Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The skanner. (Portland, Or.) 1975-2014 | View Entire Issue (Sept. 18, 2024)
Page 4 The Skanner Portland & Seattle September 18, 2024 Opinion No Cheek Left to Turn: Standing Up For Albina Head Start and the Low-Income Families it Serves is the Only Option Ronnie Herndon Albina Head Start In America today, children have the high- est official poverty rate compared to any other age group. Over 16% of our nation’s young peo- ple live below the feder- al poverty line, and in many parts of Portland the rate is even higher. In east Portland, one out of every four children is in poverty. The good news is that our country’s leaders created programs to help, and I’m proud to say I’ve dedicated most of my life to one of them: the federal Head Start Pro- gram. Since 1975 when I was first named director of Albina Head Start, I’ve had the privilege of serv- ing our community by providing educational opportunities for low-in- come Pre-K students and watching the program flourish. Today, our pro- gram is regarded as one of the top Head Starts in the country, serving nearly 1,000 families, employing a staff of over 300, and implementing innovative curriculum like our Mandarin dual language program, the first of its kind national- ly. For some of our fam- ilies, our program goes far beyond offering ear- ly learning and literacy. We also provide crucial health screenings, fami- ly support, and address children’s nutrition- al needs by providing breakfast, lunch and an afternoon snack. The results are com- pelling. Children who participate in Head Start are more likely to finish high school, more likely to go to college, and more likely to graduate from college. But there’s also bad news. This month, Albina filed a federal lawsuit against the U.S. Depart- ment of Health and Hu- man Services (HHS) to defend itself against a misapplied rule that could force the program – and all the children it serves – to lose federal funding. The issue boils down to a simple misinterpreta- tion. In 2007, under the federal Head Start Act’s reauthorization, Con- gress directed HHS to force programs with sys- temwide problems to rec- ompete for their fund- ing. Congress designated the term “deficient” to characterize such pro- grams with systemic is- sues. And it makes sense because any Head Start that is systemically “de- ficient” in carrying out the program’s overall mission should require a course correction. But in Albina’s case, our program was un- fairly deemed “deficient” not due to a systemwide problem, but a single incident of an employee breaking our rules – an anomaly in our other- wise clean, nearly 60- year track record. In 2023, a teacher as- sistant threw a toy block at a student’s leg, acting completely outside the scope of their employ- ment, contrary to their many hours of training, and contrary to our poli- cies and procedures. We reviewed the incident, confronted the employee and terminated their em- ployment within three hours of the incident, then reported the inci- dent to state authorities, the student’s parent and HHS all within 24 hours. Incidents like these un- fortunately happen in every sphere of society, no matter the precau- tions taken by an organi- zation. Our actions perfectly followed the require- ments of Head Start reg- ulations on personnel matters, but HHS still incorrectly determined that the isolated incident should result in a “defi- ciency” finding against Albina as an entire or- ganization. Congress expressly intended to prevent this use of “defi- ciency,” even indicating that it impedes the great- er mission of Head Start because “recompetition of high quality programs could have the unintend- ed effect of undermining program quality and de- creasing the efficiency of Head Start expendi- tures.” While our funding is at risk, this lawsuit is more than just dollars and cents. It’s about people. It’s about the futures of our students. It’s about the morale of our teach- ers and staff, who ask me if they’re going to be able to pay their bills. It’s about our marginal- ized communities that are barely surviving. And it’s about the other Head Start programs that might also be affected by unfair “deficiency” find- ings but lack the resourc- es to push back. Accord- ing to HHS, roughly half of all “deficiency” find- ings result from isolated incidents like the one at Albina, not systemic fail- ures of a Head Start pro- gram. The decision to take the federal government to court was not easy. Some may believe if someone “strikes you on the cheek, offer the other also.” But when I walk our halls, listen to our families, hear their stories, and look them in the eyes, I know that they have no cheek left to turn. Correcting the problem at HHS should be easy and common sense. Un- fortunately, the Office of Head Start is not serv- ing the true mission of Head Start as Congress intended. Paradoxically, the current miscarriage of HHS policy, which was crafted to address sys- temic problems, has cre- ated a systemic problem within the department that threatens high-per- forming Head Start pro- grams. We implore the court to fix this.