Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Siletz news II. ([Place of publication not identified] : $b [publisher not identified]) 1989-???? | View Entire Issue (Aug. 4, 1990)
Siletz News I I page 4 August 4,1990 Reader's Questions______ Melissa Potter, tribal m em ber o f Prineville, asked the following question. “W hat do you think will happen if Tribal Council members don’t like the final decision in the case you filed in Tribal Court?” Tribal Council has indeed shown unhappiness with previous Tribal Court decisions, most recently when Tribal Council Chair Delores Pigsley objected to an opinion written by former C hief Judge M artin Heimer (a copy o f Pigsley’s memo appears below]. Pigsley, reportedly acting without prior Tribal Council approval, presented H enner with the follow ing three choices: 1) change the C ourt’s decision; 2) resign the position of Chief Judge; 3) or be subject to “further action.” Tribal law states that the C hief Judge can only be suspended or dismissed “for cause by the Tribal Council upon due notice and an opportunity for a hearing open to tribal members.” Henner, citing a reluctance to “create a contro versy,” resigned his position June 10,1989. Given that history, Potter’s question is could this happen again? In my opinion, there is a reduced chance o f it happening again. Current C hief Judge John Roe is both a tribal mem ber and a longtime Tribal Court Judge. Both facts make it likely that Roe w ould choose to force Council to take that prom ised “further action,” i.e. make Council schedule an expulsion “hearing open to tribal members.” Even though Tribal Court lacks the support of many tribal members, it would be political suicide for an elected leader to publicly “try” a C hief Judge on the charge o f making an “unsatisfactory” decision. F or the last word, I asked Lillie Butler, Tribal Council member from Siletz, to help me answer Melissa’s question. Butler put the question to her colleagues at the July 21,1990 Tribal Council meeting. “W hat will you do if you don’t agree with the Tribal C ourt’s decision in the case o f Andrew Viles vs Tribal Council and Phil Rilatos?” This is how individual Council members an swered the question: Lillie Butler: “I was the last one who went to Tribal Court, when the judge was removed. I don’t think that’s right You set up the Court for some reaso n ... The Court is worthless if you’re going to step in and overrule the decision.” Jessie Davis: “I would rely on whatever the Court decision was.” M anuel Rilatos: “For me, I w ant to listen. Fourth, fifth, sixth, tenth hand. No. B ut to listen. If there is such a thing as a question and if they allow you to ask it, that’s the place to ask.” Delores Pigsley: “W hatever the Tribal Court rules is what w e’ll abide by.” Jane John: “I also will abide by any decision the Court issues.” Monte Kentta: “I agree with Jane John.” Gladys Staggs: “I agree with what has been s a id ... I agree that w e’ll have to go with the what the Court says.” MEMORANDUM OATE May I , TO: Martin Henner, Chief Judge FROM: Deloresi Pigsley , Tri bal Chai rman SUBJECT Tri ba, Court ’ 1989 The Trib al Council has not yet had a decision from you in the L i l l i e B utler case regarding ju ris d ic tio n in th is court case. The Court determined that the Trib al Council did not v io la te the p l a i n t i f f ’ s rig h ts . No decision or determ ination was made as to whether the T rib al Court had ju ris d ic tio n in th is case. Since the Court proceeded to hear the case without a fundamental and necessary f i r s t step being made, the Council fe e ls th a t the Court, you s p e c ific a 11y , have violated the Trib e's own law. We have waited a s u ffic ie n t length of time for you to render a d e cision . A pparently, that decision is not forthcoming. You have put the T rib a l Council in an extremely d i f f i c u l t position because of your In a c tio n . We a re , th e re fo re , ashing fo r you to submit your resignation at this tim e. I f we do not hear from you w ithin the next ten days, we w ill take fu rth e r a ction. DP/tmj