THE SUXPAY OREGOI&EAN, -POBTLAKDt DECEMBER 18, 1904. MULTNOMAH GIANTS A"RE DEFEATED Seattle Athletic Club's Light Team Plays Rings Around Portland Veterans and Wins 5-0 Foley Saves the Day for Second Team No Changes in Coast League CARTOONIST HARRY MURPHY REVIEWS EVENTS OF THE VEEK IN SPORTS. After He Goen In to Play, Mult noranb Juniors Score Two Touchdown Against Y. 31. C. A. I ill 1 1 I l-M ' Laclc of Another Good .California Team Shuts Out Spokane From Circuit. a. ma- tfc WiT m . html amt 'ssm: hi - '&msgi$icz? rHILB the first team was battling In Seattle yesterday the second Multnomah football eleyen was beating up the Y. M. C. A. In the first half It received an equal amount of beating and the score was blank, but between the halves Dan Foley showed up, and after that Multnomah scored twice- Foley kicked both goals. Score 12 to 0. The second team played about as poor football as It could all during the first half and the Y. 1L C. A. surprised" even Its supporters by the game it put up, but after Foley went in thore was" such a difference that Multnomah scored in the next four minutes. Foley carried the tall himself most of the time and maap the touchdown. Every one thought he had gone with the first team to Seattle, hut he showed up unexpectedly and "sent te team to victory. It is a remarkable frt that the second team can play only when Foley is there to give the signals. And he is not the captain. Y. M. -C. A. took the kick and gained Rtradily for ten yards, when Thorp, left ta.lt. broke through right tackle and ran 20 yards through a broken field. This rrought the ball close to the center of the field and beyond that the Y. M. C. A. was not able to force it. No Score In First Half. Multnomah took a try at ground gain ing, but except in the case of Sersanous' end run of 25 yards, could only lose ground. Multnomah's line was' weak. All the Y, M. C. A. backs broke through, as they pleasefd, and Newland, their little center was the star performer of the whole show. The three centor men to gether could not block him. He hurdled the line and got into the backfleld every time. In three downs at one stretch he forced Multnomah runners back with an aggregate loss of 20 yards. Clark, who was playing fullback, then tried to make it up with a fake kick, but was downed after gaining eight yards. Clark punted down close to the Y. M. C A. goal line, and Meyer's ten-yard gain on a double pass was lost on a fumble in the next play. Multnomah could not gain fast enough to beat out the stop-watch indicating the end of the half. Foley Saves the Day. Foley went in at the beginning of the second half, and Multnomah's poor play ing ended. Even the line, which haLieji Ineffcctlvo on offensive, bucked up and held. Foley did not give himself the ball every time, but when someone else had It he was behind pushing. He scored the touchdown and kicked the goaL Foley did everything. He even made the fumble which gave the Y. M. C. A. the ball - down on Multnomah's 20-yard line. But the Multnomah, line was better on the defensive, and a kick was forced. Gates tried a drop, but the ball flew short, though directly at the goal. Foley caught the ball on the ten-yard line and ran it back ten yards. Then Multnomah backs seemed to get together aid pushed back the Y. M. C. A., Holman finally scoring the touchdown. The offi cials of the game were "W. O. Rudy and Long of Columbia. The line-up follows: Multnomah. Position. Y. 2dC. A. Montague .......L. E. R... Carlson Wiley. Clark L. T.-R Vinson Sterling L. G. R Thing Callahan, "Wiley.. ..C Newland Shell ..R. G. L Plnkham Allen, Murray... R. T L Jamieson Sersanous. .R. E. L Llghty Harder Q Gates Holman I H. R Meyers Smith R. H L Thorp Clark. Foley. F. Hyatt CAMP PROPOSES NEW RULES. Team With Ball Would Be Compelled to Gain Ten Yards. "Walter Camp's proposed changes, to the football rules, whereby the team with the ball would be compelled to gain ten yards In three trials Instead of five yards, as the rule now reads, produced varied opinions among local football exports. On the whole tho scheme is believed here to be a good one and would have the desired effects of making the game more open. One of the local football experts said in speaking of the rule: "I think, Mr. Camp has given tho" subject a great amount of thought and his view would carry more weight than mine, but at first I don't see how the change would do much good. I think with the fclen tiflc end playing of today there would be as much difficulty in running around the ends as formerly, and contesting teams would simply have a kicking duel in mldfield nearly all the time- The team with the best kicker would have a great advantage with an eleven of more varied attack but minus a punter. "There is some question to my mind If the open play wouldn't be even more dangerous. Smashing into a line doesn't hurt as many players as being tackled by half a team and burled under a mass of players after an attempted end run "However, the change is worth trying for a year, and perhaps It will work out to great advantage. It would teach cer tain "Western teams as well as Eastern to perfect their Interference. Michigan employs the best Interference in the "West, and that team would be hand! capped by tho new rule less than the others, as they have such fast-moving backs and quick and effectlvo interfer ence for end runs. ; "It would be a great thing .in evening up games between light and heavy teams. As it is today a lighter team hasn't much chance against a team of heavy men ir tne latter nave developed a strong defense. "With ten yards to gain instead of five. the lieavy weights would be compelled to change their crushing, grinding attacks from mass plays directed against the line to end runs. Tho change will give a chance for more men to engage In the game. The light fellow, who likes the game, but is almost ineligible on account of his lack of beef, woud be put more on a par with the bulky player." FOOTBALL GATE IS A NOVELTY Improved Device for Measuring Gains Proves Useful. t If the football season of 1S04 has not de veloped much novelty In plays,-it has at least brought out an ingenious device to take the place of tho two stakes for mark ing the down and tho distance to be gained on each play. Its technical name is the "football gate." It is tho Invention of a Pennsyh'anla player. Dr. Nathan P. Stauffcr. The gate is made of two upright Iron posts placed five yards apart, joined by wooden bars. A white ball representing the football Is attached to a wire con necting the posts. As the team advances the ball the object Is advanced by the linesman and Indicates the progress of the ball. In this way the spectators and players alike can toll at a glance the gain made on each play. As a final test; of its ultlity It makes it impossible, too, for a partisan linesman to take advantage of one of the teams by manipulating the stakes under the old method. The gate was first used in the Yale-Princeton, the Yale-Harvard, the Penn-Cornell gan5s and the Army Navy contest. ' SportingCommentof the Week Brief Opinion on Hnppenlncs In AthletlcM Oregon Chose Good Captain In Lntourctte. JACK LATOURETTE was a good choice for the captaincy of the University of Oregon football team next year. He. has been playing as regular quarter on the eleven for two years and has the ability to be captain as well. "When a quarter will make a good captain it is just as well to elect him such. He generally has J the running of the team anyway and di rects it on the field. He is in a position to see the playing of every one on tho team and knows each man's ability. Tho coach, In reality, chooses-the .line-up and -the field captain Is more "responsible for victory or defeat than the nominal cap tain. If thp two can be combined, the team work is the more harmonious. THERE are so many points to the pres ent game laws which need revision that it is difficult to pick qne much more important than the rest, but there is at least one crying need. Something- must be done to stop the slaughter of Chinese pheasants and give them a chance to in crease In numbers. For years there have been plenty of these birds, ever since the expiration of the period of first protec tion provided when Judge Denny Intro duced them to tho Oregon fields, but of late they are disappearing much more rapidly than they can propogate. Two courses are open: Prohibit tho sale of birds at all times or prohibit the killing of them for a short period of years. ThQ first would be effective, but so far the Fish and Game Association has not been able to induce tho Legislature to enact such a law. That being the case the sportsmen will have to forego shooting these birds for a seaspn or two until they rccujierata from their losses. yr NUMBER of American ugnt fans on r returning from London after tho Frankie Nell-Bowker fight, accused the president of tho National Sporting Club of London, a Mr. Bettlson. of unsports manlike conduct. It seems that Jim Neh. father d Frankie, had Invited the Ameri cans to see the fight, saying that they were to be the guests of the club. Five of them saw the battle, but imagine their surprise whon Jim Neil came to them before the fight and stated that Mr. Bet tlson had, forced him to pay $75 for the five seats. These men refused to allow Noll to pay for their seats and refunded the money to IselL On arriving In this country one of the men who saw the fight, as tho supposed guest of the Nation al Sporting Club, told tho story and Mr. Bettlson was harshly criticised by New York papers. The story finally got to Mr. Bettlson's ear and it now develops that he knew nothing about the invitation which Nell had extended to the Ameri cans, neither has he scten any part of the $75. This matter places Jim Nell in an ugly position ana mere snouia oe an ox planation coming from. him. ANEW YORKER has proposed a new scale o'f weight for (lighters that, if it Is adopted, will settle forever the pres ent muddlo on the question of weights. Gans, Corbett, Brltt and a number of other of the toplinor boxers, havo been dictating the scale of wolghts until they have messed up the whole thing. Tho weights proposed by Mr. Crowley aro as follows: Pounds. Bantam-weight, tyr to , no Featherweight, up to . 120 Lightweight, up to 130 Welterweight, up to , 140 Medium-weight, up to...- .'150 Middleweight, up to ..-....lG0 Light heavyweight, up to 170 Heavyweight, over 170 T"HE second team men of the Mult- 1 nomah football squad had their first Innings yesterday. They havo been play ing hard for two years and have had" the one growing ambition to make the first team. Last week when It was found necessary to get backfleld men from some where, they wore on hand well trained and mad to play. Some of thorn havo suffered continual disappointment this season, for whenever an opportunity opened for them to play, some old and experienced 'player turned up to fill the vacancy. But this time none such ap peared and the second team mon had to bo used to make up the team. They are the men who will be playing regularly on the first team within a year or two. and their development will be worth watching. HOW "RUBE" LOtST A .WATCH Eccentric One Left Kenosha Just as Presentation Was to Be. Made. "When the life of George Edward "Wad dell Is put on the shelves of all the Car negie libraries scattered throughout the land one chapter at least will be devoted to' the adventures of Rube In "Wisconsin, says Ren Mulford in Sporting Life. Time was when Kenosha laid claim to "Waddell as one of the town celebrities. He not only shot slants across for the Kenosha ball team during the afternoons of play, but fixed up high balls o' nights whlleacting in the capacity of "a star barkeep at the dew foundry of Tommy "White, the ex-fighter, who put on the gloves with the boxing kangaroo that Noah had ia the ark, and has been at it ever since. Kenosha liked the Rube, and to all In tents and purposes Rube was madly In Jove with Kenosha. Just as aUoken of friendship and good-will the redhots of this hustling little city wont into their trousers and dug" up enough coin of the realm to buy a gold -watch for their twirl ing Idol. "While J. Keck Wheeler, an old Cin- cinnatian, was rehearsing tho address of presentation Rube slipped out of town without Eaying either au revoir, farewell. scat or rouse mlt him! It was a sudden move that cost him- a full-jeweled stem- winder. Junior Football Champions. One of the irregulars," the South Port lands, defeated the Columbians junior foot ball team yesterday by a score of 15 to 6 This was a game of little chaps, among whom there has been considerable rivalry for football honors, in spite of their size. Columbia has been going along winning right and left for weeks past, doing up all the school s little fellows, but when It bumped Jnto the South Portlands, it had to bow its head In defeat. South Portland holds the junior, football championship of the city. Pygmies Win the Football Battle Multnomah's Heavy Line" Ik Pierced by Seattle Player at Will Fluke Prevents Second Score. SEATTLE, Dec. 17. (Special.) A score of 5 to 0 in favor of Seattle Ath letlo Club is the sorry talo which the Multnomah boys will take back to Port land, and this does not In any way toll tho game. In the football gamo today be tween the Seattles and Multnomahs, the latter were completely outclassed. "When the teams lined up for the game tho Multnomahs were the giants and the Se attles the pygmies, but a few minutes af ter the whistle blew it developed that the conditions were reversed and the klddlsh Seattle players became the . conquerors. with Multnomah unable to withstand them. -For Multnomah, the least said is rab Jably tho best.hoir line was absolutely In effective, oltfief in defense or offense, and 'their backfleld was a3 bad. The same "thing may be said of the generalship and tho handling- of the team, and the one great missing feature was there was no Murphy present. Had that veteran been present the score might have been dif ferent. The light team of tho Seattles simply played rings around tho veterans of tho Multnomah club, the hitherto unvan qulshed. Tho Webfooters wcro practically on the defensive during the entire game, and it was only a fluke that saved them from being hit with a second touchdown. The only thing that can be said of the game today is the brilliant work of the light Seattle Athletic team. Dr. Roller. Seattle's left guard, was the star, and tore through Multnomah's line for any where from 5 to 25 yards at a time. New meyer. at full, and Huntoon and Tlllcy, at halves, also did great work. Game Laws of Two States in a Tangle WnshlnKtoa and Oregon Are Both' In 3feert of n Solomoa to' Revise Legislation. CLOSED FOOTBALL SEASON WITH ONLY ONE DEFEAT SALEM HIGH SCHOOL POOTBALL TEAM. SALEM, Or., Dec. 15 (Special.) The Salem High School football team closed the season with only one defeat and four victories. "scorlns 56 points to their opponents' 10. Next season, the High. School j expects to put out a team' that' will take an active part -In the contests forvthe High School championship of the' state. The average weight of the team 'Is 153 pounds. The players aro as follows: ' Beading from left to right, lop rows, H. Mourer, right' tackle; Nlles; center: Eyre. loft guard: Cross, fullback. f Center row. Stater, right guard; Cary. substitute; ' Hinges, captain, left half ; -Miller, left-tackle; Chet. Moores, quar .terbaok. , - ''.'"--. Lower row, Ralph Moores, right end; "Williams, substitute; Rhodes, left end. , . t . REGON can take some lessons from Washington on game laws. The leg islators have gone further with regula tions of this kind up there and have done some good, things and some bad. The bad ones they have recognized themselves, and are trying to undo them. But it seems at least that sportsmen there have a little eomethlng to say about what shall be open season and what not, and they use their power with discretion. Thore is just one block in the way of their progress. They have not yet di vorced the" commercial fishing interests and the game commission. Thoy are go ing to try to effect a separation as quickly as possible, probably at the coming ses jslon of the Legislature. This done, there Is nothing to prevent them having the best of game protection. Their system of game wardens Is not tho best yet. and will not be until the Wash ington State Game Protective Association, a very strong organization, composed of disinterested sportsmen, have their way. "They bave imposed upon themselves a hunting tax of 51 to the person, and they have collected more money than they can get away with profitably under their pres ent system of hiring deputy wardens. $ut that will also, bo remedied soon. They, have made one mistake, one that might possibly be made here licensing by counties. Washington sportsmen say that is tho worst nuisance possible, and brings 'very- little mors money into the treasury. iAiiq it uoes not result in tne most protec tlorr where it is most needed. That pro vision stands a good chance of being re pealed. The plan there, and here, too, for that matter. If a licensing system can be in troduced. Is to divide the state into four or five districts with a chief game warden in each district, assisted by deputies, who can do detective duty. The greatest dif ficulty in game protection is not In learn Ing that tho game laws are being broken, but In securing convictions. Resident deputies are absolutely useless for this purpose. Soma outride man must be sent Into tho country where the law Is being broken. With $10.0CO or 515,000 a year, an amount which could be raised readily with a license law, a Suitable corps of deputies could be maintained and the law would be obeyed. At present. In this state, there Is so Jlttle money approprl ated for the game wardens that they cannot pay traveling expenses and can do little good. In Washington the hunter is licensed and not the gun, nor are fishing rods 11 censed. The sportsman have learned a lesson from Idaho, which burned Its nose on this proposition. Thore they passed such a law, and found that women, not having a lgal status In such case In Idaho, could not bo llcenscd.and, more over, learned that women could fish and hunt when and where they pleased, in or out of season. Tho hunter, Instead, of the gun. is the Washington license law, adopted from Bastern codes. Here all tho talk has been toward licensing the gun, but. It Is said this leads too easily Into the law court and that Is a place a game law wants to keep out of. Once in the courts on a point of law, convictions are hard to make stick. Conditions are different in Washington from Oregon. There the whole country has been settled much later, and there arb no flsed notions for or against any sort of game laws. The most expedient Is sought for. In this state, on the other hand, every one has some different no tlon as to what aught to bo the law, and each section of the country has a fixed Idea or two hard to dislodge. Portland and the Willamette Valley are both that way, while the sportsmen of Eastern Ore gon are more catholic In their Ideas. Tho antagonism does not, however, He there. It la between the sportsman and the pothunter, whether they live In the city or the country. The pothunter wants open season for a certain length of time. He wants to kill and sell, so he kills all no can. Tne sportsman Kins liKe a sports man and quits when he has had a day's shooting. But many a aothunter takes the guise of a sportsman. This is particularly true of duck shoot ing. Most of the birds sold In the Port land market come from the big preserves down the -river. These are all supposed to be maintained by sportsmen. But some of the men owning them are sportsmen with a broad streak of pothunter in them. It costs a great deal of money to feed and they try to recuperate by making a big kill and sellfng the bjrds. These are the fellows who are making the howl against lowering the duck limit for one day from 50 to 25 -birds. Many of these same men, or those of similar type, annually go down the "Valley as soon as the season opens and begin shooting, and they do not stop at the limit. They shoot all they can and they put the birds In cold storage. Some live In the Valley, and many come from Port land. They shoot through all the early season, the portion supposed to be re served for sportsmen, and havo succeeded by this little game In ruining the" Chinese pheasant shooting In the. Willamette Val ley. Either one or the. other of these provi sions and a good license law, and the game, laws in this state will be on the fair road to perfection. Minor changes in the deorhuntlng clause, permitting the running of deer with dog3 In the coast counties, and a bounty., on wildcats and mountain Hons, are now -the only other needs. PACIFIC COAST LEAGUE moguls have met in their big annual pow wow, and according- to telegraphic reports nothing ;blg was doing. Spokane, who has been knocking at the Coast League doors for two' years, was invited to en ter, but not allowed to stay long. This means that all the talk about' Tacoma be ing dropped was the- silliest sort of rot. as -was predicted it was, when it was first printed. Just why sporting writers will grab at this sort of stuff, print It only to be forced to recall It at the end. Is a mystery. It does no good, and only makes monkeys of those who write-It. It Is a compliment to Portland to have Judge W. W. McCreedie named as vice- president of .the .Pacific Coast League. This gives the Coasters two very able legal lights at Its head, and two men who will be sure to steer the affairs of the league through all troubles without dif ficulty. President Bert has" been tried. and has proved bis worth, and it is safe to say that no league, be it maior or -minor, has a more competent president man .ugene iseru It was President Bert who called very bluff that Jim Morley made, .and the rood fans of the Coast League know that he will call every Diutr tnat the Los Angeles manager will make during 18b. President Bert is a broad, liberal-minded baseball macnate. one whose love for the game Is first, and a man that can rule with an. iron, hand yet with it all he Is just. Judge Mc- Creedie Is untried, but he is a man in love with clean sports of all kinds, and unless all signs fail, he Is the right man in the right place. While it la to be recretted that Sno kane was not taken into the Coast League ramiiy. it cannot be helped. If there had been another city In California that "could have been taken Into the league, Spokane wouiu have experienced no trouble. President Williams, of the Spokane Club, stands high In the estimation of the Coast Lejrrue masmates. and thev would have been, only too glad to have welcomed him Into the fold. With Spokane in the North, the northern wing of the league would have been Ideal and a money maker. This would have made possible the one trip South for the Northern teams, and one trip North for the South erners. The two towns In California are too small, however, and after a careful canvass It was found that not even- two California cities could be added to tho league that would have helped matters. Again the double season Is to be tried, and right here It might as well go on rec ord that it will be a dismal failure, for no matter who makes tho schedule, and no matter how carefully the dates are ar ranged, the railroads will again make the money. Then, too, there will be the same row at the end" as there was over the re cent games between Los Angeles and Ta coma. Morley, with his usual kick, want ed everything, and It took, tho action of the league to shut him up. In the North Morley has stood for nothing- when it came-fo the loyal gentlemanly sportsman, and the cry "Nothing to do with Morley" went up long" ago. It was not until his recent howl about the tie game between the Loo-Loos and the Tigers that the San Francisco baseball critics awakened to the fact that he was a short-skate. H. L. Baggerley, of the Bullotln, who at all times stood for Morley, has turned from him at last, and tolls the. following fruth about the Los Angeles magnate. Hear what he says: For stirring up trouble Jim Morley Is tho limit. He now comes forth with an other protest on tho tie gamo played be tween the Tigers and the Angels at Los Angeles last Sunday. He claims that Jim McDonald erred in calling Danny Shay's hit in tho eighth Inning, which started all the trouble, safe. Both Flood and Morley protested the game on the ground' that taa ball was an infield fly and that Shay should have been called out, but McDonald, who has been umpiring long enough to know his business, declared that the ball was not hit high enough in tho air to be called an In field fly. The trouble occurred in thfr fol lowing manner: At the opening of tho eighth inning Los Angeles had three runs and Tacoma none. The trouble began when Jud Smith tried to cover 'too much ground, struck Toman as he was fielding Hogan'a hit and made the little shortstop drop the ball. Overall flew out. but Doyle made a hit out of the first ball sent over. Shay was next on deck. Everybody was. looking .for a bunt. Toman was close In, and Flood was -well over toward first base. Shay hit up a ball that went over Newton's head and dropped almost straight, lighting about four feet inside of second base and a few feet toward 'first. Newton, Toman and Flood went after It. but nobody could come within yards of It. Shee han sent a hit out through second, scoring Hogan, and a minute later Nordyke banged one to the center field fence, scoring both Doyle and Shay. McLaughlin, struck out, and on the same play Spies caught Sheehan trying to come home, making a double play. The fans are getting tired of hearing Mor ley continually kicking and howling when ha loses. A good sport always acknowledges when he is defeated, and It is about time that the Loa Angeles manager woke up to the fact that'he Is simply making a Jaugh lng stock of himself by his silly protests. lit probably thinks that because he man aged to get the verdict In the matter of the protested game at Portland, 'which placed him on even terms -with Tacoma, he can work the same racket In this case Um pire McDonald's decision Is perfectly rlgh.t and will no doubt bo upheld at the meet ing tomorrow. Fisher and Morley signed an agreement to play a series of ten games for tho championship, and as Tacoma won five and tied one, thus giving them the necessary numbfir to win the series, the Southern magnate should certainly be man ly mough to come out and publicly state that the Northern team won strictly on Us merits. The baseball fans are not the sort of people to support a man who Is always complaining about the treatment he receives and that his team always loses by rank de cisions, etc. So the sooner Morley wakes up to this fact the better he will be liked in the sporting world. The day after Tacoma left for the North Morley ordered McDonald to report on the grounds and lined his men up for action, and after the pitcher had thrown over the requisite number of balls he had the um pire declare the game forfeited to Los Ange les. He continued these tactics all week, and claims the championship by forfeiture. A rather empty honor, for at the annual meeting Fisher was awarded the pennant. Another thing that serves to- show the picayune methods of Morley is that he not only refused to pay the Tacoma players what money was coming to them, but he also endeavored to retain the salary due McDonald for umpiring the games. Overall made him disgorge the "dough" due the Tigers, but whether McDonald win make hlra cough up the coin for him is a matter that the poor indicator handler will have to solve for himself. . When the writer interviewed Mike Fisher on the subject the King said that It was now his turn to be the protesting kid. "You see," said Mike, "Morley is endeavoring to claim the games by reason of my team's nonap pearance, and I'm going to put In a. counter claim that I wasn't present and therefore am not guilty, as I canxprove an alibi. An other thing I notice Is that the Los Angeles papers are roasting me for running away. Tou know that old saying, 'He who runs away lives to fight another day. Well, that was what was buzzing la my bones. I fig ured that If I ran away I would live to fight all next season, while Jim. If he keeps on worrying about the games he didn't and can't win, he'll bo an easy mark for me next season. Tell Morley he'll have to smoke up to get ahead of me.".