V. o/ o. Libr vz. Sumple Ballots For Recall Election Present Both Sides O f Controversy The story going the round* that there w ill be no business man l r Aahland who w ill dare ru n fo r ■■ . .. are recalled is *0 m uch eyewash. In tho fir s t place, w hy should a man be a businessman to run fo r n council seat. We can't re ­ m em ber having read that q u a lifi­ cation anyw here in the charter. In the second place, there «re m any q u a lifie d men, business- » “ ell Th. «íu ” , , o „ w hich w a . told Sample ballots fo r the recall fdm’tlr.n election Thursday, M arch 17 of C ity C ouncilm en J. P. D ougherty, H. B. Fischborn. and John Nosier were d istrib u te d th is week. In c o n fo rm ity w ith state regulations concerning recall elections the j sample ballots carried u 200 w ord statem ent from each o f the coun- elim en in defense o f th e ir noni- ' rom B etterm ent league givin g the reasons dem anding the re c a ll’ T iie C iv ic B etterm ent league stated th a t in the case o f a ll three councilm en that they In connec­ tio n w ith o th e f members of the C ity C ouncil, had fla g ra n tly de­ fied tiie wishes and w ill of the I people of the City of Ashland bv ' “ I!™1»«'"» »"<1 dem anding th a t the when we wore askod to sign the a n ti-ra c a ll p e titio n , ' that the a n ­ ti-re c a ll group was fo r the coun­ cilm an b u t desired a change in c ity a tto rn e y ” ha* a fla w In it. It's eyewash, too. The councilm an have indicated in w ritin g th a t no other attorney In Ashland is com petent and q u a lifie d to advise them on c ity procedures except W illia m Briggs j A re they going to change th e ir m ind* im m e d ia te ly another at- I torney is appointed to that posi­ tion? M“ y “ r W " l | am M Briggs as C ity A tto rn e y o f A sh­ land and Clarence W illia m s as C h ie f o f Police of said city. Said Councilm en, together w ith other members o f the C ouncil, have thereby attem pted to confer u p ­ on the council the pow er o f ap­ p o intm ent of C ity o ffic ia ls w hich is vested by the C ity C h a rte r of Aì hkdl d ‘I ’ t>W M a yo r- To th a t end said C ouncilm en together were allowed to h im d - u #• .. u u m i.i« n u ig e w e r w e r e auowed to h ire and fire at the tim e n .ir in » «1— - ..... w ith other members of the C oun­ pleasure, w ith no approval being the tim e. D u rin g the firs t tw o fuse appointm ents w hich is as i t T his dem onstrates cil, has refused to c o n firm any necessary fro m the people's re- m onths o f his term of office, the should be. m ayor has fa ile d to attend tw o the A m erican w ay o f life. It und a ll appointm ents to said o f­ b° d y ' t ?u n t‘ 1> regular, and fiv e adjourned meet- w ould have been the easy w ay fices other than those of the in ­ the c ity s governm ent could get cum bent o ffic ia ls aforesaid. Said in serious condition- u ltim a te ly lngs. The council has therefore out to have accepted the a p p o in t­ C ouncilm en, together w ith other leading to a dictatorship. The had to conduct the business of ments regardless o f the expense members o f the C ouncil, has tra in in g and experience neces- the c ity and p e rfo rm also those to the city. I believed then and w h ich w ould o rd in a rily thereby attem pted to deprive the sary and required of the fore- duties have been perform ed by the Ma s till do, th a t I acted to th* best interest o f the com m unity. M ayor M ayor o f his rig h ts and duties m ost appointm ents o f the c ity is under the C harter and to appro­ an expensive and slow process, yor. D u rin g the b rie f stays of the W illia m s recommended that some m a yo r in the c ity he has failed of the c ity jobs be given his sup­ p riate to the C ouncil the rig h ts and the taxpayers should not be to contact any of the c ity officers and duties vested In the M ayor.” burdened w ith that expense, to acquaint h im se lf w ith the de- porters. No doubt he fe lt he owed them som ething fo r p u ttin g him J. P. D augherty, said, In ju s ti­ sirn p jy because one man wants tc fica tio n o f his course In office-' exercise his granted power. H av­ ta ils of actions taken d u rin g his In office. I do not agree to g iv in g absence and thereby dem onstrat- p u b lic jobs as paym ent fo r p u b lic 'M y a ttitu d e in this controversy, in g been a councilm an fo r sever , . , , i ed a com plete lack o f Interest in office, especially under o ur pre­ and the p ositive action I have al yeais I know how the m ayor c ity affairs. U nder the circum - taken, has not been easy,— ra th e r and council m ust re ly on w o rth y, stances the council has been fo r- sent circumstances. Since the w ar the d iffic u lt and sometimes em ­ dependable departm ent he a d s tunate in having experienced de- we have been engaged In a bet­ term ent program w h ich has tak- barrassing side, leading to c r it i­ w ith experience and ju d g m e n t p a rtm e n t heads at Its side. None Jen m uch plannin g and m any cism and an undesirable s itu a ­ gained through years o f p e rfo r­ o f the im p lie d accusations o f in ­ meetings. The c ity is spending a tion. I s till stand fir m ly fo r the m ance.’ e fficie n cy or derelection of d u ty rig h t o f the council to protect the H. B. Fi chborn’s statem ent against the officers was proved large sum fo r im p ro v in g our w a t­ er system. We have purchased best interests of the citizens, and was a-- follows: “ I deny that the and 1 believe that they should re ­ m ore adequate equipm ent fo r the fu rth e r prom otion o f A s h ­ council, in d iv id u a lly or co lle ctive ­ m ain in o ffice fo r the good of the street im provem ents. The c ity land, and its best Interests. I ly have, at any tim e intended to c ity . I also jo in in the ju s tlfic a to n personnel has seasoned e xp e r­ have not been against any p a rti­ deprive the M ayor o f his rig h t given by m y fe llo w councilm en.” iences w hich to m y belief Is o f c u la r appointm ent, b u t I have and duties or have attem pted to John N osier made this state­ value to the c ity The new M a y ­ d e fin ite ly been fo r the continued appropriate these to themselves. m ent in defense o f his stand or and the tw o new C ouncilm en service of proven employees who However, when the m ayor took “ I recognize in the m ayor the should have support o f c ity em ­ have given of th e ir best in the o ffic e he indicated he w ould be rig h t o f appointm ent. I also rec ployees fa m ilia r w ith these new Interest o f Ashland. I f the M ayor o u t o f the c ity the greater p a rt of ognize thfc co u n cil’s rig h t to re -¡p ro je ct? nt this im p o rta n t tim e ” A l e n it i OREGON P lIllS M E R Judge M illa rd 's decision stated that tho council's attem pt to pas* an ordinance ho g -tyin g the M a y ­ or was in v a lid . T his ordinance was passod by the council in good fa ith and out of lo y a lty to C ity A tto rn e y W illia m B rigg* and tj.o o PER YEAR C hief of Police Clarence W ill­ iam * Formerly the Southern Oregon Miner PER IR T IO N NEWS REVIEW ASHLAND, JACKSON CO U N TY , THURSDAY, .MARCH 10, 1949 $3.00 per year V O L U M E 16, N U M B E R 1 L o y a lty i* a good tra it. B u t It has in this case p u t three coun­ cilm en out on a lim b . The tw o men responsible fo r the recall election of the three councilm en are W illia m B rigg* and Clarence W illia m *. Had those S M A L L F R Y STAG H A V E LUNCHEON THUR SD A Y tw o men follow ed norm al p o liti­ cal procedure January 1st and In g e n u ity was the keynote fo r placed th e ir resignations on the the hot dog luncheon given on Date fo r the Legion and A u x ­ de«k of the n e w ly elected m ayor Thursday, by Mrs. C liffo rd C u l- ilia r y b irth d a y p a rty has been this sad state of a ffa ir* w ould New directors of the Aahland m er, honoring her young son, Pat M arch 14 Judge O rv ille M illa rd , Josephine county c irc u it co u rt judge. W ed- Cham ber of Commerce w ill meet C ulm er, on his eig h th b irth d a y. in is p a rty w ill be in the nature nesday ru le d on the ju d g m e n t case b ro u g h t by the c ity council o f never have come about. Since a ll o f the guests had to AH of the council- we feel, are in the near fu tu re to elect a p re ­ of a covered dish d in n e r to be . A shland versus M ayor Tom W illia m s and the C ity of Ashland, responsible for haying brought sident and vice-president. B ill be in school T hursday afternoon served at 6:30 p.m. in the Log Judge M illa r d ’s decision stated th a t Rule 16A of O rdinance 1094 about this situation, out of loyal­ McGee, secretary o f the Chamber th e y »««errtbled at the C ulm er C abin Legion n a il on W in b u rn * W e h was passed by the co u n cil in Decem ber im m e d ia te ly prior ty to two men. holding appoint­ •aid today th a t the m eeting hom e at nin e o'clock fo r a m o rn ­ W ay. Celia Berninghausen w ill the rnay ° r ’8 ta k in g office, was in v a lid . The ru le had Stated that in g o f games and contests, topped be in charge o f arrangem ents fo r I the m ayor could not suspend any c ity o ffic ia l. ive offices. m ig h t be held M onday. Judge Millard's decision in d i­ New directors who w ere e le .t- o ff by a v e ry m asculine hot dog the party. According to the mayor** a t- cates that the council, acting on ed Tuesday at the annual m eet­ luncheon a t noon, served by C ar- A ll veterans and th e ir wives H O S P IT A L V O LU N T E E R tom eys, Ben L o m bard and H e r- advice from one of the men ing o f the C ham ber are: W a lt ita C ulm er and Marcene Robison. o r mothers, sisters and w idow s W O R KER S TO M E E T EZ S ke rry, this represents a great Guasts honoring young Culmer o f veterans are in v ite d to attend. whose political appointive Job Bosshard, B ert M ille r, Abe Nes- T h e dat es set fo r the V o lu n te e r v ic to ry fo r the people o f the city was under fire, attempted to rail- lin , L y n N ew bry, Chet T h o m p ­ were M ike Moaer, Johnny Culp, Each fa m ily is asked to brin g hosP‘ ta l w orkers school at Camp o f A shland and M a y o r T om Loren Macklin, Denny Robison, covered dish o r o th e r food in suf- W h ite have been set fo r 7:30 p. liam*. Judge M illard also indi­ roa