August 25, 1999
IJortlanò ©bseruer
Page A3
E
i T O R V A 1—
EDITORIAL A RTICLES DO NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEW S OF
|
Thoughts For
People, Not Statistics, Can Deliver A Fair And Accurate Census
M ost o f the people in those neighbor­
Bv J. K enneth B ia c k w e ll NN PA
^ o rtla n h
Observer
N ext year, the federal governm ent
prom ises to fix the census "D o n ’t w orry,’ ’
Bv H erbert H arris
S elf I mage IN N P A )
H o w y o u s e e y o u r s e l f in y o u r
USPS 9 5 9 6 8 0
u b l is h e r
Charles Washington
E
d it o r
Larry J. Jackson, Sr.
B
u s in e s s
M
anager
Gary Ann Taylor
A
A
d m in is t r a t iv e
s s is t a n t
Talunaka W ashington
D
ir e c t o r
of
A
d v e r t is in g
Tony Washington
opy
E
color. E xcuse m y skepticism , but I grew
r e p re s e n t. Y o u r s e l f im a g e is im p o r ­
ta n t b e c a u s e it is th e s ta r tin g p o in t o f
len g es im p ro v e s.
3 . C r itic iz in g o th e r p e o p le c o n ­
s ta n tly . W h y d o y o u c r itic iz e o th e r
y o u r lif e e x p e r ie n c e s . T h e im a g e
p e o p le c o n s ta n tly ? Is y o u r c r itic ism
ticed, w as as different as b lac k an d white.
y o u h o ld o f y o u r s e l f is lik e a g re a t
v a s e in to w h ic h a ll y o u r lif e e x p e r i­
e n c e s a re p o u r e d a n d b le n d e d .I f y o u r
c o n s tr u c tiv e a n d m o tiv a te d b y tru e
c a r e , c o n c e r n a n d d e s ir e to h e lp ?
O r , is it b a s e d o n e n v y , je a l o u s y a n d
oversee the C ensus B ureau, 1 looked
s e l f im a g e is a s m a ll, lim ite d c o n ­
c e p t, b a s e d o n ig n o ra n c e , fe a r, d o u b t
th o u g h ts o f in f e r io r ity ? I f y o u r c r it i ­
governm ent prom ised to fix the census
c is m is n o t p o s itiv e , b a s e d o n lo v e ,
w ith “m o d em scientific m ethods.'"That
a n d in s e c u r ity , th e n a ll o f y o u r e x ­
p e r ie n c e s w ill b e f ilte r e d th ro u g h
re s p e c t, a n d a s in c e r e d e s ir e to h e lp
a n d im p r o v e a n o th e r p e r s o n , th e n it
w as in 1990. L ike today, there w a s a
political firestorm o ver w hether to use
th e s e n e g a tiv e e m o tio n s . O n th e
is n o t c o n s tr u c tiv e c r itic is m . It d o e s
“ statistical sam pling” to find the people
o th e r h a n d , i f it is b a s e d o n k n o w l­
h a r m n o t o n ly to th e o th e r p e r s o n ,
the census missed. ‘ ‘Statistical sam pling’ ’
e d g e , lo v e , c o u r a g e , r e s p e c t, fa ith
b u t a ls o to y o u r o w n s e l f im a g e .
4. W aitin g fo r so m e o n e else to sol ve
is like polling - statisticians take a sm all
a n d c o n f id e n c e , y o u r life e x p e r i­
ences
th ro u g h
y o u r p ro b lem s. W h e n y o u w a it for
population. T hey use the results to esti­
t h e m .S e l f im a g e d e te r m in e s y o u r
c a p a c ity to g iv e , r e c e iv e a n d in te r ­
so m e o n e e lse to so lv e y o u r p ro b lem s,
m ate how many people are in each state,
y o u n e u tra liz e y o u r o w n p o ssib ilities
city, neighborhood, and block.People
a c t w ith th e lif e e x p e r ie n c e s a n d
fo r lea rn in g a n d g ro w in g th ro u g h the
w h o w anted to use sam pling insisted it
p o s s ib ilitie s w h ic h c o n f r o n t y o u . It
e x p erien c e . W h a t k e ep s y o u fro m ta k ­
w as the only w ay to fix the census in
is lik e a m a g n e t, a ttr a c tin g o r r e p e l­
ing a c tio n w h e n a p ro b le m p re sen ts
places w here it has alw ays been broken:
lin g , lik e o r u n lik e q u a litie s in to
itself? Is it fear o f failure o r o f su c c ess
th at c o n tra d ic ts h o w y o u re ally feel
Places like Laurel H om es, public hous­
a b o u t y o u rse lf? W h ic h e v e r it is the
T aylor H om es, the n ation’s largest p u b ­
w ill b e
filte re d
G
r a p h ic
D
D
is t r ib u t io n
M
anager
C
o n t r ib u t in g
W
r it e r
Portland, OR 9 7 2 1 1
Indian lands throughout the W e s t and in
c h a lle n g e s, y o u s u b c o n sc io u sly a c ­
A sian neighborhoods throughout the
c irc u m s ta n c e s a n d situ a tio n o n so m e ­
o n e else, y o u a v o id tak in g re sp o n sib il­
c e p t th e c o n s e q u e n c e s th a t w ill su re ly
country .N ot suiprisingly, the people w ho
re su lt fro m y o u r in a c tio n . Y o u d e ­
live in these areas o ften face barriers to
ity for w h a t y o u h a v e re a lly d o n e to
c e iv e y o u rse l f in to th in k in g th a t th ere
econom ic opportunity. Hie census m isses
y o u rself. I f y o u d o n o t ta k e resp o n si­
borhoods than tnmosL Forexam ple, w hen
w e looked hard at the 1990 sam ple, w e
sib ility fo r p e rs o n a l g ro w th a n d d e ­
y o u w ill g o th ro u g h a g a in a n d again.
v e lo p m e n t. T h e n a tu re o f c h a lle n g e s
found 783 neighborhoods w here the cen­
sus m issed m ore than 10 percent o f the
is th a t i f th e y c o n tin u e u n re so lv e d ,
people. In m any, the census m issed 20,
th e y o n ly g e t w o rse .
3 0 ,4 0 percent o r m ore o f the pop u latio u
e ad lin es c o m in g o u t o f the
e-mail pdxobserv0aol.com
P ostmaster :
r u o im M ic r t.
Send address changes to
Portland Observer
PO Box 3137
Portland, OR 9 7 2 0 8
Periodical Postage
paid in Portland, OR
nearby ProgressiveC om m unity C hurch.
Latino, A sian o r .American Indian. T hese
In B row nsville, Texas. A lm a R endon,
are the places needing the m ost attention
- the neighborhoods sam pling is sup­
director o f the C am eron P ark C e n tro
Cultural, is know n and trusted in the
p osed to m ake w hole H ow ever, w hen
w e ex am in ed w hat w ould have hap­
pened i f sam pling had b e e n used, w e
found that these neighborhoods w ould
have rem ained heavily undercounted.
la tin o com m unity. In G ulfport, M iss., it
w as Pastor A dam s o f the L ittle R ock
M issionary B aptist C hurch.In L aurel
H om es, the hum an inform ation n e tw o rk
c o n sisted o fm y "aunties” - m o re aunties
Sam pling generally added a tew people,
than m y m other and father had sisters. A t
but nev e r enough to fix the p ro b lem . Hie
any given tim e, they m ight b e o n the
stoop or at the w in d o w , from o n e e n d o f
average u n dercount in these neighbor­
hoods before sam pling w as 37 percent.
A fter sam pling, it w as 34 percen t.lt turns
o u t "m o d e m scientific m eth o d s” m ostly
the neighborhood to the other. I f y o u got
into trouble o n one end, the n e w s w a s at
the other faster than you could run. K ids
adds p eople to neighborhoods w ith good
today have the Internet. B u t in m y n e ig h ­
census counts - o r to those w here the
b o rh o o d ,
cen su s m ista k e n ly c o u n ts too m any
people. In the 1990 sam ple, 75 percent o f
N e t U nfortunately, W ashington experts
often m istake low incom e fo r lo w IQ. In
the peopleadded through sam plingw ould
other circum stances, w om en like m y
have been added to neighborhoods w here
aunties inC incmnati and m en like T y ro n e
m ore than 90 percent o f the p eople w ere
already counted. .Alarmingly, alm ost 20
and L evi in C hicago w ould b e doctors,
law yers, and professionals, c o m m a n d ­
percent o f the people add ed w ere to
neighborhuxxlsthatw ercovercountedjM l
we
had
th e
H
erage are genuinely eligible. T his m eans
1 9 9 9 O r e g o n L e g is la tu r e
checking reported incom e inform ation
pointed tooneconclusion: I a w -
even m ore carefully, requiring a docu­
ent (such as a voter care o r tax return)
m akers h a d tough decisions to m m ake
proving
O regon residency and m onitor­
ab o u t w hich service to support w ith lim ­
ited tax dollars. O n e m em orable head­
ing other eligibility c riteria
line said so m e law m akers w ere looking
elem ent o f the O regon H ealth Plan that
fo rO re g o n H e a lth P la n c u tso fu p to S 100
continues is the C hildren ’ s H ealth Insur­
m illion.
ance P rogram for uninsured children in
This m eant that the landm ark
A nother
health plan, n o w in its sixth year, faced
fam ilies that earn som ew hat m ore than
careful scrutiny, tough questions and a
the federal p o verty level. P eople w ho
d em an d to b e m ore efficient than ever.
believe they m ay be eligible m ay call toll-
W e ’re u s e d to the sc ru tin y : W h en
free (800) 359-9517 (o r T T Y 800 621 -
p olicym akers w ere creating the health
5260) for an application. H ow ever, it is
plan, they held 2 6 0 public hearings and
im portant to understand this: F o r w ork­
m eetings, focused o n prevention and the
ing p eople w h o se earnings put them
w o rld ’s first m edical priority list, and
under the federal poverty level, health
w ere seeking the w isest w ays to use
M edical dollars. A s a result o fth e recent
coverage is available - b u t it Is not free
leg islativedebate.som eO regoniansm ay
These people p a y p rem iu m s on a sliding
Subscriptions are
be con fu sed about the status o fth e health
$60.00 per year
plan. D oes it still exist? W ere m em bers
dollar, w hat O reg o n taxpayers contrib­
cut from the health p lan ? W ere services
ute.
elim inated? T h e short answ ers are yes,
w orked for years and lost her health
D E A D L IN E S
FOR ALL SUBMITTED MATERIALS:
ARTICLES:
Friday by 5 p . m .
O n e O regon w om an, w h o hail
no, a n d not yet. T hese are m ajor points
insurance in a divorce, becam e a health
resulting from ju st-com pleted legislative
plan m em b er after being hit b y a drunk
action: T h e O re g o n H ealth Plan contin­
driver. “W ith o u t it,” I w ould not be alive
ues m u ch as it h as o perated since 1994.
and m y children w ould not h ave a parent
to care for th em ." T h e health o f the
L egislators c u r n o o ne from health plan
w o u ld elim inate several services, actual
overall plan is a result o f O regonians'
support for increasing access to health
cuts w ill require federal approval w hich,
care, illustrated in part b y the v oter deci­
i f it com es, w ill take m o n th s o r longer.
sion to use state tobacco taxes to help pay
freelance submissions Manuscripts and
T he lim it o n the am ount o f liquid assets
th ata h o u seh o ld c an h a v ea n d stillq u a lify
decisions, the headline should b e that
photographs should be clearly labeled
for the health plan w as reduced from
O regon iscontinuing its bold experim ent
and will be returned i f accompanied by
$5,000 to $2,000. L iquid assets m ean
in delivering basic h ealth care to people
ready cash such as checking a n d saving
w h o n eed it m o s t H ersh C raw ford is
accounts, but not a house, car o r retire­
state M edicaid director in the O regon
eligibility. A lthough legislative action
ADS:
Monday by noon
The Portland Observer welcomes
a self addressed envelope A ll created
design display ads become the sole
property o f the newspaper and cannot
be used in other publications or per­
sonal usage without the written consent
o f the general manager, unless the c li­
for i t N o w law m akers have m ad e their
H ie thinking w as that
D epartm ent o f H um an R esources, that
som eone w h o has m ore than $2,000 can
afford to p a y forhealthcare. W e w illb e e f
state ’ s health and hum an services agency
m ent accounts.
ent has purchased the composition o f
1996 T H E P O R T L A N D
RE­
IN
W H O L E O R IN P A R T W I T H O U T
P E R M IS S IO N IS P R O H IB IT E D .
The Portland Observer-Oregon's
Oldest Multicultural Publication-ts a
member o f the National Newspaper As­
sociation-Founded in 1885. and The
National Advertising Representative
Amalgam ated Publishers, Inc. N ew
York, N Y . and The West Coast Black
Publishers Association • Serving Port­
ATTENTION READERS!
Please take a minute to send us your comments. We’re
always trying to give you a better paper and we can’t do that
without your help. Tell us what you like and what you think
needs improving.. suggestions are welcomed and appreciated.
We can take constructive criticism. Get your powerful pens out
and address letters to:
Editor, Reeder Response The Portland Obaarvar
P.O.Box 3137Portland, OR 97208
Thank you for taking the time to give us some feedback.
» A-..'--' ■'>*" **'*'**• ••****<
•A— *
A u n tie -
ing the sam e respect as the experts at the
these num bers add u p to this: sam pling
C ensus B ureau.S om e people w a n t you
to believe the census is only a bout p oli­
alone has n o hope o f c orrecting large
tics, a fight betw een D em ocrats a n d R e­
undercounts co m m o n to A frican-A m eri­
publicans. B u i there is a m ore im portant
can, Latino, A m erican Indian and A sian
neighborhoods. A nyone w h o relies on
fight the battle to m ake W ashington e x ­
perts show a little respect forourneighbor-
statistical adjustm ent to m ake their neigh-
hood experts. M y aunties at the w indow ,
boffioodwhotewiUbed1.sapp0ir1ted.When
W ashington experts fail (that is to say,
m o st often), turn to local experts. I f you
T yrone and L evi in C hicago, R everend
A dam s
in
M is s is s ip p i,
C h ie f
Apesanahkw at in M enom inee — these
w ant to find out how m an y p eople live in
are the true experts on undercounted com ­
a neighborhood, ask som eone w h o lives
munities. R espect them. L isten to them .
o r w orks there.F or the last year, m y
H ire them . G ive them the funding and
colleagues o n the C ensus M onitoring
support to count people, to b uild a plat­
B oard a n d I h ave d o n e ju st th a t W e
form forpeople to speak u p a n d speak out
visited the M enom inee Indian R eserva­
in C hicago, L atino colonias in T exas,
and break d o w n the b arners to opportu­
n ity . Politicians and statisticians can use
“m o d e m science” to m ak e th eir best
farm s throughout the M ississippi D elta,
guess from W ashington. B u t d o n 't use it
a n d o th e r neig h b o rh o o d s across the
as an excuse not to hire m y neighbors to
country. E very place w e w e n t w e found
count m y neighborhood.
local experts w ho knew the area better
than anvone from W ashington evercould.
In
W is c o n s in , it w a s
C h ie f
J. Kenneth Blackwell is Ohio's only
African-Americanstatewideelectedoffice-
holder. He was thefirst African-American
electedtostatewideexecutiveofficeinOhio
as state treasurer in 1994. Blackwell cur­
rently serves as Ohio secretary o f state
tion in W isconsin, R obert T ay lo rH o m es
ApesanahkwaL InC hicago, it w asT yrone
G altney a n d L evi N aw ls, R obert T aylor
residents w h o w o ik w ith n eighborhood
up o ur m onitoring to ensure that people
scale, averaging $ 11 a m onth p e r house­
hold. T his m o n ey reduces, dollar for
land and Vancouver
a larger percent o f p eople in these neigh­
cen c y . Y o u e lim in a te v irtu a lly all p o s ­
B i H ersh C rawford
Fax 5 03 -2 8 8 -0 0 1 5
A L L R IG H T S
along the M exican border, in A m erican
is n o n e e d fo r c h a n g e o r im p ro v e m e n t
a n d d e v e lo p a fa lse se n se o f c o m p la ­
w h o apply for O regon H ealth Plan cov­
S E R V E D . R E P R O D U C T IO N
M ississippi D elta, in L atino colonias
it. T hat w h ic h y o u cannot g ro w through,
5 03 -2 8 8 -0 0 3 3
C
ing in Cincinnati, and C h ica g o ’s R obert
hoo d s - about 60 percent - w ere B la c k
lads, and R everend H erbert M artin o fth e
Letter To the Editor
King, Jr. Blvd.
such ad
(less than one percent) sam ple o f the U . S .
th in g is a lrig h t, a c tiv e ly ig n o rin g y o u r
lem s. W h e n y o u are c o n fro n te d w ith a
4 7 4 7 NE Martin Luther
OBSERVER
hard at the results from the last tim e the
1. P u ttin g the b la m e o n so m e o n e
else. B y p u ttin g th e b la m e fo ry o u ro w n
2. R u n n in g a w a y fro m y o u r p ro b ­
Richard Luccetti
So. w hen 1 w as appointed to a panel to
is also hard in the vast farm land o f the
b ility fo r y o u r c o n d itio n , y o u can n o t
c h a n g e it. N o r, c a n y o u g ro w th ro u g h
Mark Washington
governm ent prom ised, and w hat it prac­
in ac tio n a n d u ltim a te ly failure
5. P re te n d in g th a t e v e ry th in g is
O K . W h e n y o u p re te n d th a t e v e ry ­
k e y s o r sig n a ls to lo o k for:
Heather Fairchild
up in a neighborhood w here w hat the
lic housing com m unity. C ounting people
sis o f y o u r s e l f im a g e , th ere a re certain
e s ig n e r
o f sm oking to the inferiority o f people o f
re su lt is th e sam e.. .p ro crastin atio n ,
In d o in g y o u r o w n p e rso n a l a n a ly ­
Jov Ramos
left out o f previous counts - a dispropor­
claim s about everything from the safety
y o u r lif e e x p e r ie n c e .
d it o r
face it. It is o n ly w h e n y o u face y o u r
p roblem s/challenges and co n sid er them
science" has, in the p a s t m ade false
Five Signals Of A Poor Self Image
C
em scientific m ethods” will find the people
the praises ofstatistical sam pling. "M o d ­
A s y o u r faith a n d c o n fid e n c e g row ,
y o u r a b ility to h a n d le g re a te r c h al­
y o u a re , w h a t y o u a re , a n d w h a t y o u
P
fo u r things: F le e it, fight it, fo rg et it, o r
stro n g e r in fa ith a n d s e lf co n fid e n ce .
in y o u r o w n c o n s c io u s n e s s o f w h o
STAFF
say politicians and statisticians singing
p ro jects to b e c o m p le te d , th at y o u g ro w
o u t o f life . S e l f im a g e is y o u r o w n
c o n c e p tio n o f y o u rs e lf. It is th e m e n ­
ta l a n d e m o tio n a l p ic tu r e y o u h o ld
Established 1970
p ro b le m o r c h allen g e , h o w d o y o u
re sp o n d ? G e n e ra lly , y o u c a n d o o n e o f
tionate num ber o f w hom w ere m inority
children and fam ilies.W orry. "M o d e m
o w n e y e s d e te r m in e s w h a t y o u g e t
(The Fortiani» © bseruer
Im agine this: You're p ro u d o f th e
children you raised. Your grandkids
are talented and beautiful, too. The
reality of retirement has finally arrived
and it's even better than the fantasy
ou have family behind you.
You couldn't have done it without
family behind y o u American Family
Mutual Insurance. When it comes to
y o u r future, over 70 years in th e
insurance business is experience you
can trust. With over six million policies
in an operating area of M states and
a consistent rating of A+ {Superior}
from insurance rating a u th o rity A M .
Best, we've got the kind
o f stability that invites you
to relax. A n d isn't th a t
precisely what you had in
mind? So, call today and
talk to a helpful friendly
agent. Then dive right in.
We II be close behind you