HI oireGpNt sundA july ia. i 1614.! iSEEjJEfcii -MEljljiRlAL TOME . PROPOSED Movement Begun ; Light, on the Caribbean Sea at Santo Domin scriptlons from A MOVEMENT has been begun to get the peoples of the United. 'States, of the 20 other repub lics of North, Central and South" America and of Canada, to erect by popular subscription a splendid Pan American tomb and memorial for Christopher Columbus In tne city of Santd Domingo, Dominican Republic, where bis remains are declared now to rest. i It is proposed that $500,000 be raised, and, if more detailed study makes this seem feasible, to limit each subscription to ,60 cents, so that the memorial may represent a great num ber of the sons and daughters of that new world' found by the Genoese.' The Dominican Republic Itself launched a plan about 20 years ago to build a huge tomb and monument, and dedicated a superb site in the southern part of the city 4 of Santo Domingo, on the coral coast of the Ca ribbean sea, which today is a park known aa the Plaza Columbina. A system of taxation was devised to de fray the ' cost of the intended memo rial, but .the plan was abandoned ow ing to Internal political differences. Instead, ;a marble mausoleum was erected fa the cathedral In Santo Do mingo, in which, in the opinion of nu merous historical authorities, ' the re mains of Columbus now repose. The Plaza Columbina; is still "avail able, and it is proposed to raise on this the ' Pan-American - memorial. The plan is to construct a massive tomb fof the base, something; like the Grant Tomb, and then to sweep into the air with a Superstructure, on the top of which will be placed one of the most powerful lights in the world, to be known as Columbus Light The plan further provides for an endowment fund for the perpetual maintenance of the light. The Plaza Columbina faces the open Caribbean, and thence one looks south toward the far-distant main coast of South America and southwest toward Colon, the Atlantic entrance to the Panama canal. Many ships in the1 West India trade lay their courses bo that the crews would see the rays of Columbus Light; The campaign for .the Pan-American memorial was begun one year ago by William E. Pulliam, at that time gen-i eral receiver of Dominican customs, . a post which lie occupied for six years, having been appointed by Presi dent Roosevelt. During his residence In Santo Domingo Mr Pulllanj became greatly Interested in the controversy which has been waged at various times over the resting place of the remains of Columbus.-' Both Santo Do-' mlnao and Spain ;?hrlm 1 te" have the remains. After detailed' investigation and study of 'the many authorities, Mr. Pulliam became convinced that those numerous experts are correct who hold' that; the remains are in Santo Domingo. He then conceived the Idea of the Columbus Light. Mr. Pulliam laid his" plan before , President Jose Bordas, and the Do miitican chief executive in reply, ex-pi-ptcMpd keen Interest. Widespread Interest in Project Mr. Pulliam also wrote fully about the project to John Barrett, director Kcneral of the Pan-American union nt Washington. Mr. Barrett has not of ficially gone onM-ecord as to his views, but In reply to Mr. Pulliam did ex press his personal Interest. In an ad drexs delivered by Mr. Barrett in 1912 in ' Washington before the Knights of .Columbus he emphasized the necessity of a proper memorial to the discoverer of the western hemisphere. There is to be a Pan-American con ference at Santiago, Cbile, this fall, . and there is a possibility that Mr. Pulllam'a plan may be introduced. Former Pan-American conferences have considerad in general the idea of erecting some form of a memorial to Columbus. Mr. Pulliam has further discussed , the proposal with American business men, capitalists, and steamship repre? cntatlves, all of whom he has found warmly in favor of his idea. Besides President Bordas, prominent Domini cans who have welcomed the plan are Senor Francisco J. Peynado, formerly minister of his country at Washington, and Don Kmiliano Tejera, ex-minister of foreign relations, ror many years one of the leading men of his land, and an authority on Columbus, Dominican newspapers have reviewed the plan in a friendly spirit. Mr..Pulliam's letters outlining the plan to President Bordas and Mr. Bar rett were largely similar. To Mr. Bar rett he wrote as follows;, During my residence in Santo Do mingo 1 have often thought tnat at tills late date tttere should no longer be any question as to the identity and ' final resting place of the bones of Columbus, the discoverer of the new world, and this leads to a suggestion which I respectfully present for the consideration of the Pan-American union, assuming it to be a matter Ui which the governing board of tnat or-. '. , ganization would be interested. From my personal-investigation of the subject, and as the result jf read ing several, articles that have been witten thereon, it woulds appear that the opinion is unanimous on tho part of disinterested investigators that the remaihs of Columbus tre in Santo. Do mingo, where they have lain : oontin- . uously since brought from Spain about 1537. Spain, I understand, disputes the contention. Mr. William E. Curtis, the first di rector of the " --American union and a well-known newspaper writt-r,' in- : vestigated the facts, which were used by him in a syndicated press letter In the flrft part of 1908 and appeared In the Chicago Record-Herald. He in- -dtcated satisfaction with the cliims of S.uito Domingo. Mr. Frederick A. ' Ober, the writer and authority on the Went Indies, aiso has expressed him- . self to the same effect., and presents the-jfocts in one of hii volumes. - ABbut 20 years ago, or at the. time of the four huncredth anniversary ot the discovery of America, and the Col umbian exposition at Chicago, the Do minican government cauaed to be set j- aside and vested in a Junta? Columbina . a tract of land tn the heart of the city, abutting the Caribbean , for purpose of erecting thereon a mau soleum in which would be placed the. remains of Columbus. 1 The location is ideal and peculiarly, -. appropriate. , It overlooks the - open roadstead of the sea so .often traveled by Columbus on his voyages of dis covery, and from the site one may for Erection of a the Twenty-one American Reblicsancl look out upon the anchorage where- . the humiliated and degraded admiral, , divested of his authority by Bobadilla,...' embarked for Spain in October, 1590, in - lron. The mausoleum plaa-failed of completion; in fact,-nothing was ac- complished, but as a substitute a man ument was erected in the cathedral, and in a crypt provided therefor the remains are now preserved. At that time it was understood that the ar rangement was temporary, and at a later date the original scheme of building an imposing tomb would be - carried out. While the monument in the cathedral is ornate, it is not com mensurate with the greatness of Col umbus, nor does it constitute a fitting or sufficient mark of respect for such a world character. Furthermore, the remains contained In the leaden casket in which they were discovered by accident in the ca thedral in the year 1877, were- not hermetically sealed and placed away for all time. Upon occasions, and not " infrequently, the casket is withdrawn from Its resting place, the top re moved, and the precious dust and f rag- ments of bones exposed to the air and the gaze and actual handling of the curious. This, it would seem, ahould not be. . Every school child is taught that it was the dying wish of Columbus that his mortal remains be carried to and laid away in the country he discovered, and by what might seem providential .intervention his wish has been re spected through the centuries that have passed, notwithstanding the de liberate plan of the Spanish authori ties tn 1795 to remove the remains to Havana at, the time Santo Domingo . was ceded to France. I have often thought, and I assume there will be no difference of opinion on that point, that a mausoleum- wor thy of holding; the remains of Colum bus should be erected, corresponding in a wav to the mausoleum oi Napo- IUVrb-U.v fO"LlYcf, I leon in Lea Invalldes and the Grant -Tomb at Riverside. The construction of such a monument should be the con cern of each of the 21 republics now occupying the territory in North and South America, and likewise Canada, for the fact must be appreciated that many, if not almost all the other, coun tries' have received . far greater ulti mate benefit from the stupendous work of Columbus than Santo Domin go. Hence it would be in every way fitting -tor-all America- to Join with Santo Domingo in paying this belated homage in the place so beautifully called La Cuna de Am"ica to the original blazer of the trail. The movement to construct such a mausoleum doubtless would meet with prompt and hearty approval and gen eral support, not, only from the. re-, spectlve governments but the individ ual nations of America, North- and South. My idea is that a fund of not less than $500,000 easily could be raised by popular subscription and de- - voted to the object. Besides the na tions many societies doubtless readily would respond, among the number the , Pan-American Union, the "Pan-Ameri- can Society of New York, certain Ital ian societies, and the Spanish Histori cal society. , As a further tentative suggestion, if the plan were gotten under way, a. massive tomb could be erected, and? on the same a lighthouse superim posed and a powerful light Installed to guide by nlgbt the path of the prts-ent-day perplexed mariner. Each coun try assisting might supply a marble slab or bronze tablet, suitably in scribed, to be placed in the interior . around the sarcophagus. . President B or da's Promise Mr. Pulliam's letter to President Bordas was dated on August 4 of last year. A few days later he received a reply from the chief executive, of which this is a translation: - : ' I have had the satisfaction of re ceiving your interesting letter of the fourth instant, and you may be as--- sured that the liveliest interest has. been awakened in my mind concerning the-plan which you suggest that of erecting in this city, through the co operation of all the peoples of Amer ica, a fitting monument in which may be placed for all time the venerable At- y tr? A 11 a'm' c r !?H V V1" " If ytmMm:i - x c f " &0m& II wcrc aru.rc ih Iho - f000 . 5 Mausoleum, Topped by a Great ashes of the illustrious Genoese, the discoverer of America. i . . , I assure you that I will atudy the plans which you have indicated to me bearing upon" this subject, and I am in hopes that your very beautiful, idea may be brought to a realization. -, i will give you advice in due time aa'to whatever the government , may de termine to do in this affair. "From the conversations which I" have had with men of importance both in the United States and in Santo Do mingo," said Mr. Pulliam, "I am con vinced that widespread popular enthu siasm, both in this country and in Latin America, will greet the plan for honoring the man who gave to us of the western hemisphere the lands which are now our homes. I believe that if the maximum Subscription were kept at a very low figure, say 60 cents, the money, needed would be raised in a .surprisingly short time. It seems a reproach to us citizens of the New World that there is no memorial truly worthy of so commanding a world figure as Columbus. - Bone in Unsealed Casket "In the proposed Pan-American memorial the bones of Columbus would at last be at rest, for they are not at rest In the mausoleum in the cathe dral m Santo Domingo. By this state ment I mean that the bones are being handled by the curious several times a year. I myself have . handled the bones. -The casket in which they re pose has not been sealed, the result being that Visiting officials and per sons pf prominence are allowed to touch' the sacred remains of the great H . ui admiral. Mr. Knox, when secretary of state, and Mr. Stlmson, when sec- , retary of war. and their parties were among the American visitors ; who were permitted to Inspect and handle the bones. "Of course, there has been a contro versy as to whether Santo Domingo or Spain has the bones of Columbus, But any disinterested man who will take the trouble to study the question will find that there cannot be a shadow of doubt as to the remains In Santo Do mingo being the true remains. "Briefly, the facts are these: In ac cordance with the testamentary wish of Columbus, who died in 1606 in Spain, his remains were Interred in the cathedral in Santo Domingo about the year 1637. r The remains of ' his son, Diego. - and his grandson, Luis, were also brought from Europe and interred In the cathedral. The Island remained Spanish until , 1795. when it was ceded to France. The Spanish authorities Insisted upon taking away the remains of Columbus, and In that year they exhumed what they believed were the remains. They took these to Cuba" and buried them in Havana. "In January. 1899, - after the Span . lsh-American war. the Spaniards once more exhumed ' the remains in ques- Hon this time taking them to Spain. Canada. ! - 1 t 2i t.V tt w-;? i lk -""5 iti't'-i-: ." in 5a,io Domxnjo Cily niusvoicd Ovm,topKi on s5cfo cf 0.; X ."where they were given sepulchre in Seville. It is these remains, which the Spaniards - today claim, ara those of Columbus. V " r ; Finding of the Bones ,"In 1 877, however, while ; repairs . were being made to the .cathedral in Santo Domingo,-a casket, whose exist ence had seen unknown. was found. The casket which the Spaniards had taken had borne no Identifying marks. But this newly .found casket bore In- scriptlons both on the outside and in side covers, which made it plain to every , one that it contained' the re-, mains of- Columbus, - while the casket which had "been taken by the " Span iards doubtless contained the bones of . Diego. . . v - -"The formal-opening "of the casket took place on September 10,-"X877t tn the presence of high officials of the Dominican government and of the for eign consuls, including the American and ' Spanish . representatives. The Spanish consul. Don Jose Manuel de . Echeverrt; was "convinced that the re . mains of Columbus had only then been found, and ha so reported to the king of Spain. - For this ha was recalled in disgrace, as Spain wished to insist WW. ' V, ill V 4, 1 and Nobla TToTa.g!-.PoT. Col"umbua "v IrvsonptioT cova. of laadov coffiTs . . mi mi 'LHCQhTv of Amanvca.. o o-wtida of cova that the bones were then in Havana. "At the time of the finding of the casket. In 1877, In handling the bones and dust some fragments fell upon 'the, floor of the cathedral. These fragments were taken by various per sons. The Italian consul was one of those who picked up a pinch of the precious dust, which he sent to the town hall of Genoa, the native city of Columbus. This dust now reposes In an urn in the town hall, and there is no question In the minds of the authorities there, as there was no question In the minds of the Italian consul, that this dust is part of the remains of Columbus. Scattered Fragments "In 1878 the archbishop of Santo Domingo sent to Pope Leo XIII an other bit of the dust which was ob tained when the casket was opened a second time. The University of Pavla. in Italy, which Columbus attended as a student, also got a fragment of the DRAWINGS BY THREE caricatures preserved at the City Historical Museum at Lelp - sic, Germany, have Just been iden tified as the work of E. T. A. Hoff mann, .the famous writer, whose name has become especially familiar In this country of late years owing to ' the opera, "Tales of Hoffmann," so fre quently given In American cities, tbe libretto of which Is based on his weird stories. , . t e - Besides writing, Hoffmann ' was an able artist, excelling In particular as a caricaturist, yet tbe examples of his work In Lalpslo have been credited for years to another. The discovery of the real history . Is especially Inter esting Just now. when - all Germans are much Interested in their war of Independence ; against - Napoleon 100 years ago, for the Hoffmann carica-: tures were made during that struggle, and all .three of them lampoon Na- poleon and France. . - . - remains, having sent a request for it. Still another small fragment was taken by the engineer in charge of the ex humation, which passed into the pos session of G. W. Stokes of New York. In 1901 this fragment was presented by Mr. Stokes to the Lenox library, being preserved in a small glass vial. "It has been proposed that the re mains of Columbus be taken from Santo Domingo to San Francisco next year in order that they may be shown at the Pan-American exposition. . But hostility to this plan has developed in the Dominican republic, it being felt that it would be sacrilegious to make an exhibit of the remains, while it is pointed out that there is danger of some accident happening, by which the remains might be lost Or destroyed," The Bulletin of the Pan-American Union some time ago printed a de tailed account of the finding of the re mains of Columbus in Santo Domingo, with some discussion of the contro versy over the Dominican and Spanish claims, the article in question being written by Enrique Deschamps, con sul general of the Dominican republio at Madrid, who cites various authori ties in support , of the Dominican claims. Senor Deschamps opens his article with the declaration that "the con sensus of unbiased public opinion is that the real remains of Columbus are those which rest in the cathedral of Santo Domingo." After explaining how the remains of Columbus were brought to Santo Domingo about 1637 and burled Jn the cathedral, Senor Deschamps continues as follows: In 179S Spain ceded the island of Santo Domingo to France under article 9 of the treaty of Baailca, and Lieu tenant General Gabriel de Aristlzabal of the royal navy thinking, as became a soldier and a Spaniard, that it would not be worthy of his country to leave the revered remains of .the discoverer of America under another flag, made an earnest endeavor to have them re moved to the capital of the island of Cuba at that time under the sovereign ty of Spain. There was no tablet, inscription, or mark of any kind on the tomb of Co lumbus, and the Spaniards.' when they undertook, during the following year, the exhumation, as they thought of the remains of the first admiral, had nothing to guide them other than tra dition which said "that the remains of Christopher Columbus had been said to rest in the chancel of the cathedral on the side of the gospel. 1n the place where the throne of the bishop used to be placed." These indications appearing unques tionable, the exhumers of 1795 made their search "on the aide of the gos pel" and found the remains, which tney removed to Havana. The new exhum ers of 1877. of whom we will speak later, guided by no other clue, found the same "stone casket, hollow, of a cubic shape," though' empty, its con tents having been removed at the end of the preceding century. But as they knew what the first ex humers had not known namely that the remains of the family of Columbus rested in the same presbyterium in as many different caskets, while search ing for those of Don Diego, it being supposed that - Christopher's were in Havana, and Luis' having been discov ered there only a few days beron they found, not the remains of Diego. . whi itch, as will be seen, had really been taken to Havana, but those of Christo- pner insteaa. The record of the exhumation in 1795 makes no reference to any authentfo document settinar forth that- at trie place where said anonymous remains were being removed those of the dis coverer were located; and if such doc ument had existed the clerk would have assuredly made a note of the fact, as he could not have been un aware of Its great importance. Such a document would have accounted for the absolute absence of inscriptions on the top or sides of the casket, or on the loose plates thereof, which in fact were all that remained of said casket, as stated in the record. This record, signed by Jose F. Hidalgo, the olerk of the chamber of royal Audencla of Santo Domingo, reads as follows: HOFFMANN, FAMOUS WRITER That they were made by Hoffmann , was discovered by Herr Fried rich Schultze of Leipsic, who tells all about it in the German magazine, Das Llter arische Echo. Herr Schultze found a letter written by Hoffmann to Kunz, a Leipsic publisher, dated March 24, 1814, In which he mentioned all three of tbe caricatures. Hoffmann wrote: Men who suffer from gout usually' have an excellent temper. Often when my sufferings are acute I write "con amore," but if the -pain becomes alto gether too cruel I take up my pencil and draw caricatures on events of the day. Baumgartner has published the following caricatures of mine: Picture- showing Dame Gallia (France) freed - by the allied powers from the devil that had possessed her. One showing Dame Ciallia rewarding the physicians whom she had harmed while possessed of the devil, and prom ising tirem still further presents. . Joachim will soon publish snothef called "The Exequies of the Universal Monarchy." - - "On December JO. 1795, a caaket was opened situated on the presbyterium .. beside 'the go pal, in the main wall and step before the principal altar, about one cubic yard In site, and there- . In were found some plates about a third of a yard long, of lead, indicating that it had contained a box-of said metal, and some sections of shin bones and a number of other parts of . a deceased person, which were gath ered up on a tray,-, together with all the earth contained in the same, whlcii. from fragments mixed therewith, were recognised as remains of said body. Therefore, according to the record, there were exhumed the remains of "seme deceased person," supposed to have been those of Christopher Colum bus, this supposition being based solely on tradition, which had it that the remains of the first admiral rested on that side and in that part of the presbyterium. - As was very natural at that histori cal moment, no protest whatever re specting said removal was heard In Santo Domingo. In its place, however, a vague and uncertain rumor gained circulation In tha capital to the effect -that the remains of . Columbus were still in the presbyterium of the cathe- The enlightened people of the coun try paid no attention to the unfounded rumor, baaing their incredulity on the general belief that on the right side of; the presbyterium of the cathedral the only remains were those of Chris topher Columbus, and that the act pf bis exhumation having been made pub lic and solemn there could be no doubt that they had been removed to Havana. Yet, in the face of all this skepticism, the -traditional rumor persisted year after yar, though vaguely there being no one interested In affirming or deny ing it. To that rumor, then, is due in part the find of September 10, 1877. Senor Deschamps explains that on April 77. 1877, repair work was begun In the cathedral. All the work was done under tha Immediate supervision of Canon BUlinl. On May 14 a metal lic coffin was found containing human remains, ths remains being visible from the outside. Without opening the coffin. Canon BUlinl ordered work sus pended until the arrival of the arch bishop, then traveling in the interior. In June. Carlos Noael, a Dominican historical authority, was permitted by the canon to examine-the casket. Senor Nouel found a plate bearing this in scription: The Admiral Luis Colum bus. Duke of Veragua, Marquis of " (supposedly Jamaica). On September 1. the archbishop invited the civil and military authorities . and the consular corps to be present at the opening of the casket of Luis Columbus. On this occasion it was decided thfat advantage should be taken of the op portunity to explore the cathedral fur ther, attention being called to the an cient rumor that the bones of Chris topher Columbus were still in the ca thedral. Accordingly, on September 8. under supervision of Canon Billini, fur ther excavations were undertaken. Two days later the excavation work disclosed the end of a box. Canon BU linl again suspended operations, while the archbishop, minister of the interior and Italian consul general were sum moned. On their arrival the hole was enlarged and the box came plainly to view. Its top was covered wltlv-j-the dust of centuries, but the words, "First Admiral." abbreviated, forming part of an inscription, could be read. The examination was again suspend ed, while the cabinet ministers, munici pal council, consular corps and other officials were summoned. In the presence of these officials, on the afternoon, of that day, as Senor Des champs explains, the box. which proved to be a leaden casket, was taken from its long resting place and opened. The remains were inside, while inscriptions, both on the outside and inside of the cover, proved, to the satisfaction of those present; that these were the bones of Columbus. On the outside of the cover, in ab breviation, were the words: "Discov erer of America The First Admiral." On the inside of the cover. In abbre viation, except the name, were the words: "Illustrious and Noble Person age Don Christopher Columbus." Among the remains was a silver plate bearing the words "Christopher Colum bus." On the sides of, the basket were the initials "C. C. A.," supposed to stand for "Christopher Columbus, Ad miral." Strong Body of Evidence Among the authorities from whom Senor Deschamps quotes in support of the Dominican claim is the Liguria Society of Genoese History, which in vestigated the Columbus controversy. Its secretary reporting in 1878 as fol lows: With the evidence now available, th remains which were discovered In the cathedra of Santo Domingo on Sep tember 10. 1877, must be considered as the true mortal remains of Colum bus, but not those others which were removed - to Havana in December of 1795. Senor Deschamps quotes Adolfo Cro nau, the historian, as follows: Both the anchor of this work and the Witnesses left the place convinced that the venerable remains of the great discoverer rest in the cathedral of Santo Domingo.- The Spanish writer. Dona Emilia Serrano, is quoted by Senor Deschamps .. thus: The remains of the immortal naviga tor which have given rise to such con troversies shall be for ages and ages the prised treasure of the cathedral of Santo Domingo, Its most precious Jew el, and to this shrine future genera tions will repair to render homage to Columbus, the man who represented in his day and age the greatest and best type of universal genius.' . Count Roselly de Lorgues, historian, is quoted as follows: r- - These subsequent discoveries leave no room for further doubt. Tbesa are finally the true relics of him who re vealed to us the Immensity and mani fold wonders of the earth. The late Thomas C. Dawson, who was American minister to tbe Domin ican republic Chile; Colombia and Brazil, is quoted thus by Senor Des champs: - As regards the remains of Christo pher Columbus, there can be no doubt that they still rest in the little and ancient Dominican city. In the first named of tire three th "devil". Is none other than Napoleon, who" is shown flying away from the lady, Just out of reach of the bayonets of; the "physicians." In the second . caricature the presents which grateful France is handing out to her deliverers are : territory formely occupied , by Napoleon.' '-Thus, ' Austria Is shown receiving a basket in which are pack ages labeled "Trieste, "Flume." ete.. Prussia getting another supposed - to contain Danzig and Westphalia, while 'England Is demanding free 'trade. The third, representing the burial of Napoleon's universal monarchy. Is the most elaborate of the three. It was made by Hoffmann for distribution In England, for which - reason the artist wrote out the title in English below ; the ' picture. : It ",. shews "universsl monarchy" on a hearse being borne to the grave, followed by Napoleon as chief mourner, ; : .