t wmi OREGON' CITY ENTERP.RISEf County- clackk ' ury FAIR, CA4Y, "EH SEPT. 24, 25, 2, 27, r0RTVIIVtNTH YIAA-No. 20, OREGON CITY, ORKQON, Fit 1 1 AY, MAY 16, 1913 ESTABLISHED ISM STRONG CM Id lilt AGAINST LA FRANCE Clackamai and Multnomah Authorities Piece Together Operations of Insurance Swindler and Hi Confederates in Securing Body Which They Set Afloat in isted in Moving Corpse to River, and Prison- er'i Wife, to b Arrested and Prosecuted. Wlill no decision bs m ret been rrtfhrd by Clackamas county author him and DUtrirl Attorney Waller Knit, ot Multnomah county ( J. ,Z , ths trial of J- C LaFr.nc. will t hulil. developments In the Investl nikio of the esse to'Hctt uat U M I '"'"d advisable to ar rttis snd try the Insurance, swindler to cUrkswss comity, lo connection with ths It l said to be extreme ly likely that others will also be lm niriJ lu the miliar. and wilt be ar rrttrd ind chawd wlih aiding end (MilM ijI'Viiim In bis successful slot (o eoHwt $l&.0uo In Insurance ud kxlco benefits for bis supposed dMtB. Nelihrr Hherlff E. T. Mass nor Coronor Wilson, who hss been In roaounkstlon and consultstlon with lU Multnomah county officials, will talk slwtit (ha developments of lbs csMttruif itut they believe sny an looncfdwnn ought to com from Dis trict Attorney Evans, of Cortland, ss it prlNinrr U st present In ths ifllhborluit county. In spit of tbelr cpuripir to tli Multnomah official In Hut miller, however, news of the pro treM of the Investigation has "leaked" from Portland sources, snd lbs swindle now seems to give promise of resultlni In a Kroiip of cbsrs.es smloit UKrsnre and confederates ho ikied blm In "planting ' tba body found In the river, snd subsequently kisollfled as that of 1-aFrance. tiMi Wlf to bs Prosecuted Mrs. UFrsnee, wbo collected the luannr which her husband carried, snd wbo Uler sent It to blm under sn twmed nime In Teiss, will In tit probability be prosecuted for her part Is ths rsae. It was thought by offl clals la churns of the Investigation at first that Immunity might have to be offers Mrs. laFrance so that she tssii U btlSI;.m ss witness for tho sun, but detectives and other Invest! (Mori who have worked on the esse kit obland so much Information that It It now believed thst a com pics cms ran be made out without th womin's asslslanc. In fact the officials have not even gone to the trouble of sscirtiilnlng whether or not iho would turn stste's evidence snlntt hr husband; though It Is imerallr bclltived that she could be persuided to do so. J-tFnim'o himself la said to hsve la the Investigators a great deal of assistance, willingly Ulktng shout molt f the details of the crime On certain Milnt, however, be hss refused absolutely to give any Infor M'lon. The prisoner, It Is ssld, baa pertinently refused to tell how be sm Into possession of the body In ths first pinre. and this reticence on ' part at first led to the suspicion that he might have commlMad a mur r as the itiltli.i st,.p n his swindle. Eld.nc has since been discovered, however, that hne caused the author Itlei to discard the munler theory, snd they am now prnctlcnlly certain r dm ,ly was obtained, and hoae It was. This detail, however. not almolutely aottlod. and until 1" Identity of Ixxly baa liwn defin itely aacertulned, Informntlon In re mrd to this lHint Is belnu withhold L no n,lve UHsrdedly talked snout oth,.r Incidents In the swindle. Body Not Williams' It has iweii practically established n"ui!h, tlmt the body Is not thiit of ''"yd Willlaiiia. who dlsupiiearcd, and "Ho poHHlbly i,my nttve jioj ionlB jo months before the body supposod o bs UKrunce'a was found. There reawiiianiy wol.roiindd evidence that w Hums did not die at the time of his myatorioua disappearance; In fact sonictlmn ii r, .... .)....,,. .4 Mm 'KHt In Oregon City be waa seen In ,.n '"inclsco ly a man who Is poel-u-io. hl" Identification. With the "III ami noHsihtity removed, tome !' I IhiIhr had by the aulliorltles ' ' nliiK the Identity of the body used ny UPRinco. thl1 ih"? ,"', n lp'rned that In taking pe tKuly used in the substitution to "h nnks f t!le Clackamas' river, , ",''p?, 'a,',"nce sent it adrift, the 7 hn,, ,hB aM ot one. and pos : ,,'y.nf ' men. The body was pro red B,.n,o distance from the river, ln i 'I"I""V,1 nt night from Its orU nai resting place to the stream. De- ,."""'n,H lo 1n,e I" the case Indl . .h:lt fter the corjise hnd been rll l'-irt of the way. LnFrance's """f'tcs rofus-d to further shnre thr.7,1, u ,n ,,lfl '"mmlBslon of the nleu ork' "nd lfift him to com .I ' 'h, fnrrylng of the body to the "T 'unaided. Thla grewaome feat tvilr' """PllKhed. It Is said, by gin. i t F('SPH' ,0 Ple' ""O draK" oo,u . r hT I""hs snd fnrounb the rl, J polnt 0I 'he shore of the hli !,lKht t' 't In a suit of i. mm1! r. ,et 11 dr1ft- u hod ,ook three ln to move the to ttv p,ace 11 WM procured No Compromlie Allowsd can hi UFn,nc nl his confedera'es LTT"tei ,or llIpWl trans- ZZ."' Corp"e ta but 008 of "on w i J hloh the prosecu lral m" Me CRM- That this II Clackl 'n of the y occurred In conty will be the basts m sh m v. n River Persons Who As of transferring the rase lo the local courts Is bluted by those now Inves- tlxnllng the crime. Tbls will be done, It U said, so that If a conviction Is not secured on the swndllng elisrne. tjirrsncs and the others may be held for trial upon another court. Other chargeg will also be contained In the Information, It Is said, so Uist there wilt be no opportunity for the ends of Justice lo be defested. These varloua charges are lo be placed agslnsl Iji France, It la hinted, so that tha prisoner cannot avoid punishment by arranging a set' la ment with the Insurance companies and fraternal organisations thst he swindled by paying back a part of the moneys he received. It la report ed that through bis .le mill at Co qullle the prisoner secured a consid erable quantity of aaseta, which he could convert Into cash were the op portunity offered him to avoid pun ishment by making a cash settlement I.S France la Weskenlng In a partial confession made tale Thursday night In the county Jnll at Portland, UaFranre said that the men who bad bellied him remove the body to the river, and who had ta'er balked at carrying out their part of the work, were a couple of medical stud ents. The nsmes he gsve the deputies are wlthehld from publication, mainly because some doubt Is still held as to 'he truthfulness of this confession. Officials who hsve been working on the esse are Inclined to believe that Iji France waa aided by men who lived near ths place where the body was obtained. E IS FOUND INTACT CORONER EXHUMES CASKET LAST RESORT IN PROBING LAFRANCE SWINDLE AS MULTNOMAH OFFICIALS GRATEFUL No Trscs of Tsmperlng Discovsrsd by County OfMcsr, snd Thor ough Inquiry Is Thus Closed To determine whether or not the body of the late Chsrles M. Abbott bad been removed from Ita grave and utilized by J. C. Urranoe In his plan to swindle Insurance companies out of ,14.000, Coroner Wilson Monday afternoon exhiimod tho caket It was found that the remains were Intact. Though not pluclng over much be lief In the theory advanced that Ab bott's body had been used by U Franco, Coroner Wilson considered It his duty to Investigate the possibility. Inquiry on hie part, though thorough In every way, fulled to couvlnce him positively that the body had not been inudu away with by the Insurance swludlor, and as long Ss there re mained a possibility that it had, Mr. Wilson felt that no stone Bhould be left unturned In his efforts to run down the case. Hence his determin ation to open tiie grave. This was dona Monday afternoon with tho greatest nmoiint of privacy possible. No trace of any tampering with the remnlns was found, and fol lowing the Investigation the grave was returned to its former, order. The action of the coroner closes one angle of the Investigation Iwlng mndo Into the UFrunce affair, and so simplifies the work of tne officers working on the caso. Inquiry will now be turned to olhor chan nels. Multnomah county offtclnla feal deeply Indebted to Coroner Wilson for his thorough Investigation of the Clnckamas county end of the matter, and while regretting thut It was necessary to disturb Abbott's grave feel suro that In no other way could the uncertainty be reduced to a cer tainty. ESTACADA SEEKS CA9H FOR IMPROVEMENT WORK The first entertnlnmrnt for the pur pose of raining funds to Improve the streets of fcstacada was given Sntur day evening at the Family Theater, under the asuspires of the Udles Civic Improvement club. The enter talnnent consisted of a concert In which talent from Vancouver. Port Innd snd Sprlngwater took part A 1 tho.iga the weather was unfavorable, a large and appreciative audience greeted the participate. The stage was prettily decorated with dogwoot blossoms snd plants. Mesdames Mor ton, Somers. Ilartlett and Sparks act ed as ushers and hit. Yonce sold tickets. The proceeds of the enter tainment amounted to nearly &. ABBOTTS GRAY JAPANESE PERIL ROUSES PASTORS CONGREGATIONAL CONFERENCE IS AGAINST ALIENS, BUT TAKES NO ACTION BIG GATHERING HELD AT HUBBARD Or. vsn Brskle, of Orsgon City, Talks on "Eugenics," Revlswing Sub ject Bsfore Ministers at Mtotlng Antipathy to Japanese Immigrants was nisnlfest at the conf runoe 01 the Kust Willamette association of Con gregatkmal churches, beld at Iluhard Wednesday, accordiirg to Oregon City pvople who Journeyed south to the meeting. Though the conference wss railed primarily to consider church mat ten topics of general Interest were taken up, snd among these wss the Japanese matter. Discussion of this was started by tbi presentation of a paper by one of the delegates, in which he set forth 'he desirability of welcoming Japanese to the coaat as useful forces In agricultural devuiopmmt A visit ing minister from California rose, fol lowing the paper, and gave an out line of the "Japanese situation' In that sate. Tula brought on general consideration of the matter, and It seemed to be the concensus ot opin ion that the Japanese were not want ed. One minister admitted that while "It Is unchristian to say so. the fact remains that we do not want the Jap anese.'' Among others who spoke wss Pr. J. A. van Urakle. of Oregon City, wbo discussed "Kugenlcs." Dr. vsn llrakle rivleVed the suhjoct general ly, saying In part: 'In old Japan tbey have a Bbumlte maxim which runs something like this: 'Ut men know by your deeds wbo were your ancestors.' This same Ides Is given more modern expression by Usrrie, the Scotch author, wbo re marks thst. If we know ourselves well, we know our parents also. The science of Kugenlcs Is simply a somewhat belated attempt to reduce to scientific rules the thought ot these two quotations. "Eugenics, which strictly -"derived means perfect generation, may be de fined as 'the science and art of be in well born.' or as Onlton the found er of the science said some ten years ago. 'Eugenics Is the study of agen cies that may Improve or Impair the racial qualities of future generations either mentally, physically or splrtu ally.' "Oliver Wendell Holmes tells us that the time to b.-gln the education of a child Is a hundred years bsfore it Is born, and If this Is true, as we are now beginning to reallxe, we may agree wltn tho president of the first International congress of eugenics hold in London only last year, that. At present the most urgent need is for more knowledge.' In line with tbls plea there has been founded the Carnegie station for experimental evolution at Cold Spring Harbor, which Is now busied collecting great masses of Interesting statistics. "Hut to us the question that eu genlci rulsea must come closer home, and at present there sre three funda mental and essentia! problems which we are all Interested in solving. "First we must secure wiser mat ing on the purt of men and women of Inlelllgvnce and education. The prime Importance of spiritual educa tion makes itself shown here. In ad dition, make the cnurch a meotlng plnw for young people. Acknowledge Natures great force In securing mat Ing propinquity, and let the church guide it by throwing the youth of both sexes Into good companionship. "Our second problem is the im mediate ono which sonw of the states are already meeting; limitation by public authority of the marriage of the defective, the liiBune and the crlmlnnl. The vast amount of harm done to the ruco as a whole by our 3 or 4 per cent of this off-color human i,v .hi.niii mrtiilnlv lend the church to stand firmly and agresBlvoly for progrens In this type ot legislation. "Lastly, remnlns the fantastic prob lem of breeding the suporman. This third problem, if It may even be call ed such, gives ample ground for the roving scientific imagination but In a practlcnl way, offers little of real merit. The emotlou of love abso lutely controlled, presents Just as sor ry -.a spectacle as tho passion we kuow of as utterly uncontrolled love, and the superman will for a long time remain the visionary product of that Impossible conception scientific love." TREASURE SEEKERS AWAIT DRY ROAD I W Rivers, who a short time ago announced that he had received knowledge by which he would be able to discover the whereabouts of the treasures of Captain Kldd snd other plrntos, states that arrangements are being made and that a company is be ing formed to go to Tillamook county, where the treasures are supposed to be hidden. Mr. Rivers says that n number of Oregon City and Portland pople have algnlfied their intention of Joining his compsny. and he does not expect any difficulty In financing tha proposition. As soon as the roads to the coast have become dry enough, a start will be made from this city by way of Wll- ENTERPRISE THANKED FOR BOOSTINO SHOW f The following letter has been - received by The Enterprise from the publicity department of the $ Oregon City Commercial club: "The I'ubllclty Department of the Oregon City Commercial club wishes to tbank you for the publicity and advertisement you have given the Clackamas Coun- 4 ty Htock Show and ltooster Day. The committee appreciates the 4 4 publicity given the celebration, and again thanking you, we beg 4 to remain, Very truly yours, O. C. COMMKHCIAL- CLUB. Uy O. E. KHKYTAO, Secretary. COUNTY DISPLAY PLANS UNDER WAY GRANT B. DIMICK ELECTED PRES IDENT OF FAIR BOARD AT MEETING FRIDAY THREE EXHIBITIONS TO BE HELD Clackamas Resources to bs Seen at Csnby, Salem and at Big Land Show In Portland Late In Present Year At a meeting of the Clackamas County Fair board beld Friday after noon, Judge Grant 0. Dimlck waa elected president for the ensuing term, and matter pertaining to the big annual display were taken under consideration. Owing to the lateness of the hour at which the meeting was called, much ot the detail work was left untouched, and will be taken up at a later date. There la a state appropriation of $1,708.40 for the Clackamas county fair, and aalde from this various con tributions are usually volun'.eered in the line of prises and awards. Wheth er or not an effort 'lll be made to obtain a larger working fund this year or not la still a matter ot doubt, owing to the fact that demands are going be made upon the county j count for funds to finance county ex hibits at the state fair at Salem and at the Portland land show. It la hoped that the commissioners will provide a sufficient amount so that the county can be well represent ed at these two state-wide exhibits. While the county fair Is already-pro-vided for. It Is also hoped that some further support can be obtained for It, as well, so that exhibits can be pu'. In better shape than usual, and some inovatlons Instituted. All these matters will be taken up by the fair board at later meetings. In connection with the matter of fair exhibits, 0. E. Frey'ag, manager of the publicity department of the Commercial club, Is seeking between $600 and $600 so that the displays ot fruit and produce now In the hands of his department can be renewed. These exhibits are a part of the coun ty's show each year, and during '.he balance of the time when the fair is not being hold, serve as examples of the resources of the county. They have proved ot valuable aid In ad vancing the county's claims for set tlers, and are thought to be well worth the cost or preparation and upkeep. Much of the fruit, vege tables and other products thus pre served are taken from the prlxe-wln-nlng displays at the county fair. Mr. Freytag received a letter Fri day from Frank Meredith, secretary ot the state fair board. In which the hope was expressed that Clackamas county would make a good exhibit at the big display at the capital. Mr. Meredith was one of the visitors to .he city during the ltooster DayB, and at that time was much surprised at the showing made by farmers and ranchers of the vlcluity, and urged all of them to enter similar displays at the county and state fairs. Clackamas county people have learned the value of advertising the resources of the section at all pos sible places and times, and It Is be lieved that as a result there will be no trouble in regard to the county fair or state displays. Neighboring counties, however, have not in the past been as keen In this line of en deavor, and because ot this It Is ex pected that Clackamas county this year will stand forth with greater prominence than ever when her re sources are placed on view. PLANS ACTIVITIES Invitations will be extended to a large party of Oakland, Cal.. boosters, who are coming north to attend the Rose Festival In Portland, to stop en route as tho gueets of the Oregon City Comtnercinl club. If the invita tion Is accepted the Oakland people will be taken on an automobile tour through the nearby agricultural dis trict of the county. Opportunity will also be afforded them to view the falls and the timber resources of this section. Members of the Commercial club are also taking Interest In the con ference to be held In the offlee of the state ImmiKratlon commissioner In Portland on Thursday, when discus sion will be held as to methods best suited to attract to this vicinity, and to the state at large, as many Oerman agriculturists as postlB- Germsn Immigrants have proven good farmers In many other communities, and It is believed that if a laree number of them can be brought to Oregon the states development will be material ly sldd. TRADE TO BOOM WITH HEW ROAD COMPLETION OF CLACKAMAS VALLEY LINE WILL BE IM PETUS TO BUSINE8S LUMBER ACTIVITY TO BE RESUMED 8srvlce From Beaver Creek to Put Many Dollar Into Circulation Locally (Much Progress Being Made That the Installation of service on the Clackamas Southern railroad, the latter part of this month or early In June, will result In a renewed and Increased prosperity In Oregon City Is the general beliet ot those who have been watching developments along the line and at It local term inal. Freight service will be com menced on the line as soon a track age to Heaver Creek Is completed, and initial shipments will consist largely of cord wood and timber. Boon after wards, It is expected, heavy ship ments of agricultural products will be made over the line, and refm loads of supplies will be taken In. While the cordwood traffic will mainly provide the road with re sources with which to meet Its oper sting and construction expense, bring ing to Its Oregon City terminals of a large quantity of timber is expected to result In full time operation at the local mill. This will give steady em ployment to a large number of men In the different departments of the mill, and will renew the market for ties and other mill products at Oregon City. Preparations are already under way for the handling ot tbls work at the mill, and machinery Is being over hauled, and some new apparatus is being Insulted. As soon as ship ments of timber come In on the new road, mill activity will commence, and material that cannot be handled at once will be stacked In the yards. Men will be needed to handle the stuff, and in this way the pay-roll will be considerably Increased, and this mon ey In turn will find Its way Into city trade channels. The traffic In agricultural products and aupplies on the road will make Oregon City a clearing bouse and point ot exchange tor many commodi ties to even a greater extent than It Is at present, and so again me nne will aid smterially In adding to the volume of business daily transacted here. With the extension of the line this business will Increase, and as practically all the profits of this busl n will find their way into Oregon City trade channels. It Is generally expected that the completion ot tue line will mean many thousands of dollars of annual Increase In local business. with ili nisnl hricht weather. completlon'of the line is being rapid ly advanced towards Beaver Creex, and track laying la going on - dally. Steel Is being hauled out over me line from Oregon gCity, and as the rails are nut down the instruction train is steadily advancing towards the first main station on tne roaa. Grading crews are completing their wnrir fur In advance of the track lay ing outfit, and a large crew of tamp ers is pounding ballast behind the end of the steel. Bridge and culvert work has been practically completed, so there Is nothing to delay the hur rying of the line into Beaver Creek. The light rain of Thursday did not Interfere seriously with progress that Is being made, and tracking and em bankment work so far completed is reported to be fast getting Into permanent shape. "BETTER FRUIT" Ranchers and farmers of the Clack amas valley gathered at Sunnyside Saturday evening to hear O. E. Frey tag, of the Oregon City Commercial club talk on "Better Fruit" Mr. Freytag gave his audience many valuable hints as tcthe manner In which high grade yields ot orchard and ebrry crops could be secured, and was given a most cordial recep tion. On Saturday, May 24. Mr. Freytag wlU trvel again to Sunnyside, and will visit several local orchards, dem onstrating to the ranchers the sev eral ways of using sprays and other Insecticides. One old orchards, which is badly pest-ridden, will be visited in the course of the afternoon and Mr. Freytag will show those in terested how it may be prevented from menacing nearby fruit. - Monday Mr. Freytag received a let ter from C. E. Arney. western Immi gration agent of the Northern Pacific saying that the big transcontinental road wanted to offer a prize for com petition at the Clackamas County fair, to be held at Canby. and asking what the award had better be offer ed for. Mr. Freytag has replied that a prlie for the best general farm products display of grown by one man would probably best serve to bring out the resources of the county- PLATS ARE FILED rMot. lint heen filed with the county recorder dedicating Metxier Hart's sddition to Molalia, tne town ita nf Onnortunltv. Britten's Subvdi vision snd Willamette Falls Acreage All the plats are large tracts that have been divided for residence prop erty. FOR AIDING SHOW O. E. Freytag. manager of the pub licity department of the Oregon City Commercial club, has issued the fol lowing note on behalf of the organ ization: "The Oregon City Commercial club desires to extend a vote of thanks to the merchants and business men of Oregon City for their support and interest In making a grand success of the Clackamas County Stock show; snd also to extend thanks to the livery bams for tbelr donation of hacks used In the parade. Thanks are also extended to the fraternal or ganizations that helped add to the unique character of the various page ants, and to all others who did their share In making the Booster Day cel ebration a happy affair for young and old." In addition to those whose names have been already published as con tributing to the success of the the annual celebration, the Commercial club also acknowledges receipts of material assistance from the follow ing: Gsmbrinus Brewing Co., Lar son k Co., The Morning Enterprise, Elk Horn Stable, C. Krohn, F. J. All dredge, E. L. Walters, F. D. Cox, Bell Theatre, Welnbard Brewing Co., Cal vert Studio, Salisbury Straight, P. N. Hart, J. W. MfcAnnlty John Leary. NEW BRIGK PLANT READY FOR WORK The organization of a company for the promotion and operation ot a new industry In this vicinity has been completed, and the concern known aa The Bolton Brick A Block company baa a plant at Bolton, on the west side, where t"o?y will fur nish wall cement building blocks and brick. Their products will be made by the Helm process, the latest Improve ment in that line. Shrinking and opening of the joints at the rim and rotting of woodwork are entirely eliminated. J. H. Graw, the manager, has al ready Installed a machine ot tiw lat est pattern with a pressing capacity of forty thousand pounds, which turns out five thousand bricks dally, worked by hand, and an amount many times greater when operated ty gasoline or electric power, one of which he will install In the near fu ture. Besides bricks and blocks the ma chine can also turn out door and win dow caps and sills, ornamental tiles tor mantels and ever-lasting posts for outside work. There are also at tachments for making special blocks and brick for building fronts and turn-corners. Four bricks, from three to eight weeks out of the machine, were sent to the engineering departmnt at the stat university for tests, and the re sults showed pressure tests of 10, 600, 17,809, 40.600 and 78,200 pounds respectively, according to the age of the brick, being pressures of 303, 609, 1160 and 2230 pounds per cubic inch. This shows that the only effect time has on them is to make them all the stronger. The products of the machine are ready for use In twenty days after leaving the machine. FISH OIL PLANT IS E A company of which II. M. Platch of this city is one of the principal stockholders has been organized and is at present building a fish-oil plant on the river front. The concern. known as the Columbia Fish-oil and Fertilizer company, is installing ma chinery in a large barge whlca can bo stationed at any point along tae river where material Is at hand. The nlant will be taken to the Columbia after tue machinery has been placed. and will be stationed near Corbett. All the waste matter from the fish such as heads, tins, and tails, will be used. Such fish as carp, chub and suckers will also be used. Mr. Platch states that the plant will not be com pleted as soon as was at first expect ed, owing to the fact that the floods In the Middle West delayed the ar rival of the machinery. It Is understood the plant will be the first one on the Columbia river to be engaged In the refining of fish oil. Mr. riateh, who recently arrived In this city from Minnesota and bought the Oregon City Machine shop, has opened a garage In the building re - cently vacated by the Pacific High way garage and adjoining nis ma chine shop. Mr. Platch was forced to wait two months before he could move his fam ily into the city, owing to the lack of suitable dwelling houses for rent. He stated that be was scarcely able to find a neat and modern dwelling in the town which was for rent SURVEYOR AWARDED $500 Full Judgment was given Saturday In the verdict of the circuit court Jury that heard the suit of Frank Bryant against the Canby Canal company before Judge Eakln. The sum of $500 was asked by the plaintiff for salary for work done upon land owned by the defendant and payment of which had been refused on the ground that Bryant was Incompetent Evidence was Introduced to show that Bryant had surveyed such lines and parcels of land as he had been lnstmcted to cover, and the Jury decided that his claim for salary was fully Justified. LIVE WIRES GET PROBE" T COMMITTEE OF MEMBERS WHO INVESTIGATED COURT'S ACTS GIVE SUMMARY COUNTY OFFICIALS ARE JUSTIFIED Complaint Carefully Reviewed and Found to be Biased or Bated Upon Faulty Interpreta tion of Evidence Charges against the county court of Clackamas county were clearly dis- proven Tuesday In a report made to the Live Wires by O. O. Eby and John W. Loder, who made a very plain demonstration that tbey had sought snd obtained information up on which they based their comprehen sive report Mr. Eby, who read the report, went to the bottom ot all the charges filed against the members of tne court, and treated them fairly. Following the presentation of the report, which was ordered filed for possible future reference, voluntary statements were made by Mr. Loder and Dr. Hugh S. Mount commending the contract for a timber cruise. Dr. Mount said upon more than one mil lion feet of standing timber had been added to the taxable property ot Clackamas county on his land alone in the Molalia district, and MY. Loder referred to the practical value of the cruise. M. J. Brown, chairman of the mass meeting committee, who asked for the appointment of the Live Wire committee and afterwards refused to work wth them, heard the report In silence and declined to comment up on the Invitation of L. Stlpp, wbo was in the chair. "I made my report to the mass meeting," said Brown. The report of the committee, who were thanked for their labors, by the Live Wires, follows: Oregon City, Oregon, May 13, 1913. To the Officers and Members of the Live Wires of the Commercial Club of Oregon City: Gentlemen: . We, your committee appointed to assist M. J. Brown, Robert Schuebel and S. L. Casto appointed at Mass Meeting, to investigate and make a report upon the charge of extrava gance and incompetency made against the County Court ot Clackamas Coun ty, Oregon, beg leave to submit the following report: A few daya after our appointment the first joint meeting ot the two com mittees waa held in the office of John W. Loder with aii members present at which meeting W. S. U'Rren, mem ber of the Live Wires committee ask ed to be excused from service on ac count of pressure ot business, which request was granted. At this meet ing a general plan of investigation was discussed and It waa finally unani mously agreed that a public Joint meeting of Xhe committee should be held at the Court House on Tuesday, April 29, 1913, at 10 o'clock, A. M., for the purpose ot receiving any in formation in the possession of any person relative to the charge made and also any other matters relative to the expenditure of County money and we asked that such charges be made In writing. A notice of this meeting signed by all of the committee was published in the County papers and pursuant to this notice a meeting was held at which a number of citizens attended some ot whom made statements in writing and others made verbal state ments, declining to put the Bame in writing. In the matter of the charge made by E. D. Olds that the County Court paid approximately $1000.00 above the market price for a Buffalo Pitts steam roller, will say that this charge was investigated by Robert Schuebel and M. J. Brown and that they re ported to us in person that their In vestigation had satisfied them beyond a doubt, that the charge was not true and that the price ot $3250.00 paid for such roller was the price at which the same is and has been selling and that the difference in the prices quot ed by Mr. Olds is explained by the fact that the rollers sold at Seattle and North Yakima were second hand rollers. This explanation is also con firmed by Judge Beatle and we take it for granted that this is the fact In tho matter of the charge made by E. D. Olds that the County Court let a contract for a bridge across Clear Creek at Fischers Mill for the buui of $2900.00 complete and then after wards spent approximately $800.00 in addition for concrete foundation ana other things connected with the bridge which Mr. Olds claims should have been done by the contractors at the contract price, we find the con tract for said bridge recorded in Vol. 24, page 400. of the Journals oi tne , ' Court and tnat tne contract shows that The Cotst linage- Company was to furnisa ail oi m steel, ship It and haul It to the site of the bridge and erect the bridge and lay the floor and put up the rail and paint the same, that the contract says nothing about furnishing cement or labor for the foundation or furn ishing any timber or plank golug in to this bridge. In the absence of any agreement on the part of Coast Bridge Company to put In the foundation and furnish timber and lumber, we can arrive at no other construction of the contract than that the same was to be furnished by the County which was done snd we therefore conclud-.t that this charge is not supported by In'the matter of charges made by E. D. 01dJ that the County Court ba paid exhorbitant prices for steei bridges snd material, will say that the only evidence we have on this point. Is the statement of Mr. Olds and al io figures submitted by him from oth er bridge companies, which flsures are given uion certain plans and speci . (Continued on page (-) REO