4 THE MEDFOItD MAIL TRIBUNE, MHUPORD, OREGON, MONDAY, .TAff tTAJtY 10. 1010, MedfordMailTribune PUBLISHED DAIIjT EXCOiTT SATURDAY. A eomaWdAtlon of the Medford Mall, established IMS; the Southern Oregon, tan, taUkUiUi 1$0J: the Dctuocratlo Times, established 1S7J5 tho Ashland Trlb wne, eatAsUahed 189, and tba MeJford Tribune, established 0i. Official Paper of GEORGE PUTNAM. fettered m second clui matter November uregon, unuer me net 01 i:u . sunscniPTi" onIiates: tie year, ey taall. ...S.OO AN ECHO OF Iu another colunin that stalwart pioneer, J. S. Howard, attacks the Mail Tribune, Councilman Merrick, the city ad ministration and the proposed charter amendments. This papjer is only glad to publish more effectively than could be flimsy and shallow arguments and village prejudice is based the opposition to Mayor Canon's administration. The Mail Tribune has the feelings for Mr. Howard who in Medf ord and Jackson county since he first surveyed the townsite on a brush covered plain. His final adminstration as mavor broucrht to a close the village era. The water - - - w tower, in the park still stands as a monument to the days -when the water problem was supposed to be settled forever by bringing the water of Bear creek through an open ditch to it, and interest; is still being paid on the bond issues ne cessited by water and electric light plant fiascos of that jra, and the present council's water record compares very favorably with Mr. Howard's own. It is-not so long ago when Mr. Howard's hat was Med ford's postoffice. Then a soap-box replaced the hat as the new town grew. It has continued to grow ever since and at no time faster than at present. Consequently it has outgrown its present charter, which must be altered to fit the conditions, as it has outgrown the soap box postoffice, and the public business even of the last Howard adminis tration can not be compared in volume with that of today, and it is a decided economy to pay men for looking after the public business when so much money is being spent for it is asking too much for officials to devote the neces sary time and energy without compensation. Mr. Howard has a decided grouch on. He is "agin the government," but he usually is. TTis vigor and energy are surprising and a tribute not only to the man .himself but to our wonderful climate as well, anditis too bad his abilities are wasted in efforts to block municipal progress. He should join the Commercial Club and become a booster. He is mad because Central avenue was not paved, yet he did anore to block the pavement-than anyone else, and at the ;-aame time opposes councilmen who are trying to get it paved at a lower figure. The wild assertions, they can scarcely be called argtr ments, made against the charter amendments by jSLr. Howard are answered by Mayor Canon. It can be added that amendment No. 3 enables the city to secure interest on .its deposits, something it has been hitherto unable to do, the bank. that furnished the treasurer's bond receiving.the deposits and keeping' the interest. The amendment pre Tcnts just what is now possible, "the power of a favorite bank to manipulate funds." In his. argument against amendment No. 4 Mr. How ard raises a man of straw and proceeds to demolish it. The working man's home is not in danger nor is the council given greater power than it provements. Mr. Howard evidently sighs for the old village days when the town was torn with ing was like a gathering of ney. But those old days are ory pf the.past one with the petty squabbles okyesterday, and his arguments are like those of Eip Van "Winkle come back to visit his native village As Mr. Howard says of Mr. Merrick, so say we of Mr. Howard: "Please understand we do not crticise him as a citizen, believe he is one of our best and wish we had a lot more like him, but we believe his judgment has been at fault in some matters of public hopelessly behind the times. TOMORROW'S Tomorrow's election has against Harry Wortman as ward and Robt. W. Telfer as of the administration ticket tie opposition. A comparison of these candidates w0h the opposition, must be made upon their records, not upon their perosnal ity. Mr. Wrtman has well and faithfully served his con stituents. The second ward has received more public im provements than any other during his term of office, more than since its creation as a ward. He has been an indefati gable worker for the public good at a personal sacrifice of his business interests. He takes a broad and progressive view of public matters and his defeat would be a distinct loss, not only to his ward but to the entire city. In Mr. Telfer, the city has an ideal recorder, an efficient book-keeper, prompt, accurate, accommodating and cour- tho City of Modford. Editor and Manner. 1. 10. at the postoffice at Medford. One month by mail or carrier....! . VILLAGE DAYS. the communication as it shows otherwise shown, upon what highest regard and kindliest has played an important role already posses in forcing im factions, and a council meet the celebrated cats of Kilken outgrown and a jangled mem to find it grown into a city. policy," and we might add, ELECTION". narowed down to opposition councilman from the second city recorder. The balance will be re-elected with but lit teous. He conibincs qualities rarely found (ogodier and ho should bo chosen again by a big majority. Such men as he are raro in public office. Both of the opponents of these men aro untried in of fice, and whether they would do as well (they could not do better) or whether thoy would do worse, is a matter en tirely of speculation. The city would gain nothing by chango and might lose much. It is not likely therefore, that a chango would bo considered, for there should bo no discord introduced in the program of progress. WE REFUSE AN AD. The Mail Tribuno is in receipt of a good sized advertis ing contract with Meier and Eranlc, tho Portland depart ment store kings. It has refused tho contract and roturncd the copy accompanying it, though it needs tho money. The Mail Tribune belioves in patronizing home indus try and in helping build up a city here. This cannot be done if the people send out of town to buy products, Portland houses do nothing to help Medford, they pay no taxes here, do not contribute to tho publicity fund, pay no payrolls and do nothing to aid in tho upbuilding of the city. Local merchants do, and it is tho duty of every Med ford citizen to keep the money at home. While the Mail Tribune appreciates the compliment paid it by Meier and Frank, who recognize its value as an advertising medium, it cannot print their advertisements as long as it receives considerable patronage from houses in the same line in Medford and its only valid excuse for printing foreign advertisements would be the lack of ap preciation at home by merchants. . . The Mail Tribune has set an example that every resi dent of the Rogue river valley should'follow patronize home industry. 4- UIUAT DADPDC CIV HP DISMISSAL OF P1HCH0T 1 Chicago Tribune. CHICAGO, Jan. 10. Tho country will stand by GIfford Plnchot, dis missed chief forester, right or wrong, according to tho Tribuno which says editorially: "Without Inquiring Into tho tech nical justice of the dlschargo of Mr. Plnchot, tho Tribuno must repeat that tho country will stand by Pln chot, right or wrong. It does not understand lecal technicalities and !t is prepared to accopt tho presi dent's statement that Mr. Balllnger has acted within tho law. But long since tho country has been ablo to distinguish between mon who are "law noneat" and those who aro moved by moral zeal for tho preser vation of tho public Interest against prhato privilege. In il.et sense tho Tribune belioves that tho great ma jority will dlsapprovo tho action of the president In discnarcing Pln chot. Plnchot who of all mon undor President Taft represents In . tho .clearest senso tho spirit of tho ad ministration of Theodore Roosevolt." Xcw Tork World. NEW YORK, Jan. 10. Tho re moval of Chief Forester Plnchot clears tho way for a direct investiga tion of Secrotary Balllngor, says tho Now York World In an editorial, which in part, follows: , "Taft's removal of Plnchot from pftlco has dono much to clear up tho situation. Tho administration Is no longer under tho necessity of main taining a truce between two bitterly hostile factions. Tho simple question for congress to dctermlno whether tho charges made against Secretary Balllnger aro truo. If thoy aro true Mr. Balllnger will bavo to follow Mr. Plnchot Into retirement," St. Pnul Pionccr-Press. ST. PAUL, Minn., Jan. 10. Com mentlng on tho dismissal of GIfford Plnchot, as chief forester, tho Pioneer-Press says: ,"Tho dismissal of Forostor Pin chot Is destined apparently to mnko plain who aro tho truo and who aro tho falso friends of what tho public knows as tho 'Roosovslt policies.' Tho Ploneor Press condones Pin chot's dismissal and tho possible ns- cpndancy for a tlmo of destructive in torestB ho opposed." LANGF0RD WILL MEET FLYNN IN LOS ANGELES MEMPHIS, Tonn., Jnn. 10. J. A. Woodman, noting for "I3cggnr" Sam Lnngford, announced today that tho Boston 'negro will meet Jim Flynn be fore the Pacific Athletic club of Los Angeles on February 8. Longford and tho Pueblo fireman will bnttlo over tho tcn-ronnd routo necessitated by tho law in Los An geles, Tho newspapers will announce Uw winner. Lnngford is scheduled to moot the Dixie Kid hero tonight. Following his match with Flynn in Los Angoles, ho plans to appear in Paris and Lon don, sailing from New York ' about March 1, "f-f-f-f-f-f-f-f- THE FRIVOLOUS SIDE OF LIFE A Dii tmffli. Tho Futnro Queen Stop crying and hurry up. Tho Worm I enn't hurry. I've uot two buttons left over, and they won't go In the same buttonhole. O. N Smith In Princeton Tiger. Would Fill tho Dill. Mum Uass So you think mo nice, Mr. Pelican? Mr. Pelican I think you would Jus ail tho bill. Came For Suspicion. "I believe George fooled inc. When we were murrled he vowed 1 was an old bachelor, but I hdlovo ho was a widower." "And why are you suspicious, dear?" "UccauHo ho can uctually understand what I nay when my mouth Is full of hairpins. It takes long experience to do that." Miss ITolen Watt, who haB boon spending the holidays with hor par ents, Mr. and Mrs. J, E, Watt, Kift Sunday to rosutno hor studies at St. Helen's Hall, Portland. THE CHARTER FOR THE AMENDMENTS. (I)y Mayor W. II. Canon.) The proposed charter amendments which are to be voted on next Tuesday were framed by the cltr attorn? unilor tho direction of the council to moot what seemed to them to be needs of tho city. It In fait by All the. member of tho city council, iui well as thn writer, that It would be unfortunate If any of these amendment vrcre to fall of pass, ago, and It In for thin reason that 1 desire to briefly net forth the reason why they should receive tho support of the voters of the city, IoHc Court. Tho first chartar amendment provides for a city court, of which the mayor Is to bo the Judge. Heretofore this work has been donu by the recorder. Tho work of the re corder's otftco has boon growing no heavy, by reason of the largo number of assessments for strict Improvements, water mains, sewern, etc, which must be entered, collections on which must bo noted and accounted for, that It seemed wise to relievo tho recorder of the police Judge work and to put It on the mayor's shoulders. To meet the possible contingency that the poople of the city might at some future time want a man for mayor who would be unwilling to look after this police court work, It Is provided that the council may, with the consent of the mayor, appoint a special police Judgo to perfojm these duties, and may deduct from the mayors salary the salary paid tho police Judfie for his snr vices. The second amendment Is one provld Ing salaries for the members of the council and the mayor. I do not believe that thn people of the city wilt object to paying the mon who look after the public business a reasonable compensation for their ser vices. Speaking for himself, the writer, aa mayor of Medford, has durlnc thJ past year devoted to the work almost the whole of his 4lme. This tins been absolutely necessary In order to properly porfarm the duties of the office and look after the Interests of the cltr. Any man of fair Intelligence who will give his time and attention to the duties of the office of mayor of Medford can save tho city many times the salary that lias been fixed. It Is not possible for n man who must earn his livelihood to hold the office and Ktve It proper at tention without some compensation, for tho simple reason that It renders It Im possible for him to stve his attention or time to sny other business or voca tion. The salary of the mayor has been placed at $75.00 per month. If tho pollen court work were left with the recorder, It would be necessary to employ an ad ditional clerk In that office, whose sal ary would amount to as much aa that provided for the mayor, so, In reality, the expense of running the city la not increased. The salary of councilman has been placed at 138.00 per month, and all that has been oald abovo with reference to the salary of the mayor applies to the matter of a salary for councilman. The members of the present council have during the past year davoted to tho work a large portion of their time, and It will be necessary that the mem bers of future councils do the same thine If thn Interests of the city are not to nuffer from lack of attention. The salaries are rtxed by the charter amendment, and the council or mayor has no power to Incrcale them to any extent. Tho third charter amendment relates (a thn matter of thn treasurer's duties. and Is dcslKned to placa It In tho power of the city council to secure Internal on !ie.5u?af-0Ll,"r J"-!? UUBIICU 111 UIMIHBi 4iu treasurer has hod the whole say as to where the city funds should be deposited, He and his bondsmen havo been abso. k VTT , . hw f.l they had been lost by a bank failure. Tho present plan Is to give the city council power to say in what banks thei money shall bo deposited. In this way the council can secure some corapeu on. nnu uuuuwvso kqi i nig rem, un mo cur n daily balances. Had this rule been en. forced during the past year, tho city could doubtless have secured a consld- rVrA,"'U furnish bonds for tho money deposited with them, and Inasmuch as the treaa- urcr will not be allowed to designate' wnero me money is to pe aeposiieu. ne for anv monev lost hv reason nf a hanV fatlure where he has compiled with the directions or the city council In deposit- lit Lhm "Jm 7: A e1 "0V."' th, city will at 111 have security ajralnst such a loss, but the banks themselves will furnish the bonds to cover this Instead of the treasurer. This la the method In u" . , r?r w ?iU"' ano 1 The fourth charter amendment relates. merely to tho formal method of levying assessments for public Improvements, ?.W!7.A0?!-! blind and Inconsistent In this reaped. ana ine cnarier amendment is designed merely to remedy this defect, it does "hat can be .cTed except "that It Tvc. the council power to levy against the property-owners a less amount than tho full cost of the Improvement In a case where the benoflt of tho Imraflvement Is mnatlw rvtn sen 1 ttwiA vntttat ttinn ananlsl to the nrooertv. There Is nothin In this i amendment which will In nny way of-j foot the Interests of any property-owner. It merely makes It possible for the city officials to levy assessments with somo what less of expense, and will render theso assessments lens subjcot to attack by any tax dodgers. W. It CANON, Mayor. Notice. Tho ladles aid socloty of tho Pros bytorlan church will moot on Tues day aftornoon at 2:30 In tho parlors of tho church, A largo attondanco Is dcBlrod, Perkins Improves, WASHINGTON, D. C, Jan. 10. Tho condition of Senator Qcorgo C. Perkins of California, who was in- jurod by falling on nn ioy pavpmont whilo going fromipartmonts to tho sonato chambor last wool:, is much improved today. TTis physicians stated that ho probably will bo ablo to ienvo his room witujn a few days. AMENDMENTS AGAINST THE AMENDMENTS. (Ily J. S. Howard.) To tho Kditor; In Inst Thursday's papor you oritl clso a numlior of oUUoiui of tho find ward of our city bocuuso n yonr ng thoy snw fit to oxorolso tluiir porog ativo in tho phnpo of n protust ngivinst paving u portion of Central nvonuo, and you gnvo tho public to understand that for so daring to ex press nursulvas tho city council Iiuh punished us by iioglooting to install n to' intprovotnouU in thai portion of Modford hotweon tho railroad and Honr crook, ami you statu that said protectants aro sorry thnt thoy pro tested and intimate that "now will you ho good," Now, for goodncHrt' sake, don't nceii.no us of boing good wo don't proposo to ho very good; novor was vory good, and God novor made but ono good man, and his noluhliom amcifiod hhn, and thnt should ho n warning not to ho too good. Ottos thuro'tj n whole lot thnt aro in no danger. 'Now, tho truth is, wo considered our protest well taken, and hiiIiho quont oventfl havo proved so. Wo wore novor opposed to paving Cen tral nvonuo, hut at tho titna of our protest wo considered tho cost ex cessive, nnd now wo aro promised a reduction of from 20 to 30 per cent on tho cost of a year ago n margin certainly worth saving. Wo of tho first ward west of Bear crook fool that our interests havo boon sadly Deducted and that Mr. Morriok ns councilman for our ward hns fnilod to advnnco our interests ns he should havo done. This state merit is substantiated hy tho fact that n petition for n candidate in opposition to Mr. Merrick wtin signed by a majority of tho voters of tho first wnrd, hut wo regret to sny that tho "hunch" persuaded him that "his feet was cold," and ho rofusod to stand. Please understand, wo do not criticise Mr. "Merrick ns n citizen. I hcliovo ho is ono of our best, nnd wish wo had n lot moro liko .him. Hut wo hcliovo his judgment lias been nt fault in soma nmttors of public policy which might bo avoided by some now man. Tho fact that tho nets of tho wa ter committoo in roforcuco to Wns- son canyon wore turned down hy al most n unanimous vote of their fol low. citizens would suggest to men of modost pretensions the propriety of retiring for n while. Tho fact that tho blundering ten acity (to use u chnritablo phrase) with which they clung to tho Wnsson canyon scheme, ndvisrd hv a high priced schoolmaster, who was long on theories nnd short on practice, has cost tho city tunny thousands nt dollnrs of ncodlcss expense cor- tainly would suggest thnt tho public good would bo enhanced by thoir re tircmcnt. Now, I beg to call attention to nn .. , lift I I . ar UHlttor of which only Olio sidfl hns been presented tho charter amendments. Tho first amendment provides for. ... , . . . . , . ft lot of extra officials nnd instnlls a lot or ItlUtCini mnchtnorv ns OX pensivo nnd complicated as thnt of tl0 w,10,c of jckf,on oounty. This i . i Kni expense 1 entirely UtlllPCCHSnrj . and can only ho justified by thft sentiment that "tho offices nro on "rely i.adoo.mtc to the wants of the i people. Vote no on bnllot 401. Amendment No. 2 provides pnlary for , mnyor of $75 por month (COOd), and providos that tllO COIlll- oilmen shnll bo paid $H00 por yoar each. Now, why maintnin a council nt 1800 Por year when so manv are . , 1 . , non to run and sorvo for nothing " at prosont. EiKutoon hundred dollars would not buy tho whole bunch an ounco of brains. Voto no on amendmont No. 2. Amendment No. 3 rognlntcs the duties of tho treasurer. Tho prosont fully protects tho cityi and li0 nmondmcnt puts t in the power n n nmirnu nniiK 10 mnuipuinio lite funds. Votp no on ninoiidniont No. 3. , Amendment No. 4 is the most vie limn unit RiwiminimiM ni nn, nnu pro vidos thnt in tho mnttor of any pro posed streot improvement tho council rnnv ovorrn)o nnd set nnido nny pro lt order said improvements, regnrdloss of such protest. This would enable thn spocnlntor and tho rich to override tho workingmnn with his modost homo nnd virtually con fiscate his property by oxcessivo as sessments, which ho would bo unnbln to moot, and would doprivo him of nny voice in tho matter. Tho constitution of tho United States guarantees (hero shall ho nn taxation without representation, nnd this nmondmcnt would veto this pro vision. Whilo our prosdnt chartor mnkos iih supnrior to thn Stnto of Oregon, I don't think all of our char ter amendments can mako uh Btipor ior to tho U. R, A. Workingmon, d(fond yonr hoinoH and voto no on omnndmont No, , Yours for tho riirlit, k jBjiowAnn. poJtuBsoin OJOJS (UU! poo9 u OJU ojoiji pay '.iipo) aodud on,) tij oHub -Bom-ojojs oqOfJloo joti B,ojot(x f WHAT PAPERS SAY OF ' NEW STATE SISKIYOU Tho Yroloi Jouninl of Octobor 27 printed n laruo mnp or thn proponed now slato of HUltlyou, with Yrelm ns tho capital. It tnltps In tho countlca of Douglas, Coos, Otirry, Jackson, Josophluo, Klnmnth nnd Iako coun ties, OroRon: and Hoi Norto, Hum boldt, Trinity, Siskiyou, Modoc, Shas ta, Tolininn and Lassen coutitlos, Cal ifornia. Crencont City Record. Tho Yrekn Journal publishes a map of tho propoood now stnto of Siski you. This taken nearly half of Oro t;ou nnd runs as far south In Califor nia as thn northern boundaries of Mendocino, Glonti, lltttto and Plutnns counties, Of course Yroka la uonrly. In tho center of this nreu nnd that city will bo thn capital of tho now ntntn. Tho odttor of tho Journal hns a long head, Downlovlllo Messon Kor. It seems that tho people In tho northern part of tho stnto aro deter mined not to bo behind Ij Angeles and tho people In tho southern part of tho stnto In tho matter of state division. Tho Yrekn Journal of lnat week publishes n laruo nnd Impos ing looking map, comprising elKht or ten counties In tho southern ond of OroKon nnd about nn equal number of counties In tho northern nnd of California, which territory It Is pro poiod to bo formulated Into a now stato to bo called Btsklyou, with tho capital located nt Yroka. Wo hardly think tho nchomo can bo r.uecfinful, but If It should succeed, and If our southern brethren should succeed In cuttlnK.off a fow counties In tho southern ond of tho state, then thoro will be nothing loft of thn good old state ovcopt Amndor nnd n fow of Its neighboring counties, In which cano wo now placo Jackson in nomination ns tho futuro capital of what Is loft of tho old commonwealth. Jnckeon Dispatch. In southern Oregon many pooplo and mnny nownpnpors nro fooling unkindly towards Portland and tho Wlllamotto valley. Thoy aro. ro sontful hccauio tho Improvement of tho Crator Lako road was blocked nnd tho southorn Oregon normal school loft without funds ns wan like wise tho eastern Oregon normal school. Southorn Oregontnns would liko to form n now stnto nnd leavo "tho Bnlom hog and tho Portland pig to root undisturbed nmong tho pest lndon orchards, wallow In tho streaks of mtro called rends, drink Arhucklo coffee and road tho Oro Eonlnn." lint thn Oregnntnn only snoors at tho talk of n now state. It feels safo on thnt scoro bccatiso It Is difficult work forming now states. Vory woll. Uut tho pooplo of southern Oregon havo still nnothor recourse If they want to mnko ubo of It. Tho sure way to roach n hog Is through his stomach. If tho Medfordltos wish to mako tho Port land pig squonl nnd turn flip-flops Just begin planning n healthy nlzoii cnmmorclnl boycott upon tho Itoso city. Lot southern Oregon turn Its fnco towards 8nn Francisco for a tlmo nnd Portland will soon lonrn that tho narrow policy which many of Its pooplo would follow won't do. Or course this paper Is not advis ing tho pooplo of southern Oregon to boycott Portlnnd nt this tlmo. It would hnto to do that. It Is moroly pointing out a way to mako Portland tnko notlco If tho now stato talk doos not suf Ico. Oregon la a gront and growing stnto. I3astor:i Oregon nod southorn Oregon cnnstltuto about nlnn-tonths of tho aroa of this stato. It lu In theso soctlons thnt most of tho do volopmont Is now undor wny, This progress must not bo blacked by nar rowness and RplflBhnoss on tho part of Portland and tho Wlllamotto val loy. Portland should bo Jlbornl ond fair townrds all tho stato. It must not try to mako Bouthom Oregon and enstorn Oregon n moro bnclt yard for tho metropolis.. If t does tho poo plo of enstorn Orogon and southorn Oregon will hnvp to unlto In oolf do onso. Whon ithoy do thoy mny "stnrt something" that tho Portland hog won't rollsh. PondltfJon Enst Orogonlnn. STEPSON SHOOTS TO KILL; IS ArWESTED SAN FRANCISCO. Jan. 10T.onn. r.rd Smith, n motorman la tho om- ploy of tho United Itnllror.ds. linn in tho St. Francln hospital today with a novoro millet wound In hln back, tho allogod result of a dornosllo m.nrrni. Tho shot wnB fired hy Morrll Smith, tho victim's 18-year-old Btopson. According to tho story told hv young Smith, who did tho iilinnllnir his mother nnd iitopfnthor quarroloti ovor a row dollars which Mm. Rmin. rofusod to glvo hor husband. Tho dluptito ocourrod in Morrill's room boforo ho had rlson,