4
The
Clackamas Print
Opini
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
Comparing Clinton and McCai
By Armondo Borboa
John
McCain:
Security
savant or
jeopardoL
action hei
Hillary
Clinton:
People's
advocate
or tied-up
chaperone?
MCCAIN
CLINTON
Education:
National War College, 1973
United States Naval Academy, 1958
St Stephen’s School, 1946 to 1949 - Alexandria, Va.
Episcopal High School, 1951 to 1954 - Alexandria, Va.
Education:
Yale Law School, J.D., 1973
Wellesley College, B.A., 1969
Maine South High School - Park Ridge, Ill.
Public service:
Senator, United States Senate, 2001 to present
First Lady of the United States, 1993 to 2001
First Lady of Arkansas, 1979 to 1981,1983 to 1993
House Judiciary Committee, 1974
Private experience:
Attorney, Rose Law Firm, 1976 to 1992
Faculty, University of Arkansas Law School, 1975
Board member, TCBY Yogurt Company and Wal-Mart, 1985 to 1992
Board member, Arkansas Children’s Hospital and the Children’s Defense Fund
Co-Founder, Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families
Book(s):
“Dear Socks, Dear Buddy: Kids’ Letters to the First Pets”
“Living History”
“It Takes a Village”
“Witness to Genocide: The Children of Rwanda: Drawings by Child Survivors of
the Rwandan Genocide of 1994”
Pros:
As an advocate of women’s issues and a defender of families, nobody does it better
than Hillary Rodham Clinton. She has spent her entire adult life fighting for civil rights
and the children’s causes that are near and dear to her heart.
She was the first-ever female senator from New York, and is the first-ever former
First Lady to run for political office.
Prior to her marriage, the former Hillary Rodham was a formidable lawyer with a
record of fighting for social causes. She has been noted and lauded quite often by numer
ous social groups for her work on behalf of Constitutional rights, civil liberties, migrant
workers, health care and education.
Thanks to her name recognition, her election as senator for the state of New York was
practically assured. Also thanks to her fame, all of her pet projects receive an inordinate
and enviable amount of national attention. Because of this, her New York constituents
have received many benefits that any other person would simply not be able to deliver.
Now campaigning for president of the United States, Clinton continues to make his
tory as the first-ever viable female candidate and elected office holder to make a run at
the primary.
Cons:
Bill Clinton. That’s it.
Pure and simple, Hillary Clinton’s biggest drag on her future success is her husband.
As a former president and a very popular and divisive figure, Bill Clinton continues to
draw attention away from his wife every time he opens his mouth.
In addition to the controversial statements he has made without his wife’s knowledge
or permission, his actions on the campaign trail continue to embarrass her. He tar
nishes her image as a strong and intelligent woman and powerful candidate for political
office.
In addition to all of his numerous and very public infidelities, Bill Clinton’s insane
need to steal the spotlight away from his wife will continue to drag down her campaign
and embarrass her at every turn. She looks weak in comparison and deserves better.
Analysis:
As unfair as it might be, the first and most important question to ask must be this: If
Hillary Clinton cannot control her husband, how can she be trusted to run the country?
Grade: D-
The
Clackamas Print
The Clackamas Print
19600 S. Molalla Ave.
Oregon City OR 97045
503-657-6958, ext. 2309
Public service:
United States Navy, 1958 to 1981; prisoner of war, Vietnam, 1967 to 1973
Awards: Silver Star, Legion of Merit Purple Heart and Distinguished Flying
Cross
Senate Navy Liaison, 1977 to 1981
Representative, United States House of Representatives, 1983 to 1987
Senator, United States Senate, 1987 to present
Private experience:
Board of Trustees, Gallaudet University
Founding member, Pacific Council on International Policy, USC
Board of Directors, Board of Directors Chair, International Republican Institute
Board of Directors, Nixon Center for Peace and Freedom
Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, 1995 to 2001,2003 to 20
Chair, Committee on Indian Affairs, 1995 to 1997,2005 to 2007
Book(s):
“Character Is Destiny: Inspiring Stories Every Young Person Should Know ant
Adult Should Remember”
“Why Courage Matters: The Way to a Braver Life”
‘Worth the Fighting For: A Memoir”
“Unfinished Business: Afghanistan, the Middle East, and Beyond - Defusing the I
That Threaten America’s Security”
“Faith of My Fathers”
“The Reminiscences of Admiral John S. McCain, Jr.”
Pros:
With credibility you can take to the bank and a resume as long as a telephone boJ
McCain has spent a lifetime fighting the established order.
After be ing shot down and captured during the Vietnam War, M cCain endured tri
five years of torture and depravation at the hands of the enemy. Although he was rq
beaten, starved and crippled, he never broke faith wife his fellow prisoners or accq
special “favors” from his captors.
As an Arizona senator, McCain has become well-known for his willingness to i
career on particular issues, regardless of all other popular sentiments. He was one of
few vocal supporters of fee military surge into Iraq at a time when support of that1
considered to be political suicide.
He has also been recognized for fighting against “pork barrel spending,” a euphet
politicians using federal taxpayer money to fund pet projects and buy votes back ha
Cons:
Although he would be your first choice to have your back in a bar fight, McCain h
really learned to play nice wife others. This hurts him in a very real way.
Reading into his personal history, his halo quickly loses its luster. A notorious trou
er in school, he racked up demerits and was often at odds wife authority. A difficult
he graduated fifth from fee bottom out of a class of899 Naval Cadets and never achi
rank of admiral, which was earned by both his father and grandfather.
McCain’s impulsive and controversial nature has extended itself to his political (
addition to fee Keating Five Savings and Loans Scandal, a large majority of his p
have died simply because of his inability to work well wife members of his own pa
Analysis:
In a time of war, John McCain has fee experience and credibility needed to i
nation, fight and win against anybody in fee world. In a time of peace, he is his o?
enemy.
Grade: B+
Editor in Chief: Megan Koler
Copy Editor: Colleen Watkins
News Editor: Lydia E. Bashaw
A&C Editor: Emily Walters
Sports Editor: Aijdrea Simpson
Feature Editor: Kyle Steele
Photo Editor: Kayla Berge
Photo Associate:
\
Mistymarie Wilks-Salguero
News Associate: Matt Garrison
A d M anager : Meredith James
P roduction A ssistant :
Chris Young
S taff W riters / P hotographers :
Dale Balbi, Armondo Borboa,
Kenton Benfield, John Hurlburt,
Nick Komafel, Genyva Laubach,
Riley Lundgren,
Christina Maggio,
Jess Shepard, John Shufelt
D epartment A dviser :
Melissa Jones
D epartment S ecretary :
Pat Thompson
G oals : The Clackamas Priti
to report the news in an hon
unbiased, professional mart
The opinions expressed dot
necessarily reflect those of 11
dent body, college administi
its faculty or The Print. E-m
comments to chiefed@clacki
edu.