_________ W B lack H istory M onth
9,2005
Opinion articles do not
necessarily reflect or represent the
views o f The Portland Observer
O pinion
Gambling on Social Security Benefits
Proposal would
push more seniors
into squalor
D ennis H aynes
by
Social Security is the only source of
income for I in 3 African Americans
over the age of 65. Without the guar­
anteed Social Security benefits they
receive today, the poverty rate among
older African Americans would more
than double, pushing these seniors into
squalor and poverty during their most
vulnerable years.”
As such, the National Association
for the Advancement of Colored
People (NAACP) opposes gambling
Social Security benefits on the volatile
stock market that has in recent years,
left too many seniors with nothing but
a government program to sustain them.
There is a concern that privatization
would result in all Social Security ben­
eficiaries paying more for the admin­
istration o f the program, and thus re­
ceiving less.
President B ush’s assertion that
Social Security is a bad deal for
A frican A m ericans because our life
expectancy is shorter than w hites
is m isleading because it assum es
that blacks will forever die sooner
than w hites. R ather than privatize
Social Security the adm inistration
should take steps to im prove health
care as a m eans to decrease the
black m ortality rate.
It is also noteworthy that the life
expectancy rate for blacks improves
if they survive the pathologies that
impact on young African Americans,
particularly black males. The New
York Times reported that African
American men who live to 65 gener­
ally collect benefits for 14.6 years, just
short of the rate of 16.6 years for
white men.
While the NAACP strongly en­
courages all Americans at every age
and of every racial and ethnic back­
ground to invest in the American
economy and to save for the future,
privatization of one’s Social Security
benefits would make many seniors
even more dependent on the state of
the national economy.
Furthermore, Social Security ben­
efits for disabled workers and surviv­
ing family members are also impera­
tive to the survival o f a high number of
African Americans. African Ameri­
cans between the ages of 50 and 59
are nearly two times as likely as other
workers in that age group to become
disabled. Additionally, African Ameri­
can children are almost four times
more likely to be lifted out of poverty
by Social Security benefits than their
white counterparts.
We must take care to see that the
impact of any changes in the Social
Security system does not fall dispro­
portionately on lower income groups,
or on those Americans whose work-
life has been physically demanding.
Any changes should not make the
financing of Social Security any less
progressive.
In addition to ensuring the continu­
ity of guaranteed benefits at their cur­
rent levels, the NAACP will also fo­
cus on the need to address issues that
have not changed for decades, such
as the burial amount given to survi­
vors. Currently, Social Security pro­
vides families with $255 to cover burial
fees; an amount that has not changed
since 1955. At 2005 rates, that is
barely enough to cover the flower
arrangements.
Dennis Haynes serves as NAACP
interim president and chief execu­
tive officer.
MHHMM
Social Security is Not in Crisis
Privatization wrong approach with major implications
by S en .
Be known ns one of 'America's Finest.' Become an FBI Special Agent.
FBI at work In the community
Today's FBI dem ands that w e become m ore diverse and w e are wortang la rd e r man
Foreign I anguage stalls are an especially critical need tor the FBI. particularly if you
hold a Bachelor s degree io any subject area and have a native fluency «1 any o f the
¡» M c a i affiliation, marital slams, disability ige, sex, or sexual (mentation To this end.
toflowirg Arabic, Chinese • all dialects, FarsPPersran. Hebrew, Hindi.
Japanese. Korean, Pasbtu. Punjabi. Russian, Spanish. Urdu, and Vietnamese
w e are redoubling our diversity efforts withm (tie FBI arm externally w ith such
To qualify to- th e FBI Special Agent position, you m ust possess a lo u r year
organizations as Boys and Girts Clubs of Am erca. Race Against Drugs, the I eague of
college degree plus three years o t professional w ork experience, be available tor
ever Io be inclusive — lo r a i people regardless of color, race, religion, national origin.
United l atin-Am erican Citizens. and the NAACP Add tionally. w e're very
proud to hold our br-annual, 7 w eek FBI Citizen s Academy. Duong
weekly 3 hour sessions, we bring together leaders from a
m ultitude o l ethnic and religious groups to gam an insider's mew
o f th e FBI
assignm ent anyw here m th e FBI's jurisdiction, be between the ages o l 2 3
and 36, and be in excellent physical condition w ith the ability to pass
a rigorous physical illness test.
To learn m ore about these and other opportunities, please visit our
W eb site lo r com plete details. Positions added daily.
www.ft)ijobs.com
Spexiol Agents
W e have opportunities for Special Agents from a broad range
of educational dscipiines and professions, hcwever, th e FBI
has special needs lor candidates w ith critical stalls among
the fofciwiitg areas Computer Science or IT, Engineering,
Foreign Counterintelligence. Information Systems
Security. Military Intelligence Physical Sciences, and
AccountinrpTinancial Managem ent
Y a i m ust be a U.S. citizen and consent to a complete
background investigation, dreg lest, and polygraph as a
prerequisite lo r em ploym ent. Diky those candidates determ ined to
be best qualified w ill be contacted to proceed «1 the selection
process TDD: (20 2 ) 3 2 4 -2 9 6 7
The FBI is an equal opportunity employer
FBI...Spedai People. Spedai Agenfs.
A S S IS T E D LI V I N G
in the neighborhood you call
N P W C X K H X P tN D E N C E .
TAKE COMFORT IN CX IK CARE
” t ’s easy to call Irvington Village home. We're an assisted living resi
dence right in your neighborhood, less than 20 minutes from everything
you love about Northeast Portland—sporting events, concerts. Museums
and more.
7
Lively Alberta Street is just four blocks from our building. Shop, visit with friends and family, eat at
your favorite restaurant. When you live at Irvington Village. You are still part of the extraordinary
community we call home.
At Irvington Village you live your life your way, without the responsibilities and chores o f home
ownership. Our staff is caring and supportive. We make sure you have the assistance you need so
your family can enjoy being with you instead of taking care o f you.
❖
Enjoy our new residence. Read in our cozy library.
Throw a party in the community room. Visit family
in the courtyard while the grand-children play in
the neighboring playground.
❖
Enjoy our friendship. Share delicious
home-cooked meals. Participate in musical
programming. Cheer on your favorite team
with fellow fans. Take up a new hobby.
❖
Take comfort in knowing you made sure you
have the care you need.
IRVING K )N V lLLA t ,1
A Covenant Astlsted Living Community
420 N.E. Mason St.
Portland, Oregon 97211
(503) 546-9292
Developed and managed
by Covenant Retirement
Communities
H arry R eid
During the month o f February,
Black History Month, all Ameri­
cans celebrate the achievements of
African Americans. As we observe
these achievements, we must also
engage in a serious discussion that
will certainly impact the lives of
African Americans; the debate over
the privatization o f Social Secu­
rity.
Social Security is one of our
nation’s most successful initia­
tives. The program provides criti­
cal benefits for millions of Ameri­
cans, and it is particularly impor­
tant for African Americans.
Social Security ’ s benefits are not
handouts - they are earned through
hard work and contributions into
the system throughout one’s life.
Nor are Social Security’s benefits
lavish. The average retiree benefit
isonly$955permonth. Yet without
Social Security,
nearly 50 percent
of all Americans
65 and older who
receive Social Se­
curity would live
in poverty.
Moreover, So­
cial Security pro­
v id e s A frican
American seniors
with 44 percent of
their total income
and it is the only
source of income
for one in three African Americans
65 and older. For these Americans,
Social Security’s guaranteed ben­
efit is the only thing standing be­
tween them and a life of poverty
and destitution.
Contrary to many claims, Social
Security is not in crisis, and will
remain solvent for many decades to
come. However, the system does
face long term challenges. Esti­
mates from the Congressional Bud­
get Office indicate that in 50 years
Social Security may be able to pay
only about 80 percent o f promised
benefits if Congress takes no ac­
tion. We should act to address
these long term challenges. How­
ever, we must avoid so-called solu­
tions that only make the problem
worse.
I am especially concerned by
President Bush’s proposal to move
toward the privatization o f Social
Security. The President wants to
cut the program ’s funding by di­
verting payroll taxes away from the
program ’s Trust Fund and into
privatized accounts. This cut in
funding would require very deep
cuts in benefits. Under the leading
plan being discussed, which the
President has called “a good blue­
print,” benefits would be cut by
one-third or more. These cuts
would apply to all seniors, disabled
workers and the survivors of work­
ers— widows and children. Not to
mention, they would still apply to
those who choose not to risk their
money in privatized accounts.
The White House also appar­
ently is p lanning to fund its
privatization plan by borrowing
more than $2 trillion, much of which
would come from countries like
Chinaand Japan. This not only will
increase our nation’s dependence
on foreign creditors, but it will cre-
progressive approach ultimately
reducing benefits to African Ameri­
cans.
Beyond its retiree benefits, So­
cial Security provides critical assis­
tance to the disabled, and protects
American families from the loss of
a parent or spouse, or from the loss
of income from the disability of that
parent or spouse. In fact, African
American families receive a greater
proportion of disability and survi­
vor benefits.
In my view, all American fami­
lies, including African American
families, should have the opportu­
nity to save and grow wealth. That
is why we need to strengthen and
modernize our current system of
retirement security, and to encour­
age more Americans to save for the
future. However, it is important
that we do this without weakening
Social Security and undermining
Under the leading plan
being discussed, which the
President has called 'a
good blueprint,' benefits
would be cut by one-third
or more.
-S enator Harry Reid
ate much larger budget deficits.
That, in turn, will create strong pres­
sure for cuts in important programs
like Medicare and Medicaid, among
others.
The President has tried to argue
that his privatization plan would
help African Americans. In truth,
privatization would be very harm­
ful to the African American com ­
munity, as many independent analy­
ses have shown.
First, African Americans on av­
erage earn less, and suffer from
unemployment more, than other
groups; especially in younger years
when African American employ­
ment gaps compared to whites are
at their highest. Social Security’s
progressive benefit formula ac­
counts for this disparity to deter­
m ine and p ro v id e b e n e fits.
Privatization does not address in­
come and unemployment dispari­
ties and would move away from this
the program ’s basic guarantee for
those who have been paying into
the system in good faith.
We can and should work to­
gether on a bipartisan basis to
strengthen and improve Social Se­
curity, and Democrats stand ready
to work with the President toward
that end. At the same time, we will
not support a privatization plan that
reduces the p rogram 's funding
while making deep cuts in guaran­
teed benefits and adding massive
amounts o f debt.
While we celebrate Black His­
tory Month, I ask all Americans,
especially African Americans to
carefully examine the President’s
privatization plan. I believe it’s the
wrong approach for all Americans
and has major implications for Af­
rican Americans in particular.
Harry Reid is the Democratic
Leader in the U.S. Senate and rep­
resents the state o f Nevada.
Letters to the Editor
Breaking the Promise
In President B ush's State of the Union
address, he makes it clear that he wants to
break the prom ise of the Social Security Trust
Fund. President Bush did not once mention
‘trust fund.’
For 22 years, the governm ent has vowed to
keep the prom ise Alan G reenspan and Ronald
Reagan made to the Am erican people, that if
we paid more into the Social Security system
than was needed, the surplus and its interest
would be used to pay benefits when baby
boom ers retire. President Bush and the Re­
publicans do not think that prom ise needs to
be kept.
Privatization or piratization? Rem em ber,
it’s your money.
Steve DeShazer
Northeast Portland
I