V THE WEATHER Portland aad Vielalty--Ssa,ay fair aad eostlaaed coldi eaaterry winds. .: Onto, aad Wssalagtoa, Saaday bow wet swrtlen, fair east portion Moderate aertkeaaterly trlada. r ' : CHRISTMAS 7: A poena y Stary Carolyn Davles aad ' msstrated by Hwar4 Fisher wnl tea tar fae frost cover of The Saaday Joarsal -Zuagasiae aext Saaday. ... - PORTLAND, i OREdON, SUNDAY MORNING, DECEMBER 17, 1923. NINE SECTIONS PRICE ' FIVE CENTS VOL. XIX. 'NO.. 39. CITY EDITION EMENCH DEMAND S HELED GERMANY Santa Claus TIES DRIVER. Huge Debt Ovefloadedi Is Burden On Orego n ; iimbossmle:. foe. With Gifts . . , ..... v 7 Heaviest-Buying in History of City Reported r.Shop JEarly, or You May Be Disappointed. State and Its Subdivisions Owe 25 Per Cent brjheir As- . sessed Valuation. WARSAW 18 IRlrS TAKES TAXI, READY TO lot U.S. Berlin Said to Be Anxious to Put Cards on Table With Other Nations, Hoping to Get Aid. "Germans Seek Loan From Amer ican Bankers, but Credit Must Be., Established Beforehand. Washingtpn, Dec. .16. (U. P.)- Germany, as part of the great in ternational negotiations now in 'progress looking; toward American intervention in Europe, is placing- her cards on the table before the United States. - Otherftations are expected to do "likewise, and from these negotia tions, conferences with, the leaders of the senate and administration leaders, consultations with Ambas sador George Harvey,- and discus- sions with prominent Americans, President Harding and Secretary of State Hughes will evolve their plan for preventing an economic crash in Hurope. The American plan, upon which ' Europe is pin ning high hopes for its salvation, probably cannot be announced un til early in January. WANTS U. S. AID In negotiations now under way here. Secretary of State Hughes Iras called upon German Ambassa dor WJedfeldt for a. statement as to justhow Germany' can be relied upon to pay a just indemnity, in the event America intervenes. In reply, Germany, in addition to placing her plight, in detail before this g-qvernmenV has inquired as to what extent she can expect the help :t,tbs.Jnited States if she makes a supreme and sincere effort to pay Off the reparations obligations for the responsibility of the war. Germany, like all the other na tions of Europe, wants the aid of the United States in any way it can be possibly offered. She would be glad ' to get effectively the moral support of this country in another effort to settle the reparations ques tion. , FAVORS CONFERENCE She also would heartily welcome an economic 'conference in Wash ington to bring about a solution of the problem, it was learned offi cially. Shte desires a loan from American bankers, but realizes her -credit must be established through a political settlement of the repara tions question before this is possl- ble. . -. Negotiations In the American move that has aroused the , hopes of the worm to a Higher pitch than at an? time since the armistice are progress ing rapidly, but officials warned today . that definite results cannot be expected . at too early -a date. - This government is moving cautious ly in Its effort to find a practical way in which ft can aid in solving Eu- ( Concluded ob Pate 8iiteen. Column Three.) Woman Will Head Department of New York State (Br Cnrrersal' Serrice) New Yorki Pec. 16. Women were re Joicing here today over, a statement said to have been made by Governor elect Alfred E. Smith that he would ap point one of their number as head of a state department oh assuming office at Albany, January 1. Waste Wood 4 University fOregon, Kugene, Dec, 16. After several "years work on a problem of compelling interest and im portance' to tbe lumber industry and other enterprises in tbe Pacific North west and elsewhere, ; Professor O. F. Stafford, head of the University of Oregots chemistry department, has per fected a process for utilising - waste wood t to - obtain a superior grade of charcoal and wood distillation products used In a number of basic industries. - The announcement Of Professor Staf ford's success was made here today The work Is regarded as one of the most 'outstanding contributions : to" sci ence yet made by. a University of Ore gon man. Heretofore it has not been commercially practicable to utilise mill waste; in the carbonization and wood distillation industries. PROCESS YAI.U ABLE , ; . ' Because of the great amount of cheap waste wood material available, in the Northwest, it is the judgment of those .familiar with the Stafford process that with the growth of Northwest Indus - - Oregon Chem "Radio 'a dispatch to Santa Claus and tell him- to bring along an extra sleigh this year, Portland merchants advised Saturday afternoon.' Portland people have been buying so many pres ents during the last few days that merchants don't see bow Santa pos sibly can pile them all into one ve hicle. He'll need a trailer, at least, they say. or hundreds of Portland boys and girls won't get their presents next Sunday night. Never before in the history of Port land has pre-Christmas buying been so heavy, not even in the palmy war days, when wages were high, the mer chants : declared. Specialty men find the public very discriminating In their buying this season, carefully, examin ing every article and making sure it is the very best. "Department store managers, on the other hand, report liberal sales in all lines, one manager expressing htmself thus : "They're buying anything and everything, both useful and ornamental gifts." After the snow storm and cold weather of Wednesday and Thursday, the clerks "caught it" Friday after noon and all day Saturday. Following Saturday's rush, which several stores found to be the heaviest in their his tory, store managers began devising plans to take care of "the unprecedented trade anticipated this week. Every manager interviewed made an emPhatie appeal to the people to (Concluded on Page Nineteen, Column Poor) News Index Cditerial Section 2. Pas i Foreign U. S. Intervene to Sam Greek Section 1, Tat, 2. Former lira, Lseos Retaminc to XT. 3. Sec tion 1, Pase-0. PrincwM Flora : Obtains DiTorce Section 1, , Pan i. s National McArthur Wins in Debate Section 1, Page 2. Republicans Without : ... Leader Section I , Pao 4. : GoTernment to Present - Striken Section 1, Paw 15. Haidinc HeceiTee Resignation of Supreme Justice -Section J, Pass 19. ' Pom e . COO Reacued from Barnlnf Ship Section 1. Pace 2. 4 Herria "Massacre" Section 1,-rese 4. -.. Gorwnace Onit Mectinc Secdes 1. Pas Is. Notorioua M oonaniBer Cana-ht SeuUoa 1. -Pa lt. . Northwest . CniTetaitiac Keaeitt wei SeeUon 1, Vite 8. Bank to Pay 140, 000 Section 1, Pas 8. Pleaa for Paroles and Paidoni Section 1, Pate 16. ? -;.; ;; - Williams la CodtIc ted Section i Pe 18-; PorUan - Colonel Koble Itetire Section lPeae, 3. Man Accused of JTraad Seeti6i 1, Pace 4.1 Two Persons Hurt Section 1, Pass . Two Mors Autos Seised Section l, Pco 6. Bank Clerk Diiappears Sction 1,. Paae ii. Hindoo Popcorn Vendor Indicted Section 1. Pas 14. Suspect NabbedTwice Section 1, Page IS. ' Business News Real EsUte and Bnildihs -Section 3,Pan 1. Market. Section 2. Paie 7. Knanoe Section, 2, Pace . atarlna Section S, Pace 3. Radio News Today's Radio r roe ram Section 4. Pae It. Sunday Radio Department Section 4, Pace 11. m Netfhfcorftood News Section 4. Pas 10. Amntaments Section 5, Paces 1-8. ; AvtomotlTS Section . Pases 1-S. 8 perU Section 7. Paces 1-7, Oa. the riner Siee Th Week in .Society Section 4. Pun hi. Women's One Affairs Section 4. Pace S. amerieaa .Veterans Section 4, Pate 11. The Realm of Music Section 5. Pate 4. FraUrnal Section 4. Paces t; 12. In Portland Schools Section 5. Pace 5. Case of Baby Section 4."- Pace 6. Bora and Girls .Section 5. Face 5. Features "The, Peace." by Jtay Stannard Ba Seo- r tion 2. Pace 1. -News in Picture Section 6. Pace 8. Tews. Hall Gossip Section 4, Pace 9 R;nc Lartner's Letter Section 4. - Page 9. National Capital Section 2.. Pace 2. Letters From th People Section 4, Pace 7. National Guard -Section 4. Pace 9. "Less Setdnc sad More Steppinc." by Tay Kmc Section 4, Pace . Antnoc and Publisher Section 4, Pate 9.; : Kliine Frontirr Menace, by Dsmd Uoyd Geone Section 1, Pace 1. Mafssine Section 8. Paces ' Cetntca , Section 9. Paces X-i.' :: I- ist Succeeds Is Carbonized tries and the development of foreigr. markets, a wood carbonization industry of considerable magnitude will be justi fied. . i,- . - Professor Stafford first demonstratec his process scientifically. The unU versity campus was the scene -of the early experiments. He and the firm of engineers behind him have now suc ceeded . after several years . labor, lis demonstrating' It as a practical com mercial process. Two wood- distilla tion plants on 'the Atlantic coast, -one of them controlled by a bir corporation 'jplaced every resource at Professor Staf- ford'a disposal and the success of - th process was completely demonstrated By the Stafford process a fine gradt of charcoal can be obtained as well a the usual by-products of carbonisation' acetic acid. ; acetone and wood alcohof basic in the manufacture of sucl articles as dy, taints, varnishes, cellu loid, smokeless powder and artiflcia leather. A considerable amount I charcoal is used, in the chemical -in (OoBclwiad as Pace Si Offlama Tv.) Daring; Holdup' Is Perpetrated atEast ' 11th and Broadway in - Early Period of Evening After Crtmer Bandit Tours East Side Area With Driver Se curely Bound, on Rear Floor. After engaging a taxicab driver ' to take him to the east side district, r op ine the driver's hands and feet and then taking the car and driving around to inspect the district, a bandit about 7:30 o'clock Saturday night pulled on a hold-up of the filling station at East 11th and Broadway. Harry Lee, was the .first vietim. Lee has his taxicab stand at Broadway and Stark, and the man appeared there about 1 :30 o dock Saturday axternoon and -engaged him to take him to the east side. He said he wanted to look over the district generally. Re directed Lee to take him to East 73d and GUsan streets, where there is a neighborhood grocery owned by John Shriner. Mr., and Mrs. Shriner were both in the store, and It is be lieved the presence of the woman caused the -bandit to forego plans tov a holdup there. Ho simply purchased some wrapping paper and then re turned to the auto. . COVERS HIM WITH GUI After the drive, was resumed he di rected Lee to take , him to the Benson polytechnic school, giving' the Impres sion that he was to meet someone there, but he did not leave the car and ordered Lee to proceed until he reached 12th and Wasco streets. Then he cov ered Lee with a gun, made him getl into the back of the car and opened a bundle of rope, with which he tied Lee's hands and feet and threw him on the floor of the car. The bandit then took the car and drove around until about 4 :30 o clock. Lee -says , he occasionally could get K-Hmsses of the taller buildings and that it seemed, the man was making a circle of the lower1 Irvington- district. Flsally the man j leaned over and, keeping. Lee J covered with Ms, gun. said be would release Lee If he would promise not ..to v report : the 'affair ; to the police. Lee promised, ana tne man left the ar, taking with, him the long roll of wrapping paper he had obtained at tu : ..grocery Vi ,: .r .-.i, Wwis jr ft ' - Lee- told the police or the strange proceeding as soon as he could reach the central eta tion, and officers were sent out on the hunt Lee gave" a good description of the -roan. ; ; He was wfell dressed, but of weather beaten appearance, had a florid -com plexion and reddish hair and was freckled. - There was a large Bpot - or scar on bis left cheek. The man was about S feet . 7 inches - tali. weighed about 140 pounds' and, was from 80 to 3a years oia. tie. spoe gooa , emgnsn. The holdup at the- filling station was by "a man who closely fitted this de scription. ;The police were notified immediately, and spread out in this field to seek the basdtt. Former Goyernor of Wisconsin ' Is Dead Madison. Wis.. Decl. lRjiTJ. p.) James O. Davidson, 8. former gov ernor of Wisconsin, died here today after an illness of several months. WILL THE BIRD ROUSE ITSELF? . ' . - . . - , ... 1 The -debt of Oregon and the political subdiVisona thereof, secured and unse cured.- is approximately 25 per cent of the assessed valuation of the state. w between, (20.000.0r and S300.O0o.000 according . tot the -partially completed investigations of the committee author iced by the last legislature - to "take a trial balance" of the state's finances. Completed figures may boost the total closer to $400,000,000 than to S300.000. 000. . - This stupendous total of public obli gations that , will have' to be retired or refunded within the not very dis tant future springs from the underly ing bond Issues of the general state government and runs the gamut of all sorts aad classifications of municipal promises to pay. 'And expert and painstaking examina tion into these various forms of indebt edness discloses the fact that they have been incurred promiscuously and without- thoughtful regard ' for other axnd prior obligations, mounting principal, burden of interest and comparative time of redemption. -Figures compiled from only 114 of the political units of the ' state dis close that within that radius there ex ists a deficit in sound sinking fund re quirements for the retirement of out standing debts of approximately 310.- 000,000. In other words, within these 114 units of the government there are outstanding . as direct obligations against the property of the units an aggregate bonded debt that would der mand. . under sound . financing pro- Concluded oa Pace Elshteea. Column Two) Toledo Accepts $4000 Offer for Corvallis Game . Scott jhigh . school of Toledo, Ohio, claimants : of the national scholastic gridiron championship, has accepted an offer to play the Corvalis high school eleven at Corvallis New Year's day. This will be the only game the Ohioans will play on their trip to the Pacific coast. . y: ' The following message wai received by W. P. McMasters,; principal Of the Corvallis high school. Saturday night : -"Scott accepts your offer of 14000 for only game on Facine coast few Years day. Officials must be acceptable to botlr "CachoolB and " Bat submitted 1 by Monday. The ;messagBt.. was sent' by Fred L. Selberts, manager of the Scott team. - .-,:.-.,vTy -v--;" Washington high school of .Portland, Medford high school and Aberdeen. Wash, sought games with the eastern champions. ! Business-men of Corvallis raised the 14000 guarantee in less than two hours, according to a long distance call, from Corvallis Saturday night. Lloyd George Is To Delay Memoirs Till Next Summer London, Dec. 16. Publication of Lloyd George's memoirs has been post poned. - ' ; The Intention of the former British premier is to make his book more com prehensive and devote considerable space to the sociological and industrial aspect both at home and on the battle front. Lloyd George expects to com plete his- work by the end of next sum mer." ' - , . . City Tense After M aniac Assas sinates President Narutbwicz, Who Had Ruled Only 5 Days. Successor to Be Elected Decem ber 20; Slain Leader Lies in State; Nation, Pays Tribute. Warsaw, Dec. 16. (U. P.) Troops enforcing martial law patrolled War saw tonight, following the assassina tion today of President Gabriel Na rutowicz, ruler of Poland for five days. The city, ' at? first stunned by the shooting down of the executive with out warning by a maniac - at an art exhlsition, reacted ' with excitement. and a wave of angry feeling swept throughout the nation. Immediately after the assassination Former President Pilsukski assumed charge of the cabinet, which Issued the martial law edict, to checkmate a threatened iiareup of vengeance against the followers of the "Lefts" or radicals. The cabinet fixed ' December 20 as the date for an e'ection to name Na- rutowics's successor. In the mean' time Maciej Rataj, speaker of the house of deputies, will act. The body of Narutowici was solemn ly carried to Belvedere, the official home of the executive, and is lying m state there. The catalafaque Is surmounted. by tne polish eagle. Great crowds murmured in protest at the killing of the man who ruled so shortly through such stormy scenes, Women and men stood with bowed heads as the sentries uhuff-shuffed back and forth, bayonets fixed, should the ruler's former antagonists in the crowd .start a disturbance. Narutowicz . is the flnet -.ruler, king or president in ail ioush history to oe assassinated. 5EWS TTPSETS PADEAEWSKI A3TD HE AJICELS DiySXB. By t?nlTeraal"8erirjce v. ' New York, Dec -v .rlghac h, Jan Paderewski, former premier of Poland, was so upset by news of the assassina tion of Poland's president that he cao celedi a dinner he was to; have given this eveolnjr fct the hotel Gotham to -20 friends. Including; Prince' and 'Princess KadiiwUL -iv:. r. . . ; ; Mme Paderewski informed him of the tragedy, but not until after he had completed his caneert at Carnegie hall. He said to reporters: "Had 1 known this news -1 would have canceled the concert. Please ex press my absolute condemnation and regret of the atrocious misdeed. This is the first r time in all of Poland's history that a ruler has been assassi nated. 0 . "I did not know the president per sonally. I will not comment on the political effect likely to result." FASCISM ABE BLAMED FOB 2f ARTJTOWICZ ASgASSIXATIOT By Karl H. Von Wlegaad UniTersal Serrlce Staff Correcpondent Berlin, Dec 16. The assassination In Warsaw today of Gabriel Narutowlcx, newly Installed president of the repub lic of Poland, is attributed to the im mediate results of the intense agita tion Of the Polish 'fascist! movement. Xarutowicz. who until la&t week was foreign minister, was an announced foe of - the t ascisti, whose propaganda has spread "rapidly. . . 'j . Lloyd George Reiterates Warning Against . , : Militaristic Bloc in France - THE breakdown of the London conference, and especially the rea son for that breakdown, proves that the warning- I uttered In my last article was necessary and timely. . M. Poincare demanded occupation of the only rich coal, field left: to Germany, as the gnarr antee for the carrying out of Impossible terms. - f' - : The mere fact that "there are potent, influences in France : that still press the demand (for the left bank of tjxe Rhtoe) and take advantage of every disappointment to utge It forward, calls for un remitting vigilance amongst all peoples -who have the welfare . pf humanity at heart. ' ' To- preserve French friendships I have irepeatedly given way to French demands and thus often have antagonized opinion in this country. But I cannot go to the extent of approving a policy which is endangering the "peace of the world, even to please one section , of a people for whose country I have always entertained most genuine admiration. , ; S I ' '-:::' - , v. I am told these proposals (for detachment of Rhine left province from Germany) did not mean annexation, Then what else did they mean? You doj not swallow the oyster. - You only first give it? an independent existence, by detaching it from his hard surroundings. You then, surround it on all sides and absorb it Into your qwn sys tem to equip you with added strength to prey on other oysters. --', - Lloyd answers Poincare's denials by quoting Foch, Tardieu and other French authorities, who maintained that the Rhine was the natural barrier between France and Germany and hiat it must be held as the eastern frontier of France. . ASTORIA BILL IS i Action Pends Until Perhaps Monday, When War Secre tary Sends in Survey. " Washington, Dec 16. I WASHING TON BUREAU OF THE JOURNAL) Senator McNary'a - resolution pro viding relief for Astoria, passed by tbe senate early today, will rest ' on the speaker's -table in the house un til a report comes In from the secre tary of war on conditions and, needs In the stricken city. : - Representative Hawtey, 'author 1 of another; resolution on the house side, expresses hope that the report . from the war department" will afford a ba sis tor mere comprehensive assistance than., would be authorised by tbe -Mo-Nary .""resolution. . He explained that he especially has in mind the matter of housing, which he believes may be se cured under his resolution, but not under the one passed by the senate. ; Hawley expressed the opinion that as tomorrow will be Sunday no time will actually be lost In awaiting the report from official channels, which would be available by Monday, and it can then (he decided whether more can be "ac complished by rushing through the Mo Nary resolution or toy seeking . action through house application expenditures for housing and other emergency needs as well as for issue of supplies from the quartermaster- stores. ; - McNary says he will welcome , the broadening of the resolution if that can be accomplished. He acted to ( Concluded ea Page Nineteen, Column Foot) Welch Promoted To Be Northwest Guard Commander . Salem, Dec 18. Promotion Of Major Hiram . U. .Welch, Portland, to the grade of lieutenant colonel in the Ore gon National Guard, was announced in orders issued here this afternoon by Adjutant General White. .The promo tion of Welch, the adjutant general ex plains. Is based upon an election held by the field officers and . captains of the 186th Oregon infantry regiment Lieutenant Colonel Welch will assume command of the regiment, which is lo cated in Oregon and Washington, the commanding officer. of the regiment be ing allotted to Oregon by the wardet nartment. - ' Lieutenant Colonel Welch has served for 28 years in the Oregon guard, be ing for a number of years in command of Battery A, Oregon's oldest military organisation. He served as an officer in the' Spanish-American 'war and 'as a major of field artillery in the World war.--Welch is assessor ef Multnomah county. . : Walla Walla -Fire Takes Life of Mrs. Magdalene Walsh Walla '.Walla, i Wash, Dec. '16. A woman about 50 years old, said to be Mrs. Magdalene Walsh, was burned' to death here tonight when a' fire broke out. about 10 o'clock and partially de stroyed the Walsh,, home on Alder street. .. .--1 ' K The origin of the blase has not at yet been determined by the local fire department. The ' flames were well under way when the fire flghterar rived on the scene and .it was some minutes- before ths firemen could' ex tricate .the badly charred body of tbe woman from: that, burning structure. Firemen, said she probably suffocated from tne smoke before the nre reaches her. -v't- 'Z,--r. "2 Famqu8-C6iitraltb J Will Be Out Soon Garden City. N. Ti'Dec U. P.) lime. Kmetine - Schumann-Heink. famous- singer who has been 111 at her borne here with pneumonia, will' be out and able to sing shortly, her physicians TO AV An REPORT announced torusnt. - COLDEST WEATHER PREDICTED TODAY Minimum Temperature of 17 Is Forecast; Spell Likely to Remain Indefinitely. 1 The coldest weather .of the present period was expected' to descend upon Portland this - morning, according jto a forecast issued late Saturday, night by the district, weather . office. . A minimum temperature of 17 degrees was predicted, , , - . . By- 7 o'clock' Saturday night, He mercury had dropped to 20 - degrees the same .low level reached Saturday morning at T o'clock. . Tteports received Saturday afternoon indicated that the. cold weather, is due to remain in Western Oregon tot an Indefinite'' period. - The ' Only rise In temperature was reported along -the coast,, where snow was expected, to fall today. ' The snow Is expected only along the sea line and te not expected to extend Inland to Portland. -: ; ' 'Cold weather struck Medford Satur day.. This - city,, had been about the only one to report temperatures above freezing in Oregon during ' the last two. weeks. The temperature at this place was 30 degrees late . Saturday afternoon. Ice has grown thicker and harder on Laurelhurst lake. Guilds lake and the- sloughs near Portland and many skaters were expected to visit these' spots today; Heavier., ice floes ' were reported lrr the Columbia river Saturday than, at any time during the last week. : At The Dalles and Umatilla, reports said, people were able to cross the river on the ice. - . V' ' ' OFE3F" TO COl73rTt XIKE The Columbia river highway if open as far as the eastern line of-Mult nomah county, most Of the Way with double track space. Jf there , is ; no more snow- fall, double track width will be cleared out for the entire length. This was the report brought back to Portland Saturday . night by H. B. Chapman, assistant county roadmaster, after a. trip over the highway as far as Warrendale, about, two 'miles west of Bonneville. He was accompanied by e?red W. Vogier- and Fred Young, Fierce - winds, prevailed all the way, said Chapman. - ; Between Warrendale and Bonneville trucks without skidchalns encountered difficulty in making the , grades, one turning almost In a circle. Seeing this situation. Chapman and his party -did not attempt to go , farther. . THBE GAKGS AT WORK The county has three iangs work ing on clearing the .highway. About SO men are on -thia work and will, be kept at it. unless further storms de velop,1 until a double-track 'space is cleared to the county line,' In the vi cinity bf Boaneville the snow is about IS . Inches deep.' Chapman encountered the first; . deep, snow - at Mist falls, and from' there to Multnomah falls H is about 10 inches deep. At the Oneonta gorge it began ' to get deeper. From Portland ' to Multnomah falls two tracks are cleared out, with the excep tions, of a few spaces- where there are turnouts, 'v-" ' a . ' One four-wheel drive ' tractor, : with (Conelndgd en Pae Eighteen, Columa Three! . . Mystery and Thrills - andtBlerity of Both A: In a new fiction serial ; - ' " i :' r s'The Rayner-Slade Amalgamation' , , ; ByS. B. Fletcher - A chapter a dty v (Drt?joiirournaL Beginning ,Tuesday Lloyd George Charges .That French Militaristic Bloc fn- sists Upon Impossible Terms. Occupation; of . Left -V Bank, of Rhine by France ' Declared Dangerous to World Peace. '" ' ' "" '"::"'k ' By Right Honorable David Lloyd George, O. M., M. P. -' - Farmer Britlah Premier (CopyrUbt, 1022 by Cnitod Featar Sjadi- cato. ) . . i i" (Conrdsbt ttt Oreat Brltaia by the Londoa , j, . . ChronieU.) .... .... (Ezclusive world rlfhta held by t'nlud Ftatura ' . gyndicaw.) fieprodnction In Whole or in Fart PiebibitMd. London, Deo. 1. - The break down of the London conference, and especially tor the;reaesoni for that . breakdown. jroves that the ir.&rninr I ut-. ;ered in my last irticle q was nec 3sary and time ly." M. Folncare lemanded . occu pation of the only rich coal f I e 1 d left to Germany ta tbe guarantee Cor' th" carrying ftutof impossible caifs 1 .- tilni i ppofdUndty , convince! thdt the policy represented by this project will lead to trouble at the gravest kind, for i Europe and for the" world that I f ejt . moved . to sound1 a note of warninr ' I-knew it';.! mis representation, r I am accustomed to that. IJ.defemed it to be my duty" to face , it. ' k ' ; ",; U; The' statement I made. In my last article about the existence of a strong party in Prance which re garded the Rhine as a natural bar- rler- of that country has provoked . a storm of denial, repudiation and ' indignation. - It Is denounced aS a wicked invention: some are amazed at the impudence of the calumny. Where is the party ? ; France knows nothing of it. 'Is it' pot a monster which .: has emanated . f refm"', the . brain of, the enemy o France T-i, , nEFcblATIO, WELCOME . ' -", RepHdiatipns hava their, value, especially If they come from 'then of authority, and jr. shall bear In vective with, the fortitude which all men who wish to be happy though ' polKicians should be hardened to,' provided I elicit' denials which may render ! future "international . mis- ' chief difficult, .. . , ; ' V . But a further perusal of evidence on which I based my statement has served to deepen my apprehensions. What was the statement? Let me. quote the - actual words I used, "There' was a strong party iin, France ! Which urged Clemenceau to demand "that the. Rhine; should be treated as a natural - frontier ; of their country, and that advantage should be taken of the overwhelm ing defeat of Germany ' to extend the boundaries of France ' to - that fateful ' rivers. - The most moderate and insidious , form' this demand took was a' proposal that the Ger manprovlnces on the left bank of the Rhine.should remain in French occupation until : the treaty had been fulfilled.: That meant for ever. . Reparations alone, skillfully handled.by the Qual d'Orsay. would preclude the possibility of ever wit nessing fulfilment' ' The pact was designed to strengthen the' hands of if. Clemenceau against the ag-' gressive party .'which was then and still Is, anxious to commit France to the colossar. error of annexing territory .:whch. has always ? been . purely German." v - . ' ' ; '; ' THE BBJtXE FKOBLEM .,; , What was the basis ion which I made - tWs ' assertion? 'It was thor oughly, well known to all those who were engaged in the operations of the Peace conference. The Rhine was the background of all maneuvers for week and : monthaVv """nether the ' subject, matter was the league of Nations, the German fleet, or the status of Flume, we knew that the. real struggle weuld ' come over the , Rhine. U: On the . one (Concluded oa Jg Twelve, Column Osa)