I, M. J. BROWN, BEING DULY SWORN, SAX THAT I AM EDITOR AND PART OWNER OF THE OREGON CITY COURIER, AND THAT THE AVERAGE WEEKLY CIRCULATION OF THAT PAPER FROM MAY 1,1912 TO MAY 1, 1913, HAS EXCEEDED 2000 COPIES, AND THAT THESE PAPERS HAVE BEEN PRINTED AND CIRCULATED FROM THE COURIER OFFICE M. J. BROWN. Subscribed and sworn to before me. .this 5th day of May, 1913.-Gilbert.L. Hedges, Notary Public. GITY The Farmers Society of Equity if spreading over this county and tht Courier is spreading with it. Its ad vertising columns are good as gold Clackamai County Fair September 24, 25, 26, 27 Canby, Oregon 30th YEAR. OREGON CITY, ORE., FRIDAY, MAY 3 0, 1913. No. 51 OEEGOM COUMI K in COUNTY IS RUN BY COURT TRANSACTIONS THAT SHOULD AWAKEN TAXPAYERS GIFTS TO CITY CORPORATIONS Perpetual Franchise of County Made a Present of The Enterprise has taken the pub lie into the county court's confidence and explains the why and the where fore of the deals that look so pecul iar to the people. Here is the timber cruising "explanation: In seeking a competent cruis er to discover how much standing timber there was in Clackamas county, so that the taxes could be levied with greater fairness to all, the members of the county court were forced to procure a gentleman from beyond the coun ty limits. There may have been good cruisers living within the county but they were not avail able at the time; and as compet ency was the chief factor to be taken into consideration, the county court employed an outside man. For this they have been been harshly taken to task in a certain quarter. "Forced to procure a gentleman from beyond the county limits." Well, that is rich. "Cruisers within the county were not available." It is to smile. , How did the court know whether they were available or not? How did anybody in the county know there was to be a cruise? Who ordered it? Who was consulted? Who knew there was to be a cruise or who knew one had been ordered until weeks after the contract had been signed and the matter tied up? There are any number of men in this county that would have been mighty glad to have bid on this con tract, and there is no doubt but the work could have been done and well done, for thousands of dollars less, for at least one-fourth of the pres ent price, and probably one-eigth. And no wonder "for this they have been harshly taken to task in certain quarters," for the taxpayers of this county are getting very tired of the load. And here's more "explanation" that makes everything so very clear and satisfactory to the "dear peepul:" In making alterations and re pairs upon . the county court house, the members of the county court let the work to residents of this county, after deciding not to accept the bids made by firms and persons who were not resi dents. For this they were harsh ly taken to task in a certain quar ters. Are not White Bros, residents of this county? Is not Clarence Sim mons? Are not La Salle & Son? Did not all these contractors put in bids for far less money than the court house cost? Did not Architect White of this city a man whose judgement, ability and honesty are never ques tioned say the estimates of him self and Architect J. Wilson of Port land on the court house building as called for on the adopted plans should not have exceeded $20,000 at the very most and that they thought $18,000 should complete the work? And the work cost $26,211.75. Do you wonder, as the Enterprise truly states "they were harshly tak en to task?" And here's one more "argument:" It would be interesting to know what would please the the Road Builder from Cuba, who pays less taxes and makes more noise than any other member of the disgruntled trio. Yes, it would be interesting to the Enterprise and county court to side track these matters of county expen ditures and go into personalities, but I have an idea the people are more interested in knowing where the $163 000 went to than whether the Cour ier editor is a Cuban. But to humor the "argument" I would state the Courier pays $80 per year taxes and its propritors are rsidents of Clack amas county. The Enterprise editor can't say as much. He and his family live in Port land. Here's another little matter (too insignificant to let the people know about) where a county's franchise was let months ago. A franchise was let to the Portland Gas & Coke Co. Go look it up on the county court records. It APPEARS that it is a simple little permit to lay pipes and mains from Portland out to Golf Park, but there are six little words there that give away Clackamas county to this company. The words are: AND TO POINTS AND PLACES BEYOND. This is a perpetual franchise, there are no penalties, no revoking clause. It is a gift, there is no compensation. It does not obligate the company to commence its work at any time. It is an egg in the nest of the future. Some day when the Willamette valley is a hive of industry this franchise will be worth big money, and other com panies who will get like franchises will pay big money. But this company got in early. The county court was kind to them. Beat ie, Mattoon and Blair gave them a free franchise to a county bigger than some states m the Union. Did the county court let the owners of Clackamas county know anything about this present? Were any of you taxpayers consulted? Did you know that rights to your county was given away forever to this company, then handed down to their heirs and assigns? Did you know there is no provision in the franchise that compels the com pany to do anything? They may start work now or wait 20 years. They may use this great franchise to gamble on, or they, may wait until it is val uable. What would the voters of Oregon City have done to the city council had it given such a franchise to the P.R L. & P. Co? They would have recall ed them in less than a week. And then we look up the franchise of some little concerns, and see WHAT a difference in. .the provisions A franchise was granted for a lit tle farmers' telephone line between Scotts Mills and Marquam, and the right has teeth in it. The ;coUnty re serves the right to remove the poles and wires at : any time for neglect. This isn't a PERPETUAL franchise. And the franchise to the Willam ette Valley Telephone Co. It provides that work must commence within 60 days, and the county court may can cel it at any time. ' Now these matters are for you vot ers to think over. They are for you to determine if it is justice to hold a club over a little telephone concern, tie it up with an enacting and revok ing clause and let . a big public ser vice corporation have a free gift of one of Oregon's greaties counties for all time to come without a cent's com pensation. Think it over. Blue Bells vs. White Socks Friday afternoon of this week (Me morial Day) the White Socks ball team of the Commercial Club will play the Blue Bells, the Pacific Tele phone Co's fast bunch of Portland. This should be an interesting game and draw a good crowd. - Some Day Some day the public will be able to get needed real estate without paying from five to ten . times its assessed valuation. Portland Journal. Years ago Mother Shipten prophes ied some day the world would come to an end. Must Take Out License By the provisions of an act passed at the last session of the legislature providing for the licensing and regu lation of the commission business, all commission firms must first obtain licenses from the state railroad com mission and give bonds for the pro tection of patrons. The law becomes operative June 3. The People, not the Law There seems to be quite a general opinion in this county that the re call fc. w provides for the payment of the expenses of a recall movement. This is entirely wrong. The law does no; provide for a cent of the expenses further than the election. This is also true of the initiative and referendum. If a recall is desired the "voters must themselves take up the entire matter and pay every cent of the ex penses of the signatures and the cam paign after the petitions have been filed. Spread around this expense is small, but when a half dozen men, who are working for the good of the many, have to go down in their pockets for the whole, it is a load, and one the taxpayers of this county should not put on them. TIME TO THINK Under the above head the Portland Journal puts some warm ones up to the men who are paying the freight of excessive expenditures in county, city and state. Following is the Jour nal s conclusion, and it should come home to roose to every taxpayer in Clackamas county: Is it not time for the citizens to wonder what is going on at city halls, state houses and nat ional capitals to cause this ap palling increase in what it costs us to be governed ? Is it not time for the business and profession al man, the banker, the manufac turer and the other units in the social body to begin to think as much about the election of public officials as they think about hir ign a man to mow their lawns or spade their gardens? NOTICE . The recall executive committee wants every solicitor of petitions to send them in promptly as soon as they are filled. Be sure they are sworn to, or bring them in and have them acknowledged here. June 10 the com mittee wants each solicitor to make a report of the number of signatures he has, whether petitions are fill ed or not GET WHEN CREDIT IS DUE DON'T CONDEMN . ALL FOR FAULTS OF FEW STAND BY LAWFUL DEALERS They Are Entitled to As Much Credit As Any Men in the City The Courier received a letter this week which has gone to the waste basket. It was a signed article, and this is an open paper, but this letter is so unfair and unjust to the city coun cil and to men who are doing a law ful business in this city, that we have no room or time fof it. Once more: When the voters of this county or city say they want licenses granted in this county or city, this paper is going to give the license holder who observes the laws just as much cred it as it does the man who sells us ice cream. A dealer has the right given him by law to sell cigarettes and tobacco, but that law tells him that he must not to sell it to kids. So long as he ob serves the law he is just where the law-observing saloon man is. When he violates it, he is where the saloon man is who violates hisJicense. . There are saloon men in Oregon City who stand as high as any and much higher than many as citizens and property owners. There are sa loon men here whose places are con ducted strictly according to law, who are never complained of and who are never before the courts or in any trouble men who are liberal, pub lic spirited model citizens. And this paper holds that when a man attacks them through the press, and attacks the city council for gving them li censes, that man is unjust and unfair. And this paper will not print the groundless charges. . . , The. liquor license penalties in Ore gon, and in Oregon City are drastic. Commencing with 'June 1, under the new law, they are far -more drastic. No other, business in the city or state carries with it the risks and the penalties. To Bsure, the man who goes into the business does it with full know ledge of these risks and he knows what he will get for violation of his contract. But, when a man has been in business here for years; when he has so 'conducted a saloon that there has never been an arrest or even complaint, why this record of itself should be a splendidcompliment. Let one half the provisions and restraint under which a saloon in this city is run be put onto the mills or business places in this city, then literally en force them and we'd have half our business men arrested in the next thirty days. And we say give full credit to the man who does credit to the business you voters have given to the man who you voters have given him a license to run. And we say cut off. the licenses and close the places of men who will not obey the provisions under which you have given them licenses. Since January 1 five licenses have been revoked in this city. The most of them have been second and third vi olations. Some of them have been technical, some of them open violat ions. The same excuse has been of fered in nearly every case, that the dealer was innocent of intentional law violation. Nevertheless the coun cil Sid just what it should have done when it revoked their licenses, for on the other hand are places which have no trouble to observe the laws; sa loon men who do not take any chanc es with boys, drunkards and over hours men who never give the city any trouble or keep the council con tinually busy with their troubles. The Courier wants to give this class of men full credit nad they are entitled to it They are not undesir able citizens. Considering the risks under which they do business they are a mighty sight more law abiding than the most of us. Legally they are just as much entitled to respect as the man who sells Bibles. If you are going to have saloons, then stand by the men who conduct the right kind' of saloons, and give the axe to them that don't. If you want saloons, have fewer of them and respectable places. If you have got to have the money, then raise the license on the law-observing places every time you revoke a law breaker. This means , will close thb Isour holes and put the business in the hands of men who will observe the regulations and run clean places. The city council when it grants a license does just what the voters di rected, and it is rank nonsense for a writer to charge they are moral cow ards because, having the power, do not revoke all licenses. They are weeding out violators. That is their duty, and it is equally their duty and every citizen's duty to stand by the saloon man who stands right And this paper will. ROSE FESTIVAL TO DC GREATEST EVER PORTLAND MOTOR BOAT CLUB COMING, 300 STRONG WITH FLEET AND BIG DISPLAY Human Rosebud Float, Big Parades, and Rose Show The Oregon City Rose Society is rounding out the finishing touches for the annual rose show of June 7. All committees are at work and the rose show will be one of the biggest days Oregon City has ever witnessed. The Portland Motor Boat Club will be here 275 to 300 strong with their full fleet of boats, Admirals and Captains in gaudy array. Races will take place on the river. The fastest motor boat in the world will show you just how fast she can go. Some good races will be pulled off. This feature is in charge of F. A. Olnistead, Chas. Spencer and B Roake committee. A dance will be given un der the management of Milton Price in the armory in the eyening for the public and the motor boat people. One of the grand features of the parade will be a float .representing human rose buds, by 24 little girls, drawn by the big black horses of Mof fatt & Parker. Mrs. Don E. Mel drum is in charge of this work with many co-workers. The prospect was never more prom ising for an excellent crop of roses for June 7th,' than now appears. The public is responding well with finan ces and the whole thing will be a gala day for Oregon City. Rules and regulations for the gov ernment and management of the Rose Show will be ready for the public not later than Friday May 30th. Given fair weather,' this festival will certainly be a splendid show this year, will far excell former years, and will draw hundreds of. people to the cyit Every worker: is on the move and every detail is being given close at tention that only women give, and the rose show will no doubt be a pleasing surprise and a splendid' entertain ment. Don't miss it. Pass up Fourth of July or anything else and come to Oregon City next Saturday July 7. COMMERCIAL CLUB OUTING Free Steamer Trips to Portland Rose Show Monday June 9. Members of the Commercial club and their families will enjoy a spec ial treat Monday, June 9, when the steamer Ruth and Lang will carry 200 people to see the marine pageant when Rex Oregonus will arrive and open the annual rose festival in Port land. The tickets will be free to the Com mercial Club members. The boats leave at 8 o'clock and return at 2. Lunch will be served on the boats. Why Not Aid Direct? Editor Courier: Last evening I received a sample copy of Gen. Coxey's "Highway" pub lished at Massillion, Ohio, and to say its a hummer is mild. I will surely be come a subscriber and all who wish to get their money's worth in good reading, call on me, and leave the price of subscription. I will do the rest. Among the good things I see is a resolution by the Ohio Socialists for a government loan to the flood suf ferers and in the same paper I see that Secretary McAdoo has ordered $400000 deposited in banks to be loan ed exclusively to sufferers. But why the intervention of banks? Why not direct at 2 or 3 per cent and save the profit made by the banks? But the fact remains that the resolution had some effect. Mr. McAdoo could not cut loose entirely from the graft or profit sys tem. Equity members will please take notice. I have failed as yet to see where the Live Wires, Commercial Clubs, Democrats, Republicans or Prohi's have passed any resolutions to take graft off of the poor sufferers. W. W. MYERS Miss Lenore Ginther, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Ernest Ginther, who has been teaching in the government schools in Juneau, Alaska, since August last has finished with her work and is home for the summer. Miss Ginther is a booster disciple for Alaska, and says the people of Ore gon but little appreciate what won derful and beautiful country Alaska really is. WANTED! Girls and Women To operate Sewing Machines in garment factory. Oregon City Woolen Mills ILL TRIS KIND OF GAME WIN DUT WILL FALSE STATEMENTS PASS FOR RECALL DEFENSE PLAYING THE SAME OLD GAME Of Abuse and Ridicule to Detract From the Real Issues. "The executive committee of the recall movement should extend a vote of thanks to the Enterprise for its effective work in aiding the recall. It is helping to beat Judge Beatie all it can." This was the suggestion of a citi zen to "the Courier Wednesday, after reading the utterly false statements regarding the meeting at Needy, where O. D. Olds addressed a meet ing of farmers on the recall. The meeting was held Wednesday night, May 23. The Enterprise's re port was just one week later, Wednes day May 28. You see it took some time for the doctors of The Exaggerator to hold a council and frame up the right kind of a diagnosis. Here are the statements of the En terprise or rather "it is alleged," "it was stated and- it is reported. ,We condense them. Olds became rattled at the ques tions fired at him; after the meeting men who had signed the recall petit ions fr wlsd frw lyu 1 frf dwlyl ylyl y audience asked him if he did not go back to Canby bridge six weeks af ter he had built it and tighten up bolts and charge county $70 and Olds refused to answer; Olds lost his head and broke into a torrent of words and said people were not trying him but the county court; that agitators for recall had promised to use their efforts to get political jobs for all who circulate recall petitions; that J. W. Smith, who was industriously cir culating recall petitions, was going to be the next road supervisor; "fol lowing the meeting the sentiment was strong against the recall and many wanted their names taken from the recall;" "If- you've once singed you can't get your names off," screamed Olds;" that ranehers of - Needy say "if Olds holds out a few more meet ings he .will kill the recall," etc., etc. Oak Grove, May 28. Courier: Replying to the Enterprise report of the Needy meeting May 23, would state that it is absolutely untrue in every detail concerning mje. There was never an interruption, never a question asked me during my Needy talk of one hour and forty minutes at Needy; never a person asked me to have their names taken from the re call petition; the Canby bridge was never mentioned; there was no con fusion and quiet attention was given during the entire talk; J. W. Smith's name was never mentioned in the meeting. It should not be necessary for me to make this denial the Enterprise's false report of the recent mass meet ing in Oregon City should brand that paper as untruthful and kill what lit tle influence it ever had. It seems to me the Enterprise might better be defending the charges that have been made against the County Court by the taxpayers of this county, and the charges I have made in public and in the newspap ers. Those are the things the tax payers want to know about. But as to proof of my denial of the Enter prize report, I simply ask the peop le to talk with the farmers at that meeting and find out whether Olds or the Enterprise is the liar. E. D. OLDS And here is another letter, another denial of the Enterprise's deliberate mistatements, and from a man who stands ace high in his community. It was written direct to the Enter prise: Macksburg, May 28 Editor Enterprise: I read in Thursday's Enterprise an article on the recall meeting at Needy in which my name is connected, that I wish to state is unqualifidely false in every particular so far as I am concerned or connected, and I ask you to publish this denial. 1 would state that I do not live in Needy precinct, have not been there in many months, had not singed or circulated a recall petition, and could not be a road supervisor in that pre cinct if appointed; would not take the appointment in my own district if it was handed to me in a frame, and I was not even present at the meeting. I would further ask that the En terprise confine itself to the truth so far as I am personally concerned here after, and not drag me in with a str ing of utterly false, and absurd state ments. The people are more intereseted in the recall charges than in false state ments about me. Let the Enterprise defend the charges made by Mr. Olds and others, and if it cannot then I would suggest that it would confine itself to a few truths, so that the statements might be given a litle credit . If the Enerprise knows anything about me that is deserving of criticism, then it may put me on the roaster. If I have ever done anything in political or business affairs to be a shamed of, I have forgotten it, and would like the public to do likewise. J. W. SMITH This report of the Enterprise fol lowing its utterly false statements and report of the recall meeting held in this city, will hurt rather than help the county court. The Courier editor knows that 80 percent of the taxpayers of the Max- berg and Needy country have signed the recall on Judge Beatie and Com missioner Blair. These SIGNATURES tell the story of the sentiment of this locality bet ter than the Enterprise untruthful reports. You can't get way from them Lies don't go against signatures. All this business is petty and shows the defense is hard pressed. As Mr. Olds says, WHY don't they defend the charges on which the recall is being revoked and why do they ignore the county court exposures that are being made in the Courier week after week. THESE are the things the taxpay ers want to know about Twhere the money goes and why it goes. Held for Grand Jury Justice Sievers has held W. S Smith under $500 bail, for the grand jury which will convene next week. The warrant was sworn out by Constable Jack Frost, and the charge was that of committing an unnatural crime. A 17-year-old boy was also arrested at the same time and was sent to the reform school by Judge Beatie. Smith is an employee of the O. C. T. Co's dock. ' Help to Put County at Head Manager O. E. Freytag is getting ready to prepare the fruit exhibit for the state fair this year, and he wants your help. He wants the finest, biggest and most perfect specimens of fruit and berries of all kinds. He wants them brought in on the stem and branches, and he will can them. Clackamas county got second prize last year and only needed four points of first prize. Let everyone help to get those four points this year. Bring in your choice specimens. Want Mattoon, Too There are many protests from vot ers in different parts of the county because Commissioner Mattoon is not included in the recall petition. They argue that if there Is mismanage ment of county funds and extrava gance on the part of the county court Mr. Mattoon should be included in the recall. This point has been many times explained, but if the voters want him also, there is a way. The state law provides that an of ficial must have held office six mon ths before he can be recalled or recall petitions circulated. Mr. Matoon' was re-elected at the last election and commenced his term January 1. He is not subject to a recall until July 1. If the taxpayers want Mr. Mat toon recalled bad enough to hold off the present petitions, and will organ ize and do quick work for the neces sary signatures after July 1, then it is up to them. The whole matter is up to the taxpayers the executive committee is only doing their bidding. But if this matter Is to be taken up, the committee wants to know it and know it will be vigorously attended to. Rose Show. June Seventh, . At Oregon City. Remember Graduation Day Look back to the day when you were stirred with the pleasure and enthusiasm of Graduation Day. Think of what it meant to you. Remember how you treasured and cherished Moth er's Graduation Gift Then think what it meuns or might mean to your son or daughter. The graduation gift should" be something distinctly "person al." It may be serviceable, if you like. But above everything else it should be of really last ing quality. We shall be glad to help you in the selection of a worthy and appropriate gift for Graduation Day. Burmeister & Andresen Oregon City Jewelers SusperuionlBrldge Comer LIKE WASTE OF FUNDS LEGISLATURE HAS ALREADY PROVIDED FOR WORK THEN WHY EXPEND $50,000 H. W. Hagemann Gives Taxpayers Something to Think About Editor Courier: In the Enterprise of May 23 Mr. J. E. Jack, our county Assessor, takes great pleasure to publish a letter from the Assessor of Tillamook Coun ty wherein it says that the cruising of timber in that county is a success. In the same issue Mr. G. J. Taylor, who edits a paper at Molalla, has found that there is one section of timber owned by Mr. Collins that would pay more taxes under the new cruise' than the whole Molalla coun try combined and that this cruise is the correct thing. Now gentlemen, in the way you bring this matter before the people, you are making a fine showing but there are always two sides to a ques tion and I am very sorry that I have to differ with you. Let us get at the facts: The timber cruise costs the county to Mr. Nease $51.20 per section; Mr. Boyles for cruising this same section again $5.00 per diem and expenses of $2.00, $7.00 making the total cost per section $58.20, or in round figures 9c per acre. Taking for granted that Mr. Boyles will cruise a section per day. (That this is all left to his dis cretion.) I have a statement at hand that was used durjng the campaign of 19 12, evidently coming from our As sessor's office, wherein it shows that unimproved lands (timbered I sup pose) were owned in Clackamas coun ty as folllows: Collins T. D. & S. E. 29249 acres. , Molalla Land Co. 4265 acres. y Ore. and Cal, Land , grant 8? i.-. acres, ' " .... Ore. Iron and Steel Co. 5119 acres. Weyerhause Land Co. 19852 acres. Now we all know or at least should know, that our Federal Government has been for years after the Oregon and California Land Grant of 89,383 acres and have it revert to the pub lic domain. Lately the Hon. Judge Wolverton has decided in the Govern ment's favor. The cruise of this tract wlil cost Clackamas county about $8,044.47, which sum will be a total loss, then . the land will be exempt from all tax ation. Now are you going to get this mon ey back Mr. Jack and Mr. Taylor? From the farmers I suppose. In regard to the 58486 acres own ed by other parties I will say that our worthy state tax commission in tends to take a hand, at least it so stated in an article in fi Porland pa pers recently, that there had been enough money appropriated by our last legislature, so all the former transfers during the past year could be checked and compared in order to get at the real (selling) value of all farms; and then make the apportion ment of taxes accordingly. The reas on given for this was that corporat ions had complained that they were compelled to pay more than their just share of the taxes. How does this strike you, Mr. Far mer? Here your legislature provides the money to investigate yourself. Mr. O. D. Eby, and Mr. Loder in their report to the Live Wires in an 0. C. paper, recently stated that I had referred to a certain bridge across Matlock Creek, and in reply I will say that I never knew that Mr. Chas. F. Clark had been favored Kvith the chance on the public teat, in fact I did not know that the taxpayers' money had been used to satisfy per sonal friends. My reference was to a similar bridge in Section 17 Tnp 2 S. R. 3 E. W. M. near Damascus and about 4 miles from the Matlock Creek bridge. I stated to Mr. Eby the location distinctly. As far as the letter of Chas. F, Clark is concerned, I may state that the people of Clackamas County have heard some bragging and seen some kicking over the traces before this. The facts are they cannot be denied, that a contract was let by our coun ty court to a certain gentleman with out asking for bids to build a bridge across Matlock Creek for the sum of $800 and that the specifications were to be furnished afterwards by some body. Really a fine way to do busi ness. Therefore I have refrained to do anything to get Mr. Matoon, one of our commissioners, mixed up in our . recall and because I always believed and do so today, that Mr. Matoon in tended to do right, and that he was led into some of the shady transact ions of the county court by his assoc iates. But last Saturday at the Har ding Grange picnic I was credibly in formed that Mr. Mattoon intends to resign as soon as Beatie and Blair are recalled. Would it not be a good scheme to save him the trouble and include him also too? What do you think of it, Farmers ? Let ut hear from you. N. W. HAGGSMANN L 00 G