THE SUNDAY OREGONIAN, PORTLAND, NOVEMBER 2, 1913.
COLGATE SOLVES
"DEFENSE OF VALE
WHITMAN SCORES
nil nnninn trii
T
; COACH RALPH "SPEC" HTJBLBTJRT AND HIS PORTLAND ACADEMY ELEVEN". WHICH HELD THE HEAVY LINCOLN HIGH TEAM TO A 12-0 SCORE LAST WEDNESDAY.
U!1 UUDICD IlHK
v- w. v-X
Superior Playing Defeats Old
Eli Football Squad by
Score of 16 to 6.
Fumble" by Washington Back
Permits Missionaries to
Cross Goal Line.
ir .- .:- . -:
' ... i ..
NEW HAVEN SUBS COSTLY
SUPERIOR WEIGHT TELLS
. ' i if
Star Quarterback Oornisli Suffers
liroken Jaw and His Relief Fails
to Measure Up to Standard,
r'umbles Brinj Scores.
NKW HAVEN. Conn., Nov. 1. Col
gate found Yale's much-vaunted de
fense more of a tradition than an ac
tuality today and defeated the Blue
16 to C by superior football. It was
the first time thltf year that Yale has
huen scored on, and Colgate goes down
in football annals as one of the few
collides in this country to defeat Tale.
' Colgate's team was fast, well bal
anced and splendidly drilled. It ap
earcd heavier than Yale. ItB two
Kiant tackles opened great holes in
the line outside of tackle through
which the fleet backs swept for good
Kulns. Thu consistent offense of the
visitors was a revelation and the best
teen on Yale field in many days.
Yale, however, was weakened by sev
eral substitutes in the line. Cornish,
who was playing: a star game at quar
terback, sustained a broken Jaw Just
before the close Of the second period
and his understudy failed' to measure
up to his standard, the Yale team be
ing then almost like a ship without a
rudder.
Colgate made two touchdowns and
goal from placement. One touchdown
was the direct result of a fumble and
the other partly so. Thompson, who
succeeded Cornish, fumbled a punt
when tackled and it was Colgate's ball
on Yale's 15-yard line. Five rushes
brought a touchdown. The second
score came when Knowles, standing:
back of his own goal line for a punt,
let the ball slip through his fingers
arid Riley fell on it.
In the last period Brook sent the
ball between the uprights from the 25
yard line for a goal from placement.
Yale's touchdown came in the sec
ond period Just after Colgate had
scored. The Blue, playing fiercely,
rushed the visitors off their feet until
Knowles made a dashing end run for
16 yards and crossed the line. Guern
sey tried a dropkick Just before the
period closed, but failed. Captain
Ketcham, of Yale, played a whirlwind
game on the offense and the visitors
could not gain through him.
The lineup:
Colgate. Position. Yale.
Bulllvan Li E Avery
Parker 1. T Talbott
Brooks L.G.. Ketcham (Capt.)
Peterson (Capt.) C Caldwell
Bullivan R G Warren
Abel R T Madden
Riley R B Hubbard
Huntington Q Cornish
Kamsey L. H Cornell
OIney .'..RH Knowles
Bwartout P Wilson
Referee, J. A. Evans, of Williams. Umpire,
Fred Murphy. Brown. Head linesman, Ka
than Tufts, Brown.
Colgate scoring touchdowns Swartout,
Riley; goal from placement. Brooks; goal
from touchdown. Huntington.
Yale scoring touchdown Knowles.
HARVARD'S STRENGTH SHOWN
Cornell Scores Only. When Substi
tutes Go In Xear End.
CAMBRIDGE, Mass., Nov. 1. The
strength of the Crimson first line
players and the weakness of the second
string men were brought out in
Harvard's game today against Cornell,
which the Crimson won with apparent
ease 23 to 6.
While Brickley, Hardwick, Captain
Storer.and others of the regular Har
vard players were In the lineup touch
downs were scored in each of the three
periods and Brickley added his custo
mary, goal from the field. Cornell was
held back of the middle of the field
and was a negligible factor for three
periods. m
In the last 15 minutes Coach Hough
ton sent his substitutes into the game
and they crumbled against the Ithacan
onslaught. Although they made a
frame. stand and held Cornell for three
downs, they could not prevent a score
on the fourth rush.
Cornell almost failed to make t.he
touchdown, for Barrett, in plunging
through a hole In the center, brought
up against' ' the canvas-covered goal
post. There was a mass of players
about him as he stood grasping the
upright ur.j.ble to get to the other side.
He was fortunate, however, in push
ing the ball around and Referee Lang
ford ruled that a touchdown had been
scored.
It was the first consistent march of
an opening team to the Harvard goal
line this year, although Holy Cross
scored on Harvard in the game two
weeks ago. The three Harvard touch
downs, all by Brickley, came on steady
rushing and varied plays. One of them
was of a spectacular nature made on
a 15-yard forward pass.
Brickley tried two goals from the
field from the 40-yard line which failed
by narrow margins. The successful
goal was made from the 16-yard mark.
Harvard came through the game in
prime condition for next Saturday's
contest at Princeton. The lineup:
Harvard Position. Cornell
Coolidse UK Mehaffev
Ullman L T Guayer
Cownn L, Q Munns
Trumbull C Coo!
Peimock R-g Hyland
Withlngton R T Mallory
t"rer R K O Hearn
J.osnn Q B Schuler
t'aritwilck L H B.... Frits
Uradlee R H T-i Barrett
Brickley .... . F B ' Shelton
t mpire Pultz, of Brown. Referee
l-angford, of Trinity. Head linesman Pen
it leton. of Bowdoln. Time of periods II
minutes each. Harvard scoring Touch
downs. Brickley 3; goals from touchdown,
Hardwick. Storer- goal from field. Brickley.
Cornell scorlnK Touchdown,' Barrett. .
PKIXCETOX'S VICTORY IS EASY
Reconstructed Team Outwits and
Outplays Holy Cross, 54 to 0.
PRINCETON-. N. J.. Nov. 1. Prince
ton's reconstructed football eleven de
feated Holy Cross today 54 to 0. The
visitors never threatened Princeton's
goal ilne. The locals showed the re-,
suit of the regeneration by displaying a
series of forward passes, netting gains
from 10 to 35 yards, with Captain H.
Baker, Hammond, Law and Glick do
ing the bulk. of the work.
Princeton opened up the game with
Baker flashing around the ends, Glick
fakir.tr passes for quarterback runs
through the lines, and Law faking kick
formations for forward passes. Prince
ton also showed -a punter of ability in
Law, thr- halfback recruit, whose kicks
averasred 50 "yards. The lineup:
J Princeton. Position. Holy Cross.
Hammond L E McCabe
i.r.rs'in L T. . ..; Ostregen
Pee.mens L G "McUrath
TO. Trenkham ..C Browley
IV. fci. Wart HO HaEBrty
Bnilln R T cnhill
Sheu RE Metivier
Click Q B Mullen
H. Haker I. H Tt O" f-trten
I. nw RH B Rogers
Btrelt FB..-. Donovan
KefVree Mnrshpll, of Hurvard: Umpire r
Halch. of Williams. Linesman Palmer, of
t- ; t ...W-''".li...i.rs- ,11- - -. ; ---:
s - -srs -f' fcr. ' x , - ! - - . , . 4 - A ;
v.
if., rnr-i r Ttnii
READING I.EPT TO KIGHT, 9T.DIb, COACH HlilLBlRT, 51KADB SC HOKHURG, CAPTAIN EHII AM) M' CUXG-LEFT TO RIGHT, KNEELING,
BliRY,PORTER, KCKSTKOM, BOSS A.D WHITMER.
Swarthmore. Time of periods 12 and 15
minutes. Princeton scoring: Touchdowns
Streit 8, H. Baker, B. Trenkman. Law, F.
Trenkman. Goals from touchdown H. Baker
7. Safety O'Brien (thrown by E. Trenk
man). Goals from placement Baker.
JTOTRE DAME BEATS. CADETS
Western. Team's Play Makes Army
Men Look Like Novices.
WEST POINT, N. T., Nor. 1. The
Army was beaten by Notre Dame today,
35 .to 13. The Cadets were outclassed
and except in the second quarter, whet
they scored two touchdowns, the Army
players looked like novices beside the
Westerners.
Notre Dame's long- forward passing
and pretty open field play was spec
tacular, and a revelation to Eastern
football enthusiasts. Out -of 14 at
tempts with the forward pass play the
Westerners succeeded In making 12
Rood for long grains. Rockney, Finne
gran and Pliska, on the receiving end,
with Dorals throwing: the ball, grained
many yards for their team.
In fact, all of Notre Dame's touch
downs . were directly, due to splendifl
work with the forward pass. Eichen
laub was a demon on offense, plowing
through the Army line for grood grains
and bowling- ver the interference In
slashing: style. Dorais' quarjer-back
play was grilt-edgred. He kicked five of
the goals from touchdowns and run
his team with splendid judgment.
The first half ended with the score
14 to 13 In Notre Dame's favor.
Hoge and Merrill played best for the
Cadets.
The lineup: -
Army 13. ' Notre Dame 35.
Jouett LE.. -Rookne
Wynne ........... .L T Jones
Meacham .........LO Kecfe
McEwan C Feeney
Jones RG.. Fltzprerala
Weyand R T Lathrop
Merrill ...........RE.......... Gushuret
Prlchard QB rrorala
Hon .- 1.HB Pltska
Hobbe '. RHB Flnnegan
Hodgson FB Elrhenlaub
Referee Modlce. University of Pennsyl
vania. Umpire Roper, Princeton. Head
linesman Leuhring, of Northwestern.
Army soorlng: Touchdowns Hodgson,
Pritchard. Goals from touchdowns Hoffe.
Notre Dame scoring": Touchdowns Rockne,
Elchenlaub 2. Pliska 2. Goals from touch
downs Dorais.
NAVY BEATS IEHIGH, 39 TO 0
Ixtng;, Tearing; Plunges Through
Line Mark. Anna-polls Game.
ANNAPOLIS. Md., Nov. 1. Navy's
football eleven easily defeated the
Lehigrh University team here today by
a score of 39 to 0. The game was
marked by long, . tearing plunges
through the line on the part of Navy
and in addition, there were two runs
of nearly the entire length of the field,
these being credited to Miles and NiciV.
ols, who went in as substitutes in the
last period.
Referee Whiting, of Cornell. Um
pire Thome, Delaware Institute. Head
linesman Stollenwerk. Johns Hopkins.
Time of periods 15 minutes.
Navy Touchdowns, Mitchell, Mc
Reavy, Falling, Gilchrist, Nichols; goals
from touchdown. Brown 3, Miles; goals
from field. Brown; safeties, Hoban.
Dartmouth 21, Amherst 7.
AMHERST, Mass., Nov. 1. Dartmouth
won a hard-fought game from Amherst
today, 21 to 7. The contest was closer
than the score would indicate, Amherst
holding the Green for downs many
times, twice within the three-yard line.
The game ended with the ball in Am
herst's possession on Dartmouth's 15
yard line after a march of 50 yards
down the field. With the score at the
end of the first half 7 to t. Dartmouth
sent in its regulars, and by straight
football scored touchdowns in the third
and fourth periods.
Carlisle 34, Georgetown 0.
WASHINGTON. Nov. 1; Resorting
in the main to straight football and
occasionally varying the attack with
a forward pass or criss-cross forma
tion, the Carlisle Indians overwhelmed
Georgetown University here today. 4
to 0. The. Indians battered George
town's line repeatedly and the local
collegians were on the defensive prac
tically throughout the game. George
town never threatened the Carlisle
goal.
Itucknell 9, Pitt 0.
PITTSBURG, Nov. 1. Bucknell de
feated Pitt University here today, 9 to
0. Pitt previously had defeated Car
lisle and Cornell and was looked on as
having more than a fighting chance
with Bucknell. . The visitors outplayed
the locals and won on their merits, al
though Pitt failed to take advantage
of opportunities to score through fum
bling at critical periods.
Pennsylvania 17. Penn C
PHILADELPHIA. Nov.' 1. University
of Pennsylvania f oa.ll team, with the
aid of trick plays and good general
ship, defeated Pennsylvania State Col
lege today by 17 to 0. It was a hard
fought and fast contest, Penn State
playing a stronger game than the score
Indicates.
ilES0TMS2i-3
Cardinals' Hopes Dashed in
Exciting Contest.
GAME IS FIERCE CONTEST
Badgers Miss Generalship of Tollef
son After Quarterback Is Taken
From Field Bellows' Kick
Prevents . Blank.
MADISON, Wis., Nov. 1. The Uni
versity of Wisconsin's big nine con
ference championship aspirations failed
this afternoon when the University of
Minnesota eleven inflicted an unex
pected one-sided defeat. The final
score was Minnesota,1 21; Wisconsin, 3.
It took the Gophers some time to get
started, but once in their stride they
kept Wisconsin backed up close to the
goal. The result of the game .puts
Minnesota, in a position to contest the
conference title with the University of
Chicago and their coming contest at
Minneapolis will be the chief event of
the 1913 season in the Middle West-
The game was one of the fiercest ever
piayed in Madison. Tollefson, quarter
back for Minnesota, Was seriously
hurt. He was struck over the eye and
knocked unconscious, but ultimately
recovered. Up to the time he was
taleen out he had shown excellent gen
eralship. Wisconsin took thelead early in the
game when Bellows scored "with a drop
kick. For the rest of the first half
the Cardinals' attack was wefi directed
and only the good punting of
Shaughnessy prevented further scores.
In the scond half the conditions were
reversed. Minnesota's attacks were too
much for the Badgers.
The gains in the main -were made
outside of tackle, but Mattern and
McAlmon frequently varied this by
swinging wide and. helped . by ex
cellent Interference, they reeled off
dashes of five to ten yards past the
ends. Both teams showed considerable
polish In their altack and about equal
ly ragged work on defense
AMES SPRIXTS, THEX SLOWS
Nebraska, Played Off Feet at First,
Comes Back and Wins.
AMES, Iowa,' Nov. 1. Ames out
played Nebraska for one quarter today,
scoring nine points in the first, but
the Cornhuskers came back with a
terrific attack, interspersing fierce
line plunges with forward passes. The
final score .was, Nebraska 18, Ames 9.
Nebraska's first touchdown came by
the same forward pass which they used
to defeat Minnesota at Lincoln.
Ames started Tlth a rush, turning
loose a series Cf line smashes that
ripped the Nebraska line to pieces.
Brennan, Amesr quarterback, did all
the scoring for his team. Early in the
first period he caughs Howard's punt
on his 20-yard line and raced through
the whole Nebraska line for a touch
down. A little later' ha drop-kicked
successfully 43 yards from a difficult
angle.
CHICAGO FURTHERS CHANCES
Crowd of 25,000 Sees University of
Illinois Beaten 28 to 7.
CHICAGO. Nov. 1. Chicago - Uni
versity furthered its chances for a
championship today by defeating the
University of Illinois 28 to 7. A crowd
estimated at more than 25.000 saw the
game. The visitors scored their only
touchdown after three, minutes of play,
when Quarterback PoagHie received a
punt from Norgren and ran 50 yards for
a touchdown. Captain Rowe kicked
goal.
In the. second half Chicago rushed
Illinois off its feet. At the end of the
third quarter Chicago had scored two
touchdowns. In the final quarter .Chi
cago scored two more touchdowns by
straight football.
- Michigan 43, Syracuse 7.
AnW ARBOR, Mic Nov. 1. A sav
age offense, the result of a desperate
eleven, gave the University of Michi
gan football team a 43-to-7 victory
over Syracuse today. During the first
two periods the Orange line melted
before a whirlwind attack which pro
duced repeated touchdowns. Syracuse
braced in the third quarter and gave
Michigan a battle. In the closing ses-
sion of the play Syracuse made a game
rally. Michigan relied on straight foot
ball for consistent gains.
Game Forfeited After Row.
ST. LOUIS. Mo., Nov. 1. The game
between Christian Brothers College and
De Paul University was declared for
feited to the Christian Brothers, 1 to
0 here this afternoon, the result of a
wrangle between Fish, left tackle for
De Paul, and Referee Sinler. The
wrangle took place in the fourth per
iod when the score stood 29 to 7 for
the Christian Brothers.
Colorado Mines 14, Aggies 7.
FORT COLLINS, Colo., Nov, 1. The
speed and luck of the Colorado School
of Mines overcame the weight of the
Colorado Aggies here today in a game
in which the Mines brought into prof
itable play tho Yale shift, used .ad
vantageously against the Utah Univer
sity last week. S-core, 14 to 7.
Indiana 7, Ohio State 6.
COLUMBUS, O., Nov. 1. Although
outplayed in all but the last quarter
of today's game with Ohio State, In
diana came out of the contest with a
7-to-6 victory. A fumble by Fullback
Graf, who had dropped back on a fake
punt in the last period, was responsible
for Ohio's defeat.
DrakeS2, Washington 17. -
DES MOINES, Iowa, Nov. 1. By a
series of brilliant plays, good line
smashing aid a sprint of 50 yards by
McCormick, Drake started in the first
quarter to roll up a score against
Washington here this afternoon and
kept up the pace until the final score
stood 32 to 17.
High School Team Scores 106.
IOWA CITY. Ia.. Nov. 1. The Iowa
City High School team made what they
claim to be a record football score
when they defeated the Marshalltown
High school team 106 to 0 today.
Tulane 12, St. Louis 6. .
ST. LOUIS, Nov. 1. Tulane Univer
sity defeated St. Louis University at
football this afternoon by 12 to 6 in a
game marked by a sensational run and
two placement kicks.
CRACK CHECKER PLAYER HERE
"Kid" Hanson Will Give Exhibition
Tomorrow Night.
J. B. Hanson, better known as "Kid"
Hanson and one of the best checker
players in the United States, will give
an exhibition of the game at the Port
land Chess and Checker Club tomorrow
night, when he will meet' all comers in
a simultaneous game.
Hanson has played against such men
as Jordan, the present National cham
pion. He is 22 years old, accounting for
his nickname. Checkers is usually held
to be the elderly man's game, but this
boy can beat any of the old-timers of
the Portland Club.
The place of the match has not been
decided, but it will probably be the
Commercial Club. This will be decided
today. He leaves the latter part of the
week for Los Angeles, where he meets
J. T. Bradford, the man who recently
beat De Oro, Western champion. While
In the city the player Is the guest of
his siste. Miss Ada Hanson, at 332
Tenth street.
HOWARD
XAMES
ALL-STARS
Five Portland Players Are Picked by
San Francisco Manager.
SAN FRANCISCO, Nov. 1. Manager
Del Howard. of the San Francisco
Coast League team, has picked an all
star ball club from the Pacific Coast
League. Howard's selection follows:
Pitchers Fanning, San Francisco;
Stroud, Sacramento; James, Portland;"
Malarkey, Oakland; Krause. Portland;
Lelrseld, San Francisco, and Pruitt,
Oakland. Catchers Schmidt. San Fran
cisco; Fisher, Portland, and Elliott,
Venice. First base Tom TT,n.n
Sacramento. Second base Rodgers,
Portland. Third base Ivan Howard,
Los Angeles. Shortstop Corhan, San
Francisco. Left field Maggart, Los
Angeles. Center field Johnston, San
Francisco. Right field Bayless. Venice.
Utilltv infleldar TTni-en T. .- i ,j
Utility outfielder Shlnn, Sacramento.
City Paving Plant Urged.
The Ninth Ward Protectlye Associa
tion at a meeting held 'last week
passed resolutions favoring , the es
tablishment In Portland of 'a munic
ipal paving plant for the repair of
paving and for the laying of new
paving in competition . with private
companies. The resolutions as filed
with City Auditor Barbur yesterday
ask that the city In addition to doing
the paving Itself take care of the main
tenance after the present ten year
maintenance period expires, paying the
cost from. the city's general fund.
d
V" , xk
LINCOLN LOOKS BEST
Seven More Games Scheduled
in Interscholastic League.
EASY VICTORY IS EXPECTED
Heavy High School Team Should
Take 1913 Honors Without Trou
ble Two Lively Contests to
Be Played This Week.
With but seven more games to be
played from the 1913 football sched
ule of the Portland Interscholastic
League, and the Lincoln High eleven
leading the league, the prospects of
any of the other teams depriving the
west faide school of the championship
seem nil. Coach Borleske's eleven
nave yet to play Hill Military Acad
emy and Columbia University, but as
each has been downed by one of the
icaina mai ieii Deiore the Lincoln
team, little difficulty is expected.
The Lincoln-Portland Academy game
of last Wednesday put a scare in the
West Side High School, as the ' team
went into the fray thinking the game
aireaay won. The Portland Academy
eleven played rings around the heavy
Llncolnites, and It was not until the
middle of- the last quarter that either
goal line was crossed. Lincoln man
aged to send "Rusty" Groce across thi
une twice in quick succotslon. scoring
tne oniy iz points or the game.
Hurlburt'a Men Best Tacklers.
Coach Hurlburt' has one of the sur
est tackling teams in the league, as
time after time the tacklers downed
the Lincoln players before they could
advance the ball. In grabbing forward
passes the Academy team seems to be
equal to any occasion, as three min
utes after time had been called to start
the game. Coach. Hurlburfs olavers
had the ball -on Lincoln's 10-yard pass
after a. punt by Captain Brlx and a
forward pass from Brix to Woodcock
netted the Academy 25 yards.
The Columbia University eleven did
not come up to expectation this season,
as Coaoh Calllcrate ' was supposed to
have the dark horses of the league.
This title fell to the Academy eleven.
Columbia University has won and lost
one battle, barely getting away with
the game from Coach Rinehart's pro
teges.
Jefferson-Columbia Play Fast.
The Jefferson-Columbia game was
one of the fastest seen so far this vear.
and all the scoring was done in the
last quarter. The Jefferson team
scored a touchdown, but failed to
kick goal, while four minutes later the
Columbia eleven had crossed the goal
line - and Phelan stepped back and
kicked an easy goal.
Next Wednesday the Columbia team
will meet Coach Moore's eleven of the
Hill Military Academy. The Academy
team has been unfortunate, as it has
lost Its two games so far this year.
The Hill team lost Jack Day, Olsen,
Eddie McAIlen and. Blacklstone, the
Academy's all-star players, and Coach
Moore was not able to develop players
to fill these vacancies.
The Portland Academy - Jefferson
High game Is scheduled for Friday, and
both teams will be In earnest this week
to regain lost laurels. The Jefferson
team will play hard to keep out of the
cellar. Both games are slated to start
at 3 o'clock.
"DOC" WHITE WANTS TO QUIT
Veteran Pitcher of Chicago AVhite
Sox Would Become Owner.
CHICAGO. Nov. 1. "Doc" White, who
has been pitching for the Chicago
Americans since 1901 has played his
last game In the major leagues If. he
has his way.
It was learned here today that White
Is negotiating for the purchase of the
holdings of Tom Fairweather, who
with Frank Isbell controls the Des
Moines Western League team.
White has a contract to play with
Chicago again -next season, but Presi
dent Comiskey says he will release the
veteran if "Doc" can better himself;
PHEASANT SEASON CLOSED
Hunters Get Small Bags During
Waning Days of Shooting.
ALBANY, Or., Nov. 1." (Special.)
With more shooting than has charac
terized any one day for the past three
f " -V x
ii-
v.
WOODCOCK. L4TT01. KINGS-
weeks, the open season for China
pheasants closed yesterday. Anxious
for the last opportunity for a year to
hunt the birds, many hunters took to
the fields yesterday, but the bags were
small. The birds have been scarce
since the first few days of the open
season, and, though a few hunters have
secured the limit on trips since the
first few days, most hunters have not
fared so well.
Thousands of the birds have been
killed during the past month. In some
localities the pheasants are now very
scarce, but it is believed there are
enough of the birds left to insure good
hunting next year.
BAYLEY KNOCKS OUT WHITE
Canadian ex-Lightweight Champion
Defeats Chicagoan in Ninth.
VANCOUVER. B. C, Nov. 1. Joe
Bayley, Canadian ex-lightweight cham
pion, knocked out Jack White, of Chi
cago, In the ninth round of a scheduled
15-round bout today.
Displaying all his old-time speed and
boxing ability, the Victoria lightweight
forced the milling from the start and
beat White decisively in all but vthe
seventh round, when the Chicago boxer
jolted Bayley with straight lefts and
body punches.
Within a quarter of a minute after
the ninth round opened, White walked
Into a vicious right cross that caught
him flush on the jaw and sent him
sprawling to the mat. He remained
down for the count but came up only
to go down again. He staggered to his
feet, but was sent down again and
Referee McDonald stopped the fight.
WELFARE LAW FOUGHT
STATl'TB CREATING INDUSTRIAL.
COMMISSION ATTACKED,
Clause Forbidding Judicial Review of
Ruling Target In Demurrer
Hearing in Stettler's Suit. .
That clause in the statute creating
the Industrial Welfare Commission
which forbids judicial review of the
rulings of the Commission on questions
of fact was one of the points on which
the opposing counsel in the case to
test the constitutionality of the law
locked horns yesterday.
The arguments, which were on the
demurrer of the Commission to F. C.
Stettler's complaint, were concluded
yesterday. The proceedings are re
garded as the first step in a protracted
series of legal battles which will take
the case to the United States Supreme
Court.
Dan J. Malarkey, attorney for the
Commission, had told Judge Cleeton,
who heard the case in Circuit Court,
that the clause does not prevent any
one going Into court on a question of
whether a wage-scale fixed by the
Commission is confiscatory.
C. W. Fulton, attorney for Mr. Stet
tler, the Portland paper box manufac
turer who brought the suit against the
Commission and the law creating it,
declared that the clause, in Its lan
guage denying the right of Judicial
review, renders the act void.
"Do the words referring to the denial
of the right of Judicial review render
the entire act void, or Just that portion
of the act containing them" asked
Judge Cleeton.
"According to a decision of the United
States Supreme Court on a similar case.
the entire act is rendered void," an
swered Mr. Fulton. .
"You can cut that clause right out of
the act, and the act is just as complete
without it," said Mr. Malarkey. "The
question of constitutionality is not af
fected." -
Mr. Malarkey, In completing his ar
gument, compared the Industrial Wel
fare Commission to the State Railroad
Commission, and cited the decision of
the United States Supreme Court, that
the law creating the latter Is constitu
tional, in support of his contention that
the law creating the Industrial Wel
fare Commission is constitutional.
Immorality Charge Placed.
Mrs. Alio Copple and A. H. Clark
were arrested last night by Patrolman
Shirmer at 535 Couch street on com
plaint of Mrs. Copple's husband, who is
a city fireman. An immorality charge
was placed against them. Mrs. Copple
declared that Copple had driven her to
a life of sh&me In Spokane and had not
properly supported her In Portland.
Holman School to Be Rendezvous.
The Parent-Teacher circle of the
Holman school will hold its monthly
meeting on Tuesday at 3 P. M. in the
school auditorium, o; M. Plummer, of
the School Board, will address the pu
pils. Afterward there will be an en
tertainment by the children and re
freshments will be served. x
Seattle Team Scores 4 1, Muking
Cliier Gains by Line Plunges.
Light Wnlla AVuIians Un
. able to Check Hushes.
SEATTLE. Wash.. Nov. 1 (Special.)
The University of Washington foot
ball team deteated Whitman College
here today by a score of 41 to 7. Whit
man played a fast and plucky game
against odds it could not have hoped
to overcome. The missionaries were
ouewelghed and they were outplayed
from start to finish, and it was only
by a freakish turn of fortune, coupled
with splendid leg work on the part of
Quarterback Hoover, that Whitman was
able to score against the university
eleven.
Washington went into the game with
a lineup battered from misfortunes that
have marked the past week of prac
tice. It was about seven minutes after
the opening kickoff by Whitman that
the single spectacle of the game oc
curred and Washington was shocked
Into the realization tnat it had been
scored against.
Jaequot's Fumble CotI.
After the opening kickoff Washing
ton began to advance the ball in the
manner that characterized the team's
play throughout the remainder of the
game. By steady five and ten-yard
gains they went down the field with
Whitman yielding slowly. They crossed
the Whitman ten-yard line and pressed
close under the goal-posts of the col
legians. It seemed apparent that one
more scrimmage meant a touchdown.
Then Jacquot fumbled. Quarterback
Hoover, of Whitman, was dashing to
ward the runner and he swerved as the
ball struck the ground and, without
pausing, he snatched it up and raced
on into an open field with a string of
Washington men behind. Hoover could
not be overtaken, and he went on the
full length of the field for a touch
down, made after a run of 95 yards,
one of the longest ever recorded in any
intercollegiate game. Niles easily
kicked goal and the score stood. Whit
man 7, Washington 0.
Superior Weight Tells.
Hoover's touchdown stimulated Whit
man, but the Walla Wallans could not
withstand the superior weight of Do
bie's team, and they could do nothing
but yield slowly before the rushes and
runs of the university men. Before
the quarter closed Sutton crossed the
Whitman goal line after receiving a
forward pass, and when goal was
kicked Washington had overcome the
advantage of the college men and the
score stood a tie.
Whitman was unable to threaten
the Washington goal at any time aft
erward and the college men only came
Into possession of the ball when Wash
ington punted or fumbled. With Miller
out of the game, Washington had no
one' to kick, and Whitman also was
weak in this department. The few
chances that Whitman had with the
ball were barren of result, for the col
legians could not penetrate Washing
ton's line and Invariably their end runs
were checked with losses.
Gains Made Through Line.
Washington, on the other hand, went
forward resistlessly with all forms of
play, but their substantia, gains came
from rushes through Whitman's line
and from forward passes. The lineup:
Washington. Position. Whitman.
Sutton. Savage R E Stoner
Anderson R T Neiswager
seagraves R G Bernev
Presley c Armey
Griffiths, Hardy t, G . c"ark
Leader, Curnihttn . . L. T Cowan
Hunt. Leader. ... .t. B Botts
Smith Q Hoover
"a1!6" ', L H Mason
shiel. Gill F Miles
Jacquot. Noble. .. ,R H.. Bishop. McDonald
Rcferee Varnell, Northwestern. Umpire
Lewis, Rutgers. .
WIDOWS GET PENSIONS
Two Allowances Granted, One With
drawn and Seven Refused.
Two widows" pensions were granted
by the case committee yesterday, one
application was withdrawn, seven were
refused and one was reduced. Mrs.
Ida B. Williams, of 89 East Seventy
second street North, was allowed $10
for one child, and Mrs. Ora Curtis, of
2104 Sheridan street, was allowed $25
a month for three children on condition
that they move to better quarters and
submit to free medical treatment. The
two pensions will go Into effect De
cember 16.
The allowance of $47.50, one woman,
for six children, was reduced to $35
when it was learned that one of the
children was 16 years of age. District
Attorney Evans submitted an opinion
to the case committee to the effect that
a grandmother cannot receive a pen
sion for a grandchild for which she is
caring, even though the child's father
is dead legally and Its mother hopeless
ly Insane, unless the grandmother first
be appointed guardian for le child's
mother and then make application for
the pension.
TYPHOID CASES AT NORMAL
Alva Johnson, One of Six Patient
at Monmouth, Dies.
There are six cases of typhoid fever
at the State Normal School at Mon
mouth and one proved fatal Friday in
the death of Miss Alva Johnson. of
Alice, Eastern Oregon. Miss Johnson
had been at the school since the be
ginning of the term in September. The
body will be sent to relatives at La
Grande for burial.
President Ackerman, of the school, is
much troubled over the outbreak of
typhoid. There is, however, nothing
the matter with the water supply. The
outbreak occurred in the dining-room
of the dormitory, it is said, and was
due to direct infection from one of the
normal school students, who was a
waitress in the dining-room. AH of
the six cases are girls who were work
ing their way through the school.
Since the outbreak 82 of the pupils
have been vaccinated with anti-ty phoid
vaccine.
Two Firms Incorporate.
Articles of Incorporation for two
firms were filed in County Clerk Cof
fey's office yesterday. W. T. Sofield,
Joseph H. Hltzel and Alfred P. Dodson
are the Incorporators of Sofield & Hit
zel Company, leather dealers, capital
stock $10,000; and W. H. Rice. Harry
Dore and C. C. Hall. Incorporators of
the Rice & Dore Water Carnival Com
pany, capitalized at $0000.