Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The Oregon daily journal. (Portland, Or.) 1902-1972 | View Entire Issue (Nov. 26, 1911)
t';v' .THE OREGON SUNDAY' JOURNAL. PORTLAND SUNDAY MORNING, NOVEMBER 26. 1911. jve Farmers' Sons Who Find Opportunities For " Themselves at Home rected to the method rather than to the judges,' who ought not; to b blamed for following precedent, when the whole superstructure of : Jurisprudence re eta upon precedent. as a foundation. ' It was a step In th right direction when th legislature authorised th ap pointment of ' a committee ,; to consider plana of revision. But no such commit te can succeed In bringing about a real reform unless it has the support of tha bar. Nor will any good result be gained by anything less than a thorough going revision or th whole . ystem, : begin th cornerstone of the new Ontario! BKO ftflO Catholic hospital Will take Place I Thankaglving day. Blahop O'Reilly an J I other high dlgnltaHe of th -church j will hav cnarge or ne crrauni. i ;The $10,000 fund guaranteed by, thJ citlsena of Ontario for thla Institution I a Opportxwltr. f or teadarahtp, I submit ths uestins . with, the hop that they will at least stir ln terest in tha ' aubjaet ' Oregon a aet an example to other states In many pro gressive lines. ' Her la ' field that need her labor. TU Oregon Bar asso ciation ought to lead In the reforma. Instead of waiting until they ar forced by the people, who ar Impatient of the law'a injuatie and the law dalaya. u haa been subscribed except about 12500. Tha' rmt of this aruaranteed amount Will soon b raised, a several active cony mltteea ar' soliciting. . V Main street ml ning with fundamental principles, and creating a new structure tnat is piannea Ontario alone haa donated over 115,0001 with Intelligence and carried out with Judgment. . . 'A k -'i vV'-,,'A''4'1-';V:,lV . . i ", , .i i . . r . ii ; i during the present year for public ben-1 eflts, without including charities,' and! th publlo splrltedness shown, would do credit to a town aeveral times , th. alz Lay Cornerstone at Ontario Hospital. Ontario, ,, Or, ffov." Z5. The laying pi of Ontario. jm i Tlx The People's Institute of Domestic Economy ""4 Oresham. Or., Nov. 15. "The far mar's aon la wanted at home. He haa ntered uncotiscloualy through the door of the new knowledge and both mind and hands are buay her." Thea sig nificant words, recently written con cerning the boy and the farm, fit the cases of several farmers' eons living on or near the Section Una . road in the vicinity of Oresham. Among them are Roy and Lionel Buckley, aona of J. C. Buckley; John and Will Sorenaon, aona of 8. Borenson, and 'Garnet McCartney, on of Samuel McCartney. Roy Buckley, In addition to having a abare In tha crops of tha home farm, maintains a , shop well stocked . with ' tools. Including a blacksmith's forgo, 'alio of which he haa earned., His lateat Investment waa a MeCormick reaper, purchased In plac Of a much desired ' motor cycle. Lionel Buckley haa de ' veloped a skill in handling horses, his moat recent achievement having been the putting in harness of two three year old colta. Besides being proficient In farm work, John . Sorenaon has taken up photography and while hla patronage extends over several countlea, he haa not forgotten how to build a good grain stack. '', Will Sorenaon, his younger , . . . Photographs by "John Sorenson' Top, left Roy Buckley In his shop; right. Garnet McCartney and his bee hives. Botton, leftLionel Buck ley and his favorite horse; right, John and Will Sorenson and section of their poultry yard. , brother, runs to poultry raising and by nxt spring will have 600 laying pullets In place of the single hen with which he began. He also haa raised golden and China pheasants which, with , their eggs, he haa shipped to distant states. There is no feature of the subject that this young man has not studied. Both Sorenaon brothers have booked entries for the., Portland Poultry ahow In De. comber. " - ' Garnet McCartney, son of Samuel Mc Cartney, has' taken tip bee culture. He began two yeara ago with two hives of bees which have been lncreaaed In num ber' until the present time, when he en joys a large honey : trade among his friends. Ultimate Justice Court's Sole Aim Judge Charles H. Carey Urges Fellow Members of Oregon Bar'Assocla tlon to Lead Movement to Reform Judicial Practice and Procedure. (The following are th essental parts of an address, "Th Next Oreat Reform," delivered before th Oregon Bar associa tion Wednesday afternoon by Judge Charlea H. Carey : . "Between two ha was, which flies the higher pitch: - i'v .., ,. Between two' dogs, which hath the deeper mouth; . ' ' . Between two blades, which beara th better temper; Between two horses, which doth bear Btweenlrtwo gf Vis, which hath tha mr- I haver'prhVir" soma shallow spirit of But In these ni'c sharp quillets of the Good f aitih. I am rio wiser than a daw. ehakespear. "King Henry Vi" "lit thee days of progressiva thought, when In so many fields of human en- deavor there la an awakening to the need of reform, It la not to the credit of th legal profeaalon that conaervatlsm keeps inrfiai nractica atnd orocedur so far behind th times. Courts and judges hav always been mor or lees in oDpecis oi Dooular criticism, but diaaatlsfactlon la mor pronounced now In th United State than usual. Their shortcomings w tha administration of the criminal law la a subject often discussed, but th adJudlcaUon of civil caaes per uana 'nf more ceneral interest and touches personally a greater number of people. In these case ins. judicial num. ods are certainly open to critlciam. Too often the result of the trial la to leave the peraon Injured remedlleas or to deny blm complete relief. Court proceedings are fraught with delays and ar loaded with expense. , Because of th fact that so much of the time of the courts is taken up with Questions that do not concern the real matter In controversy, more judges are required than would be otherwise nec essary. . The suitor Is dependent In no small degree for Justice upon having made ' no slip in his comings and his goings., . rrocedor Should Be Simplified. Particularly Is this true In regard to the forms and rulea of written plead ings. ;;. The adoption of the New York Code of Civil Procedure was inImprovement over older conditions, and In Its day this was a reform worthy of American enter prise. This code, when formed tha baala for the cod ps of many others of the atates, abolished common law forms of njeadlnf and simplified many of the pre posterous methods that had grown up In English and American law procedure. But, etnee that step waa taken, the bench and bar in the United States have been content to stand without further progress. . We have assumed that fur ther reform la unnecessary, and not withstanding the fact that In England and her colonies, which lingered behind us In this respect for a time, there is In use simplified pleading that puts our present method' to shame, we have not been willing to follow. Under the Judicature "acta. In Eng land, a system of pleading lias been adopted for both actions at law and suits In equity that requires but a gen- riyNowPipo Doublos Ploasuro X want every pip smoker to try my won nvriui now auu-x mun x ip ana nftve at last th full, real pleasure of a perfect amok. It absorb? the nicotine, alwaya t titles sweet and looks and colors jmstllkaa nigh-priced meerschaum, latest expensive claw bowl design. If it does not prove a reveiauon 10 you, u in now wonder pipe doesnt beat any pipe you ever bad no mat tot what you paid. I will refund your money without-argument, Isnt this a fair, square vuerr mis is u pipe iney let you smoke Jt home. Introductory price, 40o eanb i 3 0rS1.00. Mnt TYrnMli ft n vwh.M Hawaii of imitation. The genuln haa "Mangos' uuupeu va me lerrui. .; Bjl Th Pleasure wrnnout Tto r oi aon Tm4t-But SwMvwl ' I i ST I t I r ViXilaat. USB THIS uri COUPON M. Msaaca. aoa 306 aiSH Laala. MaTT X ancloM (Wo) m.oo: a a (one) (t Bati-Blootln DlM. It la aiirin. fltood thjvt If f am ul mtHA wrm will rnfiind m umh IMuraot UatdpaorpipM. . ... ft4.k..,M....MMM,.i eral statement or claim by the plaintiff and equally . simple . statement of de fens by th defendant. ; Under our codea, an elaborate sys tem of technical rules of pleading hah grown up, - Mistakes In precision, and In legal phrasing are visited with defeat, and. In fact there Is aa much technical knowledge required now to plead under the codes aa formerly under th eommof law system. Much time 1a wasted upon demurrers and motions, which ar filed In nearly every suits ' " It fa argued that this Is essential to certainty of Issue, and that unless the opposite party Is apprised of exactly what is claimed he is taken at a l sad vantage. But there la no truth, what evor, In thla. No Issue Is necessary. In fact, technical rulea that confine parttea to definite Issues are obstructions to ultimate Justice. - Courts and lawyera now make Jus tice a secondary consideration; they pro ceed on the theory that the rules must be adhered to even though the result Is to bring the victory to the party who ought not to win; and they have built up fine theories of the law under which precedent must be followed to absurd conclusions. Precedent have accumu lattid, and the fecundity of the, modern printing preas seems to have no limit ao that law libraries with hundreds of volumes of decided cases must be de pended upon for the purpose of finding a clue to th path through labyrinths aa difficult aa those of ancient Egypt or Crete, r Smdls Suggested. Now I advocate a ' total and radical change. I would make It so that rult-s of pleading or proceuure are of little or no binding force. I would have it ao that a plaintiff desiring to sue may f Ho a notice that upon a certain day he will ask relief against a party, and when thla notice la duly served the plaintiff shall be entitled to his Judg ment unless the defendant demands i statement of the claim; but that this statement, If demanded and furnished need be i no more than a memorandum Th answer like the claim, ahould be Informal It will be quite aufflcient If It states whether the defendant wishes to contest the claim, except that if It la desired to offset, or to confess and avoid, this may be done. But there need be no formalities or niceties of language, and little attention need be given to the accuracy of any statement made on either Bide. There will be no place for motions, ordftmurrera. ' I would have the court aim at ultl mate Justice, Irrespective of anything in the pleadings, or anything omitted from the pleadings. I would have the court take the evl doncq offered by the parties, but not b confined to this source of Informa tion. I would have the court of Its own motion, bring in other parties, or hear other witnesses, adjourning the proceedings from time to time, if neces sary, until the matter In controversy ta thoroughly examined into. Tha courts ahould hava power to Inspect public or private records and documents, to ap point medical or other experts, to re quire the party seeking relief to do or abstain from doing acta not necessarily referred ' to In the pleadings, and It should get at the kernel of the dispute and should see to it that no decision is made on such silly grounds, for ex ample, as that the exemplification of a record Is not exact, or that copies In stead of originate are used where there la no question that the copies ar ac curate. . Thla system relegates to the limbo of the past, all the humbug about the dis tinctions between law and equity plead ings. It will allow parties to have re lief, whether In law'or In equity, and whether they have put the claims upon paper correctlyor not Tor no Injustice can be done by abolishing formal plead ing so long as the courts are enabled to protect against surprise, and to re quire the parties to stand for Justice. ' would Slsoonrar Appeals. I suggest, therefore, that th Judicial system of Oregon b' so revised aa to enable the supreme court to review an appealed case upon the original record and without printed abstracts or briefs, and at once. This will ope rat to dis courage appeals that ar taken for de lay, and will enable the appellate court to dispense- with written opinion upon points that have already, . In Ita' Judg ment, been correctly decided, and wher no new principle or unusual featurea re quire more careful examination - and more elaborate expression of opinion. But. even If this important -reform is not adopted In full, still It la not too much to demand that all formali ties of appeals be abolished. A suitable bond or undertaking having been fur nlshed, it ahould 'under any circum stance be sufficient to Jodge in the appellate court a copy of the Judgment and' the report1 of the trial, and the ap pellate court -should confine Its de cision to the merits of the controversy; and If It finds .that any evidence of Im portance has ' been omitted' that could and oil glit to be supplied, it should re ceive .'tjt, td.ii-tt should affirm or modi fy the deblSloh In accordance with ulti mate Justice, arid without being bound by any . technical rules whatever. j .' ' These plans, it will be perceived, change radically the duties and' funic tlona of appellate courts. Printed briefs and abstracts will b no longer necessary. The courts-will be caurts of review with comprehenalve powers sufficient to enable them to dispose of th cases without returning them to the 'trial court, except In rare and 'ex ceptional Instances. Instead of bills of exception to confine these courts to the consideration of certain errors irr law cases thst are claimed to have occurred on the. trial, the appellate courts ahould be open to supplement the Investigation mad by the Inferior court, with a view to reaching substantial justice; so that. If It appear that the trial Judge elim inated subjects of inquiry that should hav been gone into, or confined the Inquiry where It should have been given wider scope, the appellate court should bo free to go into these matters fully. Under this system, the verdicts of Juriea should be made as special find ings upon definite questions submitted to them. All of the foolish practice of requiring a judge to Instruct a Jury upon nice questions of complicated law with such exactness as to give ground for new trial or a reversal of the Judg ment, if he has made a Blip of the tongue, will be abolished, and with this change will go a great many of the most cogent objections to the efficiency of our courts of Justice. There Is, it must be admitted, much to be aald In favor of the preaent plan. It la true that judgea are human, and that unless restrained by stringent rules they will at timea be guilty of doing Injustice In the name of justice; and If they have power to decide cases upon what they assert to be the real merits between the parties, they may, in ig norance, or by partiality, make the cause of the wicked to triumph and bring the administration of the law Into contempt. Vtnen the forma of procedure and the rules of evidence are certain the danger of arbitrary and unreasonable -conduct upon the part of the judicial .officer is reduced to its lowest terms, and liberty la best secured where too much personal power Is not given to Judges. Then, too, there is the argument that has much weight with many, and par ticularly with th lawyera themselves, namely, that the present plan has Its origin in antiquity and la the logical outgrowth of many centuries of experi ence, whereby the law haa come to be known as the spirit of. reason; and the application of the law by the courts through yenerable forma and rules that have been evolved by experienceand that are now buttressed and supported by a vaat body of cases and valuable precedents, cultivates that respect and deference to Judicial procedure that la essential to the perpetuity of free in stitutions. Giving due weight to these views, while it Is conceded are quit generally held by lawyers, but are little appre ciated by laymen, I submit .that the arguments have been carried too far. It Is, for example, not at all true that th people respect judicial dignity mor because of the' antiquity or the rules. Indeed, it may be safer asserted that the people generally criticise the courts on the very ground that their rules are antiquated and that the law lias' not adjusted itself to th conditions of mod ern life.'.' ,!." " j!.:' t..f-.V I favor giving th judges mor Indi vidual power, ; and holding them to greater , individual responsibility. To Justify a miscarriage" of. Justice upon th excuse of precedent, or because of the limitation of . written issues, no longer satisfies, and Judges should ' be free to decide right; and should be ex pected to do so. The change I suggest would be In complete it not supplemented by others, less fundamental, but none the less necessary to enable the courts to sim plify their proceedings. The fact is that our whole system needs revision, and the changes should be first proposed by th bar. Tha Judges administer the law as they find It. Popular criticism should be dl- ' ' oSk- j y; T ' ""''' " ' 'HP I " B -V- X i XL. .'.X-'. -M V',--: ' , M mm mm I '.; ' 4". V.'-Vivw v :'. ... ' 11 ' iiai A I BM ' i 1 m h w. TJm I 1 '.,': la I W , r:-. ; !m v ji ii . r v.v. v.". . a bm m m Jt i ti t mm s m . t m i rr -r 11 I I Zl im. T IS a new kind of school. for the housewife. ,? Its advantages are as .free as the air. Its faculty ismade up of, the foremost authorities on household science, "; , tne wnoie wiae continent oyer, .; ; f , - ,.? 4 r , The sessions are weekly and' wide open:; ;V 7 7 " . One leading authority will write W sofn important problem of household management pr,-domestic science. Whai he or she Writes will be printed, with necessary illustrations, in the Magazine and Woman's Section of THE SUNDAY JOURNAL. - V-'": Next Sunday will see the first, session' of the Institute. ' The leader for the day is Miss Winifred Stuart Gibbs, a noted dietitian and food economist of New York. Her topic is "What Every Housekeeper Should Know," She. gives facts that are invaluable and advice that means comfort, if not wealth. Menu's and recipes for a week's meals are furnished by Mrs. Lily Hax worth Wallace, one of the noted cooking experts of. the country, a graduate of the National Training School of Cookery, of London. Mrs. Wallace's recipe for the Christmas fruit cake will be a find for every housekeeper. Beginning Sunday, December 3. - THANKSGIVING SALE THANKSGIVING SALE , .,.. ... i Foster & Klelser - Sasi fth ana vmmi Bvs !, ' tfhmmm Bast, liUj m-VUH. :- ThjanksgivinSale of Cut Glass The Celebrated Empire Line Consisting of Berry Bowls, Vases, Water Sets, etc, all reduced a fourth. 6-inch Vases, regular $2.00, at , fl.50 10-inch Vases, regular $3.00, at f2.25 8-inch Rose Bowls, regular $9.00. at f6.T5 2j4-pmt Water Titcher, regular $4.50, at 3.40 3-pint .Water Pitcher, regular $6.00, at I....f4.50 Cut Glass Mayonnaise Sets2-piece star pattern, reg. $4.00, at f2.98 Cut Glass Creamer and Sugar, sunburst pattern, reg. $3.00, at,. ..f 1.95 Richly Cut Water Tumblers, star pattern, reg. $6.00, set of 6 at ...f3.95 8-inch deeply cut, Berry Bowls, sunburst pattern, reg. $5.00, at ,.f2.95 8-inch deeply cut, Berry Bowls, latest designs, star or sunburst patterns. values to $8.00, at 4.95 Beautiful Cut Glass Water Sets of 7 pieces, sunburst pattern, reg. $12.00, now at.., ...... .. . . . .$9.00 Handsome Wine and Whiskey Sets, Comports, Vases, Ice Cream Platters, Celery Trays, etc. Latest designs and cut patterns. Thanksgiving sale at OFF CM THANKSGIVING fM SALE Jfa Thermos Bottles for Thanksgiving This is the place to buy, whether it be a single ( bottle, either American or German style, Decan al ters, Humidors or omotnatipn teases. THERMOS BOTTLES, German style, finished in an mcicei. Pints 3.T5 0rts $5.75 1 THERMOS COFFEE POTS AND DECAN TERS, made in handsome nickel finish for table use. - Vt pints ........ S5T.50 V quarts ,,,.$15.00 THERMOS HUMIDORS, for cigars, cigarettes and tobaccos solid "mahogany, $12.50 upwards, Circassian walnut $15.00 upwards CARRYING CASES FOR THERMOS BOTTLES, for single bottles i and sets. ' All substantially made in various leathers, priced from $2.00 up. 1 HANDSOME COMBINATION CASES FOR CARRYING LUNCHES. The styles and leathers are extensive. You will need -see them to appreciate their real values, , American Thermos Bottles Same qualities as the German make, but looks different. Bottles that we sell as follows: , Tints $1.00, $2.00 and $2.50 Quarts .$2.00, $3.00 and $3.50 We can supply fillers for the $1.00 bottles at 85c each. Thanksgiving Showing of Beautiful Jewelry, Perfumes,Etc. NEW SHIPMENT OF DROP EARRINGS in beautiful fringe effects, pearls, jets, etc. Brooches to match earrings, at $3.00, $4.00 and $o.oo. MEN'S HANDSOME SCARF PINS, in plat . inum effects, with pearl and amethyst set tings. The latest fad adopted by well dressed men, 7&f to $z.oo. MEN'S NOBBY CUFF LINKS priced 75 - to $2.00. Initials engraved FREE. BOUQUET PINS Something new, a decided : n6velty. Bouquet Pins made to hold . a ' bunch of violets. Thanksgiving price, fl.50 Perfume Baskets Beautiful Wicker Bask ets richly lined and con taining perfume, toilet ; vater, toilet., soap -and powder, i ' : . Only one of a kind,' " priced $3.00 to f6.00 PERFUME ATOMIZER s Perfume Atomizers ; that ' work, in cut glass',' Bo hemian and plain glass.' Priced 75, $1.50, $2 o $5. . f , ' , i Thanksgiving Stationery W Ar KB AS QUARTER! Tor niCB CARDS, OAMI MILT CARD 9, COTTNTERB, BTO. . Turkey design place card folders, at doz. 75f 35c and 50c Place and tally, cards, special dozen . . V..'....V..W $1.50 and 2.50 Hand painted plac cards, ex tra special, dozen ..,.... ..50t Thanksgiving post cards in endless (Variety, 1 each, dozen V, ..l-; ..;k:'.;.10f Handsome' 1912 calendars, large and small, priced . i...., 5. to $2.00 Calendar pads, assorted sizes and , colors, prices . ... . . .'. '.. ... ..... . . . . . . .1 upwards We Make a Specialty . , of the. 'Engraving of . Cards, Wedding ; an nsuncements, Receptions, etc. j All work guar anteed. Special Thanksgiving prices. , k i MnCf('S" GRnV(i XARDSl Suitably ' engraved' assures you of exclusive Christmas or New Year cards; order how to avoid disappointment. ; Vi - This Is the Fountain Pen Stoie Pens of every iityJe 'and -lmpet'irotti' $1.00 up. Every pen guaranteedSold pn 'V-.p ,; ;t; ': ?; 10 .days' trial. ;,-V-':.e- - v -f Thanksgiving Sale qf "Cross'' Gloves LADIES' EVENING 'GLOVES in ,16-bntton . -length, at,; special,'pair .$3.60 MEN'S EVENING GLOVES in white and biscuit chamois, at, special, pair ..,$1.50 Gold Fish for Thanksgiving Table Decorations - Real live ornaments.' prettier -than flowers. Interesting and easy ,to care for. Regular as sprunent costs $1.15. 'and consists of handsome" glass bowl, two beautiful Japanese Gold Fish, and a castle ornament to fit inside, of bowl. SPECIAL FOR THREE DAYS, beginning - tomorrow .;t;,,.'",.'.'. '.. f , .r,., 78 t Fitted Bags FITTED 'BAGS in a number of handsome, combinations.-- See our ' Washington street window, display beautiful traveling bags fitted ' in Parisian Ivory, Sterling Silver and Ebony fittings; also large line of Ladies' hand and ' overnight bags all priced exceedingly low. , , WE WEAVE ELASTIC HOSIERY AND BA.NDAGES - OPEN A MONTHLY ACCOUNT ' . WITH US fre city ' " AND SUBURBAN - DELIVERIES woo C7T Out-of-Town Folks, Take Advantage of Our Cut-Rate Prices. cimm& CO' Mail Us Your Orders. ' J