Image provided by: University of Oregon Libraries; Eugene, OR
About Northwest labor press. (Portland , Ore.) 1987-current | View Entire Issue (Aug. 4, 2006)
Oman Free Trade Agreement passes NAFTA-style trade deals proliferating around the globe By DON McINTOSH Associate Editor In June and July, Congress approved yet another NAFTA-style trade agree- ment, this time with a sultanate. The U.S.-Oman Free Trade Agree- ment (OFTA) pairs the United States with Oman, a hereditary monarchy on the southeast border of Saudi Arabia. Sultan Qabus ibn Said as-Said is the country’s absolute ruler, though 10 years ago he decreed the formation of an elected advisory council. The treaty is part of the Bush Ad- ministration’s strategy to expand the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) to the Middle East by creat- ing a Middle East Free Trade Area. OFTA is the ninth trade agreement modeled on NAFTA to be ratified by the United States. Since NAFTA passed in 1993, Congress has yet to reject any trade deal, and has agreed to restrict it- self by voting each of them up or down without amendment. The national AFL-CIO opposed OFTA on the grounds that it would do nothing to protect workers’ rights, and likely will cost jobs in the United States — and lower living standards for work- ers in Oman. OFTA passed the U.S. Senate June 29 by 60 to 34. Oregon Republican Gordon Smith and Washington Democ- rat Maria Cantwell voted for it, while Oregon Democrat Ron Wyden and Washington Democrat Patty Murray voted against. Besides Cantwell, 10 other Democratic senators voted for the agreement, including Hillary Rodham Clinton (N.Y.), John Kerry (Mass.), Joseph Lieberman (Conn.), and Barack Obama (Ill.). Next, OFTA passed the House July 20 by a 221-205 vote. It was supported by 88 percent of Republicans and 11 percent of Democrats. Oregon’s Republican Congressman Q } Greg Walden voted for it, while Ore- gon’s Democrats — Earl Blumenauer, Darlene Hooley, Peter DeFazio and David Wu — voted against it. Southwest Washington Congress- man Brian Baird was one of the 22 De- mocrats in the House to vote for the treaty, despite appeals from local and national labor groups and a phone call from Richard Trumka, secretary-treas- urer of the national AFL-CIO. In a press statement after the vote, Baird said the agreement will create jobs in Washing- ton. Oman has 3 million inhabitants; 90 percent of its exports are oil. “We must ensure that future trade agreements adequately address labor and environmental concerns,” Baird said in the statement. OFTA, which lacks protection for workers’rights or the environment, still got Baird’s vote. “This is the country with the worst labor laws of any country with whom we have a free-trade agreement,” said Thea Lee, chief international economist for the national AFL-CIO. “It should have been an embarrassment to any member of Congress who voted for it.” “The State Department has identi- fied Oman as a destination country for men and women who become victims of trafficking and forced labor,” said na- tional AFL-CIO President John Sweeney, reacting to the House vote. “Yet the Republican leadership and the Administration refused to include an amendment passed by the Senate Fi- nance Committee that would have en- sured that no goods made with forced labor benefited from this agreement.” OFTA could help Oman become a low-wage producer of clothing and manufactured goods, like so many other countries. A trade agreement with Jor- dan was negotiated by the Clinton Ad- ministration and ratified in 2000; since then, Jordan has exploded as a haven for export processing, using foreign work- ers from south and southeast Asia. Oman has 3 million inhabitants, and already, most of its private-sector work- force is made up of foreign guest work- ers from Pakistan, Bangladesh, India, Sri Lanka and the Philippines. Prior to the votes in Congress, the AFL-CIO’s Lee traveled to Kuwait and Jordan and met with trade union advo- cates from Oman, as well as Yemen, Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Jor- dan. Lee said workers in the region see such trade treaties as capitulation to the United States. Like other NAFTA-style treaties, OFTA basically eliminates import tar- iffs on both sides, commits Oman to en- force legal monopolies like patents, copyrights and use of trademarks, and sets up a body of laws and procedures to protect the rights of foreign investors. What it doesn’t do is protect the rights of workers, in any way. OFTA, like other recent trade agreements, com- mits both countries to enforce their own labor laws, whatever they may be. If they fail to do so, they can theoretically be fined, a fine the country would pay to itself, to enforce the law. Of course, there’s nothing to stop Oman from worsening or eliminating its labor laws. Hearing that OFTA might be a close vote in the U.S. House, on July 8 Sultan Oman decreed a set of basic union rights and a prohibition of forced labor and child labor. Ultimately, Lee says, the passage of OFTA was more about Mideast politics than about trade. Within the region, Oman is considered a “strategic part- ner” to the United States. “It’s a pretty small country with which we have a pretty small trade rela- tionship,” Lee said. The agreement brings to 15 the num- ber of countries that have NAFTA-style bilateral or multilateral trade agree- ments with the United States. The oth- ers are Canada, Mexico, Jordan, five Central American countries and the Do- minican Republic, Australia, Morocco, Singapore, Chile and Bahrain. The agreement with Bahrain, ratified by Congress in December 2005, was also fought by the AFL-CIO, though Lee said the country does have independent trade unions and doesn’t have the awful conditions found elsewhere in the re- gion. Two more agreements have been ne- Gradine Storms Real Estate Broker Member of CWA Local 7901 E-Mail: gstorms@equitygroup.com www.equitygroup.com/gstorms Cam Johnson Adrian Hamilton Doug Goebel Each Office Independently Owned and Operated Orthodontics Available Quality, Affordable Family Dental Care • General, cosmetic, and specialty care • Most insurance and union plans accepted • Easy credit and low monthly payments, O.A.C. • Evening and Saturday appointments • Ask about our Dental Discount Program Grants Pass 1021 NE 6th St. Grants Pass, OR 97526 541-479-6696 “I CAN GO TO ONE PLACE TO FIX IT ALL?” Greg Sherwood Monte Johnson Bill Zenk Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Gresham 443 NW Burnside Road Gresham, OR 97030 503-492-8487 Salem 831 Lancaster Mall Dr. NE Salem, OR 97301 503-362-8359 Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Wilsonville 25700 SW Argyle Ave. Wilsonville, OR 97070 503-682-8552 Salmon Creek 2101 NE 129th St. Vancouver, WA 98686 360-574-4574 Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Klamath Falls 4052 S. 6th St. Klamath Falls, OR 97603 541-883-7706 Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. One SW Columbia St., Suite 1100 Portland, OR 97258 503-221-0158 Portland 3580 SE 82nd Ave. Portland, OR 97266 503-777-0761 Northwest Dental Associates, P.C. Milwaukie 17186 SE McLoughlin Blvd. Milwaukie, OR 97267 503-659-2525 Chau Ngo, D.D.S., M.S. Phong Bui, D.M.D. Charles Stirewalt, D.D.S. Stirewalt, P.C. Fisher’s Landing 3250 SE 164th Ave. Vancouver, WA 98683 360-891-1999 Peter Vu, D.M.D. Chau Ngo, D.D.S. Charles Stirewalt, D.D.S. Stirewalt, P.C. 1-888-BRIGHT NOW www.brightnow.com www.QuestInvestment.com PAGE 12 7886 SE 13th Ave. Portland, Oregon 97202 Direct: 503-495-4932 Branch: 503-233-8883 PROTECTING UNION MEMBERS’ SMILES AND WALLETS. Quest Investment Management, Inc. Serving Multi-Employer Trusts for Twenty Years gotiated but not approved yet by Con- gress. Those include agreements with Colombia and Peru. Also on Congress’ trade agenda is a bill to declare Perma- nent Normal Trade Relations with Viet- nam, removing the designation of the country as requiring an annual human rights review. Trade negotiations at various stages are under way with Panama, United Arab Emirates, South Korea, Malaysia and a group of five Southern African nations. Meanwhile, advocates of so-called “free trade” had a major setback July 24 when it was announced that negotia- tions on expanding the World Trade Or- ganization to agriculture had been sus- pended after five years. Rich countries refused to give up subsidies to their farmers, while poor countries refused to give up tariff protections of their farm- ers. Serving unions for over 25 years NORTHWEST LABOR PRESS AUGUST 4, 2006
