daily capital jocrxai - salkm, orkgox, sattrday, October 28, 1011. OREGOtl SUPREME Fill Text FibUshed b, Coirteir of Supreme state t. Hnsslnir, Multnomah County. Decided October 17, 1911. State of Oregon, respondent, v. J. . Y. Hassing, appellant Appeal from the circuit court for Multnomah county. The Hon. J. P. Kavanaugh, judge. Argued and submitted Oct. 10, 1911. John A. Jeffrey and (Chas. E. Lenon, on brief k for appellant Jos. Page, deputy district attorney, and (Geo. J. Cameron, district attorney, and J. J- Fitzgerald, deputy, on brief) for respondent. McBride, J. Affirmed. Defendant was convicted or the ; crime of mifrder in the first degree, I mary of the history of certain mem committed upon the person of Edith bers of the Hassing family, compiled Hjssius, m air. i ue ucieuac, oo iir ai tijr irom ue records of the asy as disclosed by this appeal, was in- lum, partly from Journals of the fam sanity. The defense offered In evidence a communication from the chief alienist of the public Insane hospital near Aarhus, Denmark, which appears to be a reply to an official letter of inquiry from the ministry of foreign affairs of Denmark. This communication states that it is disclosed, from the records of the asylums and from the journals of the Hassing family, who had been placed there, supplemented with details from certain relatives of the Hassings, that certain relatives of defendant, both in the direct and col lateral line, had been lnsano and con fined In the asylum. The names and family history of these persons, com piled from the above sources, are given in the communication. It has indorsed upon it the words: "Legal ized. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Copenhagen, January 27, 1911. For the Minister, H. A. Bernhoft," with the seal of state attached. Acconi- panylng this document Is a certift- ciusive presumption that a person cate of the Danish minister to the i having sufficient mentality to know Vnited States, which Is as follows: I that an act is wrongful and unlawful "It is hereby certified that in Den-1 Is capable of governing his conduct mark registers of birth, marriage and by that knowledge, and of resisting death are kept by pastors of the Dan-; any impulse to violate the law. ish Lutheran church, who are state I The only case in which our law officers; that transcripts of parish recognizes any Irresistible Impulse to registers serve as certificates of birth, kill Is In Sec. 1897 L. 0. L., which marriage and death; that the insane provides: "If any person shall, wlth- asylum near the city of Aarhus is a out malice, express or implied, and state institution, and that the chief I without deliberation, upon a sudden alienist is keeper of asylum records. ! heat of passion, caused by a provo- It is finally certified that legalization cation apparently sufficient to make made by the Danish ministry of for- the passion irresistible, voluntarily elgn affairs cover the genuineness of kill another, such person shall be the document legalized and prove that deemed guilty of manslaughter." This such document originates from the Phase of the case was fully presented proper Danish authority. I to the Jury in the general charge, and "C. MOLTKE, , I" so presenting it the court was quite "Minister of Denmark to the United 88 favorable to the defendant as the States. , evidence warranted, since in this case "Washington, D. C, March 8, 1911." ; there was no sudden heat of passion And also a certificate of P. C. Knox. ' and no provocation. Briefly, the evi secretary of state-, as to the official . dence disclosed that defendant for character of the Danish minister. The some time before the killing had state objected to the introduction of beaten and abused his wife, and, in these documents and they were ex- ne instance, driven her from home; eluded. This ruling Is assigned as that he had been arrested for threat error, i ening to kill her, and upon his prom- To rebut certain evidence offered lse to leave her alone had been al by defendant as to his insanity, the lowed his liberty; that, upon her re state called Fred Nicholson, who tes- fusal to again live with him, he wait tifled that he became acquainted with el at a dark corner and after she had defendant about two weeks before the fallen In an attempt to escape from shooting; that he was with him about blm, shot her to death and afterwards three times a week for two weeks expressed satisfaction at the deed. The and talked with him on all kinds of selection of the place, the instrument subjects; that, at his suggestion, he and the time to consummate the act came twice with him to the court showed deliberation and premedita house to listen to murder trials where tion, and a knowledge of Its wrong the defense was insanity; that In his fulness. Independent of the statute, judgment he was sane. The state also weight of authority is against i!'.e called J. C. Tally, jailer, who had doctrine that a defense of an irreslt. been in charge of the prisoner for Ible impulse to kill can be upheld :n nearly four months. He testified that any case where there exists sufficient defendant did not act differently from mentality to know the wrongfulness other prisoners and expressed the and unlawfulness of the ,-ct. opinion that he was sane. The ad- In Flanagan v. Pe-iple. 52 N. Y. 467, mission of this testimony Is also as- the court, speaklnp of the doctrine of signed as error- "irresistible impulse." say: "The a The court was requested by defen- gument proceeds upon the theory that dant's counsel to give the following there is a form of Insanity in which instructions, both of which were re- the faculties are so disordered and fused: deranged that a man, though he per- "You are instructed that before you ceives the moral quality of Ills act9, can find the accused guilty you must I9 unable to control them, and Is urged find from the evidence and beyond a hy some mysterious pressure to the reasonable doubt, that he had suffl- commission of acts, the consequences cient mental capacity to distinguish ot which he anticipates but cannot between right and wrong as applied avoid. Whatever medical or scientific to the act he was about to commit, authority there may be for this view, if he did commit it, and sufficient It has not been accepted by courts of capacity to be conscious that the said Iaw- The vagueness and uncertainty act was wrong and at the same time " tie inquiry wnlch would be o; sufficlent will power and self-control ened, and the manifest danger of In to restrain himself from the commis- troduclng the limitation claimed into slon of such act, and unless you so the rule of responsibility, in cases of find beyond a reasonable doubt in crime, may well cause courts to iVe this case, you must find the defendant before assenting to It. Indulgence in not guilty." evl1 passions weakens the restraining "You are Instructed that In order to power of the will and conscience; and convict a person of a crime, he must the rule suggested would be the cover have a memory and Intelligence for the commiseion of crime and its enough to know that the act he is Justification. The doctrine that a about to commit is wrong, to remem- criminal act may be excused upon the ber and understand and to know if notion o' an irresistible impulse to he commits the acts he will be sub- commit it, where the offender has the Ject to punishment and reason and abi'tty to discover his legal and moral will be sufficinet to enable to compare duty in respect to it, has no place in and choose between the supposed ad- the law." vantage and gratification so obtained, In State v. Knight, 95 Me. 467, the by the criminal act and the immunity court in an exhaustive opinion repu from punishment which he will secure dlate the theory of an irresistible lm by refraining from it and having so Ptse associated with a capacity to contemplated the act, the will and discern right from wrong and quote controlling power to restrain himself with approval from Dr. Hammond as frjm committing it, and unless you follows: "Although not a test of In (ind that all these elements concurred stnity. the knowiedn? of right and In the commission of the act alleged wrong is a test of responsibility. by the defendant, if he did commit it, Any individual having the capacity to you must not find him guiltv." know that an act which he contem- The refusal to give these instruc- plates is contrary to law, should be Hons is assigned as error. deemed legally responsible and should MeBrIde, J. There was no error in suffer punishment. He possesses what the ruling of the court, rejecting the Is cale!d by Bain punishable. communication of the chief alienist of The only forms of insanity which, in the Insane asylum to the Danish mln- my opinion, should absolve from re istry .of foreign affairs. Section 766 sponslbllity are such a degree of I- 0. L. requires that as foreign docu- idiocy, dementia, or mania as prevents Dr. Pierce's Favorite Prescription Ii the bot of mil medicines for the cure o diseases, disorder and weaknesses peculiar to women. It ii the only preparation of its kind devised by a regularly gradu ated physician an experienced and skilled specialist in the disease of women. It h a safe medicine in any condition of ths system THE ONE REMEDY which contains do alcohol and no injurious habnformin drugs and which creates no c raring for such stimulants. THE ONE REMEDY so good that its auM ara not afraid to print it arery ingredient on aach outside bottle -wrapper and attest to the truthfulness of the same under oath. It is sold by medicine dealers everywhere, and any 'f "ho . k get it. Don't take a substitute of unknown composition for this medicine o "ow conrosmoN. No counterfeit is s good as the genuine and Itha druggut who Mrs something else is "just as good .. Dr. P.erceV' .. ..ther nnsttke. . or b trying to deceire yon for his own selfish benefit. Such a man M 1 noT 0 1 b trusted. Ha is trifling with your most priceless possessoii-Tur health may be your life itself. St Aat yom frt what j fir. . COURT DECISIONS I, A. Tuner, Reporter of the Court. ments shall be proved "by the orig inal or by a copy certified by the legal keeper thereof, together with a certificate under the great or prin cipal seal of the country or sovereign thereof, that the document is a valid and subsisting document of such country, and that the copy is duly certified by the officer having the legal custdy of such original." Xo such certificate appears upon the copy offered in evidence nor does the communication purport to be a copy of any original document hut Bnm. ily, ana partly from oral statements of members of the family. It was clearly inadmissible. The Instructions requested were properly refused. They present the "Irresistible Impulse" doctrine at its very worst, and entirely ignore the difference between an impulse to kill, arising from mental disease or from "sudden and sufficient provocation," and one which springs from anger or a wicked and furious desire for revenge. Whatever may be the rule in other jurisdictions, we are of the opinion that the test of Insanity in this jurisdiction Is the capacity to distinguish bteween right and wrong Sec. 2408 L. 0. L. Is as follows: "A morbid propensity to commit prohib ited acts, existing in the mind of a person, who is not shown to have been Incapable of knowing the wronfgul ness of such acts, forms no defense to a prosecution therefor." The Intent of this statute is to establish a co' r 4 4 j the Individual from understanding the consequences or bis act, and the ex istence of a delusion in regard to a matter of fact which, if true, would Justify his act" , In People v. Holn, 62 Calif. 120, the court, quoting from Baron Bramwell, say: "'But If an influence be so dow- lerful as to be Irresistible, so much the more reason Is there why we should not withdraw any of the safe guards tending to counteract it There I are three powerful restraints exist jing. all tending to the assistance of I the person who Is suffering under I such an influence the restraint of j religion, the restraint of conscience, the restraint of law. But if the ln I fluence itself be held to be a legal j excuse, rendering the crime dispun ishable, you at once withdraw a most powerful restraint that forbidding and punishing Its perpetuation'. We must, therefore, return to the simple question you have to determine did the prisoner know the nature of the act he was doing; and did he know he was doing "what was wrong." In conclusion the court say: "Whatever may be the abstract truth, the law has never recognized an Impulse as uncontrollable which yet leaves the reasoning powers Including the ca pacity to appreciate the nature and quality of the particular act unaf fected by mental disease. No dif ferent rule has been adopted by Amer ican courts." The power to discriminate between right and wrong, as a test of crim inal responsibility, has been adopted by a large majority of the courts of the United States, including Oregon: State v. Murray, 11 Or. 413; People v. Hoin, supra; Mackin v. State, 59 X. J. L. 495; State v. Miller. Ill Mo. 542; Ford v. State. 73 Miss. 734; State v. Mcintosh, 39 S. C. 97; Wilcox v. State, 94 Tenn. 106; Flanagan v. Peo ple, supra; State v. Mowry. 37 Kan. 369; State v. Knight, supra; Davis v. State, 44 Fla. 32. The foregoing list does not by any means exhaust the authorities holding to the theory that a knowledge of right and wrong as to the particular act charged Is the proper test of legal responsibility. On the other hand a few courts have admitted with some reservation the theory that an uncon trollable impulse, superinduced by mental disease, even though accom panied by capacity to distinguish be tween right and wrong. Is a defense to crime. Dr. Maudsley, an eloquent champion of this theory, remarks: "There is a destiny made for a man by his ancestors and no one can elude, were he able to attempt It, the tyranny of his organization." It is submitted that these writers and the Judges who have adopted their opinions, have dealt with man's moral responsibility as between his. creator and himself, rather than his legal responsibility as a member of organized society. It ought to be plain that If every case tried should involve an investigation of the defendant's ancestry and en vironment with a view to determine to what extent these Influenced the free and untrammeled action of his will, and how far. In view of these, he was morally responsible for his acts, the Investigation would be In terminable. While one of the Inci dental objects of the law is to reform offenders, where they are reformable, Its principal object Is to protect so ciety and the only practicable- work ing theory upon which It can proceed Is to assume that every man who knows right from wrong can observe the right and avoid the wrong. The last assignment to be consid ered was the admission of the testi mony of the witnesses Nicholson and Tally, the first of whom had seen him very frequently for a period of two weeks before the crime and talked with him on a great variety of sub jects, and on two occasions, at his request, had accompanied him to the court house to listen to criminal tri als, while the latter had been his jailer for about four months. Subdi vision 10 or Sec. 727 L. O. L. permits an "Intimate acquaintance" to give his opinion respecting the mental sanity of a person, the reasons for such opinion being given. As there are degrees of Intimacy, the term Is some what Indefinite, but it should cer tainly extend far enough to enable the witness to know something of the habits, temperament and general men tal characteristics of the party whose sanity Is in question. Being an Indef inite term, the admission of such tes timony Is largely in the discretion of the trial court, and we are of the opinion that the testimony admitted is within the rule announced in State v. Murray, 11 Or. 413; and State v. Hansen. 25 Or. 395. In addition to this, defendant had called a witness having less Intimate acquaintance with him than either of the witnesses called by the state, and when his testimony was objected to, the district attorney said: "I don't think he has shown a sufficiently Intimate acquaintance to permit him to testify, but I have no objection if the state can Introduce the same character of evidence." The court said: "Very well, then let It be ad mitted." The district attorney re marked: "If It Is understood that tes timony on the same line may be of fered by the state," to which counsel for defendant answered: "Certainly, we could not help it." This practi cally amounted to a stipulation, that testimony of the character then being discussed could be admitted, and the testimony of the two witnesses above mentioned was of the same character, their qualifications being as great or greater. Counsel cannot Induce the court to adopt an erroneous rule of evidence when It operates in his favor and be heard to object to the applica tion of the same rule when it mili tates against him. If he makes it the law of the case, he must abide the consequences: Trlckey v. Clark, 60 Or. 516. Counsel for defendant has adverted to the sad consequences and Injustice of executing a man in defendant's mental condition, but the jury has found that he knew right from wrong, and understood the nature and qual ity of the act, and we must assume, in the absence of error by the court, that they found correctly. The duty of condemning any human being to suffer the extreme penalty of the law Is one which every court approaches with regret. But If the prayers of his Innocent and helpless wife were not sufficient to prevent the defendant from sending a bullet through ber brain, as she lay fallen and defense less before him, no mere considera tions of sympathy or pity ought to induce the minister of Justice to bend the law to spare blm. The Judgment of the circuit court :s affirmed. At Fountains & Elsewhere Ask for "SIORLIGK'S" Thi Original and Genuine MALTED MILK The Food-drink (or All Ages. At restaurants, hotels, and fountains. Delicious, invigorating and sustaining. Keep it 00 your sideboard at home. Don't travd without it A quick lunch prepared in a minute. Take no imitation. Just say "HORIM'S." Not in Any Milk Trust Notice of Intention to Construct a Sewer to Be Known as "Lateral Sewer District No. 4." Notice la hereby given that the common council of the city of Salem, Oregon, deems and considers It nec essary and expedient, and proposes to construct a sewer to be known as "Lateral Sewer District No. 4." and that there will be laid 8-Inch vitrified or concrete gewer pipe along Twenty first street, from Asylum avenue to Chemeketa street, as shown and des ignated and according to the maps, plans and specifications adopted for the same, and on file at the office of the city recorder, which said plans and specifications are hereby referred to for a more detailed description of said sewer, and hereby made a part of this notice, and that the entire cost of the same will be assessed up on the property directly benefitted by the construction or said sewer. This notice Is published for ten. (10) days by order of the common council of the city of Salem, Oregon, and the date of the first publication thereof Is the 24th day of October,, 1911. CHAS. F. ELGIN City Recorder. 10-24-llt 0 'o(Ice of Intention to Construct n Sewer to Be Known ns "Lateral Sewer District o. 2." Notice Is hereby given thnt the common council of the city of Salem, Oregon, deems and considers It nec essary and expedient and proposes to construct a sewer to be known as "Lateral Sewer District No. 2", and that there shall be laid S-lnch vitri fied or concrete sewer pipe along the street between blocks 2, 3 and 4 and block 1 and certain acreage proper ty In the Pleasant Home Addition to the city of Salem, Oregon; also along the street between blocks 4 and 5, 3 and 0, and 2 and 7; thence In a north westerly direction to High street; also a connecting line between blocks 2 and 3 of said Pleasant Home Ad dition; said sewer shall be construct ed at the expense of the property di rectly benefited and according to the maps, plans nnd specifications adopted for the same and on file at the office of the city recorder, which said plans and specifications are hereby referred to for a mere de tailed description of said sewer. This notice Is published for ten (10) days by order of the common council of the city of Salem, Oregon, and the date of the first publication thereof Is the 25th day of October, 1911. CHAS. E. ELGIN, 10-25-llt City Recorder. 0 A Household Medicine thnt Gives Confidence. Is Foley's Honey and Tar Compound. Mrs. T. J. Adams, 522 No. Kansas Ave., Columbus, Kas., writes: "For a number of years my children have been subject to coughs and colds. I got some of Foley's Honey and Tar Compound and bave found that It cured their coughs and colds in a very short time, so I keep It in the house all the time." Red Cross Pharmacy, (H. Jerman.) o ' Though we may never have loBt any, most of us are looking for money all the same. o The SoYcmber Wide World Maga zine. The Vlde World magazine for No vember contains a number of Inter eating articles and stories dealing with different parts of the world. There is a fully illustrated paper on "The Troglodytes of Dieppe," another on "Wild Boar Hunting In New Zeal and" and a third dealing with "The Romance of Opium-Smuggling." Captain G. D. Halgh, late of the Mat- aDeieiana Kener rorce, relates a gruesome story of a friend of his who was "Burled Alive by a Lion E. D. Burrowes describes his exper iences while "On the Trail of the Shovel-Nosed Shark" and Dr. Max! mus Neumayer continues the account of his life "Among the Indians of Bolivia." "The Trials of a Tender foot" is amusing and "The Story of the carved Peach-stone, by Com mander J. Marnab, full of mystery and thrills. Altogether the contents of the November Wide World are fully up to the mark and continue to bear witness to the undoubted fact that "Truth Is Stranger than Fic tion." Enjoyment tonight may mean suffering to morrow, but not if jour stomach, liver, and bowels are helped to do their natural work by BEECHAM'S PILLS Sold Enqnrhm, In boxae 10a. aad 22a. I Reliable Remedy FOR CATARRH Ely's Cream Balm It quickly absorb'. Cms Ratiat si Ones. It clean., soothe, bals and protects me aisoftjMHl menu brans resulting from Catarrh and drive sway a Cold in the Head quickly. ltfuturea the Sensea of Taate and bmeU, full siza SO cU. at Drnggirta or by mail. Liquid Cream Balm for um in atomizers 75 cts. EJj Uroihsrs. 66 Wsrrto Bmet. Kw York. DEBATING TEAM LOSES ZIMMERMAN University of" Oregon, Eugene, Oct. 27 In debate circles at the univer sity, great anxiety is felt over the failure of Howard Zimmerman, a former Salem boy, to turn out for debate. Owing to his Y. M. C. A. work and. bis Btudles, Zimmerman has refused to participate this year. Mr. Zimmerman last year was a member of the debating team that won the championship of the Pacific Coast, defeating both Washington and Stanford. Both of these colleges are after Oregon's scalp strong this season, and the Oregon students are very anxious to retain their prestige in debate during the coming year. -o SYSTEMATIC BURGLARY GOING OS IX SALEM That there Is a systematic band of robbers operating in the city Is little doubted by those who have been in close touch with the police depart ment the last few days. Last Wednes day the home of Mr. Ross Moores was entered some time in the evening or late afternoon and a considerable quantity of silverware and other val uable articles stolen. In this case the robbers were evidently scared away, for they did not take several things of value which were at hand. Thursday night the. home of Ralph S. Vance was entered and quite a lit tle clothing stolen. B:ntrance was gained by forcing the woodshed door and although several people were sleeping in the house, none of them were awakened. Police Chief Hamilton and Officer Burkhart are working on the cases, and although there Is but little to go on they hope to apprehend the felons In the near future. The November Strand Matftslne. The November Strand contains a very striking article entitled "A Vis ion of Gold" by the well-known Eng lish statistician, John Holt Schooling. Mr. Schooling bases his article on a single cent placed out at five per centtum compound Interest, A. D. 1. The sum which this single cent would amount to at the close of the year 1910 Is almost inconceivable. One Illustration alone will b 11 nice to show the collossal growth of an American cent In 1,910 years. The value If turned Into Bpecle would be suillclent to make 26,000 millions of spheres of solid gold, each one being equal to the planet Earth In volume! Another article of Interest Is con tributed by Charles Frohman on "Play Writing." There are stories of interest by W. W. Jacobs, Barry Pain, Richard Marsh, Arthur Morri son, Tom Callon and other well known writers. "Some Dickens Dis coveries" Is an article dealing with the origin of persons and places to be found In Dickens' works. The "Character Studies of Well Known People" Is an interesting novelty. o Kicked by a Mai Horse. Samuel Birch, of Beetown, Wis., naa a most narrow escape from los ing his leg, as no doctor could heal the frightful sore that developed, but at last Bucklen's Arnica Salve cured It completely. Its the greatest heal er of ulcers, burns, bolls, eczema, scalds, cuts, corns, cold-sores, bruises and piles on earth. Try it; 25 cents at J. C. Perry's. 1 TWO LARGE FARMS AT BARGAIN PRICES No, 58, 275 acres, 9 miles from Salem, near Lincoln, 120 acres culti vated, 155 acres in stand ing timber (5,00,000 feet), On good main road, This is principally fine, rolling fruit land, Price $65 Per Acre No, 65, 333 acres on Dallas-Salem wagon road and adjoining Dairy sta ion on the S, P, railroad, 8 1-2 miles from Salem and 6 miles from Dal las, All cleared except 25 acres, and most of it in cultivation, Fine 10-acre apple and pear orchard, Good house, barn, gran ary and other outbuild ings, The whole at $80 Per Acre The west half of the place, 160 acres, which includes the improve ments, at $90 Per Acre The east half, 175 acres, r wnicn is tinfi c. ar nnri. but unimproved, at $75 Per Acre There is no better land than these two pieces in i the valley, and these are bottom prices, I E. Hofer & Sons INVESTMENTS 213 S, Com, St, Phone 82- S Vv'- l" The Home of the IK and the Eagle Here visitor are cordially welcomed and are shown the result of over fifty years unswerving loyalty to the highest Ideals of Quality and Purity, Here they learn the reasons why " Tho Old Reliable" B King of all Bottled Beers stands alone at the top of the world's best brews. Its mildness and exquisite taste remains always the same, because it is brewed only from the cream of each year's Barley crop and from the most costly Saazer Hops grown. Bottled only at the Anheuser-Busch Brewery St Louis, Mo. t The Beer for the Home, Hotel, Club and Cafe UTH7 A The kind that give the users absolute satisfaction. Your Heater should be Selected with Four Points in mind Good Heating Qualities, Economy of Fuel, Safety and Appearance. Our Opal heaters cannot be excelled as good even heaters, Every joint in them is tight and close, they are proven fuel savers, The body of every Opal heater is made of extra thick polished steel, the bottom, top, door and lining, are all heavy best grade grey iron, every movable part fits closely so that there can be no danger from fire, You do not buy a stove for an ornament, yet we know you will like one which will add to the appearance as well as the comfort of your living room, The Opal doe? this; it is built on sensible, graceful lines, all nickel work is very plain and best grade, body is smooth polished steel, Call and look one over, NO. 16 IONE HEATERS $1.25 -mumU'l.ri' JJFJIJ..I. JlJ,M-.'MlTX.fl' Read The Journal For News HPT7Tn