Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The Oregon daily journal. (Portland, Or.) 1902-1972 | View Entire Issue (Oct. 11, 1914)
c A- THE OREGON SUNDAY JOURNAL, PORTLAND, SUNDAY MORNING, OCTOBER 11, 1914. f5- SOME PROBA WAR ECONOMIC n if- if. EFFECTS OF THE ISLE IH' HI WW !!' 'J" .-J-ir-k-JL. -1 U-UjI'J I- " i' ' '--.JU-IJ J - - ... By Professor Irving Fisher, Yale University. WHE the future bisterlatr cfmwrle the ' facts of the present great world struwgle sndf attempt to analye Itt eirmfes am effects -the econoittTo losses, gains, ttftfs and1 dislocations will firm an Important part of the story. It !, of course, ftulte Impossible at this time to know. In any detail, what alt tne economic results, will be. Much Will depend en how long the war lasts, Ttew many people and how mucn prop erty are destroyed, what financial de Vices are resorted to In order to fi nance It and which side Is finally vic torious. the most palpable and the most fundamental effects will be a partial stoppage Of earnings in the nations Arectly concerned 1. e., a reduction in the "teal income" which consists ef Aijoyeble goods. All the otner im portant results follow from this. . "The cost, however reckoned, la sure' to be etupendeous. Prof. Rlchet la quoted as reasoning It at 160,000,000 Hay. this Is probably more than fta.it the tolai Income of all the Inhabi tants of thfe warring countries The hrgbest astlmates of the total .ncome f ihe United Kingdom, France and Germany, estimates of Bowley, 1a vetge and Bucher respectively, total MP less than J70.000.000 a day. Prof. Irving Shall Fisher, Be the of Yale, Says If We; Keep Only Great Nation Whose Our Heads We Economic Relations Have Not Even Been Strained. RiMtsla hftd Austria are poor coun tries pet capita, and would scarcely -trrtng th grand total to $100,000,000 ay. Moreover, the loss of cal ln oome to Europe Is, I Imagine, In re ality, much greater than Rlchet's es timate, chiefly because he takes little count of the indirect costs, which nay well be the greatest of all. The ot tp th fiscal departments of gov ernment lprobably only a small part vt the total t t which the people will have to bear. The killing and dis abling of the men engaged will cut off tbe financial support of European fam ilies to the tune of hundreds 't mil lions of dollars per year. The physical destruction of capital through- the de .vwtatlo of crop, the burning and demolishing of merchant ship and building, the crippling of Industry through the audden withdrawal of la bor, raw materials, the Introduction of new trade riaks, and the butting off of transportation, both internal and foreign, make, up a sum of items which cannot be measured but which may sceed those which can. Last, but not least, ia the impairment of that ub tle but vital basis of bustnes com mercial Credit. In short, the central effect la a vast impairment of Europe's current in come and of the capital from which her future Income will flow. It means a veritable Impoverishment of vast populations. The great burden will bear heaviest, of cdurse, on the poor. It will impinge very unequally and will cause a great redistritxu'ion of wealth. As always happens, soma peo ple, mostly lucky speculators, will come out of the melee wealthier than before. This fact will not serve to lessen the discontent of the masses which their impoverishment is sure to create. Food prices will be high, the earnings of labor will be low; and, after the war, unemployment will ba great, due to the Impossibility of quick absorDtlon into the industrial system qf returned soldiers as well as other maladjustments, which the war Is sure to bring. The Victor may secure indemnity for part of the loss, but not far all; he will, la spite of himself, be a net loser. Taxes will be a . crushing burden, merely to secure funds with wnlch to pay high Interest on vast new war debts, to say nothing of fun-Is with which to purchase new armaments- if again the nations are forced, by lack of international control, to re sume the stupendous folly of racing each other in military equipments. Bankruptcy and Revolution. It may well ba that among the eco nomic consequences of the war there will be some national bankruptcies, and that among the political conse quences will be revolutions High prices, high taxes, low wages and un employment make an ominous combi nations We may .be sure that dis content will be profound and wide spread. This discontent is pretty sure to lead, especially in the defeated nations where there is no compensat ing "glory." to strong; revolutionary movements Just a was the case in ' Jlussia after her defeat by Japan. Whether or to what extent these movements, in which "Socialism" in the various meanings of that word la sure to play a part, will succeed, de pends oh the relative strength of op posing tendencies which cannot yet be measured. One possible if not probable result may be, as I sug gested In The Journal several weeks ago. some international device to se cure disarmament and to safeguard peace, N Though part of the losses to Europe will bd permanent, her chief loss will be Odtermlnoue with the war. She will, therefore, seek ways and means to fill in this immediate hole in her Income in order to "get by." To do thi she must borrow; that is she most secure her present bread and butter from us and other nations and strange to repay later out of th fruits of peace. She can stint herself, but not enough to meet the situation. She must borrow. And in -one way and another she will satisfy this necessity by borrowing in the United States. lldst of the strange- and unprece dented phenomena which we have wit nessed In the last month, in rapid suc- 'J' 'l . cession, are due to this pressing neces sity of the belligerent peoples to cash in now and trust to good fortune to pay later. As soon as the war became even probable, Europe tried to cash In on our securities. The pressure for our gold pushed it toward Europe faster than it could move. Exchange Jumped to the gold shipping point of $4.89 per and did not stop. In some cases it reached 17. This was partly due to the desire to get our gold and bolster up a credit structure tottering before the deadly blow of war; but it was also partly due o the need of ready money for supplies of all kinds. This need applies not only to the governments, but to the indi vidual people. To obtain this ready money they threw back on us the se curities they had purchased of us in former years. They wanted us to take back these titles to future Income and give them instead titles to present income. Had they secured our gold their next step would have he en to upend part of it for supplies and this would have caused any foreign deal ers to whom they applied to place or ders with us. The gold then might have turned the exchanges and have been brought back to us In return for our wheat and other products. This double transaction Is in es sence one, a barter of present Income in the form of our wheat to Europe for future income in the form of In vestment securities. It was interfered with by the refusal of the lnmrance companies to insure the gold and by the closing of stock exchanges against the inundating flood of securities. The first difficulty, as to transporting gold, has been largely removed by ar ranging for drafts against stocks of it kept on both sides of the Atlantic This will save the need of sending it on risky voyages back and forth, and any final net balances can be liquidated after the war. The second obstacle, the closure of the stock exchanges, is more formidable but cannot completely or permanently prevent the transac tions which so many people on both sides are anxious to consummate. Curb markets and limited cash sales on the exchanges themselves are doing some of rhis business, and, soon et dr. later 'i much more will be 'done, whether the exchanges are open or not. Europe needs our wheat and cannot pay for it except with securities, partly because her own industry Is paralysed, partly because ocean transportation is diffi cult. What Dumping Securities Means. Few people seem to realize that the dumping of securities on our stores and the efforts of foreign governments, such as France and Switzerland, to borrow money in our markets are at the bottom very much the same thing. They are simply two forms of securing present supplies from America in re turn for future supplies, the dividends and interest on securities, from Europe. It does not much matter whether we buy government bonds or other eecurl ties. If we buy of French capitalists their holdings in American railway e-" curlties we simply provide them with the wherewithal to take the French government loans themselves. They virtually, become, without our knowl edge, the go-between through which we' lend, as it were, to the French govern ment, In spite of ourselves. It is doubtless well, as a matter of policy, to refuse to loan directly to France, but we must not for a moment conclude that France or any other nation will have to finance the war without our aid. We shall not be consciously help ing any particular nation, but we shall be actually helping any nation which can trade with us. Evidently England will get more of our help than any other nation because her shores are more accessible. Qermaty is more iso lated. Unless she possesses a larger food stock than commercial statistics indicate she will be pressing for our food supplies, which may reach her in directly, we selling to Holland and Hol land to Germany, also reversely, via Holland or via Austria and" Italy, Ger many may sell a stream of securities the other end of which we receiev. Whether directly or by devious routes there will inevitably be. so far as I can see, a vast exchange of commodi ties passing to Europe for securities coming from Europe. In this inter change will be found the dominant eco rr& if .r - &mm$&m. -'mm- mm , , UBSSSt " m I m -II k rill of short time loans may fluctuate gTe&t ly. The rise in the rate of Interest on long time investments is one of the most vital and far reaching effects of the war. At bottom interest always arises from the exchange of present and future goods. The rate of interest, as I have tried to show jin my book of that title, is simply the crystallization, in a market rate, of trie impatience of the human race for its bread and but ter. War has now produced such im patience in populations of hundreds of millions. It is this impatience which dumps the securities upon us, sends down their price, and sends up the rate of interest. As Byron W. Holt has said, there is no moratorium for hun ger. The fall of securities In Europe produces the like fall in this and other countries. One of the consequences to America of being forced to play the role of money lender and one of the conse quences of the rise in the rate of in terest here, or what amounts to the 'same thing, the fall in the prices of bonds, will be an increased difficulty of financing our own enterprises. Only the most promising enterprises will be able to sell their securities. This means that we 6hall be neglect ing, to some extent, our own enter prises to finance the European war in stead. This general depreciation of invest ment securities will doubtless lead to many bankruptcies, If not to a genu ine crisis. It will, also give tempting opportunities to investors. The like lihood of a genuine panic is lessened by the fact that everyone recognizes the real cause of the disturbance and that Insolvency is not suspected.. Ac cording to the best .commercial ob servers, the previous liquidation had been fairly well completed. Unless they are mistaken, disaster will not be likely to follow. We repeat that since the necessi ties of Europe have forced her to buy our food In return for her invest ments. It is evident that during the war food prices will be high and SCARE ABOUT FOOD SUPPLY NEEDLESS By a Veteran Gram Man. THE whole country has been placed in s, state of nervous anxiety about its food supply, and the high prices which it may have to pay in the future for its food owing to the European war. Household after household has laid in stocks of flour, sugar, etc, in fear that much higher prices would have to be paid Jn the near future. Those who usual ly buy 25 pounds of flour at a time have, when able and sufficiently scared, bought a barrel or several bar rels. . This has produced an unusual and sudden demand of large extent, which naturally has reacted on the grocer and miller and has thus created an abnormal fear lest this demand last through the crop year. The farmer also, in many sections, has a most exaggerated idea of the high price he is sure to obtain for his wheat and other grain. This idea causes him to hold back bis supplies when able to do so, but most farmers are obliged to sell great quantities of their grain soon after harvest in order to meet their necessities, which per cent of our present consumption in the food supplies of our country can. be saved. .This is an immense total but we have acquired such B.ut' It Would Be a i ti . . if A total, but we have acquirea sucu UOOU 1 nlng It Amen- wasteful habits of high living, that we have added an immense total to the cans Learned Not to ctofUvlng- , . Aln We. as a people, are equal to seeing WaSte FOOdStUffS. XZrgXJkX rJl'lo?V -ted in snots, u. th. other part, of to remedy the evil until forced to it our innusinai mscmnfry. by compulsion. If it requires the en- Important dislocations will be felt rn or living, security prices, especially bonds, i be low. These are the two facts greatest economic significance to us. To the country as a whole, they defer some of our pleasures till after the war. Uncle Sam will cut down for .the present on his eating and drink ing, his clothes, sheltec and amuse ments in order to share his rations with Europe. Instead of the pleasures foregone he will invest not in new en terprises at home, but in old ones American and possibly European also purchased of Europe. We can never have our cake and eat It, too. In this case we shall let Europe eat some of it on condition that she in turn scares hers with us after the war. Moreover, we shall trade oft a relatively small piece of our present cake for a rela tively large piece of Europe's future cake. In other words, Europe will fill up the great breach in her income now Impending by inducing us to make a small breach in ours. The result will be that the course of our real income, that Is, economic satis factions or enjoyitble consumption, will imitate In some degree that of Europe. This Is, reduced to its lowest terms. the chief economic result of the war. But to many the question Is. do we gain or lose, as compared with what might have been the case if there had been no war? I do not tMnk any one can answer that question with cer tainty. Europe is willing to mortgage its future to us on terms very advan tageous to us; but when the future comes. the purchasing power of money will probably be so much less ened as to have absorbed all our ad vantage. Probably we shall lose slightly, on the whole. Bat It Is not economically Impossible that, there will be a net gain. In either case the net effect will. I believe, be small. Of more importance will be the vari ous effects on various classes. v Cer tain people will be greatly benefited by the rise in food prices, and the fall in security prices. The farming classes will profit by the former; the Investing classes by the litter. Those who have the good fortune to belong to both classes will grow rich. The farmer who Is in a position to save money will both make more money to save md be able to invest it more ad vantageously after he has saved it. If he lends to his neighbors he will find the market rate of Interest high. Even If he buys more land the pur chase price will be restrained from the great rise we might expect from the prosperity of farming by the fact that the "number of years purchase," as the phrase is In England, will be small, or. In other words, that the In terest basis, which enters into every land price. Will be high. Labor Will Not Suffer Much. On the other hand, the general con sumer of farm products win suffer from another advance in that part of his cost of living, while the debtor classes will suffer from the fall In bonds or rise in interest. Many specu lators on the stock exchange, those who have speculated for a rise, are in effect undoubtedly ruined already and many borrowers at banks on col lateral security win feel the pinch from the depreciation of their property and the-hard terms of renewing their loans. And the laboring man. who forms the majority, what of him? It seems im probable that he will be greatly af fected, that is, on the average. He will have to pay more for his food and food constitutes more than a third of his budget But some articles he boys will probably fall and he may secure higher wages because of the "with drawal of competing laborers. Some labor may rise, especially In the in dustries benefited by the war, such as for instance, farming and other food industries, canning, flour mills, sugar, etc., the automobile industry and per haps ammunition and steel. In other industries thrown out of gear for lack of foreign markets or for lack of foreign raw material, the wage earner may lose In wages and employment. In other words, labor will be dlslo- com pared with, our internal jtf&mmerce. The. internal commerce palifi for by money and checks annuail in 'this United States amounts to noirly fivo hundred billions f dollars ifwhlch Is more than a hundred timea much as our combined exports 'f, and Im ports, ij Almost all of what has bff1 said so far had grown . out of thi proapect that the prices of foods andjtber ma terials needed in Europe wR be hiah. while the prices of MCuftfJes which Europe does not need and -Usnot mi' ford, will be low. Other jpMces will rise or fall according to elal cir cumstances. Like a bombshWt, the ef fect of the war will be to Asperse or scatter prices at all anglj of rises and falls. The prices of chemicals will be raised. The same 4ticle will fall in price in one" counttf' and rise in another if the transportation from the former to the latter iif Interfered with. This is true today b cotton. There has already been ai Speculative movement to anticipate thrift changes and arbitrarily to mark swjne prices up and some prices dow But as this is guess work and wilbe subject to frequent revision, one i$ the strik ing phenomena will doubjtles be an increase in the variability if prices. The general level of prlcfri; will tend to rise. The rise will ' probably be greatest in little countrifj tike Bel gium, which are In the wit jsone, and largely dependent on forgn trade. The rise wtH he less In Entpprid and in the United States than onMhe conti nent. In fact It is conceivable that In England the hoarding ofjhoViey and the shock to credit, whicfigils as pre- . dominant there as It is hpf r may ac tually lower the general leKfiil fef prices during the war. especially! Ui e eotld include in the Index numbe the prices of securities, luxuries and ;articles of English internal trade. If 'any nation tries the old experiment eM paying its bills In irredeemable paper-hohey, that desperate expedient will ha the same result that It did with uff during the Civil war. Inflation of fte currency will expel gold from thatfeonntry and raise us price level nighgr man eiee- where. After the war is overYrlces will probably not retreat, buiciwill move upward even faster than before. There may then come the famiiar "boom" period, which may rulmtriie In a com mercial crisis In a few ytjtSra after the close of the war. as watj; true after the Crimean war. the Ajir1i,an Civil war, and the Franco-PfisslAn war. The rebound, will prObatli: he fastest In England. Statistical Wlf curves of many nations usually! io an up ward turn when war begins and an other when It ends. The'j-af will thus aggravate a rise of prls already In prospect. It would take considiiijabl space to give, completely, the ressns for these prognostications, hut I ijfiaVe tried to Justify them in a brief; fhddendum to a book recently Issued ofhf "Why Is the Dollar Shrinking?" ij J The sudden lightning fholt of war produced as one of its ?lMt economic effects a general dlelocstlloh of credit machinery In Europe anSJto some ex tent in this country. ?ve heard at once that letters of eredifc of travelers in Europe were uncalhaiJe. Gold wan honrdwl everywhere. Itjpis estimated that about $30,000,000 i fej gold was hoarded In New York Irij she first weelt in August. Ttuns on rspliks were fre quent. Bank reserves wife depleted. The moratorium was'; ffsorted to to avoid a general catac$em of bank ruptcies which might HVe occurred not from actual inso1viF-iy but from mere insufficiency of cijjK' To roe. one of the;!nt striking phenomena was the pH'Vnptriess and effectiveness of the cSjperallve ac tions by which, so fat-i any business cataclysm has been Iff voided. The closure of stock excHjgws perhaps saved us from general Hinanelal panic. Most striking of all iajj jjh manner in which the governmental at the world have come to the resdjutg of business. Those of us who wej; brought wi in the old laissez-faire; school have to rub our eyes. - Had Se world been guided by lalasez-falrj sldeas, in this emergency we should all probabil ity have witnessed bihls "time the greatest collapse of cry!t the world has ever seen. AlmofC all the large and effective measnrssg to meet the many emergencies arllfyg Were taken by . governments. TjliJi moratorium must be counted am$ig the govern mental acts which. !h5 Tar at least, have saved the dayjj for business credits. In -England, t9e government permitted suspension the bank act (not of the bank as jfnany Americans seem to imagine). 4- Improvised Accounting Methods. erain has to be stored In warehouses at central cities, and carried by those nomic effect of the war on the United engaged in the grain bustneas and by States. Foreign nations will get their much needed loans on better terms, even If less promptly, by the circuitous pro cess mentioned than if they could bor row directly in our markets; for their own cltleens will pay higher prices than we would, even if, to get the money, they have to sell their, other Investment securities to us at a con siderable sacrifice. England has sold treasury bills for $75,000,000 on as low a "basis" as 3 per cent. in this virtual trade of this year's crops for titles to future years' crops, we shall get a high price for the for mer and pay ft low prise ln present valuation) for the latter. Investment securities are and will be a drug on the market. In other words, the rate of return to the investor will be Wfh, the rate of interest on long time loans will be high and stay high; that on j - . , - - ' " the banks. This great warehousing of grain acta as a balance wheel to keep the machinery of supply and demand of grain in equilibrium, as the balance wheel in a great mill enables the milf power to produce smooth action of the machinery, or the ballast' in a boat keeps the boat right side up. We need these great reserves of storage grain to be carried by men in the grain trade as a protection to the country for its grain supplies. A great country must have great grain storage reserves, the same as a great bank must have great reserves in cash resources. We have harvested a wheat crop of over 900.000.000 bushels, which Will give us $00,000,000 for export, or 100, 000,000 more than our largest actual exports in any previous year. In the early part Of July we were Wondering how We could get rid of it at any fair price, but today we are wondering if we can keep the price within reason able bounds, as the pubile mind hat become hysterically elted- To be - sure, in 1868-7. just after the Civil war, we sold wheat' at $3.30 per bushel, and corn at $1.81. in paper money, but we had no reserves in the country to speak of. The crop of corn gathered In 1913 was a small one, and hence now at the end of the year we are seeing very high prices for corn. , The present crop to be gathered this fall, which begins to come on . the market in December, is expected to show at least 2,850,000,000 bushels, or 200,000,000 bushels more than last year. While this is not a large crop, the saving, which the farmer can readily make through care in feed, should make it equal, in results, a crop fof 2,750,000.000. owing to the high prices which it commands. The waste going on upon farms in our feed crops is every year enormous, owing to the cattle and hogs being carelessly fed, 'and immense quantities of grain are trampled under their feet and scattered carelessly over the ground. The farmer this year will be very careful to save every bushel of grain possible, and in the aggregate this saving will reach many millions of bushels. The' oat crop for this season will amount to 1,160,000,000 bushels, and Is what might be called a fair average crop. It unquestionably will command good prices, as the European countries will want immense amounts for their armies. Potatoes are showing better results . than last year, and the probabilities are that their Keeping qualities will be good. The general result of tnlhor crops this year have been fairly satisfactory. There is no necessity for the Amer ican people to become excited for their food, supply; much of the sensational talk is of a highly inflammatory and deceptive nature. If the American people can be brought to exercise care In the nsa of their foot and to ceaie the .immense wastage which is eon stantly, going on year after year through wasteful habits, at least 20 tiro change of our habits The people seem, to be awake at the present moment to tne situation, anu they will probably meet it not only as a necessity, but In a spirit of readiness and adaptability. We are creatures of habit, and If we have acquired wasteful habits we stick to these methods. Much is being done by the government, as well aa the railroads, In showing the farmer how he may increase the production of his crops by practical demonstra tions along the lines of railroad in many sections of the country. We need to be shown in some- practical way how we can serve to the best ad vantage the food supplies which are produced. In Europe we are having the great est lesson the world ever saw in tne stoppage of free and quick means of intercommunication between thickly inhabited places In present day civili sation, which will in one week pro duce results in loss of supplies that would seem incredible while the means of ready transportation were t hand. We ask where have the supplies gone? They have simply beAg stopped because we are denied the ma terial means to move those supplies, and have paralyzed the mind with fears so that it will not act with the neces sary confidence to meet the demands. The American, people should take this lesson to heart. If we have crip pled the readiness and flexibility of the will of our people to do things we have dried up the sources which pro duce the thousand and one means of livelihood even if we say nothing about Its crippling our food supply, it seems cruel to prey upon the minds of the people at such a time as this, when we need the most calm and sane presentation of facts, with the stimulus of mere temporary excite meat, which only exhaust our re sources and our capacity to see with out the glasses of distorted fears. the fields of shipping and banking. One consequence is that American enterprise has now the golden oppor tunity to capture a good share of each. The outbreak of the war and the simultaneous opening of the Pan ama canal will tend to divert the course of trade from Europe to South America. Trobably our merchant ma rine can be developed more success fully for this ilouth American trade than it could for the European trade. New York can largely take the place of London as the world's exchange center for Pan-American trade. This opportunity is increased by the possi bilities in the new banking act for the establishment of branch banks abroad. . With these opportunities and the rise of interest in Europe, the United " States will change to a great degree from a debtor to a creditor nation. One of the dislocations of the war In the United States will be the cut ting off of imports of a large part of our dutiable commodities, and there ' fore the loss of national revenue. There is an urgent need to compensate for this loss by some other form of tax. . But it is well not to lose perspective, to remember that dislocations are not necessarily losses, that, however, loud, ly they are proclaimed in news col umns, they are small in extent, when considered In relation to our whole trade, that this country of ours is a vast one, and that the rank and file of Americans will be but slightly af fected by the war especially by con trast with our friends, now fighting each' other, acres the sea. We are too nearly elf supporting to be prostrated. Our foreign trade if and always has been trifling matter The Bank of EnglaniJ has been en abled to rediscount M great mats of acceptances by the guarantee of the' British government alnst loss In to doing. These "in the Jefiil will amount to several hundred millions of dollars. Emergency notes werissued by gov ernmental authority f?u both sides of the Atlantic, and in -e arrangements made for special goldjgunds in Canada and in France the ij governments of England and Frances jplayed the im portant parts. Thujiave been lm-: pro vised mlthods of j International ac counmig by which t) transportation, T of gold balances maflbe deferred and largely dispensed wltihv Our own gov ernment has-oooperaed in the cur rency exchange and j$dit situation Jn many ways. It mi .provision for sending gold i to jurope for out stranded countrymen promptly, re vised the banking anajshipplhg laws. . Whether further latabillty will be found to need such ljIsterlng we can not be sure. ; The ptsent Outlook )s that business! conditions sre fairly sound and stable, r; which direction across the Atlantic jghe title to gold will tend to change annot as yet be. foreseen. It will ftfpend largely on bow much Europe went our products and how large a sacrifice she is willing to make in selling her securities. It will also depend c possible issues of paper money. Ftunately we are the happy possessors of over $1,600, 000,000 in gold, arils! It is inconceiv able that any large j$rt of this should flow out unless whould be so In sensate as to inflate -he currency. If "we keep our heai we shall at the end of the war be .4. the proud posi tion of being the i&y great nation whose economic retCiurces have not even been strained.?,; . -. ... : .. -. . - - - '