6 . TITE RUNDAT OKEGOXIAX, TORTLAXD, JANUARY 7, 1912. REED R C R VWEESL MAM DM PT MART KATHEBIXE WOODS. THAT the American stag of today la a disgrace to America, That our "Broadway successes' are childish, cbap. Tbac the average American play wright substitutes false thea-tricaliam for dramatic quality and commonplace mush" for realism. That the condition of our stare to day Is getting worse instead of bet ter. These are the main points In Hamlin Garland's unsparing arraignment of the drama in America, Mr. Garland, who Is an author and a playwright, whose brother Is an actor, and who has ben himself inti mately connected with the vtare In America fur upward f 20 jars, has attacked our modern drama, as he de clares, with no object of mere abuse Ho Is as willing to nupct & remedy as to point out the trouble, as quick with cure as with dlanols. Further more, he avers, his criticism is not of any one particular manager or group of managers; not f any one play wright, any ona phase of dramatic production. His criticism, he asserts, are gen oral; t he-re are, of course, ex ceptions in his general condemnation; there are some playwrights with Ideals; there are, now and then, a few good plays. But on the wholt the condition of the drama In this coun try Is, Mr. Garland declares, "frankly bad so bad as to constitute, a cryinz National disgrace. The American dramatist, he adds, works with no object of producing a good play. He has no literary or dra matic standards. He makes n effort to study life, to show it as it really Is, with truth of portraiture, truth of atmosphere, truth of emotional reac tion. He dos not even strive after originality. He does not care whether his play la good or bad. All he Is working for is "success. All he wants Is to attract an audience of pie as u re - sekers. All he really strives) for Is box office receipts. A for the manager, Mr. Garland as serts, he is not only "in tha theatrical business' to make money he Is In It to make Immense sums of money. He Is not satisfied with m -derate rue- cesjees. with tho 10 per cent profit that contents the director of any other business enterprise he must make 51.000.000. He must play to 100.000 people. Ha must have a "year's run on Broadway" before he goes on lour. And every Ideal of dramatic produc tion, every hope of dramatic quality. every standard of dramatic excellence, gives way before the all-conquering ambition to make a fortune. Hwta It lame oa Miiagrn. Mr. Garland places the major re sponsibility for what he terms the de plorable condition of our drama upon the managers en masse. The reform that Is needed to put the drama In America on a basis that even remotely approximates our o;her arts or the drum a In other countries must come, he says, from the managers first. But the playwright Is morally, he be lieves, more culpable than the manager. For while the man mho produces a play must be of necessity a business man. sZ ' A x A LIMOUSINE IS WHAT '.OUR PLAYWRIGHTS JEOt. OUR ARE NOT GOOD WORK THEY .ARE RAW, Crf EAR CHILDISH. the man who write a plajr should be of necessity an artist. That the busi ness man succumbs to the temptation of bigger business is not so remark able, not so blameworthy. That the artist succumbs to the same tempta tion so generally as have the play wrights of America, is, Mr. Garland avers, a lamentable thins;. The actor himself is to ba pitied far more than blamed for the sad state of American drama. The actor suf fers, Sir. Garland says, almost as much as the public The average actor does not want to appear In bad plays, in plays thut are "childish and raw and cheap; be wants to play in things that have some character, some In herent excellence, in things that are worth his efforts and his name. lie is really eager for good plays, and, with raro exceptions, he can't set them. Mr. Garland is convinced that if there were good plays in America there would be plenty cf American actors rcaily to produce them. But there are virtually no good plays in America. Mr. Garland's arraignment of the drama in America is aimost simultane ous with Arnold Bennett's 'criticism of our stage. The English author re turned to London with his praise for most things American, with mention of our beautiful cities, our high apprecla- i tion of art. our culture which so com pletely quashed that old foolish indict ment of "American vulgarity." And then, Mr. Bennett added, he found the rrj condition of the stage In America thoroughly disappointing, thoroughly bad. Good actors and actresses, he ad mitted, we bad, but plays weak and puerile, theaters badly arranged, pro ductions altogether inferior to those of England and the Continent. And Ham lin Garland agrees with him. The condition, Mr. Garland says, is a disgrace. The cause is the success fetish. The remedy can be found only in the infusion of a dramatic ideal. "To a certain extent we are all tarred with the same stick," Mr. Gar land said, "We all vant to make money. "We are not nearly so anxious In America to produce gdod work aa to own a limousine. "This applies in soma degree to all our arts and all our businesses. But it applies to the drama far more, and much mora ruinously, than to anything else. "After all we have standards of lit erary production In America. Our lit erature Is good. We have standards of painting, architecture, sculpture. And our painting and architecture and sculpture stand high in the ranks of the modern world's artistic achieve ment. But we seem to have no stand ards whatever when It comes to the stage. Ana our dramatic output Is a disgrace to our Nation. "I am not criticising Just to "kick.' I want my criticism to be constructive. I want it to help. I think that this de plorable condition can be remedied. It can be remedied by setting up a stand ard of excellence. It can ba remeaiea by managers who aim to produce good plays, even if they make only a 10 per cent profit. It can be remedied by playwrights who write what is In their hearts, who write with literary and dramatic skill, and who want to turn o- a good piece of work even If they do not get a town house and a country house and a limousine thereby. "It can be remedied by the public that is willing to support, even if with a primary financial loss, Independent productions of good plays, to organize theatrical societies for the betterment of the American drama, really to work work hard to remove this National disgrace. "I have read hundreds of plays by young authors and old, and I have felt always the desire of the writers to win success at all hazards. They address themselves always to the hundreds of thousands of auditors whom they may persuade to pay for tickets for the play, rather than to the few discrimi nating listeners who Judge a play by its intrinsic merit. They are not will ing to listen even to their own inward voice that tells them what is good drama and what is mush. Playwright. Are Mercenary. "The average American playwright forets that he Is not a business man. He wants to make as much money in art as his neighbor makes in trade. He wants more than anything else to get on.' He wants a 'Breadway suc cess. "And the Broadway successes are not good work. They are raw. cheap, child ish. They are absolutely ephemeral. They not only are entirely lacking in literary quality, but they are lacking in dramatic quality as well. They are mush. They are not plays at all." Mr. Garland continued, with a very definite note of sheer disgust in his voice. "They are what the public calls them they are Just, 'shows.' And they aren't good shows at that." The plea of manager and playwright that they "give the people what they want" is not. In Mr. Garland's opinion, substantiated by the public's attitude and the public's behavior. "As a matter of fact," he said, "the people don't know what they want until they see it. It is impossible to predict what the public reception of a good play will be. So long as a poor play is fairly entertaining and there is nothing better, people go to it. But as a matter of fact really good plays do meet, almost invariably, with moderate and sometimes with tremendous suc cess. The public has better taste than the managers know, or than it knows Itself. "The dramatic "literature of America lags behind that of the civilized world. But tho situation Is not hopeless. Things were almost exactly the same In England before Granville Barker took hold of a season at the Court The ater In London and began to put on Bernard Shaw's plays. If it weren't for Granville Barker's work England would probably be as bad as America today. It was he who brought forward the work of Shaw, Galsworthy and others who were unknown as writers of producible plays before. Now England has left us far behind. "Our plays do not produce the effect of reality. Thoy give us instead strained emotion In stupid language, false sentimentality expressed in com monplaces. Our dramatists seem to think that they can get realism suffi cient realism to 'pay' by putting on the stage a phonographic reproduction of some very stupid talk by very stupid people. The real truth of life, of feel ing, the truth that shows through a play the image of life for all this they care nothing. "Instead of dramatic quality we have in the 'Broadway successes' a cheap -theatrical effectiveness. Our drama, is soaked in what I call effectism. Our dramatists want to get an effect that is all. Their work lacks quality, form, distinction. A good deal of it is simply sloppy. "It lacks originality, too. The aver age American playwright seems always to be looking at some one else's work Instead of at life. He hears that some playwright has made a fortune from a play, and he immediately wants to do likewise. He thinks, 'How can I use a situation like that in somewhat that way and produce the same effect and the same success without laying myself open to a charge of actual plagiarism? He doesn't loek at life. He looks at the theater. He doesn't write what he sees and what is in his heart. He hears of the 'success' of 'The Music Master' and The Lion and the Mouse' and he sets to work to copy such models. It is all 'success' with him. "The dramatist is. of course, particu larly open to temptation. Plays are usually written by people who hang around theaters. The life of the thea ter glittering, artificial, feverish is such as to stimulate the desire for wild success, for sensational achievement even on a foundation of bad work. Every encouragement Is given to cheap work. "There is no reason, however, why a man who understands how to write, who studies life rather than the thea ter and the box office, should not write a play. rramatlc technique is not so hard to master. The man who can write a good novel should be able to write a good play. Plays Are Tra.hy. "The stage situation In America is getting worse Instead of better, on the whole. More and more plays are be ing written and produced not for real lovers of the drama, but for the hordes of idle pleasure-seekers that throng the New Tork hotels, that come from all over America Pittsburg, Butte, Mont., and Kankakee to spend money freely and 'have a good time' for a few weeks on Broadway. Of the theater these people demand merely amuse ment; anything that amuses them 'goes'; that Is their only standard. They are not the people of New York City, by any means; they are simply the great floating population that wanders up and down the Great White Way. "This population is estimated today at 260,000 persons every season. And it is getting constantly larger. It fills the theater with audiences and the pockets of manager and playwright with cash. It is the worst possible Judge of what is good in drama. It Is not representative of the real 'pub lic' of New York or of America. Yet it decides the destinies of our plays. "It seems to me horrible that a few men in New York City should dictate all the plays that the people of Amer ica are going to get. In order to have spontaneous and varied produc tions we should have more Independent managers mora variety of taste. I per sonally believe that the hope of the situation in America lies with the actor-manager both -producer and artist such as Henry Miller and Mrs. Fiske. "In all that I have said," Mr. Garland concluded, "I want it understood that I am speaking in general terms. I am not attacking any group of man agers. I am not even crying an abso lute 'Down with the commercial man ager!' I am by no means blind to the fact that there are exceptions in this criticism of mine. We have a few playwrights who are doing good work. Langdon Mitchell Is writing good plays. John Luther Long is writing good plays. Edward Sheldon's work is promising- If he doesn't get too many 'contracts' and yield to the temptation of commercialism. There is growing up about Professor Baker of Harvard a group of young men who can write, who know dramatic technique, who are, to a great extent, the hope of the coun try, from the point of view of the dra matist. "But every other art in America is making long strides forward. A com mercial Nation though we may be, we are putting out, in other arts, good work, and we are definitely advancing, "But our stage does not advance. The Broadway successes disgrace us." WSIm Became Qi fto OimetA FI MART GRAHAM MORItlSO RATNAU WHILE the Gallic element- In Pierre Thompson, the bequest of his Creole mother, thrilled at the touch of romance or superstition, the Saxon element looked on In humor ous appreciation, ready to apply the brake at the proper moment. Thus rierre was to be trusted Judicially as well as emotionally. It was through this dual nature of his that he was enabled to deal so suc cessfully with his islanders. A long string of inlets off the Alabama coast claimed rierre us their lord. Mere dots In the gulf most of them were, worth less bits of -scrub palmetto. One. some miles in extent, however, was settled by a mongrel breed of squatters, in whom French, Spanish and African blood showed in turn dangerous char acteristics. Pierre, on coming into Ms inheritance, found that much of his revenue remained uncollected through the cowardice of his agents. Fired by love of adventure, he took upon him self this d-jty. H:s audacity and ra diant youth swept all before it. The inlanders, so lately armed against the scats, vre now ready to fiKi-t to the death In the cause of Pierre. Ills quarterly trips were triumphal marches. Oa the first of these tris he dis covered Petit Diable. Tho child had other names, so claimed Mere Helen. the ghoulish old woman in whose hut he lived, but from the time he could toddle he had been so shocking, so uncanny In his naughtiness, that he was known only as the little devil of the island. Such a fearless and fast-matin little wretch, with it all. was Petit IMab'.e that 1'ierre lost his warm beart to him on the spot. Ho never stayed away long enough to forget his wee friend, and as for Petit Diable, ro was always on the watch, ready to all upon M'siru with frantic embraces. casting a keen eye, meanwhile, on any bulte in his pocket suggestive of a c-y. On Pierre's landing in September he found hU eye roving ever the waiting croup for oce ardent httie hrown face. ud his welcome seemed i-old without mc clp cf the teau little arms. Where is Petit liable?" was his first qustlon. The Jabbering was hurhed to a queer. constrained silence. Kach nudged the otinr to speak up like a nun and tell M'sieu of this stranse thing that had befallen II. em. "Hurry up there." t:ii;rd Pierre, Where's the kldr' Petit Diable allai " the tpokcsmaa rol'.eJ His eyes helplessly at hia neigh bors for assistance. "Evidcnrtly he's aliai-ed, but where?" persisted Pierre. Bit by bit he extracted the story, which finally came In a rushing chorus. On the preceding Friday, so they said. Mere Helena had sent the child down to the beach for a panful of white sand for her floor. He did not ret'urn. This excited so alarm at first, promptness not being expected of such a truant as Petit Diabla; but when dinner passed, and night was settling down. Mere Helene herself had gone to look for him. On the beach she found the empty pan, m. little further on the sand was torn up as it by a struggle, and that was all. They had helped the old woman search, all through the night, the child was gone. "An alligator?" suggester Pierre, only to be reminded that the alligators ware all back in tha hammocks. "A shark "It happened at ebb-tide. M'sieu." That superstition was holding back their own explanation Pierre divined, his Gallic blood rising In anticipation. With thumping heart ha shrank away from the old woman who croaked In his ear: "There was the track of a cloven hoof. ""M's leu." Collecting his wits sufficiently to go In search of Mere Helene, Pierre found her skulking In her cabin well nigh crazed with grief. Petit Diable when alive had been her torment, but with out him life was an abomination of desolation. Melting under tha lorce of M elcu's sympathy she recounted the 111 omens that had attended the child's birth, and found speedy development in his pitiful little life. That ha was possessed by an erll spirit she bad feared from the first, the devil bad but carried off his own. Pierre shivered In the blistering sun shine. The heavy tropical odors sick ened him. With ail haste ho set sail, and was far out in the gulf before he remembered the uncollected rent- A little later the young woman whom Pierre delighted to honor visited Mo bile, and, cow that she was here, he was in panic over entertaining her. If a girl has blossomed in New Tork society, and beea to London and seen the Queen, what Is there left for a Southern fellow to show her? Of cours tbera were dinners and dances, and then, Pierre having confided in his 11 bosom friends, there were more dinners and dances. Finally it occurred to him that a cruise on the gulf might offct something in the way of diversion He was all for renting a yacht, lie would cheerfully have chartered a man-of-war. when the girl herself interposed in favor of a sailboat that Pierre used on his trips to tha island. Tha primi tive old craft, in consequence, blos somed into a splendor of new rugs, and cushions, and canvases. The 11 bosom friends, each Joying In the presence of his own lady love, were on board, to say nothing of such neces s'ties as sailors and chaperons, when Pierre came dashing up with the guest of honor. Gay little south winds filled the sails, the boat swept down the bay and out into the gulf; and when a round moon came up out of the water Pierre was blissful to the point of pain. Ha had brought his guitar along, naturally, and what song so voiced the love and longing of the hour as "Man- frnm ;S'o4 'iitf dalay?" Pierre grew eloquent over the Burma girl, who was -A-naatin' Christian klcses on. an 'eathen i.ioi-s tkL": Bloomla fcl rnsd o mud Wot they ca:l- tfce Clrcat llftwd Fuid Plucky lot h. cred for uiola when I KlMd 'r where !ie stood V Emotion, unfortunately, so twisted his tongue that he bundled the most personal lines, and gazing deep Into the eyes of his divinity, warbled: "I've a cleaner, greener maiden in a neater sweeter land-" The 12 bosom friends having laughed unnecessarily he made that an excuse for taking her as far away from them aa the boat permitted. Seated on the bow. ami I vivifying dashes at salt spray, Pierre found courage to murmur of his love. She listened first with tender raillery to tha sweet folly of his love-making, and then, as he grew more Imperative, a silence fell upon her, and she ended by promising to think about It. In a delirium of Joy, Pierre tossed through the long night and came on deck In tha morning a limp rag of himself possessed, In tho natural reaction, by tha fear that a woman's promise to "think about It" is but her gentla way of letting a fel low down. The glare of tha sun was Intolerable, and tha twelve bosom friends devoted themselves to tha guest of honor with exasperating ardor. As night came on gusts of wind swept across the gulf, patches of cloud obscured tha glare, soma one made an uneasy reference to this season of equinoctial storms. Pierre would have given his world to be rid of this un pleasant pleasuring, but like a modern Casablanca he had to stand his deck, and presently all thought of self was swallowed up In a great fear for tha safety of his guests. The wind had now risen to an ominous whistle, before which the frail craft sped like a wan ghost of her former self. The fickle waves had turned upon them furiously. Griped by this southern storm, they were threatened momentarily with submergence. The Saxon element was now In the ascendency, Pierre was battling with Death for his beloved. When the storm was at Its helgnt he went into tha cabin, where she faced him piteously white but very still. For a long minute he held the cold little hands, and then silently left her, left her strengthened and comforted with a new courage surging through his own heart. Outside again, there was a depth of darkness ahead suggestive to Pierre of land. For hours past they had been scurrying in the direction of his own Islands. Another hour and the flick ering hope had become a certainty. Tha boat managed somehow to miss the reefs, the current sweeping her with eager haste into the sound, where the still water made landing possible. They were now close enough to recognize the characteristics of the Islet, and Pierre was giving directions for the landing, when the negro cook clutched his arm. "Boss." he quavered, "fur da Lawd's cake doan put in dar." "Why, you old fool, you ought to thank the Lord for the chance to put In." 'But it's h'anted. Boss," he protest ed frantically, his old face ashen with terror. "It's h-'antedr ' "H'anta, nothing! Take hold of that rope." In cheerful defiance of superstition and great thankfulness of spirit, the draggled party struggled up the beaoh. A hard, sandy slope stretched back for some distance from the water, broken only by broken clumps of yucca, which clawed at them as they fought their way Inward to the sheltering palmet toes. The rain had subsided to a mournful drizzle, the wind had died out, save for an occasional convulsive burst. Having selected a secure spot for a camp, the men made painful trips to the 5fJlS -fiZ7 Xx-J '4. boat for food and canvases, spurred on by the fear that when the tide changed the boat would be wrenched from her moorings. The flames of the attempted fire trembling out before the soggy wood, they huddled under one of the dripping trees, their voices drowned by tha booming of the waves, their eyes strajned out into tha darkness. A Jungle of palmettoes back of them reared black heads against the murky sky. Above them towered an immense dead sycamore. Its every limb gleam ing with tha silvery whiteness peculiar to the tree. While untouched by decay there was not a leaf to break Us grim outline, and even in this darkness It radiated a light of Its own. The very ghost of a tree It seemed, the monarch of this haunted islet. There being nothing to tempt late lingering tha little company soon ought tha shelter of their canvases. the deep sleep of exhausted youth pres ently brooding over the camp. Without a shadow of warning Pierre found himself bolt upright, his heart thump ing to suffocation. Within his earB rang the echo of a shriek. Too dazed to reason he felt a contortion spread over the camp, each man struggling to his feet, reaching trembling hands out Into the darkness, clutching with com fort the tangible form of his fellow man. The first thought of their returning faculties was that some accident had befallen the woman. Speeding to their rescue they found them paralyzed with fear but- safe. Even as they essayed soma explanation the shriek came again, a wall that'rose and broke over them and trailed off into a shrill of un utterable anguish. The sound seemed to come from above, splitting the silence with the widespread strength of a foghorn. Half dragging, half carrying the fainting women, they fled down the beach. The boat still tugged at her moorings, and into It they felL Tha current swept them from the shore, and on they fled Into the dark world of waters, pursued by that woeful shrieking. The horrors of that night were miti gated for Pierre by the brilliancy of the days that followed. Out of the darkness and doubt there had come to him a blissful content, and It was. not until a certain young woman left Mo bile that he could bring himself to Investigate the cause of their alarm. Finally he returned to the Island, ac companied by a scientist who con tended that there must be some phys ical explanation for the phenomenon. He had with him also a member of a society for psychical research, who conversed learnedly of theosophy and of the detachabillty cf astral bodies. The little beach and bit of forest were prosaic enough by daylight, and above them the old sycamore drowsed harmlessly In the sun. The camp was unmolested, save for the food which had been devoured by the birds. A bevy of coots, at their approach, rus tled out of tha trees and went skini mfng across tho water like black shadows. The scientist tapped the roots of the firm old tree disappoint edly, the psycsMst continued to argue. As for Pierre he was nervous and dis traught on -this scene of conflicting memories. Just as they were leaving he spied a small bunch, not unlike a nest, in a high fork of tho sycamore. On ex amining it with field glasses he saw that It was a roll of cloth. One of the sailors made the difficult ascent of the tree, scaled tha last slim limb, and. pulling out the carefully folded bun dle, dropped It to the waiting group below. Then, and not till then, did Pierre recognize the familiar little garments. Further to establish their identity he carried them over to the Inhabited island. Yes, the natives agreed, this was- what Petit Diable had worn when he was spirited away a ragged little gingham shirt and a tiny pair of trousers. (Copyright by Short-Story Pub. Co.) Are Whiskers Beautiful? New York World. Concerning the protest of certain gentlemen of Chicago against his de mand that all men be clean shaven. Dr. Wiley is quoted as saying: "The arguments presented are not real ar guments. The Chlcagoans plead for their whiskers on the ground of beau ty and beauty must be sacrificed to health." The case cannot with Justice be dis missed in this summary way: It shows a lack of proper consideration of the relative value of things. In Chicago beauty may be of higher value than health, as there is a great deal of the one in the city and very little of the other. The real Issue is whether whis kers add to the beauty of manhood, and on that question the gentlemen of Chicago speak with as much au thority as Dr. Wiley. Since St. Paul declared hair to be the glory of a woman, would he not have argued also that whiskers are the glory of a man? Without his flow ing beard Frederick Barbarossa could not have so powerfully impressed the Teutonic mind as he did, nor have so potently affected history. Had Blue beard been clean shaven he might have become a henpecked husband. It may be that In condemning the Chi cago beard Dr. Wiley has never seen the Chicago face. The Dickens in TL"s All. Harold Begbie's "Dickens' Characters in Real Life" in the Century. In fact, steadily contemplated and sympathetically approached, every man and woman has the makings of a Dick ens character. Some are a little crude, others have been injured artificially, but all in their degree are the raw ma terials out of which the master coin pounded his immortals. And it is the wildest folly of Ignorance to suppose that odd fish are to be found oniy In humble streams, to say that it is only among the lowest classes that one finds such characters as those who run riot In the pages of Dickens. I never read a biography without meeting the raw material of ' Dlckensian immortals. Consider such men as Sydney Smith, Benjamin Disraeli, the Duke of WelJ ington, CharleR Dickens himself all Dlckensian characters. Will you allow me to say that Theodore Roosevelt would have been Bure of a doublo Immortality if Dickens had been alive to paint his portrait!'