VOL. LX XO. 18.980 Fnrt at Portland lOrmmil MLt, V Artw pBte.ff1e.en1.Cla.s Mutter PORTLAND, OREGON, TUESDAY, SEPTE3IBER 20, 1921 PRICK FIVE CENTS IRI5H-AHE READY TO GO 10 PARLEY HOME BREW. OF ALL KINDS HELD ILLEGAL MAKING OF WIXE IX HOME IS JiOT TO. BE PERMITTED. . 38 TO HELP SOLVE DRENCHING PROVES LEAGUE THINKS TIME E MAYOR OF JOSEPH, OR., REPORTED AS MISSING TIL II. MORELOCK DECLARED FINANCIALLY INVOLVED. AUDITORIUM USE AS CLUB SHOWK VALUABLE TO 'STATE RAIXS ARE REPORTED IX ALL TO DISARM ISN'T RIPE M.VXKIXD HELD STILL TOO PROBLEM OF IDLE SECTIONS OF OREGON. FAR FROM FEACE IDEALS. SUIT FORD OC Demand for Surrender Only Possible Bar. TELEGRAM SENT TO PREMIER Intent to Impose Conditions Denied by Valera. TREATY ' IS Cnreasonablencss of Formal Itccog- ultlon of Erin as Free fctate Is Admitted. LONDON, Sept. 11 (By the Asso ciated Press) Eamonn de Valera, Irish republican leader, sent another telegram to Premier Lloyd George, in which, after declaring that the Sinn Fein had no thought of asking sc tcptanca of any conditions precedent to a conference, he requested the rremler to say whether his letter of September 7 was Intended to be a demand for surrender or an Invlta t on to a conference "free on both rides and without prejudice should an agreement not be reached" In the latter case, Mr. de Valera stated that he would confirm the Sinn Fein acceptance of the invitation, snd the Ir'h delegates would meet fcovernmert representatives. More Telegram, Neeeasary. The nature of the message from Mr. de Valera necessitated a further ex change or telegrama. unless m sort of an ultimatum ia forthcoming. Many London papers have com mented upon the danger of the "open diplomacy" Involved In ths public rxchange of messages, wh!.:h. they point out, makes It difficult for either side to recede from the position adopted. The Irish republican leader ex pressed the belief that a "treaty of accommodation and association," properly concluded between Great Britain and Ireland and between Ire land and the states making up the nrltlsh commonwealth, would end the dispute forever, enabling both Brit ish and Irish to settle down in peace and work together In friendly co operation In "affairs of agreed com mon concern." Notnln Held Conditional. Mr. do lera's telegram follows: "Sir: We have had no thought of asking you to accept any conditions precedent to a conference. We would have thought it Is aa unreasonable to expect you, as a preliminary, to recognize the Irish republic formally . or informally, to surrender our na tional position. If is precisely be cause neither side accepts the posi tion of the other that there Is a dis pute and that a conference is neces sary to search for and discuss such adjustments as might compose it. "A treaty of accommodation and association properly concluded be tween the people of these two islands and between Ireland and the states in the British commonwealth, would, we believe, end the dispute forever and enable the two nations to settle down In peace, each pursuing its own individual development and contribut ing its own quota to civilisation, but working together In frea and friendly co-operation In affairs of agreed common concern. Meeting- Held Neeessary. "To negotiate such a treaty the re spective representatives of the two nations must meet, but If you seek to Impose preliminary conditions which we must regard as Involving the sur render of our whole position, they cannot meet. "Your last telegram makes It clear that misunderstandings are more likely to Increase than diminish and the cause of peace s more likely to be retarded than alvanced by the continuance of the present corre apondence. "We request you. therefore, to state whether your letter of September 7 Is Intended to be a demand for sur render on our part or an Invitation to a conference free on both sides and without prejudice should an agreement not be reached. Definite Reply Ia Asked. "It the latter, we readily confirm our acceptance of the invitation and our appointed delegates will meet your government's representatives at any time In the Immediate future that you may designate." Tremler Lloyd George's letter of September 7 was the one In which he asked Mr. de Valera for a definite reply as to whether "he was prepared to enter a conference to ascertain how the association of Ireland with the community of nations known as the British empire can best be recon ciled with Irish national aspirations." To this Mr. do Valera replied In the affirmative, but added to his reply the paragraph now in dispute. Offer la Admitted Fair. Papera friendly to the Irish cauae, like the Westminster Gasette and the Manchester Guardlr.n, admit that the premier's last Invitation to Mr. De Valera aa the "chosen spokesman" of Ms people, was a fair offer, which Mr. De Valera would be wise to ae cipt without more ado. They also ICeaulutUd eo Pag i. Colutua 4.) Dry Law Commissioner Says Only Non-Intoxicating Fruit Juices 3Iay Be Manufactured. WASHINGTON. D. C. Sept. 1J. Warning that the making of Intoxl eating "home brew" Is illegal was Issued tonight by Prohibition Commts sicner Haynea. Numerous inquiries have been re ceived, he said, concerning home mail ufacture of fruit Juices growing out of reporta that a head of a household was entitled to make 200 gallons of wine a year under permit. The prohibition unit's attitude on the hometbrew question "was defined by Mr. Haynei as follows: nwnpTrnL 'Non"'n,oxkatln "'ruit Julce ean AUVUUAI tUfbe ma in the home. Intoxicating wine, home brew and distilled spirits may not. Two hundred gallons of non Intoxicating fruit Juice may be manu factured tax free by the head- of a family registering with a collector of internal revenue. "This tax-exemption provision has been the source of confusion. The elfect of this Is not to allow the man ufacture of 200 gallons of intoxicat ing wine free from restrictions of the national prohibition act, but merely to allow the manufacture of 200 gallons of non-intoxicating Juices free of tax" NEW PROFESSION APPEARS Export Enologlst, Otherwise Wine- maker, Offers Services. SAN FRANCISCO. Sept. 19. A new profession has appeared In San Fran Cisco. An "expert enologlst'" adver tised his services today In a local paper for the benefit of heada of families who are entitled under the iw io manufacture a maximum of svv gallons or non-Intoxicating wines. An "enologlst" is defined a. sen thoroughly experienced In the making of wine. Hia advertisement reads: "Since the law allows you to make 00 gallons of grapejuice for your own family's use. let an expert enol- osisi make It for you at your own residence, avoiding poor results and waste of money. Start now before grapes go too high." FOOD PRICES WORKING UP Figures for August Show Material Advance Over July. WASHINGTON. D. C. Sept. 1. Wholesale prices increased 2.75 rjer cent in August ov.r wholesale food prices leading ln the advance with an Increase of 13.5 ner cant, according to figures made pub lic looay oy the department of labor. Farm producta. Including many food articles, were 2.5 per cent higher in August than In July, the statement said, adding that there were decided advances in. butter, cheese, milk. eggs, rice, meata, sugars, fruits and pota toes. Meat animals, Sncluding cattle and hogs, also averaged higher in August than in July. In all other commodity groups, except clothing, which was unchanged, the statement said, there were decreases ln prices. LAD OF 11 ELECTROCUTED Boy Flaying In Tree Comes in Con tact With Wire. K I DUE FIELD, Wash.. Sept. 19. (Special.) As the result of touching a high-power line of the Ridgefleld Light & Power company near Sara, seven miles south of here, while play ing in the top of a fir tree with his companions. Earl A. Salxman, 11-year. old son of Mr. and Mrs. A. F. Salxman of Sara, was electrocuted today while his playmates looked on. The high-power line carries 11.000 voltage to Ridgefleld. The accident occurred near the John Eaton farm on the Ridgefleld - Sara Vancouver road. Besides his parents, two broth ers, M. E. Salxman and Harvey Salx man. and a sister, Thelma Salxman, survive. D. W. CHURCH GETS POST Pocatello Man Chosen Idaho Com- v missloner of Investments. BOISE, Idaho, Sept. 18. The ap pointment of D. W. Church of Poca tello to be commissioner of public In vestments In the cabinet of Gover nor Davis was announced today by the governor. Since the sudden death last Feb ruary of Charles Elmer, who had been commissioner of public invest ments since the reorganization of the state departments in 1919, the office has been vacant with Alfred Hogen sen. chief clerk of the department, acting aa commissioner. Mr. Church has been for the last 29 months man ager of the state insurance fund under the workmen's compensation law. SPOKANE MILK 10 CENTS Sale of More Than 3000 Quarts Over Average Day Reported. SPOKANE, Wash.. Sept. 19 (Spe cial.) The Producers' Distributing company, by decreasing the retail (rice of milk to 10 cents a quart. In creased Its business today by more than 2000 quarts, according to Wil liam Baker, manager. We are putting out milk at 10 cents a quart," Mr. Baker declared. "BuiA ness Is rushing. We're getting hun dreds of new customers. We put out more than 2000 quarts today over our tegular business of 2000 quarts." Harding's Call to Con ference Is Accepted. SESSIONS TO OPEN 'MONDAY Other Names to Be An nounced by Hoover Later. W. B. AYER WILL ATTEND Action Toward Relief of I'nem ploymcnt Is Expected This Win ter as Result of Session. WASHINGTON. D. C, faept. 19. An nouncement of the names cf 25 men and three women who have accepted President Harding's invitation to par ticipate in a national unemployment conference here beginning next Mon day waa made tonight by Secretary Hoover. Other names will be an nounced later, he said, when all re plies are received. The list includes Secretaries Hoo ver and Davis; Julius Barnes of Du luth, Minn.; Samuel Gompers, Charles M. Schwab and John L. Lewis of the Mine Workers. The women are Ida Tarbell of New York, Mary Van Kleeck of New York, connected with the Russell Sage foundation, and Elisabeth Chrlstman of Chicago an officer of (he National Woman's Trade Union league. Mr. Hoover has been appointed chairman of the conference, which. It was said, would dissolve Itself at once into special committees for the formulation of plans. Theae commit tees, he asserted, no doubt would seek co-operation from other repre sentatives of labor, employers and civic bodies. It was considered probable that President Harding would open the conference with an address outlining the administration's desire to remedy unemployment. Many Elements Represented. "In naming members of the confer ence," Mr. Hoover said, "It bas been the desire of the president to secure geographic representation and have regard to the different elements who are Interested and can be helpful ln the problem without attempt at pro portional numbers - or particular groups. Those of experience in those industries where there is the largest degree of unemployment have been called on in larger proportion than from trades where there is less un employment. It was Impossible to Include representation cf the whole of some of SO trade groups ln the conference and hold its size within workable limits." An economic advisory committee of 20 was appointed and, Mr. Hoover stated, has been at work on the pre paration of data and a working pro gramme. Secretary Davis also has teen co-operating ln for.oulatfng (Concluded on Page 20. Column V) THAT'S t . i Xo Damage Is Done to Prunes, but Winter Wheat Land Will Be ln . Excellent Condition. PENDLETON. Or, Sept, It (Spe claL) Three-quarters of an inch rale fell here yesterday and today. The moisture was expected to put the wheat lands of this section in excel lent condition for autumn plowing. The rain was the first in several weeks. Dust was laid on the streets and the country roads, putting them in condition for travel during Kound up week. LA GRANDE, Or.. Sept. 19 (Spe cial.) Rain falling durirg the past 24 hours will benefit greatly the win ter wheat growers, many of whom are seeding now. Spring wheat, much of which is still unharvested, prob ably will be damaged to some extent but the benefit to the winter wheat land will far offset the damage to the spring wheat. SALEM, Or., Sept, 19. (Special.) The rains of the last two days have not resulted in any harm to the prunes in the Willamette valley, ac cording to reports received at the offices of the Oregon Growers' Co operative association, with headquar ters In this city. Picking is now well under way, and practically every drier in this district is being operated to capacity. Louis Lachmund, one of the best- known hop dealers ln Oregon, said today that practically 90 per cent of the hops had been harvested, and that the product now on the vines would be saved unless the rains continued unabated for several days. Practi cally all of the hops produced here this year have been contracted to English syndicates for export trade. EUGENE. Or.. Sept. 19. (Special.) A total of 1.69 Inches of rain fell In Eugene Saturday night and Sun day. Prunes are cracking to some extent, said J..O. Holt, manager of the Eugene Fruit Growers' associa tion, and damage -will be severe, he said, if the rainfall contlnoes. The ground was moistened to a suffi cient extent as to permit of early fall plowing. BEND. Or., -Sept. 19. (Special.) A heavy rain, general throughout central Oregon during Sunday and today, has greatly benefitted roads in this section. A total precipitation of 2-10 of an Inch was recorded here.. CARLTON, Or Sept. 19. (Special.) A heavy rain started fall'.ng here Saturday night and continued through the night and most of Sunday. Prune harvest has Just started, and should the rain continue there will be heavy damage to the crop as It w'.lt cause the prunes to split, and make pick- ng disagreeable, if not Impossible. The crop is spotted In this sec. Ion and enly one-half crop is expected. WHITE SALMON, flash., Pept. 19. (Special.) Sunday, the f' st rain since April 28. fell. The dust was laid nd though too late to afiect the fruit, it washed off the leaves and apples. The unprecedented early frost of September 11 killed many of the gardens. Jefferson Welcomes Rain. JEFFERSON, Or.. Sept. 19. (Spe cial.) A heavy rain throughout this section last night and today is wel comed by all but the prune growers. ho fear damage if it continues. FIXE, JUPE, BUT DON'T OVERDO IT! Council's Commission Declares Washington Conference Can Handle Situation Better. GENEVA. Sept. 19. (By the Asso elated Press.) The commission on disarmament of the league of nations council. In its report issued today, finds that the Washington conference can better deal with the question of naval disarmament than the league, and that it can be more effectively secured by common agremeent among the great powers. Discussion by the commission thus far Is In line with this conclusion, involving a slow but sure policy, With regard to land armanents also It appeears that the same policy has the upper hand. "Mankind Is still too far removed from the ideals of peace to make possible at present the solution of the question of disarmament," Is the final conclusion of the commission. Replies to the assembly's request that the governments limit expendi tures for armaments for two years to the amount of this year's budget are quoted in support of the commission's contention. Of the 27 replies received, 17 were classed as favorable, seven as un favorable, and three as vague. Ab sence of the United States, Germany and Russia from the league consti tutes a great obstacle, ln the opinion of the commission, which adds that the difference of opinion arises from the policies of the different countries, varying circumstances and changing conditions. EIGHT BALLOONS LAND Two Americans Xot Yet Reported ln Bennett Trophy Race. BRUSSELS, Sept 19. (By the As sociated Presa) But one of the three balloons piloted by American aero nauts, which left Sunday in competi tion for the James Gordon Bennett trophy, has been heard fro-n up to fhortly before midnight tonight. Eight of the 14 starters had been ac counted for. The English entrant. Banshee, landed near Carmarthen, Wsles: the Crombex, French, at Brlghtjn, Kng- nd; the Valle, Italy, at Aberaeron. Wales: the Belglca VII, . Belgium, piloted by Lieutenant de Muvster. at I'oweratock, England, and '.he Bar- banty, Italian, near Swansea. Wales. Wade T. Van Orman, an American aeronaut, landed miles northwest of Exeter, England; the Spanish con testant, Magdalena, at Treheroert, 25 miles from Cardiff, Wales, and the gas bag piloted by the Englishman Spencer at Fishguard, Wales MELLON'S ESTIMATE RIGHT September Income and Excess Pi-oHls Tax $525,000,000. WASHINGTON, D. C, Sept. 19. In complete treasury report of collec tions of September 15 installments of income and excess profits taxes Indi cate a practical certainty that Secre- tary Mellon s estimate of Ij25.ooo.ooo wlll be realized, officials said today. I Collections so far, officials said. showed $425,000,000 ln the federal re serve banks with reports from vari ous outlying districts to be received. LOST BY STOKES Court in Same Decision Gives Decree to Wife. INFIDELITY PROOF LACKING Parentage of Children Is Al lowed to Go Unquestioned. WOMAN'S HYPOCRISY SEEN Justice Cites Fact Defendant Tea tiried Mate Was Cruel When She Wrote Endearingly. NEW YORK. Sept. 19 (Special.) W. E. D. Stokes today lost the action for divorce, which he brought against his second wife, Helen Elwood Stokes of Colorado. The decision was by Supreme Court Justice Finch. By the same decision Mrs. Stokes won her case, tried Jointly with her husband's action, and was awarded a decree of separation. In his decision. Justice Finch held that no finding of Infidelity could stand upon the testimony adduced "since the plaintiff has not overcome the burden of the proof cast upon him." Continuing his decision. Jus tice Finch said: "To give the plaintiff a divorce, wnicn wouia practically also ques tion the parentage of the children although In fairness to the plaintiff it should be said that no attempt has been made to prove their illegitimacy there must be offered proof of exact times and places and if upon the times and places, aa testified to by the witnesses for ihe plaintiff, it has not been proved that the offenses took place, the decree cannot be awarded." Mrs. Stokeu Uxaaarralrd. In reference to these dates. Justice Finch maintained that the statements of Mr. Stoke' lawyers that the tes timony on the part of the plaintiff tends to prove the necessary facts generally and without regard to par tlcular dates, and also that the wit nesses had mistaken the dates, are not sufficient. He added that "if the witnesses did not Intend the dates as given, the able and painstaking counsel for the plaintiff would not have let the mistakes occur." Reviewing . the counterclaim of Mrs. Stokes. Justice Finch held that a great deal of what she testified to "has been exaggerated.' If, indeed, some of it really happened at all.' The court maintained that this was shown by the fact that the occur rences were not entered ln the body of the diary upon which she fre- quenuy rcuea io reiresn ner memory as to the alleged cruelties of her husband, but were placed at the end of the book and only referred to by asterisks placed in the regular por tion of the diary. HypoerlNy rotated Out.' Justice Finch called attention to the fact that while Mrs. Stokes was suffering "this cruel and inhuman treatment," as she alleged, she was at the same time writing her husband most endearing and affectionate letters. "The husband, however," Justice Finch continued, "did not take the stand contenting himself with the an nouncement of his counsel that he did not wish publicly to take Issue on a question of veracity with his wife. In consequence, while making due al lowance for the exaggeration and un reliability of the testimony of the de fendant there yet remains sufficient evidence upon which to find a decree of separation, especially In view of the fact that the testimony has not been contradicted." Tea Co-repondens Named. There were upward of ten co-respondents in Mr. Stokes' action for di vorce, testimony being given on the charges as to four of them. Justice Finch declared that an anal ysis of the voluminous record con firmed the Impression produced on him at the end of the trial that there was not one charge of Infidelity upon which the evidence adduced by the plaintiff presented a case free from contradictions or detection, and that Mr. Stokes did not establish guilt on the part of his wife. Two witnesses for Mr. Stokes testi fied that in the latter part of May, 1!'14, in the late afternoon, tbey looked from an extension roof through the upper half of a window Into the room of a house on East Thirty-fifth street and there saw Mrs. Stokes, clad only ln a single gar ment arise from a bed In the apart ment of Edward T. Wallace and ar range her hair before a mirror, and that Wallace got up from the bed and pulled down the shade. Of this tes timony. Justice Finch said, "the plain tifff has failed to sustain the burden uf proving that this woman was the defendant." Pappy Incident Cited. Justice Finch declared it to be ex tremely improbable that Wallace would have, on another occasion to which one of Mr. Stokes' witnesses testified, telephoned to a tenant ln the house to bring a puppy to his apartment when, as was alleged, Mrs. Stokes was there. As to the testimony of one wit ness that she had seen Mrs. Stokei iCoucluued ou Pag 2, Column 2.) Prominent Citizen and Business Man of Many Years Is Gone After Losing Fortune. LA GRANDE. Or., Sept. 19 (Spe cial) Til H. Morelock, mayor of Jo seph, In Wallowa county; president of the commercial club there and one of the most highly respected citizens of the town for years, has disap peared and left a trail of debts run n!ng into many thousands of dollars, according to an announcement re ceived here today. Mr. Morelock has not been in Jo seph for about a month. He left Just after he had sold a shipment of lambs for cash, came to La Grande, where he cashed a check for 11500, and went to Baker, where he cashed another check. Since then no trace has been found of htm. So great was the confidence ln Mr. Morelock in his home town that it was not until the end of last week that an Investigation was begun. Then it developed that the man who was reputed to be worth about 1100. 000 had left many debts behind him. Among the heaviest creditors are the Western Bond and Mortgage com pany of Portland, the Columbia Basin Wool Warehouse company of Port land, the First National Bank of Jo seph and W. B. Fordlce of Lost Prai rie, his partner In a large stock ranch acquired two years ago. The missing man's life history Is that of a man rising rapidly from humble means and by plunging and good luck amassing a fortune and then when business conditions be came tight not being able to weather the storm. Ten years ago Mr. Morelock went to work In the Elgin Forwarding company's warehouse at Joseph, hav ing no property and dependent en tirely on his wages. He worked hard and saved and by lucky speculations amassed a fortune that reached Its height two years ago. In the meantime he served a num ber of terms in the city council and also was a member of the school board ln Joseph. MAN, 90, TAKES 7TH WIFE Oldlime Hack Driver Weds All Daughters In One Family. ATLANTIC. Ia.. Sept. IS. (Special.) Fred Harris, 90 years old, has JUBt married his seventh wife. All his wives were daughters of Peter Yost. who lived in Milwaukee and sailed a freighter on the Great Lakes in the '60s. Harris be ran by marrying the old est daughter of Yoat and has gone right down the line. The last five were widows. Mrs. Gustave tdel- mann is the last bride and ehe is now 78 years old. She has been mar ried twice before. Harris, who was a hck driver and later driver of a horse car ln Chicago after the great fire, recently bought a small fruit farm here on which to pass his remaining years. SHIP BOARD UNION TALKED Combination of Three Offices Dis rusxed With Harding. wituivnTON. D. C. Sept. 19. ("cmbinat'on of the three present of fices of treasure.-, controller ana auui icr of the shipping board under one i ,n h known as the financial vice-president of the board, was dis cussed with President Harding today .... ('ho irman I.Kkr. The new office would consolidate v.- ri,itt. nf hA nreaenL aenarate olf'ces, Chairman Lasker said, adding that he was looking for "a big flnan- ;ial man" to take the place. WOMAN LEAPS INTO FALLS Plunge Over Niagara Tuken Xeur ;at Island Bridge. NIAGARA FALLS, N. Y., Sept. 19 An unidentified woman was borne through the upper rapids and over the American falls today after "she was sten to Jump into the river near Goat island brldue. The name, Mrs. Wyant. Buffalo, scribbled on a piece of paper tucked into a purse, was found on the shore. INDEX OF TODAY'S NEWS The Weather. YESTERDAY'S Highest temperature, 04 decree.: lowe.t, 2; cloudy. TODAY'S Rain. we.lorly winds. Foreign. Irlh are ready to confer with British It surrender ia not condition. rage i. National. Home brew of all kind, declared Illegal. Page 1. Sims denies saying let Britain have ocean commerce. Page 2. Thirty-five accept call to unemployment conference. I'age l. Congres.men find arma liu la paramount with folks at Home, i-age s. Dometttlc. Arbuckle clasps wife In bla arma. Pag 16. Sports. Oulmet medalist in qualifying golf round. Page 14. Johnson denied by Tllden's cannonball tennis. Page J. Pacific Coa.t league remits: At Seattle 9. Portland io; no oiner games, teama traveling, rage 14. Commercial and Marine. All records broken for single day's wheat receipts, rage as. Export .tatlMlia have bullish effect on Chicago wheat maraet. i-age as. Advance In liberty bond prices continues. I-age S3. Twenty million feet of lumber to ! loaded for orlenl in a" aay.. rin Portland and Vicinity. gantaella cur.es America, says wife ln di vorce suit, cage i. Portland Railway. T.lght Power company to sell 110.000.000 stock. Pag 10. Third ctrcu. bandit probably Identified ln Vancouver, Wash. Page 6. Southern Pacific official! declare better time, are ahead. I'm. 13. Big delegation of bankers expected tn Pacific northwe.t shortly. Paa II. Five thou.and vli;-r. go to Portland business show. Pag 7. Film Rent Kept Up, Say Movie Men. COUNCIL HEARING IS HELD Contract for Hall Wielded t Make Good Deal. CASE CONTINUES TODAY Decision Will Be Made as Whether or Xot City Will Lease Building to 31. G. Wlustock. Charges that the public audltorlun Is. being used by outside motion pic ture producers as a "club"' to fore the Jensen & Von Herberg interests i Portland to pay excessive prices fo motion picture releases were sub stantiated yesterday before the cit council by telegraphic instruction sent in August from New York t Carl Stern, northwest manager the Metro corporation. A hearing to determine If the pub lie auditorium would bo leased for showing of "The Four Horsemen o the Apocalypse" was postponed unti 11 o'clock this morning at the aug gestion of Acting Mayor Bigelow who demanded that additional tele grams be produced before the coun ell by Mr. Stern. Members of the city council lcarnc that after Melvin G. Winstock, a rep resentative of the Metro corporation had .entered into a contract with th city for the showing of this piutur he had subsequently negotiated wit) C. S. Jensen for the booking of th picture at the Peoples theater. Three-Hour Hearing la Held. A three-hour hearing before the clt council, which waa replete with sal lies and accusations, served to glv the city fathers some Interesting ob scrvatlon 'of the manner in whit the producers of pictures operate fo favorable sales. The hearing result ed from reports received by Hal M White, manager of the auditorium, t the effect that Mr. Winstock had ne gotlated for the sale of the plctur which he had booked to show at th auditorium for 13 days. After evidence had been produce showing that Mr. Winstock had calle on Mr. Jensen the day following th signing of the auditorium contraci and told him that the picture wa still open for the Jensen houses, Da J. Malarkey, attorney for Jensen I Von Herberg. asfced Mr. WlnstocKl why he had attempted to enter Int noKiitlutlona with Mr. Jensen If It wa not to sell the picture. Whole Bn.lnrM Held "null." "I was Just 'bulling' Mr. Jensen,' answered Winstock. "You know ii the motion picture business, Mr. Jen sen bulls me and I bull him. Th whole business is bull from one en' to the other." ' "Why did you make an appolntmen to see him and then break it?" ask. Attorney Malarkey. "Well, I didn't want to do busines with him on account of the bookln. in the auditorrum," he answered. "Hut you did call at his office a 9 o'clock ln the evening, after callln. his secretary and telling her that yoi would be there at that time, did yo not?" "Yes." he answered, "but I knev that he was out on the Culumbl. highway at that time." Note Is Produced. "But how about this note here? said Attorney Malarkey, as he pro duced a note dated September 9 an signed by Winstock. "This note say that you will be at the Benson unt. your train leaves for Seattle." "Well I was only at the Benso hotel part of the time," answere Winstock. "But what if Jensen had connect with you at the Benson hotel, wha then?" Attorney Malarkey acked. "Oh, I would have bulled him som more, that's all," was Mr. Winstock' explanation. Manager White told the city counc. that last spring he had entered Into contract for the showing of "Kismet for ten days. Just before the time t show the picture in the auditorium ar rived, Mr. White declared that to booking was canceled and th clt was left to "hold the sack" with te: open dates valued at from $200 to S!0 night. Negotiations Are Lengthy. It was only after lengthy negotia tlons that a contract was entered Int with Mr. Winstock for the showing cl the "Four Horsemen of the Apoca lypse" at the auditorium, he ean. for he was demanding that the to price for the picture be $1. while th producers held out for $1.50 top prio However, atter ine conirati na' been signed and he considered that II was final, he received reports fron representatives of the Jensen & Vo- Herberg interests tnat winstocn wa negotiating with them for the sale oi the picture. It was then that he wrot lo Mr. Winstock demanding that h appear before th city council an prove that such sssertions were no true, or accept a cancellation of th dates as an alternative. In opening the hearing. Actln Mayor Blselow took exception t iCoutiudcd ou las i. Co.uiuu 1.)