January 18. 2012
Page 9
My Right as an Animal Rights Activist
in prison, and ordered to pay $1
million in restitution to the lab for
increased security, management
time spent dealing with protests,
and legal fees incurred ob­
taining injunctions against
me and other protesters.
Incidentally, I'd been plan­
ning to focus on free speech
when I got to law school.
Needless to say, now that I've
finished serving my sentence at
the federal prison in Danbury,
Conn., I'm more than a little
wary of continuing my activism,
as I fear that my speech may
once again be deemed terror­
ism.
That's why, as a plaintiff in a
lawsuit filed by the Center for
Constitutional Rights in Massa­
chusetts on Dec. 15, I've asked
a federal court to strike down
the Animal Enterprise Terror­
ism Act as an unconstitutional
Free speech is
not terrorism
by L auren G azzola
I was three weeks
away from taking the
law school admissions
test in 2004 when I
w as a rre ste d and
charged with domestic terror­
ism.
I hadn't hurt anyone or van­
dalized any property. In fact, the
indictment didn't allege that I'd
com m itted any independent
crime at all, only that I'd "con­
spired" to publish a website that
advocated and reported on pro­
test activity against a notorious
animal testing lab in New Jer­
sey.
In March 2006, I was con­
victed of "animal enterprise ter­
rorism," sentenced to 52 months
infringement on free speech.
This law punishes anyone who
causes the loss of property or
profits to a business or institution
that sells animals or animal prod­
ucts, or to any business "con­
nected to" an animal enterprise.
In short, it recasts as "terror­
ism" one of the primary pur­
poses of protest and provides
special protection to a particular
class of businesses.
This is no surprise. The Fur
Commission USA, the National
Cattlemen's Beef Association,
United Egg Producers, Pfizer,
G laxoSm ithK line, and other
pharmaceutical companies, all
o f which are protested by animal
rights activists, lobbied heavily
for the Act.
The campaign I was involved
in when I got arrested was enor­
mously successful. Dozens of
investors, customers, and ser­
vice providers abandoned the
New Jersey lab. It nearly went
out o f business several times,
due in no small part to vigorous
protests around the country.
The speech on our website
was indeed controversial. When
anonymous activists liberated 14
b e a g le s from the lab , we
cheered. When protesters dem ­
onstrated outside lab em ploy­
ees' homes, we applauded.
This is the First Amendment's
strength, not its limit. The First
Amendment doesn't just protect
uncontroversial speech. It pro­
tects speech that's unpopular,
contentious, and even shocking.
As the Supreme Court recog­
nized more than 60 years ago,
speech may "best serve its high
purpose when it induces a condi­
tion of unrest, creates dissatis­
faction with conditions as they
are, or even stirs people to an­
M H M 0K 4M H Ì
ger.
The animal rights movement
will continue to induce unrest, as
have countless other protest
movements throughout history,
and as the Occupy movement is
doing today. But creating unrest
isn 't terrorism . Unrest is the
growing pain of extending rights,
expanding compassion, and cre­
ating a better world.
When the government pro­
tects powerful corporate inter­
ests from powerful social move­
ments, America abandons its
high purposes, and we resign
ourselves to conditions as they
are.
Lauren Gazzola served 40
months in the federal prison in
Danbury, Conn, fo r publish­
ing a website that advocated
and reported on protest activ­
ity against an animal testing
lab.
■ M R M H n H N M H M M N M
Dr. King’s Voting Rights Legacy under Attack
New barriers to
voting a wake­
up call
by
M arc H. M orial
On M onday, Jan.
16, A m eric a c e l­
ebrated what would
have been the 83rd
birthday of Dr. Martin Luther
King Jr. The day was marked
from coast-to-coast with pa­
rades, speeches, and pilgrimages
to the new King Memorial on the
National Mall.
But in the midst of this out­
pouring of praise, there is a sin­
ister movement afoot to undo
one of Dr. King’s hardest fought
victories, the removal of discrimi­
natory barriers to voting and the
passage of the Voting Rights
Act signed into law by President
Lyndon Johnson in 1965.
In Dr. King’s day, billy clubs,
cattle prods and guns kept
African Americans away
from the polls. Today, new
voter restriction laws on the
books or in the works in at
least 34 states could deny
the right to vote to more
than five million Americans this
year.
These laws include new photo
ID requirements, elimination of
early voting, bans on voting by
out-of-state college students, and
rollbacks of voting rights for ex­
felons who have paid their debts
to society. Florida has even
eliminated voting on the Sunday
before Election Day which has
traditionally been a day when
flnrtlanit (PbstrDtr
Established 1970
USPS 959-680 __________________________________
47 47 NE Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd., Portland, OR 97211
Charles H. Washington
EDiroR.Michael Leighton
D istribution M anager : Mark Washington
C reative D irector : Paul Neufeldt
African-American churches or­
ganized “souls to the polls’’ drives
for their congregations.
The mostly Republican pro­
ponents of these new laws claim
they are meant to prevent wide­
spread fraud, the casting of bal­
lots by people who are not le­
gally eligible to vote. But both
the Bush and Obama Justice
Departments have looked and
not found significant voter fraud
in American elections.
Let’s be clear, the real reason
behind this spate of new laws is
to suppress the votes of people
likely to support progressive can­
d idates and issues, A frican
A m erican s, L atin o s, young
people, the elderly and people
with disabilities. This is uncon­
scionable. It is un-American.
And it dishonors the sacrifices
of generations of A m ericans
who have fought and died to
extend the right to vote to every
citizen.
Fortunately, a growing num­
ber of Americans are fighting
back. On Dec. 10, the National
U rban L eag u e jo in e d the
NAACP and a coalition of civil
rights groups at a “Stand for
Freedom” march and rally at the
United Nations to protest this
blatant attack on voting rights.
Attorney General Eric Holder
has also expressed concern about
the legality of some of these new
laws. Recently, the Justice De­
partment struck down a voter
ID law in South Carolina and
Holder promises to continue to
monitor these attempts and stop
them when they violate the law.
But beating back these ef­
forts will require citizen vigilance
and action.
In a recent speech at the LBJ
Library and Museum in Austin,
Texas, Holder urged Americans
to speak out and raise awareness
about what’s at stake. He called
on our political parties to resist the
temptation to suppress certain
votes in the hope of attaining elec­
toral su ccess, and urged
policymakers at every level to
reevaluate our election systems,
and to reform them in ways that
encourage, not limit, participation.
We agree. We must not let
the hard-won voting rights se­
cured by Dr. King, John Lewis,
LBJ and so many others slip
away.
Marc H. Morial is president
and chief executive officer o f
the National Urban League.
The Portland Observer welcomes freelance submissions. Manuscripts and photographs should be clearly labeled and will be returned if accompanied by a self addressed envelope.
All created design display ads become the sole property o f the newspaper and cannot be used in other publications or personal usage without the written consent o f the general
manager, unless the client has purchased the composition o f such ad. © 2008 THE PORTLAND OBSERVER. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED, REPRODUCTION IN WHOLE OR
IN PART WITHOUT PERMISSION IS PROHIBITED. The Portland Observer-Oregon's Oldest Multicultural Publicalion-is a member o f the National Newspaper Association-
Founded in 1885, and The National Advertising Representative Amalgamated Publishers, Inc, New York, NY, and The West Coast Black Publishers Association
E ditor - in -C hief , P ublisher :
CALL 503-288-0033 FAX 503-288-0015
news (gponlandobzerver, com
ads Gportlandobseryer, com
subscription @oonlandobserver, com
P ostmaster : Send address changes to Portland Observer, PO Box 3 1 3 7 , Portland, OR 9 7208
Advertise with diversity in 1 l,v Portland
Observer
( ’nil 5O3-288-(X)33 adst^portlandobserver.com