Oregon City enterprise., November 25, 1910, Page 6, Image 6

6
.OliEOON CITY ENTEIiPlilSK, FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 25, 11)10.
OFFICIAL COUNT ON CANDIDATES FOR STATE, DISTRICT AND COUNTY OFFICES AT GENERAL ELECTION HELD IN CLACKAMAS COUNTY NOVEMBER 0,
tjma iMOLt was KUOLlsntu IN Tnt LAST looUt Ur irit tnitnrmat, ru v.u iwntu .' .:. eriMUKa, and IT 18 THEREFORE REPUBLISHED IN CORRECTED FORM.)
fa
s
ft-
in
a,
IS
31
a
n
4
0
a 2
Candidates Voted Upon
Representative in Congress
12 H r. Elmore, Pro ..
13 W. C. Hawley, Rop...
14 C. V. Sherman, Soc.
15 R. 0, Smith, Dem
Governor $
1(1 Jay Bowerman, Rop.,.,.
17 A. E. Knton, Pro
IS V, S. Richards. Soc
19 Oswald West, Pom
Secretary of State
20 K. V. Benson, Rep
21 N. A. Pavls, Pro
22 Allen McDonald, Soc....
23 Turner Oliver, Pern
State treasurer
24 Ix-slle Butler. Tro
25 Thomas 11. Kay, Rep
26 Charles H. Otten, Soc...
Justice Supreme Court (4-year term)
27 Henry J. Ilean, Rep
28 C. J. Bright. Pro
23 Thos. A. McRride, Rep.-Dem
30 J. P. Myers, Soc
31 R. R. Ryan, Soc
32 Woodson T. Sinter, Deni.-N.P . . .
Justice Supreme Court (6-year term)
33 George H. Burnett, Rep
34 T. J. Jones, Soc
35 Will R. Kin?. Dem. N-P Jud
Frank A. Moore, Rep.-Pem
B. F. Ramp, Soc
9
75
14
BO
63
5
12
S9
77
7
16
51
15
109
24
9
4.1
12
53
11
58
1 21
20 j 53
6 I 12
16
76 ! 10
49
10
13
29
15
fifi
17
5
20
9
47
9
13
42
3
43
5
20
127
25
fit!
105
16
23
107
131
2(5
33
5S
S5
161
39
O" o" "o "T "!? "b PS
S a ? q 3 S
3 S V S
B .O T i
m ' J
9 l 5 20 16 1 11 22
77 21 4S !t 67 22 4S 110
16 S 9 19 8 2 7 15
34 6 37 1 48 60 10 54 103
49 19 35 S3 46 20 67 107
10 2 6 3 14 0 4 14
14 4 I 8 10 2 3 2 15
70 13 I 5S 94 100 IS 53 131
S9 21 5S I 102 82 2S 77 155
9 2 5 22 14 0 4 22
17 9 13 IS 16 3 6 19
25 5 2S 37 45 5 57 61
" T ""I
10 1 9 26- IS I 0 15 44
SS 24 71 119 I 104 I 30 SO 160
50 111 22 I 30 ! 26 I 5 21 34
36
37
10
US
15
63
100
7
t2
12 I 81
22 ! 126
1 I T
2 I 15
b J na
1 j 19
26 j 147
4 I 26
; i :
: i : :
4 j is
62 I 45 27
6 : 16
R0 I S 29
37 : 32 11
116 4
4 ! I T
76 i 62 60
70 ' 51 34
2! 12 71
' 7 1 7 18 1
S4 I 27 !l I
8 i 19 9
S7 ! 61 43
15 i 111 24
Attorney General
38 C. C, Brix, Soc
39 A. M. Crawford, Rep ...
Supt of Public Instruction
40 L. R. Alderman. Rep....
41 George A. Hinsdale, Soc.
42 J. B. Horner, Dem
43 Robert R. Steel, Pro
State Printer
44 George Bylander, Soc ,
45 Willis S. Dunlway, Rep ,
46 James E. Godfrey, Dem ,
Commissioner of Labor Statistics and
47 S. L. Curry, Soc
48 O. P. Hoff, Rep
49 D. L. Houston, Dem
Railroad Commissioner
50 Hugh McLain, Dem
51 Frank J. Miller, Rep
State Engineer
52 John Koob, Soc
53 John H. Lewis, Rep
Division Supt Water Division No. 1
54 James T. Chinnock, Rep
Judge of Circuit Court, 5th Jud. Dist
55 J. U. Campbell, Rep.-Dem
56 J. A. Eakin, Rep.-Dem
II
. S2 39 69 20 60 38 139 70 22 5S 109 SI 22 66 124 19 120 5S i 45 24
.15 12 10 4 I 22 7 1 S7 13 5 j 13 I 28 23 4 I 16 34 2 20 9 ; 20 11
. 97 61 S6 IS 63 j 2S 135 S2 16 I 62 9S 95 23 79 165 22 136 86 : 65 I 62
. 19 12 7 7 j 16 2 j 32 22 9 16 21 10 5 15 22 3 IS 12 I 5 16
.14 14 8 6 12 4 26 16 S I 14 22 IS 3 8 24 3 19 7 i S 13
39 3S 44 7 23 J17J49 34 5! 51 36 42 9 ! 40 77 8 M 43 I Sl29
. 90 44 70 19 59 SS 143 75 23 54 103 S6 22 73 126 22 121 56 j 4S 33
. 22 13 15 6 IS 5 34 22 8 20 2S 14 6 16 33 2 25 7 12 13
. 59 44 61 13 43 17 73 4S tO 40 I 711 66 1 11 49 120 12 S3 63! 42 39
. 78 t,S 72 IS I 45 29 113 66 14 1 52 7S ! 76 20 1 62 133 IS 110 70 i 57 4S
. JS 16 9 5 13 3 3S 20 S 15 23 1 144 13 28 j 2 ! 21 8. 7 13
. 2S 23 15 S IS 5 45 32 j 9 j 27 j 40 j 24 4 22 54 j sj 32 11 ! 15 2S
.i!21 69 1105 26 SO 41 1S1 94 1 26 ) 72 i 127 1 115 S0 7 182 I 25 i 1.51 95 ! 73 49
.j S7 4S 76 19 62 34 12S 75 21 54 103 j 79 26 74 131 21 j 120 69 SS 30
.15 13 j 9 7 11 S 31 23 10 16 IS 11 3 10 19 1 j 23 7 I 11 16
.! 43 24 I S3 6 13 4 61 26 4 2S S6 41 6 33 70 8 39 31 ' 29 27
I 7 11 j 11 4 22 3 26 14 3 5 17 j 15 . 1 7 25 0! 10 5 ' 17 5
J 13 14 6 6 16 5 31 20 6 14 24 10 ! 2 S 23 1 ! 21 9 9 19
.! 94 43 I SS 23 74 38 j 144 S3 25 59 119 91 j 28 SO 119 22 j 129 71 54 47
42 36 36 6 1 17 I S 61 31 I 6 31 40 43 6 35 70J 7 ! 49 .15 30 17
Inspector of Factory and Workshops i I I I I i "
. 21 17 10 7 1 IS 6 I 33 22 S IS j 21 I 10 5 16 30 2 26 7 I 13 21
! 92 47 92 22 6S 36 j 13S S4 21 60 ' 106 f 91 26 72 142 22 124 64 ! 53 36
35 25 ' 24 6 I 22 9 6S 2S 'Li'L'J'l '13 ' 5 ' J34 74 6 ' l!i 12 ' 29 ' 23
J 53 33 i 46 9 29 j 17 S6 43 10 40 I 5T 56 13 j 47 SS j II ' 64 41 1 36 j 43
i 90 59 I 79 21 73 33 142 81 27 I 58 j 112 S3 23 73 116 ' 17 ' 126 1 69
2S 20 101 9 j 20 ! 5 45 33 10 j 25 j 37 21 j " 23 51 j l 35 16 I 11 24 j
.';114 65 111 26 I S3 I 43 1S1 92 j 24 I 74 129 114 ( 27 S6 I 17S 26J 15J. 92 I 71 51
I 1S3 I 27 ! 154 92 i 70 59
ES
3 Sf
: ?
!.
5 4
45 49
2 9
41 57
24 19
6 I
0 7
70 100
2 16
35 48
11 8
71 S3
!L-'S.I
50 55
11 5
I 67 SI
I 6 20
4 24
37 50
I
49 50
S 22
63 60
50 63
6 JX
11 SI
74 SI
52 60
1 16
54 44 I
9 5 j
0 21
53 4S
40 56
3 21
52 49 I
30 66 I
It
60
16
106
42
6
)
117
73
l
19
99
19
109
40
67
16
127
IS
23
SS
69
21
101
115
23
16
SS
12
39
49
9
8
96
96
14
11
31
20
113
JO
75
19
96
II
7
67
S6
23
79
63
16
43 12
113 I US
2
45
t
32
33
7
0
45
60
3
3
27
11
69
5
61
9
60
6
3
23
49
4
32
47 I
5 !
S
66 I
76 9S 44
19 9 1
93 26 30
7 20 J7
21 13 2
SS 103 4S
S7 36 S3
f " :
22 13 3
68 13 I 60
l!12S
11102
Senator, 14th Senatorial Dist
57 LeGrande M. Baldwin, Pro...
5S Dan J. Malarkey, Rep.-Dem.. .
59 Claude S. Howard, Soc
Representative, 17th Rep. Dist.
60 W. H. Chatten, Rep.-Dem
61 M. V. Thomas, Soc
II 13
107
Senator
62 William Cantwell. Soc.
63 W. A. Dlmlck, R,ep
64 O. D. Eby
116
29
81 114 23 S7
CI 90 IS 66
9 I
67
16
1
19
S
43 1S7
35 151
24 6
63 36
16 j 8
OD
162
33
Representative
65 E. P. Carter, Rep
66 Linn E. Jones, Rep...
67 M. A. Magone, Rep. . .
68 R. W. Baker, Dem
O. D. Robbins, Dem..
Arthur Cliff, Soc
71 C. E. Hilton, Soc
72 John F. Stark, Soc. ..
69
70
84
118
94
44
36
18
17
18
12
CO
113
15
47
66
55
26
28
15
16
15
19
11 I
75
110
75
54
34
8
7
10
County Judge
73 R. B. Beatie, Dem..
74 J. F. Clark, Rep
82
! 7?
57
43
County Commissioner
75 N. Blair, Rep
76 Charles Thompson, Dem.
Sheriff
77 E. C. Hackett, Rep
78 Ernst P. Mass, Dem. ..
County Clerk
79 H. XV. Lang. Dem . .
80 W. L. SMlvey, Rep.
Recorder of Conveyances
81 Harry J. Harding, Dem.
82 Lloyd E. Williams, Rep.
County Treasurer
83 W. W. Mars, Dem.
84 J. A. Tufts, Rep. ..
106
48
48
101
56
37
19
20
21
10
8
6
7
68
73
61 I
35 I
21
16
13 I
1 "
36
38
33
12
14
4
4
6
191
33
12
74 I
102
84
29 I 93 141
73 I 104
11
33
132
76
135
154
130
71
71
32
32
31
SO
91
77
44
21
23
21
I 25
9
20
7
24
119
26
39
!j0S 31 100
119 33 101
S4 I 26 72
27 2 17
S6 29 S7
IS 5 1S
113 I 27 100
20 10 21
175
157
33
163
JU
174
55
29 I 163 103 79
19 I 131 83 61
CO
49
6S
62
SS
75
SO
79 101
63 81
104 I SO
i
119 40
71 I 105 I
I i
45 23 I
I1SI 121 j
.2.1 125.!
163 j 136 j
129 ! 92 I
11
44
13
JO
39
II
' 13
61
60
13
15
36
16
63
28
47
14
69
21
24
29
S3
Si'
45
24
33
1.6
49
19
SI
13
19
51
23
49
36
30
6
6
61
45
S
6
35
10
59
17
40
11
69
13
9
36
53
11
43
61
S
20
66
61
9
J l I
I
l
62
41 37
56 50
33 21
68 66
67 !
50 I
S9 j SO
62 I 65
v. . o
j n
I
? o
: ? I
6 4 S3
70 47 115
13 16 23
31 JS3 67
60 36 S3
6 1 19
9 8 13
61 81 111
77 67 122
3 3 St
13 14 2S
21 40 63
7 4 60
SS S4 153
17 31 SS
6S 61 123
II 9 43
77 74 155
15 18 27
14 16 21
38 36 73
70 63 131
14 24 33
37 43 105
70 6S 122
15 24 2S
16 33 50
95 S3 ISO j
76 55 121
10 15 28
21 49 61
6 2 10
11 5 32
SO 66 142
2-1 44 67
11 15 39
70 65 1S7
24 63 66
' " I
29 64 S9 j
79 6S 1 IS :
23 33 63
86 S3 ITS :
94 98 IS4 j :
95 107 198 I
72 79 I 157 i I
15
170
26
S9
135
13
15
161
174
17
So
SI
33
20l
43
156
2S
218
36
28
66
171
16
99
143
38
66 J
151
33
76
28
35
174
90
41
177
S3
17
IS I
19
117
160
It
19
163
ISO
16
27
111
39
219
31
IS I
34
261
28
2
90
202
37
124
1S9
28
64
254
207
19
S9
20
26
210
93
S3
2 00
98
31
110
20
74
SS
20
16
12S
115
28
SO
74
38
111
65
116
47
156
30
28
63
120
46
S4
115
42
65
151
107
S3
65
30
35
127
73
41
136
66
4
94
12
65
SS
3
ll
S5
111
6
13
63
15
131
27
110
13
119
17
13
63
108
19
72
96
17
29
136
106
12
49
. 7
14
116
44
17
17
60
S9 61
12? 111
I
69 49
2'JS
224
66
153
167
192
126
33
130
143
152
U'6
0
. 71
7
30
68
4
4
66
66
13
7
28
II
SS
13
63
10
76
8
8
34
70
10
46
60
10
13
100
73
8
25
7
6
79
29
12
79
21
36
74
It
97
96
100
59
2 ! 24
26 136
1 I 30
160
27
12
54
38
99
60
66
5S
79
56
40
27
17
14
12
104
109
,94
62
36
27
23
34
19 I 58
17 I 49
49 j
79 I
24
11 I 28
120
117
141
88
23 67 I 118 91
12 j 39 I- 64 6
S3
97
87
57
41
22
14
17
.
10 4
S3
60
103
135
38 53
55 76
39
54
26
100
37
59
8
27
12
21
Coroner
85 Thomas J. Fox, M. D., Rep.,
86 Tom J. Myets, Dem
County Surveyor
87 Lee J. Cauficld, Dem.
88 D. T. Meldrum, Rep..,
59
88
55 48
36 80
22
10
37
68
9
40
9
38
83
150
86
145
27
73
9 88
40 144
34 137
15 91
52
44
31
67
14 I 104
33 126
43
51 91 80
56 93 I 74
22
15
42 65 48
C3 113 94
6 41
28 I 65
48
122
49
90
J5
129
165
134
79
77
41
28
36
I
4 ! 14
92 i 65
17 ! 12
96
17
19
22 I 116
10 I 67
23 ! 142
22 ' HG
6 ! 5
65 1 53
43 36
!3 121
4 I 58
9 I 44
2 I 13
1 18
3 I 16
66
85
53 j
44 !
66 I
9 I
10
7 '
50
59
62
38
27
17
10
12
10
42
25
54
21
12
36
34
43
53
39
25
25
14
13
14
9
74
7
SI
7
125
122
142 I
90
26 114 82
6 I 89 33
21 I 122 I 52
9 j 68 58
28 97
9 I 25
10
36
84
10 28 60
27 I 91 I 183
157
93
74
1C5
8
28
43
CI
26 I
8 !
C2 54 I
104 j 87
110
53
80
59
10 53 71 I 63
24 I 50 I 100 75
41 92
137
79 I 140
41 89
40 I 121
73 I 120
24
7
in! ci
78 I 56
6
2G
5
26
7
24
23
8
85
110
70 J 36
122 ! 75
52
140
42
53
43
35
48
45
28
53
36
65
42
38
32
54 I
28
51
0
47
J7
49
70
64
37
40
4
28
87
33
10
63
J4
51
71
58
57
55
19
27
85
42
53
67
32
91
C2
J6
65
0
21
0
III
10
0
0
28
24
0
0
14
1
33
I
23
1
23
1
3
10
23
3
19
16
3
4
SO
23
1
14
1
1
25
13
0
23
15
14
24
3
33
33
33
21
5
21
9
Jll
in
4
N
40
2S
6
II
23
10
34
16
28
13
S3
II
12
20
30
15
2S
SO
14
14
45
3 4
11
24
7
IS
44
3
35
23
17
6
48
42
17
7
25
23
48
II
38
23
43
9
7
26
47
7
SS
45
102
S8
43
68
8
21
71
124
C4
47
54
33
42
39
50
46
47
17 ! 22 9 19 10 9 4 59 j 35 I 34 I 41 II 13 4
144 1110 58 61 ,73 S5 S8 135 196 I 230 U"J 135 87 21
19 I 16 5 -:i 9 13 25 J0 (I 48 67 23 10 3
151 125 67 69 79 91 93 ISO 220 265 160 14S 95 33
2S 15 5 34 11 16 26 46 52 45 69 24 13 2
16 13 0 14 8 10 13 27 26 IS 2S 16 8 0
76 116 39 51 47 69 63 111 163 2i0 131 97 71 20
111 29 43 43 40 33 JS 103 126 Ml SO 66 37 16
SI 89 49 61 62 CS 66 142 155 185 127 113 69 20
116112 68 70 64 73 78 155 224 269 171 114 73 26
63 117 47 50 54 67 56 132 181 198 133 123 65 20
108 47 30 39 36 25 63 79 119 146 S5 49 6(1 18
1H 20 34 37 34 34 61 73 79 I 96 64 49 32 20
26 15 6 21 10 13 20 3S 28 26 39 23 13 1
24 I 16 3 22 8 I 20 20 33 27 I 23 33 16 11 1
I -'5 I 16 3 28 12 H 16 37 J 3620 ;7 21 8 0
152 73 64 75 61 63 73 108 197 223 131 19 C9 35
-Jl'-J2 .SJ3J SS 48 J:" L- JJ8 I"3 "I s 3 I
74 107 43 50 43 83 56 141 ( 163 176 134 88 34 23
125 38 38 54 48 28 63 J5J 123 143 90 W Kfi 16
49 R9 47 42 35 67 51 140 131 160 107 92 61 13
151 61 36 64 Jj5 63 JM 94 182 184 130 90 52 25
112 25 37 42 42 40 45 74 105 112 94 17 ,ig 12
87 120 45 62 62 T.9 77 JM JJ0 223 115 131 73 25
106 23 32 36 31 25 49 77 97 109 73 61 37 12
91 128 47 I 69 69 78 J7 J55J 21 1 22j 157 116 78 25
120 I 29 36 50 43 32 48 77 111 118 107 61 40 18
77 I 1 15 45 J53 49 J4 69 148 J96 212 124 120 72 20
82 I 89 44 39 45 71 55 153 110 129 92 KG 75 22
118 I 55 35 68 44 32 64 90 192 210 1 12 89 37 16
145 I 43 34 64 48 40 63 82 164 160 120 82 46 21
-JUL' I-5 -4fi 48 44 C7 67 ,,S ir,rt 178 1,1 93 M IT
11 i
28 61
27 20
14 9
28 52
25 24
31 37
I 31 48
I
15 20
43 68
41 I 68
f
48 I 68
JI6 I 51
7 17
36 69
16 10
45 62
17 17
11 4
24 49
Jl 33
22 43
34 60
28 63
25 36
32 26
20 9
12 7
32 66
33 Jll
23 44
J17 38
28 49
36 JJ6
29 34
34 49
17 39
jt7 44
40 31
23 52
24 48
J0 JJ6
39 40
23 43
6
60
4
63
41
3
6
7I
65
5
II
61
4
87
II
67
8
63
8
II
40
6S
10
46
67
It
It
SI
63
a
61
8
7
63
46
6
69
61
57
60
I
14
S3
1
1
10
3
25
4
20
1
26
4
3
10
20
3
15
23
4
17
2
11
3
3
18
13
3
17
14
14
19
6
25
85 I 28
3
34
4
8
16
3
3
29
32
4
4
8
3
41
4
27
10
30
4
4
9
33
6
17
28
4
5
41
.13
4
7
4
4
34
13
4
39
6
13
35
6
40
99
68
4
93
10
98
13
6
43
73
66
71
61
67
54
11
10
80
38
16
104
42
79
54
62
44
JL3
63
62
45
71
62 i
64 I
26
18
3
27
3
30
3
3
17
15
41
33
6
36
5
39
T
3
30
15
33
43
28
10
21
4
3
3
30
18
33
:i I 13
13
14
18
16
14
19
16
JS
13
20
20
13
16
17
33
17
13
J
6
JO
J3
34
24
23
27
20
14
113
13
77
Nil
4
4
135
108
15
19
SO
21
118
30
116
26
133
23
17
58
116
24
SO
116
18
30
157
115
16
fill I
13 :
15 !
115 I
86 '
23 I
117 I
72 :
90
113
40
151
37 I 153 I
1;
is,', ;
125 jl
158 i
2 i!
163
31
10
121
87
91
156
127
126
68
16
15
22
138
83 I
93
114
60
177
87
129
102 i
115 I
82 I
132 I;
89
120
11C
98
29K3
736
2224
2813
615
I0II(
4035
2927
639
1466
46H
650
3236
1611
671
3105
1596
2054
3123
1038
3940
4107
4506
3.197
648
3699
KH6
4173
927
4.41
2923
2098
2968
3733
3064
2030
1673
681
618
1166
3310
2183
2890
2333
2699
2764
2008
3353
1813
3446
2043
3224
2716
2567
2519
2785
PORTER MUNSON ARRESTED.
Wrestler Taken to Astoria to Face
Forgery Charge.
Porter Munson, the wrestler who
met Carl Busch here earlier in the
fall, was arrested in Portland Thurs
day by detective Graves, charged with
forging several checks at Astoria.
Munson was fqrmerly wrestling in
structor of the Astoria Amateur Ath
letic Association, and at the time of
his arrest, was eniiaeed In the sam
capacity by the Catholic Young Man's
Club of Portland.
Following his wrestling match in
this city, Munson decamped suddenly,
leaving an unpaid board bill for he
and his partner at the Brunswick
House.
When taken to Astoria, the grappler
made good the amounts of the sev
eral small checks he forged, and was
given his liberty.
1 goa City, Ore., says: "I first used
1 Doan's Kidney Pills when living in
Kansas. My kidneys were badly dis
ordered and caused my back to be
' come weak and painful. Upon taking
Doan's Kidney Pills I steadily Im
proved and was soon free from the
complaint. I still take a box of Doan's
Kidney Pills occasionally, finding that
they act as a tonic to my kidneys."
For sale by all dealers. Price 50
cents. Foster-Milburn Co., Buffalo,
New York, sole agents for the Cnited
States.
Remember the name Doan's and
take no other.
HELVEY IS GUILTY IN SECOND DECREE
(Continued from page 1.)
a lantern, and consumed about five
minutes' time.
CASTOR I A
For Infants and Children.
The Kind You Have Always Bought
Bears the
Signature of
Tabernacle Sold.
The famous tabernacle where shafts
of denunciation were hurled at un
believers during the recent campaign
by Evangelist Taylor and his corps
of assistants, has been sold to John
Lowry for $200, and the purchaser is
now having the building torn down.
The lumber In the tabernacle cost
about S400.
HELPFUL WORDS.
From An Oregon City Citizen.
Is your back lame and painful?
Does It ache especially after exer
tion? Is there a soreness In the kidney
region?
These symptoms Indicate weak kid
neys; There Is danger In delay.
Weak kidneys fast get weaker.
Give your trouble prompt attention.
Doan's Kidney Pills act quickly.
They strengthen weak kidneys.
Read this Oregon City testimony.
A. G. Woodard, 412 Main St., Ore-
I Other witnesses were called to sub
1 stantlate the main evidence. Sheriff
Beatiie being called to substantiate
the statements of Dr. Mount in re
; gard to the experiments with a gun
; from the possible place of conceal-
rnent mentioned In the latter's testl
j mony. When cross examined, Beat
; tie admitted that had the struggle
j taken place on the Bkld road, there
would be no indications evident, and
also, that a person could have moved
from a place of concealment near the
spot without leaving any traces. He
told of arresting Helvey, and of the
fear the prisoner showed when pass
ing the Smith place also of the signs
he plainly showed on the road by
catching his breath at frequent in
tervals. Just before the session ended for
the day, the state rested its case,
j The defense Immediately opened Its
j case, and called the defendant, Curtis
I Helvey, to the stand. The young man
; showed no great signs of nervousness
I and spoke in a loud, clear manner. ,
I He told of the threats Smith had
j made against him to several other ;
' parties, and of how he on two occa- j
I sions walked away from, Smith In j
order to avoid trouble with a larger
man. The detalM of the trouble at
the Moshberger dance the Saturday
night before the killing were recount-1
ed, and Helvey swore that Smith,
without provocation, kicked him so
viciously that he suffered for days
afterwards.
The story he told of the shooting
was just the same as be has main
tained since that time; that he was
going along with his head down when
Smith jumped out with a club and
said "G d you, I'll got you."
1 Helvey maintains that he could not
I run on account of his Injury, and after
j trying to dodge, he shot.
The defendant was subjected to a
j grilling cross examination the follow
I Ing morning by District Attorney
Tongue, who got him slightly at sea
on several points of his story. When
asked to go through the actions ha
did when he shot Smith, Helvey was
plainly distressed. One and one-half
hours were used In cross examination.
D. J. Helvey, father of the defend
ant, testified to having somo trouble
with Smith on the Saturday night
prior to the shooting, at which time
he struck Smith with a beer bottle.
Ho also said that he was waiting at
the bars of the fence near the scene
of the shooting, and that Smith came
along, pushed him through the bars
and told him to keep off of the Smith
farm. He Bald Smith also intimated
that young Helvey was on the place,
and that he intended to fix hlrn. In
cross examining, Mr. Helvey testified
that he was some distance away when
he heard the shots, and thinking per
haps that his son had been killed, he
ran home.
A number of other witnesses were
called to testify as to threats that
Smith had made at various times
against Helvey's life, and also to the
facts concerning the trouble at the
dance at the Moshberger farm the
Saturday evening before the shooting.
All of the evidence for both sides
was In Friday evening, and deputy
district attorney, Livy Stlpp, deliv-,
ered his argument to the jury the !
same afternoon. He briefly reviewed 1
the case, dwelling to some extent on ;
the absence of powder burns on the I
clothing and body of Smith, and de-
dared the homicide to have been a
deliberate murder, Helvey hiding be- j
hind a log and shooting his victim '
through the back. The testimony of j
Helvey's father to the effect that he I
ran toward home when be heard the I
shots, thinking he had been killed,
was also severely criticized by Stlpp, '
who declared It to be the most, un-l
natural act a father could commit.
Hon. Gordon E. Hayes for the de
fense was the first to present his
argument to the Jury Saturday morn
ing, and In an eloquent address in he
half of his client, he touched upon the
failure to find a club at the scene of
the killing, such as Helvey says Smith
attacked him with, and intimated that
as Smith's father and brother were I
the first to arrive at the body, they,
perhaps knew of the whereabouts of near tho body to strengthen his do
the bludgeon. In attacking the state's fen Be. In concluding, he said his man
theory of the shooting, Hayes de-1 was either guilty or not guilty of pro
dared that no evidence had been in- meditated murder, and urged tho
traduced to show the helglith of Jury either to bring In a first degree
Smith, or that the model used In the , verdict or one of acquittal, as there
state's experiments was a man of the
same helglith and build. Tho fact
that Smith was shot In the back, ac
cording to Hayes, depends entirely
on the manner in which Smith swung
the club In his endeavor to hit Hel
vey. Tho attorney contended the
fact that witnesses for the state had
testified to Helvey's accurateness In
revolver shooting, and asked why It
would be necessary for a marksman,
lying In ambush, with a rest on a
log, to have shot three times In order
to hit a large man at a short dis
tance. Attorney Brownell In opening his
argument flayed conviction on cir
cumstantial evidence, and said that
In his opinion, the meanest man on
earth Is the one who will try to send
another man to the gallows on sus
picion alone. Ho declared that tho
state had failed to provo any malice
on the part of Helvey toward the dead
man. He said that Smith's father
spoiled the cane for the state by fall
ing to tell Helvey that young Smith
was also In the woods looking for the
colts, and hinted that the old man
wanted the two to meet. The physl- j
cal development of the two men was
nny Hayes, with a party of men. Jour
neyed to tho scone of tho shooting
for Iho purpose of examining tho bul
let hole witnesses for the state testi
fied was at the termination nf tho
nnglo on which they founded n por
tion of their theory of asHasHlnutlnn,
and not finding It, they rut down tlio
snag mid brought It to Oregon ('ty to
bo used us evidence.
was 110 grounds ior mo returning 01 1
either second degree or manslaughter
verdicts.
Tho final argument was made fur
the state by district attorney Tongue,
who has conducted the prosecution,
and ha bitterly assailed many of Hel
vey's witnesses, charging them with
giving conflicting evidence Helvey.
himself, said the official to his mind
plainly lied In telling Iho details of
the shooting, and on close question
ing, was picked nstinder. Ho at
tacked tho testimony of Helvey's
father, and declared him to be an un
natural parent, had he ran away as he
said ho did, when ho heard the shots
fired, knowing that Smith was looking
for his son.
The defendant was branded as a
cowardly liar, and tho Jury was asked
to choose between his unsubstantiat
ed testimony or that of many witness
es called by tho stato. Tonguo Justi
fied Smith's action In striking Helvey 1
the time of their trouble on tho way
to a basket social, and declared that
had he not dono so, he would have
been undeserving of tho nnmo of son.
All of the vital points "f 'ho testi
mony were brought up by tho district
Best
ssOLitS
FLOUR
$1.55 PER SACK AT ALL GROCERS.
D. C. LATOUHETTB President. K. J. MHYEIl, Cashlsr
THE FIRST NATIONAL BANK
of OREGON CITY , OREGON
CAPITAL, 150,000.00.
Transacts 0nrl Banking Business. Open from 9 A. M. to S P. M
compared, and the speaker sain mai , attorney who (n concluding, muted
Helvey was justified in carrying me tnftt he wnf) ony (on(? hH du(y )n
revolver. Attacking the assasslna-l n(f mmnm,.nt of rrn,B, BI1(
tlon theory. Iirownell asked why Hel-1 the jury t() ()o tnfir ,,uty ro.
vey talked to Smith's father Just be- L,ar(1(.Hg of any Bvmpathy they might
rore the shooting Instead of remain- hayo fop the ,,,.f,,n(,nnt.
Ing In hiding. The fact that no cluti I ,n Mf) inmnictlons to tho Jury .ludgo
was found, was In the eyes of the,Cnmpbo, ai)k, th,,m to ,,rng )n ono
speaker, a strong pol"t ln 'avor1or.0f four verdicts; first degree, second
the defendant, for had the shooting 1 df,Kro0i manslaughter or acquittal,
been premeditated, he could easily, an(J df,fne( ench doBrce,
have brought a club and placed It a motion for a new trial for Helvey
" was filed Monday by George C. Brown- j
I --------- Hi and Gordon E. Hayes, attorneys
, I Antnnan Tlin tn,,lltn la hlUml
n;r 1110 Utlll.linw. ,it. ' -
I upon the following reasons:
"Insufficiency of evidence to Justify
t the verdict ana mat It is against tno
j law."
I j "Newly discovered evidence, ma
t torlal to the defendant, which said
lr.fonrlnnt ennld not with reasonable
diligence have discovered and pro
duced at the trial, which evidence
and materiality thereof Is shown by
affidavits hereto attached and made
a part of this motion."
"Errors of law occurlng at the trial
and excepted to by the defendant at
the time."
In the line of new evldonce, attor-
Office Both Phonej 22
rtoaldonce Phono Main 2624
Pioneer Transfer Co.
Established 1865 Sucossor to C. N. Oroenman
FURNITURE, SAFES AND PIANOS MOVED BY EXPERIENCED
HELP. PROMPT AND RELIABLE SERVICE
SAND, GRAVEL AND BRICK
Rates Reasonable, Baggage Stored 3 Days FTee of Charge
Agency for the celebrated MT. HOOD BEER
I TAKE THE HINT
You can get the best that
money can buy If you buy of
our new stock of canned Table
Fruits. They have the delici
ous, ripe flavor.
at
HARRIS' GROCERY
Oregon City.
-f-t---it I t
Careful of Your Property
One of the secrets of our success
in the Baggage and Transfer Business
Safes, Pianos and Furniture Moving
Williams Bros. Transfer Co.
Phones, Office 1121, Residence 1833 525 Main Street
413
2691
439
1824
20N4
266
316
3025
3050
393
S03
1663
663
3718
Kill
2K 10
1165
SMI
610
6(8
1618