3 j j. -4, . ..w 4J.v!!'-.'K. - PAGE EIGH1. ASTORIA,. ORECON, WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 20. WORK TO BE CONTINUED Government Engineers Favorable to Improvement of Cut-Off I , . Channel in Upper Harbor. PROTEST IS TURNED 4 " " V, DOWN Major Langfitt Says Xw, Open ; iiiff Is Much More Tractl. v cable Than Ono Formerly V . in Use There. " - t The effort of th Astoria " Chamber of Commerce to have abandoned work on what ia known as the cut-oft has been unsuccessful thus far, . channel al though the 'matter will not be dropped. The cut-off channel is of -recent cre ation. Formally the channel at t the eastern end of the harbor followed the shore almost to the Tongue, but the cut-off opened up near the Sylvia de Grasse reef and the dredge Ladd im mediately commenced work there. Lower Astoria harbor at once com raenced Ailing below and protest was filed against the work of deepening this cut-off channel ' The chamber has received replies to its letters from Robert Shaw Oliver, acting secretary of war, and Briga dier-General. Makenkie, chief of en gineera, U. -S. A." Mr. Oliver refers to Major Langfltt's report upon the subject, while General ' Mackensle adds that "any attempt to revert the old channel would ' unquestionably excite opposition among those Inter ested In the deep water shipping trade of Portland and other points above Astoria, and could hardly fail to have an unfortunate effect, if suc cessful." The report of Major Langfitt, which followed the protest of the chamber. Is Inclosed by General Mackenzie. It is as follows: "A petition dated January , ; 1902, was sent to this office by a number of licensed masters and pilots engaged in piloting deep-draft vessels between Portland and Astoria, requesting that the dredge Ladd be put to work on the cut-off channel complained of in the petition. "Authority was asked to do the work In a letter to the chief of engineers dated January S, 1903. and approved by him. The reasons set forth In my letter in favor of opening this channel and abandoning the channel by Sylvia de Grasse reef and the cut above Tongue Point still hold good. Briefly stated, they were: "That the depth along .this new channel had been Increasing naturally, and with but little work there, the pilots claimed, they would be enabled to avoid the bad portion of the old Sylvia de Grasse reef; that, even with the imDrovement of Silvia de Grasse reef, then contemplated and under the contract, the new channel, they claimed, would be better, with some dredging, than the old. "Taking the statements of the pe tition of the Astoria Chamber of Commerce in detail, I would make the following remarks: "First The water seems to flow much more naturally along the new channel than through the old cross ing, as is shown by the relative amount of dredging required to keep them open. During the two years foilowln the opening of this cut, from August 24, 1902, to August 24, 1904, the total dredging done on the channel was 109 days, and. with the exception of a short period when there was only 1T feet, the ruling depth at mean low water has been 18Vi nl JO As compared with this, the old crossing shows very un favorably, for the latter has required almost as much dredging each year and would shoal up quickly to about 16 feet as soon as dredging stopped. "Second The old channel by Sylvia de Grasse reef is tortuous and dn gerous, as it winds around the reef. To increase the depth along the As toria front would be very expensive, as many places are rooky. Third What may be the causes of the shoaling of the harbor of Astoria It is Impossible to say with the tilfor- I matlon at hand, but it can hardly be due to the dredging of the new chan nel, as the work is so arranged that dredging is done on the lower portion only- during flood tide. "In conclusion, I would say that the actual dredging out of this new chan nel has not only confirmed all that was exoevted. but has given the greatest satisfaction to all parties in terested in navigation between Port land and the sea. To return to the old route would mean greater expense every year for less results and more danger to vessels." ' COST WOULD1 . BE NOMINAL Pressed Brick Gty Hall Could Be Erected for $15,000, Says One of the Contractors. MUCH DEPENDS ON OFFERED TO CITY PUPILS. Commercial Gymnasium May Be Plaesd at Their Disposal. At a special meeting of the board of directors of the Commercial Club last night, high school students were asked to make an effort to form a large class in physical culture. The club has ample gymnasium facilities. and if enough pupils can be Induced to Join the class the gymnasium will un questionably be set aside for the use of the school boys and girls. The high school " students promised to take up the matter with, City Superintendent Clark. The directors granted the girls of the high school use of the gym nasium Friday night, when a vaude vllle entertainment will be held. Four new members were admitted last even ing. There is considerable talk of In stalling tenpin alleys at the club, and at an adjourned meeting to be held Thursday night the report of a spec ial committee appointed to Investigate the proposal will be received. Ten pins Is now being generally bowled, and, while cocked-hat will continue to be the standard game at the club, it is believed many will take up with the other game. The club Is In flourish ing condition at present and every week Is adding materially to Jtsmem bershlp. PLANS irrialn llulMlnjr Is Df Hired Al Icrutlous Would Entail Oat. lay That Would Be JuHtlBed. " PERSONAL MENTION. Mr. and Mrs. J. R. Burke were in the city yesterday from Cathlamet. William Bell left last night for White Sulphur springs to spend a few weeks. Will S. Martin, a well known Port land traveling man, was in the city yesterday. ' Mrs. A. G. Hardesty, of Chicago, has arrived in the city and will spend the winter with her son, M. F. Hardesty, . Senator and Mrs. J. G. Megler, of Brookfleld, were In the city yesterday. They returned home on the night boat. Will Clinton will return immediately from Valdez, Alaska, to assume charge of the business affairs of his father, the late Nicholas Clinton. Yesterday County Clerk Clinton wired his brother at Valdez. The message was sent at 11 o'clock, and three hours later a re ply was received. White Star and Cunard line tickets for Europe sold at Kallunkl's candy store. . The proposal for the erection of a - i brick city hall meets with popular ap proval. Stnce the matter was' brought before the city ' council many tax payers have expressed themselves' fa vorably upon the contemplated change in the plans, and It Is believed that the brtck building will be provided for. Mr. Ferguson, one of the contrac tors, was asked yesterday whether or i not It would be possible now to provide for an alteration such as has been suggested. He made an affirmative re-1 ply, saying it would . probably be pos- Ible to countermand the lumber or ders at very little expense. As to the cost of a brick building In excess of the cost of a wooden structure, it would be difficult to make an estimate without doing some fig uring," suld Mr. Ferguson. believe, however, that a pressed brick build ing could be erected at a cost of about $15,000 In excess of the; contract price of the wooden structure. A plain, brick building would cost about 110,000 more. These figures are not given to you as accurate, for I have not figured the difference in cost. 'The excess expense attached to the construction of a brtck building would depend largely on the design used. If a plain building, such as I would fuvor, were to be planned, the cost would not be great, but a lot of fancy work would entail considerable expense.' It de pends entirely upon what the city wants." " Several considerations have prompt ed the suggestion that brick be used The new city halk will be surrounded by wooden structures, and Are would make short work of a wooden city hall. The danger would be greatly lessened If brick were used. A wooden building would be temporary In character. while a brick structure would be "per manent. So far as the cost Is concern ed, the city could better now Incur an obligation of this sort than at any other time In Its history. The 'debt Is about $150,000, so there is ample leeway. It Is estimated that the' cost of the bailding .contracted for would be about $40,000, while a pressed "brick structure, which would be permanent and a credit to the city, could be built for $55,000. " ttttttttItItttttTTtTTTtttITTTTTIlIlIIIlTTT1TTYrrTTIIXIIITlllIlIirTTT OVERCOATS The Kind That Wear! The Kind That Hold the Shape! We keep them pressed for you FREE OF CHARGE HERMAN WISE Astoria's Great Clothier. IIIIIXIlIIIIIIlIIIIirimiTXJrmillllllTTTTTTTTTT TTTtllttlTTTTTtlTtTttTVTttTttr STANDING ROOM ONLY.. Hedrick's Unable to Hold Crowd That 8ought Admittance.- At Hedrick's theater last night the attendance record was broken, for the S. R. O. sign was In evidence from the second act of the first show" until the concluding performance. The, patrons of 10-cent theaters rarely get so evenly balanced a bill as - the one at Hedrick's this week elegant scenes. fine costumes, plenty pf comedy, the cleverest ring and trapeze act . ever seen here, together with the Chinese musical act, which also enjoys the dis tinction of excelling any other similar novelty. The moving pictures and il lustrated song were, as usual, up to date, and the verdict of the crowd was that the bill was never equaled for the money. Tonight will afford theatergoers th last opportunity of seeing this splendid show, as there will be a complete change of acts on Thursday. There will be two Saturday matl nees. Everybody attending will be presented with a sobophone. On Sun day afternoon another candy matinee will be given. t 4 KNOK MAKES HIS REPLY. 8cores Parker and Cleveland for Their Recent "Trust" Speeches. Washington, Oct 25, Senator Knox, who until recently was attorney-general, tonight Issued a statement In ans wer to Purker's speech on trusts and Cleveland's remnrks on the same topic. The statement is lengthy and Is d caustic arraignment of Judge Parker, D. B. Hill and New York democrats. HOTEL ARRIVALS. Parker House. Fred Osborn, Hammond. ' ; L. L. Long, Portland. W. E. Clancy, Vhlnook, Wash. ' M. Anderson, Chlnook,"Wash. , R. B. Magruder, Portlaid. j , , ...... M. W. PUlsbury, Portland. Augus Gor, Portland. i J, B. Stlllwell, Portland. . Henry Johnson, Nasel, Wash. P. J. Young, McGowan, Wash. W. C. Snow, Portland, C, M. de Somer. Portluhd. A. F. Edwards. Portland. --r-r : Card of Thanks. J- To the many kind friends whose at tention and sympathy have been offered me in my affliction, and especially to the nfrmbers of the Eagles and Red Men, 1 desire to express my sincere -thanks and appreciation. LEE HERRING. ft i DGJPfflAl , Try the New Size mm ' Made from the cream of Havana crop We sold 20,000 in September, the largest sale of any Cigar on the market. Manufactured by JOHN V. BURNS ASTORIA, OREGON aBaaaaaaaaaaaaaaanaaaBaaaaaaaaaaaaari The Palace Cafe aaaaaaaaaaua The Best Restaurant Pf f uif Meals. 25 Cents Sunday Dinners a Specialty E erythlnf the Market Affords Palace Catering Company a'aaaaaatttttjaaaaaaBaaaaaik SHOES The Real Test Is Wear. We realize that most peo ple who wear shoes want style as well as quality, there fore you can't afford to buy your shoes before looking over our line of shoes. Prices for men: f 1.00, $1.50, $2.00, $2.25, $2.50, $3.00 and the famous White House shoes $3.50. Ladies shoes from $1.00 to $3.25. Our line of infant's, children's and misses' shoes is es pecially strong, prices from 25c to $2.00 in Box Calf, Kui garoo, Vici and Patent Leather. ' We have solved the School Shoe Problem, . Buy your boys the Good for "Bad Boys Shoe" or the "District 76" and you will realize we ar9 telling the truth. Our CLOAK AND SUIT $ " ' DEPT. Offers clever novelties in Suits, Tourists' Coats, Crave nettes and Walking Skirts. These are garments juhtly term ed the Top Notch of Style,, Attractiveness and Durability at prices that will suit the most shrewd buyers. UNDERWEAR ' This is where we lead. k We carry the Puritan Brand Each garment well made, cleaOj kiuid durable. Now is the time to prepare for cold weather. Children,' Cotton Fleece Vests and Pant? from 14c to 35c. Children's and Misses' Woolen Garments from 25c to 75c. Boy' Heavy Fleece Linod Garments 25c a garment Ladies' Cotton Heavy Fleece Lined 25c A garment. . Ladies' Woolen Garments from 48c to $1.75. 1 adies' Silk Garments from $2.00 to $3 50, Men's Heavy Cotton Fleece Lined $1.00 a suit. Men's Woolen $1.50 to $3,80 a suit..., . ' Men's All Wool Garments, an excellent value $3.80 a suit We also show a strong line of Flannel Night Gowns. ' - You Can Buy Them Cheaper at the BEE HIVE. u tt ts is tt tt tt a THE IB E EL