fl vwW Today glrla help carry tht financial load along with their parent to keep the home Area burning By Alice L. Tildesley THAT age-old pulsion for arraigning youth has lately been indulged in by Pearl S. Buck, noted writer, In a recent article In a national mngazino. Sho has, she says, been making a survey of young men and women in America, and has found them to be "charming, mild and completely selfish." They are docilo creatures who do not rebel against their parents and teachers as they should. They are beautiful, strong - bodied creatures with no angers nnd no determinations. American youth, continues Pearl Buck, is shielded, praised, coaxed and indulged Madge Evans, convicted on sight of being young, beautiful and charming, comes now before you to defend the youth of the land. "The charges are false absolutely false I" she declared, raising clear blue eye from a peruaal of them. "Youth la not selfish it la greedy, perhaps, Just u puppies are greedy; it wants to taste everything to sea what It's like. It has a hoarty appetite lor life, but that's because It's healthy and young It's thoughtless, but It's not wicked. "Selfishness belongs to older people. When people grow old, something seems to happen to them 1 don't know what It Is, but they harden, become bitter and cruel, nothing matters to them but money. They think that what happens to youth doesn't matter. They dont care whether youth suffers or not. Let youth go to war, let them do without ' Jobs, let them put off getting married, let them tut out their hearts that') the. attitude I AH they care about It how much money It means to thorn,' "That's what 1 cnll aeinshnessl" SLIM and lovely In a dove-gray dress, she sat on the blue couch In her living room and fairly flamed lth Indignation. "So we're pampered, are we?" she orted. "This Is the drat I've heard of It. Who are these weird young people In Miss Buok's survey? "We aren't a nation of Barbara Hut . tons, you might as well say that all Americans are rich becauso John D Rockefeller has done very well tor him self. The wealthy girls and boys who are so carefully shielded and Indulged are In aitoh a minority that they don't oount, The majority of our young peo ple are the Idle poor, and If you knew how they feel, you wouldn't oall them , mild and without angers. "1 don't understand the viewpoint oi. the young people who think 'bread drops as manna out of heaven, according to Miss Buck, I've worked ever since 1 , was t year old. My brothel and I posed for artists. We did baby books We posed for advertisement!, when 1 war t years old, 1 became ohlld star in motion pictures and continued working with, the company until I was 10. "1 cant remember the tune 1 dldni know that 1 had to earn a living. When X was 10 1 went to sohool, where made a number of young friends, who till art very does, They have nothing warn' inf el ( 0 Prudence and Toughle art two Scottlcs that keep the Madge Evans household In an uproar most of the day to do with the stage or screen, so I feel that when I dlecuss the youth of today I understand the problems of boys ana ulrls outside the aotlng profession. "One of my schoolmates Is an Interne in Bellevue Hospital, one of them Is In oharge of Oamp Fire Glrla' clubs, Bhe's staying here with me now, and we often talk of the problems that face our gen eration unemployment, the threat oi war. "I know about unemployment at first' .land. I spent a whole year looking foi work after I left sohool. I used to visit igents' offices every day. ! did extra 1 work; 1 pursued managers and produc ers. I know what it Is to be one of twenty-five girls sent out after one tingle Job i to be lined up In a row with twenty-four other girls and to try to look so different that ohoostng me would be Inevitable. Just try to look smart and 'different' when you haven't any - money I It's bad enough the first fev. times you go, but to keep going ever lay Is what breaks your heart, "Then we've had It In the family, as veil. My brother had a good Job In New fork, but with the depression his arm vent out of business. He tried hard, but he couldn't get anything to do, so at length MQther and I begged him to come out here nnd stay with us while he looked around. He was with us tor a vear, going out every day to try to get something to do. It what Miss Buck thinks of youth wore true, he should have been content with things as they were, for he had a good home, plenty' to eat, lota of entertainment. He was deprived of nothing but a chance to work. , , "But he wasn't satisfied. He made himself dangerously 111 worrying; for a lime the doctor wnsnt sure he could pull him through, when at last ht got V (21 KI Madge Evans Takes Vigorous Issue With Pearl Buck's Charge That American Young Folks Are a Pampered and Petted Lot his chance, he recovered; now he's doing very well and we're proud of him." She turned her bright head at the sound of footsteps In the hall, and hailed their owner, "Mother! Come In and tell us how docile your children are I" she cried 'Tell us how you've pampered me. Sit aown and listen to this Indictment." Mrs. Evans, thus appealed to, heard . It quietly. Then she said, with a smile: "I am afraid Miss Buck is confusing this country with China. It seems to me that she must be thinking of my gen eration, rather than Madge's. I grew up In England. In my day, youth didn't rebel against age at any rate, not aloud. We might mutter to ourselves: 'Well, 1 don't believe that!' but we dldnt dare soy to to the autocrats who ruled the home. It my ohlldren dont agree with me, they argue the question po lltely, perhaps, but firmly. "In my day, If a girl had said to her parents: 'I'm taking an apartment away from home. I'm going to be on my own' the parents would have said: Nonsense!' and yanked her home by the baok of her neck, Today, such an announcement would be received calmly. Madge Evans, de lightful to look at, lovely to know 'Very well,' the parent says, 'but see that you settle the bills yourself. Ill support you at home, but when you leave, you're Independent.' "A mother of yesterday dldnt permit her child to try her wings. She was afraid her darling would bump her head or bruise herself out In a callous world. Today, she knows that her child must learn how to take core of herself, that she cant be protected forever. Though It hurts, she must stand back and let the child alone." "We're both soft and mild, are we?" Madge conned the article again. "I can't believe the writer has met any of the girls I know She seems to be talk ing of girls of another era, Olrls like Agnes In 'David Copperfleld.' She was sweet and faithful and pleasant. She was devoted to her father and she waited for David, patiently, until he was able to afford to marry her All very com mendable, perhaps, "But today, Agnes would not have wasted the years. She'd have gone out after a Job herself and they'd have pooled their salaries and made a home She might have had to spend the day with a crabby old man who expected her to get out letters like a multlgraphlng machine, and she might have had to market after she left the office, and then prepare vegetables and salad, cook the hamburger and fix gelatin for des sert when she got home, but at least they d have been together. "The old Idea was that girls must marry as soon as possible to get off the family's back. They picked out a young man whatever young man was In sight and they got him If they were lucky, transferring themselves from Father's shoulders to his, but not altering the fact that they were burdens. Today they help carry the load." 'TlHE defender of youth began to at- tack the prosecution. "They sacrifice themselves tor us, do they? Not that I've noticed. "Look at the captains of Industry, as they used to be called; those 'great men' who had pieces written about them In success magasln.es telling how wonder ful they were I They rose from news boy to head of the establishment; they built empires;' they acquired holdings so vast that they couldn't count them. And they dldnt know enough about manag ing their businesses to prevent their crashing and wrecking the world I "Age should be condemned, not youth "The war was brought on by gray jeards, to satisfy their greed. Youth had to do the fighting. That was to be a war to end war, a war for humanity, a war to make the world safe for de mocracy. It settled nothing. "Everything that happened afterward was blamed on war-flaming flappers, th depression, unemployment. And s 3 "If rebellion against the old order of things is what is wanted, I'll get up on a soapbox and 'spout' it," declares Miss Evans now maybe they are going to have an other war and kill some more young people. Age never learns. Experience teaches them nothing! "If rebellion Is what is wanted by those of Miss Buck's generation (who are responsible for the frightful mess we're In now), I'm going to rebel when war comes. I'll get on a soapbox and talk against sacrificing youth until somebody cracks me down. Youth knows there's nothing to be gained by war, 11 older people dont." Madge sprang up from the couch. "That's Ruth coming In now! Ill get her. I'll let her tell you about young people today. She's the Camp Fire Club girl I mentioned " Ruth Stevens, tall and dark and calm beside the golden Same that was Madge, read the challenge quietly. "Ruth attended the Youth Today con ference, all the big youth conventions," explained Madge, eagerly. "At one convention the viewpoint of more than 200,000 young people was rep resented," said the calm girl. "It seemed to me that they were bewildered, rather than mild. They were anxious, worried, suffering. Their chief demand was for Jobs. They wanted to work more than anything else In the world, "One boy got up to address the con vention In reply to attacks on youth. 'We don't want to be like you older peo ple!' he said, looking straight down at Newton D. Baker and the other officials. I think that expresses It as well as any thing else. They'd like to do something, but they havent the power.' uvmiAT chance has youth?" Madge ' asked. Indignantly "No man gets Into a responsible position until he's . 40 and that's young for most political Jobs. They say he has no experience, but by the time they accept him, he's lost that One keen sense of what Is true. His belief In righteousness has dulled. That terrible something that happens to older people has overtaken him. "Look at college elections, as compared to national ones. At college, they may argue as to a candidates fitness for of fice, but they don't Indulge In personali ties. No one says: 'He can't be presi dent because of his religion.' 'We wont elect him because his sister was In a scandal.' 'He wont do because he's re lated to so-and-so. He's elected on his merits, because hell make a good officer, and for no other reason. "How does that compare with cam paigns tor national offices? They're un fair; they're filthy; they drag In things that have nothing to do with the case. "Youth Isn't afraid to try something new." "Not so long ago, students all over America staged a rally against war. They were rebelling against something that you'd think would gain them the re spect of every one not actually In the monster class. What happened? They were arrested, clubbed, called 'Reds' I Some were expelled. They had to take them back again and admit they werent Reds,' but doesn't It make you think? "It's the young people who will have 10 fight If we have another war. Yet older people have the nerve to talk of how they have pampered us, Indulged us, sacrificed for us. "Give us the world, and tee what wall do with It. Olve It to us now. We cant do worse with It than they have donel" 0 PAGE THREE