LET TERS
'BA-ROCK' SPIRIT AT
BACH FEST
Applause for Will Kennedy’s “Bach for
the 21st Century” (July 13). I especially
appreciated Kennedy’s “outsider” probes
about the festival’s relevance, audience
and programming.
As a living (!) composer, I’ll add some
insight: Matthew Halls comes to Eugene
on a European wave of authentic perfor-
mance and research that has produced
some amazing work and challenges our
sense of history. What we hear in these
cases, as Kennedy testifies, is pretty rock
’n’ roll. Authentic performances remind
us where rock came from, and confuse the
source of (current) classical performance.
But I’m not sure bringing “real” rockers
to the OBF stage will alleviate concerns or
VIEWPOINT
doubts about the future of ticket sales or
keep the festival “relevant.” Anyone re-
member Bang On A Can’s live interpreta-
tion of Brian Eno’s tape-loop, Music for
Airports? Theirs is a universally deplored
realization of Eno’s genre-defining work.
If that only raises an inquisitive eye-
brow, you’ll groan at the idea of Aphex
Twin as performed by the BBC Orchestra.
Yes, that happened.
On the other hand, there is a strong list
of contemporary composers OBF could
employ who would illuminate the “ba-
rock” spirit of Bach as it flourishes today.
Drawing on the energy of Authentic
Early Music Practice, the “new” OBF has
potential to change the game for Eugene
music culture across the boards. Imagine
a new generation of folk and pop artists
influenced by Early Music exploration
and bringing Eugene to a ... Harry Partch-
esque era. (I can dream, can’t I?)
Nicholas Chase, Composer
Eugene
CITY NEEDS INTERNAL
AUDITOR
Recently I was handed a flyer suggest-
ing Eugene needed an “independent” audi-
tor. The auditor would be responsible for
providing unbiased verification of public
spending, strengthening internal con-
trols and increasing trust of government.
Sounds like a good idea.
Yes, transparency in government is nec-
essary. That’s why a majority of Eugene
residents voted for Mayor Vinis, who ran on
a platform of transparency in government.
Looking over the flyer I was given, I
noticed one serious flaw. The “City Ac-
countability” group advocating for an in-
ternal auditor calls for a ballot measure to
make this an elected position. This would
be a big mistake.
A politically elected independent audi-
tor, by definition, cannot remain indepen-
dent. This could provide opportunities for
serious government mismanagement with
behind the scene deals. An elected inde-
pendent auditor is not a wise way to go.
Another possibility is to appoint an
internal auditor. Also not a good idea, be-
cause we all know the temptation would be
to appoint a “connected” friend of city ad-
ministration. Not the way to insure trans-
parency and trust.
For a true “independent” auditor, the
B Y B O B WA R R E N
It’s The Jobs, Stupid
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHOULD BE ABOUT STABLE EMPLOYMENT
W
hy write a column about economic development? Lots of
people just yawn when they hear the term. But, as they say,
write about what you know, and I do know economic devel-
opment. I did it for a living. And, besides, I actually find it
interesting.
But here’s why I write the column: There is a lot of nonsense that masquerades
as economic development, and someone needs to call “them” on it.
It’s often used as an excuse for almost anything when someone in power is
trying to help someone make a buck or get re-elected. For those guys, just about
everything qualifies as economic development. And, because a lot of people find
it boring and no one really knows what it is anyway, it often gets a pass, regard-
less of how ridiculous it is.
In his recent novel, The Whistler, John Grisham writes: “Bribes weren’t neces-
sary in their part of the country. Take any kind of growth, from high-end, gated
communities, to low-end shopping centers, fix up a slick brochure filled with half
truths and call it economic development with the promise of tax revenues and
jobs, and elected officials reached for their rubber stamps.”
This brings to mind the recent attempt by the city of Springfield to absorb
Seavey Loop and zone it industrial. Or the current scheme by the city of Eugene
to create yet another business park on prime farm land on Clear Lake Road. Both
of these efforts are touted as economic development and approved by the rubber-
stampers.
Neither of these efforts actually have much to do with economic development.
They have more to do with helping land developers snuggle up to the public
trough.
I recently asked a friend what he thought was meant by the term economic
development? He said “jobs.” He got it right — it’s jobs. While economic devel-
opment is often used as a cover to help someone make money or get re-elected,
creating jobs is what it should be about.
And that’s why I got into it. I wanted to help create jobs. I didn’t do it to ex-
pand urban growth boundaries to help land developers make a buck. I didn’t do
it to help private water companies create customers. I did it to help create jobs,
and not just any jobs, but good jobs. The kind of jobs that change people’s lives
for the better. The kind of jobs that support and enrich families and communities.
I originally got into it during Oregon’s Great Recession of the 1980s. This was
a tsunami that sucked the economic air out of many of Oregon’s rural communi-
ties. Forest product processing mills represented most or all of the high-wage
manufacturing jobs in these communities. When the recession of the ’80s shut
down Oregon’s forest products industry, the rural mills were among the first in-
dustries to go and the last to come back. Many never came back.
My first economic development project was as a district aide for Rep. Peter
DeFazio in the late ’80s. By then, the statewide recession was waning, but not
4
July 20, 2017 • eugeneweekly.com
in rural Oregon. Rural communities that had lost their manufacturing jobs were
desperately seeking alternatives.
I worked on the successful recruitment of a company called Entek to the com-
munity of Lebanon. We didn’t know it at the time, but the recruitment of Entek
to Lebanon would prove absolutely critical to that community, changing its eco-
nomic trajectory for the next several decades. It was the most significant eco-
nomic development project Lebanon would see for the next 20 years.
Entek is a cutting-edge manufacturer of membranes used in batteries, doing
high-technology research and development and manufacturing. The community
and the company proved the perfect match for each other. These were high-wage
jobs with benefits. The local workforce matched Entek’s needs to a remarkable
degree.
Entek proved to be a firm that believed in community development and sup-
port. The city and community-based nonprofits would benefit from an employer
that acted as a citizen of the community.
The successful recruitment of Entek to Lebanon was personally fulfilling. I
knew I had made a difference for the workers, their families and the community.
That’s what economic development can be about.
It’s July 3, 2007, 20 years after the Entek recruitment and I am at the grand
opening of the new Lowe’s million-square-foot distribution center in Lebanon —
the most significant economic development project in Lebanon since Entek. This,
too, was my project. I had worked on it for two years.
Lowes would be providing 500 nearly recession-proof jobs. I didn’t know
another great recession was about to land in rural Oregon but, when it did, these
jobs proved to be secure.
And Lowe’s, along with Entek, helped insulate Lebanon from yet another eco-
nomic disaster.
I’m walking into the big Lowe’s building with a large group of new employees
and their families. There is an air of excitement as men and women show off their
new locker room to their children, proud to be part of this. They are positive about
the future. There is joy and happiness in the air. And it’s real.
These are jobs that will not be dependent on the wild fluctuations of the forest
industry, in a community that was as timber dependent as any other in the state.
Lowe’s, like Entek, acts as a responsible citizen of the community.
I had the privilege of helping both Entek and Lowe’s locate in Lebanon and, to
this day, maintain about 1,000 good jobs with two responsible companies. Other
companies, also located in Lebanon, attracted by Entek and Lowe’s, create yet
more jobs. As I looked around on that day 10 years ago, I realized this was a new
Lebanon. I knew this is what economic development should be about.
For a brief moment I wondered why I felt such pride in being part of what
was happening on that day in Lebanon ten years ago. But it was obvious, I told
myself: It’s the jobs, stupid.