decemfaer 17.2QQ4 ’ j U S t O U tg IJ in ve ivi 4*1 (new s H er reason for being there was succinct. P arting W ords Oregon Supreme Court considers same-sex marriage case “We would like to become full citizens,” said Salem resident Joan Wamock on the Oregon Capitol steps Dec. 15 in Salem. It w;is the day the Oregon Supreme Court heard final arguments in Li vs. Oregon, the law­ suit challenging the states denial of marriage rights to same-sex couples. Wamock and her part­ ner of 23 years, Hanneliese Selhach, joined about 100 marriage equality supporters at a prehearing gathering organized by Basic Rights Oregon. BRO executive director Roey Thorpe called the struggle for marriage equality “the move­ ment of our time.” “ It’s about love,” she said. “True love will not fail.” The crowd erupted in cheers and began the quick walk to neighboring Willamette Universi­ ty to watch the court prcxreedings on closed- caption television. Meanwhile, Thorpe and several plaintiffs in the case made their way to the Supreme Court building. Plaintiff Kelly Burke said she was feeling both excited and pragmatic about the possible outcomes of the case. She wants her 3-year-old son, Avery, to grow up in family that is consid­ ered married just like those of his peers. “1 feel like we’re going to come out of it with something,” she said. She and her spouse, Dolores Doyle, were married March 3 in Multnomah County. It remains to he seen, however, what rights— if any— gay and lesbian couples will come away with from this case. The seven justices asked tough questions of both sides in the hour-plus allotted for oral arguments. The questions cen- by Meg D aly tered on procedural and statutory issues in the case, not the fundamental constitutional rights of gays and lesbians. Despite the fact that three of the four liti­ gants— the state of Oregon, Multnomah County and the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of nine same-sex couples and Basic Rights Oregon— agree that the case was not rendered iruxit by the passage of Measure 36, the mixitness question was of primary concern to the justices. They echcxxl the concern raised by Kelly Clark, attorney for the Defense of Marriage Coalition, regarding the package of marriage benefits being stnight by the same-sex couples. Clark called the benefits “unnamed” and “unidentifiable,” though he did indicate that he knew there were 500 such benefits at stake. “Nobody in this courtrcxnn knows what benefits they are asking for,” he said. Justice Michael Gillette questioned A C LU attorney Kenneth Choe about this issue. “How can we give substance to a phrase like ‘complete package of benefits’?” he asked. Choe said the Oregon Constitution guarantees equal protection under the law and therefore there is no basis for denying the legal benefits of marriage to a citizen based on his or her sexual orientation. . : While Clark has argued tfiat this is a “radi­ cally amended claim," Choe reminded the court « . * n> .« Marriage equality supporters on the steps of the Oregon Capitol that both married and unmarried same-sex cou­ ples are plaintiffs in the case and that the unmarried couples have always sought marriage rights in addition to the status of marriage. BRO lobbyist Maura Rix:he said Clark was being somewhat disingenuous in his assertion that the benefits are unnamed. “Our briefs didn’t regurgitate all...the statutes that reference priv­ ileges based on being a spouse.” But, she added, the statutes do exist. In a panel discussion at Willamette after the hearing, A C LU co-counsel Lynn Nakamoto said, while it is impossible to predict, the court could decide the case on suhconstitutional issues and not rule at all on the constitutionality of the 3,042 same-sex marriages. Chcx.' said, however, “We have argued vigor­ ously that the court must reach this issue.” Much of the rest of the discussion involved candid disclosure about strategy, answering lin­ gering questions about why the A C LU was pur­ suing civil unions rather than challenging the constitutionality of Measure 36. Choe said that one of the two ways to challenge a state’s con­ stitution is to take it to the U.S. Supreme Court, which, he noted, “is not our friend on this issue.” Chcx; said the A C LU consulted with queer rights groups and legal experts throughout the nation about this question and heard back resounding concern “that we would lose and it would be nationally binding.” There was also concern that if the A C LU won a Supreme Court case in favor of same-sex marriage, the backlash in Congress could mean swift passage of the Federal Marriage Amend­ ment banning gay marriage. “Congress is not our friend, and it has gotten worse,” said Choe. He said that the other way to invalidate a constitutional amendment is through state elec­ tion law but that it is unclear if that basis is open to marriage equality supporters at this time. Chcx; told the crowd of about 200 attending the panel discussion that he was “grateful to the LG BT community in Oregon.... You’ve done yourselves proud.” A niling in the case could come anytime and is expected by early 2005 JT1 S ta ff W riter M eg D aly can be reached a t m egdaly @ ju stou t.com . Celebrate your independence at Kuni Saab. 2004 9-5 Sedan 2004 9-3 Sport Sedan Visit kunisaab.com for current lease and model year closeout specials. All-W heel Drive 2005 9-2X The Best of Sweden, Right Here in Beaverton. @ 1 . 877 . 279.9194 3725 SW Cedar Hills Boulevard • Beaverton 24 hours a day5kunisaab.com Open Weekdays 8 to 7:30 • Saturday 9 to 6 • Sunday I I to 5