokes stole and the defense ssys detectives for the state atole It back again. Stokes Is alleged to have used pictures from this album In an effort to have Mrs. Stokes Identified as SECRETARY OF STATE FOR (Aanckud Pre burl Wire.) WASHINGTON, Mrr. 2. Secre tary Hughes, appearing today for the last time as chairman of the governing board of the Pan-American Institute of International Law for the codification of internation al law, as affecting this hemi sphere. The projects will be trans mitted by the members of the board to their respective govern menta and will form the basis of discussions at the forthcoming In ternational congress of Jurists In Rio De Janeir o. Secretary Hughes, asserting the projects mark a definite step to ward the fomulatlon of an 'Ameri can International law," declared that "thanks to American Initiative we are on the threshold of ac complishment In 'the most Import ant endeavor of the human race to lift itself out of the savagery of strife Into the domain of law breathing the spirit of amity and Justice." The thirty one projects were described by the secretary as em bracing a "declaration of the rights snd duties of nations, state ments of the fundamental rights of the American republics and the formulation of rules with respect to Jurisdiction International righta and duties and the pacific settle ment of International disputes." He pointed out that the recom mendations besides Including "the law universal, contain not a few rules of American origin and adapted to American exigencies." Mr. Hughes explained that the projects or draft conventions were not submitted to the governing board, 'either for approval or for criticism at this time." "On expressing our gratification we are not dealing with texts or Ml. BIN NEARLY DEAD. PEKING, March 2. Dr. Sun Yat-Hen, South China leader, who has been critically 111 here for more thun a month, was In an unchanged condition today. PRES. SIGNS BILL (AAicUtal Prm Leued Tire.) ' WASHINGTON, Mar. 2. Presi dent Coolidge signed today the bill authorizing the state of Wash ington to construct a bridge across the Columbia river near Chelan Kails. TO RESTRICT Llyl'OK. WASHINGTON, March 2. The right of the government to. re strict physicians in prescribing liquor for patients will be decid ed by the Supreme Court. Dr. Samuel W. Lambert, a practicing physician of Now York City today docketed an appeal from the court of appeals decision sustaining the Volstead act in limiting liquor prescriptions. Dr. Lambert had won In the district court, but lost in the circuit court. MR. AND MRS. FISHER RETURN FROM LEGISLATURE ' Mr. and Mrs. Walter Fisher re turned Sunday evening from Sa lem, where they have been during the full sessions of the legislature. They also spent a few days in Port land before returning to this city. Mr. Fisher was Interested in sev eral of the bills In the sessions, and brought a number before the house, among them being the bill nn the foreclosure otMrity Hens, an appro priation bill for the Soldiers' Home cemetery and several others. Mr. Fisher and R. A. Ili-rcher also worked togethi-r on several bills. Mr. rlsher states that there was a great deal of correspondence, especially from IjoiikIus county people, who were Interested In cer tain bills, which helped thi-m In their work of preparing the meas ures. However, many of the re quests were sent st the end of the session and - were unable to be given due consideration. MR. AND MRS. CARR RETURN FROM EASTERN TRIP Mr. and Mrs. D. E. Carr, proprie tors of the Csrr's Variety Store In this city, retimed lo Roseburg this! morning after spending the pastj month In the east. Mr. and Mrs.' Csrr took the southern route east, stopping over at Los Angeles and' New Orleans. They also spent a short time In Washington, D. C. 1 They spent about a week or ten days In New York City doing their spring and fall buying for the toy department. The returned home by way of the northern route, stop ping over at Buffalo, Chicago, and spetiding a few days at Ihe home town of Mr. Carr, Aberdeen, South Dakota, which he had not visited for 17 years, and vislt'd with his parents. They spent a few daysi In Seattle visiting at the home of: Mrs. Csrr's parents. They state thst they hsd splen did trip, and missed all the ex-j treme cold weather, which the, east had just before their arrival.! Mr. Carr states thai business Is' Just starting to pick up In the1 eastern cities, and that the outlook I Is favorable for spring. I HUGHES LAST TIME AS passing upon particular propos als," be said. "These projects or draft proposals are submitted to the governing board with the rec ommendation which I take pleas ure In making, that they be trans mitted by the members of the gov erning board to their respective governments for their ' considera tion with an appropriate expres sion of our gratitude for the high minded and expert endeavors which have so happily attained this point of achievement. "It Is significant that the execu tive committee of the American In stitute of International Law has stated that their projects relate to their International law of peace. There members were a unit in be lieving that the law of war should find no place in the relations of the American republics. We have dedicated ourselves to the law of peace. Fortunately, we 'have no grievances which could furnish any Just ground for war. "If we respect each others' rights, as we Intend to do. If we cooperate in friendly efforts to promote our common prosperity as It will be our privilege to do so. there will be bo such grievances In the future. There are no differ ences now, and there should be none, which do not lend them selves readily to the amicable ad justment of nations, bent on main taining friendship. "I believe that this day. with the submission of concrete pro posals which take the question of the development of International law out of mere amiable aspira tion, marka a definite step In the progress of civilization and the promotion of peace, and for that reason, will long be remeiiibered. MRA PIFJK'F, nETTF.Il. I . . . 4) rAaoHatnl Prm Lrtmi Wire.) e) SALEM, Ore., March 2. The condition of Mrs. Wal- ter M. Pierce, wife of Gover- 4 nor Pierce was somewhat Ira- e proved this morning and she was able to take light nour- Ishment. Physicians, however, have given up hope for her recovery. t PRISONERS RIOT AND ONH KILKD. AMHat1 Ptm tsmnI Wire.) SAN FRANCISCO. March 2. The Call received word that shortly before noon to- day a guard at San Cjuentln State Prison, near here, fired Into a group of rioting prl- snners and killed one. Wen- dell Dollar, serving a term for burglary was the slain man. The shots duelled tho 4 disturbance snd 25 convlet's 4 were placed In dungeons. PROTESTING TAX (AMnrlitMl Prea LMa! Wire.) WASHINGTON. Mar. 2. Twen ty five senators Joined todsy In sending a telegram of protest to the governor: of western states In whose legislatures are pending bills proposing special taxes on butter substitutes. HANDSOME HAN3 WORSE PORTLAND. Ore., Mar. . "Handsome Hans" John Fagerlle, .police agent, who was shot three weeks sko, suffered a relapse at a hospital here today. His tempera ture ran up to 102 and attendants fear Infection might set in. RTONK TAKF.M OATH AH ASSOCIATE JUSTICK. WASHINGTON. March 2 Har lan Klk Stone of New York City, rsigned today as an Attorney General and took onth . -li As sociate Justice of the Supreme Court. Tne court room was crowded when the new Justice as cended the bench st the opening of today's court session. Those present Included Frank B. Kellng, secretary of state-designate, snd John W. Davis, democratie presi dential candidate In the last cam paign. Tho simple ceremonies were conducted by Chief Justice Taft. LUCKY NUMBER TO BE DRAWN The sale of chsaces on the beau tiful set of silver on display at Bu tar Brothers Jewelry Store, will end on April first with a card party at the Macrahee Hall given by the Ladles Auxiliary to the O. R. C, who are selling the chances. The card party will be an enjoyable evxnt, and the lady who holds high score for Ihe evening's playing will be asked to draw fifteen num bers from a receptacle containing all the number sold. The fifteenth number wU receive ' the chest of stiver. GEJ MITCHELL DENIES HE DIS Flatly Contradict Weeks Statement Concerning Magazine Articles; WROTE FOR POST Says Coolidge and Superior Officers Gave Him Per mission to Prepare Series of Articles. (Aaorlstal Prea Lnued Wire.) WASHINGTON. Mar. 2. Brlr- adler General Mitchell, the assist ant air chief, today flatly contra dicted Secretary Week's statement tnat he had disobeyed presidential orders In publishing certain maga zine articles without war depart ment approval. In a letter to the houae aircraft committee, the general declared he had "In no way disobeyed or transgressed any known order or Instruction that I cm familiar with." "It would seem," his letter ad ded "that If I had violated orders my attention should have been drawn to them long before the present time and action taken ac cordingly." General Mitchells letter wa read to the committee by Chair man Lampert just before. Rear-Ad miral Bradley A. Flske, retired) took the stand to give his opinions as to the relative value of aircraft. An editor of the Saturday Even ing Post, the general said, asked him last November to write s ser ies of articles on power and later accompanied him to the White House to lay the project before the president. 'The president reiterated his great Interest In aeronautics, which he has always shown." the letter continued, "and said he con sidered a series of articles on this subject to be beneficial and that I should obtain the permission of my superior officer, the chief -of the air service. "I Immediately reported to the chief of the air service what had occured and requested the permis sion to write the articles. He gava permission then for me to write Ihem. No mention was msde at all about submitting copies." General Mitchell attached copy of a letter he said he had received from President Coolidge, saying: "Confirming my conversation with you this morning, I do not know of any objection to your pre paring some articles on aviation, so tar aa I am concerned. But, of course, I cannot speak for your superior officers, the matter should be taken up with them." Admiral Flske told the commit tee he could not agree with the recent testimony of Rear-Admiral William 8. Sims, retired, thst the battleship bsd become obsolete. "The bsttle ship Is not obso lete," Adnil.-al Flske said. "It Is not even obsolescent. ' The adpilral added that he agreed with, the navy general board on practically every posi tion R has Uken. Aircraft fits In, he sdde.- with other elements of naval warfare, such as the sub marine. He opposed unification ot the air services. I think sir power of great Im portance." be continued, and I do not think we can eyend too much money In developing It. Air pow er has great possibilities: It Is new field, but bow far it will so no one knows." Asked whether he thought the nsvy air service wss functioning properly he replied: "No. but bersuae It hssn't enough money. It hss done pret ty well under the conditions It has had to face. I personally think wo s- weaker In aeronautics than In snvthics else." The admiral conceded that tho alrplano had tended to keep battle ship activities farther off shore but added the aubmarlne had done the some. "Which would you take," asked Representative Held, republican, Illinois, "one baftleahlp costing (4S.000.000 or a thousand airplanes for defense?" The airplanes," replied Flske, WASHINGTON, Mar. I Tho dispute over charges that Briga dier General Mitchell disobeyed or ders In puubllshlng a recent series of msgazlne articles on air power became entangled today in a new maze ot contradictions and count ercharges. Secretary Weeks has told the house aircraft committee that the articles were published In viola tion of an order by President Cool idge. Today General Mitchell ad vised the bouse aircraft commit tee that the president, had given (Continued on page I.) OBEYED