Morning Oregonian. (Portland, Or.) 1861-1937, October 23, 1914, Page 7, Image 7

Below is the OCR text representation for this newspapers page. It is also available as plain text as well as XML.

    PRINCIPAL FIGURES IN CARMAN MURDER CASE.
MAID'S STORY FALSE
Alleged Murderess of Woman
in Husband's Office Tes
tifies in Own Behalf.
JEALOUSY IS ALSO DENIED
MRSL CABMAN SAYS
Explanation. Is Orrered for Every
. Acknowledged Act on Xight ot
IShooting Husband Declared
Attentive to Xurse.
MINEOLA, N. T., Oct 22. Mrs. Flor.
I nice Conklin Carman took the witness
stand in her own defense in Supreme
Court here late today to enter a sweep
ing denial of the charge that she mur
dered Mrs. Louise Bailey.
Item by item she went over the story
f Celia Coleman, the negress in her
employ, at the time of the tragedy in
the Carman home in Freeport last
June, and declared false every accusa
tion made against her by the ex-maid.
A fabrication from beginning to. end
was, in the essence, her characteriza
tion of the maid's narrative of the
alleged events on the night Mrs. Bailey
-was shot and killed in the office of
Edwin Carman, husband of the defend
ant, and of subsequent happenings in
the Carman home.
aiald'a Testimony Is Attacked.
The story told by the girl was of
fered by the prosecution as tending di
rectly to connect Mrs. Carman with the
shouting and the efforts of Mrs. Car
man's counsel today in questioning his
client were designed chiefly to dis
credit the servant's testimony.
Mrs. Carman responded with alacrity
end seemingly with entire frankness
to the questions of her attorney. Her
demeanor was that of a woman in com
plete command of herself.
On occasions she smiled. Again her
lace wore an expression of sadness,
as when she mentioned her visit to
the morgue to view the body of the
woman whom the state charges she
killed.
She looked into the faces of the jurors
with steady eyes when she desired to
Impress them with some particular
point and she seemed resentful when
certain points in the story of the
negress were under discussion.
Revolver Given Prosecutor.
"I did not show Celia a revolver "
Baid Mrs. Carmen in denying the
maid's testimony. "The only re
'volver I ever handled was a little one
the doctor kept in his bureau drawer
That was a little one. I gave It to the
IMstrict Attorney.
"Celia Coleman did not speak the
truth when she said she tried to keep
me from going into the nffir-o i
not tell Celia 1 would take care of her
"y it anytning should happen
to her. Neither did 1 ever give Celia
Jo and tell her that was for keeping
her mouth shut. 1 never winked at
Celia when you were asking me ques
tions. I ditl not tell Celia the day
after the murder to get Mr. Conklin
Irom the barn, as 1 wanted Kim to get
the revolver out of the house.
"I did not go to Celia's room the
morning after the murder. I did not
say: '1 hope God will forgive me. Oh
why did 1 kill that woman.""
Mrs. Carman then took off her gloves
and exhibited her bare arms to the
jury.
Scars on Arnu Denied.
"I never had any scars on them." she
eaid. "They were not there on the
night of June 30."
Mrs. Carman was on the witness
stand nearly an hour under direct ex
amination. She will undergo cross
examination tomorrow.
The defense sprang a surprise when
George M. Levy, her attorney, called
her name and asked her to take the
' stand. The court had been adjourning
every day at 4:30 o'clock. The crowd
in the courtroom had been listening
with little apparent interest to stories
told by witnesses called in an effort to
break down the testimony offered by
i'rank Farrell, the Bowery character
who is another of the people's impor
tant witnesses.'
Many of those who hart K.en -
tendance throughout the day had left
when the defendant was called, nearly
15 minutes after the recuii- ,.)(,,,,
time,
lf' '
i stdLif
Ph otos by Underwood & Underwood.
,T.L.S.' 'LORE CR COWMAN. ACCUSED OF MIRDER OP MRS. BAILEY. BELOW-DR. CARMt.N, HER
J' ' AN" RS. HELEN CORBY. A NIECE, WHO WAS AT THE CARMAN HOME OS NIGHT OF THE
AIL JtDER .
DRY SQUADRON DUE
itcs afte'r the regular ' closing
Serret Phone Admitted.
The wife of the Freeport physician
admitted that she had installed a tele
phone instrument in her husband's of
fice, but she flatly denied that she
was "insanely jealous." She said she
had heard people ask her husband "how
all his, giriB were." , Sometimes he had
stayed out all night. Because of her
daughter she said she did not want to
obtain a divorce, but if her husband
was as bad as he had been painted to
her she wanted to know it.
If she found what she had heard
was true, she said, she had determined
that she woukl continue to live in the
tame house with him as if nothing had
ever happened, but that she would
never speak to him again. Then, on
the morning after the murder, she de
clared she tore out the device that the
Attorney had termed a "me
chanical eaves-dropper," because she
muugni. ner nusoand already had
enough to bother him. She explained
every action.
Another Woman lu Case.
Mre. Carman even corroborated some
cf the state's witnesses by admitting
that on the evening of the murder she
Jiaa cauea to her daughter. Elizabeth,
to stop playing the piano. But she did
this, she swore, because she had a
headache and not. as the prosecution
has intimated, because she wanted to
listen over the mechanical eaves
dropper to what her husband was say
ing to a woman in his office. She ad
rnitted. too. that on one occasion she
looked in the same window as that
through which the assassin of Mrs.
Bailey fired. But this, she said, was
because she knew a trained nurse he
appeared to be fond of was in his office.
First Group to Arrive Here
Today to Aid Cause.
DELEGATION MEETS TRAIN
COURTESY SH0WN SMITH
.Corvallis Itepublicung Hear Demo
cratic Candidate Score Party.
CORVALLIS. Or., Oct. 22. (Special
Ir. c. J. Smith. Democratic candi
date for Governor, spoke last night a'
the courthouse to a large number of
people, many of whom are personal
friends and staunch supporters of Dr
Withycombe. The courtesy was in re
sponse to a comment in one of the local
papers, a strong Withycombe organ
' which read. "It would be a fine act of
courtesy if 1000 Republicans in Dr.
Withycombe's home city should go out
to hear Dr. Smith."
Dr. Smith dwelt at length on the
steady increase of taxes during the
past eight years, during the Chamber
lain and West administrations., but
more especially during the West administration.
Governor and Mayor to Welcome
Visitors Rallies to Be Held
Rose City Rink, Where
Speeches Will Be Made.
When the members of the first group
of the "Flying Squadron" arrive at the
Union Depot this morning at 7:20
o'clock they will be ' greeted by a
large committee interested in the dry
campaign in this state and escorted
to the M.iltnomah Hotel.
The Portland reception committee is
composed of H. W. Stone, chairman;
Mrs. Jennie Kemp, Mrst G. L. Buland.
A. Lv Veazie, Harry Coffin, H. M.
Esterly, F. C. Knapp, Mayor Albee,
Governor West, T. T. Geer, Dr. J. H.
Boyd, B. C. Bronaugh and Mrs. F. S.
Myers.
At meetings to be held this after
noon at 2:30 P. M. and, tonight at
7:30 speeches will be delivered at the
Rose City rink. East First and Morri
son streets, in support of the dry
movement in Oregon. Dr. John tL
Boyd will preside at the afternoon
meeting and K. C. Bronaugh at night.
The advanca group of the squadron
includes-Dr. Clarence True Wilson and
Dr. Daniel V. Poling, former Port
land pastors. Dr. Poling is now a resi
dent of Boston, where he serves as
associate president of the United So
ciety of Christian Endeavor, while Dr.
Wilson is secretary of the Temperance
Society of the Methodist Church. E. O.
Excell is the musical director, A. W.
Roper the pianist and Dr. D. V. Poling
the soloist of the first group.
The Flying Squadron is composed of
three groups, each of which will ap
pear in rotation at Portland, Salem and
Roseburg for three days.
The following are the members of
the second group, which will arrive in
Portland tomorrow:
Clinton N. Howard, Mrs. Culla Vay
inger. Charles M. Scanlon, Everett R.
Naftzger, musical director; Hugh Por
ter, pianist; Miss Laura Shawe, soloist.
Mrs. F. S. Myers and T. T. Geer will
preside at tomorrow's meetings.
While the members of the Flying
Squadron are not allied with any par
ticular party, club or society, they are
in harmony with all organizations that
are working in common for the ad
vance of the dry movement.
SENATOR GIVES UP TO DRYS
Flying Scuadron's Visit to Roseburg
Forces Chamberlain Out.
ROSEBURG, Or., Oct. 22. (Special.)
On account of the meetings being
held here by the Flying Squadron of
America. United States Senator George
E. Chamberlain has cancelled his speak
ing engagement in Roseburg Friday
night. He will pass tomorrow after
noon visiting the Soldiers' Home, while
at night he will be entertained at an
informal reception.
The members of group one of the
Flying Squadron of America made their
formal debut in Oregon today, when
they" discussed the state-wide prohibi
tion movement before crowds that
taxed the capacity of the Antlers The
ater here both afternoon and at night.
Daniel A. Poling, of Boston, who was
the chief speaker at today's meetings,
said the temperance forces were con
fronted with the gravest situation in
the history of the Nation.
"Challenged by unusual circum
stances men do unusual things. Con
fronted by that which, humanely speak
ing, is impossible, in the drive of a
great crisis men do the impossible."
he said. "When liberty is at stake
and truth crushed to earth, 1 omnip
otence opens a way and supermen set
their brothers free.
"The temperance forces of the Na
tion are challenged by unparalleled
circumstances. The challenge is tne
challenge of science, tf industry, of
ail allied reforms, of politics, of re
ligion and of highest patriotism."
The speaker then dwelt at length
upon various scientific. Industrial,
economic and political phases of the
liquor question.
Turning to the industrial phase of
the liquor problem, the speaker said:
"We can tinker with the- tariff until
doomsday and not begin to solve the
problem of the high cost of living
until we take $2,000,000,000 out of the
fists of John Barleycorn. This Is the
annual drink bill of the United States."
Other speakers at today's meeting
were Rev. Clarence True Wilson, of
Portland, and Rev. Wilbur F. Sheridan,
of Chicago. The personnel of the first
contingent of the squadron is Wilbur
F. Sherida Charles M. Sheldon, Rev.
Clarence True Wilson. Daniel Poling,
D. V. Poling and A. W. Roper. They
left here after tonight's meeting for
Portland..
The members of the group Were met
at the train by the local band, and
a reception committee of 50. After
parading through the business district
they went to - the theater, where the
first meeting of the engagement was
held.
The Epworth League, of the Metho
dist Church, of which Mr. Sheridan is
National president. entertained the
party at 6 o'clock dinner tonight. The
meetings of the squadron will con
tinue here until Saturday night.
0. A. C. HEARS M. J. FANNING
Prohibition Support Crged on Stu
dents at Regular Convocation.
OREGON AGRICULTURAL COLLEGE.
Corvallis, Oct. 22. (Special.) M. J.
Fanning, of Philadelphia, was the
speaker at the regular convocation of
Oregon Agricultural College students
and faculty yesterday. Mr. Fanning
is an orator who for many years has
devoted his time to the temperance
cause.
His subject yesterday was 'The
Liquor Traffic versus Commercial Pros
perity," and was an eloquent appeal to
the students of the college to support
the movement for prohibition. Musical
numbers were contributed by Mr. Hel-lier-Collins
and Captain Harry Beard,
both of the O. A. C. school of music.
Just In
A new
lot of
"Multnomah'
Hats at
$3.00
None better.
ConjTi!it ILrt SchiiTacr fcUus
You First
Anything; that's right for
us to sell must be right for
you to buy. That's our
theory here and we've se
lected our stock for you ac
cordingly. Because it 's what 3Tou're going
to get that you're interested in,
you'll appreciate this showing of
Hart Schaf f ner
& Marx Clothes
They're the best clothes made
anywhere in the world; there's
no better way for you to profit
than to buy them.
Pay $25 if you can; some as
low as $18; others for more.
Saml Rosenblatt & Co.
'The Men's Shop" for
quality and service.
Northwest corner
Third and Morrison.
FUGITIVE IS 'HERO'
'Happy Jack' Chretien Rescues
Sweetheart on Battlefield.
COAST POLICE WANT HIM
Ex-Convict, Former Popular Attor
ney of San Krandsco, Gives Spec
tacular Performance In War
Zone, Says Paris Paper.
SAN FRANCISCO. Oct. 22. (Spe
cial.) Although the police of New
York. London and Paris are supposed
to be vigilantly searching for "Happy
Jack" Chretien former San. Krancisco
attorney and clubman, this vigil has
not prevented the irrepressible Chre
tien from engaging in some highly
spectacular performances in the midst
of the war xone and being exploited
in the London papers as a hero.
There are many persons in San Fran
cisco and other Pacific Coast cities who
would like to interview Chretien and
the police of both this country and
Europe, where he recently was traced,
have been asked to assist in securlnsr
such interviews, but apparently this
fact has not worried Chretien
Under date of October 4, the London
Weekly Dispatch reprints a clipping
from the Central News of Paris, which
tells how the former San Francisco
attorney and a Scotchman named Dun
lop Ferguson penetrated into the midst
of the fighting in Alsace to rescue
Ferguson's sweetheart, who had been
caught in the thick of ther fighting.
Although they were at once arrested as
spies, they succedded in rescuing the
SAGE TEA KEEPS
YOUR HAIR DARK
When Mixed With Sulphur It
Brings Back Its Lustre
and Abundance.
Gray hair, however handsome, de
notes advancing age. We all know the
advantages of a youthful appearance.
lour hair is your charm. It makes or
mars the lace. When it fades, turns
gray and looks dry, wispy and
scraggly, Just a few applications of
Sage Tea and Sulphur enhances its
appearance a nunoredfold.
Don't stay gray! Look young! Either
prepare the tonic at home or get from I
any drug store a 50-cent bottle of
"Wyeth s Sage and Sulphur Compound '
Thousands of folks recommend this j
ready-to-use preparation, because it
darkens tne nair beautifully and re
moves dandruff, stops scalp itching and!
tailing nair; oesiaes. no one can pos
sibly tell, as it darkens so naturally
and evenly. Tou moisten a sponge or
sort orusn wun it. crawlng this
tnrougn tne nair, taking one small
strand at a time. By morning the
gray hair disappears; after another
application or two, its natural color
is restoied and it becomes thick, glossy
auu luauuua, una you appear years i
SA
ILfi
Today and Saturday Only
Your choice from two hundred . "Waists,
values to $6.00. Temptation
Sale Price,
WATCH OUR WINDOWS I
M3
$2.49 . m
SIXTY SKIRTS Values up to $7, that
!ve nave reaucea xor tms q yl c t f ' WA
great Temptation Sale to... pO.t 7 f
. a bp;
pies, Balmacaans and other desirable lT If) ,7 nfa
styles. Temptation Sale Price, ljj ' ' - Mm
a II ii i
I I t t M 1 H M I 11 y IJ t! R y. Tt- ' I I I .'.,iyW
STYTH Awn Ainrp ctq III! I rV'rfi
lx unnaa mw nuLii uiu. II - CM llll 1 1 1 f rSLUI
OPPOSITE OREGON I AN l Jj '81110 IP
'" .
young woman and in taking her to
Paris, and there Chretien gave out a
vivid Interview concerning the sanguin
ary fighting he had seen when the
heights of Sainte Marie were taken
by 600 Turcos, only 12 of whom survived
the victorious charge.
Chretien was once one of the most
popular of the younger attorneys in
San Francisco, but he got into trouble
and spent "several years in San Quentin
on a forgery charge. Soon after bis
release le again was charged with
cashintr worthless paper and It U on
this charge that he is wanted here now.
Postmasters Are Confirmed.
OR EGOXIAN NEWS BUREAU, Wash
ington. Oct. 22. The Senate today con-
n
firmed the nomination of John P. Cor
ley as postmaster of Brownsville. Or.;
also Leonard Taibott as postmaster at
Toppenisii, Wash., and Walter A. pis
cus as postmaster at Potlatch, Idaho.
Lecture at Library Hall Illustrated.
Dr. Harry Beal Torrey will give the
opening lecture of the course on the
care and training of young children
this afternoon at 2:30 o'clock. His
subject will be "Heredity and
Eugenics."' This lecture is given undjr
the auspices of the parents' educa
tional bureau of the Oregon Congress
of Mothers.
There are 1.400.000 cattle in Ceylon.
REDUCTION IN PRICE OF GASOLINE!!
When we began selling Gasoline the price was 20e per
gallon! We are now selling it for 12Vc per gallon and
with the automobile owner's assistance
WE HOPE FURTHER TO REDUCE THE PRICE!!
Our. price on Auto Supplies being NO HIGHER, and gen
erally lower, than other dealers, are you going to give us
your supply business T Would you prefer to pay 20c per
gallon for Gasoline or 12Vc in other words ARE YOU
FOR OR AGAINST US T
A. J. WINTERS CO., 67 6th ST.
Factory Branch
PENNSYLVANIA RUBBER CO.
Vacuum Cup Tires.
Phones: Main 6137, A 1S37.
SEATTLE
FEVER AND
DRESSMAKER
STOPS HAY
RHEUMATISM WITH AKOZ
Mrs. Carrie Gimble, 2601 Yesler Way, Says
Wonderful Medicinal Mineral Effective
Against Both Ailments
"This is the first year In 20 years
that 1 have been free from hay fever."
says Mrs. Carrie Gimble. a dressmaker,
residing at 2601 Yesler Way, Seattle,
'and I give Akoz. the wonderful medic
inal mineral, credit for being rid of
this distressing ailment.
"I began taking Akoz some months
ago." continued Mrs. Gimble, "for rheu.
matism. I had suffered from this dis
ease for 15 years. The knees and
ankles had become swollen, painful and
inflamed. After using Akoz externally
for a few weeks and drinking the Akoz
mineralized water a month. 1 was
greatly pleased to find the pain had
decreased and" the swellings going
down. I kept on the treatment for a
few months and am now cured. So
confident was I from the results Akoz
had given for rheumatism that I be
gan using it for my hay fever: well
this ailment that has been with me
for 20 years has gone. I found the
Internal treatment seemed to get at
the cause, and I used nasal sprays
and throat gargles to get at the ef
fects. This method of treating is all
that has made me free from hay fever.
I can now do my sewing without any
inconveniences whatever. as beside
ridding me of my suffering my entire
system seemed to be benefited."
Akoz has given relief to thousands
suffering from rheumatism, stomach
trouble, diabetes, Brigrht's disease,
liver, kidney and bladder complaints.y
catarrh, ulcers, piles, eczema and other
ailments. For sale at all leading drug
stores, where further information may
be nad regarding this advertisement.
Why drink water when you can get
SALEM BEER
ihe most popular beverags on tas
Pacific Coast?
SALEM BEE& is brewed in one of the most modern
plants on the Pacific Coast. It is aged in steel
glass-lined tanks. It is conveyed by modern pips
line system direct to the bottle bouse, bottled under
pressure and therefore never comes in contract with
the air from the time it leaves the fermenting tank
until the bottle is . opened by the consumer. Ths
consumer is absolutely assured a beer of ideal
tltervescence, snap and purity.
A trial will surely convince any one of the ex
cellence of Salem Bottled Beer.
The family trade of Portland is supplied by
ths firm of
PENNEY BROS.
"' olephone: Bell. E. 287
Home. B-242S
379 EAST MOEEISON STREET
younger. -a.v.
" U')'-