TOE SUNDAY OREGOXTAN, PORTLAND, JANUARY 14, 1912. 4 TmtHi flt ft 't't'lll' vNV-'-.-i I. THE COM WO PROBLEM. DA.VID seated himself comfortably before the fire to enjoy his even lag paper. With much reluctance I brought out the flrst-of-the-roonth bills and laid them upon the table. It needed, some f Inanclerlng to make thinars come out right. "I hate to disturb jrou. David dear." I brtun. apologetically, "but when this Is the only time I see you to talk to" "In the morning r" be questioned, without taklnjr his eyes from the edi torial he was reading: "In the morning you swallow a cup of hot coffee and bolt for a car." I ex postulated. "Sunday?" he suggested. "When you want to sleep and com pose your mind for the next week's tussle " "Well." he laughed, throwing; down his paper, "let s nave at 'em. then. What's the trouble?" In a few mo ments he looked up from the neat col umn of figures he had set down. "Whew! Bad as that? It does kind of takd the heart out of a fellow, doesn't Ur sula Mast Be Met. "And where does your new overcoat come In?" I asked. "And Tad ought to go to the dentist, and we must have more wood and oh! I did so hope we could go to hear Kubelik this time." "Well. I don't see any Kubelik or new overcoat either In this symposium." He ran his fingers through his hair, re flectively. "Tou take your birthday present- and go and hear him. anyway." "I hadn't the heart. Just then, to tell him that the birthday present had al ready gone to pay for Mldvet's Winter coat. A man doesn't have to know everything. We returnej to the fitrures In a chastened mood. "Could we do with less meat?" be threw this out as a feeler. "It's mostly liver and soup meat as It Is." I explained. I had ex pected better things of that month's planning. It had taken plenty of scheming and much time to convert the cheap cuts Into something resembling good living. "I've tried It with vege tables and nuts, and it doesn't come out very differently. The fact of the matter Is. everything- costs too much." Heat PraMesa Ureal. "We might perhaps find a cheaper house But I was ready for that sug gestion. I bad been looking In that di rection, too. "Tl-ere'e a duck of a bungalow out on the Beverly line. It has Just enough room for us. If Victor and Tad share their bedroom, and It's i a month cheaper than this." David bg.in to look hopeful. "It's the bullt-to-rent kind." I continued. "I looked up the builders who did the work and Investigated their style. Single floors, unsheathedwalls. skimpy paint, no laundry trays'and no furnace. It would take twice as much fuel to keep even moderately warm and we should have to pay car fare every time we poked our noses out of doors." The question of how to fit the most modest kind of comfort to the monthly salary was left hanging In the air that evening, but It was the haunting, all-day-long thought of us both for many a day thereafter. It came to the point where It had to be met. squarely, about a month later. I felt Iavld knew I had news for t.lm as soon as he opened t :e door thai evening, and I caught him looking- at me over his dinner with a kind of foreboding expression. IJtra Jab la IMwrr. When Midget hed been cuddled and kissed before the tire and tucked Into bed and the boys had gone to their room we had our quiet half-hour together a hen we sat hand In band and ex changed confidences. I had to begin It. Mr. Mae Dunn, the landlord, sent word through his sgent today that the rent will be advanced $J" Iavtd took it quietly. "I had expect ed It. property In tcis district is l:ic too valuable." Then It was his turn l.i break his tidings. s- J w J l- "Jlorley. the manager, has been dis missed. The firm has taken in a urn - & of lasaa u-Ui-tte reorgia MlliiiMli!iiliM yuD or OFPORMrr i ' i Ixera. The whole office force Is to' he readjusted, and some of us will have to go." I tried to look at the matter hope fully. "Perhaps your salary will be Increased." I suggested. "You've been with them so long." "I'm afraid not. Gordon has been with them three years longer than I have, and he got his walking papers to day." I gasped. This was. Indeed, coming face to face with stern reality. "What would you say." Iavld sug gested, "to giving up the whole despe rste struggte and getting out Into the country where we could get hold of something that would belong to us?" He felt the rashness of the suggestion and waited tensely for my answer. "Iavld. dear: It's Just what I've been wishing for. but Oaea Air la Dream. That's It.' he supplied. "Wf don't know a thing about farming nor how to go about It. Yet I remember that when I was a boy people didn't have such an anxious time. There was a chance to enjoy life as one went along; a sort of sanity and peace about liv ing that we seem to be missing, try as we may. They kept a couple of cows and had a vegetable garden. Their orchards gave them plenty of fruit the year 'round and It was out In the open air. It had breadth and freedom In It. There wasn't this perpetual striia about trying to make things come out even this sense of futility " "Getting and spending we lay wast our powers' " J supplied. "That's- Just it." he smiled appre ciatively. "The whole thing Is getting to be a farce with the laugh left out." It was plain that David carried tha thought with him as he went off to his work again the next day. and It abode with me. a dim. chimerical vla lon of something sweet and unattain able, as I attended to the day's duties and planned my customary and Inevi table economies. I a ad Lare la Felt. David brought home an armful of country life literature from the library and we spent evenings trying to find out how to go about making a living from the soil. We had no definite plan of reading, but plunged at once In ma dias res. "What." I questioned, as I endeav ored to undcrstaad an Important-looking bulletin. "Is a silo?" "Its a s'ort of tank or storage vat or something." David replied, wisely. "Oh." I replied, "and you feed cows from it?" -That's the Idea. I believe." "But. David. It must be very in convenient for the cows to have to climb up on the barn roof " "Yes." he replied vaguely. "It does seem so" David was reading attentively an ar. tlcle on the rearing of calves. It con tained much Information about carbo hydratea and protein. lie read aloud with earnestness: "Cottonseed meal and rich, well-matured corn silage consti tute an excellent ration " "Rut. David." I Interrupted. "We can't grow cotton In Oregon; It's too far north." "That's so." assented David. It la curious when one's mind begins to take in information along any line how opportunities offer to enlarge one's mental grasp. Far as Waat la Obaeasloa. As it was said In the days of Rome's glory, all roads lead to Rome, so now it seemed to us that all subjects led to country life farming, out-of-door pur suits, the lure of the land. David brought home more literature. It blaxoned these words for all tha world to see "Oregon, the Land . of Opportunity." We turned to the pre'ss; It was all of the big tTilngs to be done In the West not Iowa or Wisconsin, hut real West our own Pacific slope. Kven the conservative Eastern maga xines came out with articles telling of the amazing growth of the Far West, Its need for settlers. Its vast resources, its unparalleled richness. I had heard these things all my life but they had a new meaning now. It seemed that we were missing was the land of around us and wore we, dolus; we were missing some big thlnga Here f opportunity lying all wanting us, and here oar Uuls daily round KATMINE MAYNARD ' of dry as dust duties and letting; tha great achievements go br. Soon, it seemed, at the rate at which we were told settlers were coming In to possess the land it would all be taken. There would be no place for us and In our own Oregon, too. David' prediction In regard to the new manager was not a mistake. He brought new capital and new methods Into the conservative business firm. Instead of enlarging the scope of Dav- I - ' rn.V kj,wAVAr am, plvillff him I larger opportunities, his department was made a mere adjunct to that or Stanton's and the chance for advance ment dwindled to less than a prob ability. Vlaloa Craws A 11 ariose. Under this new regime David grew restive. The vision of a home of his own with all it meant of independent work and definite results bee am more and more alluring. If we bad only had money enough saved up to buy a farm that was producing an income we should not have hesitated longer. But there was the rub. A search through the advertisements of farms for sale failed to bring to light any which could be had for so Inadequate a sum as we possessed. And yet the yearn ing grew. Only to have our own land under foot. Just to be free from the grind of work done over and over again for the other man's advancement while one received from it a mere pltance. To know that so much definite toll would bring certain results and to feel the solidarity of ownership. That was the desirable thing. We talked much of our farm. It be came more and more attractive as the chances for breaking loose from city life grew less certain. If we could not save money on a definite salary, how should we be able to live without Jt? I uao a 1 r a 1 1 u k riuu i . iu, una night, "that If I had a spader and a half acre lot I would be rich." "Potatoes " I suggested, sententlous ly. "They're a dollar and a half a sack now and going higher." "And the room of It," David urged "room to grow. To live one's own life and be 'one's own master. The glint of the sun on the wet meadow, grass In the early morning bird songs instead of the creaking of a city's ma chinery. Fruit from one's own trees" Bota Dreasa of Pstmre. "It takes them a long time to grow." I Interrupted. David paid no atten tion. He was seeing things. "No more banging on straps in crowded street cars " "Nor lectures nor concerts ever " I suggested. "No more five-minute lunches in crowded cafeterias " "Just bacon and potatoes the year 'round." I soliloquised. "Room to swing an axe and feel one self a conquerer " "And perfectly terrible stumps left In the ground." I added. "I'll grub them out," he asserted de fiantly. "You don't know how." I reminded him. "I can learn. . I'm convinced that farming today Is more a matter of brains and persistence than luck." But what could we do without capi tal. "That's what I'm going to find out, he asserted positively, "and be fore I'm a week older.' So, after all our talk it came to this, that David would see some real estate men and find out what a man could do who was willing to work his way. but hsd so little capital that It wasn't worth mentioning. He had some diffi culty in preventing his friend, the real estate man to whom he went, from selling him a corner lot In a most ac cessible part of the city. This was a suburb that the friend himself bad re cently discovered, and he was Inordi nately proud of the achievement. Real Ketate Maa Repalaea. "Loox here," be had proudly asserted. "See what a magnlfloent view of the city. It's all at your feet, 0-foot streets, ten-foot alleys. 13000 building restrictions, water mains, gas mains, 11-foot sidewalks with the curbs all planted to roses: why. man. a lot here will doubla in value la five years; you can mortgage the lot for enough to build the house and there you are." And gently, but decisively. David had answered. "My friend, I am looking for neither gas mains, ten-foot alleys, building restrictions nor street assess ments. If you planted the whole tract to roses and a mortgage grew on every bush I wouldn't buy It. What I want li a place where I can swing; an axe and plant potatoes." And sadly the real estate man had brought him back to town. For it really was a most Inaccessible suburb, and the building restrictions and street assessments were both extremely high. We discussed advertising our wants and framed a few after this manner: Wanted A piece of land where a man with energy but no capital can swing an ax and grow, potatoes." But David was afraid it might attract the attention of the authorities of the state Insane asylum, so we gave up that idea. Aaythlag Acceptable. David's ardor for hla own piece of Oregon land, no matter what difficul ties the clearing might present had by this time mounted so high that he saw posslhllitles In every suggestion; If I had urged It he would have taken up a homestead, but the difficulty there was tlw lack of school facilities for the children. Anything else, from an aban doned timber claim to a three-acre chicken ranch looked Hko the begin ning of our fortunes. Finding him really determined to go beyond the furthest streetcar lines and out of the weary crowd that throngs the aisles. Jams the doorways and gives and receives umbrella prods for a weary hour, morning and evening in the hope of cheating a landlord out of a moiety of his -rent money, the real estate man finally reluctantly produced a description of a tract of raw wood land that seemed to be within the lim its of our slender means. David promptly applied for a day's leave of absence from the office and by leaving Saturday night was able to go out into the woods and Inspect It It probably would have made no dif ference what sort of place It was. Da vid was by this time In the frama of mind that tantalises a small boy when there Is some grinding penalty to be expiated at school and the world, new made over night, with blue distances and cloud shadows, watts to be ex plored. I wondered all day Sunday whether he would even ask the practi cal questions that suggested themselves to me: Was there water was the land light or heavy clay how near would there be a school what crops could we raise? Bargain la Inevitable. For I knew he would take it. The mere prospect of owning a piece of the world real ground .with real trees on It ground that could be dug ground that would grow potatoes would, I knew, so captivate him that a bargain was inevitable. In the midst of the demonstration that attended his home coming, even while he was struggling out of his overcoat in spite of Midget's detaining embraces, he was telling me about our new possessions and when we could talk uninterruptedly I heard of many of Its fine points. It was no common piece of woodland, this. The trees were taller and stralghter than those on other people's land; the water was clearer and colder; It had cedar as well as fir, and we agreed that cedar is a valuable asset In short, it was all we could have imag ined if we had had It made to order. Best of all was the agreement David had made with old Uncle Terry, the ownei a queer old Irishman who had formerly owned most of the country 'round about our prospective home. He had persuaded the old man to let him work out part of the purchase price by doing odd Jobs that the old man could no longer do for himself. David was to trim his orchard, build fencee and so on. at the common wage in the country, tl 60 a day. In addi tion to this concession he had persuaded the old man to take his payments In yearly Installments of $100 each. Worldly Possessions Few. We counted all our worldly wealth and found we could Just compass the first one. Where the next was to come from we did not know, but we had faith in each other and in a beneficent Provl. dence. We felt assured Just why. It Is hard to say that we should not starve and that somehow we should work the problem out. When David went down to the of fice the next morning, he had safely tucked away In his inner coat pocket, "his letter of resignation. The big step was taken. It was Interesting to hear how the other men of the office force took the news when it became known. Predic tions ranged all the way from that of our untimely death by starvation to that of Harder, who saw David rolling into town In a speedy six. Jovially toss ing out half eagles for the rest of the men to scramble for. Office Associates Frleads. There was Bretherton, pale, anaemic, sllk-hosed and soft-fingered." who ven tured the opinion that David was "nutty, you know clean daffy to want to go out In a beastly wilderness to kill himself working" and there was Moore, who only wished: "Gee. but I'd like to Join you In that game; great sport, old fellow; eh, to be your own boss and to be able to live out doors!" If only his wife would consent to live on a farm he'd have done that same thing years ago but she wouldn't; afraid she'd miss a bridge party or something. But when the time came for David to leave, there was from every one the warm handclasp, the fraternal God speed, that between men says so little and means so much. And then David outfitted himself with the fewest and simplest of uten sils and went off to begin his self-appointed tasks and the children and I were left in that incomplete state that such decapitation of the head of the family entails. (Continued next week.) Repartee. Ferton Rraley in the Popular Masaxlne. Says the captain of the tun boat to the skip per of tha barge: "I hain't anything agin' you. but. to take you hy an" large. Ta'r a fuxxy-nosed gorilla that la always craxy drunk. An' you otta be a-runnln' of a etore fer eell ln' Junk; Ta're a lubber that la cro-eyed. and yer brain la buckwheat rakes. An' I gurss the way you got here someone -wished you' on the Lake"! If they aold you fer a nickel It would be an overcharge." . gaya tha captain of the tugboat to the aklp- pr of the barge. Says the skipper of the coa! barge to tha captain of tha tug: There'e a paddad cell awaltln' fer jrer ape- clal kind of bug: I aln-t g"t a thing again" you 'cept the color of Tr hair. An' yer looks, an' ways, an' action, an" the kind of clothes you wear. I'm Just klnda sorry fer you fer yer tem per an' yer ahape. Aa a human ya re a failure, but you'd -make a handaome ape. I would git a Job aa wild maa If I had yer awful mug." Says tha skipper of the coal barge to the captain of the tug. Then the captain of the tugboat climbed upon the coal barge deck. An' the akipper of the coal barge fell upon hia brawny neck. An- they wraatlrd. an- they pounded, an they ahouted. an" they awora. An' it looked the way they acted they waa out fer blood an' gore. 8aya tha captain of the tugboat: "Well. It's good to meet you here." Bara the skipper of the coa! barge: "Same to you. Bill. -Have a beer?" An' tha two old pals an' cronlea arm In arm they goea below j-er -twaa Just to show affection that thay euaaed each other aol ENGLISH BARONESS DENIES THAT AMERICAN WOMEN BEST FENCERS British Champion Declares She Is Willing to Meet Any Woman Here, if Judges Are Present New York Girl at Biarritz Scoffs at Prudish European Critics of Bathing Costume. jpB vv - t, lvs5 Ellen M.StoiJj . ---rr ? set . ;fV M NEW YORK, Jan. 13. (Special.) The Baroness de Meyer, the cham pion woman fencer of England, denies that she was beaten with the foils by Mrs. Stuyvesant Fish, Jr., and Miss Adelaide Baylis. When the Bar oness came to America two weeks ago she lamented the fact that she could find no woman clever enough to fenoe with her In this country. Two days ago. according to the stories, she was defeated by Mrs. Fish and Miss Baylis at the Fencers' Club. She says that the meeting was Informal and that there was no referee present, and fur thermore she does not believe that either of the women had any advan tage over her. She says she is quite willing to meet any woman fencer that America can produce, but she Insists upon having qualified and cosmopol itan Judges present. a a a Miss Dorothy Taylor Is the New York society girl who created such a lot of Interest at Blarrita because she went In bathing without the conventional skirt. Miss Taylor called her critics prudish silly people with naughty GERALDINE FARRAR HIGHLY PRAISED FOR WORK IN "LE DONNE CURIOSE" Italian Composer, Wolf-Perreri, Arrives in New York Day Following Opera's Presentation at Metropolitan. Toscanini Carries Off Honors Stage Settings Are Venetian Scenes of Rare Beauty. BY EMI LIE FRANCES BAUER. a. EW YORK, Jan. 13. (Special.) Jl There were two all Important lea s' ' tures at the Metropolitan this week, the first was Monday afternoon, when Mme. Matxenauer replaced Mme. Fremstad in the role of Kundry, which she had never sung until this time, and the first performance In this country of "Le Donne Curlose" by Wolf-Ferrari the Italian composer who arrived Thursday In Ume to read the lavish press notices which the work enlisted after Its presentation the night before. The principal roles were sung by Geraldine Farrar, Rita Fornia, Bella Alten and Jeanne Mauborg, Scottl. Di dur, Jadlowker, Plni-Corsl and Da Seg- urola. . . Miss Farrar represented a young girl of tender years, and there could be none more captivating, more beautiful or more winsome than she and she de serves the utmost credit for letting her self Into the ensemble as she did. aa her part is hardly more significant than the other roles and she did not commit the usual prima donna sin of command ing the center of the stage. Mme. Alten has found a role almost as sprightly as her Gretel and she achieves most effective results. The presence of Scottl Is enough to lend artistic distinction to any picture, and his style and polish are of the utmost value to a comedy of manners as this may be termed. Toscanini Is Star. Upon Toscanini. however, fell the honors of the evening, because the per formance had all the finish of one for years in the repertory and all that a master mind and hand could bring to bear upon the artistic delivery of a work which would suffer unspeakably from any less finished performance. The stage waa one series of beautiful pictures, which reached a climax in the night scene in Venice with gondolas on the canal, the calls of the boatmen far away and especially effective was the familiar boat song which Liszt used In his "Venezla e Napoll" as played by one single instrument out of the great orchestra. . Wolf-Ferrari has twice disproved the old saying that one cannot make some thing out of nothing. He did it in the charming little opera, "The Secret of Suzanne." given at the Metropolitan last season by Mr. DIppel and his forces, and he did It again in Le Donne Curlose." "The Inquisitive Wo men" might open up suggestions of all sorts of hair-raising episodes, but these curious women only wanted to know what went on at the club be hind the ominous sign "No Women Need Apply-" The scene was laid In 5 ;'r2C' i - Ink i - 1 f .: ;' ' !r.;.-'' ;j I ' -" L - t I I . . - ik mmmm : i " -1 2 minds She is a great swimmer and at Biarritz she often covered the three miles around the Rock of the Virgin, a feat few men have been able to accom plish. She has come out in favor of the Grizzly Bear dance and says the attack on this dance Is Just another in stance of American prudlshness. A new American Countess was for merly Mary Constance Knewer and she first married Henry Coleman Drayton, of the Astor family. She got a divorce from him four years ago and now has married Count Jean Louis Suzannet. The Countess was one of the two daughters of Benjamin Knewer, a wealthy New Yorker. Their second cousin, Virginia French, married Count Louis de Suzannet. of Paris, and they had two sons. One of these, whose first name was Alan, married Margaret Knewer, and the other has Just mar ried her sister Mary. The Knewer girls have an Income of $20,000 a year each, a a "Ellen Stone is returning to Turkey as a missionary. Ten years ago while she was a missionary in Bulgaria she was held for ransom, to the disgust of Venice around the middle of the Eigh teenth Century. The usual mediums of extorting se crets from the sterner sex are in order cajoling, bulldozing and hysterics, the latter, as a matter of course, being the "open sesame" to the situation, but not of the married pairs. These hys terics were precipitated by the young girl, and such an exquisite young girl was Geraldine Farrar, upon the young man who was so desperately in love with her, that keeping a secret from her was not to be considered within the power of mere man. So deliciously coercive were Rosaura's methods, that It was easy to understand how Miss Farrar has her own way under every condition, especially aided and abetted upon this occasion by her maid Colom bina. charmingly portrayed by Mme. Alten. Methods Are Bnnglesome. How women who wanted to achieve a purpose could bungle things in such an Inconceivable manner is not to be understood In this day and date of skilled specialists in the fine art of se curing such results deftly, but these women after having gained the keys of the club, each in her own way, left these keys in the door to be found each time by some one else, until frenzied with the determination to force an en trance, they descended in a body of four upon a poor wandering clown courting Colombina, and who, with the additional Inducement of unlimited fi nancial consideration lets them Into the anteroom. Here in breathless an ticipation of seeing their husbands and sweethearts losing fabulous fortunes at cards, or finding the "philosopher's stone" or making fearful discoveries in alchemy they tumble one over each other to peer through the opening of the door until they fall Into the room headfirst without ceremony and dis cover to their horror, no doubt, that the poor. Inoffensive men are only en Joying an innocent dinner among themselves, who Instead of waging war upon the Intruders make them welcome and they celebrate by dancing a de lightful minuet. So much for the book, in which there is some light humor for those who can catch it, and Pini-Corsi. always one of the most unctuous of amusing artists, adds much by his contribution of the Venetian dialect in his delivery of the role of what might be designated as the steward of the club and leading spirit. But the music Is another matter, and must be taken in all seriousness. This is also the second time that one has wondered in connection with Wolf Ferrari whether he is the composer who , 5 III I 1 Mil! lit ) . the State Department, which was obliged to go to her rescue. The Gov ernment at Washington was distinctly hopeful that Miss Stone had had enough and that she would retire from the public eye. She Is a perfectly good old lady, but no benefit she may have brought the heathen would offset the trouble she made at Washington. - a a a . ' -Miss Jane Laurel, an actress, has an? nounced her enjrapement to Robert Jor dan, a Boston millionaire. They are to be married this month and will sail for Egypt to pass several months there. Miss Laurel will quit the stage. She began her professional career with Mr Sothern. playing small parts. After wards she appeared with William Gil lette In "Sherlock Holmes." She was two seasons with John Drew. a a a Society Is greatly worked v up over the reported separation of the William A. Mannings. Mrs. Manning, who was the beautiful Louise Leavltt Kobbe, has left her husband and Is living with her mother. The Mannings were mar ried in 1908. He is the son of Davis Manning, president of the Kings Coun- ty Bar Association. will make the first step back to Mo. zartian principles, as most of the music is entirely of this description. Slaghig Is Brilliant. In the performance of "Parsifal," one of the most beautiful that Alfred Hertz has given In the way of orchestral sup port and general finish of detail, chief interest lay in the Kundry of Mme. Matzenauer, who Joined Edith Walker and Kirkby-Lunn, both contraltos who have Bung this role successfully. She sang with superb brilliancy, takilig the high tones with ease, and only from the psychological side was her interpret tation open to question. "Parsifal" cannot be separated from its symbolism and from this viewpoint Kundry of the first act is a malevolent spirit, sexless and almost sodden, the medium of the Evil One (Klingsor), who operates through her. Her first and only sign of personal conscious ness is at the close of the first act, when she staggers from the stage as a heavy sleep falls upon her. In the second act she brings every conceivable allurement upon the "Guileless Fool," who is to redeem Amfortas from his suffering and Kundry from her sin, and although she appears as the tempt ress there is no suggestion of personal desire and nothing of feminine wile ex cept to effect the fall of Parsifal as an evil force in the garb of woman bring ing every power to awaken Parsifal from his simplicity. Mme. Matzenauer made her Kundry of the first act a woman, accentuated by a dash of red used as personal adornment, and It was duly inharmoni ous. This woman suggested sex, not savagery purely and simply, and In the second act Mme. Matzenauer's Kundry became a woman fighting for her own desire, and when she was baffled, hers was the disappointment of the woman, not the rage of the evil spirit who had lost its prey. In the third act Kundry has but two words, "Dlenen! Dlenen!" She desires nothing but to serve, she is merely the spirit of wom an cleared from all that is worldly and wicked, and at the close of the great scene as the dove of peace descends in the glory of light, Kundry is discovered at the base of the altar, her face to the ground, a great Mary Magdalen. In this act where all but two words Is dependent upon the suggestion of a state of mind. Mme. Matzenauer brings to bear the power of the theater, and she achieves splendid and telling ef fects " of pantomime, rich in dramatic feeling and intelligent in conception, but they are of the theater and not of the spirit in which this role must be felt to make the entire symbolism of "Parsifal" consistent- A M