VOL. XLVIII NO. 14,769. PORTLAND, OREGON, TUESDAY, MARCH 31, 1908. PRICE FIVE CENTS. PNC T ASSAILED BY CALIFORMIANS Question of Veracity With Forester. MONDELL RUSHES TO ATTACK Los Angeles Water Supply Causes Contention. PRAIRIE MEN TO DEFENSE Furions Assault on Extension of Forester's Powers Ends In Many Changes Democrats Fllibnstcr and Aronse Cannon's Ire. WASHINGTON, March 30. Charge -of a serious nature against Glfford. Plrjchot, Chief of the Forestry Bureau, were made today 1n the House by Smith of California, and Mondell of "Wyoming, during consideration of the agricultural appropriation bill. Smith accused him of entering into a secret understanding with the City of Los Angeles, with a view to securing to the city valuable water rights in the Owens River Valley, as against the interests of private parties having prior claims. Mondell denounced him for, as he charged, illegally paying the expenses of forest officials in attending conven tions in the West, in which the Gov ernment had no part, and also for spending Government money to boost his bureau in the newspapers. Mr. Plnchot was defended by Pollard of Nebraska and Scott of Kansas. Smith of California denounced the Forestry Service for attempting to ac quire the Owens Valley in California. Outrages by Plnchot. "If," lie said, "I should state to the House the ultimate purpose, the liouse would be shocked. In many ways," he aid, "the service is doing a great good, but it is working some outrages upon certain interests in the western part tt the country." He was referring, he said, to the manipulation of water rights under the laws of California. He openly charged that Mr. Plnchot, the Chief Forester, was trying to secure the water rights for the use of certain persons against others who had made earlier applica tion for the water. There was not, he insisted, a single element of forestry in the proposition, and it would be a sin to give the Forest Service the great privilege it nought. Los Angeles Seeks Monopoly. Pressed ly Weeks of Massachusetts to explain more in detail "his serious charge" against Mr. Pinchot, Smith said that the party he referred to as desiring to obtain the water monopoly was the City of Ixvi Angeles. He instated that the city did not desire the water, "it has not claimed the water, and it has not asserted any inteniton of uelng the water for mu nicipal purposes." The city already, he said, had a perfect water system, and simply desired "to sweep in all the water there and carry it out of the valley, 250 miles through miles of mountain tun nels, for the irrigation of land adjacent to los Angeles." Asked Him to Do It, Says Pinchot. While the debate was "going on. Pollard of Nebraska went to the telephone and had a talk with Mr. Pinchot. When he came back into the, chamber he declared that Mr. Pinchot had said that the entire I'allfornia delegation, "including Mr. Pmith." had gone to the department "antf requeued and almost demanded that this reserve be created for the purpose of fur nishing a water supply to Los Angeles," and that the city was entirely dependent rn tills supply. "Now." he charged, "Mr. Smith comes here and tries to show that the department is trying to create a mo nopoly." The policy of the department. Pollard declared, was to prevent monopo lies rather than to create them. Not True, Say Californians. Smith denied that Mr. Pirn-hot's state ment was true. Ho asked the House to call on his colleagues to bear him out. "I never did," said Kahn. "I did riot." said Know-land. "Nor did I." remarked Needhatn. "Nor 1," added Bilchright. Smith said ho would hunt up the rest of the delegation and get them also to rise nd deny Mr. Pliu-hofs statement. On objection by Mondell. the clause authorizing the Secretary of Agriculture to advise and assist owners of "lands within and adjacent to the National for ests In the proper care of the same" was stricken out. That vast tracts of untimbered land have been included in forest reserves was the charge of Smith of Arizona, who criticised such action. And this was admitted by Scott of Kansas, but he said tho Forestry Bureau had given prompt attention to petitions in pro test and had released over 12,000,000 acres of land so Included. After heated remarks by Gfilnes of Tennessee agaiast the lumber trust. Mon dell of Wyoming sarcastically aald that that gentleman, "for one who had so Teeently attended a meeting of the com mittee on public lands." seemed to be well versed on the subject. This remark nettled Gaines considerably. "It's enough," he said, "to wear any man out to keep up with these land frauds." The legislation was not satisfactory to Mondell, who charged that It had been the rule of the Forestry Bureau to se cure . "rather extraordinary opinions" from the Attorney-General. He insisted that, if the President had authority to create a reserve, he had authority to divide one. "o Tax on Water Rights. Smith of California again got the floor and, speaking of the resolution of the President that water rights should be taxed, denounced him for it. "The Fed eral Government," he declartd, "ought to be ashamed of itself, if it undertakes to extort a tax by way of a right-of-way over a piece of land that is not worth $1 an acre." On points of order the following were stricken out: Authorizing the Secre tary of Agriculture to divide and desig nate for administration land reserved for National forests; making irrevoca ble for 50 years permits for power plants within the National forests; au thorizing the Secretary of Agriculture to accept land for forest purposes or to exchange land for stumpage in the f ' f.. , t,..,. J.,.-r l1IIIIT I GifTord Pinchot. Chief Forester, Object of Violent Attacks in the House. National forests; covering into the Treasury and creating a special fund for the administration, protection and improvement of the Forest Service of all moneys received as contributions toward co-operative work; authorizing advances of money to chiefs of field parties for fighting foreBt fires. Burleson of Texas made a plea for an Investigation of the best means of preventing the ravages of the mistle toe and offered an amendment to that effect. In doing so he brought down upon himself a lot of good-natured gibes. The amendment was lost, 38 to 43. Mondell Again on Warpath. More criticism of Mr. Plnchot was Indulged in when Mondell offered an amendment providing that the money for transportation or traveling ex penses of forest officials or agents shall not be paid unless such officials traveled on business directly connect ed with the Forest Service. Mondell charged that such officers and agents last year had attended a convention in Denver with which the Government had nothing to do, and that their ex penses had been paid out of the Feder al Treasury. He knew it was not safe to attack the Forest Bureau, because of the influence it had. "That Influence," he declared, "Is used to such extent that men's motives are bound to be impugned and men are certain to be attacked in news papers every time they presume even to suggest that the service is not en tirely free from criticism." Scott protested that Mondell was mis taken in saying Government money had (Concluded on Page 5.) CONTENTS TODAY'S PAPER Th Weathr. YESTERDAY'S Maximum temjerature, 47 decrees; minimum, ST. TODAY'S Showers; westerly wind. Foreign. British Hoiine of Commons adopts home rule resolution. Page 1. Haytian President again arresting conspira tors. Fatt 1. National. Combined attack on Plnchot In House spoils his forestry policy. Page I. Senate Inadvertently prints report on sealing which attacks integrity of Fairbanks and many other prominent men. Page 1. Kaiser says Hill Incident was exaggerated by gossip. Page 2. Politic. Brvan open campaign in West with speech "at Kansas City. Page 1. AKLrlch currency bill attacked on all sides. Page 4. Itomestlc. No more bodies recovered from burning Hanna mine. Page 3. Kail road 3 forced to employ many men to repair tracks by reviving prosperity. Page 8. Berk mam unknown by Sllverstein, tho anar chist. Page Phut down of coal mines makes 250,000 miners idle. Page 3. New York grand Jury wants facts about Jackson rent to Governor and legisla ture. Page 5- m Sport. American auto to go direct to Siberia from Seattle. Page 2. Beavers eager to begin games at 6 an Fran cisco. Page 4. Pacific Coast. Fulton gives the lie to Heney at Medford. Page - Issue on Statement No. 1 clearly denned In Marion campaign. Page Commercial and Marina. Complications In banana trade. Page 16. Favorable crop weather causes weakness In grain markets. Page in. Stock prices sag at New York and London. Page 15 Exports for March break all records for that month. Page 14. Portland and Vicinity. Portland Methodist ministers favor change in form of church amusement ban. Pag 10. Harrlman attorney suggests glutton of Portland gateway problem. Page 14. Paul Morton guest of Portland business men at banquet. Page 10. Telephone companies may be forced to put in fire alarm wires. Page 16. Republican tate Central committee called to meet April 10. Page T. Hearing of suit to break Myers mill re sumed In County Court, page 7- COMMONS VOTE FOR H01V1E RULE Liberals Join With Irish on Question. BIBRELL SUPPORTS REDMOND Reform Only Alternative to "Something Like Hell." ISSUE AT NEXT ELECTION Redmond Reminds liberals of the Pledges and Gives Warning. House Adopts Resolution by a Majority of Two to One. JjQNDONV' March 30. The House of Commons tonight, after a lengthy debate on the question of home rule for Ireland, adopted by a vote of 313 to 157 a resolu tion moved by John El .Redmond, Na tionalist leader, that "in the opinion of this house a solution of this problem can only be attained by giving the Irish peo ple legislative and executive control of all purely Irish affairs after the reso lution had been amended by adding the words "all subject to the supreme author ity of the Imperial Parliament." In introducing the resolution, which de nounced the present system of govern ment In Ireland and wound up with the declaration that "in the opinion of this house a solution of the problem can only be attained by giving the Irish people legislative and executive control of all purely Irish affairs," Mr. Redmond put the home rule issue in uncompromising fashion. Force Issue at Election. Redmond declared that an overwhelm ing majority of the present House of Commons always had professed their be lief that the concession of home rule was the only solution of the Irish prob lem and that every member of the pres ent government had given pledges to this same effect. He now proposed to put them on record and force the hand of the Liberal party at the next elec tion, so as to make an issue of the gratu itous pledges made by so many members at the last election not to introduce home rule during the life of the present Parliament. Would Overcome Disloyalty. The only argument remaining against home rule, Mr. Redmond continued, was an argument of force. He said that, if Ireland is disloyal, so was Canada in 3837, and so was General Botha until the Transvaal was given self-government. Mr. Redmond in conclusion asked the house to give Ireland what has been given the Frenchmen of Quebec and the IHitchmen of the Transvaal, and thus close the blackest chapter in the history of the empire. Karl Percy, on behalf of the Unionists, moved an amendment declaring the house to be unalterably opposed to the NO DOUBT I I creation of an Irish Parliament with a responsible executive. Birrell for Home Rule. Chief Secretary of Ireland Birrell came out squarely In support of home rule and declared that there was not a man in the House of Commons but knew that sooner or later there would be a very Substantial modification In the relations between Great Britain and Ireland. The Imperial Parliament, he said, had no time to attend to the needs of Ireland; there were scores of vital measures requiring Immediate and 'constant attention, un less they were going to allow "some thing like hell" to prevail in Ireland. If the Nationalists could bring their propo sals clearly before - the people at the next general election, Mr. Birrell said he t I f s ; t I J ; i'fej j Judson Harmon, of Cincinnati, Candidate for Democratic Nom ination for Vice-President. believed the English electorate would1 rally to their help. MIKE ARRESTS IN HAYT1 OFFICERS, IMPLICATED IN AL LEGED PLOT, TAKEN IN. Fleeing to Consulates for Reruge. Five in the French, One in the German. PORT AU PRINCE, March- 30. Nu merous arrests were made last night and today of officers ' u?jected of complicity in tho latest conspiracy, of which General Iarraque, chiaf of the cavalry, was al leged to be the leader. Squads of soldiers are continuing their search of houses in quest of fugitives. Five officers, including Larraque. have taken refuge in the French legation, and one is in the German Legation. DEFRAUD UNITED STATES Suit Against Montana Surveyors Placed ou Trial. HELENA, Mont., March 30. What promises to be the most sensational cast tried here in years was begun today in the Federal Court, when Oliver C. Dallas, John D. McLeod, former employes of the Surveyor-General's office, and A. S. Ho vey, deputy mineral surveyor, were placed on trial on a charge of conspiring to de fraud the United States. Three overt ac tions are alleged in each of the two counts that falsified notes were fonged; that affidavits purporting to be that of deputy mineral surveyors were forged, and that the notes and affidavits were presented to the Surveyor-Geenral for official approval. HERE ABOUT WHICH WAY BATTLE IN WEST OPENED BY BRYAN No Reforms to Be Ex pected From Taft. LA FOLLETTE IS HIS IDEAL Says Roosevelt Policies Op posed by Leaders. NO HOPE IN REPUBLICANS Declares There Are Many Democrats in Republican Banks and They Can Only Gain Desires by a Democratic Victory. KANSAS CITY, March SO. Democrats from all parts of Missouri to the number of 2000 attended a banquet in Convention Hall in this city tonight under the aus pices of the Young Men's Democratic Club of Missouri, at which W. J. Bryan and Judson Harmon were the gruests of honor and principal speakers, and the recipients of repeated ovations from the 15,000 per sons who thronged the hall. Each ban queter paid Jl for the privilege of at tending. Even the distinguished guests Insisted upon the Democratic prerogative of paying for their plates, and the affair was probably the most elaborate political feast ever attempted in the state. Democratic clubs in St. Louis and other cities of the state sent representative del egations to the dinner. Among the guests were four ex-Governors of Missouri T. T. Crittenden, David R. Francis, Senator W. J. Stone and Alex M. Dockery to gether with the present Governor, Folk. All of the candidates for state offices were present. Thf meeting was essentially a Bryan affair, spontaneous in making mention of his candidacy for the presidency. The re ception of Mr. Harmon was no less cor dial and suggestions promising him high honors from his party were received. Mr. Bryan's opening statement that "we have met to begin the campaign of 190S and to present those principles and poli cies Which ought to appeal to Republi cans as well as to traditional Democrats," was the keynote of his speech and showed the important significance he and his fol lowers attached to the meeting tonight. A feature of Mr. Bryan's speech was his approval of Senator LaFollette as the Republican candidate for President. He said: , Democrats to Opposite Party. In this great city on the boundary line between Missouri with her rock-ribbed Democracy, and the West, which until 1898 was counted as Republican territory, we have met to begin the campaign of 1908 and to present .those . principles and policies which- ought to appeal to progressive Re publicans as -well as to traditional Demo crats. It is only a recognition of a fact which is becoming clear to all to say that there is a Democratic .element in the Re publican party to which a successful appeal can be made. I might give several in stances of this fact.- In the first place, what is known as the Roosevelt sentiment is strong in the valleys of the Mississippi and the Missouri; and the Roosevelt sentiment is not so much attachment to person as de- HE'S GOING i votion to n Idea with which th pern has Identified himself. And what U this Idea? It is the idea that conditions are. not what they should be. Before a remedy can oe applied the need ol a remedy must be admitted. For years the rroocratij party has been poirrtinff out the abuses which have been a-rowing under ths Republican rule, hut thos abuses have been denied by Republican lead ers, and the country has been congratulated upon the possession of everything; essential to its welfare. Republican platforms have been full of fulsome eulogy of the Republican party and barren of promises of reform. Even the platform of 1904, upon which President Roosevelt was elected, was silent in regard to the Government evils and gave no hope of relief. To the surprise of Democrats and to the surprise of Republican as well, the Presi dent began to recommend remedial legisla tion, taking as his guide the platform dec larations of th Democratic party. He did not follow in the footsteps of Democracy out of any desire to compliment the Democrat or to encourage them, but simply because the Democrats had pre-empted all , the ground in front and he could not go for ward without trespassing upon their land. R4osvelt Not a Democrat. It to not stramre that his sufffestlons were bailed with delight by Democrats and met with indignation by Republicans. "Whether the President cultivated a reform sentiment in the Republican party or only revealed a .v. . Augustine Birrell, Chief Secretary for Ireland. Who Declares for Home Rule. previously existing, sentiment we shall never know, and the question Is not material any how. It fs sufficient that it now exists, sufficient that it is so strong that the Presi dent is praised by the masses just in propor tion as he assails the predatory corporations and pleads for reforms that look to the res toration of equity and fairness in the Gov ernment. The President is not a Democrat, for he leans toward Hamilton rather than toward Jefferson, and he favors concentration of power in Washington and a centralization of government, which Democrats regard as dis tinctly hostile to the National welfare. It Is proof that the reform sentiment in the Re publican party is not only large, but militant, that the corporate interests, powerful as they are, have not been able to coerce the Middle "West into the support of any of the Repub lican candidates who are regarded as reac tionary. This In itself is the most hopeful sign of the Democratic victory, for, the President having aroused this sentiment, the Republican party must satisfy the expecta tions excited or lose the support of the rank and file of the party. How Republicans Can Win. Now, what prospect le there that the Re publican National Convention will satisfy the urgent demands of reform Republicans? I venture to predict that no serious attempt will be made to satisfy these demands. Two things are necessary to establishment of con fidence in addition to the repeal of its own laws and to reform of the abuses which have grown out of Republican legislation and ad ministration, and these two things are, first, a platform specifically pledging the party to clearly-defined reforms, and, second, the nom ination of a ticket composed of men imbued with a spirit of reform. If In the coming campaign the Repub licans have an ambiguous platform, filled with glittering generalities and fragrant with bouquets thrown at the Republican party, a Republican President, elected upon it would be as powerless as the present President has been. I say powerless for what has the President succeeded in doing 7 Ha Follette a True Reformer. There are more trusts today than there were when he entered office, and be has never succeeded in getting a law enacted to strengthen the present law. He has not Eucceeded in nutting a trust magnate in the penitentiary, and the only large fine that has been Imposed has aroused more criticism than commendation among Re publican leaders. He has not secured any traffic reforms, and yet he has been in office for over seven years. He has not secured the enactment of the necessary labor leg islation; has not secured an income tax, and the Republican Senators forced him into a compromise on the railroad question. But even a good platform would be worth less without a candidate who embodied the spirit of the platform, and what candidate have they? If the President had picked out Senator La Follette, a real reformer, if the Republican party had rallied to Senator La Follette's support, it could have compelled the confidence of reform Republicans. Sen ator La Follette has a record as a reformer; he ha fought corporate domination in his own state for a decade. Taft Has no Reform Record. The President has picked out Secretary Taft and given him the support of the adminis tration. "Without the support of the admin istration the Seer eta ray would scarcely have a state in the country, and with the presi dent's support he is having an uphill fight, He has no record as a reformer and his speeches do not Indicate a definite purpose or a courageous programme. He may be the best man the President could find among his Cabinet officers, but Secretary Tart's super iority over his colleagues is due not to his positive virtues, but to the fact that none of the rest of them has any reform tendencies. In fact, the widespread reform sentiment among the Republican masses is not re flected to any considerable extent among Re publican leaders. What does Secretary Taft stand for? What does he denounce as wrong? What does he propose to remedy? What would he do with the trusts? He tells us that he would not exterminate them, but simply regulate them What does he propose on the tariff question? Revision, but not until after election. What reform does Secretary Taft propose for the benefit of labor? The laboring men insist that they are entitled to trial by Jury; but Secretary Taft went all the way to Okla homa to find fault with a provision In the Oklahoma Constitution securing this protec tion to the laboring man. What relief does Secretary Taft propose to give us from the burdens which imperialism has imposed upon the country? The appro priation for the Army and Navy has Increased more than $ 100, 000. 000 since we entered upon our colonial experiment. Our Army is more than twice as large as It was in 1890, and we are still denying the Philippine Islands the doctrine set forth in the Declaration of Indopendence that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the gov erned. What is Secretary Taft going to do on the railroad question ? In one speech he took oc casion to explain that the President was not (Concluded on Page 3.) kk&a. i w 3 iftx fi F DRAKER DROPS BOMB lil SENATE He Did Not Know That It Was Loaded. FIERCE ATTACK ON FAIRBANKS Accused by Elliott of Deliber ate Falsehood. HARD ON OTHER SENATORS Keport on Sal Herd Proves to Be Savage Denunciation or All "Who Opposed Stopping Butchery. . Foraker Busy Apologizing. VTASHXN-GTON-. Maich 30. Senator For aker today obtained leave to -withdraw from the Senate files a paper introduced by him on Wednesday last and printed as a public document, and the order carried with It the suppression of all the printed copies of the paper. His Introduction of the paper last week and the withdrawal today contained no intimation of its sen sational character, which still would be unknown had not several- copies been given out before It was suppressed. The paper was prepared by Henry "Wr. Elliott, of Lakewood, O., and purported to be the "official record of the loot and' ruin of the fur seal herd of Alaska." It was stated In chronological order, begin ning about 1886 and continuing to the present time. It . was written in long hand, closely written and difficult to read. Attacks Integrity of Officials. Professor Elliott had submitted records of pelagic sealing several times and they had always been printed as public doc uments. Therefore, when Mr. Foraker was asked to have the alleged "official record" printed, he made the request in the usual form, and did not take the trouble to read it. Today he made apologies to Vice-President , Fairbanks and several Senators. It was not until the paper came out in printed form to day that its character became known. It was found to reflect upon the integ rity of the presiding officer of the Sen ate and members of the Senate, House and other officials. 1 Charge Fairbanks With. Falsehood. Passing over 30 years of the "official records," Professor Elliott dealt with the work of the Anglo-American High Com mission in connection with the sealing question and told of an argument made by Mr. Fairbanks in opposition to a seal ing bill before the Senate committee on foreign relations in 1902-3, when he was a member of, the Commission. Senator Fairbanks deliberately tells the commit tee that this bill is not needed; that the fur seal question has been agreed to by the joint cbmmission and only awaits formal publication when the Commission assembles. He assures the committee that reconvening of the Commission is to take place soon after March 4, 1903. Pro fessor Elliott then says: "The statement of Senator Fairbanks was an untruth in every respect a square and wholesale fabrication on his part to defeat the pending bill. Under the circumstances his colleagues could not dispute his false reports; therefore they took no action on this bill, at his request." Says Officials Were Suborned. The official record refers in dispar aging manner to the part taken by the late John Hay in regard to the seal ing question and charges that legisla tion was bitterly opposed "by the land and sea butchers of the fur seal herd, who had suborned certain Senators, Congressmen and diplomatic officials." It refers to the "extended trip of in spection over Alaska" made by Senat ors Dillingham, Nelson, Burnham and Patterson and mentions the fact that no legislation was accomplished. Fault is also found with the fact that Secretary Root and Assistant Secretary Bacon "had done absolutely nothing," al though informed that a plan of mutual concession and joint control by the Uni ted States and Canada "could be success fully negotiated in six weeks time." The long record closes as follows: Why should this Infamous work of the land and sea butchers of our fur seal herd go thus unchecked? And that. too. when the Canadian government asks us to unite with it on a proper plan to suppress it? No quibbling; or nonsense about the necessity of "seetnc" or Bounding JaDan or Russia, first will bear the light of honest discussion. Those governments have both been ready at any hour since 18UT to unite with us on any plan to suppress pelagic fur seaiing, which we could nrst get Canada to as sent to. EARLY MORNING BLAZE. Fire of Unknown Origin Does $3000 Damage on Burnside. Fire of unknown origin at 2 o'clock this morning destroyed the cigar and fruit stand of K. Kawand, 206 North Sixth, near Burnside. The names extended to the second floor and did slight damage to furniture In the Albany rooming-house. The saloon on the corner was also damaged.- The total loss is close to J3000. Kawand's loss is placed at $2000. He carried $1000 insurance. Officer James Anderson rescued four women and a child from the second story, one of the women being slightly oversome by the smoke which filled the upper rooms. Police attribute the Are to incendiarism. V A