OPINION
4A
THE DAILY ASTORIAN • TUESDAY, JULY 14, 2015
The GOP’s laziness dogma
Founded in 1873
STEPHEN A. FORRESTER, Editor & Publisher
LAURA SELLERS, Managing Editor
BETTY SMITH, Advertising Manager
CARL EARL, Systems Manager
JOHN D. BRUIJN, Production Manager
DEBRA BLOOM, Business Manager
HEATHER RAMSDELL, Circulation Manager
0edicare¶s decision
is a JaPe chanJer
E
QG RI OLIH FRQYHUVDWLRQV DUH GLI¿FXOW %XW HYHU\ IDPLO\
KDVWKHP
6RPHWLPHVWKH\RFFXUZKHQSHR
SOH DUH LQ WKHLU SULPH ² DV SDUW RI
DSODQQLQJSURFHVV6RPHWLPHVWKH\
RFFXULQPRUHKXUULHGFLUFXPVWDQFHV
²LQDKRVSLWDOHPHUJHQF\URRPRU
LQWHQVLYHFDUHXQLW
)RUSK\VLFLDQVDQGKRVSLWDOVWKHUH
LVHQRUPRXVEHQH¿WLQNQRZLQJZKDW
D SDWLHQW¶V GHVLUH LV )RU D SDWLHQW
WKHUHLVVHFXULW\LQNQRZLQJWKDWIDP
LO\DVZHOODVKHDOWKFDUHSURYLGHUV
NQRZWKHLUGHVLUHV
'XULQJ GHEDWH RI WKH$IIRUGDEOH
&DUH $FW 6DUDK 3DOLQ GHUDLOHG VH
ULRXV GLVFXVVLRQ RI SD\LQJ IRU HQG
RIOLIHGLVFXVVLRQVE\ODEHOLQJWKHP
³GHDWKSDQHOV´
/DVW ZHHN WKLQJV FKDQJHG GUD
PDWLFDOO\ZKHQ0HGLFDUHDQQRXQFHG
SODQV ³WR UHLPEXUVH GRFWRUV IRU
FRQYHUVDWLRQV ZLWK SDWLHQWV DERXW
ZKHWKHUDQGKRZWKH\ZRXOGZDQWWR
EHNHSWDOLYHLIWKH\EHFDPHWRRVLFN
WRVSHDNIRUWKHPVHOYHV´
3DP %HOOXFN RI The New York
TimesUHSRUWHGWKDW³/DVW6HSWHPEHU
DQDWLRQDOQRQSDUWLVDQSDQHORIPHGL
FDOOHJDODQGUHOLJLRXVOHDGHUVLVVXHG
DIDUUHDFKLQJUHSRUWVD\LQJWKDWWKH
FRXQWU\¶V V\VWHP IRU GHDOLQJ ZLWK
HQGRIOLIHFDUHZDVVHULRXVO\ÀDZHG
DQGVKRXOGEHRYHUKDXOHG´
:KLOH D EURDG UDQJH RI PHGLFDO
RUJDQL]DWLRQVDSSODXG0HGLFDUH¶VGH
FLVLRQ1DWLRQDO5LJKWWR/LIHRSSRVHV
LW IHDULQJ WKDW SHRSOH ZLOO EH SUHV
VXUHGLQWRQRWUHFHLYLQJWUHDWPHQW
,Q5LJKWWR/LIH¶VRSSRVLWLRQDQG
6DUDK 3DOLQ¶V ³GHDWK SDQHO´ VPHDU
WKHUHLVDQRYHUVLPSOL¿FDWLRQRIZKDW
Zhen the\ Srovided a vital
Pire Post hoZever is a
lifeline for tens of Pillions
Pore recent EooN Coming
Apart Zhich notes that
of $Pericans ,t drives
over the Sast feZ decades
Pericans ZorN lonJer hoXrs claiPs that Pan\ if not
ZorNinJclass Zhite faPi
Post
ZorNers
receivinJ
than their coXnterSarts in
lies have Eeen chanJinJ in
disaEilit\ Sa\Pents are
MXst aEoXt ever\ other Zealth\ PalinJerers ² “2ver half
PXch the saPe Za\ that
coXntr\ Ze are NnoZn aPonJ of the SeoSle on disaEilit\
$frican$Perican faPi
lies chanJed in the s
are
either
an[ioXs
or
their
those Zho stXd\ sXch thinJs as
and s Zith declininJ
EacN
hXrts´
sa\s
6en
the “novacation nation´
rates of ParriaJe and la
5and 3aXl
Paul
$ccordinJ to a stXd\ fXll
Eor force SarticiSation
,t all adds XS to a vision
Krugman
tiPe 86 ZorNers SXt in alPost of the Zorld in Zhich the
6oPe of Xs looN at
Sercent Pore hoXrs over the coXrse EiJJest SroEleP facinJ $Perica is these chanJes and see theP as con
of a \ear than their *erPan coXnter that Ze¶re too nice to felloZ citi]ens seTXences of an econoP\ that no
Sarts larJel\ EecaXse the\ had onl\ facinJ hardshiS $nd the aSSeal of lonJer offers Jood MoEs to ordinar\
this vision to conservatives is oE ZorNers This haSSened to $fri
half as Pan\ ZeeNs of Said leave
vioXs ,t Jives theP another reason can$Pericans ¿ rst as ElXecollar
1ot sXrSrisinJl\ ZorNlife Ealance to do Zhat the\ Zant to do an\Za\ MoEs disaSSeared froP inner cities
is a EiJ SroEleP for Pan\ SeoSle
naPel\ slash aid to the less fortXnate EXt has noZ EecoPe a PXch Zid
er ShenoPenon thanNs to soarinJ
%Xt -eE %Xsh ² Zho is still at Zhile cXttinJ ta[es on the rich
tePStinJ to MXstif\ his lXdicroXs
*iven hoZ attractive the riJht incoPe ineTXalit\ 0Xrra\ hoZ
claiP that he can doXEle oXr rate of ¿ nds the iPaJe of la]iness rXn Zild ever sees the chanJes as the con
econoPic JroZth ² sa\s that $Per \oX ZoXldn¶t e[Sect contrar\ ev seTXence of a P\sterioXs decline
icans “need to ZorN lonJer hoXrs and idence to PaNe PXch if an\ dent in traditional valXes enaEled E\
throXJh their SrodXctivit\ Jain Pore in the doJPa )ederal sSendinJ on JovernPent SroJraPs Zhich Pean
incoPe for their faPilies´
“incoPe secXrit\´ ² food staPSs that Pen no lonJer “need to ZorN
%Xsh¶s aides have tried to sSin XnePSlo\Pent Eene¿ ts and Srett\ to sXrvive´ $nd %Xsh SresXPaEl\
aZa\ his reParN claiPinJ that he PXch ever\thinJ else \oX PiJht call shares that vieZ
The Soint is that %Xsh¶s clXPs\
Zas onl\ referrinJ to ZorNers tr\inJ “Zelfare´ e[ceSt 0edicaid ² has
to ¿ nd fXlltiPe MoEs Zho rePain shoZn no XSZard trend as a share of call for lonJer ZorN hoXrs Zasn¶t a
stXcN in SarttiPe eP
*'3 it sXrJed dXrinJ Pere verEal stXPEle ,t Zas instead
Slo\Pent ,t¶s oEvi
the *reat 5ecession an indication that he stands ¿ rPl\
An
oXs froP the conte[t
and afterPath EXt on the riJht side of the Jreat divide
hoZever that this
TXicNl\ droSSed EacN over Zhat ZorNinJ $Perican faPi
Zasn¶t Zhat he Zas epidemic of to historical levels lies need
There¶s noZ an effective consen
talNinJ aEoXt The
3aXl¶s nXPEers are
laziness is all
real soXrce of his re
ZronJ and Pore sXs aPonJ 'ePocrats ² on disSla\
ParN Zas the “nation
their story Eroadl\ disaEilit\ in +illar\ &linton¶s 0onda\ sSeech
of taNers´ doJPa that
claiPs have risen no on the econoP\ ² that ZorNers need
has taNen over conser and they’re Pore than \oX ZoXld Pore helS in the forP of JXaranteed
vative circles in recent
e[Sect Jiven the aJ health insXrance hiJher PiniPXP
sticking
\ears ² the insistence
inJ of the SoSXlation ZaJes enhanced EarJaininJ SoZer
that a larJe nXPEer
%Xt no Patter an eS and Pore 5eSXElicans hoZever
with it.
of $Pericans Zhite
idePic of la]iness is Eelieve that $Perican ZorNers MXst
as Zell as ElacN are
their stor\ and the\¶re aren¶t tr\inJ hard enoXJh to iPSrove
their sitXation and that the Za\ to
choosinJ not to ZorN
sticNinJ Zith it
EecaXse the\ can live lives of leisXre
:here does -eE %Xsh ¿ t into chanJe that is to striS aZa\ the safe
thanNs to JovernPent SroJraPs
this stor\" :ell Eefore his “lonJer t\ net Zhile cXttinJ ta[es on Zealth\
<oX see this la]iness doJPa ev hoXrs´ Jaffe he had Srofessed hiP “MoE creators´
$nd Zhile -eE %Xsh Pa\ soPe
er\Zhere on the riJht ,t Zas the hid self a Jreat adPirer of the ZorN of
den EacNJroXnd to 0itt 5oPne\¶s &harles 0Xrra\ a conservative so tiPes soXnd liNe a Poderate he¶s
infaPoXs Sercent reParN ,t Xn cial anal\st Post faPoXs for his ver\ PXch in line Zith the Sart\ con
derla\ the fXrioXs attacNs on XneP EooN The Bell Curve Zhich claiPed sensXs ,f he PaNes it to the :hite
Slo\Pent Eene¿ ts at a tiPe of Pass that ElacNs are Jeneticall\ inferior +oXse the la]iness doJPa Zill rXle
XnePSlo\Pent and on food staPSs to Zhites :hat %Xsh seePs to ad SXElic Solic\
By PAUL KRUGMAN
New York Times News Service
A
SDWLHQWVDQGSK\VLFLDQVGLVFXVV,WLV
DOVRFXULRXVWRVHH5HSXEOLFDQEDVHG
SROLWLFLDQVDQGRUJDQL]DWLRQVRSSRV
LQJHQGRIOLIHSODQQLQJ
:KHQ 2UHJRQ YRWHUV FRQVLGHUHG
WKH 'HDWK :LWK 'LJQLW\ LQLWLDWLYH
ZH PDGH WKH SRLQW WKDW JLYLQJ SHR
SOHFRQWURORYHUWKHLU¿QDOGD\VZDV
D YHU\ 5HSXEOLFDQ LGHD VWHPPLQJ
IURPZKDWZDVRQFHDFDUGLQDO*23
WHQHWRISHUVRQDOIUHHGRPWKDWSHRSOH
VKRXOGEHIUHHWRFRQWUROWKHLUOLYHV
,QLWVREVHVVLRQZLWKWUHDWPHQWDW
WKHHQGRIOLIH5LJKWWR/LIHLVMXVWDV
GLFWDWRULDODVWKHIHGHUDOJRYHUQPHQW
RI5HSXEOLFDQV¶ZRUVWIHDUV
2UHJRQ¶V 'HDWK :LWK 'LJQLW\
VWDWXWH SURPSWHG PXFK PRUH DWWHQ
WLRQ WR SDOOLDWLYH FDUH RI WHUPLQDO
O\ LOO SDWLHQWV 3DOOLDWLYH FDUH LV QRW
DERXW PHGLFDO KHURLFV ,W LV DERXW
EULQJLQJFRPIRUWWRSDWLHQWVLQSDLQ
0HGLFDUH¶V DQQRXQFHPHQW ZLOO RSHQ
DQHZGRRU
,WLVLQFRUUHFWWRZULWHDERXWHQG
RIOLIH VLWXDWLRQV DV WKRXJK WKH\
ZHUH LGHQWLFDO .DW\ %XWOHU PDGH
WKDWSRLQW6XQGD\LQThe New York
Times³0DQ\RIXVZLOOIDFHTXDQ
GDULHVIDUWRRQXDQFHGWREHVROYHG
E\DLGLQG\LQJODZV´ZURWH%XWOHU
³0\SDUHQWVFHUWDLQO\GLG´
:H DUH RQ WKH EULQN RI PDMRU
By CHARLES M. BLOW
Mect to a discriPination that
the\ liNed +isSanic ZoP
FKDQJH %XWOHU REVHUYHG WKH VLJQL¿
New York Times News Service
en Zhite ZoPen and +is
is sNinshalloZ and Eone
FDQFHRI0HGLFDUH¶VIXQGLQJGHFLVLRQ
SanicZhite ZoPen aEoXt
deeS"
is that “a once hidden conversation
Zill never forJet the 2ctoEer
the saPe :hite ZoPen
+oZ does ElacNness
aEoXt PedicaO aXtonoP\ and the
featXre on National Geographic’s itself the oEsidian ethere
resSonded to Zhite Pen
and $sianZhite Pen the
al ElacNness of the SeoSle
doZnsides oI OiIesXSSort technoOoJies ZeEsite
Post folloZed E\ +isSan
There Zas a Sair of Sortraits of Zho SoSXlated P\ Zorld
is e[SOodinJ into the Zider cXOtXre´
icZhite
Pen and ElacN
olivesNinned
rXE\liSSed
Eo\s
one
as
a
child
¿
t
this
shiftinJ
7hat is a ver\ heaOth\ oXtcoPe
Zhite Pen´
Zith a Pane of cXrl\ ElacN hair the SaradiJP" ,s the laXJhaEle
)XrtherPore aPonJ all
other Zith the tendrils of Elond cXrls “Sostracial´ reall\ soPe
JroXSs
accordinJ to the
fallinJ into his face
stranJe Sro[\ for “Sost
Charles
stXd\¶s coaXthor “0en
The Sortraits rested aEove the ElacN´ as $nna +olPes
Blow
didn¶t Sla\ racial favorites
headline “The &hanJinJ )ace of Sosited recentl\ in The
as PXch as ZoPen did ([ceSt Zhen
$Perica :e¶ve EecoPe a coXntr\ New York Times Magazine"
Zhere race is no lonJer
%iracial SeoSle it coPes to ElacN ZoPen Zho Zere
so ElacN or Zhite´ ,t
can have their oZn resSonded to the least´
:hile $Perica¶s histor\ in
Zas aEoXt the e[Slosion
challenJes adaStinJ
We must
“5ivers and streaPs throXJhoXt of interracial ParriaJe
to a Zorld that ad sNincolor Solitics is lonJ and deeS
love our
the &olXPEia %asin to var\inJ de in $Perica and hoZ it is
heres to the illXsion this aversion to darNness ² SarticX
of racial SXrit\ in Sart larl\ darN fePininit\ ² and asSira
Jrees are noZ À oZinJ at levels nor liNel\ to iPSact Eoth oXr dark fl esh
EecaXse their ver\ e[ tion to liJhtness or even Zhiteness
Pall\ seen in late sXPPer µ(ver\thinJ conceSt of race and the
istence challenJes the isn¶t onl\ an $Perican ShenoPenon
as
an
Srett\ PXch soXth of the &anadian Sh\sical aSSearances of
$Pericans
notion and reveals its ,t¶s a JloEal sicNness inforPed E\
Eorder is looNinJ Srett\ Sathetic actX
histor\ and cXltXre and inÀ Xenced E\
$s the 3eZ 5esearch
ridicXloXsness
antidote
all\¶´ a senior federal h\droloJist said &enter Sointed oXt in
That PXst Ee ac colonialisP and the e[Sort of SoSX
$ll this is haSSeninJ in the conte[t a reSort “$EoXt to a world
NnoZledJed
%Xt lar cXltXre
of salPon retXrns that rePain ver\ Sercent of all neZ
,n The New York Times
Zhat PXst also Ee
stronJ at least on the &olXPEia $ drive ParriaJes in the 8nited that often
acNnoZledJed is that ran an article aEoXt &hinese ZoPen
racial SXrit\ itself ZearinJ sNi PasNs to the Eeach to
across the $storia %ridJe reveals scores 6tates in Zere Ee
disdains
Zas an instrXPent de NeeS froP JettinJ darNer
of ¿ shinJ Eoats SartaNinJ in the larJest tZeen sSoXses of a dif
The Guardian reSorted in
it.
ferent
race
or
ethnicit\
veloSed for the Sro
sXPPer &hinooN rXn since alonJ
froP one another Pore
tection of Zhiteness on “,ndia¶s oEsession Zith fair sNin´
Zith a forecast socNe\e These than doXEle the share in
froP “dilXtion´ and that incorSorates the Xse of ZhiteninJ
Eoats and salPon reSresent a larJe Sercent´
the fXrthest one coXld Pove froP cleansers that even inclXde “vaJinal
coPSonent of oXr econoP\
Zashes´ $s the SaSer SXt it “/ast
3eoSle often thinN of the EroZninJ Zhiteness Zas ElacNness
%Xt Ze shoXld Ee SreSared for de of $Perica as a factor of iPPiJration
%lacNness Zas deniJrated in di \ear ,ndians reSortedl\ consXPed
la\ed iPSacts on salPon froP cXrrent or racialethnic variances in Eirth rect SroSortion to the deJree that tons of sNinZhiteninJ SrodXcts
conditions Three \ears froP noZ rates EXt it PXst also Ee considered Zhiteness Zas Sreferred or valXed as sSendinJ Pore Pone\ on theP than
Ze Pa\ Ee looNinJ at ¿ shinJ seasons this Za\ as a fXnction of interracial sXSrePe $nd on toS of this issXe of on &oca&ola´
$nd the %%& reSorted in that
race as de¿ ned E\ color there is an
Pore liNe those of a decade or tZo coXSlinJ and racial identi¿ cations
This freedoP and À Xidit\ is on overla\ of Jender ,n SarticXlar hoZ “a recent stXd\ E\ the 8niversit\ of
aJo Zhen soPe sSoNe of the end of one level a EeaXtifXl siJn of societal do ZoPen Zith darNer sNin ¿ t this &aSe ToZn sXJJests that ZoPan in
coPPercial and recreational harvests SroJress toZard less racial riJidit\ SaradiJP in a cXltXre and Zorld that in 6oXth $frica Eleaches her sNin´
(ven this \ear state ¿ sheries PanaJ %Xt at the saPe tiPe , aP left Zith seeP to reÀ e[ivel\ conÀ ate liJht
,t seePs to Pe that Ze as a so
ers have discXssed EXt so far resisted a naJJinJ TXestion 'oes this EroZn ersNinned not onl\ Zith EeaXt\ EXt ciet\ ² nationall\ and JloEall\ ²
PXst ¿ nd soPe Seace Zith darN sNin
iPSosinJ ¿ shinJ restrictions in the af inJ reSresent an overcoPinJ on often Zith fePininit\ itself"
itself
to not iPSXte valXe and char
soPe
level
of
antiElacN
racisP
or
a
,
Zas
rePinded
of
this
this
Ponth
ternoons on soPe rivers Zhen ZarP
acter
onto
color if harPon\ is trXl\
socioevolXtionar\
sidesteSSinJ
of
it"
Zhen
The
Washington
Post
reSorted
inJ Zater EeJins to stress ¿ sh
to
Ee
had
$s
soPe
PaNe
choices
that
chal
on
a
stXd\
aEoXt
the
SoSXlarit\
of
PXl
These conditions are for noZ an
8ntil that is done it often feels
lenJe the riJid racial caste s\steP tiracial SeoSle aPonJ online daters
anoPal\ that are e[Sected to rXn their in this coXntr\ ² one strictl\ draZn
%Xt even in this oSenness there that Ze of darNer Eodies PXst re
coXrse EXt SerhaSs not Xntil after on and enforced at least in Sart to reJ Sersisted a SroZhiteantiElacN Eias sist the aEsorStion of oSSression
JoinJ (l 1ixo conditions rXn their Xlate the SaraPeters of freedoP and $s The Post Sointed oXt “+isSanic and love oXrselves defensivel\ as
coXrse in a \ear or so %Xt Zhat Ze enslavePent ² is ever\one elevated ZoPen Sreferred Pen Zho identi an eTXali]er :e PXst love oXr darN
are e[SeriencinJ noZ is a stronJ fore in the Srocess or are those on the ¿ ed as +isSanicZhite aEove all else À esh as an antidote to a Zorld that
taste of Zhat it Zill Ee liNe Pore or darNest end of the sSectrXP still sXE +isSanic Pen Zere less selective ² often disdains it
less ever\ \ear E\ PidcentXr\
:hat can Ze do" ,ncreasinJl\ Ze¶ll
need to ¿ nd Za\s to PitiJate tePSera
tXres in rivers and reservoirs Paintain
• State Rep. Brad Witt (D) &annon %each 25 $storia of¿ ce Shone
inJ shade and instreaP À oZs $s snoZ 6tate &aSitol &oXrt 6treet 1( 3hone :eE ZZZ
SacNs EecoPe a less reliaEle Pethod of + 6aleP 25 3hone leJstateorXs Eoone
• Port of Astoria ([ecXtive 'i
• State Sen. Betsy Johnson (D) rector 3ier 6Xite $storia
natXral Zater storaJe Ze Zill need to :eE ZZZleJstate
contePSlate tr\inJ to hold EacN Pore orXsZitt (Pail reSEradZitt# 6tate &aSitol &oXrt 6t 1( 25 3hone
6 6aleP 25 Tele (Pail adPin#SortofastoriacoP
Zinter rainfall for Xse in the sXPPer stateorXs
Shone
(Pail sen
•
State
Rep.
Deborah
Boone
• Clatsop County Board of
and aXtXPn $s the cliPate Ze NnoZ
(D) &oXrt 6t 1( + 6a Eets\ Mohnson#stateorXs :eE Commissioners co &oXnt\ 0an
coPes to an end onl\ fast adaStive ac leP 25 3hone ZZZEets\MohnsoncoP
'istrict aJer ([chanJe 6t 6Xite
tion stands PXch chance of SreservinJ (Pail reSdeEorah Eoone# 2f¿ ce 32 %o[ 5 6caSSoose 25 $storia 25 3hone
vestiJes of faPiliar life
stateorXs 'istrict of¿ ce 32 %o[ 3hone )a[
A bias more than skin deep
I
%e carefXl Zhat
\oX Zish for
O
Xr reJion¶s cXrioXsO\ ZarP and
dr\ sSrinJ and earO\ sXPPer
are SrovinJ to Ee a case stXd\ in “%e
careIXO Zhat \oX Zish Ior´ :arP
Zater and OoZ streaP À oZs are creat
inJ serioXs SroEOePs Ior saOPon
The latest edition of Columbia
Basin Bulletin is a litan\ of ZorrisoPe
neZs aEoXt iPSacted rivers and harP
fXl effects on ¿ sh 6o Zhile coastal res
idents of the 3aci¿ c 1orthZest reMoice
in e[SeriencinJ a JenXine sXPPer ²
XnliNe the e[tended dri]]l\ Pid\ear
Ponths that SlaJXe Xs soPe \ears ²
the neZs is not all Jood
+ere are soPe of the Bulletin’s
troXElinJ stories
“The Zater tePSeratXre at the
:illaPette )alls coXntinJ station hit
deJrees )ahrenheit -Xl\ and
continXe d to hover aroXnd de
Jrees last ZeeN $s a resXlt hXn
dreds of salPon and steelhead have
sXccXPEed to a Eacteria e[acerEated
E\ ZarPer than norPal Zater in the
:illaPette 5iver as Zell as in other
1orthZest rivers´
“6alPon and river PanaJers of
the reJional Technical 0anaJePent
TeaP ErieÀ \ lost their Eattle to NeeS
6naNe 5iver tePSeratXres in the /oZer
*ranite 'aP tailrace EeloZ deJrees
)ahrenheit last ZeeN as loZ Zater
hiJher river tePSeratXres froP XS
streaP and ZarPer than norPal Zeath
er continXes to SlaJXe the 1orthZest
“'ead and distressed socNe\e
salPon foXnd this Sast ZeeNend -Xl\
in the 'eschXtes 5iver aSSear
to have Eeen ¿ sh froP the &olXPEia
5iver EoXnd for other XSriver locations
that liNel\ sZaP into the 'eschXtes in
search of cooler Zater (arl\ Satholo
J\ resXlts sXJJest the socNe\e salPon
died froP colXPnaris a Eacterial in
fection t\Sicall\ associated Zith hiJh
Zater tePSeratXres andor loZ levels
of dissolved o[\Jen´
:here to Zrite