T!r.,4.vcrsHy Eugeno Ore OREGON CITY The Courier' ia the Official State paper for Oregon for the Farmers So ciety of Equity, and has the largest circulation from Portland to Salem. If yon want to buy, tell or trade, try small ad in The Courier the best ad vertizing medium in Clackamas County and yon will get the desired results. 31st YEAR ' OREGON CITY, ORE., THURSDAY, NOV. 20, 1913. No. 26 COURIER THE BILL ITER MATTER CHAIRMAN TOOZE REPORT CON TINUED FROM LAST WEEK WHAT IT WILL COST THE CITY Exhaustive Report that Should be Carefully Considered The Moody Land Company employ ed Mr. Scott at a much higher price to drill for water on their property immediately after drilling here. They were not successful in finding water, though, within two hundred feet of the Willamette bank and at consid erable depth. They are satisfied with their investment in finding out what conditions are, however. The following estimates of costs of conveying water to consumers are bas ed upon the maintaince of the present Reservoir at Mountain View, and the other presentReservoir by the Board of Water Commissioners and to be lo cated on the tract now onwed by the city and including the site of the Jones crusher. The pipe lines would be direct from wells to reservoirs and the present pumps removed and utiliz ed in the new plant. From Wells to Reservoir at Mountain View (1) 10,000 ft. 12 inch pipe at $1.00 $10,000.00 Hauling, Labor, Etc., at .25 2,500.00 $12,500.00 From Wells to Proposed Reservoir at Crusher (2) 5,800 ft. 12 inch pipe at $1.00 $5i,800.00 Hauling, Labor,, etc at .25 . 1450.00 $7,250.00 (3) Estimated- cost of 4-8 inch wells each producing 600,000 gals, or a total of 2,400,000 gals, per. day $1500.00 Estimated cost of Pit for Pumps 1,000.00 (4) Total cost wells and and pipe line to Mountain View Reservoir $14,500.00 (5) Total cost wells and pipe lino to Crusher site . . 9,250.00 (6) Adding cost of new pumps to (4) would cost... 17,500.00 (7) Adding cost of new pumps to (5) would cost . 11,250.00 The following estimate is based on conveying water from wells 'to present pumping station a plan not recom mended by the committee. From Wells to Station (8) 5,800 ft. 12 inch pipe " at $1.00 $5800.00 Hauling, Labor, etc at .25 . 1450.00 Pump and Pit . 1,000.00 Total 7 8,250.00 Using the present system, entering the mains at the nearest point prac ticable, would eliminate a large part of the cost of the proposed pipe lines to the 2 reservoirs. The total eost per year then for operation of these wells would be to the consumer, under this most feasible plan: Cost of water per mo. for year $0000 Int. on well construction $1500 at 5 per cent 75.00 Int. on well pit for pump 1,000 at 5 per cent 60.00 Depreciation 10 per cem on pumps & pit . .' 250.00 Cost of pipe line from wells to 5th st. main, to supply upper reservoir district estimated at (8000) dollars. Int. on $8,000 at 5 per cent . 400.00 Depreciation iron pipe 4 per cent 320.00 Superintendent 1500.00 Three Operators, ($100, $75, $75) $250 per mo 3,000.00 Incidentals 1,000.00 Cost per. year .$6595.00 Cost per month $549.58 BULL RUN SUPPLY FOR OREGON CTTY 4. Last winter definite effort was put iortn Dy tne council committee to ob tain Bull Run water from the citv of Portland, but at that time her city charter would allow only a two-year contract, thus making it necessary to renew the contract with each admin istration, or to obtain the consent of ner electorate tnru an election to i change in the charter, Under these conditions it was deem ed inadvisable to proceed with the matter farther. 1 Immedintelv nftor tha rnmrniaoinn ers took office under the new Port land cnarter July 1st, the committee renewed its efforts and from time to time urged the errant of water ririits to this city. Many conferences were held, and manv nrnhlpmo loo-ol arA civic came up for solution in connect ion inerewun. r many tne commission ers pranteri verhnllv and than J writing this concession, Oct. 22d. The city attorney's opinion coveriner the legal phases of the question most likelv to ing the right of the city to sell water The terms thereof are in general: (1) Oregon City shall construct a pipe line from reservoir No. 1, the point of contact urged by the commits tee at Mount Tabor to such point as Oregon City may select. (2) Water shall be furnished thru meter. (3) The amount of water is 1,500,000 per. day. (4) Rates (a) First 4,500 gal at 22 ft c per 1,000 gal. ' (b) Next 150,000 gal at 16 two-thirds c per 1,000 gal. , (c) Over 154,500 gal at 13 one-third per 1,000 gal. Payment therefor to be made monthly m advance, based upon the estimated flmmml. in hp ennsnm an1 adjusted toe orrespowd with the meter reading, uregon city snail also pay into the Water Board Sinking Fund (Continued on Page 2, Col. 6) Money to Loan. Paul C. Fischer, Lawyer, Room 2, Beaver Building, Oregon City, Oregon Refused to Restrain. Hillsboro went dry at this month's election, and then the wets asked Judge Campbell to issue an order re straining the county judge from de claring the city dry in 1914, because of some technical' points. The judge refused the injunction until he could hear both sides of the matter. Sealed Bids Wanted Sealed bids will be received by the directors of school district No. 34 of Clackamas County for furnishing transportation for pupils from the western end of the district to the school house and return for a period of 4 months. The number of pupils to be transported will not exceed 14. Bids must be in the hands of K. McLarty, R. F. D. 5, Oregon City, on or before Nov. 28, 1913 at 9:20 P. M. . Big Thanksgiving Ball Frost and Edwards are making ar rangements for a Thanksgiving Ball to be given at Busch s Hall on the night of Thanksgiving, that will be some dance. These gentlemen are re nowned for their high class dances and for orderly gatherings and the dancing public always look forward to their hops with much pleasure. Bowkers orchestra of Portland has been engaged for the occassion and good' music is assured. You will not want to miss this dance. Just Too Late. Charging that the election judges for the recent election were appointed by the recorder and not by the coun ty clerk, and that the city charter provides city elections must be held the first Monday in December, Law rence Ruconich, a city saloonman, started injunction proceedings last week. to prevent Judge Anderson from declaring the saloons of the city clos ed January 1. But just 45 minutes before the suit was filed Judge Anderson had issued an order declaring the saloons closed January 1st, 1914. STATE EDITORS TO MEET HERE Annual Gathering has Been Secured for Ths City Next Summer. Through the efforts of Editor E. E. Brodie, and the co-operation of the Live Wires, the next annual state meeting of the State Editorial Asso ciation will be held in1 Oregon City, the date to be fixed later. The convention lasts two days, and it is expected about one hundred edi tors of the state will attend. The Live Wires will take hold of the matter and a big time is being outlined, as they realize the big ad vertising value of having the many newspaper men of the state come here, have a good time, and depart feeling good. A fine program and series of en- trtainment will be worked out later TO GIVE HOME-TALENT PLAY Oregon City Women's Club AiUmpts Big Undertaking "Esmeralda" a four-act comedy that stood the test of a 850-niciit run in New York City, is the play nov be ing staged by the Women's Club of Oregon City, under t'ls management of a capable Portland director. 1 he proceeds are to be used for civic im provement. The play will be present ed in the course of the next four weeks and is expected to make a two night stand. The cast will be com posed of the best talent in Oregon City, chosen without respect to de nomination or creed. Miss Edith Aldridge is booked for the leading lady, while Mr. Harold Swafford will be the hero. Mr. Wag ner, the science teacher in the local Hieh school will also play a heavy character. Other members of the cast will be placed within the next few days. KIT J Clan. under the present management, and was proclaimed to be the biggest home-talent sensation ever presented. The full cast, as selected, will ap pear in next week's Courier. WHEN DOCTORS DISAGREE It Is Time for the People To Remove The Cause "Who shall decide when doctors disagree?" A local chemist analyzes the city water and says it has typhoid germs Next week another chemist from the state board of health, tests it, and says there is no typhoid. Why this thusness? Does colon bacilli take a run through the filters and mains of Ore gon City this week, and then hike out for some other Willamette Valley town? Or are these different tests like the testimony of "expert witnesses" any kind of evidence either side wants? One fellow thought the state board of health had always made a monkey of Oregon City and did it through force of habit. And another man said the first an alysis was timed to keep the pure wa ter project warm. For two years we have had these conflicting analyses. One week we are drinking nectar, the next week poison, until the people are becoming thoroughly disgusted. But be they all true or all false, certain it is that Oregon City has had enoueh bad advertising. We will never be able to make the people believe the water out of the Willamette river can be made safe to drink from now on if we run it through seventeen filters. The only thing to do now, for the present and future of Oregon City, is to unite on the best proposition for mountain water, and get it. Oregon City has been held back long enough and it has boosted Glad stone enough. Let's play our own game. LET US F I '5 AND GRANT CARVER RAILROAD QUICK FRANCHISE IT WILL BOOM THIS CITY We Have Lost One Road, let us Profit by Mistake So often you hear it said that no railroad should have been given a franchise in Oregon City only on Wa ter street. And vet when a new road wants to come in on this street a protest is at once made. Property on Main street, where the P. R. L. & P. Co., has a franchise, is worth six times what property is on Water street, which has no railroad, and which is about the deadest street in the city. The Oreeron Electric wanted a fran chise to come into this .city. Protests were started and the road was forced to another route, and along the route are towns springing up as fast as carpenters can build them. Oregon City lost a bonanza. We have another road asking for a franchise into the city, and we have the usual protests. The road is certainly going to be built. It is coming through some where. It may bo forced out so it will not do the business part of the city any good, but it would simply be another big bonehead play. Let the Carver road in. It isn't one of these future pros pects. The franchise asked for says work shall be commenced within three months and completed within eighteen months, ., We want more railroads don't we? They will boom this city, won't they? Then let them in and don't mane any more costly mistakes. The rights of property owners are details matters that must be ad justed between the individual and the railroad. There are means tnrougn which to adjust damages and these means are not for the city council to consider. . There is one street in the city for railroads. Railroads want - a fran chise over it. The taxpayers of the city are almost unanimous that the council grant them a franchise. , Yesterday the franchise was given the company in Portland. The grant was unanimous for Portland's five commissioners welcome a competing line and the people of Portland back them in their decision. The line win enter East Portland, thence over the Hawthorne Bridge and right into tne heart of the metropolis. The fran chise is not visionary. It calls for quick action and the cars must be in operation within eignteen montns. Milwaukie and Gladstone, too, have Granted the comnanv franchises to run through their streets, because the people there, too, realize what a great think a competing railroad is to the community. The line is a sure go now from Portland, clear through to Oregon City. Are we going to permit private interests to stand in the way of its construction at this end of the line l The Courier does not believe it. "Col." Moore From Now On. Frank Moore, Meade Post No. 2, G. A. R.. has been appointed aide on the staff of the department command er of the department of Oregon, with the rajik of "Colonel." . Willamette Adopts New Charter. Rv fhfl r-lnaA mninritv nf 13. Wil lamette adopted its new charter at Monday s special election. mere were 157 votes cast, 87 for and 70 against A new city hall and iire house go with the winning vote. A Rim a Twitr. n Result. It was the same old story, hunting, Louis Myres, aged 26, of Canby, was hunting with companions. They were walking single file through the woods, when a bird flew up. Chester Willis- was behind Myres. He raised his gun to shoot, it caught on a brush and was fired into Myres back. He died before tne doctor arrived. Teachers' Institute November 29 County Superintendent of Schools J. E. Calavan. has called an institute for teachers of the county to be held m the court house in this city .Satur day of next week, and has asked Frank Rigler of Portland to deliver an address on "Numbers, Step by Step," Miss Agnes Jones on "The Palmer Writing System," and State Superintendent Churchill and M. S, Palmer of the state normal to deliver addresses. Candidates for City Council. . From the petitions already filed and those in circulation, there will be at least two nominees for the city council m each ward and perhaps more. In the first ward the nominees are J. O. Staats and H. M. Templeton. In the second ward E. C. Hackett, former republican candidate for sher iff and Philip Soreghan, a P. R. L. & P. conductor, are rivals. In ward three O. W. Griffin and E, B. Andrews are candidates and an ef fort is being made to induce Council man Horton to consent to stand for re-election. For Sale at a Bargain. Until the 10th of December we are offering one new 8-room story and a half bungalow, with basement, iVi lots for $1200. One 4-room house, four years old 2 lots, $800, situated on Rosevelt street, Oregon City. Enquire of Dix Bros., owners, phone Beaver creek, PORTLAND LEAD Saturday Will Decide Saturday of this week is the day for the hearing of the arguments be fore Judge Campbell as to whether technicalities shall annul the vote of the people on the license matter in Oregon City. 1 Water Board Wins Out v Judge Campbell sustained the water board as against the ousting order of the city council last week, and he held that the newly appointed board cannot qualify. The judge held that disobedience to orders on the part of the board, when that disobed lerice was a difference in judgement, did not constitute cause for removal. Not the Hoped for Decision The decision of Judge Campbell in the Arthur Schneider case was not only justice, but it was unanimously popular in Oregon City. Mrs. Anna Schneider was losing her eyesight, and her husband was di vorced from her, leaving her with two little girls, and ne afterwards married again. Then he returned and wanted to take the girls away from the blind mother. .. ; Judge Campbell hot only refused to give the children to the father, but ordered him to pay $12 a month to ward their support at the home of their mother. County S. S. A. Officers The Clackamas County Sunday School Association closed a most in teresting meeting at Milwaukie Tues day night, and named the following officers for the coming year: President, Mrs. W. A. White, Ure gon City. First vice president, Prof. Burgees Ford of Estacada. Second vice president, A. J. Burdet- te, Canby. Secretary, Kev. Hi. A. Smith, Ore gon City. Elementary Department. Mrs. Carl Smith, Jennings Lodge. Sec. Department, E. B. Andrews. Oregon City. Adult Department, J. W. Loder, Oregon City, i Home Department, Mrs. J. R. Nash Milwaukie. j Teachers Training Department. F. J. Tooze, Oregon City. Temperance Department. S. Mac- donald, Oregon City. Missionary Dpartment, Mrs. W. H. Lucke, Canby.f NO "POLITICAL PLOT" Just a Proposition to Ask Candidates Where they Stand Why all the noise because the dry people proposed to ask the candidates for councilmen to line up and let the people know just where they would stand if elected ! Is this hatching a big political plot? "- - As a voter, don't you want to know where these candidates stand before you vote for or against them? Isn't It your right to know? If the candidate hasn't got kidney enough to come right out and tell you how he stands and what he stands for, haven't the people a right, and isn't it their duty, to smoke him out The people of this city voted out tne saloons November 4, and there isn't any doubt as to that expression. The voters said the town should be dry next year. But through fear the supreme court might annul it because John Doe did something in connection with the election that Richard Roe should have done; because a microscone found a technical wiggler in the pe tition; because there may not have been a pencil in some voting booth or someone spit on the sidewalk on el ection day through fear that jus tice may annul justice, the people who rendered the verdict thought to make it stick, despite the courts. So it was proposed to ask each can didate for city councilman to look at 'Statement No. 1," asking him to pledge himself that he will not vote to grant any licenses in Oregon City until the people vote for licenses. The candidate could sign this statement or not lust as he willed. The people, may elect him or not. because of his decision just as they win. There is nothing wrong with this proposition, but there is everything right with it. and it should not be con fined to city officials . We should smoke out all our candidates by the same method. No plot, no scheme, just making the fellows come out and line up just letting voters know what they are electing. We learn later that this matter was only talk, that it will not be carried out, that . the people believe honor should be as strong to hold them as a signed pledge. TAKE A BROAD VIEW Cut Out Grievances and Elect Coun cilmen on Principle J. O. Staats, candidate for council man in the first ward, did not wait for the people to smoke him out, but he flatly stated if elected he would not vote to grant any liquor licenses, after the people had voted dry. Mr. Staats is a candidate in the one ward of the city that gave a good ma' jority for license in the recent elec tion, and this ward will no doubt work hard to defeat him because of his stand for no license. He knew when he accepted the nomination the odds were big against him, but he had sand enough to take it But here is another thing voters of ward 1 should consider, Mr. Staats stands for some other things things that every taxpayer should be inter ested in. He is out for better government of Oregon City in a business way. He wants to put the city under a new system ; wants to have it handled un der business methods, and wants to save you taxpayers money and cut out the everlasting city scraps. He is the calibre of men needed on the council, and he should not be turned down because he has sand enough to be a dry candidate in a wet ward. JUST TO IKE REMEMBER AND WE KNOW YOU WILL THEN HELP THE TOTS 00R HOMELESS LITTLE WAIFS That an Apple, a Toy or a Cookie Make Happy Thanksgiving is just ahead of us, and then come the holiday seasons of happiness and enjoyment for we well-feds. . . 1 But down at St. Aenes baby home are fifty poor little fatherless and ., i ; .L-l 1L. L 1 : .1 motneriess wans mat uie nuuuuya won't mean much to unless you and I make them mean something. There is hardly a man or woman in Oregon City whose heart is not in the right place. The trouble is we are careless, we don't realize, and we whit for someone to jog our sympathetles and cause us to remember. The children at the baby home at. the babies of the unfortunate pool little kids thrown upon the woitfd who never knew a mother's caresk. The Sisters take in these little kid dies that we would not take, give them homes, medical care and nurs ing and all the comforts and enjoy ments that their limited means will permit. I But the little enjoyments are piti fully few food and clothing for these children keep the sisters worrying How many of us can give a piece of silver to these poor little waifs and never miss it? Will you? Then leave it, or send it to the Courier of fice, and when the quarters aggregate a nice little sum, it will be expended for a list of things that will give the little tots the happiest days of their lives. t And you ladies can't a few of you get together and give the babies! a treat? Can't you bake some things the little ones like and send them down? Can't you make them soipe clothes, send them some apples, can dies, toys? Do it, start.it, and ybu will be far happier, for "inasmuch as you do it unto the least of these ybu do it unto me." There white and colored children !ln this home, there Italians, protestnat and Catholic children. Wo discrimin ation is made. All are given the same care. They are pittiful little waifs, many of them frail and sickly. t The home depends entirely on the big hearted and sympathetic to pro vide for these children, and the Sis ters freely give their lives to the work. , I Will you give a quarter or more? Let's start it. Leave it at the Courier and we will make a purchase that will make little hearts glad. Don t think about it, do it and think about it afterwards. Skip a ci gar or two and the movies for a week, We want to send your name down to the home as a friend to the father- is. R. F. D. PATRONS NOTICE Department Wants You to Stamp Your Letters, No Loose Change in Boxes Probably the biggest nuisance the R. F. D. boys have to contend with, and smile while they do it, is picking the pennies from the mail boxes or sticking stamps on the letters. With cold fingers, under a rain, and with gloves on, it is certainly crowding good nature some to ask the boys to dig out the pennies and fix up your mail for you, and if you would just be a little more thought ful it would not be necessary. The fourth assistant postmaster general has issued orders to post masters to bring it to the attention of patrons, that letters must be stamp ed before being deposited in the boxes and for purchase of stamps the coin should be put in coin-holding receptacles and NUT enclosed in en velopes, wrapped in paper or left loose in boxes. The R. F. D. boys are dead willing to oblige you in any reasonable way and you want to meet them half way and not load it onto them. Observe the department's request, and things will run smoother all around. Money to Loan I have several sums of mone yto loan on Real Estate. Wm. Hammond Beaver Building, Oregon City. David Williams has purchased the house that has stood for many years on the property where will be erected the new postoffice building, and thu same is being removed to Mr. Will iam's property on Centre street be tween Eleventh and Iwelfth street, It is Mr. William's intention to have this renovated and will be made into a modern bungalow and will be oc cupied by he and his family. Mrs. Jennie Nelson has arrived in Oregon City, where .she is the guest of her daughter, Mrs. William Weis- mandel of Eleventh and Centre St, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Nelson ar rived in this city this week from Til lamook, and will probably remain at this place for the winter. They are for the present visiting the latter's parents, Mr. and Mrs. Maddox. . Wanted! WOMEN M uiuvui ail(1 Girls (over 18 years of age) To Operate SEWING Machines in garment factory Oregon City Woolen Mills A Challenge I herewith challenge Charles Bur chett to meet me in a 10-round box ing contest, any time and place ho may designate where boxing will be permitted, for any amount he may state. Marquise of Queensbury rules to govern. Louis Roll. Woodburn, Route 1. LLOYD WILLIAMS FOUND Lloyd Williams, former county re corder, who mysteriously disappear ed from this city something over a year and a half ago, has been locat ed in Australia, where he has been since his disappearance. A letter to his mother says he has been ill with pneumonia, asks forgiveness for leav ing as he did, and states he hopes to return home soon. - STREET CARS FOR THE HILL Would Benefit far More than Eleva tor and Would Sustain Itself Oregon City, Ore, Nov. 17. '13. Editor Courier: I noticed an article in the Courier a short time ago about changing the elevator to a railroad to Elyville. Now those are just my sentiments, although I am not a resident of the city, I am a property owner on the hill, and I am interested in the growth of the city. They talk about a greater Uregon City and the City beautiful. Why don't the Live Wires, the Commercial Club and the rest of the people get together and build a road to Elyville and to Mt. Pleasant? Let the City build and operate it. It would undoubtedly be a paying proposition for the City, and would also help to settle the hill part of the town, besides increasing the val ue of the property. This is one way of making it the greater Oregon City and the City beautiful. The people have got together and made this a dry town. Now why not get your heads together and have a streetcar line on the hill? Yours for the growth of the City, J. F. Dix. DON'T MISS THIS. It's Free, It's for Your Interests and and You Should Attend. At the fruit growers' meeting next Friday morning there will be a lec ture and a demonstration by an ex pert packer who won the State prize for the Walla Walla Commercial Club. a urill ovrtln ii tliA tQ.ilio li iron! eties of the same, the kinds used for different fruits, how to grade, and how to spray. He will have boxes and apples at the hall, and will give a thorough explanation and demonstra tion. . ' The fruit growers' organizations of Hood River, Payette Valley, Idaho, Spokane, and W.enatchee, and many other places in the Worth. West, have made their business a vety profit able one, through the use of expert methods. The producing class gets its fair share of work. The result shows up in better homes, more mon ey, automobiles, good roads and a higher standing of living. It is now possible for the growers of Clackamas County to get in the swim. The head organization will take our stuff this year, even though we are not organized at all. But our product must be graded and packed according to the rules of the big association, a copy of which rules will be given each person on ap-l plication. Also the company re-in-' spects the packing and the fruit. Every fruit and potato grower is urged to come,- Friday, November 21st, at 10 A. M., to Willamette Hall, Oregon City, Oregon, where and when the matter of sending our fruit and potatoes, the matter of an organiza tion locally to handle 'this business, and the matter of grading, packing and shipping, will be taken up. Do not fail to come, no matter what the weather may be, or how backward you may feel. This is a question of money to pay off that mortgage, and buy that auto mobile. Come and let us have your idea. The farmers' concern that we are dealing with puts more money into the bank at Spokane than Jim Hills railroad does. Bring others with you November 21st, 1913 at 10 A. M., to Willamette Hall, Oregon City, located just south of the post office. Social News. J. L. Swafford, one of the promi nent residents of this city, was given a pleasant surprise at his home Sat urday evening, when members of the M. E. church and a few of his friends called in a body in honor of his birth day anniversary. Mr. Swafford was completely surprised by the large throng of people. . A handsome gold signet ring was presented Mr. Swaff ord by Dr. Ford, on behalf of the church members, for Mr. Swafford's untiring efforts in church matters for many years. Mrs. Len Charman was the hos tess of the Wednesday Afternoon Bridge Club at her home Saturday af ternoon, and a few of her friends were also invited in to spend the af ternoon in cards. Mrs. Henry O'Mal- ley, Mrs. L. L. Pickens and Mrs. Livy Stipp were awarded the prizes. Luncheon was served during the af ternoon. The rooms were prettily decorated in chrysanthemums and ferns. In entertaining Mrs. Char man was assisted by her daughter, Miss June Charman. The cuests were: Mrs. H .L. Clark, Mrs .3. H. Walk, er, Mrs .H. P. Brightbill, Mrs. H. E. Hendry, Mrs.. H. S. Mount, Mrs. F. W. Greenman, Mrs. Theodore Os mund,, Mrs. E. A. Chapman, Mrs. W S. U'Ren, Mrs. Max Bollock of Port land, Mrs. H. S. Moody, Mrs. W. R. Log-us, Mrs. Charles D. Latourette, Mrs. William Money, Mrs. Will Mul vey, Mrs. L. L. Pickens, Mrs. Nieta Lawrence, Mrs. John Humphreys, Mrs. Livy Stipp, Mrs. E. P. Rands! Mrs. W. G. Huntley, Miss M. L. Holmes, Miss Fannie Porter and Miss Katie Porter. 1 COMMISSI E COMPARISONS WITH OUR PRES ENT METHODS CONCRETE EXAMPLES CITED Practical Proofs that Present System is Failure Editor Courier: Three weeks ago in these columns reasons were outlined why 1 consid ered Commission Government the best form of City Government. I made three points that should be bourne in mind: First, this government gives a man his personal time; second, it gives him a living, and third, it gives mm adequate power, and there is al ways the check of the recall and di rect responsibility. . Concretely, 1 . wish co show why these advantages will produce the best and quickest possible results. The best way to show this is to take a concrete case. Take the water sit uation; all cities have water troubles. Let us suppose that the commission ers are installed, clothed with proper power, and are not aided by the County and State officers of Board of Health. Oregon City is having an nually an epidemic of typhoid. How shall it be checked in the best and also quickest manner? I say the best and also the quickest manner because it is best to consider these manners as being entirely separated in as much as the quickest way may be the best way, but in municipal matters nine times out of ten it is not It is Wednesday night and the com missioners are meeting. The epidem ic is here. What shall be done? The hour is 8:30. Normally the City Coun cil would meet, talk over the matter, refer-it to, the committee on health, and police and at 11 o'clock adjourn. The commissioners are fully and per sonally responsible so they take up the situation, discuss it and without , shoving it into a committee's hands they set to work. Being allowed heir personal time by the city the work is never laid down. The next morning they do not have to worry about getting to the mill at 7 A. M., or hustling for their respec tive livings, but at 9 o'clock next morning they call in the doctors of the city and have a consultation. The work is discussed and a decision reached as to what shall be done to relieve the situation in the future years. At noon they adjourn, and the I commissioners all afternnon spend the time with their assistants and tne physicians in procurring samples of river and well water and examining dairies, alley-ways, cesspools, mud holes, conditions surrounding victims of the epidemic, and procurring samples of all kinds, especially milk. At 7:30 P. M. the commissioners meet again and report. Doctors are assigned to make special examinat ions, and a commissioner is assign ed to interview specialists in Port land. The next morning this commis sioner with all data and samples in terviews the specialist and in a day or two comes back with the answers and instructions as to what to do. The commissioner immediately orders the instructions carried out and the epidemic is stayed. They can stay it in seven days, and where forty cases might have been as a matter of fact only three or four have occurred. In other words while the committee of the city council is btting ready for business, this com mission is through work and have the situation in hand. This duel not dis parage the city councilmen at all. It is a difference cf system. Councilman A is a man of moder ate means and cannot let his business go to ruin, as he has to suoport him self and family; also it is wed known that a man who is so altruistic that he does others', business to the ne glect of his own, is never repaid. So to serve his city he may actually give up his future, or large prospectsi The difference in the system gives the commissioner his personal time; it gives him a salary; it clothes him with such power as he needs, as he. does not have to depend on red tape, yes, yards of it, and he will surely do his best because he can not shift the blame for his acts. In a few days a great tragedy could be averted by the commissioner, and in those few days the councilmens' system would permit the tragedy. No man would be to blame. The system alone muBt stand the guilt It was always so, it always will be so. The commission government was born to meet emergencies, and has always met them well. At Galveston, Texas, the City Council would have required four years to do what the commission in six months. The se cret was continuous sessions and act ivity if necessary, personal finances satisfactory at all times, adequate power and no strings tied to him thru procedure, custom or other red tape, and personal responsibility. Now the epidemic is met and the tragedy averted. The commissioners meet again to discuss the matter with a view of cleaning up the situation permanently. Not being driven to their work they do not have to decide on the fly. No one but a thorough ex pert can decide on the fly and de- i cide the question absolutely right, yet tne present city council system re quires this to be done, except in tha case of capitalists in the city council. . The commissioners meet every day; consider the question leisutely: call in experts and, bearing in mind that in the thousands of cities in our land a 11 water and fever problems have been fought out, they establish a Bureau of Investigation by corres pondence, and in the course of a few months, at a cost of $100.00, they (Continued on Page 8.) WOULD GOV