143rd YEAR, No. 51 WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2015 ONE DOLLAR Warrenton walks warily on LNG; Astoria pounces Two cities navigate contentious project By ERICK BENGEL and DERRICK DePLEDGE The Daily Astorian While Warrenton city commis- sioners are carefully taking steps to insulate themselves from public opinion on Oregon LNG so they can remain unbiased, the Astoria City Council has come out against the $6 billion project. City commissioners have been advised by legal counsel not to open or read LNG-related emails and, if they do, to forward the messages to City Manager Kurt Fritsch so staff can collect them. Warrenton Mayor Mark Kuja- la said Tuesday night that he has ignored the emails so far , and has politely told people when they ap- proach him in person that he wants to remain objective. Warrenton’s planning staff has recommended that Oregon LNG’s permit applications be approved with conditions to offset the impact of the terminal and pipeline project on traf¿ c and public works. Public hearings wrapped up last week, and the decision by Daniel Kearns, a Portland land use attorney appointed by the city to review the applications, is widely expected to be appealed to the City Commission. “We know this is something that might come to us, and more than likely will come to us,” Kujala said. “We can anticipate an appeal in this, regardless of the decision that the hearings of¿ cer makes.” The commissioners’ “ultra-con- servative approach,” as Kujala put it, is in contrast to the Astoria City Council, which had been silent on LNG for the past decade. Sending a message The Astoria City Council, which has no regulatory role over Oregon LNG, voted 4-1 Tuesday night to op- pose the project and urge local, state and federal decision-makers to deny the terminal and pipeline. See LNG, Page 10A $VWRULD Warrenton sees uptick in students GUDZV line on YDFDWLRQ UHQWDOV Clatsop Community College requested zoning change By DERRICK DePLEDGE The Daily Astorian Edward Stratton/The Daily Astorian Kids line up to load on buses at Warrenton Grade School, which has grown by 154 students between 2006-07 and last school year. Schools face ebb and À ow of enrollment By EDWARD STRATTON The Daily Astorian (QUROOPHQWFKDQJHVIRU&ODWVRS &RXQW\6FKRROGLVWULFWV $VWRULD 6HDVLGH :DUUHQWRQ +DPPRQG .QDSSD 127(3URMHFWHGHQUROOPHQWVIRULQFOXGHDQ LQFUHDVHLQHQUROOPHQWIURPKDOIWRIXOOGD\NLQGHUJDUWHQ -HZHOO (VWLPDWH P rincipal Lynn Jackson and the staff of Astoria High School greeted students Tuesday morning, as school started back up across Clatsop County. Jackson has about 20 percent fewer kids to greet than when he started as vice principal at Astoria seven years ago. Over the last nine years, Astoria School District has shrunk by more than 10 percent, while Warren- ton-Hammond School District has grown by 16 percent. Countywide, all districts be- sides Warrenton have experienced a drop in enrollment, from a nearly 20 percent drop in Jewell over the past nine years, more than 9 percent in Knappa and a 2 percent decline in Seaside. The trends might point to a movement of families to cities. (EEDQGÀRZ Nowhere has the trend of de- creasing enrollment been more 6RXUFHV2UHJRQ'HSWRI(GXFDWLRQORFDOVFKRROGLVWULFWV stark than at Astoria High School, which has lost 176 students be- tween counts in 2007 and last year, nearly a quarter of its student pop- ulation. Much of the change in enroll- ment, Jackson and Superintendent Craig Hoppes said, can be ex- (20HGLD*URXSJUDSKLF plained by the ebb and À ow of larg- er and smaller class sizes moving through school. Last year’s seniors numbered 158, while juniors were at 131, and sophomores numbered 165. Jackson, vice principal since 2007 and principal since 2012, said he expects an even further drop, as middle -school classes numbering between 130 and 150 work their way into high school. Then come last year’s second- and third-grad- ers, who numbered 161 and 152, respectively. “I think some of that is ebb and À ow, but there is also a decrease in enrollment” over time, Jackson said. When looking at economic data, Jackson said, he looks at how it af- fects the opportunities of impov- erished Title X students who face homelessness, transiency, rather than how it affects enrollment. “I know the demand for afford- able housing in Astoria is really high,” said Jackson, a former land- lord in Astoria. A teacher he recent- ly hired, Jackson said, had to ¿ nd a place in Seaside because of how tight the housing market is. “We have a lot of teachers who live in Warrenton,” Jackson said, adding a lot of homes in Astoria are often being purchased by retirees who can afford increasing prices. *URZLQJLQ:DUUHQWRQ Warrenton Grade School Princi- pal Tom Rogozinski oversees kids leaving late Tuesday afternoon. He has four new classrooms to watch See STUDENTS, Page 10A ‘David and Goliath’ on the beach Al fresco dining experience leads to neighbor clash By DANI PALMER EO Media Group Drawing an unusually sharp line, the Astoria City Council Tuesday night rejected a zoning change that would have allowed a new vacation rental at 16th Street and Franklin Av- enue. Clatsop Community College asked to amend the land use and zoning map to help sell the Josie Peper Building to a prospective buy- er who wanted to use the property as a second home and vacation rental. The rezoning from high -density resi- dential to general commercial would have also applied to the college’s Performing Arts Center next door. Some neighbors objected to the change, arguing a vacation rental would be out of character for the historic Shively-McClure neigh- borhood, and city councilors seized on the opportunity to make a larger point about the city’s housing short- age. With Astoria a tourist draw, and websites such as Airbnb helping to drive the vacation rental market, many worry that more of the city’s already lean housing stock will cater to tourists and second-home buyers. A draft affordable housing study prepared by city planners recom- mends that the city continue to dis- courage vacation rentals that are not owner occupied in residential neighborhoods . The City Council will hold a work session on the study Monday. “We are really lucky in Astoria to have our neighborhoods protect- ed from vacation rentals,” said City Councilor Zetty Nemlowill, who has been an advocate for workforce housing. “All over Oregon — Bend and Yachats, Cannon Beach — there are examples of nightmare scenarios where vacation rentals are destroy- ing the character of those communi- ties.” Vacation rentals, she said, also make “it easier for people to own second homes there. And less af- fordable for the people who live and work in those cities.” Mayor Arline LaMear said, given the city’s de¿ cit of residential prop- erty, that “it doesn’t make any sense to me to change this zone to com- mercial.” The City Council voted unani- mously to direct staff to come back with ¿ ndings later this month that support a denial of the zoning change of the Josie Peper Building and the Performing Arts Center. &RPSOH[DQGHPRWLRQDO CANNON BEACH — Wayfar- er Restaurant’s new outdoor patio is crowded with diners despite a Cannon Beach order to stop serving outside. Cannon Beach City Planner Mark Barnes sent a letter revoking the Way- farer Restaurant and Lounge’s outdoor dining approval on July 2, informing the restaurant that it “should not seat diners on the lower porch area.” ,n subseTuent letters, of¿ cials levied a per day ¿ ne on Submitted Photo Like many land-use questions, however, the issue is complex, and like most proposals for commercial uses near residential neighborhoods, emotional. Built as a single-family home in 1923, the Josie Peper Building has been used as a day care center, of¿ c- es and a law ¿ rm. The historic build- ing is named for a former student, who now lives in Alderbook, who had pressed the college for the day care center. See CLASH, Page 10A A view of the Wayfarer Restaurant and Lounge’s new patio from neighbor- ing property owner Nick Sears’ duplex. See RENTALS, Page 10A