Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Morning Oregonian. (Portland, Or.) 1861-1937 | View Entire Issue (Jan. 18, 1910)
N 1 VOL. ' XLIX.-NO. 15,333. PORTLAND, OREGON, TUESDAY, , JANUARY 18, 1910. PRICE FIVE CENTS. LIBERALS HOLDING GROUND N BRITAIN More Seats Won Than They Had Hoped. UNIONISTS GROW DESPONDENT Reduction of Liberal Majority Less Than Expected. JOHN BURNS WINS AGAIN Former Toek Laborer Overcomes Violent Opposition jof Men Who Cry "Traitor" Disturbances Occur In Several Cities. SYNOPSIS OF RE8CXTS MADK Return from the British election! up to date ihov that the Liberal rov ernment hu Buffered smaller losses than Its own supporters anticipated Tne Liberals so far have lost- 20 seats net In election of 108 mmbers. The total membership Is 670, two seats having been vaVant. The membership of the recent House of Commons -was: r Libfa.ls. 3tBj Laborltes. 53; Na tionalists. SI; Socialist, 1; total eov ernment coalition. BOO. ( Unionists. 1S. ' ' '. Liberal coalition majority over Unionists. 3.12. ' " Liberal majority over all other par ties. 6 It the Liberals should continue to lone seats at the same ratlO( as at present, they will lose approximately lO'J. which would wipe out their ma jority over all other parties com bined and make possible their defeat by a coalition of Unionists, National ists arid Laborltes, which, however, seems beyond , possibility. But their strongholds have yet to elect, and it . is ot nicely tat th vrenl ratio of loss, will be maintained. It is extremely iprobable. however, from the 'way the election is going, that the Liberals will be dependent on either the Labor or Nationalist party for Its existence, for the loss of S2 seats means the wiping out of its majority . over all. In that case. It must yield to home-rule demands for Ireland or radical labor demands, or both. LONDON, Jan. 17. At the conclusion of today's polling in the general ele'o- tlon .the- parties stand as follows: unionists 82, Liberals 77. Laborltes . iNationansts 13. Net gain for the .Unionists 29. ine government fared much 'better today than its most ardent supporters expeccea. Tne unionists gained 19 seats, thr Liberals 4, and the Laborltes , 1. making a net gain for the Unionists for the day of 14, one less than they gained In the former elections on Sat urday. This practically assures the return of the Liberals to power with a fair ma jority, for among the places still to poll are those in Scotland and "Wales, which always are solidly Liberal. Liberal Majority Reduced. There . were few surprises today. Some expected that John Burns, presi dent of the local government board, would be defeated in Battersea, but won out. Other state officials who had to fight for their seats and were suc- cessful were Augustine Blrrell, Chief Secretary for Ireland, and, C. E. Hob house, financial secretary to the treas ury in Bristol, and Dr. T.J. MacNamara, secretary to the admiralty, in Camber well. Their majorities were greatly re duced. This happened all through the country, . the huge majorities secured in 1908 show ing big reductions In almost all cases. . (Many Liberals, who became members of , the House of Commons by the grace of the landslide that year, have been sent hack to private life. Among them Is Hamar Greenwood, a Canadian, who rep resented - York and was considered a prom incut candidate for hlgh'offtce. Another Canadian, Joseph Martin, ex-Premier of mrltish Columbia, was more successful .winning the'syat for St. Pancras, .East. Prominent Members Beaten. Oilier prominent members defeated In clude L. G. Phiozza, Money, apostle of free trade, who lost Ms seat (or North (Fadrtlngton. and Will Crooks, labor leader, for Woolwich. Sir H. Robson, unerni candidate for North Kensington lancu 10 get a majority, as did also Bir John Gorst. an ex-Mlnlster and at one time a member of the fourth party w-nose leaaing spirits were A. J. Balfour ,na Lord Randolph Churchill. t-'ii inn inner siae Lord R. Cecil and . George Stewart Boles, who ran as free 1 1 hub unionists, railed to overthrow tump airowoen, laoor leader, and Sir. momae Barclay Blackburn. Doctors had much to do with the de feat of Claud Hay. Unionist, in the O. H'orton division of Show-ditch. His op ponent was Dr. C. Addison, a famous consulting surgeon. Hay on the platform- made disparaging remarks about the profession and, as a result, the whole fraternity turned out to as sist Dr. Addison. Unionist leaders who ran today. Jn cludlng A. J. ' Balfour, a:, Bonar Law, Ulofi.Util,4 SEATTLE WOMAN CAPTURES THIEF BURGLAR IS HELD IX KITCHEN' UNTIL POLICE ARRIVE. Finding Man Has Donned Suit or Husband's Cloihes, She Compels Him to Take It Off.' SEATTLE, Wash., Jan. 17. (Special. J, The plucky work of Mrs W. II. Hunter, of 214 Thirtieth avenue, in grabbing a burglar who had entered her house through a bedroom window. taking him t another room and forc ing him to take off a suit of her hus band's clothes that he had stolen, was the direct cause of the arrest of iiaroia Harmon, an Englishman, who answered the description of a man who for the past month has been prowling around the Capitol Hill residence district and has robbed some 25 houses in the day time. The man came to the back door of the Hunter residence at 10 o'clock this morning and 'tried to sell Mrs. Hunter a patent mop. She declined to buy and the fellow walked around the house. Finding a bedroom window open", he crawled through It and -calmly donned a suit of clothes belonging to Mrs. Hunter's husband. Hearing a noise in the bedroom, Mrs. Hunter entered just as the Intruder was starting-to make his escape. She col lared the man and took him into the kitchen. EVANSVILLE BANK CLOSED Citizens, National, $1,400,500 De posited, Shut by Examiner. EVANSVILLE, Ind., Jan. 17. An nouncement today that tha Citizens National Hank would suspend tempor arily, pending an investigation into its affairs by National Bank Examiner J. C. Johnson, of Indianapolis, astonished thousands who had implicit confidence in the Institution. The plain state ment of the examiner, made in ad vance of the hour of opening, today, served somewhat to allay the alarm, and there was no demonstration around the bank doors by depositors. The $1,400,000 of private money in the , bank included large .commercial deposits besides probably as Tnany small accounts as any National bank in the city. Examiner Johnson said he was unprepared to give' data on the condi tion of the bank, -but he hoped condi tions would be such that the depositors could be paid in full. This same hope is offered In the brief notice posted by the directors on the bank's doors. It is;ki(wii thst ot "f thr- 1.2''-i.- tiutsLuu..e in iiaug inert; jS a qpu siderable proportion in which the cred it is weak, but just how, much is a question. - Individual loans in excess of $50,000 caused the first suspicion of the examjner. It is said .that President S. G. Gillett has borrowed to that extent, but he lias made over personal property to in demnify the banks So far as known there is nothing criminal in the al leged mismanagement of the institu tion. NEW TURN IN SWOPE CASE Autopsy May Be Made on Friend Who Died Two Days Previous. KANSAS CITT, Jan. 17. If the exam ination of the stomach-- of Colonel Thomas H. Swope, now being made by Chicago physicians, reveals poison, an autopsy will be made on the body of James M. Hunton, a close friend of the dead millionaire, wno died suddenly in the Swope home on October 1, two'Iiyi prior to Colonel Swope's death. Apo plexy was given as the cause of death. Virgil Conkling, County Prosecutor, said tonight that he would start no criminal action in the case on his own initiative merely upon the receipt of a telecrram from the attornevs of" the Swope heirs', now in Chicago, saying poison had been found in Colonel Swope's stomach. Befor.e he will issue warrant for an arrest he must have sworn statements from the examining doctors. 1 STRIKERS SEEK MISS TAFT Aid of President's Daughter Asked by New "xTork Girls. NEW YORK. Jan. 17. Helen 'Taft aaugmer oi jfresiaeni lajt. wno was reported yesterday as having taken a systematic, interest in the Philadelphia shirtwaist strike, has been invited to oome to New York to study the strike situation here. The Invitation was sent by Miss Vloet Pike, one of the Vassar undergraduates, who enlisted in the ranks of the strikers some time ago. "We would be glad to have Miss Taft come here," said Miss Pike, "and study the conditions among the waist g'rls at first hand. I believe it would be a good thing to have the, sympathy and co-operation of a yourtg woman like Miss Helen Taft." DETECTIVES ARE RELEASED Men Accused or Hindering Detective Burns Are Let Off. SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 17. Harry Nelson, r Cliff Middlemas, Hary Zobler and John R. Hayes, the detectives held to. answer before the Superior Court for having interfered with Special Agent William J. Burns while he was investigating the dynamiting of the house of - J. L. Gallagher, star witness for the graft prosecution.- were released today by Judge Cabaniss with the con sent of Assistant District Attorney 'J. F. Brennan. MONEY OBTAINED FALSELY Man Who Posed as Press Represent ative Is Convicted. x , WASHINGTON. Jan. 1.7. Jules M. Waterbury. of New York was convicted today of false pretenses on three counts on an Indictment charging that In the guise of a representative of the Asso ciated Press In 19(18 he obtained money by false- pretenses from Representa tives Hill of Iowa and Bartholdt of Missouri, and Ormsby McHarg, assist- MITCHELL DTE IS HERMANN EVIDENCE Reserve Paid-Political Debt, Hints Heney. CASE NOT STRONG ADMITTED Judge Wolverton Intimates Conspiracy Proof Lacking. EX-SOLON MAIN WITNESS George H. Cattanach, Former Rep resentative From Grant County, Recounts '0 1 Senatorial EIec- tlon Protests Are Cited. Oregon politics, figuring in the Sena torial election of 1601, when John H. Mitchell defeated George W. McBrlde for United States Senator, were introduced yesterday In the trial of Binger Hermann for alleged complicity In the Blue Moun tain Forest Reserve conspiracy. This testimony .was introduced by the Govern ment through George -H. Cattanach, Re publican Representative from Grant County at that session, over the objec tions of Mr. Worthington for the defense. In overruling the objection of defense. Judge Wolverton held it was competent for the Government to introduce testi mony covering a wide range If it should be proved material as establishing the relationship that existed between parties to the conspiracy and served to connect the defendant with that conspiracy. In answer ' to preliminary questions by" Attorney Heney, Mr. Cattanach had re plied that Mays was a member of the State Senate and that he; Cattanach, and H. A. Smith, now deceased; were members of the House of Representa tives at the 1001 session. Th vlttf-? 1 '-. ' ".- i vriai contest which marked that session. Senator Mc Brlde was a candidate for re-election but was opposed by the late H. W. Corbett. Mr. Cattanach was about to go into the details of that contest, when Attorney Worthington objected. T object seriously to this form of ex amination of the witness since the testi mony apparently in no manner concerns the defendant," insisted counsel for the defendant. "I fall to see the competen cy of such testimony. It involves an un necessary consumption of time and serves only to open the way for an inquiry Into a thousand different situations. If we keep bringing these trifles into the case" the court and Jury will be kept here for two years." Heney After Details. "The relationship between the parties Implicated In this controversy Is always proper to be. Inquired into," answered Attorney Heney, "and we have tha right to conduct such an inquiry even if It covers a period of several years. 'The purp'ose of this examination is to show the political relations existing between Mitchell, Mays, Jones and Smith and we have the light to establish those rela tions for tire reason that all of the parties are defendants In the indictment which is being tried. This testimony will be (Concluded "on Page 32.) INDEX OF TODAY'S NEWS The Weather. TESTEEDAY'S Maximum temperature, 4S.1 degrees: minimum en. degrees. TODAY'S Rain, with blab, southerly winds. I Foreign. Unionist (rains in British elections too small to bring victory over Liberals. .page l. ' ; National. Insurrection within ranks of insurgents im pending in congressional row. Page 1. Taft and Plnchot address National Civic Federation from same platform, pige 2. Henresentative Hitchcock, of Nebraska, ftravely accuses Balllnger of nepotism. Pass 5. . Domestic. f Leak in fuel tank keeps Paulhan from beat ing Michelin cup time at Los Angeles. Page John R. Walsh, denied" hearing by Federal Supreme Court, has only slender hope of escaping prison. Page 1. - ' Sport. - - President-Manager Rowland declares Aber deen -wil lstay in Northwestern League. Page 7. Northwest." Idarion County Court to uphold fruit in- spectors scrutiny of orchards. Page 6. State Senator J. W. Bryan, of Washington, fined !W) for contempt of court In Seattle. Page 6. Four Republicans, three Democrats, seek Mayoralty of Seattle. Page e. Seattle woman captures burglar. Page 1. Boise Chinaman, marked for death, is all but killed by secret tong agents. Page 8. Commercial and Marine. Wheat weaker In local market. Page 17. Small cash demand for wheat In Bast, 'page 17. Selling - pressure on stock market leads to lower prices. Page 17. Pismasted ship William II- Smith towed to Sound by Washtenaw. Page 16. Portland and Vicinity. . Inland Empire residents spend today as Portland's, guests. Page 11. Hsjr-ry Lauder, vaudeville star .is guest of 50 local-Scotchmen at lunch. Page 9. Mayor Simon gets word Modjeski will rush work on Broadway-bridge plans. Page 18. Able State Guard officers resign because militia duties take up too much ftlme Page 18. Mayor declares crty has no authority to lay water mains. Page lO. Father of 11 children sued for divorce toe cause he is attentive to affinity. Page .to. Election of Mitchell to United States Senate is made . evidence In Hermann triaL Page 1. Detective Joe Day. sent to Philadelphia for two prisoners, is returning with one; In vestigatlon may follow. Page 13. Fierce gale raging at North Head; rain and wind predicted for Portland today. Page United Railway defends course taken In Llnnton rate controversy. Page 12. J. Couch Flanders is dying, his doctors say. . Page O. NEW BONDS ARE PROPOSED Chairman". Mondell,' of Lands- Com' mlttee, introduces Bill. WASHINGTON,- Jan. 17. The issu ance of $30,000,000 Government ten year 3 per cent bonds for reclamation projects desired by the Administration is provided for in a bill Introduced to day by Chairman Mondell of the House committee on public lands. Mr. Mon dell also offered the only other of the eight bills sent him by President Taft and Secretary Balllnger, which he ap proves, to allow more liberal assign ments of homestead entries of reclama tion l&nds. Mn. Mondell saw the President today and later declared his position In the matter had not been correctly stated He said he was not opposed to con servation. He objected, however, to the form and purpose of four of thi most important "of the eight bills pre pared by Secretary Balllnger to carry out the President's wishes. WARSHIE WRECKED, 3. DIE French Sloop Martial In Balearic Islands Disaster Four Hurt. MINORCA,, Balearic Islands, In the Mediterranean, Jan. 17. The French War Sloop Martial was wrecked today on. the coast of Minorca Island. Three of the crew were drowned and four others were Injured. WALSH ONLY OF HOPE Supreme'Court Denies Hearing to Banker. HE RECEIVES NEWS LIKE STOIC Unmoved, "Iron Man" Tele- phones Decision to Wife. NEW TRIAL AGAIN SOUGHT Attorneys No Sooner Learn of Re verse Than They Renew Fight on Ground One Juror Was Coerced by Others. CHICAGO, Jan. IT. (Special.) Fate struck John R. Walsh her final crush Ing blow today when the Supreme Court of the- United States declined to enter tain his plea for a writ of certiorari. and by that act "doomed htm to serve five years in the Government Prison at Fort Leavenworth for misapplying the funds of the Chicago National Bank. Standing amid the ruins of what he had planned to be a great .career stripped of his once great fortune, this gray old man of 72, this financial mas ter-builder, who had molded a pennl less newsboy into one of the great money kings of his age, turned to re ceive the blow a face that was lm passive and unflinching as that of fate herself. Walsh Takes Blow Like Stoic. Word that the petition had been de nied came by telephone to the Grand Central Station, where Mr. Walsh was at work. In the room with him were "!,! -.or. John W., .nd two'CnIled States .Deputy Marshals detailed to guard 'the former banker. The son received the message. He broke the news to his father In a faltering voice. Mr. Walsh received, it without the quiver of a muscle. - - . "The petition denied, you say?" he asked. "'Well well, is that the end? I hope not I guess not. We shall see what we shall see." For a moment he stood silent In the middle of the room. Then he turned back to the desk, took up the receiver of the telephone and asked for the number of -his house. The Deputy Marshals, who saw what was coming, stepped into the adjoining apartment. "Is that you, Mary?" he asked. "The news is not good. The petition has been denied, but there's a good fighting chance left." Then he turned back to his desk and went on with his work as though nothing had happened. Beaten, He Is Undaunted. Throughout the remainder of th try ing day Mr. Walsh manifested the same composure which characterized him during the whole four years of the desperate legal battling that reached Its finish with the Supreme Court's de cision of today. Ruined as completely as it is possible for a man to be ruined, fallen from the very pinnacle of suc- (Concluded on Page 2.) HAS GLIMMER WIFE DRANK WINE, CHRISTY CHARGES ATTORNEY, GOT HER PROMISE TO "CUT OUT BOOZE." Oounsel for Defendant Artist Also Quotes Improper Language Used by Fair Plaintiff. ZANESVILLE, O.. Jan. 17. An attack upon Mrs. Maybelle Thompson Christy was begun by her husband, Howard Chandler Christy, the artist. In the Pro bate Court here today, when the de fense Introduced " testimony In the suit brought by Mrs., Christy to obtain pos session of 12-year-old Natalie Christy. Attorney C. C. Lemert, for Mrs. Christy, announced that they would present no more evidence. The deposition of Attorney Frank F". Vandevere, of New York, was read In behalf , of Mr. Christy. The attorney said he had had several conferences with Mrs. Christy and that she had told him that she had "cut out booze," and had noth ing more to do with Purdy, the former Christy chauffeur, who was frequently mentioned in last week's testimony. Vandevere also 'quoted profane lan guage which he alleged Mrs. Christy used In conversation with him. SyETZ RELIEF- BILL UP Measure Drafted by Interior Depart ment Is Submitted. WASHINGTON, Jan., 17. Senator Chamberlain and Representative Haw ley today introduced a bill, drawn by the Interior Department, granting 're lief to bona fide settlers on the Siletz Reservation. The bill is even broader in Its provisions than the Hawley bill previously introduced. It provides: "No homestead ' entry made of lands within the former Siletz Indian Reser vation upon which proof was submit ted without protest or objection prior to December 31, 1906. shall be canceled merely because, of insufficient compli ance with the law In the matter of res idence and cultivation, where It shall be shown to the satisfaction of the Sec retary of the Interior that the entry was made for the exclusive use and benefit of the entryman, and that he built -a habitable house upon the land and actually entered Into occupation thereof and cultivated a portion of the tract entered; and where any such en try has heretofore been canceled, same may be reinstated upon application filed within six months from the pass age of this act, where, at the date of tne filing of such application, no other entry is of record covering such land. Provided, that nothing herein con tained shall prevent or forestall Inves tigation by the land department of any such entry upon any pending charge of fraud in connection with the making or perfection of the same. DANCER, TOO SLOW, IS SHOT Man From "Wild West I'lajs Cruel . Joke in Gotham. NEW TORK, Jan. 17. "I'm from the wild and woolly West," yelled a stranger In an uptown hotel today, as he drew a six-shooter and pointed it at the new patent leathers of a mild-mannered young man. "Dance, you tenderfoot, dance." The terrified young man did his best, but the stranger demanded: "FasFter, you dude, faster." The young man could not faster and the' man with the gun sent a bullet through hlf ankle and quickly escaped into the street. The victim is in a hospi tal with a permanently crippled- foot and the police are seeking for the man with to revolver. NAPLES WORKMEN RIOT Fully 20,000 Laborers Up in Arms Over House-Kent Increase. NAPLES, Jan. 17. Twenty thousand persons took part in rioting here yes terday, arising from the discontent due to increase In rents of workmen's houses. A huge procession paraded in the forenoon and halted at the town hall, where a deputation conferred with the Mayor," who. promised that the mu nlcipality would contribute $7,500,000 toward building workmen's dwellings. Meanwhile the crowd outside, display ing the black flag, became Impatient, and without waiting for the return of the deputation, threatened to rush the town hall. The police charged, but could not disperse the. people. .Fighting ensued in which a police captain's head was broken and several policemen and many rioters were injured. The arrival of troops prevented the mob from triumphing. The Mayor's proposal to build houses does not mett the demands of the mob, and agitation continues. IRRIGATION DAM IS DONE Highest Structure in World to Feed 159,000 Wyoming Acres. CODY, Wyo.. Jan. 17. The last bucket ful of cement to complete the big Gov ernment dam to impound the floodwaters of the Shoshone River, eight miles above Cody, was put in place today and the event is. being celebrated in fitting fash Ion. The dam i the highest structure of Its kind In the world 328 feet. It Is So feet long at- the bottom and 200 feet long at the top. It Is designed to hold back floodwaters of the Shoshone, which will form an ar tificial lake ten miles square. This is ex pected to furnish water for the irrigation of 159,000 acres. MORE TINS OF OPIUM FOUND Hidden in Ship's Hold Was $8000 ' . in Contraband Goods. SAN FRANOISCO. Jan. 17. Further search of the steamship Siberia by the customs of ficiaiS'today revealed 70 ad ditional tlnB of opium secreted in various parts of the vessel. Including today's find, nearly $8000 worth of opium has been found on the Siberia since, she ca.ma Into this porjfj INSURGENTS 111 WAR WITH SELVES Insurrection Is Due at Early Date. DEMOC Would Name Members on In quiry Committee. RAINEY AND JAMES HURT Fear Expressed by Regular Republi cans That Illinois and Kentucky Democrats Might "Muss Up Things" Row Started. WASHINGTON, Jan. 17. (Special.) An insurrection within the insurgent ranks seems impending. There are marked differences of opin ion among the opponents of Cannon ism in the House over the right of the Democrats to select the Democrat- members of the Balllngcr-Pinchot investigating committee. Yielding to the suggestions of tli; President, the insurgents experienced -no difficulty In agreeing to enter a party caucus to select the Republican members of the House end of the com mittee, the condition being imposed. It was understood at the time that the Democrats in caucus should be unre strained in naming members of that party to act for the House. Regular Republicans Start Things. When it became known that Repre sentatives Henry Rainey of Illinois, and Ollie James of Kentucky, had been chosen by the Democrats, the regular . Republicans commenced to complain. Tte fear was expressed that Messr. Ralne; pad .Tamos would "musts up tilings.".' ' They both have the reputation of be ing extreme partisans and, as mem bers of the investigating committee, would unquestionably take prominent pars In Its affairs. That they might embarrass some of the witnesses with questions, may have been the thought which caused the Cannon organization in the Houae to flatly announce oppo-- ition. All of the insurgents are unqualifiedly in favor of a . free and full investigation. without regard to who is hurt, but should the plans of the regulars be carried out to oust Rainey and James, several of the insurgents cannot see their way clear to deserting their party. ' Political Effect Feared. While they themselves' have no "mater ial objection to offer to the members selected by the Democratic caucus, they fear the political effect In their districts should they combine with the Democrats simply for the purpose of permitting the minority to name Democratic members upon a committee. The position the insurgents find them selves occupying is embarrassing in the extreme. Developments may not forca them out Into the open. Much comment and not a little criticism were heard today In the corridors of the Capitol from members of Congress over the probable personnel of the Ballinger Pinchot committee. ' While , open charges are not made bji anyone that the, committee Is to be de liberately packed, the fear is expressed that its personnel will not Command as much public confidence' as could be de sired. The only objection to Rainey and James -among the Republican regulars is that they are "troublemakers." They are both partisans and on the committee would make as much political" capital out of it as possible. v FARMER KILLS AGED SIRE Son, Father's Tenant, Ordered to Va cate Hunch, Shoots. CAMERON. Mo.. Jan. 17. Joseph Montz, a farmer, shot and killed his father, Alex ander Montz, at his home near here to day. The son, ?1 years old, who was a tenant of his father, 67 Jears old, had been ordered by the latter to vacate the farm. The elder Montz went to hie son's house to insist upon the son's removal and the shooting resulted. The son and his wife then surrendered to the sheriff, claiming self-defense. On account of strong feeling and threats against the young, man among the neigh bors, he was hurried into hiding by the Sheriff. RAILROAD SEEKS BONUS Coos Bay and Boise Line Asks $150, 0 0O Cash on Completion. MARSHFIKLD, Or.. Jan. ,17. (Special.) The promoters of the Coos Bay & Boise Railroad, which is being surveyed from this place to Roseburg, are asking for a bonus of $150,000, the money not to be paid until 30 days after the road is. in opera tion. The people of Coon Bay will be ai- Lproached with subscription papers and an effort will be made lo raise tne necessary bonus. . - Postmasters Are Nominated. OREGONIAN NEWS BUREAU. Wash ington, Jan. 17. The President today nominated John H. Williams as post masten at Hermiston. Or. The follow ing Washington postmasters were nom inated: Jacob F. Hill. Davenport; James , P. Rosenbaugh, Harrington, and Robert