BY SPRUCE HOUSER
Movement Gone Astray
Consequences of a wrong turn
A
s someone who was involved in the early
stages of the Warner Creek campaign
(and happened to create the “wild and
free” blockade banner on the opening page of
“Flames of Dissent”), I would like to affirm the
wonderful idealism of many participants.
However, an unfortunate potential consequence
of this series is that the exposure given to the
history leading up to sabotage may tend to only in-
crease an already existing fragmentation of
Eugene’s activist community.
Activists at Warner Creek were tapping into the strength of
nonviolent resistance — what Gandhi called satyagraha or moral power of truth. This
philosophy sees our entire society as trapped within the spirit of violence and those
who implement its policies as simply captured as well. Nonviolence seeks the libera-
tion of all from this system, including those currently blinded by it.
W ha t p ow er wo u ld th e m e ga - co r po r a ti o n s h a ve if we
d ev e lo pe d a t ru l y e c o- su st ai n ab le c u lt u r e wh ic h
t u rn e d i t s b a ck o n m a ss c on su m e ri s m ?
I believe the victory at Warner Creek was attributable to this approach. But I also
saw it unravel. Forest Service law enforcement officers began to become de-human-
ized as “the enemy.” This led later to an even more complete demonizing of Eugene
police officers by some anarchists in the “wars” which ensued in the Whiteaker
neighborhood. When the commitment to nonviolence devolved into a hostile di-
chotomy of “us versus them,” its power was forsaken.
For this reason, describing this period as the “eco-radical era of Eugene” makes a
fundamental error. My dictionary defines “radical” to mean “going to the root, foun-
dation, or source.” The activism depicted does not address the source at all, but in-
stead is trapped within the superficial levels of an old paradigm that can only lead to
polarization.
In no way do I defend heavy-handed police actions or extremely excessive sen-
tences. I only try to make two points. In tactics involving arson, it is all but inevitable
that people will eventually become either maimed or killed. As was the case when
someone was accidentally killed by a bomb in Madison, Wis., to protest the Vietnam
war, such an incident would be used to totally discredit whatever cause with which it
is associated.
Secondly, such tactics are counter-productive. If activism is based on hatred, it is
going to invoke those same kinds of hateful energies in response. Rather than lift all
of humanity to the higher place we all need to go to in order to avoid a planetary
eco-catastrophe, such tactics only deepen divisions and squander precious energy
toward symptoms rather than causes.
avid Korten, author of When Corporations Rule the World, recently spoke to
a capacity crowd in Eugene to promote his new groundbreaking book The
Great Turning: From Empire to Earth Community. In his stirring presenta-
tion, he described the stark decision humanity now faces in whether it will continue
to support a worldview/paradigm driven by the imperatives of empire or choose to
non-cooperate with and disempower that mentality. Many points of this quite impor-
tant book are succinctly summarized in an article by Korten available online (at
www.yesmagazine.org/article.asp?ID=1463).
The modus operandi of empire is violence. Only through the infliction of violence
on a mega-scale can the empire be upheld. It has become the master of such appli-
cation and will not be defeated by any strategy attempting to pick up this self-de-
structive tool. It can only be overcome by an energy more powerful, which is what
would be embodied in a mass movement dedicated to the unswerving application of
active nonviolent resistance, non-cooperation and boycott.
Gandhi’s movement is the best example of the power of such resistance in con-
fronting an empire. His thesis that all power is ultimately held by the people was
proven correct. When enough people of India non-violently refused to cooperate
with the British system, its hold was broken.
Similarly, what power would the mega-corporations have if we developed a truly
eco-sustainable culture which turned its back on mass consumerism? This is a soci-
etal paradigm shift that will require several generations to accomplish. But is it not
better to model the positive alternatives and take the first faltering steps of a move-
ment that could actually succeed than engage in polarizing actions which do not ad-
dress the source and are therefore destined to fail?
Rather than looking backward, it is far more important to learn the lessons being
offered and move forward. If we are ever to break free from the empire mentality
that dominates the planet and gravely threatens its future, it is my hope that such
will be the case.
D
Spruce Houser has participated in the organizing of several campaigns based on the principles of Gandhian
nonviolence, addressing such issues as nuclear energy (Trojan), nuclear weapons, forest protection and corporate
power.
4 DECEMBER 21, 2006
TO THE EDITOR
UNFAIR SENTENCES
IT TAKES SOME TIME
After following the saga of “Flames of
Disssent” and reaching what appeared to be
the conclusion (12/7), my heart sank as I read
the sentencing.
I was looking at a list of apparently ordi-
nary people — most of them educated — get-
ting a “recommended sentence” of some-
times more than 14 years! As much as I don’t
like to see vandalism, especially in the form
of arson, I cannot help realizing that whatever
brought these folks to act like they did was
pure despair and very likely not being heard.
We have not even talked enough about the
fundamental reason why they felt compelled
to act like this; we just focused on the de-
struction of private and federal
property. It sounds and looks
better on the news. These very
people had only one message
in mind: “This is the only
earth we know of; we don’t
want it gone!”
The message of Authority
is clear: hard cracking down in
order to make examples and
discourage others to follow in the tracks of
the “eco-terrorists” — how convenient a
word. Don’t get any ideas, now! Go back to
your homes; everything is going to be all
right. Come on! We all know there are so
many worse crimes out there that hardly re-
sulted in two or maybe three years in the can!
One thing is sure: For the “eco-terrorists,”
they will find jail room. Maybe by releasing a
dozen sex offenders or corrupt politicians.
(Oh, that’s right! The latter get promoted.)
I send a message to whoever rejoiced at
seeing the sentencing: Don’t you like to
breathe clean air? Don’t you enjoy walking in
our magnificent nature? When was the last
time you (not your landscaper!) planted a
tree? What would be your reaction if some-
one was threatening the life of your mother?
Look at the big picture and understand. Your
Mother is everything around you: the air you
breathe, the water you drink, everything!
Alby Thoumsin
Springfield
Regarding Ann Tattersall’s letter, asking
“Where are the 150 state troopers you prom-
ised to deploy right after the election?”
(12/7): That is in the governor’s proposed
budget for 2007-09, which must first be en-
acted by the Legislature and signed by the
governor before it goes into effect on July 1,
2007.
We’re currently still operating on the
2005-07 budget, which was enacted by the
2005 Legislature on the basis of revenue fore-
casts made in late 2004 and which has to last
until next June 30. In any event, creating the
positions, advertising for them, taking appli-
cations, doing background checks, hiring
them, buying them equip-
ment, cars, etc., and doing
any necessary training,
takes a while, too. You
don’t just hire them from
the people loitering on the
corner looking for day
labor. I drive the freeway
every day (in a carpool!),
and I too would welcome
more enforcement of existing laws. But you
can’t fix overnight budget cuts from the past
20 years.
For the past three or four months, employ-
ees in all of the state government’s depart-
ments have been working on their budget re-
quests for 2007-09. That’s right; they have to
decide now how much money to ask for to
get them through the next 30 months or so.
Then they send their requests to the governor,
who works over the numbers with his own
priorities in mind and draws up his own “gov-
ernor’s proposed budget.”
In January, the Legislature meets and
spends about four months doing various poli-
ticking until a budget forecast comes out in
about mid-April, and that’s the “crystal ball”
number they’ll work with to put together their
own budget, which they hope to send to the
governor for his signature sometime before
July 1. And then they (and all of us) hope that
there’s no major downturn in the economy, a
major disaster, an unforseen rise in petroleum