TO THE EDITOR
NOT EVEN REAL
NATURAL DISASTER
The Defense Intelligence Agency has
primary responsibility for questioning of
Iraqi prisoners. It also has the responsibility
for questioning your friends, neighbors, em-
ployers, clergy and teachers, should you
have, or request for, or are ordered into, a po-
sition of responsibility in the Defense Dept.
or associated agencies.
Inevitably, the DIA agent asks the
question of your acquaintance: “Do you
know of communists at the [nearest] uni-
versity?”
As an instructor of students going into
defense agencies, I have been asked numer-
ous times by DIA agents, “Do you know of
communists at [nearest] university?” Once,
in particular, my department had an ex-
change program with Communist China,
sponsored by the U.S. State Department,
bringing scientists to the U.S. in exchange
for American scientists going to Communist
China. I had to say, “Yes,” and then ex-
plained where they were from.
I was corrected by my DIA interviewer.
“No, no, I mean ‘real’ communists!” If a
communist from the largest communist
country in the world is not a “real” commu-
nist in the eyes of the DIA, who the heck is a
real communist? It must have showed on my
face.
“I mean, ‘American’ Communists!” my
interviewer enlightened me.
Until I saw pictures of the Iraqi prisoners,
I did not understand what the DIA investiga-
tor was talking about. If you are not an
“American,” you are not “real” in the eyes of
the DIA.
Prof. Paul Engelking
Lowell
Last night on OPB, I heard one commen-
tator say in regard to the moral blight that the
recent Iraqi prisoner abuse brings to the
U.S., “It’s not in our nature; it’s not in our
history.” Umm … excuse me! Not in our na-
ture? Not in our history? What about how
this country was taken from Native
Americans who’d lived here for thousands
of years? What about slavery and how we’ve
treated African Americans? What about the
Japanese internment camps? What about
how we treated the Chinese who built our
railways? What about the boat people we
turned away? Not in our nature? Please!
Bobbie Ingersoll
Eugene
ALL OVER AGAIN
The Cold War was ultimately won, not
by armies marching, but by triumphant dem-
ocratic ideals that proved superior to every
competing ideology. Democracy, the rights
of men and women, and the power of free
markets are proving themselves around the
world.
We see it in Latin America, Asia, parts of
Africa and wherever else these principles
have the opportunity to take root. In this new
world, economic strength will be more rele-
vant than military strength.
The new order will be defined by trade
relations, by the flow of information, capital,
technology, and goods, rather than by armies
glaring across boarders. Nations seeking
power through military strength, the devel-
opment of nuclear weapons, terrorism, or
tyrannical governments are mining “fool’s
gold.” They can never hope to match or chal-
lenge the military and economic power of
the free world, led by the U.S. Despondent
regimes, and will come to realize it in due
course when they find themselves left be-
hind while free nations prosper and provide
a better life for their people. One only has to
look at China to see a nation slowly finding a
place in the world, not through the strength
of its vast military or Maoist philosophy, but
through the release of the creative entrepre-
neurial power of the Chinese people.
Only Marxist Cuba and North Korea still
cling to old politics and ideologies, perhaps
hoping for protection under the Endangered
Species Act, but they cannot escape the tide
of history, and I sincerely believe this chal-
lenging new era in the world holds out a
promise of a bright new beginning.
Tom Bush
Eugene
NONVIOLENCE NEEDED
The Eugene Middle East Peace Group
BY DAN CAROL
Bush’s War
So how can I not write about the mess in Iraq?
W
here shall we begin? With … beheadings? Or the newspaper headlines like
“U.S. Strikes Mosque” that quickly follow? Yikes. This is not good.
We already have both sides saying openly — openly! — that “God’s will”
compels their cause. Brothers and sisters, I’m afraid we’re looking at New Crusades ma-
terial here. Welcome to a new chapter in a thousand year cycle of violence … a history I
sure don’t know chapter and verse about without first a skim read of The Idiot’s Guide to
the Crusades. It all makes me want to cry — except I am too busy fighting my anger.
Those fools in the White House — that is exactly what they are, fools — have dropped
a huge damn boulder in the pond of history. For what? Oil? A “surgical” chess experi-
ment in geo-diplomacy (remember when they thought we’d just zip into Syria right after
Iraq)? Fools! Bush and his fools and liars sat at their war table and Colin Powell bit his lip.
They were fools and by the way we’re still in Afghanistan — do you think they even think
about that? Do the fools goddamn remember we are still in freakin’ Afghanistan? Hello,
is anyone home? Those poor kids over there deserve better.
So what next besides being angry? I reflect upon the smartest thing I have heard
about what this election means, and I heard it months ago. It was attributed to George
Soros and paraphrased, it goes like this: If America re-elects Bush, the world will come
to see the war in Iraq not simply as Bush’s War, but as America’s War.
If healing is to begin at all, this chapter — Bush’s War — must end. Beyond that, it isn’t
clear to me what we need to do. I am not a pacifist — and neither are the terrorists who
hate us. If we leave, they still hate us. They’ll still attack.
Bush and his fools disturbed a hornet’s nest in Iraq we could have left alone. Now
we’d better expect to get stung.
So I take exception with anyone on the left who wants to test Kerry on his future war
stance via timelines and specifics, who stays mad at Kerry for his war vote for another
day, or asserts they have “the answer” to the mess we are in. Brothers and sisters, no-
body can read the water now. There’s too much blood in it. In short, we need to lighten
up on Kerry.
Duh, of course, he isn’t the answer to our prayers; we’re all past Clinton ’92 puppy
4 MAY 20, 2004
love aren’t we? As Arianna Huffington nicely puts it,
“We’ve got to put out the fire before we start remodeling
and fixing the house.” Kerry is our firefighter. That’s
enough. Even if that’s all we ever get from him.
It was tragic and stupid to invade Iraq, but I don’t see
a slam dunk strategy lying around. So smacking Kerry
around for not having “an answer” to this unbelievable
mess is just harsh. Yet that’s what folks are starting to do.
Robert Scheer, writing for Alternet, recently offered this:
“Today, however, Kerry seems unable to admit that the war he voted to authorize in Iraq
has been such a disaster, arguing only that we must ‘stay the course.’ To have a real
choice in this election, we need to hear the voice of that young Navy hero who once
warned us that murderous meddling in other countries’ affairs will never win the hearts
and minds of the people.”
Do we really need to hear that voice before the election? I don’t. I just need a little bit
of vision, a dash of hope and some smart-sounding ideas that point us in the right direc-
tion for building global tolerance in an era of rising hatred — not a just-add-water solu-
tion that doesn’t exist.
Is a call for a smarter war on terrorism and finishing the job in Afghanistan good
enough? Is a JFK-style call upon the American can-do spirit for a Manhattan/Apollo-
style project to reduce U.S. oil dependence and create new U.S. jobs enough? Well, it is
for me — and I’d wager, the average voter we need to win over.
S
hort of troop withdrawals, can progressive forces get a commitment from Kerry
for specific and massive investments in girls’ education in Afghanistan? Can we
add a healthy dash of smart Kucinich policies that would put the UN — and not
Halliburton — in charge of Iraqi assets and contracts? Good stuff. We should definitely
petition Kerry to take these steps.
B ut if he doesn’t inch our way, don’t get mad at him. Get even later. Whatever disap-
points, just mark it down on that progressive “to-do list” we’ll be working on starting
Nov. 3, come rain or shine. But the day before, we need to get it right — or the world will
think this was America’s War.
Dan Carol is a Democratic political strategist and a founding partner of CTSG (www.ctsg.com), a progressive
consulting firm based in Eugene, Ore., and Washington, D.C.