Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About The Oregon daily journal. (Portland, Or.) 1902-1972 | View Entire Issue (Dec. 3, 1907)
12 THE OREGON DAILY JOURNAL, PORTLAND, TUESDAY EVENING, DECEMBER 3, 1907. PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT'S MESSAGE TO CONGRESS Regulation and Supervision of Great Corpora tions by Government Control of Great Busi ness Interests Affected bj Interstate Com merceNo More Railroad Mergers To th Senat.- and House of Itepreaen iti- Vo nation hn greater re sources thnn ours, snd I think It enn be truthfully Bald that the rltlicna of no nation possess greater energy and in dustrial ability. In no nntlon are tho fundamental business londltlona sound er tl.an In ouri at this very moment. Mid ll la foolleh. when such la the caaa, for people to hoard monty Instead of keeping it In sound bunks; for It la uen hoarding that la the immediate oo caalon of money stilngency. Moreovor. a a rule, the business of our people la conducted with honeety and probity, and thlf appliea alike to farma and factorlca. to railroads and banka, to ail our le gitimate commercial enterprise. Id any large body of men, however, there are certain to be aome who are dlahoneat, and If the condition are auch that theae men prosper or commit thrlr misdeeds with Impunity, their example la a very evil thing for the community. "Where theae men are buslnese men of great sagacity and or temperament knik nnai mr.ulous and reckleas, and where the condition are auch tliat may act without supervision or control and at flrat without errectiv cneca irum public opinion, they delude many Inno cent people Into making investments or embeikliig tn kinds of business that are realty unsound. When the miadeeda of tbeaa ueoefully dlahoneat men are discovered, auflering cornea not omy upon them, but upon the Innocent men whom they have mlaled. It ta a painful wakening, wnenever it occura, aim. ' naturally, when It doea occur thoae who uffer axe apt to forget that tlie longer It waa deferred the more painful It would be. Jn the effort to pUnlah the guilty It la both wlae and proper to en deavor ao far aa poaalble to tnlnlmlae the dlatteaa of thoae who havo been mlaled by the guilty. Yet It la not poaaible to refrain becauae of auch dis tress from atrlving to put an end to the miadeeda that are the ultimate cauaea of the suffering, and, aa a mean a to thla nd. where poaaible to punish thoae reapon aible for them. There may be boneat dlffereneee of opinion aa to many governmental pollrlee. but aurely there can be no auch dlfferencea aa to the need of unflinching pereeverance In the war against successful dishonesty. ahould be by leglalntlnn. rautlously and rnrefully undertaken, tut rciiolutely peraevtrej In, to assert t tie sovereignty of the nntlonal government by affirm ative nrtlon "This In only in form en Innovation. In substance It la mciely a realon tliui for from t lit- .aill.nt time such regulation of Industrial actlvltlea haa been recognized In U" action of the om- 1 id mi ct the changed condlt Policy Outlined Two Tears Ago. In my message to the congreae on De cember e, lu, i said lawmaking bodies, and all tlmt I rr- txm- 1 (d mi ct the cnangeu numniuiw n such manner aa will prevent the commnnwualth abilini'mg the power it liaa always possessed, not "lily In tnia countr v. bin also In r.tigiana oerore and since thla country became, a Sepa rate rut Ion. It linn been misfortune that the natlonnl luwa on thin subject huve hitherto been of a negative or prohibi tive rather than an afflrmatliM kind, and still more that they haveWn part Bought to prohibit what could not be effectively prohibited, a.nd have In part In their prohibition confounded what ahould be allowed and what ahould not be allowed It la generally useless to trv to prohibit all restraint on com petition, whether thla restraint be rea sonable or unreasonable; and where it It not useless it In c-enerally hurtful. The successful prosecution )f upon the railway operations of the one device 10 evaae tne taw immrai-1 country. Kuch associations, in fact. exist now aa they did before theae de cisions, and with the aame general ef- ent Industrial aystera. It la not poaalble completely to prevent It; and 1 It were poaaible, auoh com plete prevention would do damage to the body politic. What we need is not valnlv to try to orevent all combination. but to secure auch rigorous Bnd ade quate control and supervision of tbe comblnatlona aa to prevent their Injur ing the public or existing In auch forma aa Inevitably to threaten In Jury. It la unfortunate that our preaent lawe ahould forbid all com blnatlona Inatead of sharply discrimi nating between those combination which do good and thoae comblnatlona which do evil. Often rail roads would like to con.hlne for the pur pose of preventing a big shipper rrom maintaining Improper advgnlngee at the expense or small shippers anil 01 m general nubile. Kuch a combination. In stead of being forbidden by law. ahould be favored It Is a public evil to have on the statute books a law In- cnpahle of full enforcement, because both Judges and Juries realise that lta run enrorcement would neatroy me, nus Inesa of the country; for the result la to make decent men violators of the law iiaalnat their wllL and to put a pre mium on the behavior of the willful wrongdoers. Such a result In turn tends to throw the decent man and tho will ful wrongdoer Into close association, and In the end to drag down the former to the latter a level, for the man who becomes a lawbreaker In one way un happily tends to lose all respect for law and to be willing to break It In many ways No more scathing con demnation could be visited upon a law than la contained In the words of the Interstate commerce commission when. In commenting upon the fact that the numero-is joint traffic aasociatinna do technically violate the law, they aay The decision of the United States au lire me court In the Trana-Mlaaourl cane and the Joint Traffic association case has produced no practical effect sulta. The dealgn ahould be to prevent the abuses Incident to the creation of unhealthy and Improper comblnatlona, Instead of waiting until they are In existence and then attempting to destroy them by civil or criminal pro ceedings A combination ahould not be toler ated If It abuse the power acquired by combination to tne pudiio detriment. No corporation or association of any Kind enouiu re permitted to engage in foreign or Interatate commerce that la formed for the nut-nose of. or whose operations create, a monopoly or gen eraj control or the production, sale, or distribution of any one or more o the prime neceaaltles of life or artlclea uf general uae and necessity. Much comblnatlona are in nit nubile do Icy; they violate the common law, the doora or tne courta are closed to thoae who are part lea to them, and 1 believe the oongreaa can eioae the channels Of In tcrstate commerce against them for lta protection. The law ahould make its, prohibition and permlnnlona as clear and definite aa poaaible, leaving the leaat possible room for arbitrary action, or allegation or auch action, on the part of the executive, or of diverg ent Interpretation by the courts. Among the polnta to be aimed at ahould ne tne prohibition of unhealthy compe tition, auch an by rendering service at an actual loaa for the purpose of crush ing out competition, the prevention of Inflation of capital, and the prohibition or a corporations making exclusive trade with Itself a condition of having any trade with Itself. Reasonable agreements between, or combinations of. corporations ahould be permitted, provided thev are flrat submitted to and approved by some appropriate gov ernment Doay. So 31 or Railroad Mergers. The congress has the power to charter corporation to engage In Interstate nd foreign commerce, and a general law can be enacted under the provisions of which existing corporations could take out federal charters and new fed eral corporations could be created. Au essential provision of such a law hould be a method of predetermining by soma federal board or commission whether the applicant for a federal charter was an aasoclatlon or combina tion within the restrictions of the fed eral law. Provision abould also be made for complete publicity In all mat tera affecting the public and complete protection to the investing public and the shareholders In the matter of Issu ing corporate securities. If an Incor poration law ta not deemed advlaable. a license act for big Interatate corpora -tlona might be enacted: or a combina tion of the two might be tried. The aupervlalon established might be analogoua to that now exercised over national banka. At least, tho anti trust act ahould be supplemented by specific prohibitions of the methods which experience has ahown have been of most service In enabling monopolis tic, combinations to crush out compe tition. The real owners of a corpora tion should be compelled to do busi ness in their own name. The right to hold atock in other corporations ahould hereafter be denied to Interstate corporations, unlesa on approval by the proper government officials, and a pre requisite to auch approval ahould ho the Hating with the government of all ownera and atoclcholders. both by the corporation owning such atock and by the corporation In which such stock la owned. To confer upon the national govern ment. In connection with the amend ment I advocate In the anti-trust law, power of supervision over big business concerns engaged in interstate com merce, would benefit them aa It has benefited the national banks. In the recent business crisis It la noteworthy that tne institutions which failed were at ly develops another device to ac complish the same purpose. What is needed Is not sweeping prohibition if every arrangement, goor or bad. which may tend to restrict competition, but such adequate supervision and regula tion as will prevent any restriction of oompelitlon from being to the detri ment of the public, aa well aa auch supervision and regulation as will pre vent other abuaea Tn no way connected with reatrlctlon of competition." I have called your attention In theie quotations to what I have already aald becauae I am aatisfled that it la tho duty of the national government to em body In action the principles thua cx preased. Interstate commerce. feet. In Justice to all parties, we ought probably to add that It Is difficult to aee how our Interatate railways could be operated with due regard to the In terest of the shipper and the railway without concerted action of the kind af forded through theae associations.' "This means that the law as con strued by the supreme court Is such that the hanking bualnesa of the coun try cannot be conducted without break ing it." No Foe? to Corporations. No small part of the trouble that we have cornea from carrying to an ex treme the national virtue of self-reli ance, of Independence In Initiative and action. It la wise to conserve this vir tue and to provide for Its fullest ex ercise, compatible with seeing that lib erty doea not become a liberty to wrong othera. Unfortunately, this Is the kind of liberty that the lack of all effective regulation inevitably breeds. The found ers of the constitution provided that the national government should have com plete and sole control of Interstate com merce. There waa then practically no Interatate business save such as was "If the folly of man mars the gen-1 conducted bv water, and thla the na- ral weil-belng, then thoae who are In-1 tlonal government at once proceeded to ttocent of the folly will have to pay I regulate In thoroutrhrolnz and effective part of the penalty incurred by those faahlon. Conditions have now ao wholly who are guilty of the folly. A panic changed that the Interstate commerce by brought on by tno speculative xouy 01 water la Insignificant compared wltn part of the bualnesa community would the amount that goes by land, and al hurt the whole bualnesa community, but moat all big bualnesa concerna are now suen stoppage oi weitare, inougn 11 engaged in interstate commerce. Aa mlaht be sever, would not be lasting In the long run, the one vital factor in the permanent prosperity of the coun try la the hlrh individual character of tne average American worner, me aver. result, it can be but usrtiallv and im perfectly controlled or regulated by the action of any one of the several states; auch action Inevitably tending to be either too drastic or else too lax. and in age American cltlaen, no matter whether I either case ineffective for purposes of hia work be mental or manual, whether iustlce. Onlv the national government be be farmer or wage worker, business I can In thorouRhRolnar fashion exercise man or professional man. I the needed control. This does not mean "In our Industrial and social system I that there should be anv extenaion of ma iiiiercale ui an men aie ciuinj i ieaenu auinornv. lor sucn aumoniv ai- intertwlned that In the Immense major- readv exists under tba constitution in ItV of cases a straight-dealing man, who I am Dies t and most far-reachina form: by his efficiency, by his Ingenuity and I but It doea mean that there should be an Industry, benefits himself, must alao extension of federal activity. This Is benefil others. Normally, the man or not advocating centralization. It is great Troductlv capacity who becomes I merely lookln facts in the face, and rich by guiding the labor of many other reaJixing that centralisation In business men aoes so or enaoting mem 10 pro- naa already come and can not he avo lol duce more than they could produce or undone, and that the public at large without hi guidance; and both he and I can only protect Itself from certain evil thev share In the benefit. Which comes effects of this huslneas rentrnllzntlnn io to tne public at large, ine super- by providing better methods for the ox flclal fact that the sharing may be un-1 ercise of control through the authority eauai must never blind u to the under-I already centralized In the nntlonal unv. lying fact that ther 1 thla sharing. I ernment by the constitution Itself. There and that the benefit comes In some de- ,cw w wmia, vuiiv ... .-v.. ...u.., the wags worker, the man of small means, and the average consumer, as well as the average producer, are all must be no halt in the healthy construct ive courae or action wnicn mis nation ha elected to pursue, and has steadily pursued, during the last six years, aa shown both In the legislation of the alike helped by making conditlona such congress and the administration of tho that the man of exceptional buslneaa law by the department of Justice. The anility receive an exceptional rewara most vital need is in connection with for his ability. Something can be done! the railroads. As to these, in my Judg by legislation to help the general pros-I ment there should now be either a na- Keruy, out no sucn neip oi a permanent- tlonal Incorporation act or a law llcens r beneficial character can be given to lng railway companies to engage in In itio less able and less fortunate save as I terstate commerce upon certain condi the result of a policy which shall inure tiorts The law should he n framt to the advantage of all Industrious and to give the Interstate commerce com- erricient people wno act aecentiy; ana mission power to paas upon the future this is only another way of saying that Issue of securities, while ample means f any penerit wnicn come to tne jess ahould be provided to enable the com able and les fortunate must or ne-1 mission, whenever In its judgment It In ' cessity come even more xo ine more I neceasary, to make a physical vahut able and more fortunate. If, therefore, 1 tlon of any railroad. As I state,) in my uiu iwuiiwu iun ib niuvcu vy I message to congress a year a(?o, rail nvy oi nus more rortunate Drotner to roads should be given power to enter ainue ai me conditions under wnicn into agreements, subject to these ngrc . they have both, though unequally, I ments being made public In minute de- proejwreu, me resuu wm assuredly tall and to the consent of the Interstuf ' ;. be that while damage may corns f commerce commission being first ob to the one struck at. It will visit I tained. Until the national government wnn an even neavier load ine one wno-T assumes proper control of lnterstati -avriKes mo oiow. iaKen as a wnoie, wo I commerce, in tne exercise or the autho must au go up or go down together. 1 Ity It already possesses, It will b- tm xei, wuiie noi merely admitting, possjoie eitner to give to or io get rrom ; but Insisting upon this, it Is also true the railroads full Justice. The rallroitiis that where there Is no governmental and all other groat corporations will do i restraint or supervision some of the wall to recognize that this control must V , exceptional men use their energies, not I come; the only question is as to what In ways that are for the common good, I governmental body can most wisely ex uui in ways wnicn leu against tnitt I ercise n. ine couris win oeierrmne, Common good. The fortunes nmnnsor! I the limits within which the federal nu- through corporate organisation are nowlthority can exercise It, and there will I mo large, and vest such power In those I still remain ample work within each that wield them, as to make It a mat- I state for the railway commission of that i - ter"-f necessity to give to the gov-1 state; and the national Interstate com arelgn -that is. to the government, merce commission will work In bar which represents the ceonle as b whnln mony with the several state commls some effective power of supervision I slons, each within Its own province, to over ineir corporate use. Jn order tn aciuuvo uio uesueu enu ,-, insure a neaiuiy social and industrial life, every big corporation should be , held responsible by, and be accountable As I have elsewhere said: "All this Is substantially what I have said over and over again. Surely It ought not to be necessary to aay that It In no shape or way represents any hos tility' to corporations as auch. On the contrary It mean a a frank recognition of the fact that combination of capi tal, like comblnatlona of labor, are a natural result of modern conditions and of our national development. As far as In my ability lies my endeavor Is and will be to prevent abuse of power by either and to favor both so long as they do well. The aim of the national gov ernment is quite as mucn to favor and protect honest corporations, honest bus iness men of wealth, aa to bring to Jus tice thoae individuals and corporations repreaentlng dlahonest methods. Most certainly there will be no relaxation by the government authorities In the effort to get at any great rail road wrecker any man who by clever swindling devices robs in vestors, oppresses wageworkers, and does Injustice to the general public. But any auch move aa this is tn the in terest of honest railway operators, of honest corporatlona, and of those who, when they Invest their small savings in stocks and bonds, wish to be assured that these will represent money honest ly expended for legitimate buslneas pur poses. To confer upon the national government the power for which I ask would be a check upon overcapl tallxa tlon and upon the clever gamblers who Denetlt by overcapitalisation. Hut It alone would mean an Increase In the value, an Increase In the safety of th stocks and bonds of law-abiding, hon estly managed railroads, and would render it far easier to market their se curitles. I believe In orooer publicity There has been complaint bf some of tne investigations recently carried on but those who complain should put the blame where It belongs UDon the mis deeds which Hre done in darkness and not upon the investigations which brought them to light. The admlnlatra tlon la responsible for turning on the light, but It Is not responsible for what the light showed. I ask for full power iu "9 given ine renerai government, be cause no single state can by legislation effectually cope with these powerful corporations engaged in Interstate com wlae be available for commercial uaes, i nd commercial borrowers ar forced to par abnormal rate, o that each fall a tax, In the shape of Increased Inter est charges. Is placed on the whole commerce or tn country. "The mere statement of these fact snows mat our preaent yatm I aor- loUBly defective. Thar nmA nf a cnange. Larortunately, however, many of th proposed change rouat be ruled from consideration because tbey ar complicated, are not aay of combrs henalon, and tend to disturb existing rlghta and Intereata. We muat alao rule out any plan which would mater ially Impair the value of the United Htstea 2 rtr rnt hnnili nnr nlMVA.l , secure circulation, the Issue of which Itance tax, however, 1 both a far better was made under conditions Decullarlv I mothnri nt .. . im. creditable to the treasury. I do not portant for the purpose of having th press any especial plan. Varlou plan fortune of the country bear In propor have recently been proposed by expert tlon to their Increase In six a eorre- iimuiniiwrs pi uansers. Among ine i aponoing increase and burden of taxa ' n i. pnsamiy ieasioie and tlon. Tlta government ha th abaolut mill, ll irilB III! IUUIU VVC Tl FUlll I rlEni in nM ll I n f.A tmnm linnn conalderatlon la that repeatedly brought which a man ahall receive a bequeat or "iniii j ni imi-boiii utisb i mm another, and this point in tary of the treasury, the essential fea-I the davnlutlnn nt i. ....... iii iui" wiih.ii mvn uwTii inuii ujr 1 appropriate ror tne impoaltlon or a tax many prominent bankera and bualness I Uwi Imposing such taxes have ronca! men. According to thla plan national edly been placed upon th national batiks should be permitted to Issue a statut book and aa repeatedly declared apeclfled proportion of their capital I conatitutlonal bv the n.nrt. n,l ti.. In notea of a given kind, the laaue to law contained th progressive prlnt-i-be taxed at so high a rate aa to drive I pie. that la after a certain amount la the notes back when not wanted In reached the beauest or rlfL In Ufa or irsiiinmio iraua. hub pinn wouia not aeain. rfl increasingly burdened and th omul in imut vi currency m aire i ruie or laxniioii l increased In propor- ...... n ,.u.,. fr.....,a, IM.T, uun iu inw rcrmuiBneBa vi oiouu oi ine iiib enieracnuy prvseuieu or umcs oilman receivinir the banuast Stringency. I These nrlnclnlas ara rvrna-nli1 .1 "I do not aay that this I th right ready In the leading civilised nations of srsism. i eniT auvance ll lo empoa- i tne world, in ureal Britain all the es size my belief that there I need for th tales worth lft non nr ! ara npariix Rdoptlon of om ayatem which ahall ally exempt from death duties, while be automatic and open to all Sound the Increase la sunn that whan an ..t.t. iiHiiKs. so aa 10 avoiu an poasioiiuy oi exceeds 16,000.000 In value and passes to discrimination and favoritism. Such a a distant kinsman or stranger In blood plan would tend to prevent the spasms th government receive all told an of high money and speculation which amount equivalent to nearly a fifth of now obtain In the New York market; th whole estate. In Tranc ao much of i present mere is 100 mucn cur- an inheritance as exceeds 110.000 000 r ... Immediate Attention to Cutfency Ref ornrNeeded Condition Effort to Uproot Tariff Would Cause Widespread Disaster ' Sherman Anti-Trust Law. Moreover, In my Judgment there to. some sovereign strong enough to MO;eoler' in,.,my, iud&rnnt then control Its conduct I am In no sense ?hou1 be additional legislation look nosuie 10 corporations. This Is on age of combination, and any effort to : prevent all combination will be not oqly useless, but In the end vicious, because of the contempt for law which the fail ure to enforce law Inevitably produces. W should, moreover, recognize in cor dial and ample fashion the immense good effected by corporate agoncles .'n a country such as ours, and the vcalth of Intellect, energy and fidelity devoted to their service, and therefore normally . to the ervlce of the public, by their of- licers ana directors. Tne cornoratlon lng to the proper control of th great business concerns engaged in in terstate business, this control to be ex erclsed for their own benefit and pros perity no less than for the protection of investors and of the general public. As I have repeatedly said In messages to congress and elsewhere, experience has aeriniieiy shown not merely the un wisdom but the futility of endeavoring to put a stop to ail business combina ttons. Modern industrial conditions are such that combination is not only neC' cssary but inevitable. It is so in the haa i-nma to anv tnat q .v.. ..'v. world of business Just as it is so In the 7 . . . . L1 fill 13 I ..,,,,! f. f IqKa. ar.,4 1 I. a. iAlv. union naa come 10 siay. cacn man can """" ; do and has done great good. Each 8 re t Put anend to all corporations, to should be favored so long as It does 511 .b'K. combinations of capital as to good. But each should be sharDlv desire to put an end to combinations of i, ji it f . labor. Cornoration snrt Inhnr union iium cu n u u o 11 a.&.iin i law .n. I ... ... t.i.iioa suae nave Justice. " Coremment Control Needed, come to stav. Each if DroD- ( erly managed Is a source of good and not evil. Whenever in either there Is evil. It should be nromotlv helrt tn in. The makara nf nnr r,ntii count; out It should receive heartv en- ' eonttitutlon provided especially that the agemen s. 1od5 Bs 11 18 properly regulation of IntersUte commerce I m.a.naed- It Profoundly Immoral to , should com within the sphere of tho general government. The arguments . In favor of their taking this stand : were oven then overwhelming. But they are far stronger today, in view of the enormou development of great . buSluess agencies, usually corporate In ' form.. Experience has shown conclu sively that It Is useless to try to get any adequate regulation and supervl- ; slon of the great corporafTons by tat action. . Such regulation and au- . pervlsloa can evJy be effectively exe clsed by a aovengn whose Jurisdiction . ta ootxtenalve, with . th field work of me corporation -vna i, la, oy tn na tlonal government. J bellev that thla regulation and aupervlalon car be b tauied by th enactment of law by the coagresa j . .. Out iteady alm put or keep on the statute books a law, nominally In the Interest of public mor- ..i.fi. T ""'J, puV" premium upon ?ubk!i1S '""frailty, by undertaking to forbid honest men from doing what J2,nVm don under modern business S?nfiUh "l f. that in law Itself pro e5.Anh.iJi' own Jnrractlon mu.f bo the -condition precedent upon buslneas success. To aim at the awomplUhmS" of too much usual y means the accom plishment of top little, and of teV the 5oing of positive damage, in my mes sage to congress a year ago, In SDeakinar of the antitrust lawa. I ?aid P " "The actual working of our law has shown that the effort to prohibit all combination, good or bad, la noxious where IV is not ineffective, Combina tion cf capital. Ilk combination of la bor,, la a necessary element in our pre merce. and. while (lolntr them full Ius tlce, exact from them in return full Jus tice to otners. rne conditions of rail road activity, the conditions of our Im mense Interstate commerce are Buch as to maKe the central government alone competent to exercise full supervision nmi control. "The gravo abuses in individual cases or railroad management In the past rep- i mi ni w rungs noi merely to tne general public, but. above all. wrona-s to fair- dealing, and honest corporations and men of wealth, because they excite a Popular anger and distrust which from the very nature of the case 'tends to in clude in the sweep of Its resentment good and bad alike. From the stand point of the public I can not too e.-ir- nestly say that us soon as the natural ;u:d proper resentment aroused by these abuses becomes Indiscriminate and un- uuiiKing. It also becomes not merelv unwise and unfair, but calculated to de !fe;it the very ends which those feeling ll have in view. There has been plenty I "f dishonest work by corporations In I the n-ist. There will not be the slight est let-up In the effort tn h unt Hnivn and lumlsh every dishonest man. But the bulk of our business is hnnmMv done. In the natural Indignation tho people ieel over tho dishonesty, it Is all essential that they should not lose their hi ails and t;( t drawn Into an indiscrim inate r;i Id upon all corporations, all people of wealth, whether they do well or 1.1. Out of any such wild movement good will not come, cannot come, and never has come. On the contrary, the surest way to Invite reaction is to fol low the lad of either demagogue or visionary In a sweeping assault upon property values and upon public con fidence, which would work incalculable damage In the business world and would produce such distrust of the agitators wiai mi im; irvuision tne distrust would extend to honest men who, In sincere ?h Bait6 fashloni are trying to remedy Institutions which were not under the supervision and control of the national government. Those which were under national control stood the test. National control of the kind above ad vocated would be to the benefit of every well-managed railway, rrom the stand point of the public there is need for ad ditional tracks, additional terminals, and improvements in the actual handling of the railroads, and all this as rapidly as possible. Ample, safe and speedy trans portation facilities are even more neces sary than cheap transportation. There fore, there Is need for the Investment of money which will provide for all these things while at the same time se securlng as far as possible better wages and shorter hours for their em ployes. Therefore, while there must he just and reasonable regulation of rates. we should be the first to protest against rency at certain aeaaona of the year, pay over a fifth to th state If It nu its accumulation ai new ior paaaea to a dlatant relative. Th Oer- .m r aa Kat nli a r-ai t land I at 1 n aia I t I t . . . . . T or speculative purpoaea: whereas at I becauae It makes tha Inharitann. il other tlmea when the crops are being imperial measure while allot Inr td tha moved there Is urgent need for a large I Individual atatea of th empire a por but temporary Increaae In the currency tlon of the proceed and permitting them auppiy. ii muBi never oo lorgoiien to impoee taxe In addition to thoae im mat tnia queation concern ousinea poaed by th Imperial government. Wmall men generally quite as much as bank- Innerltances are exempt, but th tax I ers; especially la thla true of atockmen. ao aharply progressive that when the innarra, aim uunmess mrn in ma west; innernanc is still not very large, pro- for at present at certain seasons of the vlded It Is not an agricultural or a for- year the difference In Interest rates be- est land, It is taxed at the rate of 21 tween the east and the west Is from ( per cent If It goes to distant relatives, to 10 per cent, whereas In Canada the Ther I no reason Why In the United corresponding difference I but 2 per States the national government should cent. Any plan muat, of course, guard not I m cos a lnherltanra ta.aa In ,i,n lion to thosa imposed by the states, and when we last had an inheritance tax about one half of the states levied such taxes concurrently with the national government, making a combined maxi mum rate. In some cases as high as 26 por cent.. The French law has one fea ture which is to be heartily commended The progressive principle Is so applied that each higher rate la Imnnserf nnlv on tha exceaa above the amount subject to the next lower rate; so that each Increase of rat will apply only to a certain amount above a certain maxi mum. The tax should If possible be made to bear more heavily upon those resiaing witnoui tne country than w th in it A heavy progressive tax upon a very large fortune is In no way such a tax upon tnrirt or industry as a like tax would-be on a small fortune. No advantage limci either to the country as a whole or to the Individuals Inherit ing the money by nermlttlna the trans mission in their entirety of the enorH mous rortunes wnicn would be affected by such a tax; and as an Incident to Its function of revenue raising, such a tax would help to preserve a measurable eouallty of opportunity for the people of the generations growing to man hood. We have not the slightest sympathy with that socialistic Idea which would try to put lar.lness, thrlftlessness and lnorriclency on a par with Industry, thrift and efficiency; which wouid any arbitrary and unthinking movement by dlslutnv-Vv leopardTo? to cut them down without, the fullest 1 fiS and most careful consideration of all ,,.il T" Vn... v. Inla.ual. nnrrnrra , i fU. .....! limn 1 1 wiuv.i 1 1 , ici iu tw ui IIHIIIB, lUf lll.'lv.l. .'.Ill . I ,1.1, KIIU V i 1 1 1 U U . . I UUl need of the. situation. Only a special body of men acting for the national government under authority conferred upon it by the congress Is competent to pass Judgment on such a matter. Precedent Been Established. Those who fear, from any reason, the extension of federal activity will do well to study the history not only of the national banking act but of the pure-food law, and notably the meat inspection law recently enacted. . The pure-food law was opposed so violently that its passage was delayed for a dec ade: yet it has worked unmixed and Im mediate good. The meat Inspection law was even more violently assailed; and the same men who now denounce the attitude of the national government In seeking to oversee and control the workings of Interstate common carriers and business concerns then asserted that we were "discrediting and ruining a great American industry." Two years have not elapsed, and already It has be come evident that the great benefit the law confers upon the public is accom panied by an equal benefit to the rep utable packing establishments. The lat ter are better off under the law than they wore without it. The benefit to Interstate common carriers and business concerns from the legislation I advo cate would be equally marked. Pure Food Law. Incidentally, In the passage of the Dure-food law the action of the varloua state food and dairy commissioners ! that our foreign trade is encouraged. the Interests of western and southern bankers as carefully as It guards the Interests of New York or Chicago hank ers, and must be .drawn from the stand points of the farmer and the merchant no less than from tne standpoints of the city banker and the country banker." Greater Elasticity Needed. I again urge on the congress the need of Immediate attention to this matter. We need a greater elasticity In our cur rency; provided, of course, that we re cognize the even greater need of a safe and secure currency. There must al wavs be the most rigid examination bv the national authorities. Provision should be made for an emergency cur rency. The emergency lasue ahould, of course, be made with an effective guar anty, and upon conditions carefully pre scribed by the government. Such emer gency issue must be based on adequate securities approved by the government, and must be Issued under a heavy tax. This would permit currency being Is sued when the demand for it was ur gent, while securing its retirement as the demand fell off. It is worth In vestigating to determine whether offi cers and directors of national banka should ever be allowed to ldan to them selves. Trust companies should be sub ject to the same supervision as banks; legislation to this effect should be en-1 acted for the District of Columbia and the territories, Yet we must also remember that even tho wisest legislation on the subject can oniy accomplish a certain amount. No legislation can bv any possibility guarantee the business community against tne results or speculative folly any more man it can guarantee an In dividual against the results of his ex trsvagance. When, an Individual mort gages his house to buy an automobile he Invites disaster, and when wealthy men, or men who pose as such, or are unscrupulously or foolishly eager to he come such, Indulge In reckless specu lation especially if It Is accompanied only of all thev expose the whole business community to panic ana distress. The income account of the nation Is in a most satisfactory condition. For tne six riscai years ending with the 1st of July last? tno total expenditures and revenues of the national government, ex clusive of the postal revenues and ex penditures, were. In round numbers, revenues, $3,465,000,000, and expend itures, $3,275,000,000. The net excess of Income over expenditures. Including In the latter the $50,000,000 expended for the Panama canal, was 1190,000,000 for tne six years, an average of about $31, 000,000 a year. This represents an ap proximation between Income and outgo which it would be hard to improve. The satisfactory working of ftie present tar iff law has been chiefly responsible for this excellent showing. Nevertheless, there Is an evident and constantly growing feeling among our people that the time Is rapidly approaching when our system of revenue legislation must be revised. protect thos right which from Mm to time It unwarrantably Invade. More over, dlacontent I often expressed with th uae of the proceaa of Injunction by th court, not only In labor dlsput, but where atat law are concerned. I refrain from discussion of thla queation aa I am Informed that It will anon ra. colv conalderatlon of th aupreme court. ine leuerai court muat or courae de cide ultimately what are th respective aphorea of state and nation In connec tion with any law. atata nr natlnnaL and they muat decide definitely and fin ally In matters affecting individual cit laen. not only a to the right and wrong of labor but a to th right and wrongs of capital; and th national gov ernment muat alwaya aee that th de cision of th court la put Into effect The process of Intunctlnn la an aaaantlal adjunct to the court' doing It work well; and aa preventive meaaure ar al ways better than remedial tha of thla process I from .every stand point commendable. But where tt la recklessly or unnecessarily uaad. tha abuse should be censured, above all by th very men who are properly anxloua to prevent anv effort tn ahaar tha mt rt a of thla necessary power. The court' de cision must be final; th protest I only against the conduct of individual Judge In needlessly anticipating auch final da. clalon, or In the tyrannical uae of what I nominally a teniDorarv Injunction ta accomplish what I In fact a permanent decision. Accident. The loas of life and limb from railroad accidents In thla country ha become ap- paiiiuK- ii a buujbci oi wnicn in na tional government abould tak super vision. It might be well to beein hv providing for a federal Inspection of In terstate railroads somewhat alone- tha line of federal Inspection of steamboats, aunougn noi going so rar; pernaps at first all that It would be necessary to have would be some officer whose duty would be to Investigate all accident on Interatate railroads and report In de tail the causes thereof. Such an offl- -er should make It his business to get into close touch with railroad operat ing men so as to become thoroughly familiar with every side of the ques tion, the Idea being to work along the lines of the present steamboat Inspec tion law. strive i to break up not merely private property, mil wnat is rar more import ant. tne home, the chief prop upon wnicn our wnoie civilization stands. Such a theory. If ever adopted, would mean the ruin of the entire country a ruin wnicn would bear heaviest upon the weakest, upon those least able to shift for themselves. But proposals for leg (station such a thla herein advocated are directly opposed to this class of so cialistic theories', our aim Is to recog nlze what Lincoln pointed out: The fact that there are some respects tn which men are obviously rot eaual: but also to insist mat mere should be an equal' Ity of self-respect and of mutual re spect, an equality of rights before the law, ana at least an approximate eoual ity in the conditions under which each man obtains the chance to show the stuff that Is In him when compared to nis reiiows. Enforcement of the Law. No Tariff Revision Now. This country Is definitely committed to the protective system and any effort to uproot it could not but cause wide spread Industrial disaster. In other words, the principle of the present tar iff law could not with wisdom be changed. But In a country of such phe nomenal growth as ours It Is probably well that every dozen years or so the tariff law should be carefully scrut inized so. as to see that no excessive or Improper benefits are conferred thereby, that proper revenue Is provided, and Open the Books. The anti-trust law should not be re Pealed; but It should be made both more efficient and mora in harmony with ac tual conditions. It should be ho amend ed as to forbid only the kind of com bination which does harm to the general public, such amendment to be accom panied by, or to be- an Incident of, a grant of supervisory power tn the mv. ernment over these big concerns en gaged in interstate bust should be accompanied by provision for the compulsory publication of and the subjection of books and papers in me iiinucciiun ui me irovernment nf. flclals. A beginning has al readv h.n made for such supervision by the es tablishment of the bureau of cornors- tions. Th antitrust law should not nrft. hlblt combinations that do no Injustice to the public, still less those the exist ence of which Is on the whole of bnneflt to the public. But even if this fonfura of the law were abolished, there would remain as an equally objectionable fea ture the difficulty and delay now Inci dent to Its enforcement. The govern ment must now submit to Irksome and repeated delay before obtaining a final decision of the court upon proceeding mauiuiea, ana even a. ravoraoie decree may mean an empty victory. More over, to attempt to control theae cor poration by laweults means to Impose upon both th department of Justte and the court an impossible burden; It Is not feasible to carry on mor than a limited number of such suit. Such a law to be really effective must of course be administered by an executive body, and not merely toy mean of law- showed in striking fashion how much gooa ror tne whole people results from the hearty cooperation of th federal and state officials In securing a given reform. It is prlmarllv to the action' of these state commissioners that we owe the enactment of this law; for they aroused the people, first to demand the enactment and enforcement of state laws on the subject, and then the en actment of the federal law, without which the state laws were largely in effective. There must be the closest cooperation between the national and state governments In administering itieee ihw. Currency Reform. In my message to the ennsreaa year ago I spoke as follows of the cur rency: "1 especially call your attention to ine conauion or our currency laws. The national-bank act has ably served a Brum purpose m tuning me enor mous business Development of the country, and within 10 years there has been an increase in circulation por capita irom i.n 10 jjs.us. f or sev eral years evidence has been accumu lating that additional legislation 1 needed. The recurrence ' of each crop season emphasizes the defects of the present laws. There must soon be a revision of them, because to leave them as they are means to incur liability of Dusiness aisasier. oince your Doay ad journed there has been a fluctuation In th interest on call money from 2 per cent to SO per cent., and the fluctua tion was ven greater during the pre ceding six month. The secretary of the treasury had to tep In and by wise action put a stop to the moat violent period of oacillatlon. Even worse than such fluctuation Is the advance in commercial rates and the uncertainty felt In the sufficiency of credit even at high rates. All commercial inter ests' suffer during each crop period. Excessive rates for call money In New York attract money from .the interior banks Into the speculative field. This, deplete the . fund that would other- There must always be as a minimum a tarlrr which, will not only allow for the collection of an ample aevenue but which will at least make good the dif ference in the labor cost here and ahnmd for the well-being of the wage-worker must ever be a cardinal point of Am erican policy. The question should be approached purely rrom a business standpoint; both the time and the man ner of th change being such as to arouse the minimum of agitation and disturbance in the business world, and to give the least play for selfish and factional motives, t The sole considera tion should be to see that the sum total of changes represents the public good. This means tnat the subject can not with wisdom be dealt with In the year preceding a presidential election, because as a -matter of fact experience has con clusively shown that at such a time it Is Impossible to get men to treat It from the standpoint of the public good. In my Judgment the wise time to deal with the matter is immedjately after such election. Income and Inheritance Tax. When our tax laws are revised tha question of an income tax and an In heritance tax should receive the careful attention or our legislators. jn my Judgment both of these taxes should be part of our system of federal taxation. I sneak, diffidently about the incomn tnv because on schema for an Income tax was declared unconstitutional byA the supreme court; while In addition It is a difficult tax to administer in its nra. tical working, and great care would nave 10 oe exerciBeu to see mat it was not X,- occur, and the resentment in the minds or tnose wno reel tnat tneir rignts are being invaded and their liberty of action and of speech unwarrantably restrained continue likewise-to grow. Much of the attack on the use of the process of in junction I wholly without warrant; but I am constrained to express the be lief that for some of it there Is war rant. Thla question I becoming more and more one of prim Importance, and unless th court will themselves deal with it in effectiv manner, it la certain ultimately to demand some form of leg islative action. It would be moat un. fortunate for our social welfare If wo ahould permit many honest and -law. abiding citizen to feel that they had lust cause zor regarding our courts with hostility, I earnestly commend to the attention of the congress thla matter, mn ha anma viv mav ha ifavlaait HrklAh will declaro constitutional. Th inner,! will limit tho abuse of injunction and A few years ago there was loud com plaint that the law could not he Invoked against wealthy offenders. There Is no sucn complaint now. The course of the department of Justice during the last few years has been such as to make it evident that no man stands above the law. that no corporation is so wealthy that It can not be held to account. The department of Justice has been as prompt to proceed against the wealthiest malefactor whose crime was one of greed, and cunning as to proceed against the agitator who Incites to brutal vio lence. Everything that can be done un der the existing law, and with the ex isting state of public opinion, which so profoundly Influences both the courts and Juries, has been done. Hut the laws themselves need strengthening in more than one Important point; they should be made more definite, so that no honest man can be Jed unwittingly to break them, and so that the real wrongdoer can fio readily punished. Moreover, there must be the public opinion back of the laws or the laws themselves will be of no avail. At present, while the average Juryman un doubtedly wishes to see trusts broken up, and is quite reody to fine tho cor poration itself, he Is very reluctant to find the facts proven beyond a reason able doubt when It comes to sending to Jail a member of the business commun ity for Indulging In practices which are profoundly unhealthy, but which, unfor tunately, the business community has grown to recognize as well-nigh nor mal. Both the present condition of tho law and the present temper of Juries render it a task of extreme difficulty to get at the real wrongdoer in any such case, especially by Imprisonment. Yet It is from every standpoint far prefer able to punish the prime offender by Im prisonment ratner man to line me cor poration, with the attendant damage to stockholders. Tho two great evil In the execution of our criminal laws today are senti mentality -and technicality. - For tha latter the remedy must come from the hands of the legislature, the courts, and the lawyers. The other must de pend for its cure upon the gradual growth of a sound publio Opinion which shall Insist-that regard for the law and the demands of reason shall control all other Influence and amotion In the Jury box. Both of these evils must be removed or public discontent with , the criminal law will continue. Injunctions. j instance oi abuse in tne granting or I islatlon un injunctions in labor disputes continue to tablished by all tha European countries. Employers' Liability. The national government should be a model employer. It should demand the highest quality of service from each of its employes and It should care for all of them properly in return. Con- frreaa should adopt legislation provld ng limited but definite compensation for accidents to all workmen within the scope of the federal power, Includ ing employes of navy yard and ar senals. In other words, a model em ployers' liability act, far-reaching and thoroughgoing, should be enacted which should apply to all position, public and private, over which the national government has Jurisdiction. The num ber of accidents to wage-workers, In cluding those that are preventable and those that are not, has become appall ing In the mechanical, manufacturing. and transportation operations of the day. It works grim hardship to th ordinary wage-worker and hi family to have the effect of such an accident fall solely upon him; and, on the other hand, there are whole classes of attorney who exist only by Inciting men who may or may not have been wronged to undertako suits for negligence. As a matter of fact a suit for negligence I generally an Inadequate remedy for t person Injured, while It often causes al together disproportionate annoyance to the employer. The law should be made such that the payment for accident by tho employer would be automatic in stead of being a matter for lawsuit. workmen should receive certain and definite compensation for all accident In Industry Irrespective of neallaenae. The employer I the agent of the public and on his own responsibility and for nis own prone ne serves tn publio When ho start In motion agencies which create risks for others, he should take all the ordinary and ex traordinary risk Involved; and tha risk he thus at the moment assume will ultimately be assumed, a It ought to be. by the general public. Only In this way can the shock of the accident be diffused, Instead of falling upon th man or woman least bdib to Dear it, as Is now the case. The community at large should share the burdens as well as the benefits of Industry. By th proposed law. employers would gain a desirable certainty of obligation and get rid or litigation to determine It, while the workman and his family would be relieved from a crushing load. With such a policy would come Increased care, and accidents would be reduced n number. The national law provld- ng or employer' liability on rail roads engaged in interstate commerce and for safety appliances, as well as for diminishing the hours any employ of a railroad ahould be permitted to work, should all be strengthened where ever In actual practice they have shown weakness; they should be kept on the statute books In thoroughgoing form. Tho constitutionality of the employ ers' liability act passed by th preced ing congress nas been carried beror the courts. In two Jurisdictions the law has been declared unconstitutional, and In three Jurisdictions Its constitu tionality has been affirmed. The ques tion has been carried to the supremo court, the case ha been heard by that tribunal, and a decision I expected at an early date. In the event that the court should affirm the constitutional ity of the act. I urge further legislation along the lines advocated In my mes sage to the preceding congress. The practice of putting the entire burden of loss to life or limb upon the victim or the victim's family Is a form of so cial Injustice in which the United States stands In unenviable prominence. In both our federal and our-state leg islation we have, with few exceptions, scarcely gone farther than the repeal of the fellow-servant principle of the old law of liability, and in some of our states even this slight modification of a completely outgrown principle has not yet been secured. The legislation of the rest of the , Industrial world stands out In striking contrast to our back wardness In this respect. Since 185 practically every country of Europe, together with Great Britain, New Zea- Aunti-olla Vtrltfah r'nlnmhl ami the 'Cape of 6ood Hope has enacted legislation embodying In one form or another the complete recognition of the principle whicn place upon the em ployer the entire trade risk In the var ious lines of industry. I urge upon tho congress the enactment of a law which will at the same time bring federal leg islation up to the standard already' es- evaded by the very men whom It wa most desirable to nave taxed, for If so evaded It would, of course, be worse than no tax at all: aa the least tir. able of all taxes Is the tax which bears heavily upon the honest as compared with the dishonest man. Nevertheless graduated income tax of the proper type would be a desirable feature of federal taxation, and It I to be hoped that one mm v pa uvriwu wmun ine supreme court and which will serve as a stimulus) to the various states to perfect their leg islation in this regard. - Eight-Hour Law. The congress should .consider tha ex tension of the eight-hour law. The con-i. stltutlonallty of the present law ha re cently been called Into Question, and th supreme court has decided that the ex isting legislation Is unquestionably within the power of the congress. The . principle of the eight-hour day should " as rapidly and as far a practicable be extended to the entire work carried on y the government; ana in present law hould be amended to embrace contracts on thoae public work which th pre ; ent wording of th act haa been con Trued to exclude- Th general Intro duction of the Tght-hour day ahould be the goal toward which we ahould -r'''-:?: -V-i'